[{"slug":"we-can-t-send-email-more-than-500-miles-2002-d9d0234fd128","title":"We can't send email more than 500 miles (2002)","domain":"web.mit.edu","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2015-04","inductedMonth":"2015-04","submissions":58,"submitters":51,"spanYears":18.376,"breakoutYears":8,"maxScore":1164,"evidenceRank":1,"evidenceScore":100.0,"freshAt":"2026-01-29T03:58:33Z","freshnessRank":71,"freshEventScore":683,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1164 pts / 198 comments (2023) + 1034 pts / 135 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,167 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 58 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 51 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":2,"peak_score":80,"peak_comments":28,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=385068","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":3,"peak_score":169,"peak_comments":18,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2701063","height":8,"chart_height":25},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3427263","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6296201","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7892556","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":4,"peak_score":915,"peak_comments":139,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9338708","height":24,"chart_height":134},{"year":2016,"count":5,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12126564","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":246,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14676835","height":12,"chart_height":36},{"year":2018,"count":5,"peak_score":135,"peak_comments":32,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18675375","height":6,"chart_height":20},{"year":2019,"count":8,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19321973","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":7,"peak_score":1034,"peak_comments":135,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23775404","height":24,"chart_height":151},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":368,"peak_comments":93,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29213064","height":18,"chart_height":54},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32709027","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":1164,"peak_comments":198,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37576633","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46139637","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":3,"peak_score":683,"peak_comments":113,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46805665","height":24,"chart_height":100}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/we-can-t-send-email-more-than-500-miles-2002-d9d0234fd128.jpg","path":"/hall/link/we-can-t-send-email-more-than-500-miles-2002-d9d0234fd128/"},{"slug":"teach-yourself-programming-in-ten-years-1998-d9d0233e123a","title":"Teach Yourself Programming in Ten Years (1998)","domain":"norvig.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2007,"candidateMonth":"2013-04","inductedMonth":"2021-06","submissions":32,"submitters":32,"spanYears":18.615,"breakoutYears":9,"maxScore":586,"evidenceRank":2,"evidenceScore":99.0,"freshAt":"2025-07-26T21:24:51Z","freshnessRank":183,"freshEventScore":179,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 586 pts / 302 comments (2024) + 253 pts / 115 comments (2021), different submitters and 953 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 32 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 32 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":2,"peak_score":54,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43243","height":4,"chart_height":16},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":88,"peak_comments":32,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1060176","height":4,"chart_height":26},{"year":2011,"count":4,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3194716","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":131,"peak_comments":29,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3439772","height":6,"chart_height":38},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":186,"peak_comments":86,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5519158","height":9,"chart_height":54},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7513672","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":67,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9395284","height":4,"chart_height":19},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13062221","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15211775","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":184,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16574248","height":9,"chart_height":53},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":174,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20543495","height":8,"chart_height":50},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":253,"peak_comments":115,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27411276","height":12,"chart_height":73},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":187,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33287618","height":9,"chart_height":54},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":586,"peak_comments":302,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39001755","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":179,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44697007","height":9,"chart_height":52},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/teach-yourself-programming-in-ten-years-1998-d9d0233e123a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/teach-yourself-programming-in-ten-years-1998-d9d0233e123a/"},{"slug":"cool-uris-don-t-change-1998-d9d0233e8637","title":"Cool URIs Don't Change (1998)","domain":"www.w3.org","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","internet_infrastructure"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2012-06","inductedMonth":"2016-05","submissions":24,"submitters":21,"spanYears":16.35,"breakoutYears":6,"maxScore":387,"evidenceRank":3,"evidenceScore":98.2,"freshAt":"2023-03-03T21:59:56Z","freshnessRank":649,"freshEventScore":295,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 387 pts / 154 comments (2020) + 297 pts / 122 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,521 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 24 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 21 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":33,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=175199","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":115,"peak_comments":25,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2492566","height":6,"chart_height":51},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":187,"peak_comments":84,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4154927","height":9,"chart_height":82},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8454570","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10086156","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":297,"peak_comments":122,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11712449","height":14,"chart_height":130},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16669998","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21151174","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":387,"peak_comments":154,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23865484","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":309,"peak_comments":140,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27537840","height":15,"chart_height":136},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33158949","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":295,"peak_comments":120,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35015624","height":14,"chart_height":130},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39223140","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/cool-uris-don-t-change-1998-d9d0233e8637.jpg","path":"/hall/link/cool-uris-don-t-change-1998-d9d0233e8637/"},{"slug":"what-you-can-t-say-2004-d9d0233f7f9b","title":"What You Can't Say (2004)","domain":"www.paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["philosophy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2014-03","inductedMonth":"2014-03","submissions":31,"submitters":31,"spanYears":14.505,"breakoutYears":6,"maxScore":241,"evidenceRank":4,"evidenceScore":97.5,"freshAt":"2022-03-16T18:28:15Z","freshnessRank":805,"freshEventScore":107,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 191 pts / 290 comments (2014) + 241 pts / 232 comments (2019), different submitters and 2,030 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 31 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 31 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":45,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=581050","height":4,"chart_height":32},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2937128","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3912560","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5402520","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":4,"peak_score":191,"peak_comments":290,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7443420","height":9,"chart_height":135},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13119269","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":5,"peak_score":143,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14952908","height":7,"chart_height":101},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":90,"peak_comments":124,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18221049","height":4,"chart_height":63},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":241,"peak_comments":232,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21229032","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23734080","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":6,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28454660","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":107,"peak_comments":204,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30702281","height":5,"chart_height":75},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38059429","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-you-can-t-say-2004-d9d0233f7f9b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-you-can-t-say-2004-d9d0233f7f9b/"},{"slug":"music-for-programming-d9d023453079","title":"Music for Programming","domain":"musicforprogramming.net","category":"media","categoryDisplay":"Audio, video & images","type":"audio","typeDisplay":"Audio","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2016-11","inductedMonth":"2016-11","submissions":27,"submitters":26,"spanYears":14.168,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":738,"evidenceRank":5,"evidenceScore":97.4,"freshAt":"2026-04-05T18:23:08Z","freshnessRank":32,"freshEventScore":356,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 738 pts / 427 comments (2016) + 427 pts / 261 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,136 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 27 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 26 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":3,"peak_score":411,"peak_comments":180,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3547694","height":20,"chart_height":95},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10575370","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":8,"peak_score":738,"peak_comments":427,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12844434","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":29,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17573053","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":427,"peak_comments":261,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21771600","height":20,"chart_height":98},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27918261","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":510,"peak_comments":259,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32009440","height":24,"chart_height":117},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":30,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39581358","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46126114","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":356,"peak_comments":175,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47652322","height":17,"chart_height":82}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/music-for-programming-d9d023453079.jpg","path":"/hall/link/music-for-programming-d9d023453079/"},{"slug":"if-the-moon-were-only-1-pixel-a-tediously-accurate-solar-system-d9d0234c2e2a","title":"If the moon were only 1 pixel: A tediously accurate solar system model (2014)","domain":"joshworth.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"space_transportation","topicDisplay":"Space & transportation","tags":["space_astronomy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2017-03","inductedMonth":"2017-03","submissions":31,"submitters":30,"spanYears":11.277,"breakoutYears":6,"maxScore":936,"evidenceRank":6,"evidenceScore":97.4,"freshAt":"2025-06-13T08:40:05Z","freshnessRank":200,"freshEventScore":936,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 936 pts / 261 comments (2025) + 476 pts / 178 comments (2014), different submitters and 4,118 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 31 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 30 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":476,"peak_comments":178,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7341690","height":23,"chart_height":86},{"year":2015,"count":6,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8834512","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":11,"peak_score":23,"peak_comments":11,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13217129","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":364,"peak_comments":81,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13790954","height":17,"chart_height":66},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":422,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21735528","height":20,"chart_height":77},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22001080","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":257,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27573172","height":12,"chart_height":47},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":266,"peak_comments":108,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32936581","height":13,"chart_height":48},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39686916","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":936,"peak_comments":261,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44266828","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/if-the-moon-were-only-1-pixel-a-tediously-accurate-solar-system-d9d0234c2e2a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/if-the-moon-were-only-1-pixel-a-tediously-accurate-solar-system-d9d0234c2e2a/"},{"slug":"choose-boring-technology-2015-d9d0234fbbc8","title":"Choose Boring Technology (2015)","domain":"mcfunley.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","databases_storage","management_strategy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-07","inductedMonth":"2020-06","submissions":41,"submitters":39,"spanYears":11.066,"breakoutYears":6,"maxScore":1357,"evidenceRank":7,"evidenceScore":97.4,"freshAt":"2023-10-01T22:53:04Z","freshnessRank":532,"freshEventScore":195,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 603 pts / 361 comments (2021) + 577 pts / 212 comments (2015), different submitters and 2,154 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 41 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 39 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":577,"peak_comments":212,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9291215","height":24,"chart_height":72},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12512006","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":7,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16217750","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":5,"peak_score":1357,"peak_comments":344,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20323246","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":459,"peak_comments":282,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23444594","height":22,"chart_height":58},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":603,"peak_comments":361,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26211721","height":24,"chart_height":76},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":148,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31558887","height":7,"chart_height":19},{"year":2023,"count":5,"peak_score":195,"peak_comments":132,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37731798","height":9,"chart_height":24},{"year":2024,"count":5,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40958880","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":5,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43635205","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":5,"peak_score":19,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46916487","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/choose-boring-technology-2015-d9d0234fbbc8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/choose-boring-technology-2015-d9d0234fbbc8/"},{"slug":"the-unix-haters-handbook-1994-pdf-d9d0234a61d4","title":"The Unix-Haters Handbook (1994) [pdf]","domain":"web.mit.edu","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2017-03","inductedMonth":"2017-03","submissions":17,"submitters":16,"spanYears":15.014,"breakoutYears":7,"maxScore":382,"evidenceRank":8,"evidenceScore":95.7,"freshAt":"2025-08-25T00:46:22Z","freshnessRank":163,"freshEventScore":214,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 382 pts / 307 comments (2017) + 284 pts / 157 comments (2019), different submitters and 744 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1621722","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3719793","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6280650","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":128,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7726115","height":6,"chart_height":57},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":30,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9976694","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":382,"peak_comments":307,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13781815","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":284,"peak_comments":157,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19416485","height":14,"chart_height":126},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25225590","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27692933","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":189,"peak_comments":86,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31417690","height":9,"chart_height":84},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":141,"peak_comments":139,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38464715","height":7,"chart_height":63},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":81,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40110729","height":4,"chart_height":36},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":214,"peak_comments":147,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45009164","height":10,"chart_height":95},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-unix-haters-handbook-1994-pdf-d9d0234a61d4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-unix-haters-handbook-1994-pdf-d9d0234a61d4/"},{"slug":"the-gervais-principle-or-the-office-according-to-the-office-d9d0234013b1","title":"The Gervais Principle, or the Office According to \"The Office\"","domain":"www.ribbonfarm.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["workplace","management_strategy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2020-12","inductedMonth":"2020-12","submissions":24,"submitters":24,"spanYears":16.394,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":325,"evidenceRank":9,"evidenceScore":95.7,"freshAt":"2026-03-07T11:28:37Z","freshnessRank":48,"freshEventScore":325,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 258 pts / 173 comments (2024) + 307 pts / 63 comments (2009), different submitters and 5,414 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 24 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 24 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":307,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=881296","height":15,"chart_height":161},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2983726","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5177077","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10144562","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":27,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14851505","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18522836","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21449030","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":7,"peak_score":122,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25486869","height":6,"chart_height":64},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":260,"peak_comments":149,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33298158","height":12,"chart_height":136},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":258,"peak_comments":173,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41214180","height":12,"chart_height":135},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":325,"peak_comments":159,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47286657","height":16,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-gervais-principle-or-the-office-according-to-the-office-d9d0234013b1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-gervais-principle-or-the-office-according-to-the-office-d9d0234013b1/"},{"slug":"why-gnu-grep-is-fast-2010-d9d0234176ba","title":"Why GNU grep is fast (2010)","domain":"lists.freebsd.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"social_post_thread","typeDisplay":"Social posts & threads","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["performance_reliability","developer_tools","algorithms_data_structures"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2013-11","inductedMonth":"2015-03","submissions":14,"submitters":14,"spanYears":11.918,"breakoutYears":7,"maxScore":512,"evidenceRank":10,"evidenceScore":94.4,"freshAt":"2022-07-24T13:46:58Z","freshnessRank":745,"freshEventScore":209,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 511 pts / 218 comments (2019) + 512 pts / 115 comments (2010), different submitters and 3,140 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":512,"peak_comments":115,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1626305","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":329,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2393587","height":16,"chart_height":109},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":495,"peak_comments":129,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6813937","height":24,"chart_height":164},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":151,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9153203","height":7,"chart_height":50},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":417,"peak_comments":145,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12350890","height":20,"chart_height":138},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17262638","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":511,"peak_comments":218,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19521872","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":78,"peak_comments":35,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23923645","height":4,"chart_height":26},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":209,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32213468","height":10,"chart_height":69},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-gnu-grep-is-fast-2010-d9d0234176ba.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-gnu-grep-is-fast-2010-d9d0234176ba/"},{"slug":"a-brief-incomplete-and-mostly-wrong-history-of-programming-langu-d9d0233f8903","title":"A Brief, Incomplete, and Mostly Wrong History of Programming Languages","domain":"james-iry.blogspot.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2012-01","inductedMonth":"2012-01","submissions":42,"submitters":41,"spanYears":17.06,"breakoutYears":8,"maxScore":391,"evidenceRank":11,"evidenceScore":94.2,"freshAt":"2023-06-25T20:00:21Z","freshnessRank":603,"freshEventScore":224,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 391 pts / 45 comments (2012) + 303 pts / 14 comments (2009), different submitters and 991 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 42 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 41 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":303,"peak_comments":14,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=599164","height":15,"chart_height":132},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":163,"peak_comments":13,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1327746","height":8,"chart_height":71},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":3,"peak_score":391,"peak_comments":45,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3503896","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":213,"peak_comments":33,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5695816","height":10,"chart_height":93},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":22,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7149634","height":5,"chart_height":44},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9718186","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":197,"peak_comments":24,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11936058","height":9,"chart_height":86},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15257308","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":5,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16695995","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19580276","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":5,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23148748","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":110,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27559618","height":5,"chart_height":48},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33001242","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":224,"peak_comments":65,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36471999","height":11,"chart_height":97},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42376768","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":6,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46006144","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2026,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46560205","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-brief-incomplete-and-mostly-wrong-history-of-programming-langu-d9d0233f8903.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-brief-incomplete-and-mostly-wrong-history-of-programming-langu-d9d0233f8903/"},{"slug":"they-re-made-out-of-meat-d9d023453155","title":"They're Made out of Meat","domain":"www.terrybisson.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["books_literature"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2014-08","inductedMonth":"2016-04","submissions":19,"submitters":19,"spanYears":14.045,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":702,"evidenceRank":12,"evidenceScore":94.2,"freshAt":"2023-11-26T08:36:23Z","freshnessRank":491,"freshEventScore":472,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 702 pts / 292 comments (2020) + 558 pts / 170 comments (2014), different submitters and 2,255 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 19 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 19 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":278,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3549320","height":13,"chart_height":67},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6929446","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":558,"peak_comments":170,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8152131","height":24,"chart_height":135},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":27,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11561522","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16872122","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":702,"peak_comments":292,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24737993","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":384,"peak_comments":151,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31965062","height":18,"chart_height":93},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":472,"peak_comments":168,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38420111","height":23,"chart_height":114},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43999964","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47034757","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/they-re-made-out-of-meat-d9d023453155/"},{"slug":"hexagonal-grids-2013-d9d0234958d3","title":"Hexagonal Grids (2013)","domain":"www.redblobgames.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_development","algorithms_data_structures","mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2017-06","inductedMonth":"2018-09","submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":12.739,"breakoutYears":6,"maxScore":709,"evidenceRank":13,"evidenceScore":94.0,"freshAt":"2026-02-03T13:11:14Z","freshnessRank":67,"freshEventScore":40,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 709 pts / 69 comments (2013) + 368 pts / 74 comments (2020), different submitters and 2,745 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":709,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5809724","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":462,"peak_comments":39,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8941588","height":22,"chart_height":111},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":174,"peak_comments":18,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14627711","height":8,"chart_height":42},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18026999","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":337,"peak_comments":46,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19184412","height":16,"chart_height":81},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":368,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25340425","height":18,"chart_height":88},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":48,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30818125","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":250,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37954600","height":12,"chart_height":60},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43296794","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":3,"peak_score":40,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46870541","height":4,"chart_height":10}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/hexagonal-grids-2013-d9d0234958d3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/hexagonal-grids-2013-d9d0234958d3/"},{"slug":"don-t-call-yourself-a-programmer-and-other-career-advice-2011-d9d023446884","title":"Don't Call Yourself a Programmer, and Other Career Advice (2011)","domain":"www.kalzumeus.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["careers","labor_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2015-02","inductedMonth":"2016-09","submissions":24,"submitters":22,"spanYears":14.694,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":1021,"evidenceRank":14,"evidenceScore":93.5,"freshAt":"2021-08-19T15:17:10Z","freshnessRank":881,"freshEventScore":71,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1021 pts / 267 comments (2011) + 570 pts / 307 comments (2019), different submitters and 2,913 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 24 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 22 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":1021,"peak_comments":267,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3170766","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7617465","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":80,"peak_comments":84,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9015160","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":154,"peak_comments":147,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12548043","height":7,"chart_height":26},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18761834","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":5,"peak_score":570,"peak_comments":307,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21303181","height":24,"chart_height":95},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":71,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28234937","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33732255","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40114892","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42817728","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48846382","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/don-t-call-yourself-a-programmer-and-other-career-advice-2011-d9d023446884.jpg","path":"/hall/link/don-t-call-yourself-a-programmer-and-other-career-advice-2011-d9d023446884/"},{"slug":"the-architecture-of-open-source-applications-d9d023433b79","title":"The Architecture of Open Source Applications","domain":"www.aosabook.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2013-09","inductedMonth":"2019-08","submissions":20,"submitters":20,"spanYears":15.165,"breakoutYears":7,"maxScore":423,"evidenceRank":15,"evidenceScore":93.3,"freshAt":"2023-10-08T11:14:30Z","freshnessRank":529,"freshEventScore":175,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 423 pts / 37 comments (2019) + 238 pts / 21 comments (2013), different submitters and 2,160 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":184,"peak_comments":13,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2904425","height":9,"chart_height":74},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":238,"peak_comments":21,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6404929","height":11,"chart_height":96},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8014163","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":116,"peak_comments":15,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9418788","height":6,"chart_height":47},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":138,"peak_comments":19,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12170182","height":7,"chart_height":55},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14945697","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17547915","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":423,"peak_comments":37,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20731206","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":395,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24332485","height":19,"chart_height":159},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":73,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31297069","height":4,"chart_height":29},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":175,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37809529","height":8,"chart_height":70},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42625549","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49011019","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-architecture-of-open-source-applications-d9d023433b79.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-architecture-of-open-source-applications-d9d023433b79/"},{"slug":"john-carmack-on-inlined-code-d9d0234e0c8b","title":"John Carmack on Inlined Code","domain":"number-none.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","performance_reliability","game_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2017-02","inductedMonth":"2019-01","submissions":21,"submitters":14,"spanYears":11.663,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":556,"evidenceRank":16,"evidenceScore":93.3,"freshAt":"2024-10-06T16:47:18Z","freshnessRank":320,"freshEventScore":556,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 556 pts / 389 comments (2024) + 456 pts / 260 comments (2014), different submitters and 3,662 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 21 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":456,"peak_comments":260,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8374345","height":22,"chart_height":139},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10294793","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":4,"peak_score":395,"peak_comments":199,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12120752","height":19,"chart_height":121},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":23,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14333115","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17793962","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":161,"peak_comments":105,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18959636","height":8,"chart_height":49},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":138,"peak_comments":169,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25263488","height":7,"chart_height":42},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31595575","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37596187","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":556,"peak_comments":389,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41758371","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48284741","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/john-carmack-on-inlined-code-d9d0234e0c8b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/john-carmack-on-inlined-code-d9d0234e0c8b/"},{"slug":"pointer-pointer-2012-d9d023465551","title":"Pointer Pointer","domain":"pointerpointer.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["user_experience","art","internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2014-11","inductedMonth":"2014-11","submissions":18,"submitters":18,"spanYears":13.328,"breakoutYears":6,"maxScore":455,"evidenceRank":17,"evidenceScore":93.2,"freshAt":"2025-10-09T12:42:01Z","freshnessRank":134,"freshEventScore":244,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 455 pts / 64 comments (2020) + 367 pts / 65 comments (2012), different submitters and 3,103 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 18 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 18 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":367,"peak_comments":65,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4095237","height":18,"chart_height":137},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6733272","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":205,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8583179","height":10,"chart_height":77},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12116863","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18630046","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19819216","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":455,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25372356","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":426,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32069578","height":20,"chart_height":159},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":149,"peak_comments":20,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38296667","height":7,"chart_height":56},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":4,"peak_score":244,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45526845","height":12,"chart_height":91},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/pointer-pointer-2012-d9d023465551.jpg","path":"/hall/link/pointer-pointer-2012-d9d023465551/"},{"slug":"fs-d9d0234a3e8c","title":"ΠFS","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["databases_storage","open_source","mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2017-03","inductedMonth":"2017-03","submissions":25,"submitters":25,"spanYears":12.827,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":962,"evidenceRank":18,"evidenceScore":93.0,"freshAt":"2026-06-10T18:54:54Z","freshnessRank":7,"freshEventScore":962,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 962 pts / 206 comments (2026) + 310 pts / 98 comments (2014), different submitters and 4,352 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 25 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 25 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":87,"peak_comments":32,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6698852","height":4,"chart_height":15},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":310,"peak_comments":98,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8018818","height":15,"chart_height":55},{"year":2015,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10485740","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10847693","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":285,"peak_comments":105,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13869691","height":14,"chart_height":50},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18687275","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21371991","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23667032","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":98,"peak_comments":30,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28699499","height":5,"chart_height":17},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":155,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36357466","height":7,"chart_height":27},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":962,"peak_comments":206,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48480978","height":24,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/fs-d9d0234a3e8c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/fs-d9d0234a3e8c/"},{"slug":"project-euler-is-offline-d9d0233e4387","title":"Project Euler is offline","domain":"projecteuler.net","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","algorithms_data_structures"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2007,"candidateMonth":"2017-12","inductedMonth":"2017-12","submissions":18,"submitters":17,"spanYears":17.938,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":792,"evidenceRank":19,"evidenceScore":92.6,"freshAt":"2025-11-12T17:24:54Z","freshnessRank":116,"freshEventScore":566,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 792 pts / 163 comments (2017) + 566 pts / 134 comments (2025), different submitters and 2,893 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 18 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":1,"peak_score":34,"peak_comments":10,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=86365","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2017479","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6826109","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":306,"peak_comments":134,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7056888","height":15,"chart_height":66},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":80,"peak_comments":35,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9990221","height":4,"chart_height":17},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":792,"peak_comments":163,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15893911","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25492736","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":331,"peak_comments":128,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29211532","height":16,"chart_height":71},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37982030","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40197505","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":566,"peak_comments":134,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45902898","height":24,"chart_height":121},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/project-euler-is-offline-d9d0233e4387.jpg","path":"/hall/link/project-euler-is-offline-d9d0233e4387/"},{"slug":"maker-s-schedule-manager-s-schedule-2009-d9d0233fc315","title":"Maker's schedule, Manager's schedule (2009)","domain":"www.paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["workplace","leadership","personal_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2015-12","inductedMonth":"2015-12","submissions":20,"submitters":20,"spanYears":15.565,"breakoutYears":6,"maxScore":383,"evidenceRank":20,"evidenceScore":92.0,"freshAt":"2023-06-24T05:30:47Z","freshnessRank":604,"freshEventScore":197,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 383 pts / 130 comments (2018) + 312 pts / 89 comments (2009), different submitters and 3,198 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":2,"peak_score":312,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=718279","height":15,"chart_height":138},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2427137","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5096209","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":156,"peak_comments":28,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10658187","height":7,"chart_height":69},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13925692","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":383,"peak_comments":130,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16922147","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":153,"peak_comments":22,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20990635","height":7,"chart_height":68},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":146,"peak_comments":39,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27987036","height":7,"chart_height":65},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":5,"peak_score":197,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36455843","height":9,"chart_height":87},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39615104","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43039131","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/maker-s-schedule-manager-s-schedule-2009-d9d0233fc315.jpg","path":"/hall/link/maker-s-schedule-manager-s-schedule-2009-d9d0233fc315/"},{"slug":"reality-has-a-surprising-amount-of-detail-2017-d9d02357042e","title":"Reality has a surprising amount of detail (2017)","domain":"johnsalvatier.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["philosophy","psychology"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-01","inductedMonth":"2020-01","submissions":19,"submitters":17,"spanYears":9.021,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":699,"evidenceRank":21,"evidenceScore":91.8,"freshAt":"2025-02-18T09:36:30Z","freshnessRank":247,"freshEventScore":386,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 699 pts / 294 comments (2018) + 498 pts / 115 comments (2020), different submitters and 722 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 19 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14347447","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":699,"peak_comments":294,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16184255","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20018441","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":498,"peak_comments":115,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22020495","height":24,"chart_height":121},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":290,"peak_comments":118,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29429385","height":14,"chart_height":71},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":5,"peak_score":397,"peak_comments":136,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38407851","height":19,"chart_height":97},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":386,"peak_comments":210,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43087779","height":19,"chart_height":94},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48249145","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/reality-has-a-surprising-amount-of-detail-2017-d9d02357042e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/reality-has-a-surprising-amount-of-detail-2017-d9d02357042e/"},{"slug":"asciiflow-d9d0234360f7","title":"Asciiflow","domain":"www.asciiflow.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","visual_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2014-01","inductedMonth":"2014-01","submissions":20,"submitters":20,"spanYears":14.207,"breakoutYears":6,"maxScore":368,"evidenceRank":22,"evidenceScore":91.7,"freshAt":"2025-08-27T12:10:21Z","freshnessRank":159,"freshEventScore":143,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 368 pts / 56 comments (2018) + 321 pts / 69 comments (2014), different submitters and 1,443 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":151,"peak_comments":20,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2847177","height":7,"chart_height":70},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":52,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3598177","height":4,"chart_height":24},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5269609","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":5,"peak_score":321,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7085133","height":15,"chart_height":148},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":59,"peak_comments":10,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9130756","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":368,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16051428","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":214,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27536253","height":10,"chart_height":99},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":290,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30273299","height":14,"chart_height":134},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38026285","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39669394","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":143,"peak_comments":34,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45038565","height":7,"chart_height":66},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/asciiflow-d9d0234360f7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/asciiflow-d9d0234360f7/"},{"slug":"explain-shell-d9d0234a67e3","title":"Explain Shell","domain":"explainshell.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","operating_systems","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2017-03","inductedMonth":"2017-03","submissions":29,"submitters":29,"spanYears":11.318,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":1372,"evidenceRank":23,"evidenceScore":91.4,"freshAt":"2022-05-30T14:03:35Z","freshnessRank":774,"freshEventScore":130,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1372 pts / 171 comments (2013) + 775 pts / 85 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,213 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 29 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 29 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":1372,"peak_comments":171,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6834791","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10700798","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11627632","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":5,"peak_score":775,"peak_comments":85,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13989215","height":24,"chart_height":96},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18293649","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":329,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19124480","height":16,"chart_height":41},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":63,"peak_comments":12,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24525999","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":130,"peak_comments":28,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31559065","height":6,"chart_height":16},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38281104","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":4,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42495938","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/explain-shell-d9d0234a67e3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/explain-shell-d9d0234a67e3/"},{"slug":"akin-s-laws-of-spacecraft-design-2003-d9d0234245aa","title":"Akin's Laws of Spacecraft Design (2003)","domain":"spacecraft.ssl.umd.edu","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"space_transportation","topicDisplay":"Space & transportation","tags":["space_astronomy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2016-03","inductedMonth":"2018-05","submissions":18,"submitters":16,"spanYears":14.505,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":558,"evidenceRank":24,"evidenceScore":91.2,"freshAt":"2023-08-09T09:45:40Z","freshnessRank":575,"freshEventScore":317,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 558 pts / 157 comments (2018) + 317 pts / 156 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,922 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 18 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":134,"peak_comments":17,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2087091","height":6,"chart_height":41},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5818612","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9035838","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":240,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11343633","height":12,"chart_height":73},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15247356","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":558,"peak_comments":157,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16996306","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20768860","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22752526","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":303,"peak_comments":119,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25698990","height":15,"chart_height":92},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33791510","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":317,"peak_comments":156,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37060470","height":15,"chart_height":97},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44550043","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/akin-s-laws-of-spacecraft-design-2003-d9d0234245aa.jpg","path":"/hall/link/akin-s-laws-of-spacecraft-design-2003-d9d0234245aa/"},{"slug":"the-lost-art-of-c-structure-packing-d9d0234b94a9","title":"The Lost Art of C Structure Packing","domain":"www.catb.org","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","performance_reliability","computer_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2016-08","inductedMonth":"2016-08","submissions":17,"submitters":15,"spanYears":12.312,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":335,"evidenceRank":25,"evidenceScore":90.9,"freshAt":"2022-04-27T16:50:24Z","freshnessRank":788,"freshEventScore":159,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 159 pts / 153 comments (2022) + 335 pts / 143 comments (2014), different submitters and 3,037 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":335,"peak_comments":143,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6995568","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9517623","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":117,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12231464","height":6,"chart_height":59},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":123,"peak_comments":49,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15626205","height":6,"chart_height":62},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20368379","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":112,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22995171","height":5,"chart_height":57},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":159,"peak_comments":153,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31182449","height":8,"chart_height":81},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":3,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46670619","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-lost-art-of-c-structure-packing-d9d0234b94a9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-lost-art-of-c-structure-packing-d9d0234b94a9/"},{"slug":"compiler-explorer-d9d023591ccd","title":"Compiler Explorer","domain":"godbolt.org","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["compilers_runtimes","programming_languages","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2017-09","inductedMonth":"2020-08","submissions":32,"submitters":31,"spanYears":13.582,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":541,"evidenceRank":26,"evidenceScore":90.6,"freshAt":"2022-10-16T15:50:51Z","freshnessRank":709,"freshEventScore":541,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 541 pts / 107 comments (2022) + 303 pts / 48 comments (2020), different submitters and 801 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 32 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 31 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4020814","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":89,"peak_comments":40,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7593109","height":4,"chart_height":28},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9808870","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":5,"peak_score":135,"peak_comments":38,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11671730","height":6,"chart_height":42},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":87,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15147335","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2018,"count":9,"peak_score":208,"peak_comments":44,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18671993","height":10,"chart_height":65},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19697135","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":303,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24066570","height":15,"chart_height":95},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28569839","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":541,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33224542","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40521954","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43808308","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/compiler-explorer-d9d023591ccd/"},{"slug":"why-to-start-a-startup-in-a-bad-economy-2008-d9d0233ef38e","title":"Why to Start a Startup in a Bad Economy (2008)","domain":"paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["startups_entrepreneurship","economics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2015-11","inductedMonth":"2020-03","submissions":15,"submitters":15,"spanYears":17.259,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":392,"evidenceRank":27,"evidenceScore":90.6,"freshAt":"2023-01-18T17:32:14Z","freshnessRank":666,"freshEventScore":392,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 392 pts / 225 comments (2023) + 254 pts / 195 comments (2008), different submitters and 5,207 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":254,"peak_comments":195,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=334355","height":12,"chart_height":110},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":118,"peak_comments":25,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2869211","height":6,"chart_height":51},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10626951","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14913718","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":196,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22554886","height":9,"chart_height":85},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":4,"peak_score":199,"peak_comments":137,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31375945","height":10,"chart_height":86},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":392,"peak_comments":225,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34429869","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43155057","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46678705","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-to-start-a-startup-in-a-bad-economy-2008-d9d0233ef38e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-to-start-a-startup-in-a-bad-economy-2008-d9d0233ef38e/"},{"slug":"how-to-write-a-spelling-corrector-d9d0233e08bd","title":"How to Write a Spelling Corrector","domain":"norvig.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["information_retrieval","machine_learning"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2007,"candidateMonth":"2010-12","inductedMonth":"2016-09","submissions":21,"submitters":21,"spanYears":16.838,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":401,"evidenceRank":28,"evidenceScore":90.4,"freshAt":"2022-03-06T06:05:34Z","freshnessRank":812,"freshEventScore":89,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 401 pts / 126 comments (2016) + 181 pts / 27 comments (2010), different submitters and 2,085 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 21 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 21 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":2,"peak_score":63,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42587","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":2,"peak_score":124,"peak_comments":18,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=665544","height":6,"chart_height":53},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":181,"peak_comments":27,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2034981","height":9,"chart_height":77},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":160,"peak_comments":24,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4617500","height":8,"chart_height":68},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":90,"peak_comments":20,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8749518","height":4,"chart_height":38},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9743764","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":401,"peak_comments":126,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12453535","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":346,"peak_comments":84,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16918757","height":17,"chart_height":147},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21882693","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25298013","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":76,"peak_comments":23,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28551468","height":4,"chart_height":32},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":89,"peak_comments":12,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30575416","height":4,"chart_height":38},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39316686","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-to-write-a-spelling-corrector-d9d0233e08bd.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-to-write-a-spelling-corrector-d9d0233e08bd/"},{"slug":"utf-8-everywhere-d9d02345f4a1","title":"UTF-8 Everywhere","domain":"utf8everywhere.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2015-03","inductedMonth":"2016-06","submissions":18,"submitters":17,"spanYears":13.043,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":381,"evidenceRank":29,"evidenceScore":89.9,"freshAt":"2020-04-14T15:55:11Z","freshnessRank":1012,"freshEventScore":326,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 326 pts / 281 comments (2020) + 381 pts / 182 comments (2012), different submitters and 2,906 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 18 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":3,"peak_score":381,"peak_comments":182,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3906253","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":275,"peak_comments":149,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7070944","height":13,"chart_height":123},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9208348","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":122,"peak_comments":153,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11933113","height":6,"chart_height":54},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21690350","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":326,"peak_comments":281,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22867503","height":16,"chart_height":145},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":4,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40583758","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43991610","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/utf-8-everywhere-d9d02345f4a1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/utf-8-everywhere-d9d02345f4a1/"},{"slug":"pass-the-standard-unix-password-manager-d9d0234cfbd8","title":"Pass: The standard Unix password manager","domain":"www.passwordstore.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography","application_security","open_source","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2021-04","inductedMonth":"2021-04","submissions":22,"submitters":21,"spanYears":11.299,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":411,"evidenceRank":30,"evidenceScore":89.9,"freshAt":"2025-09-13T23:16:40Z","freshnessRank":145,"freshEventScore":329,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 411 pts / 205 comments (2021) + 406 pts / 199 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,362 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 22 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 21 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7804377","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9455330","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":5,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12265096","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":406,"peak_comments":199,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14819136","height":19,"chart_height":168},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18831212","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24059375","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":411,"peak_comments":205,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26799021","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":168,"peak_comments":76,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31773056","height":8,"chart_height":69},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37929867","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":329,"peak_comments":181,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45236079","height":16,"chart_height":136},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/pass-the-standard-unix-password-manager-d9d0234cfbd8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/pass-the-standard-unix-password-manager-d9d0234cfbd8/"},{"slug":"keep-your-identity-small-2009-d9d0233f428f","title":"Keep Your Identity Small (2009)","domain":"www.paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["psychology","philosophy","social_issues"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2016-05","inductedMonth":"2017-09","submissions":13,"submitters":12,"spanYears":13.834,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":386,"evidenceRank":31,"evidenceScore":89.8,"freshAt":"2021-06-07T01:19:14Z","freshnessRank":903,"freshEventScore":386,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 386 pts / 300 comments (2021) + 234 pts / 253 comments (2009), different submitters and 4,502 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":234,"peak_comments":253,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=471660","height":11,"chart_height":103},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":211,"peak_comments":90,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6171790","height":10,"chart_height":93},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":184,"peak_comments":153,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11732970","height":9,"chart_height":81},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13672992","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":254,"peak_comments":110,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16454591","height":12,"chart_height":112},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19757833","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23858249","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":386,"peak_comments":300,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27417992","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33931361","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/keep-your-identity-small-2009-d9d0233f428f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/keep-your-identity-small-2009-d9d0233f428f/"},{"slug":"asciinema-d9d0234c45c5","title":"Asciinema","domain":"asciinema.org","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2018-05","inductedMonth":"2018-05","submissions":24,"submitters":24,"spanYears":11.368,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":513,"evidenceRank":32,"evidenceScore":89.7,"freshAt":"2025-07-25T02:50:32Z","freshnessRank":185,"freshEventScore":262,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 513 pts / 90 comments (2015) + 367 pts / 94 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,632 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 24 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 24 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7392382","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":4,"peak_score":513,"peak_comments":90,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9753537","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13132977","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":5,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15827994","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":275,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17048922","height":13,"chart_height":91},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":367,"peak_comments":94,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21750747","height":18,"chart_height":122},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23949754","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26825189","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32773857","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":240,"peak_comments":86,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38134861","height":12,"chart_height":80},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":262,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44679048","height":13,"chart_height":87},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/asciinema-d9d0234c45c5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/asciinema-d9d0234c45c5/"},{"slug":"crafting-interpreters-d9d02355d492","title":"Crafting Interpreters","domain":"craftinginterpreters.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["compilers_runtimes","programming_languages","algorithms_data_structures"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2019-03","inductedMonth":"2021-07","submissions":16,"submitters":15,"spanYears":8.997,"breakoutYears":6,"maxScore":623,"evidenceRank":33,"evidenceScore":89.7,"freshAt":"2026-01-14T22:26:17Z","freshnessRank":78,"freshEventScore":240,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 623 pts / 118 comments (2021) + 607 pts / 187 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,079 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":423,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13406081","height":20,"chart_height":115},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":187,"peak_comments":41,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17496238","height":9,"chart_height":51},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20074378","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":5,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22788735","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":623,"peak_comments":118,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27997167","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34074637","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":115,"peak_comments":24,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34986902","height":6,"chart_height":31},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":607,"peak_comments":187,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40950235","height":24,"chart_height":166},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":240,"peak_comments":58,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46624658","height":12,"chart_height":65}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/crafting-interpreters-d9d02355d492.jpg","path":"/hall/link/crafting-interpreters-d9d02355d492/"},{"slug":"operating-systems-three-easy-pieces-d9d0234b8caf","title":"Operating Systems: Three Easy Pieces","domain":"pages.cs.wisc.edu","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2017-03","inductedMonth":"2018-09","submissions":20,"submitters":17,"spanYears":12.298,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":334,"evidenceRank":34,"evidenceScore":89.1,"freshAt":"2021-02-07T00:08:18Z","freshnessRank":945,"freshEventScore":324,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 334 pts / 35 comments (2015) + 324 pts / 28 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,979 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6972395","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":189,"peak_comments":35,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7076973","height":9,"chart_height":96},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":334,"peak_comments":35,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10182727","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":5,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14300042","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":303,"peak_comments":26,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18104600","height":15,"chart_height":154},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22244428","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":324,"peak_comments":28,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26051386","height":16,"chart_height":165},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33612347","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38385266","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39050108","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42860454","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47773047","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/operating-systems-three-easy-pieces-d9d0234b8caf.jpg","path":"/hall/link/operating-systems-three-easy-pieces-d9d0234b8caf/"},{"slug":"a-primer-on-b-zier-curves-2013-d9d0234945d2","title":"A Primer on Bézier Curves (2013)","domain":"pomax.github.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","computer_graphics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-04","inductedMonth":"2017-04","submissions":25,"submitters":19,"spanYears":12.991,"breakoutYears":6,"maxScore":398,"evidenceRank":35,"evidenceScore":88.9,"freshAt":"2026-04-28T12:57:53Z","freshnessRank":23,"freshEventScore":151,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 398 pts / 61 comments (2017) + 243 pts / 34 comments (2019), different submitters and 847 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 25 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 19 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5639433","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":114,"peak_comments":23,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8804691","height":5,"chart_height":49},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9135007","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":190,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11402656","height":9,"chart_height":81},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":398,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14191577","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":5,"peak_score":74,"peak_comments":19,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17528187","height":4,"chart_height":32},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":243,"peak_comments":34,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20751074","height":12,"chart_height":104},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25142160","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28686939","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":197,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30100427","height":9,"chart_height":84},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36925968","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41605894","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":151,"peak_comments":21,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47933934","height":7,"chart_height":64}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-primer-on-b-zier-curves-2013-d9d0234945d2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-primer-on-b-zier-curves-2013-d9d0234945d2/"},{"slug":"how-not-to-sort-by-average-rating-2009-d9d0233f46a4","title":"How Not to Sort by Average Rating (2009)","domain":"www.evanmiller.org","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","data_science"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2012-04","inductedMonth":"2017-08","submissions":18,"submitters":17,"spanYears":15.699,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":383,"evidenceRank":36,"evidenceScore":88.9,"freshAt":"2024-10-25T16:01:05Z","freshnessRank":309,"freshEventScore":77,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 383 pts / 156 comments (2017) + 325 pts / 82 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,535 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 18 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":195,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=478632","height":9,"chart_height":87},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":141,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1218951","height":7,"chart_height":63},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3784912","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7466236","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":150,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9855784","height":7,"chart_height":67},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12874538","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":5,"peak_score":383,"peak_comments":156,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15131611","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21365704","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24231345","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":325,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29200103","height":16,"chart_height":144},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37676146","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":77,"peak_comments":25,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41946534","height":4,"chart_height":34},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-not-to-sort-by-average-rating-2009-d9d0233f46a4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-not-to-sort-by-average-rating-2009-d9d0233f46a4/"},{"slug":"universal-paperclips-d9d02362cd04","title":"Universal Paperclips","domain":"www.decisionproblem.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"computer_game","typeDisplay":"Computer games","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["indie_games","game_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-09","inductedMonth":"2020-09","submissions":29,"submitters":27,"spanYears":8.674,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":403,"evidenceRank":37,"evidenceScore":88.9,"freshAt":"2023-08-02T15:28:42Z","freshnessRank":581,"freshEventScore":183,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 403 pts / 170 comments (2022) + 257 pts / 112 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,845 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 29 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 27 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":257,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15474055","height":12,"chart_height":108},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20955089","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":246,"peak_comments":84,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24389655","height":12,"chart_height":104},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27121348","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":6,"peak_score":403,"peak_comments":170,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33446121","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":183,"peak_comments":165,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36972227","height":9,"chart_height":77},{"year":2024,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40993302","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44153547","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48515685","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/universal-paperclips-d9d02362cd04.jpg","path":"/hall/link/universal-paperclips-d9d02362cd04/"},{"slug":"how-sqlite-is-tested-d9d0233f98ba","title":"How SQLite Is Tested","domain":"www.sqlite.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["testing_quality","databases_storage"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2012-10","inductedMonth":"2025-12","submissions":23,"submitters":20,"spanYears":16.55,"breakoutYears":6,"maxScore":319,"evidenceRank":38,"evidenceScore":88.7,"freshAt":"2025-12-17T18:15:38Z","freshnessRank":95,"freshEventScore":319,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 319 pts / 82 comments (2025) + 200 pts / 57 comments (2016), different submitters and 3,467 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 23 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":115,"peak_comments":28,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=633151","height":6,"chart_height":61},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1281485","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":176,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4616548","height":8,"chart_height":94},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":163,"peak_comments":37,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6815321","height":8,"chart_height":87},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8509439","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":59,"peak_comments":17,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9095836","height":4,"chart_height":31},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":200,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11936435","height":10,"chart_height":107},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15190162","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16071740","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22807081","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":164,"peak_comments":47,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29460240","height":8,"chart_height":87},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31167927","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36833665","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38963383","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":319,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46303277","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-sqlite-is-tested-d9d0233f98ba.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-sqlite-is-tested-d9d0233f98ba/"},{"slug":"submarine-cable-map-d9d0234418c7","title":"Submarine Cable Map","domain":"www.submarinecablemap.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["internet_infrastructure","protocols_networking"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2017-02","inductedMonth":"2017-02","submissions":30,"submitters":30,"spanYears":13.966,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":317,"evidenceRank":39,"evidenceScore":88.6,"freshAt":"2025-09-07T18:17:29Z","freshnessRank":152,"freshEventScore":61,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 235 pts / 134 comments (2020) + 317 pts / 109 comments (2012), different submitters and 3,175 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 30 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 30 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3020065","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":317,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3643749","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5861102","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":66,"peak_comments":39,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9216894","height":4,"chart_height":35},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":103,"peak_comments":35,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13614598","height":5,"chart_height":55},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18330944","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":7,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21523340","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":235,"peak_comments":134,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25020431","height":11,"chart_height":126},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":175,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33110478","height":8,"chart_height":94},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":7,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41604404","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":61,"peak_comments":12,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45160780","height":4,"chart_height":33},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/submarine-cable-map-d9d0234418c7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/submarine-cable-map-d9d0234418c7/"},{"slug":"webgl-water-d9d02343d271","title":"WebGL Water","domain":"madebyevan.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["computer_graphics","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2014-02","inductedMonth":"2014-02","submissions":17,"submitters":16,"spanYears":13.739,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":467,"evidenceRank":40,"evidenceScore":88.6,"freshAt":"2025-05-10T00:13:38Z","freshnessRank":213,"freshEventScore":220,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 467 pts / 131 comments (2014) + 463 pts / 85 comments (2011), different submitters and 919 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":463,"peak_comments":85,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2884141","height":22,"chart_height":169},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4265066","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6434183","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":467,"peak_comments":131,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7264103","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10731223","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10989598","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":91,"peak_comments":31,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14432809","height":4,"chart_height":33},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":27,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18681245","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":369,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29376037","height":18,"chart_height":134},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38369580","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":220,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43942149","height":11,"chart_height":80},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/webgl-water-d9d02343d271.jpg","path":"/hall/link/webgl-water-d9d02343d271/"},{"slug":"ffmpeg-4-0-released-d9d02342befc","title":"FFmpeg 4.0 released","domain":"ffmpeg.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2019-08","inductedMonth":"2021-04","submissions":11,"submitters":8,"spanYears":15.003,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":987,"evidenceRank":41,"evidenceScore":88.5,"freshAt":"2026-03-17T14:51:57Z","freshnessRank":44,"freshEventScore":438,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 987 pts / 200 comments (2025) + 462 pts / 61 comments (2018), different submitters and 2,680 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2330819","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9989147","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":462,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16888605","height":22,"chart_height":80},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":327,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20629325","height":16,"chart_height":56},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":365,"peak_comments":130,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26746537","height":18,"chart_height":63},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29968123","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36169234","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":987,"peak_comments":200,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44985730","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":438,"peak_comments":65,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47413525","height":21,"chart_height":75}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/ffmpeg-4-0-released-d9d02342befc.jpg","path":"/hall/link/ffmpeg-4-0-released-d9d02342befc/"},{"slug":"feynman-lectures-on-physics-now-free-online-d9d0234b46d1","title":"Feynman Lectures on Physics now free online","domain":"www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["physics","mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2017-01","inductedMonth":"2017-01","submissions":15,"submitters":15,"spanYears":12.208,"breakoutYears":6,"maxScore":749,"evidenceRank":42,"evidenceScore":88.5,"freshAt":"2026-02-10T11:36:14Z","freshnessRank":62,"freshEventScore":490,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 749 pts / 93 comments (2014) + 490 pts / 141 comments (2026), different submitters and 4,188 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6804332","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":749,"peak_comments":93,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8216546","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":247,"peak_comments":20,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10390296","height":12,"chart_height":56},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":143,"peak_comments":38,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13368748","height":7,"chart_height":32},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16921334","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":253,"peak_comments":27,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19887468","height":12,"chart_height":57},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25452745","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25834071","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":222,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36017793","height":11,"chart_height":50},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43434057","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":490,"peak_comments":141,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46958345","height":24,"chart_height":111}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/feynman-lectures-on-physics-now-free-online-d9d0234b46d1/"},{"slug":"laws-of-ux-d9d023593b6b","title":"Laws of UX","domain":"lawsofux.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["user_experience","product_design","psychology"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2020-08","inductedMonth":"2020-08","submissions":17,"submitters":17,"spanYears":8.285,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":1037,"evidenceRank":43,"evidenceScore":88.4,"freshAt":"2026-04-29T16:58:13Z","freshnessRank":22,"freshEventScore":346,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1037 pts / 293 comments (2020) + 535 pts / 207 comments (2018), different submitters and 926 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":535,"peak_comments":207,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16185118","height":24,"chart_height":88},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20856239","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":1037,"peak_comments":293,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24030969","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29135308","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29915939","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":134,"peak_comments":110,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36680835","height":6,"chart_height":22},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41942397","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43671064","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":3,"peak_score":346,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47951137","height":17,"chart_height":57}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/laws-of-ux-d9d023593b6b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/laws-of-ux-d9d023593b6b/"},{"slug":"hiroshima-1946-d9d02350f956","title":"Hiroshima (1946)","domain":"www.newyorker.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["history","geopolitics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-11","inductedMonth":"2018-11","submissions":17,"submitters":14,"spanYears":9.99,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":181,"evidenceRank":44,"evidenceScore":88.2,"freshAt":"2025-08-02T10:59:38Z","freshnessRank":177,"freshEventScore":120,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 120 pts / 266 comments (2025) + 173 pts / 187 comments (2016), different submitters and 3,358 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10018003","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":173,"peak_comments":187,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11750331","height":8,"chart_height":162},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15322621","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":132,"peak_comments":119,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18536235","height":6,"chart_height":124},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":181,"peak_comments":158,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24101712","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32303785","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2023,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36114749","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39738388","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":120,"peak_comments":266,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44766551","height":6,"chart_height":113},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/hiroshima-1946-d9d02350f956.jpg","path":"/hall/link/hiroshima-1946-d9d02350f956/"},{"slug":"why-numbering-should-start-at-zero-1982-d9d0233fe0ea","title":"Why numbering should start at zero (1982)","domain":"www.cs.utexas.edu","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["programming_languages","mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2016-12","inductedMonth":"2016-12","submissions":17,"submitters":16,"spanYears":13.9,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":169,"evidenceRank":45,"evidenceScore":88.1,"freshAt":"2023-07-16T02:26:05Z","freshnessRank":590,"freshEventScore":31,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 169 pts / 220 comments (2020) + 161 pts / 216 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,138 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":48,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=777580","height":4,"chart_height":48},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2703492","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6618700","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8150794","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":4,"peak_score":67,"peak_comments":47,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9761355","height":4,"chart_height":67},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":161,"peak_comments":216,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13186225","height":8,"chart_height":162},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":42,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17765034","height":4,"chart_height":42},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":169,"peak_comments":220,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22162705","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28035700","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":31,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36742920","height":4,"chart_height":31},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-numbering-should-start-at-zero-1982-d9d0233fe0ea.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-numbering-should-start-at-zero-1982-d9d0233fe0ea/"},{"slug":"the-true-size-of-countries-mercator-projection-d9d023513f96","title":"The True Size Of Countries: Mercator projection","domain":"thetruesize.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","earth_science"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-09","inductedMonth":"2020-11","submissions":21,"submitters":20,"spanYears":9.634,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":556,"evidenceRank":46,"evidenceScore":88.0,"freshAt":"2025-04-26T15:41:44Z","freshnessRank":215,"freshEventScore":295,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 556 pts / 266 comments (2020) + 295 pts / 138 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,622 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 21 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":105,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10182024","height":5,"chart_height":32},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13096485","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":193,"peak_comments":66,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13327973","height":9,"chart_height":59},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18592972","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":155,"peak_comments":49,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20898538","height":7,"chart_height":47},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":556,"peak_comments":266,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25104787","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33615312","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38684058","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":295,"peak_comments":138,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43804561","height":14,"chart_height":90},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/the-true-size-of-countries-mercator-projection-d9d023513f96/"},{"slug":"pijul-a-intuitive-vcs-unlike-git-that-s-based-on-sound-theory-of-d9d0235168c3","title":"Pijul: A intuitive VCS unlike Git that's based on sound theory of patches","domain":"pijul.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","distributed_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-06","inductedMonth":"2020-09","submissions":16,"submitters":15,"spanYears":10.533,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":269,"evidenceRank":47,"evidenceScore":88.0,"freshAt":"2026-04-07T10:16:38Z","freshnessRank":30,"freshEventScore":191,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 255 pts / 210 comments (2024) + 259 pts / 172 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,562 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":5,"peak_score":104,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10470281","height":5,"chart_height":66},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":259,"peak_comments":172,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13643025","height":12,"chart_height":164},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":69,"peak_comments":13,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18654958","height":4,"chart_height":44},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":269,"peak_comments":165,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24592568","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":37,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31788265","height":4,"chart_height":23},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38810624","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":255,"peak_comments":210,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39452543","height":12,"chart_height":161},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":191,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47672941","height":9,"chart_height":121}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/pijul-a-intuitive-vcs-unlike-git-that-s-based-on-sound-theory-of-d9d0235168c3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/pijul-a-intuitive-vcs-unlike-git-that-s-based-on-sound-theory-of-d9d0235168c3/"},{"slug":"microsoft-is-dead-2007-d9d0233e0844","title":"Microsoft is Dead (2007)","domain":"www.paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["markets"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2007,"candidateMonth":"2014-02","inductedMonth":"2017-05","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":16.624,"breakoutYears":6,"maxScore":182,"evidenceRank":48,"evidenceScore":87.6,"freshAt":"2020-12-30T13:22:46Z","freshnessRank":957,"freshEventScore":50,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 77 pts / 445 comments (2007) + 182 pts / 182 comments (2014), different submitters and 2,496 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":1,"peak_score":77,"peak_comments":445,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9770","height":4,"chart_height":72},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":97,"peak_comments":93,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2085601","height":5,"chart_height":91},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":182,"peak_comments":182,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7182179","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":97,"peak_comments":92,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10343458","height":5,"chart_height":91},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15387926","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":111,"peak_comments":96,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18579913","height":5,"chart_height":104},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":50,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25581417","height":4,"chart_height":47},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31776056","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38344424","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/microsoft-is-dead-2007-d9d0233e0844.jpg","path":"/hall/link/microsoft-is-dead-2007-d9d0233e0844/"},{"slug":"google-earth-for-live-radios-d9d0235584c7","title":"Google Earth for live radios","domain":"radio.garden","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["music","internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-02","inductedMonth":"2020-06","submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":8.821,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":527,"evidenceRank":49,"evidenceScore":87.6,"freshAt":"2025-10-08T23:34:42Z","freshnessRank":135,"freshEventScore":36,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 527 pts / 110 comments (2016) + 461 pts / 123 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,275 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":527,"peak_comments":110,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13164058","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":522,"peak_comments":98,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18427701","height":24,"chart_height":168},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":461,"peak_comments":123,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23477771","height":22,"chart_height":149},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29740046","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":206,"peak_comments":34,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30441847","height":10,"chart_height":66},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38247022","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":294,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40887359","height":14,"chart_height":95},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":36,"peak_comments":10,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45521833","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/google-earth-for-live-radios-d9d0235584c7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/google-earth-for-live-radios-d9d0235584c7/"},{"slug":"open-source-home-automation-d9d02351357c","title":"Open-Source Home Automation","domain":"www.home-assistant.io","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["embedded_iot","open_source","privacy_surveillance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-11","inductedMonth":"2019-11","submissions":14,"submitters":14,"spanYears":10.338,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":869,"evidenceRank":50,"evidenceScore":87.5,"freshAt":"2021-09-15T21:52:57Z","freshnessRank":873,"freshEventScore":561,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 869 pts / 231 comments (2019) + 552 pts / 170 comments (2017), different submitters and 769 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10159673","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11313032","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":552,"peak_comments":170,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15521743","height":24,"chart_height":108},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":540,"peak_comments":196,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17826373","height":24,"chart_height":106},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":869,"peak_comments":231,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21665125","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":561,"peak_comments":177,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28544835","height":24,"chart_height":110},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34171704","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34809843","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46471226","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/open-source-home-automation-d9d02351357c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/open-source-home-automation-d9d02351357c/"},{"slug":"windows93-sp2-d9d0234e4ef6","title":"Windows93 SP2","domain":"www.windows93.net","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["art","internet_culture","retrocomputing"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2017-06","inductedMonth":"2017-06","submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":11.332,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":790,"evidenceRank":51,"evidenceScore":87.5,"freshAt":"2021-07-28T08:01:05Z","freshnessRank":891,"freshEventScore":30,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 790 pts / 113 comments (2016) + 630 pts / 232 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,237 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":91,"peak_comments":25,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8507786","height":4,"chart_height":20},{"year":2015,"count":4,"peak_score":291,"peak_comments":73,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9162566","height":14,"chart_height":63},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":790,"peak_comments":113,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12691597","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":517,"peak_comments":121,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14531578","height":24,"chart_height":111},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19143984","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":630,"peak_comments":232,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22463415","height":24,"chart_height":136},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":30,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27981405","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33364340","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":19,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38832658","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47117937","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/windows93-sp2-d9d0234e4ef6/"},{"slug":"eloquent-javascript-4th-edition-2024-d9d0233e1fc4","title":"Eloquent JavaScript 4th edition (2024)","domain":"eloquentjavascript.net","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2007,"candidateMonth":"2014-07","inductedMonth":"2014-07","submissions":14,"submitters":14,"spanYears":18.453,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":1274,"evidenceRank":52,"evidenceScore":87.5,"freshAt":"2024-03-07T13:52:16Z","freshnessRank":432,"freshEventScore":1274,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1274 pts / 231 comments (2024) + 767 pts / 185 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,410 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":1,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39024","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=190747","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":12,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1056132","height":5,"chart_height":13},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3389122","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5546960","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":632,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8107394","height":24,"chart_height":84},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16467441","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20616612","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":767,"peak_comments":185,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22990926","height":24,"chart_height":102},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":50,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29953822","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1274,"peak_comments":231,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39629044","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46635964","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/eloquent-javascript-4th-edition-2024-d9d0233e1fc4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/eloquent-javascript-4th-edition-2024-d9d0233e1fc4/"},{"slug":"notes-on-distributed-systems-for-young-bloods-2013-d9d023482ff8","title":"Notes on Distributed Systems for Young Bloods (2013)","domain":"www.somethingsimilar.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["distributed_systems","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2015-03","inductedMonth":"2016-08","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":12.893,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":386,"evidenceRank":53,"evidenceScore":87.3,"freshAt":"2024-09-02T17:23:26Z","freshnessRank":338,"freshEventScore":373,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 386 pts / 133 comments (2016) + 373 pts / 55 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,947 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":346,"peak_comments":42,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5055371","height":17,"chart_height":152},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":100,"peak_comments":7,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9227254","height":5,"chart_height":44},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":386,"peak_comments":133,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12245909","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17325889","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":216,"peak_comments":8,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23365402","height":10,"chart_height":95},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33223977","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":373,"peak_comments":55,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41427185","height":18,"chart_height":164},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46175891","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/notes-on-distributed-systems-for-young-bloods-2013-d9d023482ff8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/notes-on-distributed-systems-for-young-bloods-2013-d9d023482ff8/"},{"slug":"incomplete-list-of-mistakes-in-the-design-of-css-d9d02351ad82","title":"Incomplete list of mistakes in the design of CSS","domain":"wiki.csswg.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","browsers_web_standards"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-10","inductedMonth":"2020-09","submissions":14,"submitters":11,"spanYears":10.136,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":197,"evidenceRank":54,"evidenceScore":87.2,"freshAt":"2025-12-11T04:20:52Z","freshnessRank":99,"freshEventScore":197,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 196 pts / 150 comments (2018) + 112 pts / 143 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,853 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":4,"peak_score":146,"peak_comments":106,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10453850","height":7,"chart_height":126},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":196,"peak_comments":150,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18297757","height":9,"chart_height":169},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24359009","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":183,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25891435","height":9,"chart_height":158},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32481477","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":112,"peak_comments":143,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38363698","height":5,"chart_height":97},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":197,"peak_comments":131,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46227619","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/incomplete-list-of-mistakes-in-the-design-of-css-d9d02351ad82.jpg","path":"/hall/link/incomplete-list-of-mistakes-in-the-design-of-css-d9d02351ad82/"},{"slug":"crystal-programming-language-d9d02349f75f","title":"Crystal Programming Language","domain":"crystal-lang.