HN Hall of Fame Weekly email

What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole?

arxiv.org Research & data Research papers Mathematics & science Candidate
Screenshot of arxiv.org captured 2026-07-20
Page preview · captured 2026-07-20

Resurfaced independently across 3 calendar years, with breakout response in 3 of them.

submissions
3
submitters
3
observed span
2019–2023
peak thread · 345 comments
285 pts
latest 20+ return · 2023-09-28
117 pts

Submission timeline

2007–2026

One slot for every year since HN launched. Height is that year's peak points; orange marks a 100+ point or 50+ comment breakout. Select a bar to open its strongest thread.

First comments on top threads

HN comment order

Some potentially interesting uses for it: - definitive sink to send all of our nuclear waste (it would be the /dev/null of the Solar System) - gravitational energy generator (limitless, until we have no more mass to throw in)

there's a 1:1 scale picture of the black hole fig 1: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1909.11090.pdf

sabujp·159-point thread·

This is a very "dense" paper. So: if dark matter is something that annihilates itself, that's a two-particle interaction, so its macroscopic rate scales as density squared ρ². If there's a black hole in the solar system, the dark matter halo immediately surrounding it would be compressed far denser than around a normal object, so it'd have a much brighter annihilation signal. Nothing's known about dark matter annihilation. They speculate, if its cross section is large enough, this annihilation could…

The first top-level comment from each of the four biggest threads, in HN’s own order. Excerpts are shortened; open a comment for full context.

Breakout years
3

100+ points or 50+ comments

Total points
561

reference only — not used in Hall rules or ranking

Total comments
675

reference only — not used in Hall rules or ranking

Every submission

DateTitle as submittedByPointsComments
2019-09-26What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole?First breakout · Best threadanpat285345
2021-08-13What if Planet 9 is a Primordial Black Hole? (2019)rbanffy159153
2023-09-28What if Planet 9 is a Primordial Black Hole? (2019)Latest 20+ point returnnequo117177