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","compilers_runtimes","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2018-04","inductedMonth":"2018-04","submissions":23,"submitters":22,"spanYears":10.719,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":254,"evidenceRank":55,"evidenceScore":87.2,"freshAt":"2022-09-01T21:26:39Z","freshnessRank":722,"freshEventScore":206,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 254 pts / 171 comments (2015) + 206 pts / 112 comments (2022), different submitters and 2,644 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 23 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 22 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":21,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6428723","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":50,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8658358","height":4,"chart_height":33},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":254,"peak_comments":171,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9669166","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13071994","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":5,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13947447","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":143,"peak_comments":73,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16842442","height":7,"chart_height":96},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":5,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22746840","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29507362","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":206,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32683473","height":10,"chart_height":138},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39886753","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/crystal-programming-language-d9d02349f75f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/crystal-programming-language-d9d02349f75f/"},{"slug":"linux-ate-my-ram-d9d023426e29","title":"Linux ate my RAM ","domain":"www.linuxatemyram.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2013-11","inductedMonth":"2017-02","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":12.684,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":245,"evidenceRank":56,"evidenceScore":87.1,"freshAt":"2023-10-09T17:31:30Z","freshnessRank":528,"freshEventScore":245,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 245 pts / 186 comments (2023) + 194 pts / 125 comments (2013), different submitters and 3,619 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":155,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2165376","height":7,"chart_height":108},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":102,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3698652","height":5,"chart_height":71},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":194,"peak_comments":125,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6711069","height":9,"chart_height":135},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10834722","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13904349","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":26,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17070007","height":4,"chart_height":18},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24912836","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":97,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29653573","height":5,"chart_height":67},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":245,"peak_comments":186,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37822927","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/linux-ate-my-ram-d9d023426e29.jpg","path":"/hall/link/linux-ate-my-ram-d9d023426e29/"},{"slug":"what-did-earth-look-like-x-million-years-ago-d9d0235a9e25","title":"What did Earth look like X million years ago?","domain":"dinosaurpictures.org","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["earth_science","scientific_method","computer_graphics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2020-09","inductedMonth":"2020-09","submissions":25,"submitters":23,"spanYears":7.411,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":509,"evidenceRank":57,"evidenceScore":87.0,"freshAt":"2023-08-08T19:53:49Z","freshnessRank":577,"freshEventScore":107,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 509 pts / 111 comments (2022) + 423 pts / 75 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,390 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 25 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 23 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":423,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17690693","height":20,"chart_height":141},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19174406","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":230,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24459997","height":11,"chart_height":77},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":7,"peak_score":509,"peak_comments":111,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31520483","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":5,"peak_score":107,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37054603","height":5,"chart_height":36},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39690983","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45857439","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-did-earth-look-like-x-million-years-ago-d9d0235a9e25.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-did-earth-look-like-x-million-years-ago-d9d0235a9e25/"},{"slug":"the-elves-leave-middle-earth-sodas-are-no-longer-free-2009-d9d023405428","title":"The Elves Leave Middle Earth – Sodas Are No Longer Free (2009)","domain":"steveblank.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["startups_entrepreneurship","management_strategy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2015-11","inductedMonth":"2016-12","submissions":15,"submitters":12,"spanYears":13.985,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":458,"evidenceRank":58,"evidenceScore":86.7,"freshAt":"2023-12-16T15:51:12Z","freshnessRank":482,"freshEventScore":35,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 458 pts / 390 comments (2013) + 327 pts / 226 comments (2009), different submitters and 1,248 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":327,"peak_comments":226,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1007750","height":16,"chart_height":121},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":458,"peak_comments":390,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5751329","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10544735","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":105,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13134712","height":5,"chart_height":39},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15847371","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16801710","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19690250","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27445943","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":159,"peak_comments":198,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31573108","height":8,"chart_height":59},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":35,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38665089","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-elves-leave-middle-earth-sodas-are-no-longer-free-2009-d9d023405428.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-elves-leave-middle-earth-sodas-are-no-longer-free-2009-d9d023405428/"},{"slug":"how-i-do-my-computing-d9d02345c04a","title":"How I do my computing","domain":"stallman.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["open_source","operating_systems","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2015-05","inductedMonth":"2016-10","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":14.289,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":334,"evidenceRank":59,"evidenceScore":86.7,"freshAt":"2023-07-29T19:18:00Z","freshnessRank":584,"freshEventScore":60,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 334 pts / 327 comments (2015) + 205 pts / 276 comments (2012), different submitters and 1,135 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":205,"peak_comments":276,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3809836","height":10,"chart_height":104},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5383586","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7289602","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":334,"peak_comments":327,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9559672","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":82,"peak_comments":117,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12789797","height":4,"chart_height":42},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15862357","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":54,"peak_comments":22,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18564037","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":28,"peak_comments":20,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23911181","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29015892","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":60,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36923520","height":4,"chart_height":31},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46205395","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49011506","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-i-do-my-computing-d9d02345c04a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-i-do-my-computing-d9d02345c04a/"},{"slug":"understanding-the-bin-sbin-usr-bin-usr-sbin-split-d9d023452175","title":"Understanding the bin, sbin, usr/bin , usr/sbin split","domain":"lists.busybox.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2018-11","inductedMonth":"2022-05","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":13.938,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":857,"evidenceRank":60,"evidenceScore":86.5,"freshAt":"2026-01-04T13:49:04Z","freshnessRank":85,"freshEventScore":199,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 857 pts / 151 comments (2012) + 534 pts / 231 comments (2022), different submitters and 3,756 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":857,"peak_comments":151,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3519952","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":378,"peak_comments":129,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11647304","height":18,"chart_height":75},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18501487","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":398,"peak_comments":105,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22614731","height":19,"chart_height":79},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":534,"peak_comments":231,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31336396","height":24,"chart_height":106},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39539596","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43362175","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":199,"peak_comments":157,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46487921","height":10,"chart_height":39}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/understanding-the-bin-sbin-usr-bin-usr-sbin-split-d9d023452175.jpg","path":"/hall/link/understanding-the-bin-sbin-usr-bin-usr-sbin-split-d9d023452175/"},{"slug":"0-30000000000000004-d9d02351dfbc","title":"0.30000000000000004","domain":"0.30000000000000004.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["programming_languages","mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-12","inductedMonth":"2021-04","submissions":17,"submitters":16,"spanYears":10.615,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":768,"evidenceRank":61,"evidenceScore":86.5,"freshAt":"2022-06-20T01:48:34Z","freshnessRank":765,"freshEventScore":56,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 768 pts / 402 comments (2019) + 533 pts / 240 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,480 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":533,"peak_comments":240,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10558871","height":24,"chart_height":118},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":380,"peak_comments":130,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14018450","height":18,"chart_height":84},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":768,"peak_comments":402,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21686264","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":5,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29687473","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":56,"peak_comments":65,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31805431","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41229718","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44011218","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48674279","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/0-30000000000000004-d9d02351dfbc.jpg","path":"/hall/link/0-30000000000000004-d9d02351dfbc/"},{"slug":"jewish-problems-d9d0234441eb","title":"Jewish problems","domain":"arxiv.org","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"research_paper","typeDisplay":"Research papers","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","history","social_issues"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2013-12","inductedMonth":"2017-10","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":13.117,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":303,"evidenceRank":62,"evidenceScore":86.4,"freshAt":"2021-08-11T01:05:25Z","freshnessRank":883,"freshEventScore":110,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 303 pts / 187 comments (2011) + 156 pts / 170 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,188 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":303,"peak_comments":187,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3096793","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":115,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4759642","height":6,"chart_height":65},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6899599","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":120,"peak_comments":95,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10923934","height":6,"chart_height":67},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":156,"peak_comments":170,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15424117","height":7,"chart_height":88},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":37,"peak_comments":33,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22896047","height":4,"chart_height":21},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":110,"peak_comments":126,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28136729","height":5,"chart_height":62},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34022978","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39083895","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/jewish-problems-d9d0234441eb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/jewish-problems-d9d0234441eb/"},{"slug":"open-source-game-clones-d9d023434b57","title":"Open Source Game Clones","domain":"osgameclones.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_development","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2014-08","inductedMonth":"2017-10","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":14.275,"breakoutYears":6,"maxScore":576,"evidenceRank":63,"evidenceScore":86.4,"freshAt":"2023-12-27T02:09:22Z","freshnessRank":474,"freshEventScore":150,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 576 pts / 96 comments (2019) + 219 pts / 81 comments (2013), different submitters and 2,200 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":208,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2607619","height":10,"chart_height":61},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":219,"peak_comments":81,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5775714","height":11,"chart_height":65},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":121,"peak_comments":28,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8184463","height":6,"chart_height":36},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9523058","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":309,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15468487","height":15,"chart_height":91},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":576,"peak_comments":96,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20110442","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27262817","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":62,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32426925","height":4,"chart_height":18},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":150,"peak_comments":26,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38778313","height":7,"chart_height":44},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45190111","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/open-source-game-clones-d9d023434b57.jpg","path":"/hall/link/open-source-game-clones-d9d023434b57/"},{"slug":"falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-names-2010-d9d0234126ef","title":"Falsehoods Programmers Believe About Names (2010)","domain":"www.kalzumeus.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":[],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2019-11","inductedMonth":"2019-11","submissions":31,"submitters":29,"spanYears":16.077,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":176,"evidenceRank":64,"evidenceScore":86.3,"freshAt":"2021-03-07T09:53:55Z","freshnessRank":936,"freshEventScore":51,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 150 pts / 142 comments (2019) + 176 pts / 138 comments (2010), different submitters and 3,432 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 31 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 29 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":176,"peak_comments":138,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1438472","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5994098","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7365517","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2015,"count":4,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":13,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10255610","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":37,"peak_comments":43,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12450825","height":4,"chart_height":36},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18402796","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":150,"peak_comments":142,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21492464","height":7,"chart_height":145},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":51,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26374593","height":4,"chart_height":49},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33800775","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36020037","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42230716","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":5,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43297681","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2026,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48307145","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-names-2010-d9d0234126ef.jpg","path":"/hall/link/falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-names-2010-d9d0234126ef/"},{"slug":"command-line-tools-can-be-faster-than-a-hadoop-cluster-2014-d9d0235a7325","title":"Command-line tools can be faster than a Hadoop cluster (2014)","domain":"adamdrake.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","performance_reliability","data_engineering"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-06","inductedMonth":"2022-03","submissions":11,"submitters":10,"spanYears":7.658,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":463,"evidenceRank":65,"evidenceScore":86.3,"freshAt":"2026-01-18T08:58:40Z","freshnessRank":75,"freshEventScore":409,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 409 pts / 276 comments (2026) + 463 pts / 253 comments (2020), different submitters and 2,180 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":438,"peak_comments":222,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17135841","height":21,"chart_height":161},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21836008","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":463,"peak_comments":253,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22188877","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29106133","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":362,"peak_comments":166,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30595026","height":17,"chart_height":133},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38176442","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":240,"peak_comments":139,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39136472","height":12,"chart_height":88},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":409,"peak_comments":276,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46666085","height":20,"chart_height":150}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/command-line-tools-can-be-faster-than-a-hadoop-cluster-2014-d9d0235a7325.jpg","path":"/hall/link/command-line-tools-can-be-faster-than-a-hadoop-cluster-2014-d9d0235a7325/"},{"slug":"on-chomsky-and-the-two-cultures-of-statistical-learning-d9d023434337","title":"On Chomsky and the Two Cultures of Statistical Learning","domain":"norvig.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["machine_learning"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2016-06","inductedMonth":"2016-06","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":14.557,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":313,"evidenceRank":66,"evidenceScore":86.2,"freshAt":"2025-12-16T09:33:22Z","freshnessRank":96,"freshEventScore":101,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 83 pts / 135 comments (2023) + 313 pts / 107 comments (2011), different submitters and 4,304 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":313,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2591154","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4993109","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":152,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11951444","height":7,"chart_height":83},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":85,"peak_comments":12,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16489828","height":4,"chart_height":46},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21246081","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28891630","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30636605","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":83,"peak_comments":135,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35081102","height":4,"chart_height":45},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":90,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46286533","height":5,"chart_height":55},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/on-chomsky-and-the-two-cultures-of-statistical-learning-d9d023434337.jpg","path":"/hall/link/on-chomsky-and-the-two-cultures-of-statistical-learning-d9d023434337/"},{"slug":"the-twelve-factor-app-d9d023449887","title":"The Twelve-Factor App","domain":"12factor.net","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2022-04","inductedMonth":"2022-04","submissions":62,"submitters":61,"spanYears":14.549,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":381,"evidenceRank":67,"evidenceScore":86.2,"freshAt":"2023-10-12T14:19:46Z","freshnessRank":524,"freshEventScore":381,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 381 pts / 254 comments (2023) + 250 pts / 37 comments (2011), different submitters and 4,341 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 62 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 61 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":250,"peak_comments":37,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3267187","height":12,"chart_height":112},{"year":2012,"count":7,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4027026","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2013,"count":10,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6060381","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7600413","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":5,"peak_score":21,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10288216","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":8,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14933639","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":7,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18252248","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":40,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19947507","height":4,"chart_height":18},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24955125","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":5,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27544184","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":200,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31198956","height":10,"chart_height":89},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":381,"peak_comments":254,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37857544","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44652234","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48472794","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-twelve-factor-app-d9d023449887.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-twelve-factor-app-d9d023449887/"},{"slug":"timeline-of-the-far-future-d9d023460514","title":"Timeline of the far future","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"space_transportation","topicDisplay":"Space & transportation","tags":["space_astronomy","earth_science","biology"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2018-07","inductedMonth":"2018-07","submissions":45,"submitters":45,"spanYears":14.179,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":696,"evidenceRank":68,"evidenceScore":86.1,"freshAt":"2020-05-17T15:56:04Z","freshnessRank":1008,"freshEventScore":168,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 696 pts / 258 comments (2018) + 294 pts / 88 comments (2012), different submitters and 2,263 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 45 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 45 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":294,"peak_comments":88,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3936320","height":14,"chart_height":72},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6861343","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7221530","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10788635","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13187111","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":6,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15086232","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":696,"peak_comments":258,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17559822","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":168,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23212805","height":8,"chart_height":41},{"year":2021,"count":5,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29445443","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":5,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31005716","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35466306","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":6,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38995674","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43966466","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47025638","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/timeline-of-the-far-future-d9d023460514.jpg","path":"/hall/link/timeline-of-the-far-future-d9d023460514/"},{"slug":"advent-of-code-2021-d9d02352060f","title":"Advent of Code 2021","domain":"adventofcode.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["algorithms_data_structures","programming_languages","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-11","inductedMonth":"2021-12","submissions":24,"submitters":22,"spanYears":9.99,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":725,"evidenceRank":69,"evidenceScore":86.0,"freshAt":"2023-11-28T18:27:18Z","freshnessRank":489,"freshEventScore":134,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 725 pts / 264 comments (2021) + 134 pts / 160 comments (2023), different submitters and 727 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 24 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 22 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":5,"peak_score":201,"peak_comments":47,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10677207","height":10,"chart_height":47},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13087119","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15824296","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18585977","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":204,"peak_comments":72,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21660423","height":10,"chart_height":48},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":725,"peak_comments":264,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29403522","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":134,"peak_comments":160,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38449233","height":6,"chart_height":31},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45665648","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/advent-of-code-2021-d9d02352060f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/advent-of-code-2021-d9d02352060f/"},{"slug":"tutorial-how-to-use-git-in-a-team-development-environment-d9d02341a470","title":"Tutorial: How to use Git in a team development environment","domain":"nvie.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","software_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2017-10","inductedMonth":"2017-10","submissions":17,"submitters":17,"spanYears":12.945,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":199,"evidenceRank":70,"evidenceScore":86.0,"freshAt":"2023-09-07T07:12:50Z","freshnessRank":553,"freshEventScore":70,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 127 pts / 120 comments (2017) + 199 pts / 100 comments (2020), different submitters and 886 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":3,"peak_score":137,"peak_comments":26,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1826279","height":7,"chart_height":117},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3026732","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4409149","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":61,"peak_comments":15,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6437983","height":4,"chart_height":52},{"year":2014,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8447257","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11991564","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":127,"peak_comments":120,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15376841","height":6,"chart_height":108},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":199,"peak_comments":100,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22496724","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34146230","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":70,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37415677","height":4,"chart_height":60},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/tutorial-how-to-use-git-in-a-team-development-environment-d9d02341a470.jpg","path":"/hall/link/tutorial-how-to-use-git-in-a-team-development-environment-d9d02341a470/"},{"slug":"qubes-os-a-reasonably-secure-operating-system-d9d0235054c4","title":"Qubes OS: A reasonably secure operating system","domain":"www.qubes-os.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security","operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2022-03","inductedMonth":"2022-03","submissions":15,"submitters":15,"spanYears":11.009,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":441,"evidenceRank":71,"evidenceScore":85.8,"freshAt":"2025-01-12T22:28:30Z","freshnessRank":268,"freshEventScore":175,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 441 pts / 144 comments (2017) + 176 pts / 135 comments (2023), different submitters and 2,060 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10458429","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11691288","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":441,"peak_comments":144,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15734416","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24789146","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":187,"peak_comments":97,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30776103","height":9,"chart_height":72},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":176,"peak_comments":135,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36684946","height":8,"chart_height":68},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":175,"peak_comments":115,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42677608","height":8,"chart_height":67},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48357931","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/qubes-os-a-reasonably-secure-operating-system-d9d0235054c4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/qubes-os-a-reasonably-secure-operating-system-d9d0235054c4/"},{"slug":"myths-about-dev-urandom-d9d0234c36d6","title":"Myths about /dev/urandom","domain":"www.2uo.de","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2017-01","inductedMonth":"2017-01","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":12.186,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":232,"evidenceRank":72,"evidenceScore":85.7,"freshAt":"2026-05-14T11:26:22Z","freshnessRank":16,"freshEventScore":89,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 232 pts / 171 comments (2014) + 201 pts / 104 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,035 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":232,"peak_comments":171,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7359992","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":186,"peak_comments":106,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10149019","height":9,"chart_height":136},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":201,"peak_comments":104,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13332741","height":10,"chart_height":147},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":80,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17779657","height":4,"chart_height":59},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21638054","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":67,"peak_comments":35,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22683627","height":4,"chart_height":49},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":89,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48133908","height":4,"chart_height":65}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/myths-about-dev-urandom-d9d0234c36d6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/myths-about-dev-urandom-d9d0234c36d6/"},{"slug":"do-things-that-don-t-scale-d9d02349fbb1","title":"Do Things that Don't Scale","domain":"paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["startups_entrepreneurship","management_strategy","labor_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2017-08","inductedMonth":"2017-08","submissions":18,"submitters":18,"spanYears":12.088,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":1275,"evidenceRank":73,"evidenceScore":85.7,"freshAt":"2025-08-15T15:07:04Z","freshnessRank":170,"freshEventScore":368,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1275 pts / 207 comments (2013) + 368 pts / 113 comments (2025), different submitters and 4,414 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 18 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 18 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":1275,"peak_comments":207,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6041765","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11648412","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":209,"peak_comments":37,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14957007","height":10,"chart_height":28},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21229546","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":177,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26086196","height":8,"chart_height":24},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30624507","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35544317","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40931631","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":368,"peak_comments":113,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44913359","height":18,"chart_height":49},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/do-things-that-don-t-scale-d9d02349fbb1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/do-things-that-don-t-scale-d9d02349fbb1/"},{"slug":"why-open-source-misses-the-point-of-free-software-2007-d9d023415a3b","title":"Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software (2007)","domain":"www.gnu.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["technology_ethics","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2014-03","inductedMonth":"2014-05","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":15.072,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":298,"evidenceRank":74,"evidenceScore":85.6,"freshAt":"2019-09-24T00:56:59Z","freshnessRank":1045,"freshEventScore":277,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 277 pts / 399 comments (2019) + 298 pts / 312 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,563 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2000239","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":123,"peak_comments":117,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2239288","height":6,"chart_height":70},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":113,"peak_comments":256,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7435720","height":5,"chart_height":64},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":298,"peak_comments":312,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9711346","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18530107","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":277,"peak_comments":399,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21055419","height":13,"chart_height":158},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29889567","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45020581","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/why-open-source-misses-the-point-of-free-software-2007-d9d023415a3b/"},{"slug":"oh-shit-git-d9d02354a087","title":"Oh Shit, Git?","domain":"ohshitgit.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-05","inductedMonth":"2022-01","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":8.353,"breakoutYears":6,"maxScore":1209,"evidenceRank":75,"evidenceScore":85.6,"freshAt":"2025-01-16T18:24:09Z","freshnessRank":266,"freshEventScore":464,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1209 pts / 508 comments (2017) + 464 pts / 264 comments (2025), different submitters and 2,586 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":713,"peak_comments":335,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12459755","height":24,"chart_height":100},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1209,"peak_comments":508,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15951825","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":412,"peak_comments":272,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19906972","height":20,"chart_height":58},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":302,"peak_comments":156,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24173238","height":14,"chart_height":42},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":382,"peak_comments":231,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31874308","height":18,"chart_height":54},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39359133","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":464,"peak_comments":264,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42728916","height":22,"chart_height":65},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/oh-shit-git-d9d02354a087.jpg","path":"/hall/link/oh-shit-git-d9d02354a087/"},{"slug":"shellcheck-finds-bugs-in-your-shell-scripts-d9d023497598","title":"Shellcheck finds bugs in your shell scripts","domain":"www.shellcheck.net","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["testing_quality","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2021-05","inductedMonth":"2021-05","submissions":25,"submitters":22,"spanYears":11.904,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":342,"evidenceRank":76,"evidenceScore":85.4,"freshAt":"2023-11-23T19:16:08Z","freshnessRank":494,"freshEventScore":342,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 342 pts / 129 comments (2023) + 301 pts / 54 comments (2021), different submitters and 933 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 25 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 22 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6643206","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2014,"count":3,"peak_score":27,"peak_comments":14,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8182745","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2015,"count":5,"peak_score":102,"peak_comments":46,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9001931","height":5,"chart_height":51},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11839427","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14322018","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18123401","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21454855","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":301,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27030504","height":14,"chart_height":150},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":4,"peak_score":342,"peak_comments":129,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38396345","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43710763","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/shellcheck-finds-bugs-in-your-shell-scripts-d9d023497598.jpg","path":"/hall/link/shellcheck-finds-bugs-in-your-shell-scripts-d9d023497598/"},{"slug":"let-s-build-a-simple-database-2017-d9d023580802","title":"Let’s Build a Simple Database (2017)","domain":"cstack.github.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["databases_storage","programming_languages","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-08","inductedMonth":"2021-07","submissions":17,"submitters":15,"spanYears":8.783,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":783,"evidenceRank":77,"evidenceScore":85.4,"freshAt":"2023-05-03T09:40:42Z","freshnessRank":635,"freshEventScore":328,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 783 pts / 88 comments (2019) + 328 pts / 52 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,488 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":574,"peak_comments":146,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15168467","height":24,"chart_height":125},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":783,"peak_comments":88,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19581721","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24287202","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":210,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27731966","height":10,"chart_height":46},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":328,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35800109","height":16,"chart_height":71},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42534602","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43440955","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46959972","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/let-s-build-a-simple-database-2017-d9d023580802.jpg","path":"/hall/link/let-s-build-a-simple-database-2017-d9d023580802/"},{"slug":"the-land-of-lisp-d9d02341d19f","title":"The Land of Lisp","domain":"landoflisp.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["programming_languages","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2013-01","inductedMonth":"2013-01","submissions":11,"submitters":10,"spanYears":11.201,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":477,"evidenceRank":78,"evidenceScore":85.3,"freshAt":"2022-01-08T19:50:25Z","freshnessRank":837,"freshEventScore":183,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 382 pts / 229 comments (2013) + 477 pts / 135 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,731 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":398,"peak_comments":108,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1836935","height":19,"chart_height":142},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3013673","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3481456","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":382,"peak_comments":229,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5030803","height":18,"chart_height":136},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9731664","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":477,"peak_comments":135,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15417735","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":247,"peak_comments":80,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19677292","height":12,"chart_height":88},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27337167","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":183,"peak_comments":86,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29855453","height":9,"chart_height":65},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-land-of-lisp-d9d02341d19f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-land-of-lisp-d9d02341d19f/"},{"slug":"kids-can-t-use-computers-and-why-it-should-worry-you-d9d0234a3a2b","title":"Kids can't use computers, and why it should worry you","domain":"www.coding2learn.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["teaching","human_computer_interaction","children_parenting"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2017-01","inductedMonth":"2017-01","submissions":19,"submitters":18,"spanYears":12.742,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":625,"evidenceRank":79,"evidenceScore":85.3,"freshAt":"2025-04-10T13:19:22Z","freshnessRank":226,"freshEventScore":51,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 625 pts / 422 comments (2013) + 181 pts / 129 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,267 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 19 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 18 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":625,"peak_comments":422,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6186730","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7992043","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11950895","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":181,"peak_comments":129,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13506283","height":9,"chart_height":49},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17871658","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22177533","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":5,"peak_score":36,"peak_comments":21,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28218225","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":58,"peak_comments":28,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34654927","height":4,"chart_height":16},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":51,"peak_comments":95,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43643498","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48052156","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/kids-can-t-use-computers-and-why-it-should-worry-you-d9d0234a3a2b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/kids-can-t-use-computers-and-why-it-should-worry-you-d9d0234a3a2b/"},{"slug":"naughty-strings-a-list-of-strings-likely-to-cause-issues-as-user-d9d023510000","title":"Naughty Strings: A list of strings likely to cause issues as user-input data","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["testing_quality","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-08","inductedMonth":"2018-11","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":10.535,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":937,"evidenceRank":80,"evidenceScore":85.1,"freshAt":"2026-02-21T21:25:54Z","freshnessRank":55,"freshEventScore":24,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 937 pts / 144 comments (2017) + 409 pts / 92 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,224 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":514,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10035008","height":24,"chart_height":93},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":937,"peak_comments":144,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13406119","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":4,"peak_score":780,"peak_comments":146,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18466787","height":24,"chart_height":142},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":409,"peak_comments":92,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23291458","height":20,"chart_height":74},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30565288","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":22,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37426895","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":24,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47104953","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/naughty-strings-a-list-of-strings-likely-to-cause-issues-as-user-d9d023510000.jpg","path":"/hall/link/naughty-strings-a-list-of-strings-likely-to-cause-issues-as-user-d9d023510000/"},{"slug":"cool-retro-terminal-d9d0234e18d0","title":"Cool Retro Terminal","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","operating_systems","retrocomputing"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2022-03","inductedMonth":"2023-07","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":11.146,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":305,"evidenceRank":81,"evidenceScore":85.1,"freshAt":"2025-11-24T17:52:01Z","freshnessRank":113,"freshEventScore":298,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 298 pts / 118 comments (2025) + 305 pts / 89 comments (2023), different submitters and 858 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":246,"peak_comments":85,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8399461","height":12,"chart_height":137},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":176,"peak_comments":47,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9093545","height":8,"chart_height":98},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15586177","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18262102","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21250887","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23891063","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26400858","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":282,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30734137","height":14,"chart_height":157},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":305,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36798774","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":298,"peak_comments":118,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46036895","height":14,"chart_height":166},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/cool-retro-terminal-d9d0234e18d0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/cool-retro-terminal-d9d0234e18d0/"},{"slug":"the-tyranny-of-structurelessness-1970-d9d023405912","title":"The Tyranny of Structurelessness (1970)","domain":"www.jofreeman.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["social_issues","politics_government"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2018-07","inductedMonth":"2025-01","submissions":17,"submitters":17,"spanYears":16.323,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":387,"evidenceRank":82,"evidenceScore":84.9,"freshAt":"2025-01-22T14:57:23Z","freshnessRank":261,"freshEventScore":387,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 387 pts / 149 comments (2025) + 115 pts / 20 comments (2018), different submitters and 2,376 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1018665","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6021263","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":36,"peak_comments":15,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7762486","height":4,"chart_height":16},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8999937","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":98,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11651406","height":5,"chart_height":43},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":28,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15535834","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":115,"peak_comments":20,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17585104","height":6,"chart_height":51},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":26,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20202795","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":108,"peak_comments":19,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24728477","height":5,"chart_height":47},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31829486","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":282,"peak_comments":73,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36285097","height":14,"chart_height":124},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":387,"peak_comments":149,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42793483","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47899708","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-tyranny-of-structurelessness-1970-d9d023405912.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-tyranny-of-structurelessness-1970-d9d023405912/"},{"slug":"crypto-101-introductory-course-on-cryptography-d9d0234c5559","title":"Crypto 101 – Introductory course on cryptography","domain":"www.crypto101.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography","application_security","protocols_networking"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2016-12","inductedMonth":"2016-12","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":11.299,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":919,"evidenceRank":83,"evidenceScore":84.9,"freshAt":"2025-07-06T21:09:42Z","freshnessRank":191,"freshEventScore":236,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 919 pts / 140 comments (2016) + 514 pts / 67 comments (2018), different submitters and 755 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":352,"peak_comments":86,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7430946","height":17,"chart_height":65},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":36,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9716841","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":919,"peak_comments":140,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13089489","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":514,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18776369","height":24,"chart_height":95},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22865237","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28476219","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36043536","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":236,"peak_comments":15,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44484074","height":11,"chart_height":44},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/crypto-101-introductory-course-on-cryptography-d9d0234c5559.jpg","path":"/hall/link/crypto-101-introductory-course-on-cryptography-d9d0234c5559/"},{"slug":"cross-platform-rust-rewrite-of-the-gnu-coreutils-d9d0234b4d51","title":"Cross-platform Rust rewrite of the GNU coreutils","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-03","inductedMonth":"2021-12","submissions":12,"submitters":10,"spanYears":12.118,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":548,"evidenceRank":84,"evidenceScore":84.8,"freshAt":"2024-01-03T07:56:18Z","freshnessRank":469,"freshEventScore":302,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 548 pts / 487 comments (2016) + 243 pts / 314 comments (2021), different submitters and 2,084 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6821292","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":299,"peak_comments":208,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7882211","height":14,"chart_height":93},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":548,"peak_comments":487,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11337399","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24282623","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":6,"peak_score":243,"peak_comments":314,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29456115","height":12,"chart_height":75},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":302,"peak_comments":305,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38851740","height":14,"chart_height":94},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46575536","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/cross-platform-rust-rewrite-of-the-gnu-coreutils-d9d0234b4d51.jpg","path":"/hall/link/cross-platform-rust-rewrite-of-the-gnu-coreutils-d9d0234b4d51/"},{"slug":"nginx-1-0-0-is-out-d9d02342f3ce","title":"Nginx 1.0.0 is out","domain":"nginx.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["internet_infrastructure","protocols_networking","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2013-04","inductedMonth":"2014-04","submissions":13,"submitters":11,"spanYears":14.031,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":549,"evidenceRank":85,"evidenceScore":84.6,"freshAt":"2018-04-25T13:48:01Z","freshnessRank":1100,"freshEventScore":132,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 549 pts / 75 comments (2011) + 233 pts / 109 comments (2014), different submitters and 1,108 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":549,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2436536","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":4,"peak_score":210,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5601653","height":10,"chart_height":65},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":233,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7640167","height":11,"chart_height":72},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10265766","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":132,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16921452","height":6,"chart_height":41},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26886720","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41247584","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43773576","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/nginx-1-0-0-is-out-d9d02342f3ce.jpg","path":"/hall/link/nginx-1-0-0-is-out-d9d02342f3ce/"},{"slug":"lisping-at-jpl-2002-d9d0233ede6b","title":"Lisping at JPL (2002)","domain":"www.flownet.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["artificial_intelligence","programming_languages","space_astronomy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2014-07","inductedMonth":"2020-01","submissions":22,"submitters":19,"spanYears":16.682,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":307,"evidenceRank":86,"evidenceScore":84.4,"freshAt":"2025-05-22T08:31:36Z","freshnessRank":208,"freshEventScore":169,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 307 pts / 307 comments (2020) + 169 pts / 89 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,950 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 22 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 19 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":82,"peak_comments":72,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=304736","height":4,"chart_height":45},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":97,"peak_comments":36,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2212211","height":5,"chart_height":54},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3773087","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":120,"peak_comments":19,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7989328","height":6,"chart_height":66},{"year":2015,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10183987","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12765393","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":71,"peak_comments":37,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13626074","height":4,"chart_height":39},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":22,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17051503","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":307,"peak_comments":307,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22087419","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":56,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28113434","height":4,"chart_height":31},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33706902","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36888754","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":169,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44059994","height":8,"chart_height":94},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/lisping-at-jpl-2002-d9d0233ede6b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/lisping-at-jpl-2002-d9d0233ede6b/"},{"slug":"2000-lines-of-code-d9d0234071d4","title":"-2000 lines of code","domain":"www.folklore.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["management_strategy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2015-12","inductedMonth":"2021-03","submissions":10,"submitters":9,"spanYears":12.786,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":646,"evidenceRank":87,"evidenceScore":84.4,"freshAt":"2022-11-05T16:48:58Z","freshnessRank":694,"freshEventScore":332,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 646 pts / 256 comments (2021) + 317 pts / 139 comments (2014), different submitters and 2,531 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1069066","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":317,"peak_comments":139,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7516671","height":15,"chart_height":83},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":229,"peak_comments":131,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10734815","height":11,"chart_height":60},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16014298","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17603495","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20527308","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":646,"peak_comments":256,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26387179","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":332,"peak_comments":167,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33483165","height":16,"chart_height":87},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/2000-lines-of-code-d9d0234071d4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/2000-lines-of-code-d9d0234071d4/"},{"slug":"why-should-i-have-written-zeromq-in-c-not-c-2012-d9d0234a48d4","title":"Why should I have written ZeroMQ in C, not C++ (2012)","domain":"250bpm.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2018-07","inductedMonth":"2020-04","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":11.521,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":289,"evidenceRank":88,"evidenceScore":84.4,"freshAt":"2022-08-12T23:57:27Z","freshnessRank":732,"freshEventScore":140,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 289 pts / 251 comments (2018) + 122 pts / 143 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,302 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":108,"peak_comments":119,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6220049","height":5,"chart_height":64},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":122,"peak_comments":143,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9577988","height":6,"chart_height":72},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":289,"peak_comments":251,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18668669","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":223,"peak_comments":163,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22932837","height":11,"chart_height":131},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":140,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32445394","height":7,"chart_height":82},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42563763","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-should-i-have-written-zeromq-in-c-not-c-2012-d9d0234a48d4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-should-i-have-written-zeromq-in-c-not-c-2012-d9d0234a48d4/"},{"slug":"devdocs-d9d02349d6fd","title":"DevDocs","domain":"devdocs.io","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","programming_languages","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2017-10","inductedMonth":"2017-10","submissions":22,"submitters":22,"spanYears":10.541,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1239,"evidenceRank":89,"evidenceScore":84.4,"freshAt":"2024-01-12T18:46:39Z","freshnessRank":460,"freshEventScore":462,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1239 pts / 141 comments (2017) + 462 pts / 112 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,276 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 22 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 22 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":288,"peak_comments":76,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5956958","height":14,"chart_height":40},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10528758","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":6,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11985110","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":1239,"peak_comments":141,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15507871","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20109610","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22368746","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25846676","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30343473","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37288740","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":462,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38972153","height":22,"chart_height":63},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/devdocs-d9d02349d6fd.jpg","path":"/hall/link/devdocs-d9d02349d6fd/"},{"slug":"illegal-prime-d9d023406559","title":"Illegal prime","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["law_regulation","technology_ethics","cryptography"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2013-10","inductedMonth":"2018-04","submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":11.25,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":267,"evidenceRank":90,"evidenceScore":84.3,"freshAt":"2021-04-12T07:56:41Z","freshnessRank":925,"freshEventScore":218,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 267 pts / 192 comments (2018) + 218 pts / 107 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,081 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":152,"peak_comments":76,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1045150","height":7,"chart_height":97},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":178,"peak_comments":58,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6568660","height":9,"chart_height":113},{"year":2014,"count":4,"peak_score":59,"peak_comments":30,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8107782","height":4,"chart_height":38},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9977537","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":39,"peak_comments":26,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13015778","height":4,"chart_height":25},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":267,"peak_comments":192,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16938908","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20924700","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25163355","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":218,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26776949","height":10,"chart_height":139},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/illegal-prime-d9d023406559.jpg","path":"/hall/link/illegal-prime-d9d023406559/"},{"slug":"cockpit-web-based-graphical-interface-for-servers-d9d0234bf7e2","title":"Cockpit: Web-based graphical interface for servers","domain":"cockpit-project.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2021-02","inductedMonth":"2021-02","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":11.699,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":470,"evidenceRank":91,"evidenceScore":84.2,"freshAt":"2023-10-16T02:48:21Z","freshnessRank":518,"freshEventScore":470,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 470 pts / 192 comments (2023) + 377 pts / 148 comments (2018), different submitters and 2,060 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7216906","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12423648","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14417256","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":377,"peak_comments":148,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16445612","height":18,"chart_height":136},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22604560","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":347,"peak_comments":126,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26197510","height":17,"chart_height":126},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":325,"peak_comments":80,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31439811","height":16,"chart_height":118},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":470,"peak_comments":192,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37895446","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45695753","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/cockpit-web-based-graphical-interface-for-servers-d9d0234bf7e2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/cockpit-web-based-graphical-interface-for-servers-d9d0234bf7e2/"},{"slug":"falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-time-d9d023466569","title":"Falsehoods programmers believe about time","domain":"infiniteundo.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["testing_quality"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2016-10","inductedMonth":"2019-01","submissions":14,"submitters":13,"spanYears":13.689,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":364,"evidenceRank":92,"evidenceScore":84.2,"freshAt":"2022-08-22T06:39:36Z","freshnessRank":725,"freshEventScore":178,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 364 pts / 213 comments (2012) + 178 pts / 204 comments (2022), different submitters and 3,716 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":364,"peak_comments":213,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4128208","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10198796","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":183,"peak_comments":154,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12675527","height":9,"chart_height":85},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16615594","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18952391","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":19,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24453712","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":178,"peak_comments":204,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32548085","height":9,"chart_height":83},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39551483","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43283223","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47157087","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-time-d9d023466569.jpg","path":"/hall/link/falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-time-d9d023466569/"},{"slug":"teach-yourself-computer-science-d9d02356678d","title":"Teach Yourself Computer Science","domain":"teachyourselfcs.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["learning_methods","academic_life","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-04","inductedMonth":"2020-06","submissions":15,"submitters":11,"spanYears":8.827,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":1308,"evidenceRank":93,"evidenceScore":84.1,"freshAt":"2021-11-26T20:43:49Z","freshnessRank":854,"freshEventScore":302,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1308 pts / 237 comments (2017) + 1169 pts / 265 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,195 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1308,"peak_comments":237,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13862284","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":4,"peak_score":334,"peak_comments":81,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17581589","height":16,"chart_height":43},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":7,"peak_score":1169,"peak_comments":265,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23588896","height":24,"chart_height":152},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":302,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29353904","height":14,"chart_height":39},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41302673","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46552036","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/teach-yourself-computer-science-d9d02356678d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/teach-yourself-computer-science-d9d02356678d/"},{"slug":"every-noise-at-once-d9d0235059eb","title":"Every Noise at Once","domain":"everynoise.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["music","internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2021-04","inductedMonth":"2024-01","submissions":22,"submitters":22,"spanYears":11.118,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":344,"evidenceRank":94,"evidenceScore":84.1,"freshAt":"2024-01-23T23:59:21Z","freshnessRank":452,"freshEventScore":127,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 344 pts / 94 comments (2021) + 127 pts / 63 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,026 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 22 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 22 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9638613","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15680241","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":333,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20585447","height":16,"chart_height":165},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":344,"peak_comments":94,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26668426","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32413765","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38519343","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":5,"peak_score":127,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39111730","height":6,"chart_height":63},{"year":2025,"count":6,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45333379","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48905547","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/every-noise-at-once-d9d0235059eb/"},{"slug":"shapecatcher-draw-the-unicode-character-you-want-d9d02344827c","title":"Shapecatcher: Draw the Unicode character you want","domain":"shapecatcher.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["language_linguistics","human_computer_interaction"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2014-10","inductedMonth":"2017-05","submissions":17,"submitters":16,"spanYears":13.188,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":271,"evidenceRank":95,"evidenceScore":84.1,"freshAt":"2025-01-18T15:15:03Z","freshnessRank":263,"freshEventScore":28,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 271 pts / 107 comments (2013) + 155 pts / 37 comments (2023), different submitters and 3,633 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":210,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3222964","height":10,"chart_height":132},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4947188","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":271,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5150107","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":87,"peak_comments":38,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8403103","height":4,"chart_height":55},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9854367","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11829191","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":115,"peak_comments":28,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14284750","height":6,"chart_height":72},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17821910","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19141441","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24052347","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27868174","height":5,"chart_height":63},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":155,"peak_comments":37,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34374083","height":7,"chart_height":97},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":28,"peak_comments":12,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42748949","height":4,"chart_height":18},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/shapecatcher-draw-the-unicode-character-you-want-d9d02344827c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/shapecatcher-draw-the-unicode-character-you-want-d9d02344827c/"},{"slug":"beej-s-guide-to-network-programming-d9d0233ef5b1","title":"Beej's Guide to Network Programming","domain":"beej.us","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2021-02","inductedMonth":"2021-02","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":17.229,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":993,"evidenceRank":96,"evidenceScore":84.0,"freshAt":"2023-10-11T10:43:00Z","freshnessRank":526,"freshEventScore":277,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 993 pts / 165 comments (2021) + 518 pts / 88 comments (2023), different submitters and 829 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":22,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=337371","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1593037","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":65,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9623813","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":333,"peak_comments":44,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13983212","height":16,"chart_height":57},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23696009","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":993,"peak_comments":165,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26100075","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33359535","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":518,"peak_comments":88,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36025611","height":24,"chart_height":89},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43300500","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46578472","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/beej-s-guide-to-network-programming-d9d0233ef5b1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/beej-s-guide-to-network-programming-d9d0233ef5b1/"},{"slug":"what-color-is-your-function-2015-d9d0234f2d96","title":"What Color is Your Function? (2015)","domain":"journal.stuffwithstuff.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","compilers_runtimes"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2021-09","inductedMonth":"2026-05","submissions":25,"submitters":22,"spanYears":11.31,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":138,"evidenceRank":97,"evidenceScore":84.0,"freshAt":"2026-05-26T15:58:32Z","freshnessRank":14,"freshEventScore":138,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 138 pts / 189 comments (2026) + 129 pts / 57 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,703 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 25 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 22 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":24,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8982494","height":4,"chart_height":30},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12029790","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13494291","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":109,"peak_comments":45,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16732948","height":5,"chart_height":134},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21886980","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":5,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22963645","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":129,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28657358","height":6,"chart_height":159},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":4,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37647611","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":53,"peak_comments":92,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41898204","height":4,"chart_height":65},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":3,"peak_score":138,"peak_comments":189,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48281515","height":7,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-color-is-your-function-2015-d9d0234f2d96.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-color-is-your-function-2015-d9d0234f2d96/"},{"slug":"list-of-falsehoods-programmers-believe-in-d9d023549e00","title":"List of falsehoods programmers believe in","domain":"github.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","testing_quality"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-09","inductedMonth":"2020-09","submissions":15,"submitters":14,"spanYears":8.912,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":255,"evidenceRank":98,"evidenceScore":84.0,"freshAt":"2023-08-03T16:09:20Z","freshnessRank":579,"freshEventScore":84,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 173 pts / 123 comments (2020) + 255 pts / 118 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,302 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13271541","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":255,"peak_comments":118,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13637102","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17830658","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":173,"peak_comments":123,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24405941","height":8,"chart_height":115},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":119,"peak_comments":117,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30710908","height":6,"chart_height":79},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":84,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36987808","height":4,"chart_height":56},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44829424","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/list-of-falsehoods-programmers-believe-in-d9d023549e00.jpg","path":"/hall/link/list-of-falsehoods-programmers-believe-in-d9d023549e00/"},{"slug":"gobolinux-d9d02341a6c9","title":"GoboLinux","domain":"www.gobolinux.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2021-02","inductedMonth":"2021-02","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":15.524,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":329,"evidenceRank":99,"evidenceScore":83.9,"freshAt":"2024-02-28T01:15:56Z","freshnessRank":437,"freshEventScore":283,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 329 pts / 216 comments (2021) + 283 pts / 212 comments (2024), different submitters and 791 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":45,"peak_comments":22,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1735532","height":4,"chart_height":23},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":42,"peak_comments":23,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7722690","height":4,"chart_height":22},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":133,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14925743","height":6,"chart_height":69},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17083905","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25211681","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":329,"peak_comments":216,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29714825","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":283,"peak_comments":212,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39532650","height":14,"chart_height":146},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46184879","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47674770","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/gobolinux-d9d02341a6c9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/gobolinux-d9d02341a6c9/"},{"slug":"pi-hole-a-black-hole-for-internet-advertisements-d9d02354074d","title":"Pi-hole – A black hole for Internet advertisements","domain":"pi-hole.net","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["internet_infrastructure","privacy_surveillance","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-02","inductedMonth":"2019-05","submissions":17,"submitters":17,"spanYears":7.255,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":551,"evidenceRank":100,"evidenceScore":83.8,"freshAt":"2023-01-13T22:22:31Z","freshnessRank":670,"freshEventScore":438,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 551 pts / 309 comments (2017) + 438 pts / 276 comments (2023), different submitters and 2,132 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":6,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13030144","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":551,"peak_comments":309,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13857887","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":492,"peak_comments":249,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19258717","height":24,"chart_height":152},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24658165","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":27,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28526234","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":438,"peak_comments":276,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34374725","height":21,"chart_height":135},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/pi-hole-a-black-hole-for-internet-advertisements-d9d02354074d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/pi-hole-a-black-hole-for-internet-advertisements-d9d02354074d/"},{"slug":"raft-visualization-d9d0234b9f1c","title":"Raft Visualization","domain":"thesecretlivesofdata.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["distributed_systems","algorithms_data_structures","human_computer_interaction"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2020-12","inductedMonth":"2022-08","submissions":29,"submitters":29,"spanYears":10.721,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":411,"evidenceRank":101,"evidenceScore":83.8,"freshAt":"2024-09-27T12:54:55Z","freshnessRank":325,"freshEventScore":235,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 411 pts / 67 comments (2022) + 235 pts / 87 comments (2024), different submitters and 772 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 29 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 29 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":3,"peak_score":161,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8271957","height":8,"chart_height":67},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10330590","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11477455","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":5,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15272757","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17337851","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21869813","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":9,"peak_score":238,"peak_comments":35,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25326645","height":11,"chart_height":98},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":411,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32484584","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38270565","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":235,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41669850","height":11,"chart_height":97},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/raft-visualization-d9d0234b9f1c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/raft-visualization-d9d0234b9f1c/"},{"slug":"north-american-regional-dialects-and-accents-2016-d9d023423324","title":"North American Regional Dialects and Accents (2016)","domain":"aschmann.net","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["language_linguistics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2017-09","inductedMonth":"2017-09","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":15.296,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":261,"evidenceRank":102,"evidenceScore":83.7,"freshAt":"2026-04-16T03:38:45Z","freshnessRank":27,"freshEventScore":164,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 261 pts / 217 comments (2023) + 222 pts / 203 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,152 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":3,"peak_score":51,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2048000","height":4,"chart_height":33},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2060162","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":174,"peak_comments":126,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5664786","height":8,"chart_height":113},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":222,"peak_comments":203,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15225032","height":11,"chart_height":145},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20882436","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":261,"peak_comments":217,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37004720","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":164,"peak_comments":94,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47788398","height":8,"chart_height":107}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/north-american-regional-dialects-and-accents-2016-d9d023423324.jpg","path":"/hall/link/north-american-regional-dialects-and-accents-2016-d9d023423324/"},{"slug":"rich-hickey-simple-made-easy-from-strange-loop-2011-video-d9d0234456cf","title":"Rich Hickey: \"Simple Made Easy\" from Strange Loop 2011 [video]","domain":"www.infoq.com","category":"media","categoryDisplay":"Audio, video & images","type":"video","typeDisplay":"Video","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2017-02","inductedMonth":"2017-02","submissions":19,"submitters":19,"spanYears":14.289,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":356,"evidenceRank":103,"evidenceScore":83.6,"freshAt":"2020-07-21T07:40:53Z","freshnessRank":998,"freshEventScore":133,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 356 pts / 99 comments (2011) + 168 pts / 36 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,946 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 19 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 19 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":356,"peak_comments":99,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3135185","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":176,"peak_comments":42,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4173854","height":8,"chart_height":84},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8151375","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10537441","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":168,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13660797","height":8,"chart_height":80},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17133770","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21036021","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":133,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23905051","height":6,"chart_height":64},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34036920","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46432860","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46854266","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/rich-hickey-simple-made-easy-from-strange-loop-2011-video-d9d0234456cf.jpg","path":"/hall/link/rich-hickey-simple-made-easy-from-strange-loop-2011-video-d9d0234456cf/"},{"slug":"analysis-of-bank-pin-numbers-d9d023472a92","title":"Analysis of bank PIN numbers","domain":"www.datagenetics.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security","data_science","abuse_fraud"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2018-08","inductedMonth":"2018-08","submissions":21,"submitters":21,"spanYears":13.18,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":255,"evidenceRank":104,"evidenceScore":83.4,"freshAt":"2024-05-14T20:22:42Z","freshnessRank":396,"freshEventScore":127,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 255 pts / 111 comments (2012) + 127 pts / 88 comments (2024), different submitters and 4,256 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 21 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 21 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":4,"peak_score":255,"peak_comments":111,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4535417","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":134,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5124024","height":6,"chart_height":89},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8451705","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9757478","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":8,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11248803","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14033132","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":112,"peak_comments":72,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17670173","height":5,"chart_height":75},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":127,"peak_comments":88,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40359736","height":6,"chart_height":85},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46011944","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/analysis-of-bank-pin-numbers-d9d023472a92.jpg","path":"/hall/link/analysis-of-bank-pin-numbers-d9d023472a92/"},{"slug":"you-weren-t-meant-to-have-a-boss-2008-d9d0233e6f5d","title":"You Weren't Meant to Have a Boss (2008)","domain":"www.paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["workplace","startups_entrepreneurship"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2011-07","inductedMonth":"2015-06","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":14.842,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":322,"evidenceRank":105,"evidenceScore":83.4,"freshAt":"2020-10-10T09:33:41Z","freshnessRank":986,"freshEventScore":202,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 239 pts / 298 comments (2008) + 202 pts / 165 comments (2020), different submitters and 4,586 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":2,"peak_score":239,"peak_comments":298,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=141898","height":11,"chart_height":126},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":228,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2760732","height":11,"chart_height":120},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":93,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9751767","height":4,"chart_height":49},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":322,"peak_comments":164,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18881383","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":202,"peak_comments":165,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24737737","height":10,"chart_height":107},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34481455","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/you-weren-t-meant-to-have-a-boss-2008-d9d0233e6f5d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/you-weren-t-meant-to-have-a-boss-2008-d9d0233e6f5d/"},{"slug":"the-illustrated-guide-to-a-ph-d-d9d02341658a","title":"The illustrated guide to a Ph.D.","domain":"matt.might.net","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["academic_life","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2013-03","inductedMonth":"2013-03","submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":14.626,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":319,"evidenceRank":106,"evidenceScore":83.3,"freshAt":"2021-11-07T11:38:49Z","freshnessRank":857,"freshEventScore":158,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 158 pts / 121 comments (2021) + 319 pts / 42 comments (2010), different submitters and 4,107 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":319,"peak_comments":42,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1588727","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2922233","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3785705","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":116,"peak_comments":49,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5385881","height":6,"chart_height":62},{"year":2014,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7512171","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11366553","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":66,"peak_comments":46,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13381843","height":4,"chart_height":35},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":40,"peak_comments":13,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24003734","height":4,"chart_height":21},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":158,"peak_comments":121,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29138570","height":8,"chart_height":84},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37123117","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43469898","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-illustrated-guide-to-a-ph-d-d9d02341658a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-illustrated-guide-to-a-ph-d-d9d02341658a/"},{"slug":"cities-and-ambition-d9d0233e97f0","title":"Cities and Ambition","domain":"www.paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["cities_infrastructure"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2014-01","inductedMonth":"2014-01","submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":14.464,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":185,"evidenceRank":107,"evidenceScore":83.3,"freshAt":"2018-02-26T16:55:59Z","freshnessRank":1108,"freshEventScore":93,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 156 pts / 306 comments (2008) + 185 pts / 124 comments (2014), different submitters and 2,062 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":2,"peak_score":156,"peak_comments":306,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=201373","height":7,"chart_height":143},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2398200","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":185,"peak_comments":124,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7083151","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11130260","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15126663","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":93,"peak_comments":58,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16466768","height":4,"chart_height":85},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20069531","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25312848","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29164718","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33582128","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/cities-and-ambition-d9d0233e97f0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/cities-and-ambition-d9d0233e97f0/"},{"slug":"caddy-the-ultimate-server-with-automatic-https-d9d023500608","title":"Caddy – The Ultimate Server with Automatic HTTPS","domain":"caddyserver.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","internet_infrastructure","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-04","inductedMonth":"2021-11","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":9.807,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":568,"evidenceRank":108,"evidenceScore":83.2,"freshAt":"2025-02-16T17:56:15Z","freshnessRank":248,"freshEventScore":568,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 568 pts / 227 comments (2025) + 308 pts / 79 comments (2016), different submitters and 3,045 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":208,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9452606","height":10,"chart_height":62},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":308,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12719563","height":15,"chart_height":92},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":84,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16918797","height":4,"chart_height":25},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22969834","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":149,"peak_comments":129,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29378030","height":7,"chart_height":45},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":13,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38604172","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":568,"peak_comments":227,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43070025","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/caddy-the-ultimate-server-with-automatic-https-d9d023500608.jpg","path":"/hall/link/caddy-the-ultimate-server-with-automatic-https-d9d023500608/"},{"slug":"a-spellchecker-used-to-be-a-major-feat-of-software-engineering-d9d0233e9fbf","title":"A Spellchecker Used To Be A Major Feat of Software Engineering","domain":"prog21.dadgum.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["performance_reliability","databases_storage"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2020-12","inductedMonth":"2020-12","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":17.169,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":363,"evidenceRank":109,"evidenceScore":83.1,"freshAt":"2025-08-09T01:07:48Z","freshnessRank":172,"freshEventScore":190,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 190 pts / 199 comments (2025) + 363 pts / 143 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,709 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":47,"peak_comments":22,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=212221","height":4,"chart_height":22},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1702445","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2928102","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":156,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3466388","height":7,"chart_height":73},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5298411","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":48,"peak_comments":29,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10789019","height":4,"chart_height":22},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":363,"peak_comments":143,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25296900","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":314,"peak_comments":180,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34971924","height":15,"chart_height":147},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":190,"peak_comments":199,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44843223","height":9,"chart_height":89},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-spellchecker-used-to-be-a-major-feat-of-software-engineering-d9d0233e9fbf.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-spellchecker-used-to-be-a-major-feat-of-software-engineering-d9d0233e9fbf/"},{"slug":"imba-a-new-programming-language-for-the-web-d9d0235117e2","title":"Imba – A new programming language for the web","domain":"imba.io","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-07","inductedMonth":"2019-07","submissions":16,"submitters":15,"spanYears":10.075,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":319,"evidenceRank":110,"evidenceScore":83.0,"freshAt":"2023-09-23T11:14:52Z","freshnessRank":539,"freshEventScore":141,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 319 pts / 171 comments (2015) + 141 pts / 94 comments (2023), different submitters and 2,955 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":319,"peak_comments":171,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10091454","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":206,"peak_comments":128,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10901054","height":10,"chart_height":110},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":4,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18248482","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":138,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20487972","height":7,"chart_height":74},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28923550","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33763672","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":141,"peak_comments":94,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37622184","height":7,"chart_height":75},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45257960","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/imba-a-new-programming-language-for-the-web-d9d0235117e2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/imba-a-new-programming-language-for-the-web-d9d0235117e2/"},{"slug":"game-programming-patterns-2014-d9d023401042","title":"Game Programming Patterns (2014)","domain":"gameprogrammingpatterns.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_development","software_architecture","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2017-06","inductedMonth":"2020-05","submissions":14,"submitters":14,"spanYears":14.363,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":635,"evidenceRank":111,"evidenceScore":83.0,"freshAt":"2024-02-21T07:23:55Z","freshnessRank":443,"freshEventScore":118,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 635 pts / 86 comments (2020) + 271 pts / 47 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,078 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":38,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=874080","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4978597","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":265,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6004885","height":13,"chart_height":71},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":53,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8555248","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10030574","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12316652","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":271,"peak_comments":47,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14475489","height":13,"chart_height":73},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":37,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18774227","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":635,"peak_comments":86,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23203699","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":142,"peak_comments":20,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32837121","height":7,"chart_height":38},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":118,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39451016","height":6,"chart_height":32},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/game-programming-patterns-2014-d9d023401042.jpg","path":"/hall/link/game-programming-patterns-2014-d9d023401042/"},{"slug":"null-references-the-billion-dollar-mistake-d9d0233fe45d","title":"Null References: The Billion Dollar Mistake","domain":"www.infoq.com","category":"media","categoryDisplay":"Audio, video & images","type":"video","typeDisplay":"Video","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2020-01","inductedMonth":"2020-01","submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":13.511,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":93,"evidenceRank":112,"evidenceScore":83.0,"freshAt":"2023-02-28T18:03:43Z","freshnessRank":651,"freshEventScore":53,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 93 pts / 150 comments (2020) + 53 pts / 125 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,144 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=785254","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2349027","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4171360","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6352998","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8209081","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9446489","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":48,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11798518","height":4,"chart_height":88},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16145195","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21189397","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":93,"peak_comments":150,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22019627","height":4,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28404604","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":19,"peak_comments":13,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30719472","height":4,"chart_height":35},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":53,"peak_comments":125,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34972584","height":4,"chart_height":97},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/null-references-the-billion-dollar-mistake-d9d0233fe45d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/null-references-the-billion-dollar-mistake-d9d0233fe45d/"},{"slug":"fish-a-user-friendly-command-line-shell-for-macos-linux-etc-d9d0234a4aae","title":"Fish: A user-friendly command line shell for macOS, Linux, etc","domain":"fishshell.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-08","inductedMonth":"2019-10","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":12.424,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":467,"evidenceRank":113,"evidenceScore":82.9,"freshAt":"2026-01-18T01:07:13Z","freshnessRank":76,"freshEventScore":21,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 467 pts / 204 comments (2017) + 451 pts / 182 comments (2015), different submitters and 939 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":122,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6224524","height":6,"chart_height":44},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":451,"peak_comments":182,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9566441","height":22,"chart_height":164},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12350481","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":467,"peak_comments":204,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15910897","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":149,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21361696","height":7,"chart_height":54},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":233,"peak_comments":118,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27180420","height":11,"chart_height":85},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45452333","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":21,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46663819","height":4,"chart_height":8}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/fish-a-user-friendly-command-line-shell-for-macos-linux-etc-d9d0234a4aae.jpg","path":"/hall/link/fish-a-user-friendly-command-line-shell-for-macos-linux-etc-d9d0234a4aae/"},{"slug":"i-could-do-that-in-a-weekend-2016-d9d02354d8d1","title":"I could do that in a weekend (2016)","domain":"danluu.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["startups_entrepreneurship","management_strategy","labor_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-04","inductedMonth":"2020-04","submissions":14,"submitters":11,"spanYears":9.793,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":712,"evidenceRank":114,"evidenceScore":82.9,"freshAt":"2023-09-27T10:08:43Z","freshnessRank":536,"freshEventScore":98,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 712 pts / 423 comments (2016) + 338 pts / 195 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,304 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":712,"peak_comments":423,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12626314","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":4,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18026032","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21140096","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":338,"peak_comments":195,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23019816","height":16,"chart_height":81},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":121,"peak_comments":84,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28289322","height":6,"chart_height":29},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":4,"peak_score":98,"peak_comments":141,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37672604","height":5,"chart_height":23},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48982321","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/i-could-do-that-in-a-weekend-2016-d9d02354d8d1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/i-could-do-that-in-a-weekend-2016-d9d02354d8d1/"},{"slug":"vim-tutorial-as-an-adventure-game-d9d02345e524","title":"Vim Tutorial as an Adventure Game","domain":"vim-adventures.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"computer_game","typeDisplay":"Computer games","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["learning_methods","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2015-01","inductedMonth":"2015-03","submissions":18,"submitters":17,"spanYears":14.073,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":497,"evidenceRank":115,"evidenceScore":82.8,"freshAt":"2022-09-23T11:50:52Z","freshnessRank":715,"freshEventScore":78,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 497 pts / 125 comments (2012) + 285 pts / 59 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,892 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 18 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":497,"peak_comments":125,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3877880","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":140,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5689971","height":7,"chart_height":48},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7251940","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":200,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9250190","height":10,"chart_height":68},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13063389","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":285,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14656591","height":14,"chart_height":97},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":26,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24319611","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":4,"peak_score":78,"peak_comments":15,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32950623","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38750572","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40561953","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44675466","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48206392","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/vim-tutorial-as-an-adventure-game-d9d02345e524.jpg","path":"/hall/link/vim-tutorial-as-an-adventure-game-d9d02345e524/"},{"slug":"how-to-disagree-d9d0233e7495","title":"How to Disagree","domain":"www.paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["online_communities","social_issues"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2010-12","inductedMonth":"2012-11","submissions":15,"submitters":15,"spanYears":14.426,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":183,"evidenceRank":116,"evidenceScore":82.7,"freshAt":"2018-02-24T19:02:49Z","freshnessRank":1109,"freshEventScore":31,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 183 pts / 224 comments (2008) + 109 pts / 58 comments (2011), different submitters and 1,037 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":183,"peak_comments":224,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=149052","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":151,"peak_comments":231,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1021060","height":7,"chart_height":140},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1963100","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":109,"peak_comments":58,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2157703","height":5,"chart_height":101},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4736606","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5659481","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10833609","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15052402","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":31,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16454704","height":4,"chart_height":29},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24319304","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32670356","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-to-disagree-d9d0233e7495.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-to-disagree-d9d0233e7495/"},{"slug":"advanced-programming-languages-2009-d9d023404c69","title":"Advanced programming languages (2009)","domain":"matt.might.net","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2012-01","inductedMonth":"2016-06","submissions":12,"submitters":10,"spanYears":10.393,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":219,"evidenceRank":117,"evidenceScore":82.7,"freshAt":"2020-05-05T09:04:36Z","freshnessRank":1011,"freshEventScore":151,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 219 pts / 202 comments (2016) + 151 pts / 133 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,415 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":52,"peak_comments":44,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=992218","height":4,"chart_height":40},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":131,"peak_comments":81,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1374635","height":6,"chart_height":102},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":100,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2435129","height":5,"chart_height":78},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":125,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3444732","height":6,"chart_height":97},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5084152","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":91,"peak_comments":39,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8749782","height":4,"chart_height":71},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":219,"peak_comments":202,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11932675","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19232505","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":151,"peak_comments":133,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23077992","height":7,"chart_height":117},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/advanced-programming-languages-2009-d9d023404c69.jpg","path":"/hall/link/advanced-programming-languages-2009-d9d023404c69/"},{"slug":"a-single-div-d9d0234dc4b0","title":"A Single Div","domain":"a.singlediv.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design","art","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2020-06","inductedMonth":"2024-05","submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":9.684,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":649,"evidenceRank":118,"evidenceScore":82.6,"freshAt":"2024-05-02T23:17:40Z","freshnessRank":408,"freshEventScore":433,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 649 pts / 140 comments (2014) + 433 pts / 69 comments (2024), different submitters and 3,537 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":649,"peak_comments":140,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8229072","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":4,"peak_score":535,"peak_comments":106,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12091173","height":24,"chart_height":140},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23517408","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26898130","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32907755","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37918463","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":4,"peak_score":433,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40242410","height":21,"chart_height":113},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-single-div-d9d0234dc4b0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-single-div-d9d0234dc4b0/"},{"slug":"100k-stars-d9d0234e1c4d","title":"100k Stars","domain":"stars.chromeexperiments.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"space_transportation","topicDisplay":"Space & transportation","tags":["space_astronomy","computer_graphics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2022-03","inductedMonth":"2024-05","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":11.307,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":471,"evidenceRank":119,"evidenceScore":82.6,"freshAt":"2024-05-10T07:45:31Z","freshnessRank":400,"freshEventScore":389,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 471 pts / 172 comments (2020) + 389 pts / 101 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,311 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8405527","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10787837","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11027173","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15456393","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19529805","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":471,"peak_comments":172,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24702874","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":333,"peak_comments":81,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30850625","height":16,"chart_height":120},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":389,"peak_comments":101,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40316345","height":19,"chart_height":140},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46732015","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/100k-stars-d9d0234e1c4d/"},{"slug":"history-of-the-browser-user-agent-string-2008-d9d0233edaa9","title":"History of the browser user-agent string (2008)","domain":"webaim.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["browsers_web_standards"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2013-11","inductedMonth":"2018-03","submissions":37,"submitters":34,"spanYears":17.385,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":558,"evidenceRank":120,"evidenceScore":82.6,"freshAt":"2026-01-27T19:03:45Z","freshnessRank":72,"freshEventScore":20,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 558 pts / 168 comments (2018) + 195 pts / 46 comments (2012), different submitters and 2,059 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 37 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 34 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":36,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=298844","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=521138","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2224026","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":3,"peak_score":195,"peak_comments":46,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4246912","height":9,"chart_height":59},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":100,"peak_comments":32,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6674812","height":5,"chart_height":30},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8647883","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9915332","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":38,"peak_comments":12,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11693455","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2017,"count":5,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14521917","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":558,"peak_comments":168,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16525559","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":62,"peak_comments":23,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21085388","height":4,"chart_height":19},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29538760","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":87,"peak_comments":20,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31246438","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38068735","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41808856","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44354063","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":20,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46784676","height":4,"chart_height":6}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/history-of-the-browser-user-agent-string-2008-d9d0233edaa9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/history-of-the-browser-user-agent-string-2008-d9d0233edaa9/"},{"slug":"jevons-paradox-d9d0234090d1","title":"Jevons paradox","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["economics","energy","climate_environment"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2023-11","inductedMonth":"2025-01","submissions":35,"submitters":31,"spanYears":16.312,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":196,"evidenceRank":121,"evidenceScore":82.6,"freshAt":"2025-01-29T11:34:46Z","freshnessRank":255,"freshEventScore":196,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 196 pts / 159 comments (2025) + 113 pts / 90 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,113 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 35 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 31 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1128381","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5115216","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9335160","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15507289","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":95,"peak_comments":44,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16451575","height":5,"chart_height":82},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21555220","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":6,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25473004","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":7,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28779356","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":113,"peak_comments":90,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29899297","height":5,"chart_height":98},{"year":2023,"count":4,"peak_score":98,"peak_comments":81,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38130060","height":5,"chart_height":85},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41932069","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":4,"peak_score":196,"peak_comments":159,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42863808","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48441462","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/jevons-paradox-d9d0234090d1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/jevons-paradox-d9d0234090d1/"},{"slug":"who-can-name-the-bigger-number-d9d0233e267a","title":"Who Can Name the Bigger Number?","domain":"www.scottaaronson.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2007,"candidateMonth":"2015-02","inductedMonth":"2015-02","submissions":28,"submitters":28,"spanYears":17.886,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":223,"evidenceRank":122,"evidenceScore":82.6,"freshAt":"2020-01-21T23:21:39Z","freshnessRank":1024,"freshEventScore":100,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 223 pts / 145 comments (2015) + 132 pts / 68 comments (2010), different submitters and 1,669 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 28 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 28 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47408","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":3,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=951095","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":132,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1539538","height":6,"chart_height":101},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2531994","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":4,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5656231","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7384951","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":223,"peak_comments":145,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9058986","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11596059","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15545667","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18508471","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20493920","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":100,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22112854","height":5,"chart_height":76},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30634982","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38694820","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44595559","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/who-can-name-the-bigger-number-d9d0233e267a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/who-can-name-the-bigger-number-d9d0233e267a/"},{"slug":"syncthing-a-continuous-file-synchronization-program-d9d0234c655a","title":"Syncthing – a continuous file synchronization program","domain":"syncthing.net","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","internet_infrastructure","cryptography","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2021-10","inductedMonth":"2021-10","submissions":14,"submitters":13,"spanYears":10.401,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":623,"evidenceRank":123,"evidenceScore":82.5,"freshAt":"2024-08-18T09:12:42Z","freshnessRank":346,"freshEventScore":61,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 545 pts / 230 comments (2021) + 623 pts / 184 comments (2014), different submitters and 2,711 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":3,"peak_score":623,"peak_comments":184,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7734114","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9600796","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13214250","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16421724","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":68,"peak_comments":41,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20466469","height":4,"chart_height":19},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23835235","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":545,"peak_comments":230,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28859521","height":24,"chart_height":149},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":313,"peak_comments":124,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35879039","height":15,"chart_height":85},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":61,"peak_comments":23,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41281152","height":4,"chart_height":17},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/syncthing-a-continuous-file-synchronization-program-d9d0234c655a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/syncthing-a-continuous-file-synchronization-program-d9d0234c655a/"},{"slug":"why-oh-why-do-those-nutheads-use-vi-d9d0233e7610","title":"Why, oh why, do those nutheads use vi?","domain":"www.viemu.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2012-02","inductedMonth":"2017-04","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":13.684,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":232,"evidenceRank":124,"evidenceScore":82.5,"freshAt":"2021-12-07T05:30:47Z","freshnessRank":850,"freshEventScore":62,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 232 pts / 220 comments (2012) + 86 pts / 126 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,164 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":56,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=151637","height":4,"chart_height":41},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1582609","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":232,"peak_comments":220,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3542507","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":86,"peak_comments":126,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9362786","height":4,"chart_height":63},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14153147","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":38,"peak_comments":23,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18582221","height":4,"chart_height":28},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":62,"peak_comments":123,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29469345","height":4,"chart_height":45},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-oh-why-do-those-nutheads-use-vi-d9d0233e7610.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-oh-why-do-those-nutheads-use-vi-d9d0233e7610/"},{"slug":"the-secretary-problem-d9d0233e901d","title":"The Secretary Problem","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2017-10","inductedMonth":"2022-08","submissions":24,"submitters":21,"spanYears":15.912,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":202,"evidenceRank":125,"evidenceScore":82.4,"freshAt":"2024-04-12T19:01:08Z","freshnessRank":420,"freshEventScore":31,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 202 pts / 120 comments (2022) + 145 pts / 62 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,756 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 24 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 21 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=189509","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=495074","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2832130","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5754707","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":90,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7337759","height":4,"chart_height":76},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12296188","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":145,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15567307","height":7,"chart_height":122},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21733387","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24071263","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28887714","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":202,"peak_comments":120,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32508998","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":31,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40016456","height":4,"chart_height":26},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-secretary-problem-d9d0233e901d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-secretary-problem-d9d0233e901d/"},{"slug":"log-file-viewer-for-the-terminal-d9d0234a6b52","title":"Log File Viewer for the Terminal","domain":"lnav.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","databases_storage","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2023-01","inductedMonth":"2026-03","submissions":20,"submitters":16,"spanYears":12.564,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":335,"evidenceRank":126,"evidenceScore":82.4,"freshAt":"2026-03-24T05:32:53Z","freshnessRank":39,"freshEventScore":335,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 335 pts / 56 comments (2026) + 179 pts / 58 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,174 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6301515","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8573133","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":120,"peak_comments":27,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9294622","height":6,"chart_height":61},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13155469","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15320216","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17735371","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27815784","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":6,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30011269","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":179,"peak_comments":58,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34243520","height":9,"chart_height":91},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":156,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40703892","height":7,"chart_height":79},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":335,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47498924","height":16,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/log-file-viewer-for-the-terminal-d9d0234a6b52.jpg","path":"/hall/link/log-file-viewer-for-the-terminal-d9d0234a6b52/"},{"slug":"superintelligence-the-idea-that-eats-smart-people-d9d02355a06e","title":"Superintelligence: The Idea That Eats Smart People","domain":"idlewords.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["artificial_intelligence","technology_ethics","philosophy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-05","inductedMonth":"2023-05","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":9.44,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":883,"evidenceRank":127,"evidenceScore":82.3,"freshAt":"2026-06-01T17:43:07Z","freshnessRank":11,"freshEventScore":161,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 883 pts / 580 comments (2016) + 214 pts / 363 comments (2023), different submitters and 2,346 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":883,"peak_comments":580,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13240811","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":303,"peak_comments":248,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18499973","height":15,"chart_height":58},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23334252","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":41,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26217372","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":214,"peak_comments":363,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36098332","height":10,"chart_height":41},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":161,"peak_comments":243,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48360137","height":8,"chart_height":31}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/superintelligence-the-idea-that-eats-smart-people-d9d02355a06e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/superintelligence-the-idea-that-eats-smart-people-d9d02355a06e/"},{"slug":"a-guide-to-undefined-behavior-in-c-and-c-d9d0234140be","title":"A Guide to Undefined Behavior in C and C++","domain":"blog.regehr.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2023-08","inductedMonth":"2023-08","submissions":15,"submitters":15,"spanYears":14.678,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":111,"evidenceRank":128,"evidenceScore":82.3,"freshAt":"2025-03-13T12:16:33Z","freshnessRank":241,"freshEventScore":79,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 111 pts / 185 comments (2023) + 74 pts / 103 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,747 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1615050","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":37,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2544159","height":4,"chart_height":57},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6241555","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":41,"peak_comments":10,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9884074","height":4,"chart_height":63},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15888270","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":74,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18372613","height":4,"chart_height":113},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27703261","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":111,"peak_comments":185,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37165042","height":5,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":79,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43352503","height":4,"chart_height":121},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-guide-to-undefined-behavior-in-c-and-c-d9d0234140be.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-guide-to-undefined-behavior-in-c-and-c-d9d0234140be/"},{"slug":"new-racket-language-website-d9d023411aca","title":"New Racket Language Website","domain":"racket-lang.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2016-12","inductedMonth":"2020-08","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":15.814,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":326,"evidenceRank":129,"evidenceScore":82.2,"freshAt":"2024-04-21T03:18:05Z","freshnessRank":415,"freshEventScore":276,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 276 pts / 135 comments (2024) + 326 pts / 98 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,333 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":180,"peak_comments":46,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1411265","height":9,"chart_height":94},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6564303","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":123,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13242590","height":6,"chart_height":64},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18062526","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":326,"peak_comments":98,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24283478","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25670194","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30612747","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":276,"peak_comments":135,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40102912","height":13,"chart_height":144},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47584570","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/new-racket-language-website-d9d023411aca.jpg","path":"/hall/link/new-racket-language-website-d9d023411aca/"},{"slug":"silk-d9d023424721","title":"Silk","domain":"weavesilk.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["art","visual_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2015-05","inductedMonth":"2015-05","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":13.941,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":687,"evidenceRank":130,"evidenceScore":82.2,"freshAt":"2024-12-19T19:55:48Z","freshnessRank":281,"freshEventScore":85,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 687 pts / 88 comments (2011) + 442 pts / 63 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,593 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":687,"peak_comments":88,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2089615","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":74,"peak_comments":33,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5441869","height":4,"chart_height":18},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8629125","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":442,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9593507","height":21,"chart_height":109},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":332,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20609676","height":16,"chart_height":82},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25371810","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27266155","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":85,"peak_comments":26,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42465109","height":4,"chart_height":21},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/silk-d9d023424721.jpg","path":"/hall/link/silk-d9d023424721/"},{"slug":"jslinux-now-supports-x86-64-d9d023432fd1","title":"JSLinux Now Supports x86_64","domain":"bellard.org","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","developer_tools","computer_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2017-09","inductedMonth":"2019-07","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":14.812,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":1820,"evidenceRank":131,"evidenceScore":82.1,"freshAt":"2026-03-09T16:43:39Z","freshnessRank":47,"freshEventScore":380,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1820 pts / 239 comments (2011) + 380 pts / 137 comments (2026), different submitters and 5,410 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":1820,"peak_comments":239,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2555349","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10345949","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":312,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15274423","height":15,"chart_height":29},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":212,"peak_comments":28,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21617643","height":10,"chart_height":20},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35616525","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":380,"peak_comments":137,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47311484","height":18,"chart_height":35}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/jslinux-now-supports-x86-64-d9d023432fd1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/jslinux-now-supports-x86-64-d9d023432fd1/"},{"slug":"parse-don-t-validate-d9d0235f7caa","title":"Parse, Don’t Validate","domain":"lexi-lambda.github.io","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","software_architecture","testing_quality"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-01","inductedMonth":"2023-03","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":6.261,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":642,"evidenceRank":132,"evidenceScore":82.1,"freshAt":"2026-02-10T14:49:29Z","freshnessRank":61,"freshEventScore":252,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 389 pts / 270 comments (2021) + 252 pts / 172 comments (2026), different submitters and 1,690 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":642,"peak_comments":230,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21476261","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":389,"peak_comments":270,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27639890","height":19,"chart_height":103},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":398,"peak_comments":219,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35053118","height":19,"chart_height":105},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":321,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41031585","height":15,"chart_height":85},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":252,"peak_comments":172,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46960392","height":12,"chart_height":67}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/parse-don-t-validate-d9d0235f7caa.jpg","path":"/hall/link/parse-don-t-validate-d9d0235f7caa/"},{"slug":"gail-com-faq-d9d02350b207","title":"Gail.com FAQ","domain":"gail.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2021-08","inductedMonth":"2021-08","submissions":15,"submitters":14,"spanYears":10.719,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":926,"evidenceRank":133,"evidenceScore":82.1,"freshAt":"2023-01-09T07:17:52Z","freshnessRank":673,"freshEventScore":926,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 926 pts / 209 comments (2023) + 505 pts / 154 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,133 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9849524","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":505,"peak_comments":154,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13817969","height":24,"chart_height":93},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":36,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21854961","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":5,"peak_score":525,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28283890","height":24,"chart_height":96},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":926,"peak_comments":209,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34307705","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41514717","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47545106","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/gail-com-faq-d9d02350b207.jpg","path":"/hall/link/gail-com-faq-d9d02350b207/"},{"slug":"the-birth-and-death-of-javascript-video-d9d0234ca1dd","title":"The Birth and Death of JavaScript [video]","domain":"www.destroyallsoftware.com","category":"media","categoryDisplay":"Audio, video & images","type":"video","typeDisplay":"Video","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2026-06","inductedMonth":"2026-06","submissions":27,"submitters":23,"spanYears":12.159,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":635,"evidenceRank":134,"evidenceScore":82.1,"freshAt":"2026-06-14T12:38:31Z","freshnessRank":4,"freshEventScore":242,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 635 pts / 227 comments (2014) + 242 pts / 134 comments (2026), different submitters and 4,440 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 27 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 23 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":635,"peak_comments":227,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7605687","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9112040","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":5,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12641576","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14058852","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18075075","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19147184","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":7,"peak_score":73,"peak_comments":42,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27538040","height":4,"chart_height":20},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33291407","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":84,"peak_comments":36,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35901981","height":4,"chart_height":22},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":242,"peak_comments":134,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48526661","height":12,"chart_height":65}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-birth-and-death-of-javascript-video-d9d0234ca1dd.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-birth-and-death-of-javascript-video-d9d0234ca1dd/"},{"slug":"understanding-the-working-of-x11-from-the-ground-up-2017-d9d0234d606b","title":"Understanding the working of X11 from the ground up (2017)","domain":"magcius.github.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["computer_graphics","human_computer_interaction","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2019-09","inductedMonth":"2019-09","submissions":10,"submitters":9,"spanYears":8.498,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":456,"evidenceRank":135,"evidenceScore":82.1,"freshAt":"2023-01-09T10:17:51Z","freshnessRank":672,"freshEventScore":41,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 456 pts / 44 comments (2016) + 443 pts / 132 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,172 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":329,"peak_comments":65,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8019346","height":16,"chart_height":123},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":19,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10389525","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":456,"peak_comments":44,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12042548","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":443,"peak_comments":132,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21039848","height":21,"chart_height":165},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":326,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24197528","height":16,"chart_height":122},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30622255","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":41,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34308744","height":4,"chart_height":15},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/understanding-the-working-of-x11-from-the-ground-up-2017-d9d0234d606b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/understanding-the-working-of-x11-from-the-ground-up-2017-d9d0234d606b/"},{"slug":"my-history-with-forth-and-stack-machines-2010-d9d023418f0b","title":"My history with Forth and stack machines (2010)","domain":"yosefk.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","computer_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2019-10","inductedMonth":"2023-08","submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":14.3,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":147,"evidenceRank":136,"evidenceScore":82.1,"freshAt":"2024-12-28T16:34:24Z","freshnessRank":275,"freshEventScore":115,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 80 pts / 100 comments (2023) + 147 pts / 43 comments (2010), different submitters and 4,712 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":147,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1680149","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":70,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2985601","height":4,"chart_height":81},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":95,"peak_comments":11,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3963896","height":5,"chart_height":110},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":99,"peak_comments":17,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8146306","height":5,"chart_height":114},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":56,"peak_comments":26,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8869150","height":4,"chart_height":65},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12805004","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13344809","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":102,"peak_comments":33,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21153555","height":5,"chart_height":118},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":95,"peak_comments":25,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26203518","height":5,"chart_height":110},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32605477","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":80,"peak_comments":100,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37025393","height":4,"chart_height":93},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":115,"peak_comments":28,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42532157","height":6,"chart_height":133},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/my-history-with-forth-and-stack-machines-2010-d9d023418f0b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/my-history-with-forth-and-stack-machines-2010-d9d023418f0b/"},{"slug":"what-is-code-d9d023507458","title":"What is code","domain":"www.bloomberg.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-06","inductedMonth":"2018-06","submissions":20,"submitters":19,"spanYears":10.56,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":1384,"evidenceRank":137,"evidenceScore":82.1,"freshAt":"2026-01-01T22:08:05Z","freshnessRank":90,"freshEventScore":132,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1384 pts / 355 comments (2015) + 198 pts / 36 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,092 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 19 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":1384,"peak_comments":355,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9698870","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12838475","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":5,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15146226","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":198,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17259483","height":10,"chart_height":24},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25053470","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26541370","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":4,"peak_score":106,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33331697","height":5,"chart_height":13},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41871292","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":132,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46458610","height":6,"chart_height":16}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/what-is-code-d9d023507458/"},{"slug":"dictionary-of-algorithms-and-data-structures-d9d02342c05b","title":"Dictionary of Algorithms and Data Structures","domain":"xlinux.nist.gov","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["algorithms_data_structures"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2013-04","inductedMonth":"2023-09","submissions":17,"submitters":17,"spanYears":12.537,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":409,"evidenceRank":138,"evidenceScore":82.1,"freshAt":"2023-09-28T20:19:26Z","freshnessRank":534,"freshEventScore":409,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 409 pts / 42 comments (2023) + 242 pts / 16 comments (2011), different submitters and 4,535 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":4,"peak_score":242,"peak_comments":16,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2496539","height":12,"chart_height":101},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3537951","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":178,"peak_comments":15,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5525893","height":9,"chart_height":74},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":68,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8905348","height":4,"chart_height":28},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":222,"peak_comments":18,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12758176","height":11,"chart_height":92},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17384691","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23062448","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28036431","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31908548","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":409,"peak_comments":42,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37695245","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/dictionary-of-algorithms-and-data-structures-d9d02342c05b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/dictionary-of-algorithms-and-data-structures-d9d02342c05b/"},{"slug":"regex-crossword-d9d02349bc7b","title":"Regex Crossword","domain":"regexcrossword.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"computer_game","typeDisplay":"Computer games","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_design","programming_languages","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2019-09","inductedMonth":"2019-09","submissions":30,"submitters":27,"spanYears":11.948,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":409,"evidenceRank":139,"evidenceScore":82.0,"freshAt":"2022-12-31T21:26:09Z","freshnessRank":678,"freshEventScore":25,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 409 pts / 59 comments (2019) + 330 pts / 108 comments (2014), different submitters and 1,739 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 30 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 27 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":4,"peak_score":23,"peak_comments":11,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6056011","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2014,"count":4,"peak_score":330,"peak_comments":108,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8674039","height":16,"chart_height":137},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":5,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10997861","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14715819","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17394756","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":409,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20874475","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25564258","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":58,"peak_comments":10,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27244758","height":4,"chart_height":24},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":25,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34200936","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41404862","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44136587","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/regex-crossword-d9d02349bc7b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/regex-crossword-d9d02349bc7b/"},{"slug":"the-hardest-program-i-ve-ever-written-how-a-code-formatter-works-d9d023514581","title":"The Hardest Program I've Ever Written – How a code formatter works (2015)","domain":"journal.stuffwithstuff.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-06","inductedMonth":"2019-11","submissions":11,"submitters":7,"spanYears":10.138,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":500,"evidenceRank":140,"evidenceScore":82.0,"freshAt":"2025-10-29T05:14:33Z","freshnessRank":124,"freshEventScore":97,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 500 pts / 125 comments (2020) + 242 pts / 76 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,660 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":242,"peak_comments":76,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10195091","height":12,"chart_height":82},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":303,"peak_comments":76,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17271963","height":15,"chart_height":103},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21559112","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":500,"peak_comments":125,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22706242","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":261,"peak_comments":133,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30566111","height":13,"chart_height":89},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39438314","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":97,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45742886","height":5,"chart_height":33},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-hardest-program-i-ve-ever-written-how-a-code-formatter-works-d9d023514581.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-hardest-program-i-ve-ever-written-how-a-code-formatter-works-d9d023514581/"},{"slug":"quine-relay-d9d02349fd62","title":"Quine Relay","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2020-11","inductedMonth":"2020-11","submissions":26,"submitters":26,"spanYears":13.008,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":983,"evidenceRank":141,"evidenceScore":82.0,"freshAt":"2022-05-28T00:00:52Z","freshnessRank":778,"freshEventScore":106,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 983 pts / 177 comments (2013) + 119 pts / 13 comments (2020), different submitters and 2,671 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 26 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 26 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":983,"peak_comments":177,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6048761","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8976842","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":5,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11739762","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14978477","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17456527","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":52,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19857325","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":119,"peak_comments":13,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25015965","height":6,"chart_height":21},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":106,"peak_comments":11,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31536320","height":5,"chart_height":18},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38158549","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39804145","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47721798","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/quine-relay-d9d02349fd62.jpg","path":"/hall/link/quine-relay-d9d02349fd62/"},{"slug":"academic-torrents-making-27tb-of-research-data-available-d9d0234bd87e","title":"Academic Torrents – Making 27TB of research data available","domain":"academictorrents.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["data_engineering","protocols_networking"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2016-08","inductedMonth":"2016-08","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":11.959,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":1082,"evidenceRank":142,"evidenceScore":81.9,"freshAt":"2020-01-13T12:29:08Z","freshnessRank":1026,"freshEventScore":297,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1082 pts / 140 comments (2018) + 448 pts / 63 comments (2014), different submitters and 1,655 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":448,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7149006","height":22,"chart_height":70},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10215255","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":552,"peak_comments":95,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12381791","height":24,"chart_height":87},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":1082,"peak_comments":140,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17744150","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":297,"peak_comments":32,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22033833","height":14,"chart_height":47},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33330826","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46633838","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/academic-torrents-making-27tb-of-research-data-available-d9d0234bd87e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/academic-torrents-making-27tb-of-research-data-available-d9d0234bd87e/"},{"slug":"notes-on-structured-concurrency-or-go-statement-considered-harmf-d9d0235a3041","title":"Notes on structured concurrency, or: Go statement considered harmful","domain":"vorpus.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["distributed_systems","programming_languages","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-03","inductedMonth":"2021-03","submissions":20,"submitters":20,"spanYears":8.225,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":301,"evidenceRank":143,"evidenceScore":81.9,"freshAt":"2022-07-02T01:55:19Z","freshnessRank":756,"freshEventScore":157,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 301 pts / 230 comments (2018) + 157 pts / 122 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,528 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":301,"peak_comments":230,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16921761","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21023786","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24229931","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":176,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26509986","height":8,"chart_height":99},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":157,"peak_comments":122,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31955334","height":8,"chart_height":89},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36870917","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43412562","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48930991","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/notes-on-structured-concurrency-or-go-statement-considered-harmf-d9d0235a3041.jpg","path":"/hall/link/notes-on-structured-concurrency-or-go-statement-considered-harmf-d9d0235a3041/"},{"slug":"big-ball-of-mud-1999-d9d0233e2ed0","title":"Big Ball of Mud (1999)","domain":"www.laputan.org","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"technical_report","typeDisplay":"Technical reports","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2007,"candidateMonth":"2023-04","inductedMonth":"2024-07","submissions":21,"submitters":20,"spanYears":18.297,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":162,"evidenceRank":144,"evidenceScore":81.9,"freshAt":"2024-07-10T19:29:32Z","freshnessRank":364,"freshEventScore":162,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 162 pts / 133 comments (2024) + 122 pts / 48 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,603 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 21 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=59465","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1051122","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4868851","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":97,"peak_comments":21,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6745991","height":5,"chart_height":102},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8630622","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":52,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9989424","height":4,"chart_height":55},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":73,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13716667","height":4,"chart_height":77},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17254162","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":5,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21484045","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":122,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22365496","height":6,"chart_height":128},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28157348","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29892418","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":142,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35481309","height":7,"chart_height":149},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":162,"peak_comments":133,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40930549","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46571730","height":4,"chart_height":10}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/big-ball-of-mud-1999-d9d0233e2ed0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/big-ball-of-mud-1999-d9d0233e2ed0/"},{"slug":"structured-procrastination-do-less-deceive-yourself-and-succeed-d9d0233e14e7","title":"Structured Procrastination: Do Less, Deceive Yourself, and Succeed Long-Term","domain":"www.structuredprocrastination.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["personal_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2007,"candidateMonth":"2018-04","inductedMonth":"2018-04","submissions":21,"submitters":20,"spanYears":18.995,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":323,"evidenceRank":145,"evidenceScore":81.9,"freshAt":"2022-02-10T21:00:39Z","freshnessRank":827,"freshEventScore":198,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 323 pts / 79 comments (2015) + 198 pts / 36 comments (2022), different submitters and 2,354 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 21 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":1,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26391","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=212590","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1125284","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3122298","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4604512","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6351097","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":323,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10151481","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":180,"peak_comments":38,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16941717","height":9,"chart_height":95},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20798670","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":53,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24884347","height":4,"chart_height":28},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":198,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30292440","height":10,"chart_height":104},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36433304","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41099441","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48055387","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/structured-procrastination-do-less-deceive-yourself-and-succeed-d9d0233e14e7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/structured-procrastination-do-less-deceive-yourself-and-succeed-d9d0233e14e7/"},{"slug":"suicide-linux-d9d0234094ef","title":"Suicide Linux","domain":"qntm.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_design","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2017-10","inductedMonth":"2017-10","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":15.995,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":272,"evidenceRank":146,"evidenceScore":81.9,"freshAt":"2026-02-16T20:34:27Z","freshnessRank":57,"freshEventScore":116,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 147 pts / 170 comments (2020) + 272 pts / 131 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,070 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1135140","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4389931","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5095877","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":71,"peak_comments":55,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9401065","height":4,"chart_height":44},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12741153","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":272,"peak_comments":131,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15561987","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":147,"peak_comments":170,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24652733","height":7,"chart_height":92},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41748336","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42699498","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":116,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47039966","height":6,"chart_height":72}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/suicide-linux-d9d0234094ef.jpg","path":"/hall/link/suicide-linux-d9d0234094ef/"},{"slug":"modern-microprocessors-a-90-minute-guide-2001-2016-d9d02342f009","title":"Modern Microprocessors – A 90-Minute Guide (2001-2016)","domain":"www.lighterra.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["computer_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2014-02","inductedMonth":"2018-10","submissions":14,"submitters":11,"spanYears":14.483,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":443,"evidenceRank":147,"evidenceScore":81.8,"freshAt":"2021-05-02T10:55:35Z","freshnessRank":918,"freshEventScore":178,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 443 pts / 87 comments (2018) + 283 pts / 30 comments (2011), different submitters and 2,746 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":283,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2428403","height":14,"chart_height":109},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6846053","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":226,"peak_comments":37,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7174513","height":11,"chart_height":87},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10722053","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":170,"peak_comments":12,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11116211","height":8,"chart_height":65},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":443,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18230383","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":178,"peak_comments":41,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27014027","height":9,"chart_height":68},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38786030","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40010698","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45451319","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/modern-microprocessors-a-90-minute-guide-2001-2016-d9d02342f009.jpg","path":"/hall/link/modern-microprocessors-a-90-minute-guide-2001-2016-d9d02342f009/"},{"slug":"shoelace-a-library-of-web-components-d9d02357b23a","title":"Shoelace: A library of web components","domain":"shoelace.style","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","user_experience","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-07","inductedMonth":"2021-12","submissions":12,"submitters":10,"spanYears":8.441,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":294,"evidenceRank":148,"evidenceScore":81.8,"freshAt":"2024-01-10T20:46:33Z","freshnessRank":462,"freshEventScore":294,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 257 pts / 122 comments (2017) + 294 pts / 110 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,353 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":257,"peak_comments":122,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14898627","height":12,"chart_height":149},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":218,"peak_comments":110,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23866894","height":10,"chart_height":126},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29524607","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":117,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30900220","height":6,"chart_height":68},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37807808","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":294,"peak_comments":110,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38942847","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44269498","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46493180","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/shoelace-a-library-of-web-components-d9d02357b23a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/shoelace-a-library-of-web-components-d9d02357b23a/"},{"slug":"the-philosophy-of-computer-science-2017-d9d0234020e8","title":"The Philosophy of Computer Science (2017)","domain":"plato.stanford.edu","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["theory_of_computation","philosophy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2014-12","inductedMonth":"2020-03","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":15.622,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":330,"evidenceRank":149,"evidenceScore":81.8,"freshAt":"2023-02-20T19:29:58Z","freshnessRank":655,"freshEventScore":205,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 330 pts / 81 comments (2020) + 205 pts / 49 comments (2018), different submitters and 752 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=907355","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":118,"peak_comments":22,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4936515","height":6,"chart_height":61},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":116,"peak_comments":34,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8685971","height":6,"chart_height":60},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16005950","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":205,"peak_comments":49,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16451072","height":10,"chart_height":106},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":330,"peak_comments":81,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22607568","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29223736","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":205,"peak_comments":95,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34871824","height":10,"chart_height":106},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42503159","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43339371","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-philosophy-of-computer-science-2017-d9d0234020e8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-philosophy-of-computer-science-2017-d9d0234020e8/"},{"slug":"how-to-slice-a-bagel-into-two-linked-halves-2009-d9d023404764","title":"How to Slice a Bagel into Two Linked Halves (2009)","domain":"www.georgehart.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2013-04","inductedMonth":"2014-05","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":14.344,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":415,"evidenceRank":150,"evidenceScore":81.8,"freshAt":"2022-03-06T00:39:32Z","freshnessRank":814,"freshEventScore":394,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 415 pts / 61 comments (2018) + 394 pts / 112 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,499 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":350,"peak_comments":25,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=982249","height":17,"chart_height":143},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3529355","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":198,"peak_comments":34,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5569014","height":10,"chart_height":81},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7748608","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":415,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16241007","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":394,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30573660","height":19,"chart_height":161},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39998962","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-to-slice-a-bagel-into-two-linked-halves-2009-d9d023404764.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-to-slice-a-bagel-into-two-linked-halves-2009-d9d023404764/"},{"slug":"data-structure-visualizations-d9d023431669","title":"Data Structure Visualizations","domain":"www.cs.usfca.edu","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["algorithms_data_structures"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2015-09","inductedMonth":"2017-10","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":10.179,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":514,"evidenceRank":151,"evidenceScore":81.8,"freshAt":"2021-07-06T07:29:46Z","freshnessRank":892,"freshEventScore":492,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 514 pts / 35 comments (2013) + 492 pts / 19 comments (2021), different submitters and 2,756 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":72,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2505862","height":4,"chart_height":24},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":514,"peak_comments":35,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6928904","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":111,"peak_comments":3,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10183811","height":5,"chart_height":37},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":216,"peak_comments":9,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15480517","height":10,"chart_height":71},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":384,"peak_comments":33,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19082943","height":18,"chart_height":127},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":492,"peak_comments":19,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27745184","height":24,"chart_height":163},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/data-structure-visualizations-d9d023431669.jpg","path":"/hall/link/data-structure-visualizations-d9d023431669/"},{"slug":"statically-recompiling-nes-games-into-native-executables-with-ll-d9d02349a065","title":"Statically Recompiling NES Games into Native Executables with LLVM and Go","domain":"andrewkelley.me","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["compilers_runtimes","emulation","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-03","inductedMonth":"2017-08","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":12.862,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":560,"evidenceRank":152,"evidenceScore":81.8,"freshAt":"2017-09-15T03:54:15Z","freshnessRank":1119,"freshEventScore":265,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 560 pts / 96 comments (2013) + 356 pts / 64 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,014 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":560,"peak_comments":96,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5838326","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":113,"peak_comments":26,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8405214","height":5,"chart_height":34},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":356,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11309907","height":17,"chart_height":108},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":265,"peak_comments":44,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15254506","height":13,"chart_height":80},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19030846","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32629213","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39884663","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47815821","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/statically-recompiling-nes-games-into-native-executables-with-ll-d9d02349a065.jpg","path":"/hall/link/statically-recompiling-nes-games-into-native-executables-with-ll-d9d02349a065/"},{"slug":"sqlite-small-blob-storage-35-faster-than-the-filesystem-d9d0235749e7","title":"SQLite small blob storage: 35% Faster Than the Filesystem","domain":"www.sqlite.org","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"technical_report","typeDisplay":"Technical reports","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["databases_storage","performance_reliability","testing_quality"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-05","inductedMonth":"2023-01","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":7.368,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":612,"evidenceRank":153,"evidenceScore":81.8,"freshAt":"2024-10-26T17:08:41Z","freshnessRank":308,"freshEventScore":46,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 612 pts / 202 comments (2017) + 487 pts / 193 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,600 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":612,"peak_comments":202,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14550060","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":267,"peak_comments":164,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20729930","height":13,"chart_height":74},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":226,"peak_comments":127,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27897427","height":11,"chart_height":63},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":216,"peak_comments":137,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34387407","height":10,"chart_height":60},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":487,"peak_comments":193,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41085376","height":23,"chart_height":135},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/sqlite-small-blob-storage-35-faster-than-the-filesystem-d9d0235749e7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/sqlite-small-blob-storage-35-faster-than-the-filesystem-d9d0235749e7/"},{"slug":"24-192-music-downloads-and-why-they-make-no-sense-2012-d9d0234572e2","title":"24/192 Music Downloads and why they make no sense (2012)","domain":"people.xiph.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["music","physics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2015-11","inductedMonth":"2018-12","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":14.324,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":732,"evidenceRank":154,"evidenceScore":81.8,"freshAt":"2026-07-02T16:24:49Z","freshnessRank":2,"freshEventScore":39,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 732 pts / 316 comments (2012) + 295 pts / 314 comments (2019), different submitters and 2,556 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":732,"peak_comments":316,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3668310","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6799247","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":325,"peak_comments":228,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10520639","height":16,"chart_height":75},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13695672","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18780987","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":295,"peak_comments":314,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19318898","height":14,"chart_height":69},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":24,"peak_comments":13,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34698427","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41627389","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46354179","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":39,"peak_comments":32,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48763790","height":4,"chart_height":9}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/24-192-music-downloads-and-why-they-make-no-sense-2012-d9d0234572e2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/24-192-music-downloads-and-why-they-make-no-sense-2012-d9d0234572e2/"},{"slug":"the-disadvantages-of-an-elite-education-2008-d9d0233f9df6","title":"The Disadvantages of an Elite Education (2008)","domain":"theamericanscholar.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["academic_life"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2016-12","inductedMonth":"2016-12","submissions":20,"submitters":20,"spanYears":16.914,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":238,"evidenceRank":155,"evidenceScore":81.7,"freshAt":"2026-05-06T16:21:03Z","freshnessRank":19,"freshEventScore":40,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 238 pts / 206 comments (2016) + 130 pts / 78 comments (2009), different submitters and 2,756 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":130,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=645000","height":6,"chart_height":93},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":69,"peak_comments":36,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1843491","height":4,"chart_height":49},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3064141","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2012,"count":5,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3742613","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5469046","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8270242","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":238,"peak_comments":206,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13241784","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25393257","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33869474","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37877435","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":40,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48038031","height":4,"chart_height":29}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-disadvantages-of-an-elite-education-2008-d9d0233f9df6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-disadvantages-of-an-elite-education-2008-d9d0233f9df6/"},{"slug":"programmer-competency-matrix-2016-d9d02349bf0b","title":"Programmer Competency Matrix (2016)","domain":"sijinjoseph.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["careers","hiring_interviews","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2013-06","inductedMonth":"2015-04","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":9.588,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":360,"evidenceRank":156,"evidenceScore":81.6,"freshAt":"2017-03-26T13:41:11Z","freshnessRank":1132,"freshEventScore":203,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 360 pts / 122 comments (2012) + 203 pts / 106 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,630 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":156,"peak_comments":106,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1949915","height":7,"chart_height":74},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":360,"peak_comments":122,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4626695","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":13,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5905330","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":76,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9341146","height":4,"chart_height":36},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12081124","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":203,"peak_comments":106,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13960729","height":10,"chart_height":96},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17469921","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23705728","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/programmer-competency-matrix-2016-d9d02349bf0b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/programmer-competency-matrix-2016-d9d02349bf0b/"},{"slug":"in-the-beginning-was-the-command-line-1999-d9d02351d770","title":"In the Beginning Was the Command Line (1999)","domain":"web.stanford.edu","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2018-04","inductedMonth":"2024-07","submissions":14,"submitters":14,"spanYears":11.636,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":412,"evidenceRank":157,"evidenceScore":81.6,"freshAt":"2025-12-08T08:44:06Z","freshnessRank":102,"freshEventScore":188,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 412 pts / 260 comments (2024) + 179 pts / 64 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,359 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7618587","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10539937","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":145,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12469797","height":7,"chart_height":60},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":102,"peak_comments":13,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16843739","height":5,"chart_height":42},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21209970","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":179,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24998305","height":9,"chart_height":74},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37314225","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":412,"peak_comments":260,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41084795","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":188,"peak_comments":98,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46189905","height":9,"chart_height":78},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/in-the-beginning-was-the-command-line-1999-d9d02351d770.jpg","path":"/hall/link/in-the-beginning-was-the-command-line-1999-d9d02351d770/"},{"slug":"prac-ti-cal-ty-pog-ra-phy-d9d0234a128d","title":"Prac­ti­cal Ty­pog­ra­phy","domain":"practicaltypography.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design","writing_craft"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2018-11","inductedMonth":"2018-11","submissions":24,"submitters":24,"spanYears":12.381,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":472,"evidenceRank":158,"evidenceScore":81.6,"freshAt":"2021-04-04T09:58:40Z","freshnessRank":929,"freshEventScore":182,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 472 pts / 159 comments (2013) + 261 pts / 61 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,942 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 24 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 24 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":472,"peak_comments":159,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6094946","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7680962","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15405904","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":4,"peak_score":261,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18477231","height":13,"chart_height":94},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22934134","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":182,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26688142","height":9,"chart_height":66},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32999570","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37622231","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41631180","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42601411","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/prac-ti-cal-ty-pog-ra-phy-d9d0234a128d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/prac-ti-cal-ty-pog-ra-phy-d9d0234a128d/"},{"slug":"dna-seen-through-the-eyes-of-a-coder-2017-d9d0233e7137","title":"DNA seen through the eyes of a coder (2017)","domain":"ds9a.nl","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["biology"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2018-01","inductedMonth":"2018-01","submissions":21,"submitters":19,"spanYears":13.385,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":326,"evidenceRank":159,"evidenceScore":81.6,"freshAt":"2018-01-25T19:17:15Z","freshnessRank":1112,"freshEventScore":326,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 326 pts / 72 comments (2018) + 322 pts / 97 comments (2013), different submitters and 1,502 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 21 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 19 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":46,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=144611","height":4,"chart_height":24},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3108372","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3947321","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2013,"count":5,"peak_score":322,"peak_comments":97,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6909711","height":15,"chart_height":168},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8262584","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9155051","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10897704","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15222150","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":326,"peak_comments":72,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16233644","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25728890","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/dna-seen-through-the-eyes-of-a-coder-2017-d9d0233e7137.jpg","path":"/hall/link/dna-seen-through-the-eyes-of-a-coder-2017-d9d0233e7137/"},{"slug":"computer-latency-1977-2017-d9d023590f38","title":"Computer latency: 1977-2017","domain":"danluu.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["human_computer_interaction","performance_reliability","computer_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-12","inductedMonth":"2020-12","submissions":17,"submitters":14,"spanYears":8.118,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":588,"evidenceRank":160,"evidenceScore":81.5,"freshAt":"2022-11-20T17:51:03Z","freshnessRank":684,"freshEventScore":240,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 454 pts / 259 comments (2020) + 588 pts / 161 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,074 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":588,"peak_comments":161,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16001407","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18018121","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":6,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21466208","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":5,"peak_score":454,"peak_comments":259,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25290118","height":22,"chart_height":131},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":240,"peak_comments":100,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33683278","height":12,"chart_height":69},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40429682","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46897319","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/computer-latency-1977-2017-d9d023590f38.jpg","path":"/hall/link/computer-latency-1977-2017-d9d023590f38/"},{"slug":"why-i-wrote-pgp-1999-d9d02347616e","title":"Why I Wrote PGP (1999)","domain":"www.philzimmermann.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography","privacy_surveillance","law_regulation"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2015-11","inductedMonth":"2021-08","submissions":14,"submitters":13,"spanYears":13.498,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":422,"evidenceRank":161,"evidenceScore":81.4,"freshAt":"2021-08-09T11:34:14Z","freshnessRank":884,"freshEventScore":76,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 422 pts / 181 comments (2021) + 257 pts / 109 comments (2013), different submitters and 2,807 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4645833","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":257,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6823668","height":12,"chart_height":104},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":149,"peak_comments":47,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10581971","height":7,"chart_height":60},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13832495","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17980690","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":422,"peak_comments":181,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28103734","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37275034","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40381057","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42735328","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47737067","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-i-wrote-pgp-1999-d9d02347616e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-i-wrote-pgp-1999-d9d02347616e/"},{"slug":"chemistry-of-cast-iron-seasoning-2010-d9d0234269d3","title":"Chemistry of Cast-Iron Seasoning (2010)","domain":"sherylcanter.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["food_travel","chemistry_materials"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2017-12","inductedMonth":"2017-12","submissions":15,"submitters":7,"spanYears":14.023,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":348,"evidenceRank":162,"evidenceScore":81.4,"freshAt":"2022-06-02T15:15:09Z","freshnessRank":772,"freshEventScore":47,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 348 pts / 286 comments (2021) + 218 pts / 142 comments (2014), different submitters and 2,248 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2156460","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5847922","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":218,"peak_comments":142,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8611468","height":10,"chart_height":106},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13150590","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":81,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15915502","height":4,"chart_height":40},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20910349","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23459182","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":348,"peak_comments":286,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25715781","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":47,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31595899","height":4,"chart_height":23},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42962248","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/chemistry-of-cast-iron-seasoning-2010-d9d0234269d3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/chemistry-of-cast-iron-seasoning-2010-d9d0234269d3/"},{"slug":"in-defense-of-swap-common-misconceptions-2018-d9d023592ea5","title":"In defense of swap: common misconceptions (2018)","domain":"chrisdown.name","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","performance_reliability","computer_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2020-06","inductedMonth":"2022-04","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":7.699,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":182,"evidenceRank":163,"evidenceScore":81.4,"freshAt":"2025-09-21T00:06:38Z","freshnessRank":141,"freshEventScore":116,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 182 pts / 165 comments (2022) + 116 pts / 150 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,249 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":150,"peak_comments":148,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16145294","height":7,"chart_height":140},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":68,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23455051","height":4,"chart_height":64},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29159755","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":182,"peak_comments":165,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31104126","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38263901","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":82,"peak_comments":97,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40582029","height":4,"chart_height":77},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":116,"peak_comments":150,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45318798","height":6,"chart_height":108},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/in-defense-of-swap-common-misconceptions-2018-d9d023592ea5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/in-defense-of-swap-common-misconceptions-2018-d9d023592ea5/"},{"slug":"visualizing-algorithms-2014-d9d0234d4103","title":"Visualizing Algorithms (2014)","domain":"bost.ocks.org","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["algorithms_data_structures","computer_graphics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2016-07","inductedMonth":"2017-07","submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":12.068,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":1557,"evidenceRank":164,"evidenceScore":81.3,"freshAt":"2022-07-01T07:40:31Z","freshnessRank":758,"freshEventScore":294,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1557 pts / 88 comments (2014) + 294 pts / 27 comments (2022), different submitters and 2,926 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1557,"peak_comments":88,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7949995","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":182,"peak_comments":2,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10216124","height":9,"chart_height":20},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12138515","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":152,"peak_comments":12,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14806488","height":7,"chart_height":17},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18574169","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24375195","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":294,"peak_comments":27,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31943531","height":14,"chart_height":32},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38395924","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41669849","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45256418","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48993324","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/visualizing-algorithms-2014-d9d0234d4103.jpg","path":"/hall/link/visualizing-algorithms-2014-d9d0234d4103/"},{"slug":"sqrl-secure-quick-reliable-login-d9d0234aba3f","title":"SQRL – Secure Quick Reliable Login","domain":"www.grc.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"standard_specification","typeDisplay":"Standards & specifications","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography","application_security","protocols_networking"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2017-06","inductedMonth":"2017-06","submissions":20,"submitters":20,"spanYears":12.487,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":213,"evidenceRank":165,"evidenceScore":81.3,"freshAt":"2017-06-01T12:02:28Z","freshnessRank":1124,"freshEventScore":213,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 213 pts / 135 comments (2017) + 205 pts / 131 comments (2013), different submitters and 1,337 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":205,"peak_comments":131,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6484577","height":10,"chart_height":164},{"year":2014,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8176090","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11928352","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":213,"peak_comments":135,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14459537","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18381070","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2019,"count":5,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20805520","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":15,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24351622","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29269633","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33441701","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37954836","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47568281","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/sqrl-secure-quick-reliable-login-d9d0234aba3f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/sqrl-secure-quick-reliable-login-d9d0234aba3f/"},{"slug":"life-is-short-d9d023526bd6","title":"Life is Short","domain":"paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["philosophy","psychology"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2018-04","inductedMonth":"2020-08","submissions":14,"submitters":13,"spanYears":10.357,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":970,"evidenceRank":166,"evidenceScore":81.3,"freshAt":"2022-12-25T05:51:29Z","freshnessRank":679,"freshEventScore":47,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 970 pts / 408 comments (2016) + 568 pts / 184 comments (2018), different submitters and 805 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":970,"peak_comments":408,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10917446","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":568,"peak_comments":184,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16729555","height":24,"chart_height":100},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":346,"peak_comments":164,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24313158","height":17,"chart_height":61},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29610261","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":4,"peak_score":47,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34124726","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44014051","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48286117","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/life-is-short-d9d023526bd6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/life-is-short-d9d023526bd6/"},{"slug":"bitwarden-free-open-source-password-manager-d9d02354e8cd","title":"Bitwarden: Free, open-source password manager","domain":"bitwarden.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography","application_security","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-10","inductedMonth":"2021-02","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.957,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":455,"evidenceRank":167,"evidenceScore":81.2,"freshAt":"2023-09-25T08:11:30Z","freshnessRank":537,"freshEventScore":455,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 455 pts / 300 comments (2023) + 353 pts / 167 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,449 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":231,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12676979","height":11,"chart_height":86},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":337,"peak_comments":160,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17503917","height":16,"chart_height":126},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":353,"peak_comments":167,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21175332","height":17,"chart_height":132},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26186611","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":409,"peak_comments":235,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29991585","height":20,"chart_height":153},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":455,"peak_comments":300,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37640816","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/bitwarden-free-open-source-password-manager-d9d02354e8cd.jpg","path":"/hall/link/bitwarden-free-open-source-password-manager-d9d02354e8cd/"},{"slug":"doomsday-planning-for-less-crazy-folk-d9d0235267c7","title":"Doomsday planning for less crazy folk","domain":"lcamtuf.coredump.cx","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["social_issues"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-03","inductedMonth":"2020-11","submissions":17,"submitters":16,"spanYears":7.567,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":575,"evidenceRank":168,"evidenceScore":81.2,"freshAt":"2020-11-11T17:26:26Z","freshnessRank":974,"freshEventScore":173,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 575 pts / 330 comments (2017) + 173 pts / 115 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,172 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":213,"peak_comments":162,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10906232","height":10,"chart_height":63},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":575,"peak_comments":330,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15110850","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19473303","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":8,"peak_score":173,"peak_comments":115,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25060418","height":8,"chart_height":51},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30459399","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37071219","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/doomsday-planning-for-less-crazy-folk-d9d0235267c7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/doomsday-planning-for-less-crazy-folk-d9d0235267c7/"},{"slug":"notation-as-a-tool-of-thought-1979-d9d023412d41","title":"Notation as a Tool of Thought (1979)","domain":"www.jsoftware.com","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"research_paper","typeDisplay":"Research papers","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2016-12","inductedMonth":"2025-04","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":14.839,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":322,"evidenceRank":169,"evidenceScore":81.0,"freshAt":"2025-04-25T02:30:34Z","freshnessRank":216,"freshEventScore":322,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 322 pts / 107 comments (2025) + 203 pts / 43 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,607 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1454462","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3123455","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6202826","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":124,"peak_comments":17,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10182942","height":6,"chart_height":65},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":106,"peak_comments":25,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13199880","height":5,"chart_height":56},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":33,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18188685","height":4,"chart_height":17},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20605950","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":203,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25249563","height":10,"chart_height":107},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":188,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32178291","height":9,"chart_height":99},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39274475","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":322,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43789593","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/notation-as-a-tool-of-thought-1979-d9d023412d41.jpg","path":"/hall/link/notation-as-a-tool-of-thought-1979-d9d023412d41/"},{"slug":"http-cats-d9d023512acf","title":"HTTP Cats","domain":"http.cat","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2022-05","inductedMonth":"2022-05","submissions":14,"submitters":12,"spanYears":10.426,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":593,"evidenceRank":170,"evidenceScore":81.0,"freshAt":"2026-01-30T13:56:51Z","freshnessRank":69,"freshEventScore":593,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 593 pts / 88 comments (2026) + 427 pts / 63 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,351 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10135736","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":5,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13786722","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18361287","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":408,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20283794","height":20,"chart_height":117},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":427,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31438989","height":20,"chart_height":122},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":58,"peak_comments":11,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37735614","height":4,"chart_height":17},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":593,"peak_comments":88,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46824422","height":24,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/http-cats-d9d023512acf.jpg","path":"/hall/link/http-cats-d9d023512acf/"},{"slug":"dynamicland-2024-d9d02359048b","title":"Dynamicland 2024","domain":"dynamicland.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["human_computer_interaction","teaching","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-04","inductedMonth":"2021-04","submissions":13,"submitters":12,"spanYears":8.323,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":590,"evidenceRank":171,"evidenceScore":80.9,"freshAt":"2024-09-04T17:02:14Z","freshnessRank":336,"freshEventScore":590,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 590 pts / 194 comments (2024) + 297 pts / 112 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,246 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":446,"peak_comments":117,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15962730","height":21,"chart_height":129},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":77,"peak_comments":28,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19528468","height":4,"chart_height":22},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24229885","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":297,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26725370","height":14,"chart_height":86},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32688242","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36607314","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":590,"peak_comments":194,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41448022","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46312556","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47789293","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/dynamicland-2024-d9d02359048b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/dynamicland-2024-d9d02359048b/"},{"slug":"how-google-code-search-worked-regex-matching-with-a-trigram-inde-d9d023450d65","title":"How Google Code Search Worked: Regex Matching with a Trigram Index (2012)","domain":"swtch.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["algorithms_data_structures","information_retrieval","compilers_runtimes"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2018-12","inductedMonth":"2018-12","submissions":15,"submitters":15,"spanYears":12.353,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":434,"evidenceRank":172,"evidenceScore":80.9,"freshAt":"2024-05-27T20:13:20Z","freshnessRank":389,"freshEventScore":96,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 434 pts / 70 comments (2018) + 287 pts / 45 comments (2012), different submitters and 2,508 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":287,"peak_comments":45,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3484899","height":14,"chart_height":112},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5105287","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11805546","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13326786","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":434,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18582469","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":168,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22552460","height":8,"chart_height":66},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25931756","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32071804","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":122,"peak_comments":16,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34692373","height":6,"chart_height":48},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":96,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40494216","height":5,"chart_height":38},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-google-code-search-worked-regex-matching-with-a-trigram-inde-d9d023450d65.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-google-code-search-worked-regex-matching-with-a-trigram-inde-d9d023450d65/"},{"slug":"tiddlywiki-a-non-linear-personal-web-notebook-d9d0233e02ca","title":"Tiddlywiki – A non-linear personal web notebook","domain":"tiddlywiki.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["open_source","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2007,"candidateMonth":"2018-09","inductedMonth":"2020-12","submissions":20,"submitters":17,"spanYears":19.135,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":331,"evidenceRank":173,"evidenceScore":80.9,"freshAt":"2026-04-28T04:32:51Z","freshnessRank":25,"freshEventScore":20,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 331 pts / 108 comments (2018) + 125 pts / 31 comments (2020), different submitters and 815 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3433","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1257848","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2673408","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6961668","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9498442","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":191,"peak_comments":55,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13523660","height":9,"chart_height":98},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":331,"peak_comments":108,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18107271","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":125,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25527581","height":6,"chart_height":64},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42514144","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":5,"peak_score":27,"peak_comments":12,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44198116","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":20,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47930484","height":4,"chart_height":10}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/tiddlywiki-a-non-linear-personal-web-notebook-d9d0233e02ca.jpg","path":"/hall/link/tiddlywiki-a-non-linear-personal-web-notebook-d9d0233e02ca/"},{"slug":"the-magic-of-the-kalman-filter-in-pictures-d9d0235102e1","title":"The magic of the Kalman filter, in pictures","domain":"www.bzarg.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","data_science","embedded_iot"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-05","inductedMonth":"2020-01","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":8.646,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":481,"evidenceRank":174,"evidenceScore":80.8,"freshAt":"2024-04-03T21:11:58Z","freshnessRank":424,"freshEventScore":48,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 481 pts / 78 comments (2021) + 443 pts / 48 comments (2015), different submitters and 2,309 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":443,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10042050","height":21,"chart_height":157},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12648724","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":213,"peak_comments":32,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13449229","height":10,"chart_height":75},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":390,"peak_comments":34,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17116149","height":19,"chart_height":138},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":194,"peak_comments":27,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23943836","height":9,"chart_height":69},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":481,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29473271","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":48,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39923212","height":4,"chart_height":17},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-magic-of-the-kalman-filter-in-pictures-d9d0235102e1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-magic-of-the-kalman-filter-in-pictures-d9d0235102e1/"},{"slug":"i-can-tolerate-anything-except-the-outgroup-d9d0234e176f","title":"I Can Tolerate Anything Except the Outgroup","domain":"slatestarcodex.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["social_issues","psychology","politics_government"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2021-01","inductedMonth":"2023-09","submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":8.931,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":293,"evidenceRank":175,"evidenceScore":80.8,"freshAt":"2023-09-06T15:39:50Z","freshnessRank":554,"freshEventScore":293,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 293 pts / 371 comments (2023) + 282 pts / 169 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,545 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8396296","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":46,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9948575","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13248993","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13971787","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17948612","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":282,"peak_comments":169,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20183001","height":14,"chart_height":164},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":131,"peak_comments":44,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25725150","height":6,"chart_height":76},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31101986","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":293,"peak_comments":371,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37406719","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/i-can-tolerate-anything-except-the-outgroup-d9d0234e176f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/i-can-tolerate-anything-except-the-outgroup-d9d0234e176f/"},{"slug":"nixos-purely-functional-linux-distribution-d9d0234969b3","title":"NixOS – Purely Functional Linux Distribution","domain":"nixos.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2018-11","inductedMonth":"2018-11","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":10.664,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":292,"evidenceRank":176,"evidenceScore":80.8,"freshAt":"2024-01-14T22:27:47Z","freshnessRank":459,"freshEventScore":96,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 292 pts / 135 comments (2018) + 231 pts / 100 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,238 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5717533","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":88,"peak_comments":34,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7667123","height":4,"chart_height":51},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":231,"peak_comments":100,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9708282","height":11,"chart_height":134},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15695559","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":292,"peak_comments":135,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18363522","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24553091","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":229,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25718098","height":11,"chart_height":133},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33785770","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":96,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38995068","height":5,"chart_height":56},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/nixos-purely-functional-linux-distribution-d9d0234969b3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/nixos-purely-functional-linux-distribution-d9d0234969b3/"},{"slug":"h-264-is-magic-d9d0235528f1","title":"H.264 is Magic","domain":"sidbala.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["computer_graphics","algorithms_data_structures","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-05","inductedMonth":"2022-03","submissions":9,"submitters":8,"spanYears":7.608,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":1228,"evidenceRank":177,"evidenceScore":80.7,"freshAt":"2024-06-14T14:35:21Z","freshnessRank":378,"freshEventScore":333,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1228 pts / 219 comments (2016) + 714 pts / 219 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,959 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1228,"peak_comments":219,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12871403","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17101627","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":680,"peak_comments":180,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19997813","height":24,"chart_height":94},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25784424","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":714,"peak_comments":219,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30710574","height":24,"chart_height":99},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38218551","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":333,"peak_comments":205,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40681306","height":16,"chart_height":46},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/h-264-is-magic-d9d0235528f1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/h-264-is-magic-d9d0235528f1/"},{"slug":"json5-json-for-humans-d9d0234c279f","title":"JSON5 – JSON for Humans","domain":"json5.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"standard_specification","typeDisplay":"Standards & specifications","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","web_development","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2021-09","inductedMonth":"2021-09","submissions":12,"submitters":11,"spanYears":10.773,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":364,"evidenceRank":178,"evidenceScore":80.7,"freshAt":"2024-12-08T21:29:05Z","freshnessRank":287,"freshEventScore":364,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 364 pts / 344 comments (2024) + 143 pts / 246 comments (2014), different submitters and 3,935 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":143,"peak_comments":246,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7325735","height":7,"chart_height":67},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10956943","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13628330","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17375850","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18934935","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23627602","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":100,"peak_comments":150,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28668282","height":5,"chart_height":47},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":364,"peak_comments":344,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42360681","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/json5-json-for-humans-d9d0234c279f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/json5-json-for-humans-d9d0234c279f/"},{"slug":"electron-band-structure-in-germanium-my-ass-2001-d9d0234319ff","title":"Electron band structure in germanium, my ass (2001)","domain":"pages.cs.wisc.edu","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2020-05","inductedMonth":"2022-03","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":13.911,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":903,"evidenceRank":179,"evidenceScore":80.7,"freshAt":"2025-04-01T12:25:12Z","freshnessRank":231,"freshEventScore":903,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 903 pts / 407 comments (2025) + 316 pts / 97 comments (2011), different submitters and 5,081 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":316,"peak_comments":97,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2513293","height":15,"chart_height":59},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":163,"peak_comments":38,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16360479","height":8,"chart_height":31},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23321966","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30690075","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":461,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37026780","height":22,"chart_height":87},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42078400","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":903,"peak_comments":407,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43545917","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/electron-band-structure-in-germanium-my-ass-2001-d9d0234319ff.jpg","path":"/hall/link/electron-band-structure-in-germanium-my-ass-2001-d9d0234319ff/"},{"slug":"the-xy-problem-2014-d9d02350fbce","title":"The XY Problem (2014)","domain":"xyproblem.info","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","workplace"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-06","inductedMonth":"2019-06","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":10.327,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":319,"evidenceRank":180,"evidenceScore":80.7,"freshAt":"2025-12-04T12:08:34Z","freshnessRank":105,"freshEventScore":35,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 319 pts / 158 comments (2019) + 120 pts / 95 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,453 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":68,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10023882","height":4,"chart_height":36},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12946273","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15653954","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":319,"peak_comments":158,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20068686","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24832169","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":96,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27061704","height":5,"chart_height":51},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33877163","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":120,"peak_comments":95,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36068243","height":6,"chart_height":64},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":35,"peak_comments":20,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46146729","height":4,"chart_height":19},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-xy-problem-2014-d9d02350fbce.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-xy-problem-2014-d9d02350fbce/"},{"slug":"boltzmann-brain-d9d023415ce3","title":"Boltzmann Brain","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["physics","philosophy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2024-12","inductedMonth":"2024-12","submissions":17,"submitters":17,"spanYears":15.598,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":238,"evidenceRank":181,"evidenceScore":80.6,"freshAt":"2024-12-10T05:22:50Z","freshnessRank":286,"freshEventScore":148,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 148 pts / 150 comments (2024) + 238 pts / 149 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,788 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1568141","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":59,"peak_comments":18,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6999074","height":4,"chart_height":42},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":58,"peak_comments":17,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12152658","height":4,"chart_height":41},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17559966","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":238,"peak_comments":149,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22079253","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27775602","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31861080","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34590288","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":148,"peak_comments":150,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42374027","height":7,"chart_height":106},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47296059","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/boltzmann-brain-d9d023415ce3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/boltzmann-brain-d9d023415ce3/"},{"slug":"diamonds-suck-2006-d9d0234b6134","title":"Diamonds Suck (2006)","domain":"diamondssuck.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["markets","finance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2018-05","inductedMonth":"2021-04","submissions":11,"submitters":6,"spanYears":12.405,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":1336,"evidenceRank":182,"evidenceScore":80.6,"freshAt":"2023-11-13T05:32:47Z","freshnessRank":498,"freshEventScore":233,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1336 pts / 576 comments (2016) + 233 pts / 163 comments (2023), different submitters and 2,555 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6868968","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":1336,"peak_comments":576,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12944464","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":392,"peak_comments":215,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17186457","height":19,"chart_height":50},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21659098","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":51,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26698511","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34146663","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":233,"peak_comments":163,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38247300","height":11,"chart_height":30},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48023738","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/diamonds-suck-2006-d9d0234b6134.jpg","path":"/hall/link/diamonds-suck-2006-d9d0234b6134/"},{"slug":"the-5000-compression-challenge-d9d02342a949","title":"The $5000 Compression Challenge","domain":"www.patrickcraig.co.uk","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["algorithms_data_structures"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2015-03","inductedMonth":"2021-03","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":13.725,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":323,"evidenceRank":183,"evidenceScore":80.6,"freshAt":"2024-11-23T21:10:03Z","freshnessRank":294,"freshEventScore":181,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 181 pts / 185 comments (2024) + 323 pts / 168 comments (2015), different submitters and 3,548 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2288098","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":104,"peak_comments":119,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4616704","height":5,"chart_height":55},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":42,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5025211","height":4,"chart_height":22},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":323,"peak_comments":168,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9163782","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26341865","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34434616","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":181,"peak_comments":185,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42223905","height":9,"chart_height":95},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-5000-compression-challenge-d9d02342a949.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-5000-compression-challenge-d9d02342a949/"},{"slug":"how-automakers-invented-the-crime-of-jaywalking-d9d0234f0414","title":"How Automakers Invented the Crime of “Jaywalking”","domain":"www.vox.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["history","cities_infrastructure"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-01","inductedMonth":"2018-08","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":11.379,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":429,"evidenceRank":184,"evidenceScore":80.6,"freshAt":"2023-10-12T17:05:03Z","freshnessRank":523,"freshEventScore":368,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 429 pts / 424 comments (2018) + 368 pts / 312 comments (2023), different submitters and 2,095 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":187,"peak_comments":189,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8893738","height":9,"chart_height":74},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11748787","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14243086","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":429,"peak_comments":424,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16158918","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20961800","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28932340","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":368,"peak_comments":312,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37859905","height":18,"chart_height":146},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48370488","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-automakers-invented-the-crime-of-jaywalking-d9d0234f0414.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-automakers-invented-the-crime-of-jaywalking-d9d0234f0414/"},{"slug":"essential-c-2003-pdf-d9d02342501f","title":"Essential C (2003) [pdf]","domain":"cslibrary.stanford.edu","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2016-05","inductedMonth":"2018-12","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":13.689,"breakoutYears":6,"maxScore":291,"evidenceRank":185,"evidenceScore":80.6,"freshAt":"2022-03-05T10:08:04Z","freshnessRank":815,"freshEventScore":173,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 285 pts / 146 comments (2018) + 228 pts / 89 comments (2016), different submitters and 963 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2106605","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":222,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4371951","height":11,"chart_height":130},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":228,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11671985","height":11,"chart_height":133},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":291,"peak_comments":55,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15480033","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":285,"peak_comments":146,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18790421","height":14,"chart_height":166},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":183,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24356246","height":9,"chart_height":107},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":173,"peak_comments":76,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30566118","height":8,"chart_height":101},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41631183","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/essential-c-2003-pdf-d9d02342501f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/essential-c-2003-pdf-d9d02342501f/"},{"slug":"darling-run-mac-apps-on-linux-d9d02354c5bc","title":"Darling – Run Mac apps on Linux","domain":"www.darlinghq.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","open_source","computer_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-04","inductedMonth":"2022-01","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":7.17,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":652,"evidenceRank":186,"evidenceScore":80.5,"freshAt":"2023-11-26T17:52:46Z","freshnessRank":490,"freshEventScore":466,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 630 pts / 265 comments (2016) + 652 pts / 200 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,890 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":630,"peak_comments":265,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12854895","height":24,"chart_height":164},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":300,"peak_comments":174,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19772322","height":14,"chart_height":78},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":614,"peak_comments":199,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24683669","height":24,"chart_height":160},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":652,"peak_comments":200,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29813679","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":466,"peak_comments":125,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38423469","height":22,"chart_height":122},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/darling-run-mac-apps-on-linux-d9d02354c5bc.jpg","path":"/hall/link/darling-run-mac-apps-on-linux-d9d02354c5bc/"},{"slug":"haiku-project-d9d0233eb40d","title":"Haiku Project","domain":"www.haiku-os.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2016-09","inductedMonth":"2016-09","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":17.843,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":255,"evidenceRank":187,"evidenceScore":80.5,"freshAt":"2026-05-13T16:22:10Z","freshnessRank":18,"freshEventScore":175,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 255 pts / 143 comments (2016) + 101 pts / 110 comments (2013), different submitters and 1,255 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=241796","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1294229","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2325045","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":110,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5564766","height":5,"chart_height":67},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":86,"peak_comments":27,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9046701","height":4,"chart_height":57},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":255,"peak_comments":143,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12566056","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":147,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15973918","height":7,"chart_height":98},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24896178","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":175,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48124002","height":8,"chart_height":117}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/haiku-project-d9d0233eb40d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/haiku-project-d9d0233eb40d/"},{"slug":"how-not-to-die-2007-d9d0233e272e","title":"How Not to Die (2007)","domain":"www.paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["startups_entrepreneurship"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2007,"candidateMonth":"2012-03","inductedMonth":"2019-11","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":18.765,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":428,"evidenceRank":188,"evidenceScore":80.4,"freshAt":"2019-11-11T14:03:47Z","freshnessRank":1037,"freshEventScore":428,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 169 pts / 143 comments (2007) + 428 pts / 130 comments (2019), different submitters and 4,455 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":1,"peak_score":169,"peak_comments":143,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48294","height":8,"chart_height":67},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":145,"peak_comments":47,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=769163","height":7,"chart_height":58},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3708725","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":80,"peak_comments":30,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10009262","height":4,"chart_height":32},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12449789","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":428,"peak_comments":130,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21504862","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24198421","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39115807","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48416417","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-not-to-die-2007-d9d0233e272e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-not-to-die-2007-d9d0233e272e/"},{"slug":"visual-and-interactive-way-to-learn-git-d9d023543de4","title":"Visual and interactive way to learn Git","domain":"learngitbranching.js.org","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source","human_computer_interaction"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-09","inductedMonth":"2024-09","submissions":14,"submitters":13,"spanYears":8.137,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":342,"evidenceRank":189,"evidenceScore":80.4,"freshAt":"2024-09-15T11:14:41Z","freshnessRank":333,"freshEventScore":259,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 259 pts / 133 comments (2024) + 342 pts / 66 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,451 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13153516","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13451124","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":300,"peak_comments":27,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18504948","height":14,"chart_height":149},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":342,"peak_comments":66,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24586436","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31802048","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38486872","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":259,"peak_comments":133,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41546769","height":12,"chart_height":129},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/visual-and-interactive-way-to-learn-git-d9d023543de4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/visual-and-interactive-way-to-learn-git-d9d023543de4/"},{"slug":"programmers-before-you-turn-40-get-a-plan-b-2009-d9d0233fa045","title":"Programmers: Before you turn 40, get a plan B (2009)","domain":"improvingsoftware.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["careers"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2015-04","inductedMonth":"2019-07","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":14.779,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":452,"evidenceRank":190,"evidenceScore":80.3,"freshAt":"2019-08-02T12:11:44Z","freshnessRank":1052,"freshEventScore":452,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 452 pts / 430 comments (2019) + 351 pts / 289 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,573 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":110,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=650437","height":5,"chart_height":41},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7752683","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":351,"peak_comments":289,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9361580","height":17,"chart_height":132},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":107,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16934500","height":5,"chart_height":40},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":452,"peak_comments":430,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20592384","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26312500","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39774933","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/programmers-before-you-turn-40-get-a-plan-b-2009-d9d0233fa045/"},{"slug":"cello-higher-level-programming-in-c-d9d023495274","title":"Cello: Higher level programming in C","domain":"libcello.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-06","inductedMonth":"2017-04","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":11.389,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":535,"evidenceRank":191,"evidenceScore":80.3,"freshAt":"2024-09-26T20:42:11Z","freshnessRank":327,"freshEventScore":57,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 535 pts / 157 comments (2013) + 348 pts / 151 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,366 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":535,"peak_comments":157,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6047576","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":291,"peak_comments":65,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8799070","height":14,"chart_height":92},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11912427","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":348,"peak_comments":151,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14091630","height":17,"chart_height":111},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":251,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22102533","height":12,"chart_height":80},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":162,"peak_comments":85,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30564292","height":8,"chart_height":51},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":57,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41663129","height":4,"chart_height":18},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/cello-higher-level-programming-in-c-d9d023495274.jpg","path":"/hall/link/cello-higher-level-programming-in-c-d9d023495274/"},{"slug":"wtf-happened-in-1971-2019-d9d0235ec33b","title":"WTF Happened in 1971? (2019)","domain":"wtfhappenedin1971.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["economics","finance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-05","inductedMonth":"2023-09","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.768,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":808,"evidenceRank":192,"evidenceScore":80.1,"freshAt":"2025-01-15T15:17:00Z","freshnessRank":267,"freshEventScore":279,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 808 pts / 454 comments (2020) + 279 pts / 268 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,513 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":44,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20811004","height":5,"chart_height":21},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":808,"peak_comments":454,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25188457","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":117,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31471602","height":6,"chart_height":25},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":128,"peak_comments":105,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37482646","height":6,"chart_height":27},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":279,"peak_comments":268,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42711781","height":13,"chart_height":59},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48391692","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/wtf-happened-in-1971-2019-d9d0235ec33b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/wtf-happened-in-1971-2019-d9d0235ec33b/"},{"slug":"regex-101-d9d023481510","title":"Regex 101","domain":"regex101.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","programming_languages","testing_quality"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-11","inductedMonth":"2016-11","submissions":25,"submitters":20,"spanYears":12.668,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":303,"evidenceRank":193,"evidenceScore":80.1,"freshAt":"2018-08-25T16:11:45Z","freshnessRank":1087,"freshEventScore":21,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 303 pts / 67 comments (2016) + 161 pts / 77 comments (2013), different submitters and 1,214 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 25 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":5,"peak_score":161,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6075948","height":8,"chart_height":90},{"year":2014,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8734749","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9581768","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":4,"peak_score":303,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12961333","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":21,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17841356","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24682639","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29418042","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30647267","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37119215","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40827390","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45110914","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/regex-101-d9d023481510.jpg","path":"/hall/link/regex-101-d9d023481510/"},{"slug":"lisp-as-the-maxwell-equations-of-software-2012-d9d02345cba6","title":"Lisp as the Maxwell Equations of Software (2012)","domain":"www.michaelnielsen.org","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","compilers_runtimes"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2015-05","inductedMonth":"2019-08","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":14.242,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":196,"evidenceRank":194,"evidenceScore":80.0,"freshAt":"2022-11-08T06:21:53Z","freshnessRank":692,"freshEventScore":128,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 196 pts / 122 comments (2015) + 179 pts / 37 comments (2012), different submitters and 1,036 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":179,"peak_comments":37,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3830867","height":9,"chart_height":155},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":196,"peak_comments":122,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9038505","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14534010","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20594270","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":117,"peak_comments":46,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23687904","height":6,"chart_height":101},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26036147","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":128,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33516422","height":6,"chart_height":111},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41010798","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48856099","height":4,"chart_height":6}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/lisp-as-the-maxwell-equations-of-software-2012-d9d02345cba6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/lisp-as-the-maxwell-equations-of-software-2012-d9d02345cba6/"},{"slug":"sandstorm-an-open-source-platform-for-personal-servers-d9d0234cf9e6","title":"Sandstorm – An open source platform for personal servers","domain":"sandstorm.io","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["internet_infrastructure","open_source","privacy_surveillance","application_security"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2016-07","inductedMonth":"2023-06","submissions":11,"submitters":10,"spanYears":10.982,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":509,"evidenceRank":195,"evidenceScore":80.0,"freshAt":"2023-06-05T05:41:46Z","freshnessRank":618,"freshEventScore":468,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 509 pts / 184 comments (2015) + 468 pts / 137 comments (2023), different submitters and 3,047 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":3,"peak_score":32,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7961118","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":509,"peak_comments":184,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8972066","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":434,"peak_comments":164,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12104361","height":21,"chart_height":145},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20312655","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22236197","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31664675","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":468,"peak_comments":137,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36192777","height":22,"chart_height":156},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44029073","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/sandstorm-an-open-source-platform-for-personal-servers-d9d0234cf9e6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/sandstorm-an-open-source-platform-for-personal-servers-d9d0234cf9e6/"},{"slug":"noclip-website-a-digital-museum-of-video-game-levels-d9d0235cf23b","title":"Noclip.website – A digital museum of video game levels","domain":"noclip.website","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_history","computer_graphics","game_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-08","inductedMonth":"2023-08","submissions":15,"submitters":15,"spanYears":6.82,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":531,"evidenceRank":196,"evidenceScore":80.0,"freshAt":"2025-12-19T02:20:08Z","freshnessRank":94,"freshEventScore":480,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 531 pts / 96 comments (2023) + 480 pts / 57 comments (2025), different submitters and 863 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":66,"peak_comments":31,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19232022","height":4,"chart_height":21},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25271608","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":369,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27902949","height":18,"chart_height":118},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33927660","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":531,"peak_comments":96,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37043934","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":480,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46321619","height":23,"chart_height":154},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/noclip-website-a-digital-museum-of-video-game-levels-d9d0235cf23b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/noclip-website-a-digital-museum-of-video-game-levels-d9d0235cf23b/"},{"slug":"java-s-cover-april-2001-d9d02340aefa","title":"Java's Cover (April 2001)","domain":"www.paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2012-09","inductedMonth":"2022-06","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":12.991,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":185,"evidenceRank":197,"evidenceScore":79.9,"freshAt":"2022-06-26T17:50:23Z","freshnessRank":761,"freshEventScore":50,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 185 pts / 180 comments (2012) + 50 pts / 123 comments (2022), different submitters and 3,575 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":3,"peak_score":32,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2004512","height":4,"chart_height":29},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":185,"peak_comments":180,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4504375","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5622926","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":21,"peak_comments":40,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10761400","height":4,"chart_height":19},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18202505","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":21,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21558053","height":4,"chart_height":17},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":50,"peak_comments":123,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31886130","height":4,"chart_height":46},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35064553","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/java-s-cover-april-2001-d9d02340aefa.jpg","path":"/hall/link/java-s-cover-april-2001-d9d02340aefa/"},{"slug":"the-fuck-correct-your-previous-console-command-d9d0234fec11","title":"The Fuck – Correct your previous console command","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2017-04","inductedMonth":"2018-10","submissions":15,"submitters":14,"spanYears":8.958,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":438,"evidenceRank":198,"evidenceScore":79.9,"freshAt":"2022-03-18T13:53:56Z","freshnessRank":802,"freshEventScore":42,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 438 pts / 165 comments (2015) + 287 pts / 103 comments (2017), different submitters and 731 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":438,"peak_comments":165,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9396116","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10842035","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":287,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14133647","height":14,"chart_height":111},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":112,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18249686","height":5,"chart_height":43},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22411272","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29607133","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":42,"peak_comments":18,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30722254","height":4,"chart_height":16},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36414269","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39893334","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-fuck-correct-your-previous-console-command-d9d0234fec11.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-fuck-correct-your-previous-console-command-d9d0234fec11/"},{"slug":"learn-c-and-build-your-own-lisp-d9d0234c811f","title":"Learn C and build your own Lisp","domain":"www.buildyourownlisp.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","compilers_runtimes","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2017-02","inductedMonth":"2021-06","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":11.337,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":641,"evidenceRank":199,"evidenceScore":79.9,"freshAt":"2025-08-05T11:55:20Z","freshnessRank":175,"freshEventScore":271,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 641 pts / 145 comments (2014) + 271 pts / 75 comments (2025), different submitters and 4,141 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":641,"peak_comments":145,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7530427","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":320,"peak_comments":49,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10474717","height":15,"chart_height":85},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13647330","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18468728","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":231,"peak_comments":86,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27598424","height":11,"chart_height":61},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40865870","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":271,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44796953","height":13,"chart_height":72},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/learn-c-and-build-your-own-lisp-d9d0234c811f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/learn-c-and-build-your-own-lisp-d9d0234c811f/"},{"slug":"xerox-scanners-and-photocopiers-randomly-alter-numbers-in-scanne-d9d0234a294a","title":"Xerox scanners and photocopiers randomly alter numbers in scanned documents","domain":"www.dkriesel.com","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"technical_report","typeDisplay":"Technical reports","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["performance_reliability","security_incidents","electronics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2015-09","inductedMonth":"2021-11","submissions":14,"submitters":14,"spanYears":12.66,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":570,"evidenceRank":200,"evidenceScore":79.9,"freshAt":"2021-11-15T04:47:03Z","freshnessRank":855,"freshEventScore":486,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 570 pts / 112 comments (2013) + 486 pts / 184 comments (2021), different submitters and 3,024 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":570,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6156238","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":159,"peak_comments":22,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9584172","height":8,"chart_height":47},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12842941","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22369240","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":486,"peak_comments":184,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29223815","height":23,"chart_height":145},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44309044","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47591428","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/xerox-scanners-and-photocopiers-randomly-alter-numbers-in-scanne-d9d0234a294a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/xerox-scanners-and-photocopiers-randomly-alter-numbers-in-scanne-d9d0234a294a/"},{"slug":"falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-addresses-d9d023498b69","title":"Falsehoods programmers believe about addresses","domain":"www.mjt.me.uk","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["databases_storage"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-06","inductedMonth":"2020-10","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":12.786,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":206,"evidenceRank":201,"evidenceScore":79.9,"freshAt":"2020-10-29T02:25:46Z","freshnessRank":978,"freshEventScore":60,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 206 pts / 147 comments (2015) + 60 pts / 62 comments (2020), different submitters and 2,110 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":144,"peak_comments":128,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5791489","height":7,"chart_height":119},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":206,"peak_comments":147,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8907301","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12261311","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18035745","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20093623","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":60,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24926417","height":4,"chart_height":50},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41416871","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47363085","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-addresses-d9d023498b69.jpg","path":"/hall/link/falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-addresses-d9d023498b69/"},{"slug":"terrain-rendering-in-fewer-than-20-lines-of-code-d9d0235840ec","title":"Terrain rendering in fewer than 20 lines of code","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["computer_graphics","algorithms_data_structures","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-01","inductedMonth":"2021-03","submissions":9,"submitters":8,"spanYears":7.272,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":793,"evidenceRank":202,"evidenceScore":79.8,"freshAt":"2025-01-03T20:01:29Z","freshnessRank":271,"freshEventScore":339,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 793 pts / 93 comments (2017) + 720 pts / 116 comments (2020), different submitters and 769 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":793,"peak_comments":93,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15772065","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":720,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21944573","height":24,"chart_height":154},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":366,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26631995","height":18,"chart_height":78},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33824145","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38051859","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":339,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42588956","height":16,"chart_height":73},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/terrain-rendering-in-fewer-than-20-lines-of-code-d9d0235840ec.jpg","path":"/hall/link/terrain-rendering-in-fewer-than-20-lines-of-code-d9d0235840ec/"},{"slug":"i-hate-the-news-2006-d9d023482e3e","title":"I Hate the News (2006)","domain":"www.aaronsw.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["journalism_media","politics_government"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2015-03","inductedMonth":"2018-03","submissions":14,"submitters":14,"spanYears":12.151,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":222,"evidenceRank":203,"evidenceScore":79.7,"freshAt":"2023-07-04T22:20:30Z","freshnessRank":598,"freshEventScore":115,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 222 pts / 187 comments (2015) + 213 pts / 74 comments (2013), different submitters and 793 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":213,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5051902","height":10,"chart_height":163},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":222,"peak_comments":187,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9224858","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15181042","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":98,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16684881","height":5,"chart_height":75},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25384242","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29262060","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":115,"peak_comments":93,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36593249","height":6,"chart_height":88},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41811327","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43211977","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/i-hate-the-news-2006-d9d023482e3e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/i-hate-the-news-2006-d9d023482e3e/"},{"slug":"path-to-a-free-self-taught-education-in-computer-science-d9d023590c71","title":"Path to a free, self-taught education in Computer Science","domain":"github.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"course_lecture","typeDisplay":"Courses & lectures","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["learning_methods","teaching","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-03","inductedMonth":"2021-07","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":7.422,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":691,"evidenceRank":204,"evidenceScore":79.7,"freshAt":"2025-05-25T17:06:55Z","freshnessRank":207,"freshEventScore":534,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 691 pts / 199 comments (2023) + 534 pts / 162 comments (2025), different submitters and 839 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":264,"peak_comments":66,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16035839","height":13,"chart_height":65},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":474,"peak_comments":172,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21062799","height":23,"chart_height":117},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":322,"peak_comments":149,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27744255","height":15,"chart_height":79},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":691,"peak_comments":199,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34673581","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":534,"peak_comments":162,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44089150","height":24,"chart_height":131},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/path-to-a-free-self-taught-education-in-computer-science-d9d023590c71.jpg","path":"/hall/link/path-to-a-free-self-taught-education-in-computer-science-d9d023590c71/"},{"slug":"mining-bitcoin-with-pencil-and-paper-0-67-hashes-per-day-d9d0234e0f10","title":"Mining Bitcoin with pencil and paper: 0.67 hashes per day","domain":"www.righto.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography","finance","computer_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2017-12","inductedMonth":"2017-12","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":10.067,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":653,"evidenceRank":205,"evidenceScore":79.5,"freshAt":"2021-02-15T19:12:51Z","freshnessRank":942,"freshEventScore":404,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 404 pts / 378 comments (2021) + 653 pts / 103 comments (2014), different submitters and 2,332 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":653,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8380110","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9596444","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12173402","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":642,"peak_comments":156,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15950599","height":24,"chart_height":167},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":404,"peak_comments":378,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26146026","height":19,"chart_height":105},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41916574","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/mining-bitcoin-with-pencil-and-paper-0-67-hashes-per-day-d9d0234e0f10.jpg","path":"/hall/link/mining-bitcoin-with-pencil-and-paper-0-67-hashes-per-day-d9d0234e0f10/"},{"slug":"linux-performance-d9d0234cf9b9","title":"Linux Performance","domain":"www.brendangregg.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["performance_reliability","operating_systems","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2017-01","inductedMonth":"2017-01","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":11.666,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":536,"evidenceRank":206,"evidenceScore":79.5,"freshAt":"2023-10-14T11:32:16Z","freshnessRank":519,"freshEventScore":355,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 536 pts / 64 comments (2017) + 355 pts / 58 comments (2023), different submitters and 2,451 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":186,"peak_comments":22,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8205057","height":9,"chart_height":59},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11305382","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":536,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13498485","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18423275","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28672412","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":355,"peak_comments":58,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37879706","height":17,"chart_height":113},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45871103","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46745937","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/linux-performance-d9d0234cf9b9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/linux-performance-d9d0234cf9b9/"},{"slug":"kernighan-s-law-you-are-not-smart-enough-to-debug-it-d9d0235dba0f","title":"Kernighan's Law: You are not smart enough to debug it","domain":"github.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","programming_languages","leadership"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-01","inductedMonth":"2022-01","submissions":36,"submitters":12,"spanYears":5.76,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":289,"evidenceRank":207,"evidenceScore":79.4,"freshAt":"2022-01-01T17:26:27Z","freshnessRank":839,"freshEventScore":270,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 177 pts / 102 comments (2019) + 270 pts / 44 comments (2022), different submitters and 963 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 36 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":18,"peak_score":203,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21601996","height":10,"chart_height":119},{"year":2020,"count":10,"peak_score":289,"peak_comments":153,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22348386","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28715245","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":270,"peak_comments":44,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29760511","height":13,"chart_height":159},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37365756","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40944444","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43058979","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/kernighan-s-law-you-are-not-smart-enough-to-debug-it-d9d0235dba0f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/kernighan-s-law-you-are-not-smart-enough-to-debug-it-d9d0235dba0f/"},{"slug":"immersive-linear-algebra-2016-d9d02351403a","title":"Immersive Linear Algebra (2016)","domain":"immersivemath.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","teaching"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-10","inductedMonth":"2021-02","submissions":8,"submitters":6,"spanYears":8.674,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":1269,"evidenceRank":208,"evidenceScore":79.4,"freshAt":"2024-05-11T17:16:08Z","freshnessRank":399,"freshEventScore":876,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1269 pts / 140 comments (2019) + 876 pts / 71 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,900 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":434,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10183725","height":21,"chart_height":58},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1015,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13904881","height":24,"chart_height":136},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18288500","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1269,"peak_comments":140,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19264048","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":80,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26294588","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34091375","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":876,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40329388","height":24,"chart_height":117},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/immersive-linear-algebra-2016-d9d02351403a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/immersive-linear-algebra-2016-d9d02351403a/"},{"slug":"git-koans-d9d023490a32","title":"Git koans","domain":"stevelosh.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2017-01","inductedMonth":"2020-08","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":13.29,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":305,"evidenceRank":209,"evidenceScore":79.4,"freshAt":"2020-12-23T03:59:52Z","freshnessRank":962,"freshEventScore":197,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 305 pts / 141 comments (2013) + 197 pts / 65 comments (2020), different submitters and 2,815 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":305,"peak_comments":141,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5511863","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":6,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9926330","height":5,"chart_height":56},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":194,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13379572","height":9,"chart_height":108},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17572734","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":197,"peak_comments":65,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25514238","height":9,"chart_height":110},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32642315","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37742176","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44253092","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49017399","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/git-koans-d9d023490a32.jpg","path":"/hall/link/git-koans-d9d023490a32/"},{"slug":"simpson-s-paradox-d9d0233fc7eb","title":"Simpson's paradox","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","data_science","scientific_method"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2024-03","inductedMonth":"2024-03","submissions":28,"submitters":28,"spanYears":16.767,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":365,"evidenceRank":210,"evidenceScore":79.2,"freshAt":"2024-03-11T22:02:53Z","freshnessRank":430,"freshEventScore":365,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 365 pts / 106 comments (2024) + 152 pts / 17 comments (2009), different submitters and 5,309 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 28 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 28 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":2,"peak_score":152,"peak_comments":17,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=791821","height":7,"chart_height":71},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7186870","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":6,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10031257","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16007052","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17728930","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21337922","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":6,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22532808","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26856747","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30230206","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":365,"peak_comments":106,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39673754","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45119876","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48002240","height":4,"chart_height":5}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/simpson-s-paradox-d9d0233fc7eb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/simpson-s-paradox-d9d0233fc7eb/"},{"slug":"the-egg-d9d023413bd9","title":"The Egg","domain":"www.galactanet.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["books_literature","philosophy","religion"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2018-05","inductedMonth":"2018-05","submissions":35,"submitters":25,"spanYears":15.759,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":450,"evidenceRank":211,"evidenceScore":79.2,"freshAt":"2018-05-24T16:45:22Z","freshnessRank":1096,"freshEventScore":223,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 450 pts / 153 comments (2014) + 223 pts / 51 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,565 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 35 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 25 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":80,"peak_comments":20,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1489497","height":4,"chart_height":30},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2986498","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4541303","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6524488","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":450,"peak_comments":153,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7203095","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9274311","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13209427","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15726296","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":223,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17145811","height":11,"chart_height":84},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20855792","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25568632","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28415159","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":5,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31329077","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37441192","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42080701","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":4,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47699337","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-egg-d9d023413bd9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-egg-d9d023413bd9/"},{"slug":"cyberchef-a-cyber-swiss-army-knife-d9d023556044","title":"CyberChef – A Cyber Swiss Army Knife","domain":"gchq.github.io","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography","application_security","data_engineering"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-08","inductedMonth":"2021-04","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":7.176,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":785,"evidenceRank":212,"evidenceScore":79.2,"freshAt":"2024-02-01T19:01:45Z","freshnessRank":450,"freshEventScore":174,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 785 pts / 139 comments (2016) + 394 pts / 59 comments (2019), different submitters and 996 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":785,"peak_comments":139,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13056254","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":394,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20767183","height":19,"chart_height":85},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26855824","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":392,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29982286","height":19,"chart_height":85},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37272738","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":174,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39219761","height":8,"chart_height":38},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/cyberchef-a-cyber-swiss-army-knife-d9d023556044.jpg","path":"/hall/link/cyberchef-a-cyber-swiss-army-knife-d9d023556044/"},{"slug":"johnny-decimal-d9d0235c787b","title":"Johnny.Decimal","domain":"johnnydecimal.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["personal_productivity","management_strategy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-09","inductedMonth":"2023-09","submissions":15,"submitters":12,"spanYears":7.411,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":578,"evidenceRank":213,"evidenceScore":79.2,"freshAt":"2025-02-21T14:52:14Z","freshnessRank":246,"freshEventScore":578,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 578 pts / 291 comments (2025) + 531 pts / 187 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,532 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18838446","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":531,"peak_comments":187,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25398027","height":24,"chart_height":156},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":4,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32314170","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":4,"peak_score":124,"peak_comments":118,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37506640","height":6,"chart_height":36},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":578,"peak_comments":291,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43128093","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48231958","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/johnny-decimal-d9d0235c787b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/johnny-decimal-d9d0235c787b/"},{"slug":"the-lonely-work-of-moderating-hacker-news-d9d0235e92eb","title":"The Lonely Work of Moderating Hacker News","domain":"www.newyorker.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["online_communities","journalism_media","technology_ethics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-02","inductedMonth":"2025-03","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":6.864,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":1663,"evidenceRank":214,"evidenceScore":79.2,"freshAt":"2025-04-02T21:25:23Z","freshnessRank":230,"freshEventScore":20,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1663 pts / 777 comments (2019) + 292 pts / 245 comments (2022), different submitters and 924 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1663,"peak_comments":777,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20643052","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":615,"peak_comments":291,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25048415","height":24,"chart_height":63},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":292,"peak_comments":245,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30374040","height":14,"chart_height":30},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":225,"peak_comments":244,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36911923","height":11,"chart_height":23},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":20,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43561809","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48595482","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-lonely-work-of-moderating-hacker-news-d9d0235e92eb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-lonely-work-of-moderating-hacker-news-d9d0235e92eb/"},{"slug":"monty-hall-problem-d9d023409872","title":"Monty Hall Problem","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2022-06","inductedMonth":"2022-06","submissions":15,"submitters":15,"spanYears":13.689,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":122,"evidenceRank":215,"evidenceScore":79.1,"freshAt":"2022-06-09T17:06:34Z","freshnessRank":767,"freshEventScore":24,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 122 pts / 251 comments (2019) + 24 pts / 116 comments (2022), different submitters and 958 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":27,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1142405","height":4,"chart_height":20},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3242067","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5042646","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10452708","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11931682","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18502223","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":122,"peak_comments":251,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21348476","height":6,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28779322","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":24,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31683850","height":4,"chart_height":33},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38094994","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/monty-hall-problem-d9d023409872.jpg","path":"/hall/link/monty-hall-problem-d9d023409872/"},{"slug":"hacker-s-guide-to-neural-networks-d9d0234d9636","title":"Hacker's Guide to Neural Networks","domain":"karpathy.github.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["artificial_intelligence","machine_learning","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2017-07","inductedMonth":"2017-07","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":9.591,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":450,"evidenceRank":216,"evidenceScore":79.1,"freshAt":"2019-01-06T21:13:43Z","freshnessRank":1071,"freshEventScore":383,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 450 pts / 34 comments (2014) + 424 pts / 39 comments (2017), different submitters and 983 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":450,"peak_comments":34,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8553307","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":236,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9249924","height":11,"chart_height":89},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12095825","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":424,"peak_comments":39,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14769525","height":20,"chart_height":160},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":383,"peak_comments":24,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18840747","height":18,"chart_height":145},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22901855","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39641154","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/hacker-s-guide-to-neural-networks-d9d0234d9636.jpg","path":"/hall/link/hacker-s-guide-to-neural-networks-d9d0234d9636/"},{"slug":"reasons-not-to-use-i-e-be-used-by-facebook-d9d02345c058","title":"Reasons not to use (i.e., be used by) Facebook","domain":"stallman.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["privacy_surveillance","social_issues","technology_ethics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2015-03","inductedMonth":"2018-03","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":12.389,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":670,"evidenceRank":217,"evidenceScore":79.0,"freshAt":"2018-03-26T22:16:54Z","freshnessRank":1104,"freshEventScore":188,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 670 pts / 353 comments (2016) + 317 pts / 145 comments (2013), different submitters and 940 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3809965","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":317,"peak_comments":145,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6816072","height":15,"chart_height":80},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":605,"peak_comments":362,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9201644","height":24,"chart_height":154},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":670,"peak_comments":353,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11981496","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":188,"peak_comments":29,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16683147","height":9,"chart_height":48},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23438742","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41366758","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/reasons-not-to-use-i-e-be-used-by-facebook-d9d02345c058.jpg","path":"/hall/link/reasons-not-to-use-i-e-be-used-by-facebook-d9d02345c058/"},{"slug":"what-rr-does-d9d0234c607e","title":"What rr does","domain":"rr-project.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","testing_quality","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2022-06","inductedMonth":"2022-06","submissions":14,"submitters":14,"spanYears":10.327,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":880,"evidenceRank":218,"evidenceScore":79.0,"freshAt":"2024-07-21T08:54:13Z","freshnessRank":361,"freshEventScore":402,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 880 pts / 81 comments (2022) + 402 pts / 131 comments (2024), different submitters and 778 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7458554","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9569606","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":33,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14716008","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":274,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18388879","height":13,"chart_height":53},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":5,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24810060","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":880,"peak_comments":81,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31617600","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":402,"peak_comments":131,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41023547","height":19,"chart_height":78},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-rr-does-d9d0234c607e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-rr-does-d9d0234c607e/"},{"slug":"return-of-the-mac-2005-d9d0233e199c","title":"Return of the Mac (2005)","domain":"www.paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2007,"candidateMonth":"2016-11","inductedMonth":"2019-04","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":15.294,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":121,"evidenceRank":219,"evidenceScore":79.0,"freshAt":"2021-07-04T10:14:50Z","freshnessRank":894,"freshEventScore":100,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 121 pts / 191 comments (2016) + 100 pts / 181 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,705 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":1,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":15,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32301","height":4,"chart_height":22},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":40,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1186066","height":4,"chart_height":22},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":92,"peak_comments":108,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2858356","height":4,"chart_height":129},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":121,"peak_comments":191,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12850247","height":6,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19653868","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23621649","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":100,"peak_comments":181,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27728550","height":5,"chart_height":140},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33246249","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/return-of-the-mac-2005-d9d0233e199c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/return-of-the-mac-2005-d9d0233e199c/"},{"slug":"standard-ebooks-d9d02357515e","title":"Standard Ebooks","domain":"standardebooks.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["books_literature","digital_archives","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2019-08","inductedMonth":"2022-07","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.543,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":1578,"evidenceRank":220,"evidenceScore":78.9,"freshAt":"2024-01-01T11:51:35Z","freshnessRank":470,"freshEventScore":701,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1578 pts / 256 comments (2022) + 820 pts / 129 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,086 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":441,"peak_comments":96,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14570035","height":21,"chart_height":48},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":820,"peak_comments":129,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20594802","height":24,"chart_height":88},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":639,"peak_comments":106,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25138534","height":24,"chart_height":69},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1578,"peak_comments":256,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32215324","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":701,"peak_comments":153,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38831219","height":24,"chart_height":76},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/standard-ebooks-d9d02357515e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/standard-ebooks-d9d02357515e/"},{"slug":"speed-matters-why-working-quickly-is-more-important-than-it-seem-d9d02350e10c","title":"Speed matters: Why working quickly is more important than it seems","domain":"jsomers.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["personal_productivity","workplace"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-08","inductedMonth":"2023-03","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":10.385,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":513,"evidenceRank":221,"evidenceScore":78.9,"freshAt":"2025-12-15T05:54:28Z","freshnessRank":97,"freshEventScore":268,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 513 pts / 183 comments (2023) + 453 pts / 171 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,408 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":348,"peak_comments":139,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10020827","height":17,"chart_height":115},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":453,"peak_comments":171,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20611539","height":22,"chart_height":150},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30180680","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":513,"peak_comments":183,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36312295","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":268,"peak_comments":127,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46270918","height":13,"chart_height":89},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/speed-matters-why-working-quickly-is-more-important-than-it-seem-d9d02350e10c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/speed-matters-why-working-quickly-is-more-important-than-it-seem-d9d02350e10c/"},{"slug":"flexbox-froggy-d9d023520521","title":"Flexbox Froggy","domain":"flexboxfroggy.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"computer_game","typeDisplay":"Computer games","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["learning_methods","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2022-02","inductedMonth":"2022-02","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":9.177,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":499,"evidenceRank":222,"evidenceScore":78.9,"freshAt":"2023-09-30T08:05:12Z","freshnessRank":533,"freshEventScore":499,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 499 pts / 68 comments (2023) + 315 pts / 69 comments (2015), different submitters and 2,860 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":315,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10652909","height":15,"chart_height":107},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15605783","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18731852","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21796926","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":27,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22629903","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":317,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30251054","height":15,"chart_height":108},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":499,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37713530","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42921740","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/flexbox-froggy-d9d023520521.jpg","path":"/hall/link/flexbox-froggy-d9d023520521/"},{"slug":"get-started-making-music-d9d02356f274","title":"Get started making music","domain":"learningmusic.ableton.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["music","teaching","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2019-09","inductedMonth":"2019-09","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":6.015,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":2106,"evidenceRank":223,"evidenceScore":78.8,"freshAt":"2023-05-14T06:28:53Z","freshnessRank":629,"freshEventScore":1176,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 2106 pts / 461 comments (2017) + 1176 pts / 243 comments (2023), different submitters and 2,195 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":2106,"peak_comments":461,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14299628","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18773790","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1085,"peak_comments":184,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20965386","height":24,"chart_height":88},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":441,"peak_comments":144,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29055433","height":21,"chart_height":36},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":1176,"peak_comments":243,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35935796","height":24,"chart_height":95},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/get-started-making-music-d9d02356f274.jpg","path":"/hall/link/get-started-making-music-d9d02356f274/"},{"slug":"giving-up-reading-news-will-make-us-happier-d9d0234b6c7b","title":"Giving up reading news will make us happier","domain":"www.theguardian.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["journalism_media","mental_health","personal_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2017-10","inductedMonth":"2018-04","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":12.329,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":486,"evidenceRank":224,"evidenceScore":78.8,"freshAt":"2023-07-05T13:16:53Z","freshnessRank":597,"freshEventScore":267,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 267 pts / 256 comments (2023) + 486 pts / 232 comments (2013), different submitters and 3,491 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":486,"peak_comments":232,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6894244","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":142,"peak_comments":41,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10525902","height":7,"chart_height":50},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15659812","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":369,"peak_comments":192,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16763604","height":18,"chart_height":129},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":267,"peak_comments":256,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36600020","height":13,"chart_height":93},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47728449","height":4,"chart_height":6}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/giving-up-reading-news-will-make-us-happier-d9d0234b6c7b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/giving-up-reading-news-will-make-us-happier-d9d0234b6c7b/"},{"slug":"dear-imgui-bloat-free-graphical-user-interface-library-for-c-d9d0234da274","title":"Dear ImGui – Bloat-free graphical user interface library for C++","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"source_code","typeDisplay":"Source code","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["human_computer_interaction","computer_graphics","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2020-11","inductedMonth":"2020-11","submissions":15,"submitters":12,"spanYears":9.358,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":284,"evidenceRank":225,"evidenceScore":78.7,"freshAt":"2023-12-20T17:01:26Z","freshnessRank":478,"freshEventScore":146,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 284 pts / 180 comments (2020) + 146 pts / 109 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,141 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":134,"peak_comments":41,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8161601","height":6,"chart_height":80},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10728804","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12047758","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14002324","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16193560","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19075115","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":5,"peak_score":284,"peak_comments":180,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24986908","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":146,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38710818","height":7,"chart_height":87},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/dear-imgui-bloat-free-graphical-user-interface-library-for-c-d9d0234da274.jpg","path":"/hall/link/dear-imgui-bloat-free-graphical-user-interface-library-for-c-d9d0234da274/"},{"slug":"overthewire-org-d9d0234f0d05","title":"Overthewire.org","domain":"overthewire.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security","cryptography"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-01","inductedMonth":"2023-08","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":11.143,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":326,"evidenceRank":226,"evidenceScore":78.7,"freshAt":"2023-08-27T11:53:56Z","freshnessRank":559,"freshEventScore":326,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 326 pts / 49 comments (2023) + 172 pts / 23 comments (2018), different submitters and 2,036 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":146,"peak_comments":17,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9878302","height":7,"chart_height":76},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12944148","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15551986","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":172,"peak_comments":23,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16252873","height":8,"chart_height":90},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25416901","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":220,"peak_comments":26,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29724594","height":11,"chart_height":115},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":326,"peak_comments":49,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37281745","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44898853","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47351896","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/overthewire-org-d9d0234f0d05.jpg","path":"/hall/link/overthewire-org-d9d0234f0d05/"},{"slug":"v-programming-language-d9d0235d26ce","title":"V Programming Language","domain":"vlang.io","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","compilers_runtimes","performance_reliability","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2021-12","inductedMonth":"2023-08","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":6.461,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":191,"evidenceRank":227,"evidenceScore":78.6,"freshAt":"2025-08-30T15:40:57Z","freshnessRank":156,"freshEventScore":22,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 85 pts / 229 comments (2023) + 144 pts / 191 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,076 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":191,"peak_comments":181,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19403271","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":144,"peak_comments":191,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24481883","height":7,"chart_height":128},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29727693","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":63,"peak_comments":48,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29799154","height":4,"chart_height":56},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":85,"peak_comments":229,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37291607","height":4,"chart_height":76},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":22,"peak_comments":32,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45075571","height":4,"chart_height":20},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/v-programming-language-d9d0235d26ce.jpg","path":"/hall/link/v-programming-language-d9d0235d26ce/"},{"slug":"introduction-to-the-a-algorithm-2014-d9d0234d72e3","title":"Introduction to the A* Algorithm (2014)","domain":"www.redblobgames.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["algorithms_data_structures","game_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2018-12","inductedMonth":"2018-12","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":10.91,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":509,"evidenceRank":228,"evidenceScore":78.6,"freshAt":"2025-06-17T07:25:23Z","freshnessRank":199,"freshEventScore":288,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 509 pts / 28 comments (2014) + 288 pts / 103 comments (2025), different submitters and 3,985 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":509,"peak_comments":28,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8059237","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10724098","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14456237","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":201,"peak_comments":14,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18642462","height":10,"chart_height":67},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24146045","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":202,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30287733","height":10,"chart_height":67},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41897736","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":288,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44296523","height":14,"chart_height":96},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/introduction-to-the-a-algorithm-2014-d9d0234d72e3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/introduction-to-the-a-algorithm-2014-d9d0234d72e3/"},{"slug":"editorconfig-d9d023472c56","title":"EditorConfig","domain":"editorconfig.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"standard_specification","typeDisplay":"Standards & specifications","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2015-11","inductedMonth":"2019-03","submissions":14,"submitters":14,"spanYears":10.59,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":393,"evidenceRank":229,"evidenceScore":78.6,"freshAt":"2023-04-22T06:08:02Z","freshnessRank":638,"freshEventScore":72,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 393 pts / 216 comments (2019) + 241 pts / 38 comments (2014), different submitters and 1,598 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4539378","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5395340","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":4,"peak_score":241,"peak_comments":38,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8462825","height":12,"chart_height":104},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":235,"peak_comments":46,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10531788","height":11,"chart_height":102},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":164,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14816427","height":8,"chart_height":71},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":393,"peak_comments":216,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19289782","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33238414","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":72,"peak_comments":47,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35663845","height":4,"chart_height":31},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/editorconfig-d9d023472c56.jpg","path":"/hall/link/editorconfig-d9d023472c56/"},{"slug":"moonscript-a-programmer-friendly-language-that-compiles-to-lua-d9d02343ccd4","title":"MoonScript, a programmer friendly language that compiles to Lua","domain":"moonscript.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","compilers_runtimes","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2017-05","inductedMonth":"2017-05","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":14.185,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":391,"evidenceRank":230,"evidenceScore":78.5,"freshAt":"2022-05-29T09:35:08Z","freshnessRank":776,"freshEventScore":26,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 391 pts / 162 comments (2017) + 164 pts / 109 comments (2020), different submitters and 977 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":107,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2871748","height":5,"chart_height":47},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10196831","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13028545","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":391,"peak_comments":162,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14441492","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18827129","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":164,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22209985","height":8,"chart_height":71},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":26,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31547790","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40474563","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45621734","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/moonscript-a-programmer-friendly-language-that-compiles-to-lua-d9d02343ccd4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/moonscript-a-programmer-friendly-language-that-compiles-to-lua-d9d02343ccd4/"},{"slug":"bouba-kiki-effect-d9d0233f3dce","title":"Bouba/kiki effect","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["language_linguistics","psychology","neuroscience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2024-06","inductedMonth":"2024-06","submissions":21,"submitters":21,"spanYears":16.632,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":257,"evidenceRank":231,"evidenceScore":78.5,"freshAt":"2024-06-16T19:50:16Z","freshnessRank":375,"freshEventScore":257,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 257 pts / 170 comments (2024) + 238 pts / 94 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,063 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 21 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 21 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=462353","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5095972","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8372550","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11300717","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15669953","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17638817","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20487246","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22582164","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":238,"peak_comments":94,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27885703","height":11,"chart_height":157},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":4,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36512418","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":257,"peak_comments":170,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40699583","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45320327","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/bouba-kiki-effect-d9d0233f3dce.jpg","path":"/hall/link/bouba-kiki-effect-d9d0233f3dce/"},{"slug":"shouting-in-the-datacenter-2008-video-d9d0233fed72","title":"Shouting in the Datacenter (2008) [video]","domain":"www.youtube.com","category":"media","categoryDisplay":"Audio, video & images","type":"video","typeDisplay":"Video","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["computer_architecture","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2022-08","inductedMonth":"2022-08","submissions":21,"submitters":21,"spanYears":16.75,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":437,"evidenceRank":232,"evidenceScore":78.5,"freshAt":"2022-08-18T18:32:13Z","freshnessRank":729,"freshEventScore":437,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 437 pts / 78 comments (2022) + 149 pts / 29 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,515 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 21 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 21 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=803694","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4895602","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7970705","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12493485","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14894533","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":149,"peak_comments":29,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17388144","height":7,"chart_height":58},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23948987","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29174605","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":437,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32513240","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40830419","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48405802","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/shouting-in-the-datacenter-2008-video-d9d0233fed72.jpg","path":"/hall/link/shouting-in-the-datacenter-2008-video-d9d0233fed72/"},{"slug":"elevator-saga-an-elevator-programming-game-d9d0234f14ba","title":"Elevator Saga – An elevator programming game","domain":"play.elevatorsaga.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"computer_game","typeDisplay":"Computer games","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_design","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2021-06","inductedMonth":"2021-06","submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":11.422,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":411,"evidenceRank":233,"evidenceScore":78.5,"freshAt":"2022-10-18T16:30:31Z","freshnessRank":708,"freshEventScore":169,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 411 pts / 104 comments (2015) + 278 pts / 99 comments (2021), different submitters and 2,333 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":411,"peak_comments":104,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8929314","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15945268","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16685488","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21425054","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25327572","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":278,"peak_comments":99,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27487111","height":13,"chart_height":115},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":169,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33249988","height":8,"chart_height":70},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42368149","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45903351","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48677966","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/elevator-saga-an-elevator-programming-game-d9d0234f14ba.jpg","path":"/hall/link/elevator-saga-an-elevator-programming-game-d9d0234f14ba/"},{"slug":"a-generation-lost-in-the-bazaar-2012-d9d02346edf6","title":"A Generation Lost in the Bazaar (2012)","domain":"queue.acm.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2017-12","inductedMonth":"2021-08","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":13.673,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":444,"evidenceRank":234,"evidenceScore":78.5,"freshAt":"2023-10-18T07:48:53Z","freshnessRank":514,"freshEventScore":95,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 444 pts / 341 comments (2016) + 108 pts / 70 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,819 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4409901","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":30,"peak_comments":12,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9403124","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":444,"peak_comments":341,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12251323","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":260,"peak_comments":108,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15836907","height":12,"chart_height":100},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24102279","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":108,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28035779","height":5,"chart_height":41},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":95,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37925929","height":5,"chart_height":36},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47871512","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/a-generation-lost-in-the-bazaar-2012-d9d02346edf6/"},{"slug":"functors-applicatives-and-monads-in-pictures-d9d02349278d","title":"Functors, applicatives, and monads in pictures","domain":"adit.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["theory_of_computation","programming_languages","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2015-09","inductedMonth":"2015-09","submissions":15,"submitters":14,"spanYears":8.501,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":200,"evidenceRank":235,"evidenceScore":78.5,"freshAt":"2021-10-19T09:13:19Z","freshnessRank":862,"freshEventScore":156,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 200 pts / 125 comments (2013) + 156 pts / 112 comments (2021), different submitters and 3,075 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":200,"peak_comments":125,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5731164","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7615394","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":128,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10265013","height":6,"chart_height":109},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14681782","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17829836","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21002408","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":156,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28916247","height":7,"chart_height":133},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/functors-applicatives-and-monads-in-pictures-d9d02349278d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/functors-applicatives-and-monads-in-pictures-d9d02349278d/"},{"slug":"an-introduction-to-reactive-programming-d9d0234d4796","title":"An Introduction to Reactive Programming","domain":"gist.github.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","programming_languages","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2018-02","inductedMonth":"2018-02","submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":10.445,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":455,"evidenceRank":236,"evidenceScore":78.5,"freshAt":"2020-10-25T08:59:41Z","freshnessRank":980,"freshEventScore":37,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 455 pts / 119 comments (2014) + 357 pts / 72 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,312 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":455,"peak_comments":119,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7964873","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":6,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13011524","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14728861","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":357,"peak_comments":72,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16285104","height":17,"chart_height":133},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20920295","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":37,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24884843","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39097313","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/an-introduction-to-reactive-programming-d9d0234d4796.jpg","path":"/hall/link/an-introduction-to-reactive-programming-d9d0234d4796/"},{"slug":"low-background-steel-d9d0234b740d","title":"Low-Background Steel","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["physics","chemistry_materials","history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2020-07","inductedMonth":"2020-07","submissions":30,"submitters":29,"spanYears":12.6,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":359,"evidenceRank":237,"evidenceScore":78.5,"freshAt":"2021-10-24T12:46:19Z","freshnessRank":860,"freshEventScore":27,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 359 pts / 107 comments (2020) + 159 pts / 28 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,490 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 30 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 29 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6911127","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10808897","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":159,"peak_comments":28,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11931747","height":8,"chart_height":75},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20244249","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":359,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23886501","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":27,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28977388","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":9,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36487187","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":6,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41761659","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42646347","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48806395","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/low-background-steel-d9d0234b740d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/low-background-steel-d9d0234b740d/"},{"slug":"make-a-lisp-d9d0234f6fdf","title":"Make a Lisp","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["compilers_runtimes","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2017-03","inductedMonth":"2017-09","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":11.384,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":361,"evidenceRank":238,"evidenceScore":78.5,"freshAt":"2021-04-24T12:15:11Z","freshnessRank":921,"freshEventScore":170,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 361 pts / 41 comments (2015) + 236 pts / 69 comments (2017), different submitters and 927 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":361,"peak_comments":41,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9121448","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12720777","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":236,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15226110","height":11,"chart_height":111},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16680032","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":218,"peak_comments":11,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21670442","height":10,"chart_height":103},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":170,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26924344","height":8,"chart_height":80},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39458684","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48949143","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/make-a-lisp-d9d0234f6fdf.jpg","path":"/hall/link/make-a-lisp-d9d0234f6fdf/"},{"slug":"what-i-ve-learned-from-hacker-news-d9d0233f50e7","title":"What I've Learned from Hacker News","domain":"www.paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["online_communities"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2013-05","inductedMonth":"2019-02","submissions":14,"submitters":14,"spanYears":17.347,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":381,"evidenceRank":239,"evidenceScore":78.5,"freshAt":"2022-02-19T04:41:07Z","freshnessRank":822,"freshEventScore":58,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 381 pts / 119 comments (2009) + 229 pts / 98 comments (2012), different submitters and 1,244 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":381,"peak_comments":119,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=495053","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":229,"peak_comments":98,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4285333","height":11,"chart_height":102},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5730494","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8466459","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19210923","height":5,"chart_height":45},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28576637","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":58,"peak_comments":18,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30394474","height":4,"chart_height":26},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37258052","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42019247","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45222398","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48758957","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-i-ve-learned-from-hacker-news-d9d0233f50e7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-i-ve-learned-from-hacker-news-d9d0233f50e7/"},{"slug":"the-missing-semester-of-cs-education-d9d023604ce9","title":"The missing semester of CS education","domain":"missing.csail.mit.edu","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"course_lecture","typeDisplay":"Courses & lectures","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-02","inductedMonth":"2023-02","submissions":9,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.07,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":1163,"evidenceRank":240,"evidenceScore":78.5,"freshAt":"2026-02-23T16:02:48Z","freshnessRank":54,"freshEventScore":457,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1163 pts / 196 comments (2020) + 1024 pts / 336 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,117 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":1163,"peak_comments":196,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22226380","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":205,"peak_comments":185,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27154577","height":10,"chart_height":30},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1024,"peak_comments":336,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34934216","height":24,"chart_height":150},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":70,"peak_comments":16,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41125733","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":90,"peak_comments":38,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45702736","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":457,"peak_comments":132,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47124171","height":22,"chart_height":67}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-missing-semester-of-cs-education-d9d023604ce9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-missing-semester-of-cs-education-d9d023604ce9/"},{"slug":"adnauseam-clicking-ads-so-you-don-t-have-to-d9d02355998a","title":"AdNauseam – clicking ads so you don't have to","domain":"adnauseam.io","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["privacy_surveillance","browsers_web_standards","application_security"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-03","inductedMonth":"2023-02","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":8.29,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":276,"evidenceRank":241,"evidenceScore":78.4,"freshAt":"2025-04-05T11:10:14Z","freshnessRank":228,"freshEventScore":67,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 175 pts / 174 comments (2017) + 81 pts / 69 comments (2023), different submitters and 2,004 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13221916","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":175,"peak_comments":174,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15109251","height":8,"chart_height":108},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18667514","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":276,"peak_comments":164,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19278936","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":26,"peak_comments":11,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25043165","height":4,"chart_height":16},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":81,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34886300","height":4,"chart_height":50},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40770128","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":67,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43592462","height":4,"chart_height":41},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/adnauseam-clicking-ads-so-you-don-t-have-to-d9d02355998a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/adnauseam-clicking-ads-so-you-don-t-have-to-d9d02355998a/"},{"slug":"what-i-wish-i-knew-when-learning-haskell-d9d0234919ca","title":"What I Wish I Knew When Learning Haskell","domain":"dev.stephendiehl.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2015-09","inductedMonth":"2015-09","submissions":11,"submitters":9,"spanYears":7.825,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":306,"evidenceRank":242,"evidenceScore":78.4,"freshAt":"2020-04-11T07:31:22Z","freshnessRank":1014,"freshEventScore":286,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 286 pts / 143 comments (2020) + 306 pts / 99 comments (2013), different submitters and 2,553 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":306,"peak_comments":99,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5546679","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":251,"peak_comments":94,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7637278","height":12,"chart_height":139},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":202,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10209249","height":10,"chart_height":112},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":65,"peak_comments":27,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14226310","height":4,"chart_height":36},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21145922","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":286,"peak_comments":143,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22840211","height":14,"chart_height":159},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26080366","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-i-wish-i-knew-when-learning-haskell-d9d0234919ca.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-i-wish-i-knew-when-learning-haskell-d9d0234919ca/"},{"slug":"don-t-use-vpn-services-d9d0235206ee","title":"Don't Use VPN Services","domain":"gist.github.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["privacy_surveillance","protocols_networking"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-10","inductedMonth":"2020-10","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":10.574,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":408,"evidenceRank":243,"evidenceScore":78.4,"freshAt":"2023-05-23T22:22:21Z","freshnessRank":624,"freshEventScore":20,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 384 pts / 195 comments (2018) + 66 pts / 59 comments (2020), different submitters and 982 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10657064","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11728852","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14437032","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":384,"peak_comments":195,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16371030","height":18,"chart_height":160},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":408,"peak_comments":257,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21326484","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":66,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24867295","height":4,"chart_height":28},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":20,"peak_comments":18,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36051588","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48711094","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/don-t-use-vpn-services-d9d0235206ee.jpg","path":"/hall/link/don-t-use-vpn-services-d9d0235206ee/"},{"slug":"the-javascript-trap-d9d0233f6433","title":"The JavaScript Trap","domain":"www.gnu.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2014-12","inductedMonth":"2015-03","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":15.143,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":79,"evidenceRank":244,"evidenceScore":78.2,"freshAt":"2014-12-06T23:14:25Z","freshnessRank":1169,"freshEventScore":78,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 79 pts / 114 comments (2009) + 78 pts / 111 comments (2014), different submitters and 2,085 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":79,"peak_comments":114,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=527500","height":4,"chart_height":170},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4048006","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6566676","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":78,"peak_comments":111,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8710561","height":4,"chart_height":168},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9236786","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11830143","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13322533","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17311788","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19484550","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40339170","height":4,"chart_height":39},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/the-javascript-trap-d9d0233f6433/"},{"slug":"an-earthquake-could-destroy-a-sizable-portion-of-the-coastal-nor-d9d02350be8a","title":"An earthquake could destroy a sizable portion of the coastal Northwest (2015)","domain":"www.newyorker.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["earth_science","cities_infrastructure"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2020-01","inductedMonth":"2020-01","submissions":19,"submitters":11,"spanYears":9.78,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":612,"evidenceRank":245,"evidenceScore":78.2,"freshAt":"2025-04-23T17:49:52Z","freshnessRank":217,"freshEventScore":39,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 612 pts / 274 comments (2015) + 121 pts / 90 comments (2022), different submitters and 2,589 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 19 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":612,"peak_comments":274,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9878160","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15277768","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":5,"peak_score":60,"peak_comments":15,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17887101","height":4,"chart_height":17},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":37,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22072494","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26995249","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":6,"peak_score":121,"peak_comments":90,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32465615","height":6,"chart_height":34},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":75,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39153939","height":4,"chart_height":21},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":39,"peak_comments":14,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43774742","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/an-earthquake-could-destroy-a-sizable-portion-of-the-coastal-nor-d9d02350be8a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/an-earthquake-could-destroy-a-sizable-portion-of-the-coastal-nor-d9d02350be8a/"},{"slug":"the-evolution-of-a-haskell-programmer-2001-d9d0233ed2af","title":"The Evolution of a Haskell Programmer (2001)","domain":"www.willamette.edu","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2016-02","inductedMonth":"2016-02","submissions":14,"submitters":14,"spanYears":13.613,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":137,"evidenceRank":246,"evidenceScore":78.1,"freshAt":"2021-01-04T23:28:09Z","freshnessRank":955,"freshEventScore":121,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 137 pts / 109 comments (2016) + 121 pts / 34 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,792 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=287179","height":4,"chart_height":20},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":22,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1010925","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":31,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1087130","height":4,"chart_height":38},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2424610","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3609413","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":117,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6194759","height":6,"chart_height":145},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7641202","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":137,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11060257","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17917198","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":121,"peak_comments":34,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25639717","height":6,"chart_height":150},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30574402","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-evolution-of-a-haskell-programmer-2001-d9d0233ed2af.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-evolution-of-a-haskell-programmer-2001-d9d0233ed2af/"},{"slug":"web-design-museum-d9d023572c6e","title":"Web Design Museum","domain":"www.webdesignmuseum.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design","web_development","digital_archives","internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-07","inductedMonth":"2023-02","submissions":14,"submitters":14,"spanYears":9.12,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":372,"evidenceRank":247,"evidenceScore":78.0,"freshAt":"2024-08-29T11:23:53Z","freshnessRank":341,"freshEventScore":228,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 372 pts / 90 comments (2018) + 228 pts / 41 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,188 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14458406","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":372,"peak_comments":90,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17891826","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":104,"peak_comments":14,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23723141","height":5,"chart_height":48},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29071216","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":5,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31572582","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":141,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34675360","height":7,"chart_height":64},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":228,"peak_comments":41,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41389642","height":11,"chart_height":104},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48917507","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/web-design-museum-d9d023572c6e/"},{"slug":"less-is-exponentially-more-2012-d9d0234674ce","title":"Less is Exponentially More (2012)","domain":"commandcenter.blogspot.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","software_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2018-03","inductedMonth":"2020-05","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":13.914,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":235,"evidenceRank":248,"evidenceScore":77.9,"freshAt":"2022-11-13T17:22:27Z","freshnessRank":689,"freshEventScore":66,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 235 pts / 122 comments (2012) + 67 pts / 100 comments (2020), different submitters and 2,877 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":235,"peak_comments":122,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4158865","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10343905","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11856894","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":145,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16548684","height":7,"chart_height":105},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":67,"peak_comments":100,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23152992","height":4,"chart_height":48},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":66,"peak_comments":28,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33585097","height":4,"chart_height":48},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40303281","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48133135","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/less-is-exponentially-more-2012-d9d0234674ce.jpg","path":"/hall/link/less-is-exponentially-more-2012-d9d0234674ce/"},{"slug":"mezzano-an-operating-system-written-in-common-lisp-d9d0234f2132","title":"Mezzano – An operating system written in Common Lisp","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-02","inductedMonth":"2019-06","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":10.505,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":396,"evidenceRank":249,"evidenceScore":77.9,"freshAt":"2025-07-30T14:09:40Z","freshnessRank":180,"freshEventScore":114,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 396 pts / 136 comments (2019) + 213 pts / 63 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,026 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":149,"peak_comments":15,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8955140","height":7,"chart_height":64},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":213,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12358177","height":10,"chart_height":91},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16279609","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":396,"peak_comments":136,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20210227","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":224,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26051255","height":11,"chart_height":96},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36171840","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":114,"peak_comments":25,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44734450","height":5,"chart_height":49},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/mezzano-an-operating-system-written-in-common-lisp-d9d0234f2132.jpg","path":"/hall/link/mezzano-an-operating-system-written-in-common-lisp-d9d0234f2132/"},{"slug":"wtfpython-exploring-and-understanding-python-through-surprising-d9d02358033d","title":"WTFPython: Exploring and understanding Python through surprising snippets","domain":"github.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","learning_methods","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2022-05","inductedMonth":"2023-08","submissions":14,"submitters":13,"spanYears":7.357,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":460,"evidenceRank":250,"evidenceScore":77.9,"freshAt":"2023-08-27T11:46:30Z","freshnessRank":560,"freshEventScore":251,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 359 pts / 162 comments (2021) + 251 pts / 80 comments (2023), different submitters and 927 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":37,"peak_comments":11,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15140440","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18727021","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21883454","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":5,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23052033","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":359,"peak_comments":162,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26097732","height":17,"chart_height":133},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":460,"peak_comments":139,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31566031","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":251,"peak_comments":80,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37281692","height":12,"chart_height":93},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42630011","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/wtfpython-exploring-and-understanding-python-through-surprising-d9d02358033d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/wtfpython-exploring-and-understanding-python-through-surprising-d9d02358033d/"},{"slug":"janet-a-lightweight-expressive-and-modern-lisp-d9d0235c62f1","title":"Janet: a lightweight, expressive and modern Lisp","domain":"janet-lang.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-08","inductedMonth":"2023-02","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.587,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":408,"evidenceRank":251,"evidenceScore":77.9,"freshAt":"2025-07-27T01:28:36Z","freshnessRank":182,"freshEventScore":215,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 408 pts / 269 comments (2020) + 299 pts / 195 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,010 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18759277","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20250271","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":408,"peak_comments":269,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23164614","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":231,"peak_comments":114,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28255116","height":11,"chart_height":96},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":299,"peak_comments":195,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34843306","height":14,"chart_height":125},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":215,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44698185","height":10,"chart_height":90},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/janet-a-lightweight-expressive-and-modern-lisp-d9d0235c62f1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/janet-a-lightweight-expressive-and-modern-lisp-d9d0235c62f1/"},{"slug":"game-theory-illustrated-by-an-animated-cartoon-game-d9d0235c6bdb","title":"Game theory illustrated by an animated cartoon game","domain":"ncase.me","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","psychology","social_issues"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2025-05","inductedMonth":"2025-05","submissions":25,"submitters":24,"spanYears":6.382,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":449,"evidenceRank":252,"evidenceScore":77.9,"freshAt":"2025-05-19T16:28:18Z","freshnessRank":210,"freshEventScore":449,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 449 pts / 74 comments (2025) + 405 pts / 62 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,379 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 25 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 24 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18792817","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":11,"peak_score":42,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21720734","height":4,"chart_height":16},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":405,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28114404","height":19,"chart_height":153},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34039267","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":76,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35807981","height":4,"chart_height":29},{"year":2024,"count":5,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42445912","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":449,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44031535","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/game-theory-illustrated-by-an-animated-cartoon-game-d9d0235c6bdb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/game-theory-illustrated-by-an-animated-cartoon-game-d9d0235c6bdb/"},{"slug":"c-is-not-a-low-level-language-d9d0235a3e6f","title":"C Is Not a Low-Level Language","domain":"queue.acm.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-12","inductedMonth":"2025-02","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":7.034,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":472,"evidenceRank":253,"evidenceScore":77.8,"freshAt":"2023-10-16T10:46:10Z","freshnessRank":517,"freshEventScore":293,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 293 pts / 396 comments (2023) + 472 pts / 316 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,993 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":472,"peak_comments":316,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16967675","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":343,"peak_comments":167,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21888096","height":16,"chart_height":124},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":204,"peak_comments":192,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29702001","height":10,"chart_height":73},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":293,"peak_comments":396,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37897946","height":14,"chart_height":106},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":4,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":14,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43973536","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/c-is-not-a-low-level-language-d9d0235a3e6f/"},{"slug":"accounting-for-computer-scientists-d9d02342ae53","title":"Accounting for Computer Scientists","domain":"martin.kleppmann.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["economics","finance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2023-10","inductedMonth":"2023-10","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":14.825,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":520,"evidenceRank":254,"evidenceScore":77.8,"freshAt":"2026-01-02T18:16:07Z","freshnessRank":88,"freshEventScore":187,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 520 pts / 75 comments (2011) + 208 pts / 50 comments (2023), different submitters and 4,608 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":520,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2298471","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5094176","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9621651","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11240888","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15446202","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21652569","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24214630","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29628088","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32497472","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":208,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37940973","height":10,"chart_height":68},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":187,"peak_comments":73,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46467651","height":9,"chart_height":61}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/accounting-for-computer-scientists-d9d02342ae53.jpg","path":"/hall/link/accounting-for-computer-scientists-d9d02342ae53/"},{"slug":"thoughts-on-flash-d9d02340e96d","title":"Thoughts on Flash","domain":"www.apple.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["browsers_web_standards"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2021-05","inductedMonth":"2021-05","submissions":15,"submitters":15,"spanYears":11.02,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":962,"evidenceRank":255,"evidenceScore":77.7,"freshAt":"2021-05-06T06:52:25Z","freshnessRank":915,"freshEventScore":198,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 962 pts / 505 comments (2010) + 198 pts / 190 comments (2021), different submitters and 4,024 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":962,"peak_comments":505,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1304310","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3217216","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6706581","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7670842","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14856199","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17399196","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20970363","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23476337","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":198,"peak_comments":190,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27059938","height":10,"chart_height":35},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/thoughts-on-flash-d9d02340e96d/"},{"slug":"up-and-down-the-ladder-of-abstraction-d9d02344438e","title":"Up and Down the Ladder of Abstraction","domain":"worrydream.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["human_computer_interaction","visual_design","software_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2017-05","inductedMonth":"2017-05","submissions":14,"submitters":11,"spanYears":11.559,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":733,"evidenceRank":256,"evidenceScore":77.7,"freshAt":"2021-09-11T16:08:47Z","freshnessRank":874,"freshEventScore":122,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 733 pts / 72 comments (2011) + 142 pts / 5 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,047 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":733,"peak_comments":72,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3099595","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7295333","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13020320","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":142,"peak_comments":5,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14382730","height":7,"chart_height":33},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":122,"peak_comments":4,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18044709","height":6,"chart_height":28},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24143502","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":122,"peak_comments":8,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28493086","height":6,"chart_height":28},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35804129","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/up-and-down-the-ladder-of-abstraction-d9d02344438e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/up-and-down-the-ladder-of-abstraction-d9d02344438e/"},{"slug":"atlantropa-d9d023429cd4","title":"Atlantropa","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["cities_infrastructure","geopolitics","energy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2017-11","inductedMonth":"2019-07","submissions":14,"submitters":12,"spanYears":15.266,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":238,"evidenceRank":257,"evidenceScore":77.7,"freshAt":"2020-12-28T13:11:21Z","freshnessRank":958,"freshEventScore":46,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 238 pts / 118 comments (2019) + 170 pts / 55 comments (2014), different submitters and 1,805 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2263343","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6151313","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":170,"peak_comments":55,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8099038","height":8,"chart_height":121},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":94,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15618203","height":5,"chart_height":67},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":238,"peak_comments":118,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20380250","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":46,"peak_comments":12,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25558929","height":4,"chart_height":33},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32176810","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35533854","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39343180","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46236183","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48373597","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/atlantropa-d9d023429cd4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/atlantropa-d9d023429cd4/"},{"slug":"rich-programmer-food-d9d0233e1823","title":"Rich Programmer Food","domain":"steve-yegge.blogspot.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["compilers_runtimes"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2007,"candidateMonth":"2016-05","inductedMonth":"2016-05","submissions":19,"submitters":18,"spanYears":18.998,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":217,"evidenceRank":258,"evidenceScore":77.6,"freshAt":"2016-05-23T15:48:18Z","freshnessRank":1151,"freshEventScore":92,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 217 pts / 103 comments (2010) + 92 pts / 72 comments (2016), different submitters and 2,106 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 19 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 18 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":1,"peak_score":30,"peak_comments":25,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30136","height":4,"chart_height":24},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":28,"peak_comments":25,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=103500","height":4,"chart_height":22},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":217,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1608129","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9788256","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":92,"peak_comments":72,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11754605","height":4,"chart_height":72},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17845787","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21144694","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23376409","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28906211","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29920748","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38656182","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39274661","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42746215","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48619895","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/rich-programmer-food-d9d0233e1823.jpg","path":"/hall/link/rich-programmer-food-d9d0233e1823/"},{"slug":"goodhart-s-law-when-a-measure-becomes-a-target-it-ceases-to-be-a-d9d02341071e","title":"Goodhart's Law: When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["economics","management_strategy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2021-09","inductedMonth":"2021-09","submissions":19,"submitters":18,"spanYears":15.704,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":229,"evidenceRank":259,"evidenceScore":77.6,"freshAt":"2021-09-17T13:42:50Z","freshnessRank":871,"freshEventScore":178,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 229 pts / 134 comments (2018) + 178 pts / 83 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,189 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 19 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 18 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1368745","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8383615","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10075780","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":229,"peak_comments":134,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17320640","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21773506","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22968447","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":178,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28565379","height":9,"chart_height":132},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37416854","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43484133","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46859489","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/goodhart-s-law-when-a-measure-becomes-a-target-it-ceases-to-be-a-d9d02341071e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/goodhart-s-law-when-a-measure-becomes-a-target-it-ceases-to-be-a-d9d02341071e/"},{"slug":"apollo-11-guidance-computer-source-code-d9d023540c6d","title":"Apollo 11 Guidance Computer source code","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"source_code","typeDisplay":"Source code","topic":"space_transportation","topicDisplay":"Space & transportation","tags":["space_astronomy","retrocomputing","computer_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-02","inductedMonth":"2020-02","submissions":29,"submitters":27,"spanYears":10.042,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":652,"evidenceRank":260,"evidenceScore":77.6,"freshAt":"2024-07-04T20:53:16Z","freshnessRank":367,"freshEventScore":28,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 652 pts / 145 comments (2016) + 158 pts / 30 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,322 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 29 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 27 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":652,"peak_comments":145,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12048945","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16024944","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17560741","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":7,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20461858","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":158,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22367416","height":8,"chart_height":41},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29249509","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30940244","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":28,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40877959","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2025,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45422207","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":4,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48017897","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/apollo-11-guidance-computer-source-code-d9d023540c6d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/apollo-11-guidance-computer-source-code-d9d023540c6d/"},{"slug":"how-much-your-computer-can-do-in-a-second-d9d02351af97","title":"How much your computer can do in a second","domain":"computers-are-fast.github.io","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["performance_reliability","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-02","inductedMonth":"2023-06","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":9.15,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":602,"evidenceRank":261,"evidenceScore":77.5,"freshAt":"2023-06-22T18:27:14Z","freshnessRank":605,"freshEventScore":281,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 602 pts / 234 comments (2017) + 281 pts / 142 comments (2023), different submitters and 2,279 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":557,"peak_comments":174,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10445927","height":24,"chart_height":157},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":602,"peak_comments":234,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13960183","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19482087","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23170615","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":281,"peak_comments":142,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36436598","height":13,"chart_height":79},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42451624","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-much-your-computer-can-do-in-a-second-d9d02351af97.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-much-your-computer-can-do-in-a-second-d9d02351af97/"},{"slug":"my-wife-has-complained-that-openoffice-will-never-print-on-tuesd-d9d0234da7f0","title":"“My wife has complained that OpenOffice will never print on Tuesdays” (2009)","domain":"bugs.launchpad.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"social_post_thread","typeDisplay":"Social posts & threads","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","testing_quality"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2018-10","inductedMonth":"2020-01","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":10.418,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":577,"evidenceRank":262,"evidenceScore":77.5,"freshAt":"2020-01-27T07:18:28Z","freshnessRank":1023,"freshEventScore":577,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 577 pts / 207 comments (2020) + 419 pts / 155 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,349 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":244,"peak_comments":37,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8171956","height":12,"chart_height":72},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10435031","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":419,"peak_comments":155,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11717010","height":20,"chart_height":123},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18269921","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20344655","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":577,"peak_comments":207,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22157430","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28107819","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42567656","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/my-wife-has-complained-that-openoffice-will-never-print-on-tuesd-d9d0234da7f0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/my-wife-has-complained-that-openoffice-will-never-print-on-tuesd-d9d0234da7f0/"},{"slug":"why-finnish-babies-sleep-in-cardboard-boxes-2013-d9d0234d341e","title":"Why Finnish babies sleep in cardboard boxes (2013)","domain":"www.bbc.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["social_issues","public_health","children_parenting"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2019-09","inductedMonth":"2019-09","submissions":11,"submitters":6,"spanYears":10.916,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":442,"evidenceRank":263,"evidenceScore":77.5,"freshAt":"2021-12-20T21:25:17Z","freshnessRank":845,"freshEventScore":235,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 354 pts / 262 comments (2016) + 442 pts / 253 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,078 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7921333","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8920208","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":354,"peak_comments":262,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12547353","height":17,"chart_height":136},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":442,"peak_comments":253,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20884456","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25543504","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":235,"peak_comments":165,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29630496","height":11,"chart_height":90},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41748932","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44045160","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-finnish-babies-sleep-in-cardboard-boxes-2013-d9d0234d341e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-finnish-babies-sleep-in-cardboard-boxes-2013-d9d0234d341e/"},{"slug":"the-tao-of-programming-1987-d9d0234d679e","title":"The Tao of Programming (1987)","domain":"www.mit.edu","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","operating_systems","writing_craft"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2020-11","inductedMonth":"2023-09","submissions":17,"submitters":16,"spanYears":10.801,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":269,"evidenceRank":264,"evidenceScore":77.5,"freshAt":"2023-09-27T17:37:04Z","freshnessRank":535,"freshEventScore":223,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 223 pts / 105 comments (2023) + 269 pts / 63 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,052 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":153,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8035332","height":7,"chart_height":97},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9676092","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12781028","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":6,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20051040","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":269,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25031486","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33226416","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":223,"peak_comments":105,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37678181","height":11,"chart_height":141},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43877143","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-tao-of-programming-1987-d9d0234d679e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-tao-of-programming-1987-d9d0234d679e/"},{"slug":"open-source-license-helper-tool-d9d02349fdb3","title":"Open Source License Helper Tool","domain":"choosealicense.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"policy_guidelines","typeDisplay":"Policies & guidelines","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["law_regulation","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2018-06","inductedMonth":"2018-06","submissions":20,"submitters":20,"spanYears":12.142,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":172,"evidenceRank":265,"evidenceScore":77.5,"freshAt":"2018-06-05T21:26:29Z","freshnessRank":1093,"freshEventScore":172,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 117 pts / 162 comments (2013) + 172 pts / 89 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,786 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":117,"peak_comments":162,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6046591","height":6,"chart_height":116},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10489881","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11698078","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":172,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17242238","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21734262","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24765823","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33489004","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36545512","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41290511","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43632052","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/open-source-license-helper-tool-d9d02349fdb3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/open-source-license-helper-tool-d9d02349fdb3/"},{"slug":"tufte-css-d9d02351de48","title":"Tufte CSS","domain":"edwardtufte.github.io","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-08","inductedMonth":"2020-07","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":9.81,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":377,"evidenceRank":266,"evidenceScore":77.4,"freshAt":"2025-09-03T18:41:57Z","freshnessRank":154,"freshEventScore":207,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 377 pts / 59 comments (2017) + 207 pts / 48 comments (2025), different submitters and 2,858 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":169,"peak_comments":26,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10555319","height":8,"chart_height":76},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":377,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15633102","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20603289","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":60,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23828196","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29625999","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32855936","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":132,"peak_comments":32,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35032334","height":6,"chart_height":60},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42461229","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":207,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45119103","height":10,"chart_height":93},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/tufte-css-d9d02351de48.jpg","path":"/hall/link/tufte-css-d9d02351de48/"},{"slug":"one-electron-universe-d9d0234406ec","title":"One-electron universe","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["physics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2015-02","inductedMonth":"2018-05","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":13.426,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":192,"evidenceRank":267,"evidenceScore":77.3,"freshAt":"2015-02-06T01:35:36Z","freshnessRank":1167,"freshEventScore":128,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 169 pts / 100 comments (2011) + 192 pts / 99 comments (2013), different submitters and 744 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":169,"peak_comments":100,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2986291","height":8,"chart_height":150},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":192,"peak_comments":99,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6446328","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":128,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9007308","height":6,"chart_height":113},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17146237","height":4,"chart_height":15},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21280668","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24530951","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27871572","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37051851","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39775177","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43048232","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/one-electron-universe-d9d0234406ec.jpg","path":"/hall/link/one-electron-universe-d9d0234406ec/"},{"slug":"dark-patterns-user-interfaces-designed-to-trick-people-d9d023419759","title":"Dark Patterns - User Interfaces Designed to Trick People","domain":"darkpatterns.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2016-12","inductedMonth":"2016-12","submissions":15,"submitters":15,"spanYears":10.845,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":639,"evidenceRank":268,"evidenceScore":77.3,"freshAt":"2019-09-02T12:41:00Z","freshnessRank":1049,"freshEventScore":141,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 639 pts / 311 comments (2016) + 265 pts / 94 comments (2013), different submitters and 1,194 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1699875","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":4,"peak_score":265,"peak_comments":94,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6301378","height":13,"chart_height":71},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8244719","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10346247","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":639,"peak_comments":311,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13116703","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":141,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20858714","height":7,"chart_height":38},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27918507","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/dark-patterns-user-interfaces-designed-to-trick-people-d9d023419759/"},{"slug":"the-deep-sea-d9d0235fc161","title":"The Deep Sea","domain":"neal.fun","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["earth_science"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-06","inductedMonth":"2023-06","submissions":22,"submitters":22,"spanYears":4.961,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":703,"evidenceRank":269,"evidenceScore":77.3,"freshAt":"2024-11-19T18:40:15Z","freshnessRank":296,"freshEventScore":42,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 703 pts / 96 comments (2019) + 363 pts / 124 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,284 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 22 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 22 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":13,"peak_score":703,"peak_comments":96,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21850527","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":222,"peak_comments":45,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29290204","height":11,"chart_height":54},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":5,"peak_score":363,"peak_comments":124,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36491514","height":17,"chart_height":88},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":42,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42186746","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/the-deep-sea-d9d0235fc161/"},{"slug":"m5-macbook-pro-d9d0234655e6","title":"M5 MacBook Pro","domain":"www.apple.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["computer_architecture","product_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2016-10","inductedMonth":"2025-10","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":13.344,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":861,"evidenceRank":270,"evidenceScore":77.2,"freshAt":"2025-10-15T13:10:08Z","freshnessRank":130,"freshEventScore":370,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 861 pts / 1713 comments (2016) + 370 pts / 564 comments (2025), different submitters and 3,274 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":11,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4096206","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":91,"peak_comments":125,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9569862","height":4,"chart_height":18},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":861,"peak_comments":1713,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12807826","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17513863","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28908382","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":69,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38078079","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":370,"peak_comments":564,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45591902","height":18,"chart_height":73},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/m5-macbook-pro-d9d0234655e6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/m5-macbook-pro-d9d0234655e6/"},{"slug":"the-world-in-which-ipv6-was-a-good-design-2017-d9d0235e055e","title":"The world in which IPv6 was a good design (2017)","domain":"apenwarr.ca","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","internet_infrastructure"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-08","inductedMonth":"2023-08","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.853,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":589,"evidenceRank":271,"evidenceScore":77.2,"freshAt":"2026-04-19T02:50:43Z","freshnessRank":26,"freshEventScore":231,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 179 pts / 306 comments (2023) + 589 pts / 238 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,523 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":589,"peak_comments":238,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20167686","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":120,"peak_comments":131,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25568766","height":6,"chart_height":35},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":179,"peak_comments":306,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37116487","height":9,"chart_height":52},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43887398","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":231,"peak_comments":166,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47821429","height":11,"chart_height":67}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-world-in-which-ipv6-was-a-good-design-2017-d9d0235e055e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-world-in-which-ipv6-was-a-good-design-2017-d9d0235e055e/"},{"slug":"micro-a-modern-alternative-to-nano-d9d02355b2cf","title":"micro – A Modern Alternative to nano","domain":"micro-editor.github.io","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-11","inductedMonth":"2023-08","submissions":14,"submitters":11,"spanYears":6.623,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":383,"evidenceRank":272,"evidenceScore":77.2,"freshAt":"2023-08-18T04:06:04Z","freshnessRank":566,"freshEventScore":383,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 383 pts / 324 comments (2023) + 349 pts / 103 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,176 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":6,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13735395","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16368756","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":349,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23334190","height":17,"chart_height":155},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":324,"peak_comments":161,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29128702","height":16,"chart_height":144},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":4,"peak_score":383,"peak_comments":324,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37171294","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/micro-a-modern-alternative-to-nano-d9d02355b2cf.jpg","path":"/hall/link/micro-a-modern-alternative-to-nano-d9d02355b2cf/"},{"slug":"the-days-are-long-but-the-decades-are-short-2015-d9d02350072b","title":"The days are long but the decades are short (2015)","domain":"blog.samaltman.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["careers","personal_productivity","workplace"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-09","inductedMonth":"2019-09","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":10.606,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":1163,"evidenceRank":273,"evidenceScore":77.2,"freshAt":"2023-04-19T21:12:56Z","freshnessRank":639,"freshEventScore":115,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1163 pts / 387 comments (2015) + 193 pts / 33 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,592 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1163,"peak_comments":387,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9454440","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17284262","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":193,"peak_comments":33,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20903714","height":9,"chart_height":28},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":104,"peak_comments":73,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26065466","height":5,"chart_height":15},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31833686","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":115,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35633398","height":6,"chart_height":17},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41202165","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46168708","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-days-are-long-but-the-decades-are-short-2015-d9d02350072b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-days-are-long-but-the-decades-are-short-2015-d9d02350072b/"},{"slug":"things-you-should-never-do-part-i-2000-d9d023557950","title":"Things You Should Never Do, Part I (2000)","domain":"www.joelonsoftware.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2024-02","inductedMonth":"2024-02","submissions":31,"submitters":31,"spanYears":9.202,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":157,"evidenceRank":274,"evidenceScore":77.2,"freshAt":"2024-02-29T21:46:06Z","freshnessRank":436,"freshEventScore":157,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 157 pts / 100 comments (2024) + 128 pts / 83 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,336 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 31 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 31 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13124118","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15433527","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":6,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16937464","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19962001","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":128,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23725867","height":6,"chart_height":139},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28952307","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":21,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31122975","height":4,"chart_height":23},{"year":2023,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37416339","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":157,"peak_comments":100,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39555598","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45124944","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47068250","height":4,"chart_height":5}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/things-you-should-never-do-part-i-2000-d9d023557950.jpg","path":"/hall/link/things-you-should-never-do-part-i-2000-d9d023557950/"},{"slug":"advantages-of-monorepos-2015-d9d0235036b4","title":"Advantages of Monorepos (2015)","domain":"danluu.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","management_strategy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-02","inductedMonth":"2018-02","submissions":15,"submitters":9,"spanYears":9.054,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":198,"evidenceRank":275,"evidenceScore":77.2,"freshAt":"2022-04-07T15:20:28Z","freshnessRank":795,"freshEventScore":183,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 183 pts / 140 comments (2022) + 198 pts / 138 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,514 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":92,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9562923","height":4,"chart_height":79},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12803208","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":6,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15730014","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":198,"peak_comments":138,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16362345","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28125591","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":183,"peak_comments":140,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30945613","height":9,"chart_height":157},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36680360","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40594102","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/advantages-of-monorepos-2015-d9d0235036b4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/advantages-of-monorepos-2015-d9d0235036b4/"},{"slug":"you-can-t-tell-people-anything-d9d02340a6bd","title":"You can't tell people anything","domain":"habitatchronicles.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2020-06","inductedMonth":"2023-03","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":16.233,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":440,"evidenceRank":276,"evidenceScore":77.2,"freshAt":"2023-03-23T22:29:34Z","freshnessRank":642,"freshEventScore":440,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 405 pts / 191 comments (2020) + 440 pts / 182 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,003 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1167249","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":272,"peak_comments":66,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17384703","height":13,"chart_height":105},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":405,"peak_comments":191,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23617188","height":19,"chart_height":156},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":266,"peak_comments":88,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28775517","height":13,"chart_height":103},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":440,"peak_comments":182,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35282293","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39409457","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48306226","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/you-can-t-tell-people-anything-d9d02340a6bd.jpg","path":"/hall/link/you-can-t-tell-people-anything-d9d02340a6bd/"},{"slug":"parable-of-the-polygons-a-playable-post-on-the-shape-of-society-d9d0234eb48a","title":"Parable of the Polygons – a playable post on the shape of society","domain":"ncase.me","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["social_issues","mathematics","technology_ethics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2024-01","inductedMonth":"2024-01","submissions":34,"submitters":23,"spanYears":9.081,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":357,"evidenceRank":277,"evidenceScore":77.1,"freshAt":"2024-01-07T01:39:46Z","freshnessRank":465,"freshEventScore":76,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 357 pts / 86 comments (2014) + 76 pts / 86 comments (2024), different submitters and 3,316 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 34 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 23 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":357,"peak_comments":86,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8716538","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9545467","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":6,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11302688","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":13,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13965827","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18644343","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":99,"peak_comments":27,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19714441","height":5,"chart_height":47},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":5,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27623857","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31604718","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34487974","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":76,"peak_comments":86,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38897510","height":4,"chart_height":36},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/parable-of-the-polygons-a-playable-post-on-the-shape-of-society-d9d0234eb48a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/parable-of-the-polygons-a-playable-post-on-the-shape-of-society-d9d0234eb48a/"},{"slug":"why-chinese-is-so-damn-hard-1992-d9d0233e8702","title":"Why Chinese Is So Damn Hard (1992)","domain":"pinyin.info","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["language_linguistics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2014-04","inductedMonth":"2014-04","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":17.413,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":270,"evidenceRank":278,"evidenceScore":77.0,"freshAt":"2018-12-13T05:23:29Z","freshnessRank":1073,"freshEventScore":55,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 270 pts / 294 comments (2014) + 97 pts / 103 comments (2010), different submitters and 1,431 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=176498","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":97,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1368051","height":5,"chart_height":61},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5017703","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":270,"peak_comments":294,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7622432","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":55,"peak_comments":49,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18670031","height":4,"chart_height":35},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23600429","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26955871","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36045456","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45397101","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-chinese-is-so-damn-hard-1992-d9d0233e8702.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-chinese-is-so-damn-hard-1992-d9d0233e8702/"},{"slug":"the-website-obesity-crisis-d9d023524795","title":"The Website Obesity Crisis","domain":"idlewords.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"course_lecture","typeDisplay":"Courses & lectures","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2018-08","inductedMonth":"2021-06","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":9.342,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":1122,"evidenceRank":279,"evidenceScore":76.9,"freshAt":"2023-01-21T15:10:49Z","freshnessRank":664,"freshEventScore":114,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1122 pts / 367 comments (2016) + 119 pts / 89 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,978 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":1122,"peak_comments":367,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10820445","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":197,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14088092","height":9,"chart_height":30},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":67,"peak_comments":30,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17943754","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":49,"peak_comments":22,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22283344","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":119,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27355556","height":6,"chart_height":18},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":114,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34466910","height":5,"chart_height":17},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40354347","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43899402","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-website-obesity-crisis-d9d023524795.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-website-obesity-crisis-d9d023524795/"},{"slug":"the-cryptopals-crypto-challenges-d9d0234da4c9","title":"The cryptopals crypto challenges","domain":"cryptopals.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"course_lecture","typeDisplay":"Courses & lectures","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography","application_security","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2016-10","inductedMonth":"2019-02","submissions":16,"submitters":14,"spanYears":11.625,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":404,"evidenceRank":280,"evidenceScore":76.9,"freshAt":"2023-06-20T00:41:12Z","freshnessRank":607,"freshEventScore":169,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 404 pts / 71 comments (2014) + 226 pts / 50 comments (2016), different submitters and 796 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":404,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8166064","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":226,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12720009","height":11,"chart_height":95},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19481899","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22090450","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26437312","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33358765","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":169,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36398292","height":8,"chart_height":71},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47558463","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-cryptopals-crypto-challenges-d9d0234da4c9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-cryptopals-crypto-challenges-d9d0234da4c9/"},{"slug":"markets-are-efficient-if-and-only-if-p-np-2010-d9d023408ee9","title":"Markets are efficient if and only if P = NP (2010)","domain":"arxiv.org","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"research_paper","typeDisplay":"Research papers","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["markets","theory_of_computation"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2018-06","inductedMonth":"2018-06","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":12.249,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":332,"evidenceRank":281,"evidenceScore":76.8,"freshAt":"2020-10-21T03:34:45Z","freshnessRank":983,"freshEventScore":214,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 332 pts / 191 comments (2018) + 214 pts / 169 comments (2020), different submitters and 872 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1124782","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":3,"peak_score":107,"peak_comments":123,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4589264","height":5,"chart_height":55},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16008921","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":332,"peak_comments":191,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17202950","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":214,"peak_comments":169,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24844529","height":10,"chart_height":110},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31396205","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/markets-are-efficient-if-and-only-if-p-np-2010-d9d023408ee9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/markets-are-efficient-if-and-only-if-p-np-2010-d9d023408ee9/"},{"slug":"on-the-foolishness-of-natural-language-programming-d9d02341f264","title":"On the foolishness of “natural language programming”","domain":"www.cs.utexas.edu","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","software_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2017-03","inductedMonth":"2020-09","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":12.493,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":170,"evidenceRank":282,"evidenceScore":76.8,"freshAt":"2023-05-16T21:42:54Z","freshnessRank":628,"freshEventScore":126,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 132 pts / 152 comments (2014) + 170 pts / 121 comments (2020), different submitters and 2,217 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":119,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1913308","height":6,"chart_height":119},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":132,"peak_comments":152,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8222017","height":6,"chart_height":132},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13806388","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":170,"peak_comments":121,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24529900","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33894546","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":126,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35968148","height":6,"chart_height":126},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/on-the-foolishness-of-natural-language-programming-d9d02341f264.jpg","path":"/hall/link/on-the-foolishness-of-natural-language-programming-d9d02341f264/"},{"slug":"open-source-is-not-about-you-d9d0235c1f8c","title":"Open Source is Not About You","domain":"gist.github.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["open_source","technology_ethics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2022-07","inductedMonth":"2022-07","submissions":10,"submitters":9,"spanYears":7.214,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":734,"evidenceRank":283,"evidenceScore":76.8,"freshAt":"2026-02-13T14:36:28Z","freshnessRank":59,"freshEventScore":226,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 734 pts / 277 comments (2018) + 304 pts / 205 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,313 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":734,"peak_comments":277,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18538123","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24780928","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27003713","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":304,"peak_comments":205,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31957554","height":15,"chart_height":70},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37758234","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39905557","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":226,"peak_comments":188,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47003219","height":11,"chart_height":52}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/open-source-is-not-about-you-d9d0235c1f8c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/open-source-is-not-about-you-d9d0235c1f8c/"},{"slug":"what-every-computer-science-major-should-know-2011-d9d02343e5a5","title":"What every computer science major should know (2011)","domain":"matt.might.net","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["academic_life","learning_methods","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2019-07","inductedMonth":"2019-07","submissions":17,"submitters":17,"spanYears":14.524,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":540,"evidenceRank":284,"evidenceScore":76.7,"freshAt":"2019-07-16T19:46:20Z","freshnessRank":1055,"freshEventScore":540,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 540 pts / 182 comments (2019) + 148 pts / 95 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,533 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":87,"peak_comments":29,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2921440","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3784744","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":20,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8035177","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":148,"peak_comments":95,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9490723","height":7,"chart_height":47},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13384683","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17916730","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":540,"peak_comments":182,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20453241","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31098876","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37725455","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40345282","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43484237","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47226127","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-every-computer-science-major-should-know-2011-d9d02343e5a5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-every-computer-science-major-should-know-2011-d9d02343e5a5/"},{"slug":"the-acceleration-of-addictiveness-2010-d9d02341548e","title":"The Acceleration of Addictiveness (2010)","domain":"www.paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["social_issues","technology_ethics","mental_health"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2017-07","inductedMonth":"2018-02","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":15.674,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":470,"evidenceRank":285,"evidenceScore":76.7,"freshAt":"2019-11-02T02:36:29Z","freshnessRank":1040,"freshEventScore":144,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 470 pts / 269 comments (2010) + 229 pts / 110 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,555 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":470,"peak_comments":269,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1549363","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9522647","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":229,"peak_comments":110,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14847250","height":11,"chart_height":83},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16323774","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":144,"peak_comments":38,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21425542","height":7,"chart_height":52},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41647060","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47567150","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-acceleration-of-addictiveness-2010-d9d02341548e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-acceleration-of-addictiveness-2010-d9d02341548e/"},{"slug":"linux-problems-on-the-desktop-2018-d9d0235c0ef3","title":"Linux Problems on the Desktop (2018)","domain":"itvision.altervista.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","open_source","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-10","inductedMonth":"2022-08","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":4.797,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":287,"evidenceRank":286,"evidenceScore":76.7,"freshAt":"2022-08-06T19:11:17Z","freshnessRank":736,"freshEventScore":73,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 287 pts / 391 comments (2019) + 217 pts / 328 comments (2021), different submitters and 970 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18483304","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":287,"peak_comments":391,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19241394","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":115,"peak_comments":177,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23368115","height":6,"chart_height":68},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":217,"peak_comments":328,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28960330","height":10,"chart_height":129},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":73,"peak_comments":65,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32370732","height":4,"chart_height":43},{"year":2023,"count":4,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35663337","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/linux-problems-on-the-desktop-2018-d9d0235c0ef3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/linux-problems-on-the-desktop-2018-d9d0235c0ef3/"},{"slug":"coroutines-in-c-simon-tatham-2000-d9d0233fe89f","title":"Coroutines in C (Simon Tatham, 2000)","domain":"www.chiark.greenend.org.uk","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","software_architecture","compilers_runtimes"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2024-02","inductedMonth":"2024-02","submissions":18,"submitters":16,"spanYears":14.489,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":307,"evidenceRank":287,"evidenceScore":76.6,"freshAt":"2024-02-25T16:45:03Z","freshnessRank":440,"freshEventScore":307,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 307 pts / 93 comments (2024) + 181 pts / 59 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,843 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 18 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":2,"peak_score":40,"peak_comments":16,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=835849","height":4,"chart_height":22},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":58,"peak_comments":16,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1380044","height":4,"chart_height":32},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4742087","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6244994","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":47,"peak_comments":27,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8615501","height":4,"chart_height":26},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10102837","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":43,"peak_comments":11,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11051004","height":4,"chart_height":24},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15614155","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":181,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19106796","height":9,"chart_height":100},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":28,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23293835","height":4,"chart_height":16},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37357673","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":307,"peak_comments":93,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39502276","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/coroutines-in-c-simon-tatham-2000-d9d0233fe89f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/coroutines-in-c-simon-tatham-2000-d9d0233fe89f/"},{"slug":"meditations-on-moloch-2014-d9d0234d8a3e","title":"Meditations on Moloch (2014)","domain":"slatestarcodex.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["social_issues","technology_ethics","philosophy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2023-03","inductedMonth":"2023-03","submissions":19,"submitters":18,"spanYears":11.907,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":226,"evidenceRank":288,"evidenceScore":76.6,"freshAt":"2023-03-19T17:48:51Z","freshnessRank":643,"freshEventScore":221,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 221 pts / 105 comments (2023) + 226 pts / 54 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,423 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 19 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 18 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8108619","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10532551","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12743209","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15674409","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17577913","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":226,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19756487","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":24,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26129062","height":4,"chart_height":18},{"year":2022,"count":4,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31954394","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":221,"peak_comments":105,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35221609","height":11,"chart_height":166},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42396792","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47996584","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/meditations-on-moloch-2014-d9d0234d8a3e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/meditations-on-moloch-2014-d9d0234d8a3e/"},{"slug":"page-weight-matters-d9d02348035b","title":"Page Weight Matters","domain":"blog.chriszacharias.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["performance_reliability","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2017-05","inductedMonth":"2018-04","submissions":12,"submitters":10,"spanYears":11.858,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":717,"evidenceRank":289,"evidenceScore":76.6,"freshAt":"2022-07-29T17:51:02Z","freshnessRank":741,"freshEventScore":137,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 717 pts / 164 comments (2012) + 556 pts / 165 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,026 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":717,"peak_comments":164,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4957992","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":556,"peak_comments":165,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10393930","height":24,"chart_height":132},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15678674","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":82,"peak_comments":24,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18098955","height":4,"chart_height":19},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":137,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32279897","height":7,"chart_height":32},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":4,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42021880","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/page-weight-matters-d9d02348035b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/page-weight-matters-d9d02348035b/"},{"slug":"little-book-about-os-development-2015-pdf-d9d0234ef728","title":"Little book about OS development (2015) [pdf]","domain":"littleosbook.github.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","computer_architecture","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2022-07","inductedMonth":"2022-07","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":10.193,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":497,"evidenceRank":290,"evidenceScore":76.6,"freshAt":"2025-03-21T20:30:32Z","freshnessRank":235,"freshEventScore":370,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 497 pts / 45 comments (2016) + 370 pts / 54 comments (2025), different submitters and 3,007 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":37,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9586983","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":497,"peak_comments":45,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13258063","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13986999","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16666211","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25082707","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28983839","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":146,"peak_comments":20,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32147872","height":7,"chart_height":50},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":370,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43440473","height":18,"chart_height":127},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/little-book-about-os-development-2015-pdf-d9d0234ef728.jpg","path":"/hall/link/little-book-about-os-development-2015-pdf-d9d0234ef728/"},{"slug":"a-love-letter-to-geocities-sites-d9d02351155d","title":"A Love Letter to Geocities Sites","domain":"www.cameronsworld.net","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["internet_culture","digital_archives","visual_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2020-10","inductedMonth":"2022-08","submissions":14,"submitters":14,"spanYears":10.839,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":269,"evidenceRank":291,"evidenceScore":76.6,"freshAt":"2022-08-01T23:44:07Z","freshnessRank":740,"freshEventScore":269,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 269 pts / 111 comments (2022) + 249 pts / 63 comments (2015), different submitters and 2,539 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":249,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10085542","height":12,"chart_height":157},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14716531","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18743850","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20618922","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":211,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24942246","height":10,"chart_height":133},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":269,"peak_comments":111,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32313574","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41271768","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43961031","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48618383","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-love-letter-to-geocities-sites-d9d02351155d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-love-letter-to-geocities-sites-d9d02351155d/"},{"slug":"panopticlick-d9d0234078a3","title":"Panopticlick","domain":"panopticlick.eff.org","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["privacy_surveillance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2019-10","inductedMonth":"2019-10","submissions":19,"submitters":19,"spanYears":9.739,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":248,"evidenceRank":292,"evidenceScore":76.6,"freshAt":"2019-10-25T05:58:44Z","freshnessRank":1041,"freshEventScore":248,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 210 pts / 143 comments (2013) + 248 pts / 82 comments (2019), different submitters and 2,267 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 19 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 19 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":4,"peak_score":88,"peak_comments":36,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1082464","height":4,"chart_height":60},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2699576","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":4,"peak_score":210,"peak_comments":143,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6188543","height":10,"chart_height":144},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7728920","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":77,"peak_comments":34,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10753087","height":4,"chart_height":53},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15586886","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17283295","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":248,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21352278","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/panopticlick-d9d0234078a3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/panopticlick-d9d0234078a3/"},{"slug":"volkswagen-detects-when-your-tests-are-run-in-a-ci-server-and-ma-d9d02351867b","title":"Volkswagen – detects when your tests are run in a CI server, and makes them pass","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["testing_quality","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-09","inductedMonth":"2018-09","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":10.606,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":538,"evidenceRank":293,"evidenceScore":76.6,"freshAt":"2024-04-09T14:09:36Z","freshnessRank":421,"freshEventScore":269,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 538 pts / 119 comments (2018) + 269 pts / 25 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,022 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":195,"peak_comments":20,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10349026","height":9,"chart_height":62},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":91,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13588153","height":4,"chart_height":29},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":538,"peak_comments":119,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18067861","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23842053","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":163,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28180352","height":8,"chart_height":52},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":269,"peak_comments":25,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39979609","height":13,"chart_height":85},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48155704","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/volkswagen-detects-when-your-tests-are-run-in-a-ci-server-and-ma-d9d02351867b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/volkswagen-detects-when-your-tests-are-run-in-a-ci-server-and-ma-d9d02351867b/"},{"slug":"it-s-like-json-but-fast-and-small-d9d023412cda","title":"It's like JSON. but fast and small.","domain":"msgpack.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","data_engineering"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2020-03","inductedMonth":"2020-03","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":14.557,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":326,"evidenceRank":294,"evidenceScore":76.6,"freshAt":"2025-01-11T03:28:30Z","freshnessRank":269,"freshEventScore":102,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 326 pts / 379 comments (2020) + 188 pts / 100 comments (2012), different submitters and 2,628 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":22,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1453332","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2011,"count":3,"peak_score":50,"peak_comments":15,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2886106","height":4,"chart_height":26},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":188,"peak_comments":100,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4981376","height":9,"chart_height":98},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15427875","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17835105","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":326,"peak_comments":379,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22537250","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":102,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42663047","height":5,"chart_height":53},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/it-s-like-json-but-fast-and-small-d9d023412cda.jpg","path":"/hall/link/it-s-like-json-but-fast-and-small-d9d023412cda/"},{"slug":"frighteningly-ambitious-startup-ideas-2012-d9d023457e2d","title":"Frighteningly Ambitious Startup Ideas (2012)","domain":"www.paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["startups_entrepreneurship"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2017-05","inductedMonth":"2017-05","submissions":14,"submitters":14,"spanYears":11.02,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1032,"evidenceRank":295,"evidenceScore":76.6,"freshAt":"2017-05-20T10:15:50Z","freshnessRank":1125,"freshEventScore":252,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1032 pts / 430 comments (2012) + 252 pts / 245 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,897 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":1032,"peak_comments":430,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3686840","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5410846","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12861964","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":252,"peak_comments":245,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14381699","height":12,"chart_height":42},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18117556","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24668399","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28770053","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34760067","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/frighteningly-ambitious-startup-ideas-2012-d9d023457e2d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/frighteningly-ambitious-startup-ideas-2012-d9d023457e2d/"},{"slug":"the-wetware-crisis-the-dead-sea-effect-2008-d9d0233e7d84","title":"The Wetware Crisis: the Dead Sea effect (2008)","domain":"brucefwebster.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["workplace","management_strategy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2024-02","inductedMonth":"2024-02","submissions":17,"submitters":16,"spanYears":15.817,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":127,"evidenceRank":296,"evidenceScore":76.6,"freshAt":"2024-02-06T11:45:45Z","freshnessRank":446,"freshEventScore":60,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 127 pts / 127 comments (2020) + 60 pts / 52 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,363 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=162485","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1379782","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5267660","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8103337","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11364607","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15990484","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16878547","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":127,"peak_comments":127,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23166786","height":6,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29210826","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31720399","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":60,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39273245","height":4,"chart_height":80},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-wetware-crisis-the-dead-sea-effect-2008-d9d0233e7d84.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-wetware-crisis-the-dead-sea-effect-2008-d9d0233e7d84/"},{"slug":"the-lisp-curse-d9d02342fb26","title":"The Lisp Curse","domain":"www.winestockwebdesign.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2016-02","inductedMonth":"2019-09","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":10.943,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":268,"evidenceRank":297,"evidenceScore":76.5,"freshAt":"2022-03-25T10:44:20Z","freshnessRank":800,"freshEventScore":64,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 194 pts / 303 comments (2016) + 268 pts / 151 comments (2011), different submitters and 1,776 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":268,"peak_comments":151,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2450973","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":136,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3808194","height":7,"chart_height":86},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10709250","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":194,"peak_comments":303,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11174946","height":9,"chart_height":123},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":59,"peak_comments":98,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20919819","height":4,"chart_height":37},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":64,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30800520","height":4,"chart_height":41},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-lisp-curse-d9d02342fb26.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-lisp-curse-d9d02342fb26/"},{"slug":"why-japanese-web-design-is-so-different-2013-d9d0234b25c5","title":"Why Japanese web design is so different (2013)","domain":"randomwire.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design","web_development","language_linguistics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2020-11","inductedMonth":"2020-11","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":12.597,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":367,"evidenceRank":298,"evidenceScore":76.5,"freshAt":"2022-03-02T05:02:31Z","freshnessRank":817,"freshEventScore":183,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 367 pts / 207 comments (2020) + 257 pts / 153 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,025 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6731180","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":26,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8975735","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12445402","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":257,"peak_comments":153,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16254569","height":12,"chart_height":119},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":367,"peak_comments":207,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25148942","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":183,"peak_comments":106,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30523955","height":9,"chart_height":85},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48611731","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-japanese-web-design-is-so-different-2013-d9d0234b25c5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-japanese-web-design-is-so-different-2013-d9d0234b25c5/"},{"slug":"why-doctors-hate-their-computers-2018-d9d0235bef79","title":"Why Doctors Hate Their Computers (2018)","domain":"www.newyorker.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"medicine_health","topicDisplay":"Medicine & health","tags":["medicine","human_computer_interaction","workplace"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2022-10","inductedMonth":"2023-07","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.746,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":279,"evidenceRank":299,"evidenceScore":76.4,"freshAt":"2025-08-04T00:41:28Z","freshnessRank":176,"freshEventScore":121,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 279 pts / 317 comments (2020) + 121 pts / 219 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,798 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":157,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18381969","height":8,"chart_height":96},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":279,"peak_comments":317,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24336039","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33245768","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":100,"peak_comments":113,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36903220","height":5,"chart_height":61},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":121,"peak_comments":219,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44781116","height":6,"chart_height":74},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-doctors-hate-their-computers-2018-d9d0235bef79.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-doctors-hate-their-computers-2018-d9d0235bef79/"},{"slug":"vim-clutch-d9d023466bf3","title":"Vim clutch","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","electronics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2018-03","inductedMonth":"2021-03","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":12.32,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":546,"evidenceRank":300,"evidenceScore":76.4,"freshAt":"2022-06-21T19:09:11Z","freshnessRank":764,"freshEventScore":25,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 513 pts / 261 comments (2018) + 546 pts / 219 comments (2012), different submitters and 2,089 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":546,"peak_comments":219,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4141410","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10444153","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12808000","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":513,"peak_comments":261,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16563210","height":24,"chart_height":160},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":193,"peak_comments":165,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26430466","height":9,"chart_height":60},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":25,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31827844","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41855562","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/vim-clutch-d9d023466bf3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/vim-clutch-d9d023466bf3/"},{"slug":"fast-d9d0235da8bd","title":"Fast","domain":"patrickcollison.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["leadership","labor_productivity","history","cities_infrastructure"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-03","inductedMonth":"2022-03","submissions":16,"submitters":15,"spanYears":6.237,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1314,"evidenceRank":301,"evidenceScore":76.4,"freshAt":"2025-08-01T15:19:43Z","freshnessRank":178,"freshEventScore":93,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1314 pts / 291 comments (2019) + 905 pts / 298 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,292 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":9,"peak_score":1314,"peak_comments":291,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21848860","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27227005","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":189,"peak_comments":97,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30872279","height":9,"chart_height":24},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":905,"peak_comments":298,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36605912","height":24,"chart_height":117},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":93,"peak_comments":22,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44758132","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/fast-d9d0235da8bd.jpg","path":"/hall/link/fast-d9d0235da8bd/"},{"slug":"source-of-the-famous-now-you-have-two-problems-quote-2006-d9d02340b4c4","title":"Source of the famous “Now you have two problems” quote (2006)","domain":"regex.info","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2015-08","inductedMonth":"2020-12","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":14.133,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":159,"evidenceRank":302,"evidenceScore":76.4,"freshAt":"2020-12-14T10:30:06Z","freshnessRank":966,"freshEventScore":154,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 154 pts / 117 comments (2020) + 159 pts / 60 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,944 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":75,"peak_comments":18,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1195704","height":4,"chart_height":80},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3894663","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":145,"peak_comments":41,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5187686","height":7,"chart_height":155},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8811355","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":159,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10083420","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11291568","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":154,"peak_comments":117,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25415441","height":7,"chart_height":165},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37440818","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39106094","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/source-of-the-famous-now-you-have-two-problems-quote-2006-d9d02340b4c4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/source-of-the-famous-now-you-have-two-problems-quote-2006-d9d02340b4c4/"},{"slug":"non-english-based-programming-languages-d9d0233f62f6","title":"Non-English-based programming languages","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2019-06","inductedMonth":"2019-06","submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":16.646,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":262,"evidenceRank":303,"evidenceScore":76.3,"freshAt":"2019-06-30T17:50:59Z","freshnessRank":1057,"freshEventScore":262,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 262 pts / 222 comments (2019) + 77 pts / 75 comments (2013), different submitters and 2,127 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":30,"peak_comments":23,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=524758","height":4,"chart_height":19},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":77,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6315913","height":4,"chart_height":50},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":57,"peak_comments":18,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11961223","height":4,"chart_height":37},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14506485","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17030172","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":262,"peak_comments":222,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20319434","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28822707","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32705947","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36541105","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39388483","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45589788","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/non-english-based-programming-languages-d9d0233f62f6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/non-english-based-programming-languages-d9d0233f62f6/"},{"slug":"why-anti-authoritarians-are-diagnosed-as-mentally-ill-2012-d9d0234564a8","title":"Why Anti-Authoritarians Are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill (2012)","domain":"www.madinamerica.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"medicine_health","topicDisplay":"Medicine & health","tags":["mental_health","psychology","social_issues"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2016-03","inductedMonth":"2020-09","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":14.146,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":382,"evidenceRank":304,"evidenceScore":76.3,"freshAt":"2024-09-01T18:12:40Z","freshnessRank":339,"freshEventScore":85,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 382 pts / 290 comments (2016) + 225 pts / 204 comments (2013), different submitters and 1,051 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":304,"peak_comments":136,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3642570","height":15,"chart_height":135},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":225,"peak_comments":204,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5674438","height":11,"chart_height":100},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":382,"peak_comments":290,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11358931","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16673552","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24447989","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":85,"peak_comments":38,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41418943","height":4,"chart_height":38},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47860812","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-anti-authoritarians-are-diagnosed-as-mentally-ill-2012-d9d0234564a8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-anti-authoritarians-are-diagnosed-as-mentally-ill-2012-d9d0234564a8/"},{"slug":"gitless-a-simple-vcs-built-on-top-of-git-d9d0234f7abe","title":"Gitless a simple VCS built on top of Git","domain":"gitless.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-11","inductedMonth":"2021-04","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":8.293,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":516,"evidenceRank":305,"evidenceScore":76.2,"freshAt":"2023-06-17T14:01:06Z","freshnessRank":611,"freshEventScore":230,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 516 pts / 372 comments (2016) + 230 pts / 286 comments (2023), different submitters and 2,449 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":42,"peak_comments":47,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9144160","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":516,"peak_comments":372,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12621837","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":181,"peak_comments":138,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18512854","height":9,"chart_height":60},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26963622","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29984160","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":230,"peak_comments":286,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36370225","height":11,"chart_height":76},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/gitless-a-simple-vcs-built-on-top-of-git-d9d0234f7abe.jpg","path":"/hall/link/gitless-a-simple-vcs-built-on-top-of-git-d9d0234f7abe/"},{"slug":"the-art-of-command-line-2015-d9d023507d66","title":"The Art of Command Line (2015)","domain":"github.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-05","inductedMonth":"2021-05","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":8.893,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":597,"evidenceRank":306,"evidenceScore":76.2,"freshAt":"2022-11-24T01:29:31Z","freshnessRank":683,"freshEventScore":375,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 597 pts / 169 comments (2019) + 466 pts / 133 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,437 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":466,"peak_comments":133,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9720813","height":22,"chart_height":133},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12606519","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16071891","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":597,"peak_comments":169,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19988548","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27286799","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":375,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33726831","height":18,"chart_height":107},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40277086","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-art-of-command-line-2015-d9d023507d66.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-art-of-command-line-2015-d9d023507d66/"},{"slug":"it-s-not-wrong-that-length-7-d9d0235ee107","title":"It’s Not Wrong that “ ”.length == 7","domain":"hsivonen.fi","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","browsers_web_standards","language_linguistics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-10","inductedMonth":"2024-12","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.952,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":280,"evidenceRank":307,"evidenceScore":76.2,"freshAt":"2025-08-22T06:18:56Z","freshnessRank":166,"freshEventScore":195,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 280 pts / 303 comments (2023) + 195 pts / 274 comments (2025), different submitters and 812 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":230,"peak_comments":140,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20914184","height":11,"chart_height":140},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":116,"peak_comments":127,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26591373","height":6,"chart_height":70},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33369188","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":280,"peak_comments":303,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36159443","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42550461","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":195,"peak_comments":274,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44981525","height":9,"chart_height":118},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/it-s-not-wrong-that-length-7-d9d0235ee107.jpg","path":"/hall/link/it-s-not-wrong-that-length-7-d9d0235ee107/"},{"slug":"don-t-talk-to-police-d9d02358be19","title":"Don’t Talk to Police","domain":"www.youtube.com","category":"media","categoryDisplay":"Audio, video & images","type":"video","typeDisplay":"Video","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["social_issues"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2023-06","inductedMonth":"2023-06","submissions":15,"submitters":15,"spanYears":8.594,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":234,"evidenceRank":308,"evidenceScore":76.2,"freshAt":"2023-06-17T15:48:48Z","freshnessRank":610,"freshEventScore":234,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 234 pts / 225 comments (2023) + 190 pts / 165 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,015 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":190,"peak_comments":165,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15886628","height":9,"chart_height":138},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18288380","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19717507","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":25,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23390344","height":4,"chart_height":18},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":34,"peak_comments":14,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29526047","height":4,"chart_height":25},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":234,"peak_comments":225,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36371237","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45317167","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48630663","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/don-t-talk-to-police-d9d02358be19.jpg","path":"/hall/link/don-t-talk-to-police-d9d02358be19/"},{"slug":"build-your-own-text-editor-d9d02356a2f7","title":"Build Your Own Text Editor","domain":"viewsourcecode.org","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-01","inductedMonth":"2021-01","submissions":12,"submitters":11,"spanYears":7.899,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1275,"evidenceRank":309,"evidenceScore":76.1,"freshAt":"2022-11-13T10:52:46Z","freshnessRank":690,"freshEventScore":236,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1275 pts / 159 comments (2017) + 323 pts / 34 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,375 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":1275,"peak_comments":159,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14046446","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19198016","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22358650","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":323,"peak_comments":34,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25712949","height":16,"chart_height":43},{"year":2022,"count":4,"peak_score":236,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33581856","height":11,"chart_height":31},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41625316","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43194492","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/build-your-own-text-editor-d9d02356a2f7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/build-your-own-text-editor-d9d02356a2f7/"},{"slug":"the-tragedy-of-google-books-2017-d9d02356cd4e","title":"The Tragedy of Google Books (2017)","domain":"www.theatlantic.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["digital_archives","technology_ethics","journalism_media"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2024-10","inductedMonth":"2024-10","submissions":17,"submitters":15,"spanYears":8.783,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":503,"evidenceRank":310,"evidenceScore":76.1,"freshAt":"2024-10-22T18:11:03Z","freshnessRank":310,"freshEventScore":503,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 503 pts / 179 comments (2024) + 310 pts / 71 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,740 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":310,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14172791","height":15,"chart_height":105},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19199549","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23284973","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":20,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26125334","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31975624","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":503,"peak_comments":179,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41917016","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46863670","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-tragedy-of-google-books-2017-d9d02356cd4e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-tragedy-of-google-books-2017-d9d02356cd4e/"},{"slug":"400m-in-assets-to-bankrupt-in-45-minutes-because-of-a-failed-dep-d9d0234cb5f4","title":"$400M in assets to bankrupt in 45-minutes because of a failed deployment (2014)","domain":"dougseven.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["performance_reliability","developer_tools","management_strategy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2020-02","inductedMonth":"2023-09","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":9.374,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":460,"evidenceRank":311,"evidenceScore":76.1,"freshAt":"2023-09-10T20:07:12Z","freshnessRank":550,"freshEventScore":460,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 460 pts / 275 comments (2023) + 207 pts / 85 comments (2015), different submitters and 3,140 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7652036","height":5,"chart_height":37},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":207,"peak_comments":85,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8994701","height":10,"chart_height":76},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12166551","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15580478","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":120,"peak_comments":33,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22250847","height":6,"chart_height":44},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28391267","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":460,"peak_comments":275,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37459495","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/400m-in-assets-to-bankrupt-in-45-minutes-because-of-a-failed-dep-d9d0234cb5f4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/400m-in-assets-to-bankrupt-in-45-minutes-because-of-a-failed-dep-d9d0234cb5f4/"},{"slug":"mosh-ssh-for-2012-d9d02345c268","title":"Mosh: SSH for 2012","domain":"mosh.mit.edu","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2014-09","inductedMonth":"2014-09","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":4.049,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":900,"evidenceRank":312,"evidenceScore":76.1,"freshAt":"2016-04-26T14:29:52Z","freshnessRank":1152,"freshEventScore":469,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 900 pts / 193 comments (2012) + 469 pts / 148 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,477 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":5,"peak_score":900,"peak_comments":193,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3819382","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":4,"peak_score":257,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5016745","height":12,"chart_height":49},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":402,"peak_comments":122,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8252093","height":19,"chart_height":76},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":469,"peak_comments":148,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11572146","height":23,"chart_height":89},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/mosh-ssh-for-2012-d9d02345c268.jpg","path":"/hall/link/mosh-ssh-for-2012-d9d02345c268/"},{"slug":"kill-the-newsletter-convert-email-newsletters-into-atom-feeds-d9d023553df4","title":"Kill the Newsletter – Convert email newsletters into Atom feeds","domain":"kill-the-newsletter.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","internet_infrastructure","online_communities"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-02","inductedMonth":"2021-02","submissions":12,"submitters":11,"spanYears":7.767,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":344,"evidenceRank":313,"evidenceScore":76.1,"freshAt":"2024-08-21T17:15:29Z","freshnessRank":343,"freshEventScore":114,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 344 pts / 123 comments (2021) + 343 pts / 109 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,556 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":343,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12949154","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21636106","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22474337","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":344,"peak_comments":123,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26167248","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33704008","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35605546","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":114,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41312259","height":5,"chart_height":56},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/kill-the-newsletter-convert-email-newsletters-into-atom-feeds-d9d023553df4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/kill-the-newsletter-convert-email-newsletters-into-atom-feeds-d9d023553df4/"},{"slug":"an-app-can-be-a-home-cooked-meal-2020-d9d023607afd","title":"An app can be a home-cooked meal (2020)","domain":"www.robinsloan.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["product_design","user_experience","writing_craft"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2022-09","inductedMonth":"2022-09","submissions":16,"submitters":15,"spanYears":5.7,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1051,"evidenceRank":314,"evidenceScore":76.0,"freshAt":"2024-01-05T10:03:27Z","freshnessRank":466,"freshEventScore":1051,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1051 pts / 288 comments (2024) + 556 pts / 130 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,420 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":556,"peak_comments":130,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22332629","height":24,"chart_height":90},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29127927","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":4,"peak_score":186,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32800518","height":9,"chart_height":30},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":4,"peak_score":1051,"peak_comments":288,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38877423","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44572403","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/an-app-can-be-a-home-cooked-meal-2020-d9d023607afd.jpg","path":"/hall/link/an-app-can-be-a-home-cooked-meal-2020-d9d023607afd/"},{"slug":"cold-showers-d9d023591411","title":"Cold Showers","domain":"github.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["philosophy","technology_ethics","internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2022-06","inductedMonth":"2024-01","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":7.849,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":629,"evidenceRank":315,"evidenceScore":76.0,"freshAt":"2025-11-03T22:28:37Z","freshnessRank":121,"freshEventScore":34,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 588 pts / 241 comments (2020) + 215 pts / 162 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,259 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16023947","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":38,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17604379","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":588,"peak_comments":241,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23935943","height":24,"chart_height":159},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":629,"peak_comments":355,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31793030","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":215,"peak_comments":162,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38870727","height":10,"chart_height":58},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":34,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45805217","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/cold-showers-d9d023591411.jpg","path":"/hall/link/cold-showers-d9d023591411/"},{"slug":"hiring-without-whiteboards-d9d023566bb5","title":"Hiring Without Whiteboards","domain":"github.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["hiring_interviews","workplace"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-07","inductedMonth":"2022-02","submissions":10,"submitters":9,"spanYears":6.845,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":481,"evidenceRank":316,"evidenceScore":75.9,"freshAt":"2020-07-28T23:26:45Z","freshnessRank":997,"freshEventScore":481,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 481 pts / 450 comments (2020) + 423 pts / 363 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,231 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":423,"peak_comments":363,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13874026","height":20,"chart_height":150},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":369,"peak_comments":232,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19290044","height":18,"chart_height":130},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":481,"peak_comments":450,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23981795","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":5,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31436833","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35039144","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39036153","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/hiring-without-whiteboards-d9d023566bb5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/hiring-without-whiteboards-d9d023566bb5/"},{"slug":"never-use-black-2012-d9d02346d4ea","title":"Never Use Black (2012)","domain":"ianstormtaylor.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2020-08","inductedMonth":"2020-08","submissions":10,"submitters":6,"spanYears":9.32,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":761,"evidenceRank":317,"evidenceScore":75.9,"freshAt":"2021-12-03T14:21:08Z","freshnessRank":851,"freshEventScore":320,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 761 pts / 210 comments (2012) + 320 pts / 217 comments (2021), different submitters and 3,403 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":761,"peak_comments":210,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4357002","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9131748","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12760763","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14478423","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":87,"peak_comments":44,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17334627","height":4,"chart_height":19},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":158,"peak_comments":162,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24303042","height":8,"chart_height":35},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":320,"peak_comments":217,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29430288","height":15,"chart_height":71},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/never-use-black-2012-d9d02346d4ea.jpg","path":"/hall/link/never-use-black-2012-d9d02346d4ea/"},{"slug":"rob-pike-s-rules-of-programming-1989-d9d0234d546e","title":"Rob Pike's Rules of Programming (1989)","domain":"users.ece.utexas.edu","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["performance_reliability","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2017-11","inductedMonth":"2023-11","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":11.083,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":631,"evidenceRank":318,"evidenceScore":75.8,"freshAt":"2023-11-01T11:47:53Z","freshnessRank":502,"freshEventScore":473,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 631 pts / 323 comments (2020) + 473 pts / 259 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,175 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":237,"peak_comments":96,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7994102","height":11,"chart_height":64},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":383,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15265356","height":18,"chart_height":103},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":631,"peak_comments":323,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24135189","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":473,"peak_comments":259,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38097031","height":23,"chart_height":127},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44796320","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/rob-pike-s-rules-of-programming-1989-d9d0234d546e/"},{"slug":"sonic-pi-is-a-code-based-music-creation-and-performance-tool-d9d0234dfd4b","title":"Sonic Pi is a code-based music creation and performance tool","domain":"sonic-pi.net","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["music","programming_languages","teaching"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2018-07","inductedMonth":"2020-05","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":11.277,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":342,"evidenceRank":319,"evidenceScore":75.8,"freshAt":"2022-11-08T06:18:48Z","freshnessRank":693,"freshEventScore":301,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 342 pts / 66 comments (2020) + 301 pts / 64 comments (2022), different submitters and 917 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":117,"peak_comments":28,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8344827","height":6,"chart_height":58},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9707703","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":280,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17632999","height":13,"chart_height":139},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":342,"peak_comments":66,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23066922","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":301,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33516405","height":14,"chart_height":150},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46432764","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/sonic-pi-is-a-code-based-music-creation-and-performance-tool-d9d0234dfd4b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/sonic-pi-is-a-code-based-music-creation-and-performance-tool-d9d0234dfd4b/"},{"slug":"computer-science-from-the-bottom-up-2013-d9d0234c14cc","title":"Computer Science from the Bottom Up (2013)","domain":"www.bottomupcs.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["computer_architecture","operating_systems","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2021-04","inductedMonth":"2021-04","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":11.959,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":516,"evidenceRank":320,"evidenceScore":75.8,"freshAt":"2023-09-10T00:00:17Z","freshnessRank":551,"freshEventScore":119,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 516 pts / 156 comments (2016) + 307 pts / 100 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,587 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8500108","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10002853","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":516,"peak_comments":156,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13249675","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21898829","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":307,"peak_comments":100,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26981668","height":15,"chart_height":101},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":119,"peak_comments":21,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37451551","height":6,"chart_height":39},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46925578","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/computer-science-from-the-bottom-up-2013-d9d0234c14cc.jpg","path":"/hall/link/computer-science-from-the-bottom-up-2013-d9d0234c14cc/"},{"slug":"the-theory-of-relativity-in-words-of-four-letters-or-less-d9d0233e706a","title":"The theory of relativity in words of four letters or less","domain":"www.muppetlabs.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["physics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2025-04","inductedMonth":"2025-04","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":17.062,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":240,"evidenceRank":321,"evidenceScore":75.7,"freshAt":"2025-04-14T05:22:44Z","freshnessRank":221,"freshEventScore":240,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 240 pts / 130 comments (2025) + 228 pts / 126 comments (2013), different submitters and 4,349 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=143407","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1325669","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":228,"peak_comments":126,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5724813","height":11,"chart_height":162},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10933120","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15838012","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25058507","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36466073","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":240,"peak_comments":130,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43678312","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-theory-of-relativity-in-words-of-four-letters-or-less-d9d0233e706a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-theory-of-relativity-in-words-of-four-letters-or-less-d9d0233e706a/"},{"slug":"your-body-wasn-t-built-to-last-a-lesson-from-human-mortality-rat-d9d0233fcd7f","title":"Your body wasn’t built to last: a lesson from human mortality rates","domain":"gravityandlevity.wordpress.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"medicine_health","topicDisplay":"Medicine & health","tags":["public_health"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2013-12","inductedMonth":"2015-04","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":16.808,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":266,"evidenceRank":322,"evidenceScore":75.7,"freshAt":"2018-02-15T06:38:22Z","freshnessRank":1110,"freshEventScore":88,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 151 pts / 175 comments (2013) + 266 pts / 108 comments (2012), different submitters and 720 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":51,"peak_comments":37,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=737709","height":4,"chart_height":33},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":266,"peak_comments":108,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3443337","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":151,"peak_comments":175,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6984944","height":7,"chart_height":97},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":85,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9414176","height":4,"chart_height":54},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":88,"peak_comments":26,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16382322","height":4,"chart_height":56},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43398981","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48256260","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/your-body-wasn-t-built-to-last-a-lesson-from-human-mortality-rat-d9d0233fcd7f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/your-body-wasn-t-built-to-last-a-lesson-from-human-mortality-rat-d9d0233fcd7f/"},{"slug":"building-a-modern-computer-from-first-principles-d9d023476044","title":"Building a Modern Computer from First Principles","domain":"www.nand2tetris.org","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"course_lecture","typeDisplay":"Courses & lectures","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["computer_architecture","programming_languages","teaching"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2016-08","inductedMonth":"2023-12","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":13.561,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":667,"evidenceRank":323,"evidenceScore":75.6,"freshAt":"2023-12-22T15:31:59Z","freshnessRank":476,"freshEventScore":667,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 667 pts / 174 comments (2023) + 238 pts / 83 comments (2013), different submitters and 3,841 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4643836","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":238,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5888705","height":11,"chart_height":61},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8203302","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10369795","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":171,"peak_comments":26,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12333508","height":8,"chart_height":44},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":47,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27030046","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":667,"peak_comments":174,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38735066","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48030390","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/building-a-modern-computer-from-first-principles-d9d023476044.jpg","path":"/hall/link/building-a-modern-computer-from-first-principles-d9d023476044/"},{"slug":"opensnitch-is-a-gnu-linux-port-of-the-little-snitch-application-d9d02356bf90","title":"OpenSnitch is a GNU/Linux port of the Little Snitch application firewall","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"source_code","typeDisplay":"Source code","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security","open_source","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-01","inductedMonth":"2022-06","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":7.316,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":589,"evidenceRank":324,"evidenceScore":75.6,"freshAt":"2024-08-10T14:15:52Z","freshnessRank":351,"freshEventScore":408,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 589 pts / 131 comments (2020) + 408 pts / 101 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,652 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":319,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14245270","height":15,"chart_height":92},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":589,"peak_comments":131,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22206116","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":208,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31876220","height":10,"chart_height":60},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":408,"peak_comments":101,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41209688","height":20,"chart_height":118},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/opensnitch-is-a-gnu-linux-port-of-the-little-snitch-application-d9d02356bf90.jpg","path":"/hall/link/opensnitch-is-a-gnu-linux-port-of-the-little-snitch-application-d9d02356bf90/"},{"slug":"who-wants-to-be-a-thousandaire-2011-d9d0234408dd","title":"Who Wants to Be a Thousandaire? (2011)","domain":"www.damninteresting.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["film_television"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2021-01","inductedMonth":"2021-01","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":14.034,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":233,"evidenceRank":325,"evidenceScore":75.6,"freshAt":"2024-05-08T11:27:23Z","freshnessRank":403,"freshEventScore":233,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 233 pts / 156 comments (2024) + 217 pts / 114 comments (2015), different submitters and 3,276 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2989450","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":217,"peak_comments":114,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9570713","height":10,"chart_height":158},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23252460","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":185,"peak_comments":110,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25664433","height":9,"chart_height":135},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":233,"peak_comments":156,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40296744","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45369321","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/who-wants-to-be-a-thousandaire-2011-d9d0234408dd.jpg","path":"/hall/link/who-wants-to-be-a-thousandaire-2011-d9d0234408dd/"},{"slug":"micropython-d9d0234b33ac","title":"MicroPython","domain":"micropython.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["embedded_iot","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2020-08","inductedMonth":"2020-08","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":11.354,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":338,"evidenceRank":326,"evidenceScore":75.5,"freshAt":"2022-06-06T12:40:15Z","freshnessRank":770,"freshEventScore":251,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 338 pts / 147 comments (2020) + 103 pts / 19 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,917 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6763123","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":76,"peak_comments":17,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8177695","height":4,"chart_height":38},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":103,"peak_comments":19,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9558969","height":5,"chart_height":52},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19212177","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":338,"peak_comments":147,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24166861","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":251,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31639707","height":12,"chart_height":126},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43505492","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/micropython-d9d0234b33ac.jpg","path":"/hall/link/micropython-d9d0234b33ac/"},{"slug":"delta-chat-is-a-decentralized-and-secure-messenger-app-d9d02357476c","title":"Delta Chat is a decentralized and secure messenger app","domain":"delta.chat","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography","privacy_surveillance","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2025-06","inductedMonth":"2025-06","submissions":15,"submitters":14,"spanYears":8.022,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":309,"evidenceRank":327,"evidenceScore":75.5,"freshAt":"2025-06-21T06:29:00Z","freshnessRank":195,"freshEventScore":309,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 309 pts / 203 comments (2025) + 220 pts / 148 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,608 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14543063","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":4,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16678319","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":51,"peak_comments":11,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19263357","height":4,"chart_height":28},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":220,"peak_comments":148,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25893626","height":11,"chart_height":121},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32561979","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35007980","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39367895","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":309,"peak_comments":203,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44335065","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/delta-chat-is-a-decentralized-and-secure-messenger-app-d9d02357476c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/delta-chat-is-a-decentralized-and-secure-messenger-app-d9d02357476c/"},{"slug":"new-mac-mini-d9d023477888","title":"New Mac Mini","domain":"www.apple.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["computer_architecture","product_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2018-10","inductedMonth":"2020-11","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":10.234,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":305,"evidenceRank":328,"evidenceScore":75.5,"freshAt":"2023-01-17T14:22:53Z","freshnessRank":668,"freshEventScore":305,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 305 pts / 404 comments (2023) + 283 pts / 248 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,035 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4689789","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":192,"peak_comments":129,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8466454","height":9,"chart_height":107},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":84,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18336780","height":4,"chart_height":47},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":283,"peak_comments":248,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22615946","height":14,"chart_height":158},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":305,"peak_comments":404,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34412671","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/new-mac-mini-d9d023477888.jpg","path":"/hall/link/new-mac-mini-d9d023477888/"},{"slug":"pure-bash-bible-d9d0235aa7ef","title":"Pure Bash Bible","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","programming_languages","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2022-02","inductedMonth":"2022-02","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":7.066,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":746,"evidenceRank":329,"evidenceScore":75.4,"freshAt":"2023-08-09T01:55:47Z","freshnessRank":576,"freshEventScore":191,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 746 pts / 248 comments (2019) + 291 pts / 96 comments (2022), different submitters and 881 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":6,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17386213","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":746,"peak_comments":248,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21013150","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29481703","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":291,"peak_comments":96,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30363506","height":14,"chart_height":66},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":191,"peak_comments":101,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37057866","height":9,"chart_height":44},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43450630","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/pure-bash-bible-d9d0235aa7ef.jpg","path":"/hall/link/pure-bash-bible-d9d0235aa7ef/"},{"slug":"who-goes-nazi-1941-d9d02352a27f","title":"Who Goes Nazi? (1941)","domain":"harpers.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2018-02","inductedMonth":"2019-12","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":10.094,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":197,"evidenceRank":330,"evidenceScore":75.4,"freshAt":"2026-03-13T19:58:02Z","freshnessRank":46,"freshEventScore":44,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 120 pts / 122 comments (2016) + 197 pts / 116 comments (2018), different submitters and 748 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":120,"peak_comments":122,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11053415","height":6,"chart_height":104},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15941871","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":197,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16455813","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21801144","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22228889","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":41,"peak_comments":28,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27204311","height":4,"chart_height":35},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":41,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34515012","height":4,"chart_height":35},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":67,"peak_comments":29,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41249066","height":4,"chart_height":58},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":44,"peak_comments":22,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47369036","height":4,"chart_height":38}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/who-goes-nazi-1941-d9d02352a27f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/who-goes-nazi-1941-d9d02352a27f/"},{"slug":"hacker-typer-now-you-can-type-like-a-hacker-in-movies-d9d023430c75","title":"Hacker Typer - now you can type like a hacker in movies","domain":"hackertyper.net","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2024-10","inductedMonth":"2024-10","submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":13.473,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":272,"evidenceRank":331,"evidenceScore":75.4,"freshAt":"2024-10-15T10:41:33Z","freshnessRank":315,"freshEventScore":272,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 272 pts / 131 comments (2024) + 162 pts / 43 comments (2011), different submitters and 4,920 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":162,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2485159","height":8,"chart_height":101},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":91,"peak_comments":32,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6865571","height":4,"chart_height":57},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8701060","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":4,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11298735","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13657310","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22501975","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27578127","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":60,"peak_comments":33,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32314952","height":4,"chart_height":38},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":272,"peak_comments":131,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41847149","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/hacker-typer-now-you-can-type-like-a-hacker-in-movies-d9d023430c75.jpg","path":"/hall/link/hacker-typer-now-you-can-type-like-a-hacker-in-movies-d9d023430c75/"},{"slug":"50-years-ago-sugar-industry-quietly-paid-scientists-to-blame-fat-d9d0235a1e7b","title":"50 Years Ago, Sugar Industry Quietly Paid Scientists to Blame Fat (2016)","domain":"www.npr.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"medicine_health","topicDisplay":"Medicine & health","tags":["nutrition_fitness","public_health","scientific_method","economics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-02","inductedMonth":"2024-10","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":8.183,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":789,"evidenceRank":332,"evidenceScore":75.4,"freshAt":"2024-10-27T14:10:47Z","freshnessRank":307,"freshEventScore":188,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 789 pts / 460 comments (2021) + 645 pts / 279 comments (2019), different submitters and 756 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16866543","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":645,"peak_comments":279,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18944011","height":24,"chart_height":139},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":789,"peak_comments":460,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26126183","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":173,"peak_comments":84,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32978590","height":8,"chart_height":37},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":188,"peak_comments":170,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41962750","height":9,"chart_height":41},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48658230","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/50-years-ago-sugar-industry-quietly-paid-scientists-to-blame-fat-d9d0235a1e7b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/50-years-ago-sugar-industry-quietly-paid-scientists-to-blame-fat-d9d0235a1e7b/"},{"slug":"ipad-pro-d9d02340784b","title":"iPad Pro","domain":"www.apple.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":[],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2017-06","inductedMonth":"2017-06","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":11.228,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":269,"evidenceRank":333,"evidenceScore":75.4,"freshAt":"2017-06-05T18:55:21Z","freshnessRank":1123,"freshEventScore":269,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 269 pts / 386 comments (2017) + 108 pts / 175 comments (2010), different submitters and 2,685 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":108,"peak_comments":175,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1081397","height":5,"chart_height":68},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2280675","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":6,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3676722","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6593956","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":269,"peak_comments":386,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14490292","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24484567","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26877850","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/ipad-pro-d9d02340784b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/ipad-pro-d9d02340784b/"},{"slug":"the-wrong-abstraction-2016-d9d02356215e","title":"The Wrong Abstraction (2016)","domain":"www.sandimetz.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","programming_languages","testing_quality"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-07","inductedMonth":"2023-05","submissions":11,"submitters":10,"spanYears":9.344,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":717,"evidenceRank":334,"evidenceScore":75.3,"freshAt":"2026-06-21T16:08:23Z","freshnessRank":3,"freshEventScore":60,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 654 pts / 240 comments (2020) + 154 pts / 69 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,041 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15416958","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":717,"peak_comments":207,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17578714","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":654,"peak_comments":240,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23739596","height":24,"chart_height":155},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":64,"peak_comments":17,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27095503","height":4,"chart_height":15},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":154,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35927149","height":7,"chart_height":37},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":60,"peak_comments":28,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48620090","height":4,"chart_height":14}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-wrong-abstraction-2016-d9d02356215e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-wrong-abstraction-2016-d9d02356215e/"},{"slug":"bash-pitfalls-d9d023400e63","title":"Bash Pitfalls","domain":"mywiki.wooledge.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2020-09","inductedMonth":"2020-09","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":16.589,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":288,"evidenceRank":335,"evidenceScore":75.3,"freshAt":"2022-02-15T12:19:04Z","freshnessRank":825,"freshEventScore":106,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 288 pts / 111 comments (2020) + 114 pts / 38 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,849 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":60,"peak_comments":25,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=869560","height":4,"chart_height":35},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8439416","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":114,"peak_comments":38,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10068567","height":5,"chart_height":67},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18841028","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":288,"peak_comments":111,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24401085","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":106,"peak_comments":32,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30345487","height":5,"chart_height":63},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40875105","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48092019","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/bash-pitfalls-d9d023400e63.jpg","path":"/hall/link/bash-pitfalls-d9d023400e63/"},{"slug":"things-that-turbo-pascal-is-smaller-than-2011-d9d023446a76","title":"Things That Turbo Pascal Is Smaller Than (2011)","domain":"prog21.dadgum.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","retrocomputing"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2020-04","inductedMonth":"2020-04","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":14.387,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":367,"evidenceRank":336,"evidenceScore":75.3,"freshAt":"2024-10-20T06:15:14Z","freshnessRank":311,"freshEventScore":31,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 297 pts / 170 comments (2020) + 367 pts / 114 comments (2011), different submitters and 3,085 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":367,"peak_comments":114,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3175629","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3644166","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11733610","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":79,"peak_comments":15,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15104766","height":4,"chart_height":37},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":297,"peak_comments":170,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22843140","height":14,"chart_height":138},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28736383","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":68,"peak_comments":32,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30644308","height":4,"chart_height":31},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":31,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41893287","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47452859","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/things-that-turbo-pascal-is-smaller-than-2011-d9d023446a76.jpg","path":"/hall/link/things-that-turbo-pascal-is-smaller-than-2011-d9d023446a76/"},{"slug":"keep-your-stuff-for-life-d9d02358fae2","title":"Keep Your Stuff, for Life","domain":"perkeep.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["databases_storage","privacy_surveillance","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-06","inductedMonth":"2022-03","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":7.91,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":355,"evidenceRank":337,"evidenceScore":75.2,"freshAt":"2025-11-12T03:34:32Z","freshnessRank":117,"freshEventScore":334,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 355 pts / 109 comments (2020) + 334 pts / 75 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,961 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":255,"peak_comments":105,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15928685","height":12,"chart_height":122},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":355,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23676350","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30830790","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37480399","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":334,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45896130","height":16,"chart_height":160},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/keep-your-stuff-for-life-d9d02358fae2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/keep-your-stuff-for-life-d9d02358fae2/"},{"slug":"free-public-domain-audiobooks-d9d02350b371","title":"Free public domain audiobooks","domain":"librivox.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["books_literature"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2020-06","inductedMonth":"2021-11","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":9.9,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":370,"evidenceRank":338,"evidenceScore":75.2,"freshAt":"2025-06-01T21:02:58Z","freshnessRank":204,"freshEventScore":259,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 370 pts / 59 comments (2021) + 259 pts / 67 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,280 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10513396","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":179,"peak_comments":37,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11141452","height":9,"chart_height":82},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":286,"peak_comments":81,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23558686","height":14,"chart_height":131},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":370,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29382006","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":103,"peak_comments":22,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35849368","height":5,"chart_height":47},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":259,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44153738","height":12,"chart_height":119},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/free-public-domain-audiobooks-d9d02350b371.jpg","path":"/hall/link/free-public-domain-audiobooks-d9d02350b371/"},{"slug":"aether-free-privacy-sensitive-public-communities-d9d0234e52f6","title":"Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities","domain":"getaether.net","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["online_communities","privacy_surveillance","open_source","protocols_networking"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2018-11","inductedMonth":"2020-01","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":11.066,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":290,"evidenceRank":339,"evidenceScore":75.2,"freshAt":"2018-11-03T14:10:24Z","freshnessRank":1078,"freshEventScore":290,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 290 pts / 221 comments (2018) + 207 pts / 102 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,218 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8516774","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":207,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9828061","height":10,"chart_height":121},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":290,"peak_comments":221,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18370208","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22910717","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26474344","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32763560","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34487205","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45996474","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/aether-free-privacy-sensitive-public-communities-d9d0234e52f6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/aether-free-privacy-sensitive-public-communities-d9d0234e52f6/"},{"slug":"exploring-different-microcontrollers-less-than-1-d9d02358a075","title":"Exploring different microcontrollers less than $1","domain":"jaycarlson.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["embedded_iot","computer_architecture","manufacturing"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-09","inductedMonth":"2024-04","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.976,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":929,"evidenceRank":340,"evidenceScore":75.2,"freshAt":"2024-04-30T14:51:14Z","freshnessRank":409,"freshEventScore":20,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 929 pts / 183 comments (2017) + 332 pts / 177 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,038 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":929,"peak_comments":183,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15633785","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":670,"peak_comments":195,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19851744","height":24,"chart_height":123},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":332,"peak_comments":177,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24426882","height":16,"chart_height":61},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":173,"peak_comments":93,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30575434","height":8,"chart_height":32},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":20,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40211583","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/exploring-different-microcontrollers-less-than-1-d9d02358a075.jpg","path":"/hall/link/exploring-different-microcontrollers-less-than-1-d9d02358a075/"},{"slug":"manim-3blue1brown-s-animation-engine-for-explanatory-math-videos-d9d02356efcc","title":"Manim – 3Blue1Brown's animation engine for explanatory math videos","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","computer_graphics","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-10","inductedMonth":"2022-06","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":8.298,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":669,"evidenceRank":341,"evidenceScore":75.2,"freshAt":"2025-08-23T07:35:49Z","freshnessRank":165,"freshEventScore":434,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 669 pts / 80 comments (2019) + 434 pts / 68 comments (2025), different submitters and 2,315 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14281412","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":669,"peak_comments":80,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19716019","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":283,"peak_comments":19,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24926947","height":14,"chart_height":72},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":124,"peak_comments":16,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31636657","height":6,"chart_height":32},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41659403","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":434,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44994071","height":21,"chart_height":110},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/manim-3blue1brown-s-animation-engine-for-explanatory-math-videos-d9d02356efcc.jpg","path":"/hall/link/manim-3blue1brown-s-animation-engine-for-explanatory-math-videos-d9d02356efcc/"},{"slug":"how-developers-stop-learning-rise-of-the-expert-beginner-2012-d9d0234922c2","title":"How Developers Stop Learning: Rise of the Expert Beginner (2012)","domain":"daedtech.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["careers","leadership"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2019-03","inductedMonth":"2020-07","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":10.418,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":672,"evidenceRank":342,"evidenceScore":75.1,"freshAt":"2023-09-17T16:53:41Z","freshnessRank":543,"freshEventScore":33,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 672 pts / 432 comments (2020) + 238 pts / 85 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,569 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5565772","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8589922","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8839252","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":238,"peak_comments":85,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11327669","height":11,"chart_height":60},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18714386","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":157,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19467367","height":8,"chart_height":40},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":672,"peak_comments":432,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23767438","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29718730","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":33,"peak_comments":10,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37547076","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-developers-stop-learning-rise-of-the-expert-beginner-2012-d9d0234922c2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-developers-stop-learning-rise-of-the-expert-beginner-2012-d9d0234922c2/"},{"slug":"bret-victor-learnable-programming-d9d023473e87","title":"Bret Victor: Learnable Programming","domain":"worrydream.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["human_computer_interaction","programming_languages","teaching"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2021-07","inductedMonth":"2021-07","submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":11.017,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1080,"evidenceRank":343,"evidenceScore":75.0,"freshAt":"2023-10-03T01:44:21Z","freshnessRank":531,"freshEventScore":74,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1080 pts / 183 comments (2012) + 117 pts / 30 comments (2021), different submitters and 3,209 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":1080,"peak_comments":183,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4577133","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7153739","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10644047","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13132981","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13789503","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16869111","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19026023","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22399355","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":117,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27799420","height":6,"chart_height":18},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":74,"peak_comments":20,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37746918","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/bret-victor-learnable-programming-d9d023473e87.jpg","path":"/hall/link/bret-victor-learnable-programming-d9d023473e87/"},{"slug":"main-is-usually-a-function-so-when-is-it-not-2015-d9d0234f1f0f","title":"Main is usually a function, so when is it not? (2015)","domain":"jroweboy.github.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","compilers_runtimes","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2017-09","inductedMonth":"2017-09","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":8.528,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":338,"evidenceRank":344,"evidenceScore":74.9,"freshAt":"2023-08-08T07:47:15Z","freshnessRank":578,"freshEventScore":127,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 338 pts / 60 comments (2015) + 224 pts / 63 comments (2021), different submitters and 2,330 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":338,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8951283","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12799637","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":136,"peak_comments":65,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15206198","height":7,"chart_height":68},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18948681","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24322446","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":224,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27504254","height":11,"chart_height":113},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":127,"peak_comments":55,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37045803","height":6,"chart_height":64},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/main-is-usually-a-function-so-when-is-it-not-2015-d9d0234f1f0f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/main-is-usually-a-function-so-when-is-it-not-2015-d9d0234f1f0f/"},{"slug":"cargo-cult-science-1974-d9d023520aa7","title":"Cargo Cult Science (1974)","domain":"calteches.library.caltech.edu","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["scientific_method"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-09","inductedMonth":"2023-03","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":7.258,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":174,"evidenceRank":345,"evidenceScore":74.9,"freshAt":"2023-03-06T14:41:04Z","freshnessRank":647,"freshEventScore":174,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 174 pts / 156 comments (2023) + 142 pts / 33 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,252 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10666200","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":139,"peak_comments":38,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11669004","height":7,"chart_height":136},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15599046","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16168752","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":142,"peak_comments":33,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21120637","height":7,"chart_height":139},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":128,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26563567","height":6,"chart_height":125},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32146683","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":174,"peak_comments":156,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35041549","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/cargo-cult-science-1974-d9d023520aa7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/cargo-cult-science-1974-d9d023520aa7/"},{"slug":"gleam-a-statically-typed-language-for-the-erlang-vm-d9d0235d43bc","title":"Gleam: A statically typed language for the Erlang VM","domain":"gleam.run","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","distributed_systems","compilers_runtimes"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-11","inductedMonth":"2023-11","submissions":9,"submitters":8,"spanYears":6.804,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":331,"evidenceRank":346,"evidenceScore":74.9,"freshAt":"2026-01-14T02:49:25Z","freshnessRank":79,"freshEventScore":273,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 325 pts / 236 comments (2023) + 273 pts / 177 comments (2026), different submitters and 798 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19505968","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":331,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22902462","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33017653","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":325,"peak_comments":236,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38183454","height":16,"chart_height":167},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44230649","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":273,"peak_comments":177,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46611667","height":13,"chart_height":140}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/gleam-a-statically-typed-language-for-the-erlang-vm-d9d0235d43bc.jpg","path":"/hall/link/gleam-a-statically-typed-language-for-the-erlang-vm-d9d0235d43bc/"},{"slug":"a-brief-rant-on-the-future-of-interaction-design-d9d023447d14","title":"A Brief Rant on the Future of Interaction Design","domain":"worrydream.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["user_experience","human_computer_interaction","product_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2022-05","inductedMonth":"2022-05","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":10.732,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":830,"evidenceRank":347,"evidenceScore":74.9,"freshAt":"2022-05-25T22:12:58Z","freshnessRank":779,"freshEventScore":238,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 830 pts / 150 comments (2011) + 238 pts / 132 comments (2022), different submitters and 3,851 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":830,"peak_comments":150,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3212949","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":83,"peak_comments":35,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6325996","height":4,"chart_height":17},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7429742","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8960370","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16459588","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18933399","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24395012","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25724241","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":238,"peak_comments":132,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31511361","height":11,"chart_height":49},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-brief-rant-on-the-future-of-interaction-design-d9d023447d14.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-brief-rant-on-the-future-of-interaction-design-d9d023447d14/"},{"slug":"georgism-d9d0234a9533","title":"Georgism","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["economics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2023-09","inductedMonth":"2023-09","submissions":11,"submitters":10,"spanYears":11.929,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":210,"evidenceRank":348,"evidenceScore":74.8,"freshAt":"2023-09-19T04:44:04Z","freshnessRank":542,"freshEventScore":99,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 210 pts / 332 comments (2020) + 99 pts / 103 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,219 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6402110","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10437474","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12402723","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16342123","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21497939","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":210,"peak_comments":332,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23210804","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29186340","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":99,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37565682","height":5,"chart_height":80},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44984768","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/georgism-d9d0234a9533.jpg","path":"/hall/link/georgism-d9d0234a9533/"},{"slug":"algorithms-by-jeff-erickson-d9d02353551e","title":"Algorithms, by Jeff Erickson","domain":"jeffe.cs.illinois.edu","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["algorithms_data_structures","theory_of_computation","teaching"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-02","inductedMonth":"2021-02","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":7.567,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1463,"evidenceRank":349,"evidenceScore":74.8,"freshAt":"2023-11-13T19:28:01Z","freshnessRank":496,"freshEventScore":138,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1463 pts / 238 comments (2019) + 595 pts / 152 comments (2021), different submitters and 768 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11525059","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15904019","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":66,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16379236","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":1463,"peak_comments":238,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18805624","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23563249","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":595,"peak_comments":152,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26074289","height":24,"chart_height":69},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":138,"peak_comments":23,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38254153","height":7,"chart_height":16},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/algorithms-by-jeff-erickson-d9d02353551e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/algorithms-by-jeff-erickson-d9d02353551e/"},{"slug":"fd-a-simple-fast-and-user-friendly-alternative-to-find-d9d023573d0a","title":"fd: A simple, fast and user-friendly alternative to 'find'","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2022-05","inductedMonth":"2022-05","submissions":9,"submitters":7,"spanYears":7.778,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":718,"evidenceRank":350,"evidenceScore":74.8,"freshAt":"2025-03-19T11:44:17Z","freshnessRank":236,"freshEventScore":718,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 718 pts / 294 comments (2025) + 456 pts / 215 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,718 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":456,"peak_comments":215,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15429390","height":22,"chart_height":108},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":45,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20609199","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25490689","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":432,"peak_comments":178,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31448148","height":21,"chart_height":102},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41639019","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":718,"peak_comments":294,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43410692","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/fd-a-simple-fast-and-user-friendly-alternative-to-find-d9d023573d0a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/fd-a-simple-fast-and-user-friendly-alternative-to-find-d9d023573d0a/"},{"slug":"the-lobster-programming-language-d9d02348418f","title":"The Lobster Programming Language","domain":"strlen.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","open_source","game_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2019-04","inductedMonth":"2019-04","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":13.112,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":387,"evidenceRank":351,"evidenceScore":74.7,"freshAt":"2026-03-03T22:24:54Z","freshnessRank":52,"freshEventScore":121,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 387 pts / 164 comments (2019) + 145 pts / 32 comments (2013), different submitters and 2,114 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":145,"peak_comments":32,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5904430","height":7,"chart_height":64},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":75,"peak_comments":19,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8661502","height":4,"chart_height":33},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15557060","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":387,"peak_comments":164,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19567160","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":43,"peak_comments":14,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31453822","height":4,"chart_height":19},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39420439","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":19,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44051841","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":121,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47239955","height":6,"chart_height":53}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-lobster-programming-language-d9d02348418f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-lobster-programming-language-d9d02348418f/"},{"slug":"418-i-m-a-teapot-d9d02359653d","title":"418 I’m a teapot","domain":"developer.mozilla.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","browsers_web_standards"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2023-05","inductedMonth":"2024-10","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":6.741,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":255,"evidenceRank":352,"evidenceScore":74.6,"freshAt":"2024-10-28T04:32:06Z","freshnessRank":306,"freshEventScore":255,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 255 pts / 139 comments (2024) + 193 pts / 107 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,138 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":54,"peak_comments":39,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17652557","height":4,"chart_height":36},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":36,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22215285","height":4,"chart_height":24},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":193,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28541327","height":9,"chart_height":129},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":206,"peak_comments":189,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36090344","height":10,"chart_height":137},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":255,"peak_comments":139,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41967897","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/418-i-m-a-teapot-d9d02359653d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/418-i-m-a-teapot-d9d02359653d/"},{"slug":"show-hn-every-mountain-building-and-tree-shadow-mapped-for-any-d-d9d02365ae4b","title":"Show HN: Every mountain, building and tree shadow mapped for any date and time","domain":"shademap.app","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["earth_science","space_astronomy","visual_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2024-05","inductedMonth":"2024-05","submissions":16,"submitters":13,"spanYears":4.939,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":685,"evidenceRank":353,"evidenceScore":74.6,"freshAt":"2024-05-31T05:09:24Z","freshnessRank":387,"freshEventScore":387,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 387 pts / 1 comments (2024) + 368 pts / 71 comments (2022), different submitters and 875 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29681693","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":368,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29827943","height":18,"chart_height":91},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":685,"peak_comments":183,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40528045","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45536125","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":3,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46816506","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/show-hn-every-mountain-building-and-tree-shadow-mapped-for-any-d-d9d02365ae4b/"},{"slug":"in-praise-of-idleness-1932-d9d0235adb55","title":"In Praise of Idleness (1932)","domain":"harpers.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["labor_productivity","philosophy","economics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-11","inductedMonth":"2023-07","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":7.195,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":270,"evidenceRank":354,"evidenceScore":74.6,"freshAt":"2025-09-17T06:04:06Z","freshnessRank":144,"freshEventScore":152,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 255 pts / 170 comments (2021) + 270 pts / 107 comments (2024), different submitters and 891 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17485665","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":213,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21509144","height":10,"chart_height":134},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":255,"peak_comments":170,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29338666","height":12,"chart_height":161},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36859003","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":270,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40257677","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":152,"peak_comments":14,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45272296","height":7,"chart_height":96},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/in-praise-of-idleness-1932-d9d0235adb55.jpg","path":"/hall/link/in-praise-of-idleness-1932-d9d0235adb55/"},{"slug":"my-productivity-app-for-the-past-12-years-has-been-a-single-txt-d9d0236068c0","title":"My productivity app for the past 12 years has been a single .txt file","domain":"jeffhuang.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["personal_productivity","workplace"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2024-01","inductedMonth":"2024-02","submissions":8,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.84,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":1545,"evidenceRank":355,"evidenceScore":74.6,"freshAt":"2025-12-11T19:30:58Z","freshnessRank":98,"freshEventScore":295,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1545 pts / 402 comments (2020) + 499 pts / 264 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,472 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1545,"peak_comments":402,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22276184","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":523,"peak_comments":202,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29661167","height":24,"chart_height":58},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":499,"peak_comments":264,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39432876","height":24,"chart_height":55},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":295,"peak_comments":189,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46236037","height":14,"chart_height":32},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/my-productivity-app-for-the-past-12-years-has-been-a-single-txt-d9d0236068c0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/my-productivity-app-for-the-past-12-years-has-been-a-single-txt-d9d0236068c0/"},{"slug":"coconut-pythonic-functional-programming-d9d02353e8f8","title":"Coconut: Pythonic functional programming","domain":"coconut-lang.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","compilers_runtimes","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-01","inductedMonth":"2019-01","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":5.374,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":428,"evidenceRank":356,"evidenceScore":74.6,"freshAt":"2021-11-04T09:22:43Z","freshnessRank":858,"freshEventScore":99,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 428 pts / 169 comments (2019) + 259 pts / 130 comments (2016), different submitters and 924 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":259,"peak_comments":130,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11960692","height":12,"chart_height":103},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17793559","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":428,"peak_comments":169,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18815125","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":149,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23759721","height":7,"chart_height":59},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":99,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29104961","height":5,"chart_height":39},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/coconut-pythonic-functional-programming-d9d02353e8f8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/coconut-pythonic-functional-programming-d9d02353e8f8/"},{"slug":"an-intuitive-guide-to-linear-algebra-2012-d9d023475a93","title":"An Intuitive Guide to Linear Algebra (2012)","domain":"betterexplained.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2020-02","inductedMonth":"2024-06","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":11.655,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":709,"evidenceRank":357,"evidenceScore":74.5,"freshAt":"2022-03-31T12:03:52Z","freshnessRank":798,"freshEventScore":285,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 709 pts / 102 comments (2020) + 371 pts / 51 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,861 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":261,"peak_comments":115,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4633662","height":13,"chart_height":63},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":371,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8920638","height":18,"chart_height":89},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":709,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22416319","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":285,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30866244","height":14,"chart_height":68},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40585234","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/an-intuitive-guide-to-linear-algebra-2012-d9d023475a93.jpg","path":"/hall/link/an-intuitive-guide-to-linear-algebra-2012-d9d023475a93/"},{"slug":"drowning-doesn-t-look-like-drowning-d9d023413d3b","title":"Drowning Doesn't Look Like Drowning","domain":"mariovittone.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"medicine_health","topicDisplay":"Medicine & health","tags":["public_health"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2016-05","inductedMonth":"2016-05","submissions":10,"submitters":9,"spanYears":15.893,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":611,"evidenceRank":358,"evidenceScore":74.5,"freshAt":"2018-05-28T04:29:07Z","freshnessRank":1095,"freshEventScore":217,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 611 pts / 127 comments (2010) + 217 pts / 91 comments (2018), different submitters and 2,882 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":611,"peak_comments":127,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1492835","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":10,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2393594","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4028232","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":127,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11667755","height":6,"chart_height":35},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":217,"peak_comments":91,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17170593","height":10,"chart_height":60},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22483390","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27513437","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41174236","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48306230","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/drowning-doesn-t-look-like-drowning-d9d023413d3b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/drowning-doesn-t-look-like-drowning-d9d023413d3b/"},{"slug":"lessons-i-wish-i-had-been-taught-1996-pdf-d9d023621cb2","title":"Lessons I Wish I Had Been Taught (1996) [pdf]","domain":"www.ams.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["academic_life","teaching"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2020-07","inductedMonth":"2024-06","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":13.944,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":341,"evidenceRank":359,"evidenceScore":74.5,"freshAt":"2024-06-27T10:06:18Z","freshnessRank":371,"freshEventScore":341,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 341 pts / 88 comments (2024) + 227 pts / 20 comments (2011), different submitters and 4,612 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":227,"peak_comments":20,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3220746","height":11,"chart_height":113},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":136,"peak_comments":20,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11747598","height":7,"chart_height":68},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":226,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23722803","height":11,"chart_height":113},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29549092","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":278,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32081288","height":13,"chart_height":139},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":341,"peak_comments":88,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40808933","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45648346","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/lessons-i-wish-i-had-been-taught-1996-pdf-d9d023621cb2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/lessons-i-wish-i-had-been-taught-1996-pdf-d9d023621cb2/"},{"slug":"python-for-lisp-programmers-2000-d9d0233ebdda","title":"Python for Lisp Programmers (2000)","domain":"norvig.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2021-02","inductedMonth":"2021-02","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":15.211,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":133,"evidenceRank":360,"evidenceScore":74.5,"freshAt":"2021-02-22T09:15:54Z","freshnessRank":939,"freshEventScore":78,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 133 pts / 100 comments (2018) + 78 pts / 65 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,008 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":24,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=255774","height":4,"chart_height":31},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2168689","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3928193","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8364256","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12824148","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":133,"peak_comments":100,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17116780","height":6,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21895334","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":78,"peak_comments":65,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26222374","height":4,"chart_height":100},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31599774","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37831262","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/python-for-lisp-programmers-2000-d9d0233ebdda.jpg","path":"/hall/link/python-for-lisp-programmers-2000-d9d0233ebdda/"},{"slug":"homepage-of-berkshire-hathaway-17th-biggest-company-in-the-world-d9d023402476","title":"Homepage of Berkshire Hathaway, 17th biggest company in the world","domain":"www.berkshirehathaway.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["finance","management_strategy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2022-11","inductedMonth":"2022-11","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":16.605,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":163,"evidenceRank":361,"evidenceScore":74.5,"freshAt":"2026-06-09T00:56:28Z","freshnessRank":10,"freshEventScore":25,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 163 pts / 116 comments (2009) + 63 pts / 99 comments (2022), different submitters and 4,767 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":163,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=914065","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5973572","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9848633","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":43,"peak_comments":32,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11920431","height":4,"chart_height":45},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20625237","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23055756","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":63,"peak_comments":99,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33682276","height":4,"chart_height":66},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34957070","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44890410","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":25,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48454729","height":4,"chart_height":26}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/homepage-of-berkshire-hathaway-17th-biggest-company-in-the-world-d9d023402476.jpg","path":"/hall/link/homepage-of-berkshire-hathaway-17th-biggest-company-in-the-world-d9d023402476/"},{"slug":"linux-on-an-8-bit-micro-2012-d9d02358df4f","title":"Linux on an 8-Bit Micro? (2012)","domain":"dmitry.gr","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["embedded_iot","computer_architecture","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-09","inductedMonth":"2019-04","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":10.483,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":436,"evidenceRank":362,"evidenceScore":74.4,"freshAt":"2023-10-14T07:59:02Z","freshnessRank":520,"freshEventScore":123,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 436 pts / 74 comments (2013) + 192 pts / 60 comments (2019), different submitters and 2,197 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":436,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5581851","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":152,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12537653","height":7,"chart_height":59},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":172,"peak_comments":38,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15841241","height":8,"chart_height":67},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":192,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19762928","height":9,"chart_height":75},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":92,"peak_comments":25,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25497727","height":4,"chart_height":36},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":123,"peak_comments":37,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37878851","height":6,"chart_height":48},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/linux-on-an-8-bit-micro-2012-d9d02358df4f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/linux-on-an-8-bit-micro-2012-d9d02358df4f/"},{"slug":"go-by-example-d9d023476185","title":"Go by Example","domain":"gobyexample.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2016-03","inductedMonth":"2016-03","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":11.734,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":392,"evidenceRank":363,"evidenceScore":74.4,"freshAt":"2022-05-07T22:52:10Z","freshnessRank":783,"freshEventScore":21,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 392 pts / 72 comments (2016) + 301 pts / 124 comments (2014), different submitters and 776 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4645948","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6538508","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":301,"peak_comments":124,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7075515","height":14,"chart_height":131},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9468515","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":392,"peak_comments":72,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11223096","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21063822","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26405402","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":21,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31299368","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40899290","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/go-by-example-d9d023476185.jpg","path":"/hall/link/go-by-example-d9d023476185/"},{"slug":"project-naptha-make-text-in-browser-images-selectable-d9d0234cab92","title":"Project Naptha: Make Text in Browser Images Selectable","domain":"projectnaptha.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["artificial_intelligence","information_retrieval","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2019-09","inductedMonth":"2021-03","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":8.219,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1055,"evidenceRank":364,"evidenceScore":74.4,"freshAt":"2022-07-11T03:06:29Z","freshnessRank":751,"freshEventScore":317,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1055 pts / 134 comments (2014) + 324 pts / 52 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,965 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1055,"peak_comments":134,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7629396","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11260440","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":324,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20919147","height":16,"chart_height":52},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26618425","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":317,"peak_comments":85,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32051736","height":15,"chart_height":51},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/project-naptha-make-text-in-browser-images-selectable-d9d0234cab92.jpg","path":"/hall/link/project-naptha-make-text-in-browser-images-selectable-d9d0234cab92/"},{"slug":"your-problem-with-vim-is-that-you-don-t-grok-vi-d9d02340c6b1","title":"Your problem with Vim is that you don't grok vi","domain":"stackoverflow.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"forum_discussion","typeDisplay":"Forum discussions","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2013-10","inductedMonth":"2015-11","submissions":14,"submitters":12,"spanYears":15.233,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":417,"evidenceRank":365,"evidenceScore":74.3,"freshAt":"2021-05-07T02:59:23Z","freshnessRank":914,"freshEventScore":51,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 417 pts / 182 comments (2011) + 30 pts / 57 comments (2013), different submitters and 789 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1232808","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":417,"peak_comments":182,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2911930","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":30,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6578926","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8128378","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10511345","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10849571","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":52,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14792067","height":4,"chart_height":21},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":19,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18315497","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":51,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27071582","height":4,"chart_height":21},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34151357","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44365878","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/your-problem-with-vim-is-that-you-don-t-grok-vi-d9d02340c6b1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/your-problem-with-vim-is-that-you-don-t-grok-vi-d9d02340c6b1/"},{"slug":"neocities-free-modern-geocities-reboot-d9d0234f5662","title":"Neocities: Free, modern Geocities reboot","domain":"neocities.org","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","online_communities"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2022-11","inductedMonth":"2022-11","submissions":16,"submitters":15,"spanYears":11.395,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":416,"evidenceRank":366,"evidenceScore":74.3,"freshAt":"2022-11-18T01:29:50Z","freshnessRank":687,"freshEventScore":119,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 416 pts / 99 comments (2017) + 119 pts / 22 comments (2022), different submitters and 2,127 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9068820","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":416,"peak_comments":99,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13445181","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18079882","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23231963","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":20,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26821746","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":119,"peak_comments":22,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33648618","height":6,"chart_height":49},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40273894","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46050805","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47820717","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/neocities-free-modern-geocities-reboot-d9d0234f5662.jpg","path":"/hall/link/neocities-free-modern-geocities-reboot-d9d0234f5662/"},{"slug":"altstore-home-for-apps-that-push-the-boundaries-of-ios-no-jailbr-d9d0235f0ec8","title":"Altstore: Home for apps that push the boundaries of iOS. No jailbreak required","domain":"altstore.io","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-03","inductedMonth":"2024-04","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":6.502,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":333,"evidenceRank":367,"evidenceScore":74.3,"freshAt":"2024-04-20T19:17:49Z","freshnessRank":416,"freshEventScore":145,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 302 pts / 215 comments (2021) + 145 pts / 90 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,035 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21076155","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24256333","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":302,"peak_comments":215,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27568379","height":14,"chart_height":154},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":333,"peak_comments":244,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35226197","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":145,"peak_comments":90,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40100151","height":7,"chart_height":74},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47540366","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/altstore-home-for-apps-that-push-the-boundaries-of-ios-no-jailbr-d9d0235f0ec8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/altstore-home-for-apps-that-push-the-boundaries-of-ios-no-jailbr-d9d0235f0ec8/"},{"slug":"how-to-corrupt-an-sqlite-database-file-d9d023579e6a","title":"How to Corrupt an SQLite Database File","domain":"sqlite.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["databases_storage","performance_reliability","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-01","inductedMonth":"2022-04","submissions":10,"submitters":9,"spanYears":8.936,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":372,"evidenceRank":368,"evidenceScore":74.3,"freshAt":"2022-04-30T07:36:15Z","freshnessRank":787,"freshEventScore":225,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 372 pts / 148 comments (2020) + 225 pts / 139 comments (2022), different submitters and 830 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14803034","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":104,"peak_comments":10,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16579986","height":5,"chart_height":48},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":372,"peak_comments":148,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22098832","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":225,"peak_comments":139,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31214131","height":11,"chart_height":103},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41976232","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47849581","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-to-corrupt-an-sqlite-database-file-d9d023579e6a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-to-corrupt-an-sqlite-database-file-d9d023579e6a/"},{"slug":"forgotten-employee-2002-d9d0234a0f40","title":"Forgotten Employee (2002)","domain":"sites.google.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["careers","workplace"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2019-11","inductedMonth":"2022-02","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":9.24,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":747,"evidenceRank":369,"evidenceScore":74.2,"freshAt":"2022-10-19T08:40:24Z","freshnessRank":707,"freshEventScore":223,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 747 pts / 291 comments (2013) + 520 pts / 166 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,790 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":747,"peak_comments":291,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6087935","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":520,"peak_comments":166,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17332440","height":24,"chart_height":118},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21596936","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22968637","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":4,"peak_score":223,"peak_comments":125,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33259289","height":11,"chart_height":51},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/forgotten-employee-2002-d9d0234a0f40.jpg","path":"/hall/link/forgotten-employee-2002-d9d0234a0f40/"},{"slug":"why-facts-don-t-change-our-minds-2017-d9d0235ab22a","title":"Why Facts Don’t Change Our Minds (2017)","domain":"www.newyorker.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["psychology","scientific_method"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2020-07","inductedMonth":"2024-11","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":6.374,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":144,"evidenceRank":370,"evidenceScore":74.2,"freshAt":"2024-11-03T22:47:19Z","freshnessRank":303,"freshEventScore":95,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 144 pts / 158 comments (2018) + 95 pts / 86 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,227 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":4,"peak_score":144,"peak_comments":158,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18099488","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19829881","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":116,"peak_comments":122,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23757135","height":6,"chart_height":137},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32711493","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":95,"peak_comments":86,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42036733","height":5,"chart_height":112},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-facts-don-t-change-our-minds-2017-d9d0235ab22a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-facts-don-t-change-our-minds-2017-d9d0235ab22a/"},{"slug":"inter-ui-a-typeface-designed-for-user-interfaces-d9d023588c61","title":"Inter UI, a typeface designed for user interfaces","domain":"rsms.me","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-07","inductedMonth":"2021-07","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":8.69,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":664,"evidenceRank":371,"evidenceScore":74.2,"freshAt":"2021-07-30T15:28:17Z","freshnessRank":889,"freshEventScore":339,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 664 pts / 92 comments (2018) + 339 pts / 95 comments (2021), different submitters and 943 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15569483","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":664,"peak_comments":92,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18784583","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23540767","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":339,"peak_comments":95,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28009042","height":16,"chart_height":87},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38342182","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41653886","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43285345","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48799355","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/inter-ui-a-typeface-designed-for-user-interfaces-d9d023588c61.jpg","path":"/hall/link/inter-ui-a-typeface-designed-for-user-interfaces-d9d023588c61/"},{"slug":"autopilot-an-open-source-driving-agent-d9d023556745","title":"Autopilot: an open source driving agent","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"space_transportation","topicDisplay":"Space & transportation","tags":["automotive","embedded_iot","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-06","inductedMonth":"2023-01","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":7.806,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":344,"evidenceRank":372,"evidenceScore":74.2,"freshAt":"2024-09-20T09:19:00Z","freshnessRank":329,"freshEventScore":241,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 241 pts / 140 comments (2024) + 344 pts / 119 comments (2016), different submitters and 2,850 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":344,"peak_comments":119,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13073331","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":262,"peak_comments":111,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19893283","height":13,"chart_height":129},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27399676","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34516826","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":241,"peak_comments":140,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41600177","height":12,"chart_height":119},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/autopilot-an-open-source-driving-agent-d9d023556745.jpg","path":"/hall/link/autopilot-an-open-source-driving-agent-d9d023556745/"},{"slug":"apple-s-mistake-2009-d9d023403728","title":"Apple’s Mistake (2009)","domain":"www.paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["application_security","startups_entrepreneurship"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2014-03","inductedMonth":"2014-03","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":12.257,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":723,"evidenceRank":373,"evidenceScore":74.2,"freshAt":"2022-02-21T16:47:01Z","freshnessRank":820,"freshEventScore":177,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 723 pts / 269 comments (2009) + 177 pts / 262 comments (2022), different submitters and 4,476 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":723,"peak_comments":269,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=950751","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":82,"peak_comments":25,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1081514","height":4,"chart_height":19},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":3,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3866322","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6329991","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":40,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7344783","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":177,"peak_comments":262,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30417819","height":8,"chart_height":42},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/apple-s-mistake-2009-d9d023403728.jpg","path":"/hall/link/apple-s-mistake-2009-d9d023403728/"},{"slug":"inventors-killed-by-their-own-inventions-d9d0233febba","title":"Inventors killed by their own inventions","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2019-06","inductedMonth":"2019-06","submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":11.433,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":273,"evidenceRank":374,"evidenceScore":74.1,"freshAt":"2021-02-07T16:03:15Z","freshnessRank":943,"freshEventScore":73,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 273 pts / 149 comments (2019) + 109 pts / 59 comments (2009), different submitters and 3,563 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":109,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=800243","height":5,"chart_height":68},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":25,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5299212","height":4,"chart_height":16},{"year":2014,"count":3,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7781563","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9699698","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":67,"peak_comments":27,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13211574","height":4,"chart_height":42},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18228834","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":273,"peak_comments":149,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20112207","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":73,"peak_comments":22,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26055861","height":4,"chart_height":45},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/inventors-killed-by-their-own-inventions-d9d0233febba.jpg","path":"/hall/link/inventors-killed-by-their-own-inventions-d9d0233febba/"},{"slug":"what-s-new-in-xcode-7-d9d02342b2e5","title":"What's new in Xcode 7","domain":"developer.apple.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2016-09","inductedMonth":"2019-06","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":12.531,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":252,"evidenceRank":375,"evidenceScore":74.1,"freshAt":"2021-06-07T20:59:31Z","freshnessRank":902,"freshEventScore":80,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 252 pts / 174 comments (2015) + 55 pts / 104 comments (2011), different submitters and 1,551 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":55,"peak_comments":104,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2306070","height":4,"chart_height":37},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":252,"peak_comments":174,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9681697","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":44,"peak_comments":13,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12492007","height":4,"chart_height":30},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14491058","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20087257","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23631584","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":80,"peak_comments":17,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27426827","height":4,"chart_height":54},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37571698","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-s-new-in-xcode-7-d9d02342b2e5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-s-new-in-xcode-7-d9d02342b2e5/"},{"slug":"i-ve-got-nothing-to-hide-and-other-misunderstandings-of-privacy-d9d02340489b","title":"'I've Got Nothing to Hide' and Other Misunderstandings of Privacy","domain":"papers.ssrn.com","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"research_paper","typeDisplay":"Research papers","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["privacy_surveillance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2019-11","inductedMonth":"2023-08","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":13.678,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":323,"evidenceRank":376,"evidenceScore":74.1,"freshAt":"2023-08-13T18:23:29Z","freshnessRank":567,"freshEventScore":323,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 323 pts / 282 comments (2023) + 212 pts / 83 comments (2021), different submitters and 734 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=984832","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":174,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5899784","height":8,"chart_height":92},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9216793","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16948838","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":210,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21416115","height":10,"chart_height":111},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":212,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28111606","height":10,"chart_height":112},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":323,"peak_comments":282,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37112625","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/i-ve-got-nothing-to-hide-and-other-misunderstandings-of-privacy-d9d02340489b/"},{"slug":"the-first-few-milliseconds-of-an-https-connection-2009-d9d0233fa090","title":"The First Few Milliseconds of an HTTPS Connection (2009)","domain":"www.moserware.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2013-08","inductedMonth":"2015-07","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":11.362,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":549,"evidenceRank":377,"evidenceScore":74.1,"freshAt":"2020-10-20T11:31:50Z","freshnessRank":984,"freshEventScore":190,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 549 pts / 37 comments (2013) + 236 pts / 33 comments (2009), different submitters and 1,540 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":236,"peak_comments":33,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=650914","height":11,"chart_height":73},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3739267","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":549,"peak_comments":37,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6295146","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7284941","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":82,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9896815","height":4,"chart_height":25},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12822664","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16728480","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":190,"peak_comments":35,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24836167","height":9,"chart_height":59},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-first-few-milliseconds-of-an-https-connection-2009-d9d0233fa090.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-first-few-milliseconds-of-an-https-connection-2009-d9d0233fa090/"},{"slug":"how-fake-money-saved-brazil-2010-d9d023505130","title":"How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010)","domain":"www.npr.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["economics","finance","markets"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2021-05","inductedMonth":"2021-05","submissions":9,"submitters":8,"spanYears":10.932,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":261,"evidenceRank":378,"evidenceScore":74.1,"freshAt":"2021-05-12T03:23:30Z","freshnessRank":912,"freshEventScore":111,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 261 pts / 154 comments (2015) + 111 pts / 93 comments (2021), different submitters and 2,175 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":261,"peak_comments":154,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9617710","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":162,"peak_comments":119,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12419117","height":8,"chart_height":106},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":111,"peak_comments":93,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27126258","height":5,"chart_height":72},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35737276","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41019047","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47999851","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-fake-money-saved-brazil-2010-d9d023505130.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-fake-money-saved-brazil-2010-d9d023505130/"},{"slug":"lena-d9d0236405da","title":"Lena","domain":"qntm.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["books_literature","artificial_intelligence","technology_ethics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2023-12","inductedMonth":"2023-12","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":5.106,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":620,"evidenceRank":379,"evidenceScore":74.1,"freshAt":"2026-02-13T05:24:40Z","freshnessRank":60,"freshEventScore":340,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 620 pts / 218 comments (2021) + 340 pts / 185 comments (2026), different submitters and 1,816 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":620,"peak_comments":218,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26224835","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":86,"peak_comments":16,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32696089","height":4,"chart_height":24},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":144,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38536778","height":7,"chart_height":39},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":4,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43994642","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":340,"peak_comments":185,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46999224","height":16,"chart_height":93}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/lena-d9d0236405da.jpg","path":"/hall/link/lena-d9d0236405da/"},{"slug":"i-don-t-know-timmy-being-god-is-a-big-responsibility-2007-d9d023411a17","title":"I don't know, Timmy, being God is a big responsibility (2007)","domain":"qntm.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["books_literature"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2021-02","inductedMonth":"2021-02","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":15.775,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":401,"evidenceRank":380,"evidenceScore":74.0,"freshAt":"2026-03-17T23:33:08Z","freshnessRank":43,"freshEventScore":23,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 401 pts / 158 comments (2021) + 226 pts / 112 comments (2014), different submitters and 2,557 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":75,"peak_comments":35,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1410026","height":4,"chart_height":32},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":226,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7267811","height":11,"chart_height":96},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11101838","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24880848","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":401,"peak_comments":158,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26202063","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31984684","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41110431","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":23,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47419790","height":4,"chart_height":10}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/i-don-t-know-timmy-being-god-is-a-big-responsibility-2007-d9d023411a17.jpg","path":"/hall/link/i-don-t-know-timmy-being-god-is-a-big-responsibility-2007-d9d023411a17/"},{"slug":"no-pi-is-wrong-the-tau-manifesto-d9d0234587fd","title":"No, pi is wrong: The Tau Manifesto","domain":"tauday.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2021-05","inductedMonth":"2021-05","submissions":15,"submitters":15,"spanYears":12.624,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":186,"evidenceRank":381,"evidenceScore":74.0,"freshAt":"2021-05-09T07:02:22Z","freshnessRank":913,"freshEventScore":128,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 186 pts / 110 comments (2012) + 128 pts / 60 comments (2021), different submitters and 3,342 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":186,"peak_comments":110,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3704664","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11952086","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14653528","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16754139","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19445885","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":128,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27093866","height":6,"chart_height":117},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34688236","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41969080","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/no-pi-is-wrong-the-tau-manifesto-d9d0234587fd.jpg","path":"/hall/link/no-pi-is-wrong-the-tau-manifesto-d9d0234587fd/"},{"slug":"hammerspoon-macos-automation-with-lua-d9d0234ee96a","title":"Hammerspoon – macOS automation with Lua","domain":"www.hammerspoon.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","programming_languages","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-12","inductedMonth":"2021-08","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":11.518,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":319,"evidenceRank":382,"evidenceScore":73.9,"freshAt":"2021-12-12T20:52:40Z","freshnessRank":849,"freshEventScore":272,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 266 pts / 122 comments (2016) + 319 pts / 90 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,249 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8836868","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":266,"peak_comments":122,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12097303","height":13,"chart_height":142},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":319,"peak_comments":90,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21801178","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":272,"peak_comments":80,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29533495","height":13,"chart_height":145},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45126610","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48889504","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/hammerspoon-macos-automation-with-lua-d9d0234ee96a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/hammerspoon-macos-automation-with-lua-d9d0234ee96a/"},{"slug":"monolith-first-2015-d9d0235794c7","title":"Monolith First (2015)","domain":"martinfowler.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","distributed_systems","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-02","inductedMonth":"2021-02","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":7.176,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":820,"evidenceRank":383,"evidenceScore":73.9,"freshAt":"2024-09-16T17:54:24Z","freshnessRank":330,"freshEventScore":40,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 820 pts / 340 comments (2021) + 430 pts / 163 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,314 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":430,"peak_comments":163,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14778685","height":21,"chart_height":89},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18297659","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19189222","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":820,"peak_comments":340,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26190584","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34413742","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":40,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41558668","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/monolith-first-2015-d9d0235794c7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/monolith-first-2015-d9d0235794c7/"},{"slug":"why-programmers-are-not-paid-in-proportion-to-their-productivity-d9d02340569f","title":"Why programmers are not paid in proportion to their productivity (2009)","domain":"www.johndcook.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["labor_productivity","workplace"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2018-04","inductedMonth":"2022-06","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":12.515,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":285,"evidenceRank":384,"evidenceScore":73.9,"freshAt":"2022-06-29T06:49:15Z","freshnessRank":759,"freshEventScore":191,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 191 pts / 306 comments (2022) + 285 pts / 187 comments (2011), different submitters and 4,081 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":2,"peak_score":114,"peak_comments":129,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1012381","height":5,"chart_height":68},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":285,"peak_comments":187,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2485098","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":98,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16888908","height":5,"chart_height":58},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":191,"peak_comments":306,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31917229","height":9,"chart_height":114},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-programmers-are-not-paid-in-proportion-to-their-productivity-d9d02340569f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-programmers-are-not-paid-in-proportion-to-their-productivity-d9d02340569f/"},{"slug":"the-unreasonable-effectiveness-of-recurrent-neural-networks-d9d0235041ed","title":"The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Recurrent Neural Networks","domain":"karpathy.github.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["machine_learning","artificial_intelligence"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-02","inductedMonth":"2019-02","submissions":14,"submitters":14,"spanYears":11.132,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":913,"evidenceRank":385,"evidenceScore":73.9,"freshAt":"2023-08-28T08:14:57Z","freshnessRank":558,"freshEventScore":21,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 913 pts / 207 comments (2015) + 161 pts / 51 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,353 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":913,"peak_comments":207,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9584325","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":65,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12335502","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15859487","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17419131","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":161,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19070547","height":8,"chart_height":30},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23757228","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28710951","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":21,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37291235","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44517472","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48834169","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-unreasonable-effectiveness-of-recurrent-neural-networks-d9d0235041ed.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-unreasonable-effectiveness-of-recurrent-neural-networks-d9d0235041ed/"},{"slug":"salary-negotiation-make-more-money-be-more-valued-2012-d9d0234516b9","title":"Salary Negotiation: Make More Money, Be More Valued (2012)","domain":"www.kalzumeus.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["careers","hiring_interviews"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2020-09","inductedMonth":"2020-09","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":11.439,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":596,"evidenceRank":386,"evidenceScore":73.9,"freshAt":"2023-07-02T02:44:18Z","freshnessRank":601,"freshEventScore":128,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 420 pts / 260 comments (2020) + 596 pts / 193 comments (2012), different submitters and 3,167 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":596,"peak_comments":193,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3501366","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10102366","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16011543","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":72,"peak_comments":14,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19262732","height":4,"chart_height":21},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":420,"peak_comments":260,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24588379","height":20,"chart_height":120},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":128,"peak_comments":44,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36557679","height":6,"chart_height":37},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/salary-negotiation-make-more-money-be-more-valued-2012-d9d0234516b9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/salary-negotiation-make-more-money-be-more-valued-2012-d9d0234516b9/"},{"slug":"monodraw-d9d02358c02e","title":"Monodraw","domain":"monodraw.helftone.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design","user_experience","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2024-03","inductedMonth":"2024-03","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":7.77,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":996,"evidenceRank":387,"evidenceScore":73.8,"freshAt":"2025-08-27T10:54:41Z","freshnessRank":160,"freshEventScore":605,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 996 pts / 200 comments (2024) + 335 pts / 102 comments (2021), different submitters and 969 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15734212","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16993518","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20082499","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":335,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27832910","height":16,"chart_height":57},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":996,"peak_comments":200,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39651796","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":605,"peak_comments":192,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45037904","height":24,"chart_height":103},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/monodraw-d9d02358c02e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/monodraw-d9d02358c02e/"},{"slug":"no-hello-2013-d9d02357b362","title":"No Hello (2013)","domain":"www.nohello.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["workplace","personal_productivity","online_communities"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-08","inductedMonth":"2024-03","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.76,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":323,"evidenceRank":388,"evidenceScore":73.8,"freshAt":"2024-04-30T10:02:33Z","freshnessRank":410,"freshEventScore":79,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 323 pts / 265 comments (2019) + 79 pts / 126 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,844 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":66,"peak_comments":46,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14868294","height":4,"chart_height":35},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":323,"peak_comments":265,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19648415","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":255,"peak_comments":210,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24239880","height":12,"chart_height":134},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":90,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29978860","height":4,"chart_height":47},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":79,"peak_comments":126,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40209142","height":4,"chart_height":42},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/no-hello-2013-d9d02357b362.jpg","path":"/hall/link/no-hello-2013-d9d02357b362/"},{"slug":"quickjs-javascript-engine-d9d0235e4bc7","title":"QuickJS JavaScript Engine","domain":"bellard.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","compilers_runtimes","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-03","inductedMonth":"2022-03","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":7.003,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":948,"evidenceRank":389,"evidenceScore":73.8,"freshAt":"2022-03-08T09:10:06Z","freshnessRank":809,"freshEventScore":141,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 948 pts / 261 comments (2019) + 141 pts / 67 comments (2022), different submitters and 970 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":948,"peak_comments":261,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20411154","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":438,"peak_comments":146,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24867103","height":21,"chart_height":79},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":141,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30598026","height":7,"chart_height":25},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39046251","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45705934","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48875653","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/quickjs-javascript-engine-d9d0235e4bc7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/quickjs-javascript-engine-d9d0235e4bc7/"},{"slug":"build-an-8-bit-computer-from-scratch-2016-d9d02357b831","title":"Build an 8-bit computer from scratch (2016)","domain":"eater.net","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["computer_architecture","electronics","teaching"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2019-12","inductedMonth":"2023-10","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":7.669,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":489,"evidenceRank":390,"evidenceScore":73.8,"freshAt":"2025-03-31T11:29:34Z","freshnessRank":232,"freshEventScore":398,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 489 pts / 52 comments (2019) + 398 pts / 62 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,919 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":341,"peak_comments":28,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14883776","height":16,"chart_height":119},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":489,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21902281","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32154801","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38040510","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42047640","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":398,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43533715","height":19,"chart_height":138},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/build-an-8-bit-computer-from-scratch-2016-d9d02357b831.jpg","path":"/hall/link/build-an-8-bit-computer-from-scratch-2016-d9d02357b831/"},{"slug":"sailfish-4-d9d023489d53","title":"Sailfish 4","domain":"sailfishos.org","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","open_source","privacy_surveillance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2021-08","inductedMonth":"2021-08","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":11.608,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":375,"evidenceRank":391,"evidenceScore":73.7,"freshAt":"2024-10-05T12:00:26Z","freshnessRank":321,"freshEventScore":153,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 153 pts / 144 comments (2024) + 375 pts / 144 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,136 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5279643","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":126,"peak_comments":100,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15122799","height":6,"chart_height":57},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":375,"peak_comments":144,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28313750","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":153,"peak_comments":144,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41749296","height":7,"chart_height":69},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/sailfish-4-d9d023489d53.jpg","path":"/hall/link/sailfish-4-d9d023489d53/"},{"slug":"reasons-not-to-become-famous-d9d0236058e0","title":"Reasons not to become famous","domain":"tim.blog","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-05","inductedMonth":"2025-08","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":5.881,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":850,"evidenceRank":392,"evidenceScore":73.7,"freshAt":"2025-12-21T15:07:18Z","freshnessRank":92,"freshEventScore":154,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 850 pts / 408 comments (2020) + 97 pts / 127 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,197 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":8,"peak_score":850,"peak_comments":408,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22280753","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":97,"peak_comments":127,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36019038","height":5,"chart_height":19},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":154,"peak_comments":118,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46345341","height":7,"chart_height":31},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/reasons-not-to-become-famous-d9d0236058e0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/reasons-not-to-become-famous-d9d0236058e0/"},{"slug":"always-bet-on-text-2014-d9d0234e3349","title":"Always Bet on Text (2014)","domain":"graydon2.dreamwidth.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["writing_craft","books_literature","internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2021-02","inductedMonth":"2021-02","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":11.203,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":570,"evidenceRank":393,"evidenceScore":73.7,"freshAt":"2023-01-07T02:03:41Z","freshnessRank":674,"freshEventScore":35,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 570 pts / 338 comments (2021) + 355 pts / 196 comments (2014), different submitters and 2,318 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":355,"peak_comments":196,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8451271","height":17,"chart_height":106},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8902597","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12815829","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16652328","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":570,"peak_comments":338,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26164001","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":35,"peak_comments":11,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34284254","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39938941","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46397379","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/always-bet-on-text-2014-d9d0234e3349.jpg","path":"/hall/link/always-bet-on-text-2014-d9d0234e3349/"},{"slug":"it-s-charisma-stupid-2004-d9d0233e5b78","title":"It's Charisma, Stupid (2004)","domain":"www.paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["politics_government","psychology"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2016-05","inductedMonth":"2016-05","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":14.976,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":141,"evidenceRank":394,"evidenceScore":73.7,"freshAt":"2016-11-09T04:27:14Z","freshnessRank":1145,"freshEventScore":141,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 92 pts / 131 comments (2016) + 29 pts / 67 comments (2008), different submitters and 3,004 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":29,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=113838","height":4,"chart_height":35},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2989422","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4708773","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":5,"peak_score":141,"peak_comments":131,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12906040","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19529392","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25042180","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34645847","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/it-s-charisma-stupid-2004-d9d0233e5b78.jpg","path":"/hall/link/it-s-charisma-stupid-2004-d9d0233e5b78/"},{"slug":"john-scalzi-being-poor-2005-d9d023419c89","title":"John Scalzi: Being Poor (2005)","domain":"whatever.scalzi.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["social_issues"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2017-08","inductedMonth":"2021-05","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":15.644,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":262,"evidenceRank":395,"evidenceScore":73.6,"freshAt":"2021-05-22T07:01:33Z","freshnessRank":906,"freshEventScore":187,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 262 pts / 237 comments (2017) + 257 pts / 218 comments (2010), different submitters and 2,522 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":257,"peak_comments":218,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1712493","height":12,"chart_height":167},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":31,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10387061","height":4,"chart_height":20},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":262,"peak_comments":237,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15041758","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":187,"peak_comments":216,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27244223","height":9,"chart_height":121},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48132887","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/john-scalzi-being-poor-2005-d9d023419c89.jpg","path":"/hall/link/john-scalzi-being-poor-2005-d9d023419c89/"},{"slug":"lisp-as-an-alternative-to-java-d9d0233eefa1","title":"Lisp as an Alternative to Java","domain":"norvig.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2016-07","inductedMonth":"2019-12","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":12.81,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":156,"evidenceRank":396,"evidenceScore":73.6,"freshAt":"2021-08-02T14:07:00Z","freshnessRank":886,"freshEventScore":150,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 150 pts / 108 comments (2021) + 77 pts / 103 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,827 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=328709","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":114,"peak_comments":37,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3447101","height":5,"chart_height":124},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":77,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12197131","height":4,"chart_height":84},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21708869","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":156,"peak_comments":108,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26720403","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/lisp-as-an-alternative-to-java-d9d0233eefa1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/lisp-as-an-alternative-to-java-d9d0233eefa1/"},{"slug":"learn-how-to-design-large-scale-systems-d9d023565c36","title":"Learn how to design large-scale systems","domain":"github.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["distributed_systems","software_architecture","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-12","inductedMonth":"2021-12","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":8.093,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1273,"evidenceRank":397,"evidenceScore":73.6,"freshAt":"2023-10-29T07:41:20Z","freshnessRank":504,"freshEventScore":112,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1273 pts / 185 comments (2018) + 170 pts / 29 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,264 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":5,"peak_score":19,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13828257","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":1273,"peak_comments":185,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17522362","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19316413","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":34,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22051489","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":170,"peak_comments":29,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29716292","height":8,"chart_height":23},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":112,"peak_comments":20,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38056547","height":5,"chart_height":15},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43666996","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/learn-how-to-design-large-scale-systems-d9d023565c36.jpg","path":"/hall/link/learn-how-to-design-large-scale-systems-d9d023565c36/"},{"slug":"the-raising-of-chicago-d9d023493551","title":"The Raising of Chicago","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["cities_infrastructure","history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2018-10","inductedMonth":"2018-10","submissions":14,"submitters":14,"spanYears":11.702,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":222,"evidenceRank":398,"evidenceScore":73.6,"freshAt":"2025-01-06T16:31:27Z","freshnessRank":270,"freshEventScore":82,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 216 pts / 134 comments (2018) + 222 pts / 73 comments (2013), different submitters and 1,883 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":222,"peak_comments":73,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6295279","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7796670","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12207625","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14307146","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":216,"peak_comments":134,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18300270","height":10,"chart_height":165},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27135286","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38250743","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38891933","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":82,"peak_comments":41,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42611978","height":4,"chart_height":63},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-raising-of-chicago-d9d023493551.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-raising-of-chicago-d9d023493551/"},{"slug":"show-hn-wave-function-collapse-algorithm-d9d02354d406","title":"Show HN: Wave function collapse algorithm","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_development","computer_graphics","algorithms_data_structures"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-06","inductedMonth":"2021-07","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":9.58,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1226,"evidenceRank":399,"evidenceScore":73.6,"freshAt":"2026-04-30T11:51:02Z","freshnessRank":21,"freshEventScore":83,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1226 pts / 122 comments (2016) + 281 pts / 39 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,749 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1226,"peak_comments":122,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12612246","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":153,"peak_comments":9,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16415912","height":7,"chart_height":21},{"year":2019,"count":5,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20169397","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24883913","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":281,"peak_comments":39,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27853392","height":13,"chart_height":39},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37354731","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":83,"peak_comments":14,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47961100","height":4,"chart_height":12}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/show-hn-wave-function-collapse-algorithm-d9d02354d406.jpg","path":"/hall/link/show-hn-wave-function-collapse-algorithm-d9d02354d406/"},{"slug":"so-you-want-to-abolish-time-zones-2015-d9d023552deb","title":"So You Want to Abolish Time Zones (2015)","domain":"qntm.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["cities_infrastructure","transportation"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2024-03","inductedMonth":"2024-03","submissions":13,"submitters":11,"spanYears":7.346,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":67,"evidenceRank":400,"evidenceScore":73.4,"freshAt":"2024-03-13T14:58:19Z","freshnessRank":429,"freshEventScore":57,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 57 pts / 140 comments (2024) + 67 pts / 100 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,098 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12890891","height":4,"chart_height":15},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14800898","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16628642","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19927487","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":67,"peak_comments":100,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26416337","height":4,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33514406","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38148496","height":4,"chart_height":18},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":57,"peak_comments":140,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39692011","height":4,"chart_height":145},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/so-you-want-to-abolish-time-zones-2015-d9d023552deb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/so-you-want-to-abolish-time-zones-2015-d9d023552deb/"},{"slug":"english-has-been-my-pain-for-15-years-d9d0234a6fa9","title":"English has been my pain for 15 years","domain":"antirez.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["learning_methods","language_linguistics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2019-08","inductedMonth":"2021-04","submissions":6,"submitters":4,"spanYears":8.304,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":433,"evidenceRank":401,"evidenceScore":73.4,"freshAt":"2021-12-22T06:46:44Z","freshnessRank":844,"freshEventScore":142,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 433 pts / 300 comments (2013) + 142 pts / 281 comments (2021), different submitters and 3,032 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":433,"peak_comments":300,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6314628","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":261,"peak_comments":238,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10641246","height":13,"chart_height":102},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":73,"peak_comments":111,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21179539","height":4,"chart_height":29},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":142,"peak_comments":281,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29646242","height":7,"chart_height":56},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/english-has-been-my-pain-for-15-years-d9d0234a6fa9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/english-has-been-my-pain-for-15-years-d9d0234a6fa9/"},{"slug":"tcl-the-misunderstood-2006-d9d0233f172f","title":"Tcl the Misunderstood (2006)","domain":"antirez.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2014-01","inductedMonth":"2022-04","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":15.838,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":182,"evidenceRank":402,"evidenceScore":73.4,"freshAt":"2024-10-09T19:46:30Z","freshnessRank":318,"freshEventScore":135,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 181 pts / 108 comments (2012) + 182 pts / 77 comments (2022), different submitters and 3,416 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":31,"peak_comments":17,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=389107","height":4,"chart_height":29},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":181,"peak_comments":108,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4920831","height":9,"chart_height":169},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":131,"peak_comments":45,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7069642","height":6,"chart_height":122},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12438337","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":21,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21377975","height":4,"chart_height":20},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":182,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31129936","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":135,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41791875","height":6,"chart_height":126},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/tcl-the-misunderstood-2006-d9d0233f172f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/tcl-the-misunderstood-2006-d9d0233f172f/"},{"slug":"why-adventure-games-suck-1989-d9d023491f5a","title":"Why Adventure Games Suck (1989)","domain":"grumpygamer.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_design","game_development","interactive_fiction"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2022-09","inductedMonth":"2022-09","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":11.266,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":150,"evidenceRank":403,"evidenceScore":73.4,"freshAt":"2024-07-22T17:02:39Z","freshnessRank":359,"freshEventScore":131,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 131 pts / 154 comments (2024) + 150 pts / 104 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,586 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5559165","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8915698","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15569221","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17657892","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":150,"peak_comments":104,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22625578","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":47,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32936015","height":4,"chart_height":53},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":131,"peak_comments":154,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41036663","height":6,"chart_height":148},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-adventure-games-suck-1989-d9d023491f5a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-adventure-games-suck-1989-d9d023491f5a/"},{"slug":"p5-js-d9d0234d2544","title":"p5.js","domain":"p5js.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["art","visual_design","programming_languages","teaching"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2022-10","inductedMonth":"2022-10","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":10.141,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":468,"evidenceRank":404,"evidenceScore":73.4,"freshAt":"2024-08-03T04:53:10Z","freshnessRank":355,"freshEventScore":468,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 468 pts / 68 comments (2024) + 349 pts / 76 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,579 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7891077","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9940861","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":349,"peak_comments":76,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14749527","height":17,"chart_height":127},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22195586","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":244,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33176026","height":12,"chart_height":89},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":468,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41144755","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/p5-js-d9d0234d2544.jpg","path":"/hall/link/p5-js-d9d0234d2544/"},{"slug":"common-crawl-d9d02345806b","title":"Common Crawl","domain":"commoncrawl.org","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"dataset","typeDisplay":"Datasets","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["digital_archives","data_engineering"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2021-03","inductedMonth":"2021-03","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":12.98,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":397,"evidenceRank":405,"evidenceScore":73.4,"freshAt":"2025-03-04T23:22:04Z","freshnessRank":243,"freshEventScore":27,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 397 pts / 61 comments (2021) + 125 pts / 5 comments (2012), different submitters and 3,301 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":125,"peak_comments":5,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3690974","height":6,"chart_height":54},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5154057","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10124709","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18203325","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22544693","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":397,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26594172","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33814797","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":4,"peak_score":68,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35607070","height":4,"chart_height":29},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":27,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43260814","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/common-crawl-d9d02345806b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/common-crawl-d9d02345806b/"},{"slug":"git-for-computer-scientists-d9d0233e1c07","title":"Git for Computer Scientists","domain":"eagain.net","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2007,"candidateMonth":"2021-06","inductedMonth":"2021-06","submissions":12,"submitters":11,"spanYears":17.667,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":259,"evidenceRank":406,"evidenceScore":73.3,"freshAt":"2021-06-13T10:06:13Z","freshnessRank":899,"freshEventScore":259,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 259 pts / 101 comments (2021) + 103 pts / 15 comments (2011), different submitters and 3,520 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34899","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=573018","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":70,"peak_comments":17,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1485612","height":4,"chart_height":46},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":103,"peak_comments":15,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3146466","height":5,"chart_height":68},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11173948","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16101253","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19004780","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23952764","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":259,"peak_comments":101,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27491286","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36325208","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43384336","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/git-for-computer-scientists-d9d0233e1c07.jpg","path":"/hall/link/git-for-computer-scientists-d9d0233e1c07/"},{"slug":"terry-davis-has-died-d9d02348df9b","title":"Terry Davis has died","domain":"www.templeos.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2018-09","inductedMonth":"2020-05","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":12.093,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":634,"evidenceRank":407,"evidenceScore":73.3,"freshAt":"2020-05-08T09:23:45Z","freshnessRank":1010,"freshEventScore":154,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 634 pts / 198 comments (2018) + 174 pts / 136 comments (2013), different submitters and 1,830 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":174,"peak_comments":136,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6308017","height":8,"chart_height":47},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":634,"peak_comments":198,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17912618","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":154,"peak_comments":73,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23112887","height":7,"chart_height":41},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32220134","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43778778","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/terry-davis-has-died-d9d02348df9b/"},{"slug":"lessons-i-wish-i-had-learned-before-i-started-teaching-different-d9d0235809f7","title":"Lessons I wish I had learned before I started teaching differential equations [pdf] (1997)","domain":"web.williams.edu","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"research_paper","typeDisplay":"Research papers","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2022-08","inductedMonth":"2022-08","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":6.193,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":426,"evidenceRank":408,"evidenceScore":73.3,"freshAt":"2023-11-13T09:36:16Z","freshnessRank":497,"freshEventScore":351,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 351 pts / 248 comments (2023) + 308 pts / 108 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,261 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":308,"peak_comments":108,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15163979","height":15,"chart_height":123},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20692260","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27551162","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":426,"peak_comments":177,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32530035","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":351,"peak_comments":248,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38248532","height":17,"chart_height":140},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/lessons-i-wish-i-had-learned-before-i-started-teaching-different-d9d0235809f7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/lessons-i-wish-i-had-learned-before-i-started-teaching-different-d9d0235809f7/"},{"slug":"a-python-3-implementation-for-client-side-web-programming-d9d0234991f4","title":"A Python 3 implementation for client-side web programming","domain":"www.brython.info","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-11","inductedMonth":"2019-06","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":10.984,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":403,"evidenceRank":409,"evidenceScore":73.3,"freshAt":"2020-07-06T09:21:38Z","freshnessRank":1001,"freshEventScore":403,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 403 pts / 214 comments (2020) + 278 pts / 117 comments (2013), different submitters and 2,591 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":278,"peak_comments":117,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5807059","height":13,"chart_height":117},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":117,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9792536","height":6,"chart_height":49},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13058532","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15914805","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20082491","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":403,"peak_comments":214,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23746067","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40494714","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-python-3-implementation-for-client-side-web-programming-d9d0234991f4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-python-3-implementation-for-client-side-web-programming-d9d0234991f4/"},{"slug":"why-do-we-need-modules-at-all-2011-d9d0234e6f30","title":"Why do we need modules at all? (2011)","domain":"erlang.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"social_post_thread","typeDisplay":"Social posts & threads","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","software_architecture","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2019-08","inductedMonth":"2019-08","submissions":9,"submitters":8,"spanYears":8.882,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":155,"evidenceRank":410,"evidenceScore":73.3,"freshAt":"2023-09-25T01:53:28Z","freshnessRank":538,"freshEventScore":116,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 116 pts / 118 comments (2023) + 151 pts / 102 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,489 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":155,"peak_comments":76,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8572600","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9202241","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11350433","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15237160","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":151,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20808000","height":7,"chart_height":166},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":116,"peak_comments":118,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37638894","height":6,"chart_height":127},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-do-we-need-modules-at-all-2011-d9d0234e6f30.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-do-we-need-modules-at-all-2011-d9d0234e6f30/"},{"slug":"latency-numbers-every-programmer-should-know-d9d023463dd5","title":"Latency numbers every programmer should know","domain":"gist.github.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["performance_reliability","computer_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2017-01","inductedMonth":"2018-07","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":13.988,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":265,"evidenceRank":411,"evidenceScore":73.3,"freshAt":"2020-10-03T19:49:04Z","freshnessRank":990,"freshEventScore":197,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 265 pts / 134 comments (2012) + 197 pts / 68 comments (2020), different submitters and 3,047 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":265,"peak_comments":134,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4047623","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11447363","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":107,"peak_comments":22,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13530820","height":5,"chart_height":69},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17529783","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":197,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24674239","height":9,"chart_height":126},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29785085","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43438418","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48293691","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/latency-numbers-every-programmer-should-know-d9d023463dd5/"},{"slug":"a-guide-to-implementing-2d-platformers-d9d023462858","title":"A guide to implementing 2D platformers","domain":"higherorderfun.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_development","computer_graphics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2022-05","inductedMonth":"2022-05","submissions":12,"submitters":8,"spanYears":12.35,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":307,"evidenceRank":412,"evidenceScore":73.2,"freshAt":"2024-09-27T16:39:43Z","freshnessRank":324,"freshEventScore":122,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 307 pts / 32 comments (2015) + 190 pts / 37 comments (2022), different submitters and 2,443 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":3,"peak_score":31,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4005883","height":4,"chart_height":17},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5277048","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":307,"peak_comments":32,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10202275","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16032426","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19237768","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28483991","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":190,"peak_comments":37,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31450218","height":9,"chart_height":105},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":122,"peak_comments":8,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41672669","height":6,"chart_height":68},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-guide-to-implementing-2d-platformers-d9d023462858.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-guide-to-implementing-2d-platformers-d9d023462858/"},{"slug":"webdesigners-please-make-text-readable-d9d02343ad72","title":"Webdesigners: please make text readable","domain":"contrastrebellion.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["user_experience","visual_design","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2015-07","inductedMonth":"2017-06","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":11.781,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":467,"evidenceRank":413,"evidenceScore":73.2,"freshAt":"2023-05-07T10:40:15Z","freshnessRank":634,"freshEventScore":280,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 467 pts / 106 comments (2011) + 280 pts / 144 comments (2023), different submitters and 4,302 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":467,"peak_comments":106,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2807047","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":99,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9442322","height":5,"chart_height":36},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":86,"peak_comments":46,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14575153","height":4,"chart_height":31},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":70,"peak_comments":39,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26741509","height":4,"chart_height":25},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":280,"peak_comments":144,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35850044","height":13,"chart_height":102},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/webdesigners-please-make-text-readable-d9d02343ad72.jpg","path":"/hall/link/webdesigners-please-make-text-readable-d9d02343ad72/"},{"slug":"curl-wttr-in-d9d02352e307","title":"Curl Wttr.in","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["earth_science","open_source","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2022-05","inductedMonth":"2025-07","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":9.372,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":461,"evidenceRank":414,"evidenceScore":73.1,"freshAt":"2025-07-17T06:05:19Z","freshnessRank":189,"freshEventScore":264,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 461 pts / 122 comments (2020) + 264 pts / 87 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,847 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11215099","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13893563","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17848508","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19754043","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":461,"peak_comments":122,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23646953","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":368,"peak_comments":143,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31384236","height":18,"chart_height":136},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":264,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44590189","height":13,"chart_height":97},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/curl-wttr-in-d9d02352e307.jpg","path":"/hall/link/curl-wttr-in-d9d02352e307/"},{"slug":"webgl-fluid-simulation-d9d0235dcaec","title":"WebGL Fluid Simulation","domain":"paveldogreat.github.io","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["computer_graphics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-07","inductedMonth":"2024-07","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.613,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":868,"evidenceRank":415,"evidenceScore":73.1,"freshAt":"2024-12-29T04:39:49Z","freshnessRank":274,"freshEventScore":466,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 868 pts / 102 comments (2019) + 466 pts / 60 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,049 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":868,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19963640","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":314,"peak_comments":47,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25031304","height":15,"chart_height":61},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32051941","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":143,"peak_comments":21,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34422948","height":7,"chart_height":28},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":466,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42537567","height":22,"chart_height":91},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/webgl-fluid-simulation-d9d0235dcaec.jpg","path":"/hall/link/webgl-fluid-simulation-d9d0235dcaec/"},{"slug":"why-you-should-never-use-mongodb-d9d0234b1ca3","title":"Why You Should Never Use MongoDB","domain":"www.sarahmei.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["databases_storage"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2019-04","inductedMonth":"2021-02","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":10.645,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":568,"evidenceRank":416,"evidenceScore":73.0,"freshAt":"2021-02-01T16:55:23Z","freshnessRank":946,"freshEventScore":131,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 568 pts / 337 comments (2013) + 194 pts / 183 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,007 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":568,"peak_comments":337,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6712703","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":194,"peak_comments":183,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12290739","height":9,"chart_height":58},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19563583","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":131,"peak_comments":141,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25990400","height":6,"chart_height":39},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40872312","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/why-you-should-never-use-mongodb-d9d0234b1ca3/"},{"slug":"nandgame-build-a-computer-from-scratch-d9d0235ae2da","title":"NandGame – Build a Computer from Scratch","domain":"nandgame.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"computer_game","typeDisplay":"Computer games","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["computer_architecture","learning_methods","electronics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2020-12","inductedMonth":"2022-04","submissions":13,"submitters":12,"spanYears":7.732,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":627,"evidenceRank":417,"evidenceScore":73.0,"freshAt":"2022-04-16T19:27:20Z","freshnessRank":791,"freshEventScore":137,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 627 pts / 136 comments (2020) + 143 pts / 60 comments (2018), different submitters and 875 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":143,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17508151","height":7,"chart_height":39},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":627,"peak_comments":136,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25282507","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":137,"peak_comments":14,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31055307","height":7,"chart_height":37},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36862274","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41916156","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42959331","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47642552","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/nandgame-build-a-computer-from-scratch-d9d0235ae2da.jpg","path":"/hall/link/nandgame-build-a-computer-from-scratch-d9d0235ae2da/"},{"slug":"regexr-a-website-for-interactive-regex-prototyping-with-syntax-h-d9d0234c69b5","title":"RegExr: A website for interactive regex prototyping with syntax highlighting","domain":"regexr.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2017-02","inductedMonth":"2019-08","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":7.838,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":384,"evidenceRank":418,"evidenceScore":73.0,"freshAt":"2022-01-27T17:09:30Z","freshnessRank":829,"freshEventScore":188,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 384 pts / 70 comments (2015) + 349 pts / 54 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,537 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7477702","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":384,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9581225","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":131,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13599952","height":6,"chart_height":58},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":349,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20614847","height":17,"chart_height":155},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":188,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30103085","height":9,"chart_height":83},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/regexr-a-website-for-interactive-regex-prototyping-with-syntax-h-d9d0234c69b5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/regexr-a-website-for-interactive-regex-prototyping-with-syntax-h-d9d0234c69b5/"},{"slug":"designing-better-file-organization-around-tags-not-hierarchies-2-d9d023565e19","title":"Designing better file organization around tags, not hierarchies (2017)","domain":"www.nayuki.io","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["databases_storage","user_experience","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-11","inductedMonth":"2021-11","submissions":9,"submitters":8,"spanYears":8.238,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":286,"evidenceRank":419,"evidenceScore":73.0,"freshAt":"2025-06-04T12:55:16Z","freshnessRank":203,"freshEventScore":43,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 286 pts / 226 comments (2021) + 230 pts / 161 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,312 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13832694","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":230,"peak_comments":161,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16763235","height":11,"chart_height":137},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24230229","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":286,"peak_comments":226,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29141800","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36027854","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":43,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44180239","height":4,"chart_height":26},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/designing-better-file-organization-around-tags-not-hierarchies-2-d9d023565e19.jpg","path":"/hall/link/designing-better-file-organization-around-tags-not-hierarchies-2-d9d023565e19/"},{"slug":"vendors-that-treat-single-sign-on-as-a-luxury-feature-d9d0235bcb85","title":"Vendors that treat single sign-on as a luxury feature","domain":"sso.tax","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security","management_strategy","startups_entrepreneurship"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2022-04","inductedMonth":"2025-08","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":6.831,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":288,"evidenceRank":420,"evidenceScore":72.9,"freshAt":"2025-08-19T19:38:38Z","freshnessRank":169,"freshEventScore":288,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 288 pts / 191 comments (2025) + 65 pts / 64 comments (2020), different submitters and 2,014 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":39,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18260954","height":4,"chart_height":23},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":65,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22313973","height":4,"chart_height":38},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28728047","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":106,"peak_comments":41,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31175300","height":5,"chart_height":63},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38688926","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41123605","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":288,"peak_comments":191,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44955457","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/vendors-that-treat-single-sign-on-as-a-luxury-feature-d9d0235bcb85.jpg","path":"/hall/link/vendors-that-treat-single-sign-on-as-a-luxury-feature-d9d0235bcb85/"},{"slug":"an-interactive-guide-to-the-fourier-transform-2012-d9d02347fe40","title":"An Interactive Guide to the Fourier Transform (2012)","domain":"betterexplained.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2017-04","inductedMonth":"2023-12","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":12.95,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":301,"evidenceRank":421,"evidenceScore":72.9,"freshAt":"2025-12-02T06:50:17Z","freshnessRank":110,"freshEventScore":252,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 301 pts / 79 comments (2021) + 252 pts / 60 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,656 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":218,"peak_comments":25,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4948082","height":10,"chart_height":123},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":156,"peak_comments":18,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10635075","height":7,"chart_height":88},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14085089","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":301,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27229836","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":221,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38652794","height":11,"chart_height":125},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":252,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46118358","height":12,"chart_height":142},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/an-interactive-guide-to-the-fourier-transform-2012-d9d02347fe40.jpg","path":"/hall/link/an-interactive-guide-to-the-fourier-transform-2012-d9d02347fe40/"},{"slug":"show-hn-i-made-a-tool-that-made-me-faster-at-git-d9d0235b1a4d","title":"Show HN: I made a tool that made me faster at Git","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-11","inductedMonth":"2021-11","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":6.825,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":551,"evidenceRank":422,"evidenceScore":72.9,"freshAt":"2023-07-19T04:07:08Z","freshnessRank":588,"freshEventScore":239,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 551 pts / 229 comments (2018) + 395 pts / 141 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,213 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":551,"peak_comments":229,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17689014","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24960594","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":395,"peak_comments":141,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29394162","height":19,"chart_height":122},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":239,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36782018","height":11,"chart_height":74},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44160357","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/show-hn-i-made-a-tool-that-made-me-faster-at-git-d9d0235b1a4d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/show-hn-i-made-a-tool-that-made-me-faster-at-git-d9d0235b1a4d/"},{"slug":"dive-a-tool-for-exploring-each-layer-in-a-docker-image-d9d0235bd556","title":"Dive – A tool for exploring each layer in a Docker image","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","performance_reliability","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2024-01","inductedMonth":"2024-01","submissions":15,"submitters":15,"spanYears":5.207,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":684,"evidenceRank":423,"evidenceScore":72.9,"freshAt":"2024-01-08T15:35:38Z","freshnessRank":464,"freshEventScore":464,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 684 pts / 42 comments (2018) + 464 pts / 61 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,869 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":6,"peak_score":684,"peak_comments":42,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18528423","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23008000","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26516641","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32032455","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37947436","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":464,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38913425","height":22,"chart_height":115},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/dive-a-tool-for-exploring-each-layer-in-a-docker-image-d9d0235bd556.jpg","path":"/hall/link/dive-a-tool-for-exploring-each-layer-in-a-docker-image-d9d0235bd556/"},{"slug":"a-list-of-hacker-news-s-undocumented-features-and-behaviors-2018-d9d0235cebfb","title":"A List of Hacker News's Undocumented Features and Behaviors (2018)","domain":"github.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["internet_culture","online_communities","digital_archives"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-02","inductedMonth":"2023-12","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.62,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":673,"evidenceRank":424,"evidenceScore":72.9,"freshAt":"2025-10-04T15:32:03Z","freshnessRank":137,"freshEventScore":60,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 653 pts / 279 comments (2023) + 673 pts / 266 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,298 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":437,"peak_comments":183,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19212822","height":21,"chart_height":110},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":673,"peak_comments":266,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23439437","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":99,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30459276","height":5,"chart_height":25},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":653,"peak_comments":279,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38773957","height":24,"chart_height":165},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":60,"peak_comments":10,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45474050","height":4,"chart_height":15},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-list-of-hacker-news-s-undocumented-features-and-behaviors-2018-d9d0235cebfb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-list-of-hacker-news-s-undocumented-features-and-behaviors-2018-d9d0235cebfb/"},{"slug":"why-python-is-slow-looking-under-the-hood-d9d0234cd547","title":"Why Python Is Slow: Looking Under the Hood","domain":"jakevdp.github.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","performance_reliability","compilers_runtimes"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2016-07","inductedMonth":"2021-08","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":9.884,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":220,"evidenceRank":425,"evidenceScore":72.9,"freshAt":"2017-10-25T10:27:06Z","freshnessRank":1117,"freshEventScore":170,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 170 pts / 178 comments (2017) + 208 pts / 176 comments (2014), different submitters and 1,264 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":220,"peak_comments":176,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8625280","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":142,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12051542","height":7,"chart_height":110},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":170,"peak_comments":178,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15548904","height":8,"chart_height":131},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28317170","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39838522","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-python-is-slow-looking-under-the-hood-d9d0234cd547.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-python-is-slow-looking-under-the-hood-d9d0234cd547/"},{"slug":"bedrock-linux-a-meta-linux-distribution-d9d02346ee62","title":"Bedrock Linux – a meta Linux distribution","domain":"bedrocklinux.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2021-01","inductedMonth":"2021-01","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":13.681,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":242,"evidenceRank":426,"evidenceScore":72.9,"freshAt":"2021-01-31T23:34:44Z","freshnessRank":947,"freshEventScore":203,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 203 pts / 105 comments (2021) + 242 pts / 62 comments (2013), different submitters and 2,674 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4410612","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":242,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6504878","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20977723","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23264441","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":203,"peak_comments":105,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25983759","height":10,"chart_height":143},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31598691","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37156333","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46185122","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47917063","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/bedrock-linux-a-meta-linux-distribution-d9d02346ee62.jpg","path":"/hall/link/bedrock-linux-a-meta-linux-distribution-d9d02346ee62/"},{"slug":"system-bus-radio-transmits-am-radio-on-computers-without-transmi-d9d02352deaf","title":"System Bus Radio: Transmits AM radio on computers without transmitting hardware","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["electronics","computer_architecture","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-12","inductedMonth":"2023-04","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":8.381,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":515,"evidenceRank":427,"evidenceScore":72.9,"freshAt":"2020-12-17T04:23:54Z","freshnessRank":964,"freshEventScore":476,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 515 pts / 120 comments (2018) + 476 pts / 92 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,064 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":499,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11203951","height":24,"chart_height":165},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":515,"peak_comments":120,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16167594","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":476,"peak_comments":92,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25452435","height":23,"chart_height":157},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31710669","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35709278","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40999847","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/system-bus-radio-transmits-am-radio-on-computers-without-transmi-d9d02352deaf.jpg","path":"/hall/link/system-bus-radio-transmits-am-radio-on-computers-without-transmi-d9d02352deaf/"},{"slug":"against-dnssec-2015-d9d0234f04a5","title":"Against DNSSEC (2015)","domain":"sockpuppet.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography","protocols_networking"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2022-10","inductedMonth":"2022-10","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":11.305,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":186,"evidenceRank":428,"evidenceScore":72.8,"freshAt":"2022-10-21T14:40:28Z","freshnessRank":706,"freshEventScore":56,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 186 pts / 144 comments (2015) + 56 pts / 102 comments (2022), different submitters and 2,835 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":186,"peak_comments":144,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8894902","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12159477","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21499710","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22727260","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27103777","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":56,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33288466","height":4,"chart_height":51},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45157222","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48035788","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/against-dnssec-2015-d9d0234f04a5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/against-dnssec-2015-d9d0234f04a5/"},{"slug":"vivaldi-a-browser-for-our-friends-d9d0234f1f4f","title":"Vivaldi – A Browser for Our Friends","domain":"vivaldi.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["browsers_web_standards","privacy_surveillance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-09","inductedMonth":"2018-09","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":8.764,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":352,"evidenceRank":429,"evidenceScore":72.8,"freshAt":"2018-09-10T08:08:43Z","freshnessRank":1083,"freshEventScore":54,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 352 pts / 250 comments (2015) + 54 pts / 53 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,321 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":352,"peak_comments":250,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8952100","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12507691","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":209,"peak_comments":183,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13332480","height":10,"chart_height":101},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":54,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17950192","height":4,"chart_height":26},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31918288","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38108949","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/vivaldi-a-browser-for-our-friends-d9d0234f1f4f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/vivaldi-a-browser-for-our-friends-d9d0234f1f4f/"},{"slug":"you-suck-at-excel-with-joel-spolsky-2015-video-d9d0235142d3","title":"You Suck at Excel with Joel Spolsky (2015) [video]","domain":"youtube.com","category":"media","categoryDisplay":"Audio, video & images","type":"video","typeDisplay":"Video","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["teaching"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-12","inductedMonth":"2019-12","submissions":9,"submitters":8,"spanYears":7.83,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":957,"evidenceRank":430,"evidenceScore":72.8,"freshAt":"2023-07-08T21:41:02Z","freshnessRank":594,"freshEventScore":219,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 957 pts / 420 comments (2016) + 228 pts / 77 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,198 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":37,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10201441","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":957,"peak_comments":420,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12448545","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":228,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21847372","height":11,"chart_height":41},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":41,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26510527","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32759837","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":219,"peak_comments":114,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36649047","height":11,"chart_height":39},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/you-suck-at-excel-with-joel-spolsky-2015-video-d9d0235142d3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/you-suck-at-excel-with-joel-spolsky-2015-video-d9d0235142d3/"},{"slug":"trunk-based-development-d9d02355f7b1","title":"Trunk-Based Development","domain":"trunkbaseddevelopment.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","testing_quality","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2024-01","inductedMonth":"2024-01","submissions":11,"submitters":10,"spanYears":9.062,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":199,"evidenceRank":431,"evidenceScore":72.7,"freshAt":"2026-02-21T07:07:12Z","freshnessRank":56,"freshEventScore":73,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 199 pts / 205 comments (2017) + 90 pts / 99 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,548 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":199,"peak_comments":205,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13514289","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20146549","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23627280","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26429382","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37378943","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":90,"peak_comments":99,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39084135","height":4,"chart_height":77},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45747111","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":73,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47098252","height":4,"chart_height":62}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/trunk-based-development-d9d02355f7b1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/trunk-based-development-d9d02355f7b1/"},{"slug":"the-great-unbundling-d9d023604b0c","title":"The Great Unbundling","domain":"www.ben-evans.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["management_strategy","markets","artificial_intelligence"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2024-11","inductedMonth":"2024-11","submissions":21,"submitters":20,"spanYears":6.3,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":246,"evidenceRank":432,"evidenceScore":72.6,"freshAt":"2024-11-22T06:30:48Z","freshnessRank":295,"freshEventScore":104,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 246 pts / 131 comments (2021) + 104 pts / 95 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,391 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 21 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":7,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22228254","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":246,"peak_comments":131,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25970658","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":4,"peak_score":33,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34755983","height":4,"chart_height":23},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":104,"peak_comments":95,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42211616","height":5,"chart_height":72},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46062906","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48175891","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-great-unbundling-d9d023604b0c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-great-unbundling-d9d023604b0c/"},{"slug":"paris-syndrome-d9d0234c2ec5","title":"Paris syndrome","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"medicine_health","topicDisplay":"Medicine & health","tags":["mental_health","psychology"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2020-01","inductedMonth":"2020-01","submissions":14,"submitters":14,"spanYears":10.593,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":120,"evidenceRank":433,"evidenceScore":72.6,"freshAt":"2020-01-11T15:33:08Z","freshnessRank":1028,"freshEventScore":120,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 120 pts / 156 comments (2020) + 74 pts / 70 comments (2014), different submitters and 1,994 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":74,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8092535","height":4,"chart_height":105},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15389043","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18688623","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21910768","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":120,"peak_comments":156,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22020336","height":6,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29863904","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":19,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35295376","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41755706","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/paris-syndrome-d9d0234c2ec5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/paris-syndrome-d9d0234c2ec5/"},{"slug":"the-board-game-of-the-alpha-nerds-d9d0234d2fa5","title":"The Board Game of the Alpha Nerds","domain":"grantland.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_design","game_history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2018-10","inductedMonth":"2018-10","submissions":14,"submitters":7,"spanYears":10.749,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":315,"evidenceRank":434,"evidenceScore":72.6,"freshAt":"2021-02-21T18:26:04Z","freshnessRank":940,"freshEventScore":139,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 315 pts / 153 comments (2014) + 139 pts / 87 comments (2021), different submitters and 2,439 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":315,"peak_comments":153,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7913183","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9424163","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14614805","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":118,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18159770","height":6,"chart_height":64},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23982970","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":139,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26215764","height":7,"chart_height":75},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31473034","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43404686","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-board-game-of-the-alpha-nerds-d9d0234d2fa5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-board-game-of-the-alpha-nerds-d9d0234d2fa5/"},{"slug":"what-i-learned-as-a-hired-consultant-to-autodidact-physicists-20-d9d023545eae","title":"What I learned as a hired consultant to autodidact physicists (2016)","domain":"aeon.co","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["physics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2022-04","inductedMonth":"2022-04","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":8.088,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":765,"evidenceRank":435,"evidenceScore":72.6,"freshAt":"2022-04-04T15:51:42Z","freshnessRank":796,"freshEventScore":765,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 765 pts / 396 comments (2022) + 563 pts / 318 comments (2016), different submitters and 2,062 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":563,"peak_comments":318,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12268362","height":24,"chart_height":125},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17731742","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21753140","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26299103","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":765,"peak_comments":396,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30908084","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39653961","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-i-learned-as-a-hired-consultant-to-autodidact-physicists-20-d9d023545eae.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-i-learned-as-a-hired-consultant-to-autodidact-physicists-20-d9d023545eae/"},{"slug":"holding-a-program-in-one-s-head-2007-d9d0233e2530","title":"Holding a Program in One's Head (2007)","domain":"paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2007,"candidateMonth":"2012-12","inductedMonth":"2017-07","submissions":7,"submitters":5,"spanYears":13.61,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":215,"evidenceRank":436,"evidenceScore":72.6,"freshAt":"2018-09-21T17:40:31Z","freshnessRank":1081,"freshEventScore":215,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 142 pts / 131 comments (2007) + 215 pts / 79 comments (2018), different submitters and 4,047 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":1,"peak_score":142,"peak_comments":131,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45698","height":7,"chart_height":112},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":55,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2988835","height":4,"chart_height":43},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":213,"peak_comments":101,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4890788","height":10,"chart_height":168},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13271047","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14873724","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":215,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18041337","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26670995","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/holding-a-program-in-one-s-head-2007-d9d0233e2530.jpg","path":"/hall/link/holding-a-program-in-one-s-head-2007-d9d0233e2530/"},{"slug":"kitty-a-fast-featureful-gpu-based-terminal-emulator-d9d0235b61f1","title":"Kitty – a fast, featureful, GPU based terminal emulator","domain":"sw.kovidgoyal.net","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","performance_reliability","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-02","inductedMonth":"2022-03","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":7.042,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":452,"evidenceRank":437,"evidenceScore":72.6,"freshAt":"2025-09-20T13:51:05Z","freshnessRank":142,"freshEventScore":98,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 452 pts / 315 comments (2018) + 385 pts / 195 comments (2020), different submitters and 756 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":452,"peak_comments":315,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17915829","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":385,"peak_comments":195,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24643008","height":18,"chart_height":145},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26275638","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":62,"peak_comments":31,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30779782","height":4,"chart_height":23},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":22,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37064481","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42248356","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":98,"peak_comments":84,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45313417","height":5,"chart_height":37},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/kitty-a-fast-featureful-gpu-based-terminal-emulator-d9d0235b61f1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/kitty-a-fast-featureful-gpu-based-terminal-emulator-d9d0235b61f1/"},{"slug":"cli-guidelines-a-guide-to-help-you-write-better-command-line-pro-d9d02363b578","title":"CLI Guidelines – A guide to help you write better command-line programs","domain":"clig.dev","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","user_experience","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2024-02","inductedMonth":"2024-02","submissions":14,"submitters":14,"spanYears":5.602,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":564,"evidenceRank":438,"evidenceScore":72.6,"freshAt":"2024-02-06T13:25:34Z","freshnessRank":445,"freshEventScore":341,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 564 pts / 212 comments (2020) + 341 pts / 201 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,158 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":564,"peak_comments":212,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25304257","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":61,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31651161","height":4,"chart_height":18},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38177318","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":341,"peak_comments":201,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39273932","height":16,"chart_height":103},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45818235","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48881064","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/cli-guidelines-a-guide-to-help-you-write-better-command-line-pro-d9d02363b578.jpg","path":"/hall/link/cli-guidelines-a-guide-to-help-you-write-better-command-line-pro-d9d02363b578/"},{"slug":"why-functional-programming-matters-1990-pdf-d9d0234d46eb","title":"Why functional programming matters (1990) [pdf]","domain":"www.cs.kent.ac.uk","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"research_paper","typeDisplay":"Research papers","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2019-11","inductedMonth":"2019-11","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":9.895,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":113,"evidenceRank":439,"evidenceScore":72.5,"freshAt":"2024-05-22T20:57:21Z","freshnessRank":390,"freshEventScore":27,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 113 pts / 139 comments (2015) + 102 pts / 103 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,646 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8491100","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":113,"peak_comments":139,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9502049","height":5,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17941223","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":102,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21480926","height":5,"chart_height":153},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29946167","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38555471","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":27,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40446449","height":4,"chart_height":41},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-functional-programming-matters-1990-pdf-d9d0234d46eb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-functional-programming-matters-1990-pdf-d9d0234d46eb/"},{"slug":"room-641a-d9d02342cd7d","title":"Room 641A","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["privacy_surveillance","security_incidents"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2016-09","inductedMonth":"2020-05","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":14.976,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":333,"evidenceRank":440,"evidenceScore":72.5,"freshAt":"2024-09-11T00:57:23Z","freshnessRank":334,"freshEventScore":51,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 333 pts / 70 comments (2020) + 248 pts / 44 comments (2013), different submitters and 2,546 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2359169","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4582376","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":248,"peak_comments":44,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5847166","height":12,"chart_height":127},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":207,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12515724","height":10,"chart_height":106},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":333,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23350120","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":29,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32984515","height":4,"chart_height":15},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":51,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41507188","height":4,"chart_height":26},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47374643","height":4,"chart_height":6}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/room-641a-d9d02342cd7d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/room-641a-d9d02342cd7d/"},{"slug":"a-conspiracy-to-kill-ie6-2019-d9d02362869a","title":"A Conspiracy to Kill IE6 (2019)","domain":"blog.chriszacharias.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["browsers_web_standards","web_development","internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2024-02","inductedMonth":"2024-02","submissions":12,"submitters":10,"spanYears":5.183,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":236,"evidenceRank":441,"evidenceScore":72.5,"freshAt":"2025-10-16T18:22:08Z","freshnessRank":127,"freshEventScore":212,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 212 pts / 141 comments (2025) + 236 pts / 77 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,475 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24464189","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":7,"peak_score":236,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28725293","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38210439","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":185,"peak_comments":106,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39294406","height":9,"chart_height":133},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":212,"peak_comments":141,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45608887","height":10,"chart_height":153},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-conspiracy-to-kill-ie6-2019-d9d02362869a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-conspiracy-to-kill-ie6-2019-d9d02362869a/"},{"slug":"show-hn-bocker-docker-implemented-in-100-lines-of-bash-d9d02350d332","title":"Show HN: Bocker – Docker implemented in 100 lines of bash","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2022-10","inductedMonth":"2022-10","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":9.344,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":662,"evidenceRank":442,"evidenceScore":72.5,"freshAt":"2024-11-23T23:18:51Z","freshnessRank":293,"freshEventScore":398,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 662 pts / 87 comments (2015) + 398 pts / 114 comments (2024), different submitters and 3,413 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":662,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9925896","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":51,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16453610","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23167284","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":315,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33218094","height":15,"chart_height":81},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":398,"peak_comments":114,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42224670","height":19,"chart_height":102},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/show-hn-bocker-docker-implemented-in-100-lines-of-bash-d9d02350d332.jpg","path":"/hall/link/show-hn-bocker-docker-implemented-in-100-lines-of-bash-d9d02350d332/"},{"slug":"stop-using-jwt-for-sessions-2016-d9d02353d92d","title":"Stop using JWT for sessions (2016)","domain":"cryto.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security","cryptography","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2018-11","inductedMonth":"2018-11","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":7.984,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":248,"evidenceRank":443,"evidenceScore":72.5,"freshAt":"2018-11-01T13:56:10Z","freshnessRank":1079,"freshEventScore":248,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 248 pts / 245 comments (2018) + 226 pts / 147 comments (2016), different submitters and 870 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":226,"peak_comments":147,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11895440","height":11,"chart_height":155},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":20,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15450042","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":248,"peak_comments":245,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18353874","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24538823","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27727708","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33064259","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40605637","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/stop-using-jwt-for-sessions-2016-d9d02353d92d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/stop-using-jwt-for-sessions-2016-d9d02353d92d/"},{"slug":"ink-react-for-interactive-command-line-apps-d9d0235796b8","title":"Ink: React for interactive command-line apps","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2023-05","inductedMonth":"2023-05","submissions":9,"submitters":8,"spanYears":7.296,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":588,"evidenceRank":444,"evidenceScore":72.5,"freshAt":"2024-11-01T13:15:47Z","freshnessRank":304,"freshEventScore":164,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 588 pts / 178 comments (2023) + 129 pts / 42 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,115 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":129,"peak_comments":42,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14831961","height":6,"chart_height":37},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16732693","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23739791","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27248769","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":588,"peak_comments":178,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35863837","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":164,"peak_comments":106,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42016639","height":8,"chart_height":47},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/ink-react-for-interactive-command-line-apps-d9d0235796b8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/ink-react-for-interactive-command-line-apps-d9d0235796b8/"},{"slug":"open-infrastructure-map-d9d0235bb156","title":"Open Infrastructure Map","domain":"openinframap.org","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["cities_infrastructure","energy","internet_infrastructure"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2024-01","inductedMonth":"2026-01","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":7.25,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":465,"evidenceRank":445,"evidenceScore":72.5,"freshAt":"2026-01-08T03:31:12Z","freshnessRank":83,"freshEventScore":465,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 465 pts / 93 comments (2026) + 298 pts / 45 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,453 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18179352","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":37,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20523882","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25591906","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":4,"peak_score":298,"peak_comments":45,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29948473","height":14,"chart_height":109},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":187,"peak_comments":39,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39109185","height":9,"chart_height":68},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42870695","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":465,"peak_comments":93,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46536866","height":22,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/open-infrastructure-map-d9d0235bb156.jpg","path":"/hall/link/open-infrastructure-map-d9d0235bb156/"},{"slug":"tough-times-on-the-road-to-starcraft-2012-d9d0234715e9","title":"Tough times on the road to Starcraft (2012)","domain":"www.codeofhonor.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_history","game_development","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2020-08","inductedMonth":"2022-08","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":12.657,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":360,"evidenceRank":446,"evidenceScore":72.4,"freshAt":"2022-08-13T03:34:10Z","freshnessRank":731,"freshEventScore":212,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 360 pts / 68 comments (2012) + 212 pts / 112 comments (2022), different submitters and 3,626 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":360,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4491216","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":165,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8938647","height":8,"chart_height":78},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24577140","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":212,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32446653","height":10,"chart_height":100},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40896045","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43894034","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/tough-times-on-the-road-to-starcraft-2012-d9d0234715e9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/tough-times-on-the-road-to-starcraft-2012-d9d0234715e9/"},{"slug":"the-hunt-for-the-death-valley-germans-d9d023507e57","title":"The Hunt for the Death Valley Germans","domain":"www.otherhand.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["food_travel"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-02","inductedMonth":"2023-02","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":8.966,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":179,"evidenceRank":447,"evidenceScore":72.4,"freshAt":"2024-06-03T22:07:14Z","freshnessRank":385,"freshEventScore":23,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 127 pts / 147 comments (2023) + 179 pts / 61 comments (2016), different submitters and 2,410 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9723065","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":179,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12019567","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":112,"peak_comments":38,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19263057","height":5,"chart_height":106},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":103,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23582417","height":5,"chart_height":98},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32871761","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":127,"peak_comments":147,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34676129","height":6,"chart_height":121},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":23,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40568151","height":4,"chart_height":22},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-hunt-for-the-death-valley-germans-d9d023507e57.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-hunt-for-the-death-valley-germans-d9d023507e57/"},{"slug":"social-cooling-2017-d9d023574b3e","title":"Social Cooling (2017)","domain":"www.socialcooling.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["privacy_surveillance","technology_ethics","social_issues"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-09","inductedMonth":"2023-12","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":8.309,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":2692,"evidenceRank":448,"evidenceScore":72.4,"freshAt":"2025-10-05T06:01:24Z","freshnessRank":136,"freshEventScore":432,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 2692 pts / 1059 comments (2020) + 432 pts / 276 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,831 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":389,"peak_comments":185,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14585882","height":19,"chart_height":25},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2692,"peak_comments":1059,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24627363","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":50,"peak_comments":15,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38482582","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":432,"peak_comments":276,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45479165","height":21,"chart_height":27},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/social-cooling-2017-d9d023574b3e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/social-cooling-2017-d9d023574b3e/"},{"slug":"practical-common-lisp-2005-d9d0233e0ea4","title":"Practical Common Lisp (2005)","domain":"www.gigamonkeys.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2007,"candidateMonth":"2018-07","inductedMonth":"2022-01","submissions":9,"submitters":7,"spanYears":19.069,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":296,"evidenceRank":449,"evidenceScore":72.3,"freshAt":"2026-05-29T10:39:47Z","freshnessRank":12,"freshEventScore":20,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 296 pts / 157 comments (2016) + 144 pts / 43 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,861 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19360","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9359479","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":296,"peak_comments":157,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13096576","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":144,"peak_comments":84,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17644067","height":7,"chart_height":83},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25289352","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":144,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29850703","height":7,"chart_height":83},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37862428","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":20,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48321398","height":4,"chart_height":11}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/practical-common-lisp-2005-d9d0233e0ea4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/practical-common-lisp-2005-d9d0233e0ea4/"},{"slug":"adblock-via-etc-hosts-d9d0234d31f7","title":"Adblock via /etc/hosts","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"source_code","typeDisplay":"Source code","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["abuse_fraud","privacy_surveillance","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2023-06","inductedMonth":"2023-06","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":8.98,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":273,"evidenceRank":450,"evidenceScore":72.3,"freshAt":"2023-06-12T13:24:38Z","freshnessRank":615,"freshEventScore":150,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 273 pts / 139 comments (2016) + 150 pts / 78 comments (2023), different submitters and 2,677 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7917576","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10601358","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":273,"peak_comments":139,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11084968","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15866034","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17454786","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21674229","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23953737","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27394039","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32378433","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":150,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36293026","height":7,"chart_height":93},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/adblock-via-etc-hosts-d9d0234d31f7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/adblock-via-etc-hosts-d9d0234d31f7/"},{"slug":"h-r-block-and-intuit-lobbying-against-simpler-tax-filing-2017-d9d023567bc2","title":"H&R Block and Intuit Lobbying Against Simpler Tax Filing (2017)","domain":"www.propublica.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["finance","law_regulation","management_strategy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2022-02","inductedMonth":"2022-03","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.024,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":631,"evidenceRank":451,"evidenceScore":72.3,"freshAt":"2022-03-30T15:57:53Z","freshnessRank":799,"freshEventScore":395,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 593 pts / 234 comments (2017) + 395 pts / 114 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,835 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":593,"peak_comments":234,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13922482","height":24,"chart_height":160},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":631,"peak_comments":232,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16841449","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":509,"peak_comments":190,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18956883","height":24,"chart_height":137},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":395,"peak_comments":114,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30856968","height":19,"chart_height":106},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/h-r-block-and-intuit-lobbying-against-simpler-tax-filing-2017-d9d023567bc2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/h-r-block-and-intuit-lobbying-against-simpler-tax-filing-2017-d9d023567bc2/"},{"slug":"alan-kay-smalltalk-is-not-about-objects-it-s-about-messaging-199-d9d0234100cc","title":"Alan Kay: Smalltalk is not about objects, it’s about messaging (1998)","domain":"lists.squeakfoundation.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"social_post_thread","typeDisplay":"Social posts & threads","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","software_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2019-12","inductedMonth":"2022-03","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":13.988,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":318,"evidenceRank":452,"evidenceScore":72.3,"freshAt":"2019-12-21T18:00:59Z","freshnessRank":1030,"freshEventScore":318,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 240 pts / 206 comments (2016) + 318 pts / 174 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,275 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":119,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1355977","height":6,"chart_height":64},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":240,"peak_comments":206,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11966570","height":12,"chart_height":128},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":318,"peak_comments":174,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21852444","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26527265","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30576524","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40332340","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/alan-kay-smalltalk-is-not-about-objects-it-s-about-messaging-199-d9d0234100cc/"},{"slug":"pathfinding-js-d9d023492d65","title":"PathFinding.js","domain":"qiao.github.io","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["algorithms_data_structures","human_computer_interaction","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2019-03","inductedMonth":"2019-03","submissions":12,"submitters":11,"spanYears":7.765,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":337,"evidenceRank":453,"evidenceScore":72.3,"freshAt":"2019-03-02T21:57:00Z","freshnessRank":1065,"freshEventScore":186,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 337 pts / 25 comments (2014) + 186 pts / 20 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,622 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":25,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5589699","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":337,"peak_comments":25,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8349069","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":215,"peak_comments":47,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9612990","height":10,"chart_height":108},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13163686","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14329367","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":186,"peak_comments":20,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19291394","height":9,"chart_height":94},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25914379","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/pathfinding-js-d9d023492d65.jpg","path":"/hall/link/pathfinding-js-d9d023492d65/"},{"slug":"yggdrasil-network-d9d0235aa3af","title":"Yggdrasil Network","domain":"yggdrasil-network.github.io","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","internet_infrastructure","cryptography"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2022-01","inductedMonth":"2024-11","submissions":9,"submitters":8,"spanYears":7.803,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":324,"evidenceRank":454,"evidenceScore":72.3,"freshAt":"2026-04-02T18:15:19Z","freshnessRank":35,"freshEventScore":122,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 324 pts / 106 comments (2024) + 216 pts / 77 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,019 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18666245","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":120,"peak_comments":15,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18863554","height":6,"chart_height":63},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29603682","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":216,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30156551","height":10,"chart_height":113},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38103951","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":324,"peak_comments":106,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42155780","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":122,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47618100","height":6,"chart_height":64}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/yggdrasil-network-d9d0235aa3af.jpg","path":"/hall/link/yggdrasil-network-d9d0235aa3af/"},{"slug":"e-prime-english-without-the-verb-to-be-d9d0233f27a5","title":"E-Prime: English without the verb 'to be'","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["language_linguistics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2019-08","inductedMonth":"2020-05","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":16.153,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":221,"evidenceRank":455,"evidenceScore":72.2,"freshAt":"2021-05-26T13:37:37Z","freshnessRank":905,"freshEventScore":108,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 221 pts / 152 comments (2015) + 108 pts / 76 comments (2009), different submitters and 2,527 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":108,"peak_comments":76,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=419895","height":5,"chart_height":83},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":221,"peak_comments":152,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10688201","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20772488","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23035485","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":108,"peak_comments":66,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27290317","height":5,"chart_height":83},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43235226","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/e-prime-english-without-the-verb-to-be-d9d0233f27a5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/e-prime-english-without-the-verb-to-be-d9d0233f27a5/"},{"slug":"show-hn-hn-replies-get-notified-of-replies-to-your-comments-d9d02352adb1","title":"Show HN: HN Replies – Get notified of replies to your comments","domain":"www.hnreplies.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["online_communities"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-10","inductedMonth":"2020-10","submissions":16,"submitters":12,"spanYears":10.218,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":217,"evidenceRank":456,"evidenceScore":72.2,"freshAt":"2022-04-10T17:21:01Z","freshnessRank":793,"freshEventScore":20,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 217 pts / 122 comments (2016) + 113 pts / 56 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,712 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":217,"peak_comments":122,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11080539","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21626942","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":113,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24834158","height":5,"chart_height":89},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29232257","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2022,"count":4,"peak_score":20,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30979295","height":4,"chart_height":16},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40529777","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45306059","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47979557","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/show-hn-hn-replies-get-notified-of-replies-to-your-comments-d9d02352adb1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/show-hn-hn-replies-get-notified-of-replies-to-your-comments-d9d02352adb1/"},{"slug":"veloren-voxel-action-adventure-role-playing-d9d0235f25fe","title":"Veloren – Voxel action-adventure role-playing","domain":"veloren.net","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"computer_game","typeDisplay":"Computer games","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["indie_games","game_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-03","inductedMonth":"2025-03","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":5.484,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":811,"evidenceRank":457,"evidenceScore":72.2,"freshAt":"2025-03-29T18:05:08Z","freshnessRank":233,"freshEventScore":340,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 811 pts / 177 comments (2022) + 340 pts / 91 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,111 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21161415","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24930475","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":308,"peak_comments":143,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26037461","height":15,"chart_height":65},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":811,"peak_comments":177,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30667022","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":340,"peak_comments":91,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43517337","height":16,"chart_height":71},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/veloren-voxel-action-adventure-role-playing-d9d0235f25fe.jpg","path":"/hall/link/veloren-voxel-action-adventure-role-playing-d9d0235f25fe/"},{"slug":"gooey-turn-almost-any-python-command-line-program-into-a-full-gu-d9d0234dbf73","title":"Gooey: Turn almost any Python command line program into a full GUI application","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"source_code","typeDisplay":"Source code","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","human_computer_interaction","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2021-06","inductedMonth":"2021-06","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":9.292,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":769,"evidenceRank":458,"evidenceScore":72.1,"freshAt":"2023-12-09T22:30:02Z","freshnessRank":486,"freshEventScore":769,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 769 pts / 118 comments (2023) + 693 pts / 115 comments (2021), different submitters and 909 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":486,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8218785","height":23,"chart_height":107},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16328355","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":693,"peak_comments":115,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27490291","height":24,"chart_height":153},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":769,"peak_comments":118,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38586767","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/gooey-turn-almost-any-python-command-line-program-into-a-full-gu-d9d0234dbf73.jpg","path":"/hall/link/gooey-turn-almost-any-python-command-line-program-into-a-full-gu-d9d0234dbf73/"},{"slug":"user-inyerface-a-worst-practice-ui-experiment-d9d0235e3afb","title":"User Inyerface – A worst-practice UI experiment","domain":"userinyerface.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["user_experience","product_design","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-10","inductedMonth":"2025-12","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.795,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":944,"evidenceRank":459,"evidenceScore":72.0,"freshAt":"2023-05-18T08:13:03Z","freshnessRank":627,"freshEventScore":362,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 944 pts / 215 comments (2021) + 757 pts / 255 comments (2019), different submitters and 723 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":757,"peak_comments":255,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20344565","height":24,"chart_height":136},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":944,"peak_comments":215,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27635310","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33187815","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":362,"peak_comments":113,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35985240","height":17,"chart_height":65},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46207805","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47821661","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/user-inyerface-a-worst-practice-ui-experiment-d9d0235e3afb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/user-inyerface-a-worst-practice-ui-experiment-d9d0235e3afb/"},{"slug":"the-grug-brained-developer-2022-d9d02368f97d","title":"The Grug Brained Developer (2022)","domain":"grugbrain.dev","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","testing_quality","personal_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2022,"candidateMonth":"2025-01","inductedMonth":"2025-06","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":2.987,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1087,"evidenceRank":460,"evidenceScore":72.0,"freshAt":"2025-06-17T20:24:36Z","freshnessRank":197,"freshEventScore":1087,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1087 pts / 578 comments (2025) + 1068 pts / 374 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,091 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":1068,"peak_comments":374,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31840331","height":24,"chart_height":167},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":490,"peak_comments":192,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38076886","height":24,"chart_height":77},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":8,"peak_score":1087,"peak_comments":578,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44303542","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-grug-brained-developer-2022-d9d02368f97d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-grug-brained-developer-2022-d9d02368f97d/"},{"slug":"using-the-wrong-dictionary-2014-d9d0234ce969","title":"Using the wrong dictionary (2014)","domain":"jsomers.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["language_linguistics","books_literature"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2021-12","inductedMonth":"2021-12","submissions":14,"submitters":13,"spanYears":11.548,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":291,"evidenceRank":461,"evidenceScore":72.0,"freshAt":"2023-09-03T07:44:00Z","freshnessRank":555,"freshEventScore":89,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 231 pts / 170 comments (2021) + 291 pts / 87 comments (2019), different submitters and 978 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7765006","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9294518","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18546144","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":291,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19763435","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":231,"peak_comments":170,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29734242","height":11,"chart_height":135},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":89,"peak_comments":33,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37368505","height":4,"chart_height":52},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46168791","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/using-the-wrong-dictionary-2014-d9d0234ce969.jpg","path":"/hall/link/using-the-wrong-dictionary-2014-d9d0234ce969/"},{"slug":"unix-toolbox-d9d0233ec569","title":"Unix Toolbox","domain":"cb.vu","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2015-08","inductedMonth":"2020-02","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":11.54,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":491,"evidenceRank":462,"evidenceScore":72.0,"freshAt":"2020-02-19T16:00:12Z","freshnessRank":1021,"freshEventScore":160,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 491 pts / 38 comments (2015) + 333 pts / 23 comments (2010), different submitters and 1,886 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=267577","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":333,"peak_comments":23,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1411075","height":16,"chart_height":115},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4678148","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":491,"peak_comments":38,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10022729","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":160,"peak_comments":25,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22366638","height":8,"chart_height":55},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/unix-toolbox-d9d0233ec569.jpg","path":"/hall/link/unix-toolbox-d9d0233ec569/"},{"slug":"why-use-make-d9d023489b49","title":"Why Use Make","domain":"bost.ocks.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","data_engineering","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2015-12","inductedMonth":"2023-01","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":12.901,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":358,"evidenceRank":463,"evidenceScore":72.0,"freshAt":"2023-01-11T19:03:26Z","freshnessRank":671,"freshEventScore":104,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 358 pts / 240 comments (2013) + 104 pts / 92 comments (2023), different submitters and 3,608 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":358,"peak_comments":240,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5275313","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":164,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7492418","height":8,"chart_height":78},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10669646","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10944033","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":104,"peak_comments":92,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34342901","height":5,"chart_height":49},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46678546","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-use-make-d9d023489b49.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-use-make-d9d023489b49/"},{"slug":"should-i-use-a-carousel-d9d02349f229","title":"Should I use a carousel?","domain":"shouldiuseacarousel.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["user_experience","visual_design","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2020-07","inductedMonth":"2020-07","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":11.912,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":483,"evidenceRank":464,"evidenceScore":72.0,"freshAt":"2025-06-08T01:16:28Z","freshnessRank":201,"freshEventScore":99,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 483 pts / 155 comments (2013) + 290 pts / 94 comments (2020), different submitters and 2,553 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":483,"peak_comments":155,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6018316","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8361514","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17818763","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20744657","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":290,"peak_comments":94,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23754676","height":14,"chart_height":102},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":247,"peak_comments":95,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31127385","height":12,"chart_height":87},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":99,"peak_comments":48,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44213878","height":5,"chart_height":35},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/should-i-use-a-carousel-d9d02349f229.jpg","path":"/hall/link/should-i-use-a-carousel-d9d02349f229/"},{"slug":"piet-a-programming-language-in-which-programs-look-like-abstract-d9d0233eb069","title":"Piet – A programming language in which programs look like abstract paintings","domain":"www.dangermouse.net","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"standard_specification","typeDisplay":"Standards & specifications","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2019-12","inductedMonth":"2024-04","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":15.806,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":447,"evidenceRank":465,"evidenceScore":71.9,"freshAt":"2024-04-24T07:52:58Z","freshnessRank":412,"freshEventScore":447,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 447 pts / 71 comments (2024) + 152 pts / 12 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,643 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=235975","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":32,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2430357","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6854048","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12759541","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":152,"peak_comments":12,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13503841","height":7,"chart_height":58},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":122,"peak_comments":19,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21913483","height":6,"chart_height":46},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":447,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40141777","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/piet-a-programming-language-in-which-programs-look-like-abstract-d9d0233eb069.jpg","path":"/hall/link/piet-a-programming-language-in-which-programs-look-like-abstract-d9d0233eb069/"},{"slug":"the-odin-programming-language-d9d0235deb5b","title":"The Odin Programming Language","domain":"odin-lang.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","compilers_runtimes","performance_reliability","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2024-01","inductedMonth":"2024-01","submissions":11,"submitters":10,"spanYears":6.59,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":194,"evidenceRank":466,"evidenceScore":71.9,"freshAt":"2026-01-03T23:17:29Z","freshnessRank":87,"freshEventScore":24,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 194 pts / 141 comments (2020) + 104 pts / 102 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,431 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20075638","height":4,"chart_height":16},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":194,"peak_comments":141,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22199942","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28438419","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":90,"peak_comments":42,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30394000","height":4,"chart_height":79},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36178703","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":104,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38836512","height":5,"chart_height":91},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46150932","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":24,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46482806","height":4,"chart_height":21}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-odin-programming-language-d9d0235deb5b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-odin-programming-language-d9d0235deb5b/"},{"slug":"kill-sticky-headers-2013-d9d02353371a","title":"Kill sticky headers (2013)","domain":"alisdair.mcdiarmid.org","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["browsers_web_standards","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-12","inductedMonth":"2019-12","submissions":11,"submitters":10,"spanYears":10.163,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":267,"evidenceRank":467,"evidenceScore":71.9,"freshAt":"2025-02-01T21:12:37Z","freshnessRank":254,"freshEventScore":219,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 267 pts / 116 comments (2017) + 219 pts / 88 comments (2025), different submitters and 2,776 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11441694","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":267,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14647777","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":5,"peak_score":176,"peak_comments":81,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21699871","height":8,"chart_height":112},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":22,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28131721","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":219,"peak_comments":88,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42902395","height":11,"chart_height":139},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48410145","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/kill-sticky-headers-2013-d9d02353371a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/kill-sticky-headers-2013-d9d02353371a/"},{"slug":"crontab-guru-cron-schedule-expression-editor-d9d02351e83f","title":"Crontab.guru – cron schedule expression editor","domain":"crontab.guru","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-10","inductedMonth":"2019-10","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":8.164,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":340,"evidenceRank":468,"evidenceScore":71.9,"freshAt":"2021-08-30T19:53:24Z","freshnessRank":879,"freshEventScore":288,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 330 pts / 126 comments (2016) + 340 pts / 83 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,174 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10581811","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":330,"peak_comments":126,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12105286","height":16,"chart_height":165},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17341637","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":340,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21151433","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":288,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28360139","height":14,"chart_height":144},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39009839","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/crontab-guru-cron-schedule-expression-editor-d9d02351e83f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/crontab-guru-cron-schedule-expression-editor-d9d02351e83f/"},{"slug":"railway-oriented-programming-d9d023546ed6","title":"Railway Oriented Programming","domain":"fsharpforfunandprofit.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"course_lecture","typeDisplay":"Courses & lectures","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","software_architecture","testing_quality"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2023-08","inductedMonth":"2023-08","submissions":10,"submitters":9,"spanYears":9.47,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":332,"evidenceRank":469,"evidenceScore":71.8,"freshAt":"2023-08-18T06:20:29Z","freshnessRank":565,"freshEventScore":332,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 332 pts / 166 comments (2023) + 260 pts / 160 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,886 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12313204","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":260,"peak_comments":160,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17337155","height":12,"chart_height":133},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29243070","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31404643","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":332,"peak_comments":166,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37171943","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45980173","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46913655","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/railway-oriented-programming-d9d023546ed6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/railway-oriented-programming-d9d023546ed6/"},{"slug":"most-of-what-we-read-on-the-internet-is-written-by-insane-people-d9d0235bdddd","title":"Most of What We Read on the Internet is Written by Insane People","domain":"www.reddit.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"forum_discussion","typeDisplay":"Forum discussions","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["psychology"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-01","inductedMonth":"2022-09","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":7.652,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":718,"evidenceRank":470,"evidenceScore":71.8,"freshAt":"2022-09-19T13:09:56Z","freshnessRank":717,"freshEventScore":140,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 539 pts / 328 comments (2021) + 718 pts / 309 comments (2019), different submitters and 720 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18319949","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":718,"peak_comments":309,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18881827","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23717786","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":539,"peak_comments":328,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25600274","height":24,"chart_height":128},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":140,"peak_comments":81,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32897812","height":7,"chart_height":33},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46224121","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48641932","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/most-of-what-we-read-on-the-internet-is-written-by-insane-people-d9d0235bdddd/"},{"slug":"diagram-as-code-d9d023617e02","title":"Diagram as Code","domain":"diagrams.mingrammer.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","software_architecture","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2022-06","inductedMonth":"2022-06","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":4.734,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":515,"evidenceRank":471,"evidenceScore":71.8,"freshAt":"2024-11-04T18:46:42Z","freshnessRank":302,"freshEventScore":515,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 515 pts / 131 comments (2024) + 396 pts / 74 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,637 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":396,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23154846","height":19,"chart_height":131},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27701583","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":151,"peak_comments":39,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31849787","height":7,"chart_height":50},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34257741","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":515,"peak_comments":131,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42044771","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/diagram-as-code-d9d023617e02.jpg","path":"/hall/link/diagram-as-code-d9d023617e02/"},{"slug":"fingerprints-are-usernames-not-passwords-d9d0234ab709","title":"Fingerprints are Usernames, not Passwords","domain":"blog.dustinkirkland.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security","privacy_surveillance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-03","inductedMonth":"2016-04","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":3.956,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":587,"evidenceRank":472,"evidenceScore":71.8,"freshAt":"2017-09-15T01:30:58Z","freshnessRank":1120,"freshEventScore":264,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 587 pts / 255 comments (2013) + 264 pts / 124 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,444 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":587,"peak_comments":255,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6477505","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":219,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8496797","height":11,"chart_height":63},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10146053","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":184,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11549536","height":9,"chart_height":53},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":264,"peak_comments":124,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15253884","height":13,"chart_height":76},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/fingerprints-are-usernames-not-passwords-d9d0234ab709.jpg","path":"/hall/link/fingerprints-are-usernames-not-passwords-d9d0234ab709/"},{"slug":"a-python-interpreter-written-in-rust-d9d0235cbd35","title":"A Python Interpreter Written in Rust","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","compilers_runtimes","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2021-08","inductedMonth":"2023-02","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":5.498,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":430,"evidenceRank":473,"evidenceScore":71.8,"freshAt":"2024-08-02T15:23:18Z","freshnessRank":356,"freshEventScore":196,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 430 pts / 194 comments (2019) + 229 pts / 136 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,493 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":430,"peak_comments":194,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19064069","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":128,"peak_comments":49,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28280790","height":6,"chart_height":51},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":229,"peak_comments":136,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35056586","height":11,"chart_height":91},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":196,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41139595","height":9,"chart_height":77},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-python-interpreter-written-in-rust-d9d0235cbd35.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-python-interpreter-written-in-rust-d9d0235cbd35/"},{"slug":"how-to-destroy-the-earth-2006-d9d023412a1e","title":"How to Destroy the Earth (2006)","domain":"qntm.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["physics","space_astronomy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2021-02","inductedMonth":"2021-02","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":16.014,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":293,"evidenceRank":474,"evidenceScore":71.7,"freshAt":"2021-02-20T15:40:31Z","freshnessRank":941,"freshEventScore":293,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 293 pts / 155 comments (2021) + 117 pts / 73 comments (2010), different submitters and 3,898 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":117,"peak_comments":73,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1446612","height":6,"chart_height":68},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2448216","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9117135","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":92,"peak_comments":44,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11808723","height":4,"chart_height":53},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16639590","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":293,"peak_comments":155,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26204892","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33874477","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36740733","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48670421","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-to-destroy-the-earth-2006-d9d023412a1e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-to-destroy-the-earth-2006-d9d023412a1e/"},{"slug":"gimli-glider-d9d023401cb5","title":"Gimli Glider","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"space_transportation","topicDisplay":"Space & transportation","tags":["aviation"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2016-12","inductedMonth":"2016-12","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":13.906,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":385,"evidenceRank":475,"evidenceScore":71.6,"freshAt":"2016-12-18T21:43:28Z","freshnessRank":1140,"freshEventScore":385,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 385 pts / 198 comments (2016) + 176 pts / 80 comments (2014), different submitters and 962 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":26,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=898478","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6088362","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":3,"peak_score":176,"peak_comments":80,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7682609","height":8,"chart_height":78},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":385,"peak_comments":198,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13207825","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21669233","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28032700","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31305925","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37565313","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/gimli-glider-d9d023401cb5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/gimli-glider-d9d023401cb5/"},{"slug":"mapscii-braille-and-ascii-map-renderer-for-the-console-d9d02356e00d","title":"MapSCII – Braille and ASCII map renderer for the console","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["computer_graphics","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2019-07","inductedMonth":"2024-04","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":8.386,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":389,"evidenceRank":476,"evidenceScore":71.6,"freshAt":"2025-09-18T18:12:58Z","freshnessRank":143,"freshEventScore":218,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 389 pts / 65 comments (2017) + 218 pts / 21 comments (2025), different submitters and 3,060 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":389,"peak_comments":65,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14254165","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":169,"peak_comments":24,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20375881","height":8,"chart_height":74},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":187,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27042629","height":9,"chart_height":82},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":147,"peak_comments":23,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39975887","height":7,"chart_height":64},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":218,"peak_comments":21,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45293012","height":10,"chart_height":95},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/mapscii-braille-and-ascii-map-renderer-for-the-console-d9d02356e00d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/mapscii-braille-and-ascii-map-renderer-for-the-console-d9d02356e00d/"},{"slug":"the-time-everyone-corrected-the-world-s-smartest-woman-2015-d9d02354a8fc","title":"The Time Everyone “Corrected” the World’s Smartest Woman (2015)","domain":"priceonomics.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","psychology"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-05","inductedMonth":"2021-05","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":7.45,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":211,"evidenceRank":477,"evidenceScore":71.6,"freshAt":"2024-02-25T20:19:31Z","freshnessRank":439,"freshEventScore":101,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 101 pts / 316 comments (2024) + 211 pts / 303 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,022 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12487137","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15381627","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":44,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17686279","height":4,"chart_height":35},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":211,"peak_comments":303,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27092258","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":316,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39504351","height":5,"chart_height":81},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-time-everyone-corrected-the-world-s-smartest-woman-2015-d9d02354a8fc.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-time-everyone-corrected-the-world-s-smartest-woman-2015-d9d02354a8fc/"},{"slug":"there-s-no-speed-limit-2009-d9d0234041ca","title":"There's no speed limit (2009)","domain":"sivers.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["teaching","learning_methods","music"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2012-03","inductedMonth":"2016-11","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":8.646,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":699,"evidenceRank":478,"evidenceScore":71.6,"freshAt":"2016-06-20T17:51:28Z","freshnessRank":1149,"freshEventScore":20,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 699 pts / 194 comments (2012) + 386 pts / 60 comments (2009), different submitters and 846 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":386,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=970945","height":19,"chart_height":94},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":118,"peak_comments":25,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2766060","height":6,"chart_height":29},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":699,"peak_comments":194,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3761013","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":20,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11939729","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15838906","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17609350","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/there-s-no-speed-limit-2009-d9d0234041ca.jpg","path":"/hall/link/there-s-no-speed-limit-2009-d9d0234041ca/"},{"slug":"html5-genetic-cars-d9d02349cffa","title":"HTML5 Genetic Cars","domain":"rednuht.org","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["artificial_intelligence","physics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2015-11","inductedMonth":"2019-08","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":12.474,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":664,"evidenceRank":479,"evidenceScore":71.6,"freshAt":"2024-04-27T05:46:55Z","freshnessRank":411,"freshEventScore":484,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 664 pts / 169 comments (2013) + 484 pts / 73 comments (2024), different submitters and 3,958 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":664,"peak_comments":169,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5942757","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":162,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10600486","height":8,"chart_height":41},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20758805","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":484,"peak_comments":73,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40177599","height":23,"chart_height":124},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46272267","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/html5-genetic-cars-d9d02349cffa.jpg","path":"/hall/link/html5-genetic-cars-d9d02349cffa/"},{"slug":"nyxt-the-hacker-s-browser-d9d023620f10","title":"Nyxt: The Hacker's Browser","domain":"nyxt.atlas.engineer","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","browsers_web_standards","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-05","inductedMonth":"2023-05","submissions":9,"submitters":8,"spanYears":4.444,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":648,"evidenceRank":480,"evidenceScore":71.5,"freshAt":"2024-12-08T02:54:54Z","freshnessRank":288,"freshEventScore":471,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 648 pts / 252 comments (2023) + 533 pts / 125 comments (2021), different submitters and 791 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23674302","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":533,"peak_comments":125,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26509612","height":24,"chart_height":140},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":648,"peak_comments":252,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36006423","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":471,"peak_comments":224,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42354691","height":23,"chart_height":124},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/nyxt-the-hacker-s-browser-d9d023620f10.jpg","path":"/hall/link/nyxt-the-hacker-s-browser-d9d023620f10/"},{"slug":"detecting-the-use-of-curl-bash-server-side-d9d0235355a0","title":"Detecting the use of \"curl | bash\" server-side","domain":"www.idontplaydarts.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2018-07","inductedMonth":"2020-05","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.689,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":500,"evidenceRank":481,"evidenceScore":71.5,"freshAt":"2020-12-09T09:15:09Z","freshnessRank":967,"freshEventScore":198,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 500 pts / 145 comments (2018) + 352 pts / 120 comments (2016), different submitters and 829 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":352,"peak_comments":120,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11532599","height":17,"chart_height":120},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":500,"peak_comments":145,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17636032","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":198,"peak_comments":132,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25356757","height":10,"chart_height":67},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34145799","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/detecting-the-use-of-curl-bash-server-side-d9d0235355a0/"},{"slug":"software-disenchantment-2018-d9d0236001ef","title":"Software Disenchantment (2018)","domain":"tonsky.me","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["performance_reliability","software_architecture","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2022-06","inductedMonth":"2022-06","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":5.194,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":934,"evidenceRank":482,"evidenceScore":71.5,"freshAt":"2023-10-23T13:17:23Z","freshnessRank":507,"freshEventScore":577,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 934 pts / 488 comments (2020) + 577 pts / 413 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,390 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":934,"peak_comments":488,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21929709","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27775262","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":230,"peak_comments":132,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31798580","height":11,"chart_height":42},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":577,"peak_comments":413,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37985176","height":24,"chart_height":105},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43347314","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/software-disenchantment-2018-d9d0236001ef.jpg","path":"/hall/link/software-disenchantment-2018-d9d0236001ef/"},{"slug":"teavm-build-fast-modern-web-apps-in-java-d9d02359243b","title":"TeaVM: Build Fast, Modern Web Apps in Java","domain":"teavm.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["compilers_runtimes","programming_languages","web_development","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-01","inductedMonth":"2022-02","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":8.172,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":202,"evidenceRank":483,"evidenceScore":71.5,"freshAt":"2021-01-31T11:34:28Z","freshnessRank":949,"freshEventScore":202,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 202 pts / 161 comments (2021) + 195 pts / 126 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,122 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":195,"peak_comments":126,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16075933","height":9,"chart_height":164},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21801547","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24893027","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":202,"peak_comments":161,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25978053","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32075692","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35922523","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43380418","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47305154","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/teavm-build-fast-modern-web-apps-in-java-d9d02359243b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/teavm-build-fast-modern-web-apps-in-java-d9d02359243b/"},{"slug":"the-brain-is-not-a-computer-d9d023539c5a","title":"The brain is not a computer","domain":"aeon.co","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"medicine_health","topicDisplay":"Medicine & health","tags":["neuroscience","psychology","philosophy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-03","inductedMonth":"2019-03","submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":8.077,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":131,"evidenceRank":484,"evidenceScore":71.4,"freshAt":"2024-06-13T01:43:39Z","freshnessRank":379,"freshEventScore":20,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 131 pts / 161 comments (2016) + 57 pts / 70 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,025 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":131,"peak_comments":161,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11729499","height":6,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":35,"peak_comments":24,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15518150","height":4,"chart_height":45},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":57,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19352920","height":4,"chart_height":74},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28614363","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31777455","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":20,"peak_comments":15,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40665087","height":4,"chart_height":26},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-brain-is-not-a-computer-d9d023539c5a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-brain-is-not-a-computer-d9d023539c5a/"},{"slug":"things-you-re-allowed-to-do-d9d02363e97a","title":"Things You're Allowed to Do","domain":"milan.cvitkovic.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["personal_productivity","labor_productivity","careers","management_strategy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-11","inductedMonth":"2023-11","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":4.846,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":537,"evidenceRank":485,"evidenceScore":71.4,"freshAt":"2023-11-24T01:15:23Z","freshnessRank":493,"freshEventScore":402,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 537 pts / 416 comments (2020) + 402 pts / 218 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,065 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":537,"peak_comments":416,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25513713","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":227,"peak_comments":171,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31705542","height":11,"chart_height":72},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":402,"peak_comments":218,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38399740","height":19,"chart_height":127},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43144727","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/things-you-re-allowed-to-do-d9d02363e97a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/things-you-re-allowed-to-do-d9d02363e97a/"},{"slug":"the-high-level-cpu-challenge-2008-d9d0233f9631","title":"The “high-level CPU” challenge (2008)","domain":"yosefk.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["computer_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2017-02","inductedMonth":"2025-08","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":16.211,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":172,"evidenceRank":486,"evidenceScore":71.2,"freshAt":"2025-08-12T17:07:43Z","freshnessRank":171,"freshEventScore":73,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 172 pts / 127 comments (2017) + 73 pts / 51 comments (2025), different submitters and 3,088 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=627861","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7193062","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":57,"peak_comments":58,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10358153","height":4,"chart_height":56},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":172,"peak_comments":127,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13741269","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30687279","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":73,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44879113","height":4,"chart_height":72},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-high-level-cpu-challenge-2008-d9d0233f9631.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-high-level-cpu-challenge-2008-d9d0233f9631/"},{"slug":"pulling-jpegs-out-of-thin-air-d9d0234e6eab","title":"Pulling JPEGs out of thin air","domain":"lcamtuf.blogspot.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security","testing_quality"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2017-05","inductedMonth":"2022-01","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":9.613,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":444,"evidenceRank":487,"evidenceScore":71.2,"freshAt":"2019-03-23T15:44:02Z","freshnessRank":1063,"freshEventScore":177,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 444 pts / 83 comments (2014) + 384 pts / 40 comments (2017), different submitters and 916 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":444,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8571879","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":384,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14315690","height":18,"chart_height":147},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":177,"peak_comments":14,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19470890","height":8,"chart_height":68},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30119323","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40716973","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/pulling-jpegs-out-of-thin-air-d9d0234e6eab.jpg","path":"/hall/link/pulling-jpegs-out-of-thin-air-d9d0234e6eab/"},{"slug":"codeberg-fast-open-source-alternative-to-github-d9d0235dff61","title":"Codeberg – Fast Open Source Alternative to GitHub","domain":"codeberg.org","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-04","inductedMonth":"2023-04","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":6.311,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":503,"evidenceRank":488,"evidenceScore":71.2,"freshAt":"2025-10-01T16:48:20Z","freshnessRank":138,"freshEventScore":215,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 503 pts / 211 comments (2023) + 215 pts / 87 comments (2025), different submitters and 908 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20145139","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":159,"peak_comments":90,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22795930","height":8,"chart_height":54},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29718689","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33057523","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":503,"peak_comments":211,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35480056","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":215,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45439955","height":10,"chart_height":73},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/codeberg-fast-open-source-alternative-to-github-d9d0235dff61.jpg","path":"/hall/link/codeberg-fast-open-source-alternative-to-github-d9d0235dff61/"},{"slug":"leafletjs-a-javascript-library-for-interactive-maps-d9d02349cc12","title":"LeafletJS: a JavaScript library for interactive maps","domain":"leafletjs.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2021-08","inductedMonth":"2021-08","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":12.816,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":361,"evidenceRank":489,"evidenceScore":71.2,"freshAt":"2021-08-16T21:32:53Z","freshnessRank":882,"freshEventScore":361,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 361 pts / 87 comments (2021) + 321 pts / 71 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,717 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6968256","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":321,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13095390","height":15,"chart_height":151},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":361,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28203242","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33563299","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47702576","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/leafletjs-a-javascript-library-for-interactive-maps-d9d02349cc12.jpg","path":"/hall/link/leafletjs-a-javascript-library-for-interactive-maps-d9d02349cc12/"},{"slug":"why-nerds-are-unpopular-2003-d9d023427261","title":"Why Nerds are Unpopular (2003)","domain":"www.paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["psychology","social_issues","academic_life"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2017-01","inductedMonth":"2017-01","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":10.418,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":78,"evidenceRank":490,"evidenceScore":71.2,"freshAt":"2020-10-07T17:21:05Z","freshnessRank":987,"freshEventScore":62,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 78 pts / 115 comments (2014) + 61 pts / 70 comments (2017), different submitters and 983 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":4,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":20,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2848043","height":4,"chart_height":28},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":78,"peak_comments":115,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7759892","height":4,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12699400","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":61,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13475146","height":4,"chart_height":133},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18241507","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20161420","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":62,"peak_comments":44,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24710474","height":4,"chart_height":135},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27733833","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-nerds-are-unpopular-2003-d9d023427261.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-nerds-are-unpopular-2003-d9d023427261/"},{"slug":"why-there-is-no-hitchhiker-s-guide-to-mathematics-for-programmer-d9d02348734f","title":"Why there is no Hitchhiker’s Guide to Mathematics for Programmers","domain":"jeremykun.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["learning_methods","mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-02","inductedMonth":"2017-12","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":9.092,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":213,"evidenceRank":491,"evidenceScore":71.2,"freshAt":"2016-02-18T21:14:24Z","freshnessRank":1159,"freshEventScore":145,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 145 pts / 130 comments (2016) + 213 pts / 75 comments (2013), different submitters and 1,105 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":213,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5189790","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":145,"peak_comments":130,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11129375","height":7,"chart_height":116},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16024036","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17861075","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28720819","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30672429","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-there-is-no-hitchhiker-s-guide-to-mathematics-for-programmer-d9d02348734f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-there-is-no-hitchhiker-s-guide-to-mathematics-for-programmer-d9d02348734f/"},{"slug":"brandolini-s-law-d9d02361c690","title":"Brandolini's Law","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["internet_culture","journalism_media"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-04","inductedMonth":"2023-04","submissions":17,"submitters":16,"spanYears":5.922,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":179,"evidenceRank":492,"evidenceScore":71.1,"freshAt":"2025-02-04T21:43:55Z","freshnessRank":252,"freshEventScore":27,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 179 pts / 110 comments (2023) + 132 pts / 59 comments (2021), different submitters and 804 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23417790","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":132,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25956905","height":6,"chart_height":125},{"year":2022,"count":4,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33267011","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":179,"peak_comments":110,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35567904","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42174646","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":27,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42939269","height":4,"chart_height":26},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48055039","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/brandolini-s-law-d9d02361c690.jpg","path":"/hall/link/brandolini-s-law-d9d02361c690/"},{"slug":"gtfobins-d9d0235a728b","title":"GTFOBins","domain":"gtfobins.github.io","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security","developer_tools","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-10","inductedMonth":"2021-10","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":7.647,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":324,"evidenceRank":493,"evidenceScore":71.1,"freshAt":"2023-07-07T08:41:58Z","freshnessRank":595,"freshEventScore":201,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 324 pts / 54 comments (2021) + 163 pts / 35 comments (2019), different submitters and 796 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17134341","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":163,"peak_comments":35,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20648329","height":8,"chart_height":86},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25264706","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":324,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28849101","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":201,"peak_comments":99,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36628976","height":10,"chart_height":105},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43586078","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46622843","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/gtfobins-d9d0235a728b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/gtfobins-d9d0235a728b/"},{"slug":"a-visual-proof-that-neural-nets-can-approximate-any-function-d9d0234dd2f2","title":"A visual proof that neural nets can approximate any function","domain":"neuralnetworksanddeeplearning.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["machine_learning","mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2019-04","inductedMonth":"2024-04","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":9.61,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":341,"evidenceRank":494,"evidenceScore":71.1,"freshAt":"2022-03-06T11:56:54Z","freshnessRank":811,"freshEventScore":259,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 259 pts / 189 comments (2022) + 341 pts / 128 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,050 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":217,"peak_comments":80,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8258652","height":10,"chart_height":108},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":116,"peak_comments":65,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10095364","height":6,"chart_height":58},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":341,"peak_comments":128,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19708620","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":259,"peak_comments":189,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30576943","height":12,"chart_height":129},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40014762","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-visual-proof-that-neural-nets-can-approximate-any-function-d9d0234dd2f2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-visual-proof-that-neural-nets-can-approximate-any-function-d9d0234dd2f2/"},{"slug":"a-gambler-who-cracked-the-horse-racing-code-2018-d9d0235a4402","title":"A Gambler Who Cracked the Horse-Racing Code (2018)","domain":"www.bloomberg.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["markets"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-04","inductedMonth":"2024-12","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.65,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":360,"evidenceRank":495,"evidenceScore":71.1,"freshAt":"2024-12-26T19:39:39Z","freshnessRank":278,"freshEventScore":178,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 360 pts / 225 comments (2019) + 178 pts / 103 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,941 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":223,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16985413","height":11,"chart_height":105},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":360,"peak_comments":225,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20865312","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":187,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26992070","height":9,"chart_height":88},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36509572","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":178,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42517234","height":9,"chart_height":84},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/a-gambler-who-cracked-the-horse-racing-code-2018-d9d0235a4402/"},{"slug":"to-become-a-good-c-programmer-2011-d9d02344d640","title":"To become a good C programmer (2011)","domain":"fabiensanglard.net","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2020-02","inductedMonth":"2021-08","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":14.335,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":364,"evidenceRank":496,"evidenceScore":71.0,"freshAt":"2021-08-01T16:24:22Z","freshnessRank":887,"freshEventScore":62,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 364 pts / 132 comments (2020) + 272 pts / 103 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,383 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3385707","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":272,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11606296","height":13,"chart_height":127},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20626720","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":364,"peak_comments":132,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22325088","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":62,"peak_comments":15,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28027456","height":4,"chart_height":29},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45363771","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47894790","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/to-become-a-good-c-programmer-2011-d9d02344d640.jpg","path":"/hall/link/to-become-a-good-c-programmer-2011-d9d02344d640/"},{"slug":"vigil-a-programming-language-with-eternal-moral-vigilance-d9d023481670","title":"Vigil: A programming language with eternal moral vigilance","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2017-09","inductedMonth":"2020-11","submissions":8,"submitters":6,"spanYears":10.664,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":362,"evidenceRank":497,"evidenceScore":71.0,"freshAt":"2023-09-03T00:32:38Z","freshnessRank":556,"freshEventScore":121,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 362 pts / 118 comments (2013) + 180 pts / 34 comments (2020), different submitters and 2,868 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":362,"peak_comments":118,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5002597","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9312180","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":173,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15209452","height":8,"chart_height":81},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20451115","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":180,"peak_comments":34,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25052001","height":9,"chart_height":85},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":121,"peak_comments":25,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37366678","height":6,"chart_height":57},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/vigil-a-programming-language-with-eternal-moral-vigilance-d9d023481670.jpg","path":"/hall/link/vigil-a-programming-language-with-eternal-moral-vigilance-d9d023481670/"},{"slug":"c-is-quirky-flawed-and-an-enormous-success-dennis-ritchie-d9d023522d2f","title":"“C is quirky, flawed, and an enormous success” – Dennis Ritchie","domain":"www.bell-labs.com","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"research_paper","typeDisplay":"Research papers","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["programming_languages","operating_systems","history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-03","inductedMonth":"2023-07","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":7.559,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":255,"evidenceRank":498,"evidenceScore":71.0,"freshAt":"2023-07-09T09:15:09Z","freshnessRank":593,"freshEventScore":255,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 255 pts / 325 comments (2023) + 143 pts / 10 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,583 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":57,"peak_comments":28,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10749358","height":4,"chart_height":38},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":117,"peak_comments":22,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15134903","height":6,"chart_height":78},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":143,"peak_comments":10,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19338525","height":7,"chart_height":95},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24385008","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27652857","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30261619","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":255,"peak_comments":325,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36652934","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/c-is-quirky-flawed-and-an-enormous-success-dennis-ritchie-d9d023522d2f/"},{"slug":"wordstar-a-writer-s-word-processor-1996-d9d0234dda3c","title":"WordStar: A Writer's Word Processor (1996)","domain":"sfwriter.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["retrocomputing","writing_craft","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2021-03","inductedMonth":"2024-06","submissions":10,"submitters":6,"spanYears":11.808,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":152,"evidenceRank":499,"evidenceScore":71.0,"freshAt":"2024-06-26T21:16:41Z","freshnessRank":372,"freshEventScore":142,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 152 pts / 106 comments (2017) + 142 pts / 51 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,663 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8272952","height":4,"chart_height":16},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12816234","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":152,"peak_comments":106,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13850693","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17429145","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":148,"peak_comments":92,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26370252","height":7,"chart_height":166},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34092213","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":142,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40804675","height":7,"chart_height":159},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48694853","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/wordstar-a-writer-s-word-processor-1996-d9d0234dda3c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/wordstar-a-writer-s-word-processor-1996-d9d0234dda3c/"},{"slug":"the-mit-license-line-by-line-d9d02354bf50","title":"The MIT License, Line by Line","domain":"writing.kemitchell.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["law_regulation","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-01","inductedMonth":"2019-01","submissions":9,"submitters":6,"spanYears":7.009,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":531,"evidenceRank":500,"evidenceScore":71.0,"freshAt":"2021-01-31T15:44:36Z","freshnessRank":948,"freshEventScore":371,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 531 pts / 134 comments (2016) + 371 pts / 142 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,591 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":531,"peak_comments":134,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12559169","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17846875","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":143,"peak_comments":20,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19011980","height":7,"chart_height":46},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":371,"peak_comments":142,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25979584","height":18,"chart_height":119},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34078076","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37638700","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-mit-license-line-by-line-d9d02354bf50.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-mit-license-line-by-line-d9d02354bf50/"},{"slug":"git-s-initial-commit-d9d02346e781","title":"Git's initial commit","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"source_code","typeDisplay":"Source code","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2014-11","inductedMonth":"2021-11","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":12.638,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":351,"evidenceRank":501,"evidenceScore":70.9,"freshAt":"2025-04-07T14:02:20Z","freshnessRank":227,"freshEventScore":20,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 351 pts / 121 comments (2014) + 120 pts / 67 comments (2012), different submitters and 828 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":120,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4395014","height":6,"chart_height":58},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6661497","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":351,"peak_comments":121,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8650483","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9329160","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29146572","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31130259","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35799567","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41492360","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":20,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43611631","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/git-s-initial-commit-d9d02346e781.jpg","path":"/hall/link/git-s-initial-commit-d9d02346e781/"},{"slug":"ascii-delimited-text-not-csv-or-tab-delimited-text-d9d0234c6831","title":"ASCII Delimited Text – Not CSV or TAB delimited text","domain":"ronaldduncan.wordpress.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["data_engineering","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2024-11","inductedMonth":"2024-11","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":10.628,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":695,"evidenceRank":502,"evidenceScore":70.9,"freshAt":"2024-11-10T14:42:12Z","freshnessRank":298,"freshEventScore":114,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 695 pts / 280 comments (2014) + 114 pts / 117 comments (2024), different submitters and 3,881 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":695,"peak_comments":280,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7474600","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12332539","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15229524","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17082533","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24591290","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31936662","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":114,"peak_comments":117,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42100499","height":5,"chart_height":28},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/ascii-delimited-text-not-csv-or-tab-delimited-text-d9d0234c6831.jpg","path":"/hall/link/ascii-delimited-text-not-csv-or-tab-delimited-text-d9d0234c6831/"},{"slug":"engineering-management-lessons-2014-d9d0234e1ce1","title":"Engineering management lessons (2014)","domain":"www.defmacro.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["leadership","management_strategy","workplace"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2017-05","inductedMonth":"2018-09","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":9.147,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":517,"evidenceRank":503,"evidenceScore":70.9,"freshAt":"2018-09-07T23:46:55Z","freshnessRank":1085,"freshEventScore":41,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 517 pts / 109 comments (2017) + 375 pts / 51 comments (2014), different submitters and 959 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":375,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8406507","height":18,"chart_height":123},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":35,"peak_comments":21,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9624465","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12650937","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":517,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14381264","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":41,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17938479","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22365095","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30501633","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38419211","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/engineering-management-lessons-2014-d9d0234e1ce1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/engineering-management-lessons-2014-d9d0234e1ce1/"},{"slug":"why-there-aren-t-more-googles-2008-d9d0233e7e4b","title":"Why There Aren't More Googles (2008)","domain":"paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["startups_entrepreneurship","finance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2020-11","inductedMonth":"2020-11","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":13.851,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":175,"evidenceRank":504,"evidenceScore":70.9,"freshAt":"2020-11-06T05:59:25Z","freshnessRank":976,"freshEventScore":175,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 175 pts / 160 comments (2020) + 152 pts / 154 comments (2008), different submitters and 4,588 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":152,"peak_comments":154,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=163552","height":7,"chart_height":148},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2013500","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4841328","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5372466","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15524431","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":175,"peak_comments":160,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25005305","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30397445","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-there-aren-t-more-googles-2008-d9d0233e7e4b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-there-aren-t-more-googles-2008-d9d0233e7e4b/"},{"slug":"subject-airbnb-2011-d9d02342c28d","title":"Subject: Airbnb (2011)","domain":"www.paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["startups_entrepreneurship","finance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2018-09","inductedMonth":"2018-09","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":12.457,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":614,"evidenceRank":505,"evidenceScore":70.9,"freshAt":"2018-09-17T09:32:24Z","freshnessRank":1082,"freshEventScore":161,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 614 pts / 134 comments (2011) + 161 pts / 162 comments (2018), different submitters and 2,740 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":3,"peak_score":614,"peak_comments":134,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2337093","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7615579","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":161,"peak_comments":162,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18004356","height":8,"chart_height":45},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28340899","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30323109","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37336404","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/subject-airbnb-2011-d9d02342c28d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/subject-airbnb-2011-d9d02342c28d/"},{"slug":"use-plaintext-email-d9d0235e6d5e","title":"Use plaintext email","domain":"useplaintext.email","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","online_communities","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-09","inductedMonth":"2025-06","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.93,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":337,"evidenceRank":506,"evidenceScore":70.9,"freshAt":"2025-06-28T18:10:50Z","freshnessRank":194,"freshEventScore":118,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 337 pts / 334 comments (2019) + 225 pts / 194 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,146 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":337,"peak_comments":334,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20513987","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":225,"peak_comments":194,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32810515","height":11,"chart_height":114},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":79,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39033046","height":4,"chart_height":40},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":118,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44406837","height":6,"chart_height":60},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/use-plaintext-email-d9d0235e6d5e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/use-plaintext-email-d9d0235e6d5e/"},{"slug":"little-free-library-d9d0234b8e6b","title":"Little Free Library","domain":"littlefreelibrary.org","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["books_literature","social_issues"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2026-03","inductedMonth":"2026-03","submissions":17,"submitters":6,"spanYears":12.17,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":178,"evidenceRank":507,"evidenceScore":70.9,"freshAt":"2026-03-01T22:18:10Z","freshnessRank":53,"freshEventScore":178,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 178 pts / 102 comments (2026) + 117 pts / 86 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,759 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6977678","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":84,"peak_comments":32,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8237696","height":4,"chart_height":80},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10206407","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12884068","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15550763","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18140680","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20637291","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22344049","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":117,"peak_comments":86,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27080639","height":6,"chart_height":112},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34160509","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":178,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47211280","height":9,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/little-free-library-d9d0234b8e6b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/little-free-library-d9d0234b8e6b/"},{"slug":"online-python-tutor-learn-programming-by-visualizing-code-execut-d9d023472c3d","title":"Online Python Tutor: Learn programming by visualizing code execution","domain":"pythontutor.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["teaching","programming_languages","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2016-02","inductedMonth":"2016-02","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":6.489,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":325,"evidenceRank":508,"evidenceScore":70.9,"freshAt":"2016-02-29T02:51:03Z","freshnessRank":1158,"freshEventScore":317,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 325 pts / 41 comments (2012) + 317 pts / 18 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,244 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":3,"peak_score":325,"peak_comments":41,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4601478","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5064933","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7434596","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10677871","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":317,"peak_comments":18,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11193380","height":15,"chart_height":166},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18181255","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19408271","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/online-python-tutor-learn-programming-by-visualizing-code-execut-d9d023472c3d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/online-python-tutor-learn-programming-by-visualizing-code-execut-d9d023472c3d/"},{"slug":"learn-you-a-haskell-for-great-good-d9d0233ef4de","title":"Learn You a Haskell for Great Good","domain":"learnyouahaskell.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2015-02","inductedMonth":"2017-01","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":9.843,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":322,"evidenceRank":509,"evidenceScore":70.8,"freshAt":"2018-08-21T19:04:43Z","freshnessRank":1088,"freshEventScore":322,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 322 pts / 145 comments (2018) + 189 pts / 120 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,279 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":59,"peak_comments":11,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=336085","height":4,"chart_height":31},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":61,"peak_comments":24,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=535675","height":4,"chart_height":32},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":186,"peak_comments":65,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2383490","height":9,"chart_height":98},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":189,"peak_comments":120,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9071965","height":9,"chart_height":100},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13424741","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":322,"peak_comments":145,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17812713","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/learn-you-a-haskell-for-great-good-d9d0233ef4de/"},{"slug":"how-i-cut-gta-online-loading-times-by-70-d9d0236493b8","title":"How I cut GTA Online loading times by 70%","domain":"nee.lv","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_development","performance_reliability","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2023-09","inductedMonth":"2024-01","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":5.32,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":3883,"evidenceRank":510,"evidenceScore":70.8,"freshAt":"2024-01-09T01:55:50Z","freshnessRank":463,"freshEventScore":215,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 3883 pts / 697 comments (2021) + 215 pts / 99 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,044 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3883,"peak_comments":697,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26296339","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":476,"peak_comments":213,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31681515","height":23,"chart_height":21},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38554298","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":215,"peak_comments":99,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38921237","height":10,"chart_height":9},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45826499","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48670426","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-i-cut-gta-online-loading-times-by-70-d9d0236493b8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-i-cut-gta-online-loading-times-by-70-d9d0236493b8/"},{"slug":"peter-higgs-i-wouldn-t-be-productive-enough-for-today-s-academic-d9d02354f868","title":"Peter Higgs: I wouldn't be productive enough for today's academic system (2013)","domain":"www.theguardian.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["academic_life","physics","labor_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2023-09","inductedMonth":"2023-09","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":9.607,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":378,"evidenceRank":511,"evidenceScore":70.8,"freshAt":"2023-09-16T15:46:39Z","freshnessRank":545,"freshEventScore":223,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 378 pts / 141 comments (2016) + 223 pts / 125 comments (2023), different submitters and 2,526 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":378,"peak_comments":141,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12717553","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26056080","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31563576","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":223,"peak_comments":125,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37535814","height":11,"chart_height":100},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46320826","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48276735","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/peter-higgs-i-wouldn-t-be-productive-enough-for-today-s-academic-d9d02354f868.jpg","path":"/hall/link/peter-higgs-i-wouldn-t-be-productive-enough-for-today-s-academic-d9d02354f868/"},{"slug":"many-small-queries-are-efficient-in-sqlite-d9d023627e50","title":"Many Small Queries Are Efficient in SQLite","domain":"www.sqlite.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["databases_storage","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2024-08","inductedMonth":"2024-08","submissions":9,"submitters":7,"spanYears":5.465,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":542,"evidenceRank":512,"evidenceScore":70.7,"freshAt":"2026-01-24T11:15:15Z","freshnessRank":73,"freshEventScore":189,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 542 pts / 342 comments (2021) + 189 pts / 121 comments (2026), different submitters and 1,803 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24642729","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":542,"peak_comments":342,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26151302","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":67,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29902345","height":4,"chart_height":21},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35649882","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":87,"peak_comments":80,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41383947","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":189,"peak_comments":121,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46742635","height":9,"chart_height":59}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/many-small-queries-are-efficient-in-sqlite-d9d023627e50.jpg","path":"/hall/link/many-small-queries-are-efficient-in-sqlite-d9d023627e50/"},{"slug":"php-the-right-way-d9d023468eb2","title":"PHP: The Right Way","domain":"www.phptherightway.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","web_development","application_security"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2022-02","inductedMonth":"2022-02","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":11.74,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":393,"evidenceRank":513,"evidenceScore":70.7,"freshAt":"2024-04-03T22:52:41Z","freshnessRank":423,"freshEventScore":24,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 287 pts / 332 comments (2022) + 393 pts / 219 comments (2012), different submitters and 3,499 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":393,"peak_comments":219,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4212568","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6341405","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12302149","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29348422","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":287,"peak_comments":332,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30219984","height":14,"chart_height":124},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36248061","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":24,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39924362","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/php-the-right-way-d9d023468eb2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/php-the-right-way-d9d023468eb2/"},{"slug":"markdeep-plain-text-documents-with-diagrams-equations-and-markdo-d9d023519ae8","title":"Markdeep – plain text documents with diagrams, equations, and Markdown syntax","domain":"casual-effects.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-08","inductedMonth":"2020-02","submissions":9,"submitters":7,"spanYears":8.906,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":360,"evidenceRank":514,"evidenceScore":70.7,"freshAt":"2022-07-09T07:53:28Z","freshnessRank":753,"freshEventScore":109,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 360 pts / 108 comments (2020) + 256 pts / 78 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,584 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":256,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10402121","height":12,"chart_height":121},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":174,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17686281","height":8,"chart_height":82},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":360,"peak_comments":108,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22348190","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":109,"peak_comments":14,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32032913","height":5,"chart_height":51},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41513957","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/markdeep-plain-text-documents-with-diagrams-equations-and-markdo-d9d023519ae8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/markdeep-plain-text-documents-with-diagrams-equations-and-markdo-d9d023519ae8/"},{"slug":"principal-component-analysis-explained-visually-2015-d9d0234f49d5","title":"Principal Component Analysis Explained Visually (2015)","domain":"setosa.io","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["data_science","mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2017-05","inductedMonth":"2021-05","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":9.161,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":315,"evidenceRank":515,"evidenceScore":70.7,"freshAt":"2022-10-29T18:02:52Z","freshnessRank":697,"freshEventScore":176,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 315 pts / 25 comments (2017) + 213 pts / 44 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,439 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":187,"peak_comments":22,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9040266","height":9,"chart_height":101},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":315,"peak_comments":25,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14405665","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20927453","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":213,"peak_comments":44,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27017675","height":10,"chart_height":115},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":176,"peak_comments":13,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33386475","height":8,"chart_height":95},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40002472","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/principal-component-analysis-explained-visually-2015-d9d0234f49d5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/principal-component-analysis-explained-visually-2015-d9d0234f49d5/"},{"slug":"the-mathematical-hacker-d9d02347ed97","title":"The Mathematical Hacker","domain":"www.evanmiller.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","data_science","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2015-09","inductedMonth":"2019-06","submissions":7,"submitters":5,"spanYears":10.026,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":293,"evidenceRank":516,"evidenceScore":70.6,"freshAt":"2022-12-23T17:33:11Z","freshnessRank":680,"freshEventScore":30,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 293 pts / 132 comments (2012) + 168 pts / 86 comments (2019), different submitters and 2,369 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":293,"peak_comments":132,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4915328","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":147,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6953774","height":7,"chart_height":85},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10226120","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15584481","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":168,"peak_comments":86,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20142828","height":8,"chart_height":97},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":30,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34108434","height":4,"chart_height":17},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-mathematical-hacker-d9d02347ed97.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-mathematical-hacker-d9d02347ed97/"},{"slug":"calculus-made-easy-1910-d9d0235bc7f1","title":"Calculus Made Easy (1910)","domain":"calculusmadeeasy.org","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","teaching"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-07","inductedMonth":"2023-01","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":7.329,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":417,"evidenceRank":517,"evidenceScore":70.6,"freshAt":"2021-07-28T23:40:46Z","freshnessRank":890,"freshEventScore":417,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 417 pts / 97 comments (2021) + 378 pts / 68 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,014 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":378,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18250034","height":18,"chart_height":154},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25480120","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":417,"peak_comments":97,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27991120","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":4,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38003823","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42987496","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47023129","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/calculus-made-easy-1910-d9d0235bc7f1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/calculus-made-easy-1910-d9d0235bc7f1/"},{"slug":"open-guide-to-equity-compensation-d9d023520ce3","title":"Open guide to equity compensation","domain":"github.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["finance","startups_entrepreneurship","careers"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2025-04","inductedMonth":"2025-04","submissions":9,"submitters":6,"spanYears":9.361,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":656,"evidenceRank":518,"evidenceScore":70.6,"freshAt":"2025-04-13T19:13:37Z","freshnessRank":223,"freshEventScore":656,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 656 pts / 297 comments (2025) + 482 pts / 74 comments (2016), different submitters and 3,380 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10671494","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":482,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10880726","height":23,"chart_height":125},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16023356","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20700601","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22466184","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26472117","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36418225","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39672229","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":656,"peak_comments":297,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43675126","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/open-guide-to-equity-compensation-d9d023520ce3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/open-guide-to-equity-compensation-d9d023520ce3/"},{"slug":"nobody-ever-gets-credit-for-fixing-problems-that-never-happened-d9d0234f1a13","title":"Nobody ever gets credit for fixing problems that never happened (2001) [pdf]","domain":"web.mit.edu","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"research_paper","typeDisplay":"Research papers","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["management_strategy","labor_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2024-02","inductedMonth":"2024-02","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":11.381,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1031,"evidenceRank":519,"evidenceScore":70.6,"freshAt":"2026-06-12T00:38:11Z","freshnessRank":6,"freshEventScore":791,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1031 pts / 424 comments (2024) + 791 pts / 263 comments (2026), different submitters and 840 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":201,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8940820","height":10,"chart_height":33},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14318266","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20490856","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34598544","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1031,"peak_comments":424,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39472693","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":791,"peak_comments":263,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48498385","height":24,"chart_height":130}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/nobody-ever-gets-credit-for-fixing-problems-that-never-happened-d9d0234f1a13.jpg","path":"/hall/link/nobody-ever-gets-credit-for-fixing-problems-that-never-happened-d9d0234f1a13/"},{"slug":"a-great-old-timey-game-programming-hack-d9d0234b74b2","title":"A Great Old-Timey Game-Programming Hack","domain":"blog.moertel.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["performance_reliability","retrocomputing"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2018-10","inductedMonth":"2020-12","submissions":9,"submitters":7,"spanYears":11.247,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":571,"evidenceRank":520,"evidenceScore":70.5,"freshAt":"2022-03-08T11:41:12Z","freshnessRank":808,"freshEventScore":140,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 571 pts / 143 comments (2013) + 252 pts / 22 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,761 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":571,"peak_comments":143,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6913467","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":97,"peak_comments":11,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10491768","height":5,"chart_height":29},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":252,"peak_comments":22,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18206463","height":12,"chart_height":75},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25269387","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28548983","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":140,"peak_comments":23,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30598849","height":7,"chart_height":42},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43378795","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-great-old-timey-game-programming-hack-d9d0234b74b2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-great-old-timey-game-programming-hack-d9d0234b74b2/"},{"slug":"stuff-in-space-d9d02350ae34","title":"Stuff in Space","domain":"stuffin.space","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"space_transportation","topicDisplay":"Space & transportation","tags":["space_astronomy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-04","inductedMonth":"2018-04","submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":6.442,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":629,"evidenceRank":521,"evidenceScore":70.5,"freshAt":"2018-04-05T09:13:43Z","freshnessRank":1103,"freshEventScore":223,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 629 pts / 130 comments (2015) + 223 pts / 63 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,003 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":629,"peak_comments":130,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9841831","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":6,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13949682","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":223,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16763162","height":11,"chart_height":60},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21326051","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22981818","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27108020","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/stuff-in-space-d9d02350ae34/"},{"slug":"google-has-most-of-my-email-because-it-has-all-of-yours-2014-d9d023514b6c","title":"Google has most of my email because it has all of yours (2014)","domain":"mako.cc","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["privacy_surveillance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2022-10","inductedMonth":"2022-10","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":9.648,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":453,"evidenceRank":522,"evidenceScore":70.5,"freshAt":"2025-05-06T02:09:29Z","freshnessRank":214,"freshEventScore":252,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 453 pts / 386 comments (2022) + 118 pts / 53 comments (2015), different submitters and 2,593 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":118,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10229928","height":6,"chart_height":44},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15534117","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":453,"peak_comments":386,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33304075","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42256630","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":252,"peak_comments":205,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43901204","height":12,"chart_height":95},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/google-has-most-of-my-email-because-it-has-all-of-yours-2014-d9d023514b6c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/google-has-most-of-my-email-because-it-has-all-of-yours-2014-d9d023514b6c/"},{"slug":"considered-harmful-essays-considered-harmful-d9d0233ed539","title":"“Considered Harmful” Essays Considered Harmful","domain":"meyerweb.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["browsers_web_standards"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2023-05","inductedMonth":"2023-05","submissions":10,"submitters":9,"spanYears":14.697,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":233,"evidenceRank":523,"evidenceScore":70.5,"freshAt":"2023-05-11T17:20:44Z","freshnessRank":631,"freshEventScore":109,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 109 pts / 108 comments (2023) + 233 pts / 79 comments (2015), different submitters and 2,883 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=290490","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8101926","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":233,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9744916","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13031883","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21709499","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28477720","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32420026","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":109,"peak_comments":108,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35905269","height":5,"chart_height":80},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/considered-harmful-essays-considered-harmful-d9d0233ed539.jpg","path":"/hall/link/considered-harmful-essays-considered-harmful-d9d0233ed539/"},{"slug":"css-grid-garden-d9d02356a2b8","title":"CSS grid garden","domain":"cssgridgarden.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","teaching","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2023-10","inductedMonth":"2024-06","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":7.162,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":426,"evidenceRank":524,"evidenceScore":70.5,"freshAt":"2024-06-03T03:14:15Z","freshnessRank":386,"freshEventScore":354,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 426 pts / 128 comments (2018) + 354 pts / 61 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,987 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":404,"peak_comments":131,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14041367","height":19,"chart_height":161},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":426,"peak_comments":128,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18753358","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37738632","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":354,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40559015","height":17,"chart_height":141},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/css-grid-garden-d9d02356a2b8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/css-grid-garden-d9d02356a2b8/"},{"slug":"write-like-you-talk-d9d02351b0b4","title":"Write like you talk","domain":"paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["writing_craft","language_linguistics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2022-10","inductedMonth":"2022-10","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":6.995,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":647,"evidenceRank":525,"evidenceScore":70.4,"freshAt":"2022-10-23T16:59:32Z","freshnessRank":703,"freshEventScore":122,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 647 pts / 272 comments (2015) + 122 pts / 145 comments (2022), different submitters and 2,554 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":647,"peak_comments":272,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10448445","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15447099","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17403512","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21922500","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24822613","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":122,"peak_comments":145,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33308393","height":6,"chart_height":32},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/write-like-you-talk-d9d02351b0b4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/write-like-you-talk-d9d02351b0b4/"},{"slug":"bug-647959-add-honest-achmed-s-root-certificate-d9d02343017e","title":"Bug 647959 – Add Honest Achmed's root certificate","domain":"bugzilla.mozilla.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"forum_discussion","typeDisplay":"Forum discussions","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2016-01","inductedMonth":"2020-01","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":13.752,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":200,"evidenceRank":526,"evidenceScore":70.4,"freshAt":"2025-01-18T09:31:45Z","freshnessRank":264,"freshEventScore":110,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 200 pts / 114 comments (2011) + 111 pts / 68 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,721 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":200,"peak_comments":114,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2463762","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7546972","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":111,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10839315","height":5,"chart_height":94},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":32,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15838324","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22132899","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":73,"peak_comments":25,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35490740","height":4,"chart_height":62},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":110,"peak_comments":46,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42747065","height":5,"chart_height":94},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/bug-647959-add-honest-achmed-s-root-certificate-d9d02343017e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/bug-647959-add-honest-achmed-s-root-certificate-d9d02343017e/"},{"slug":"why-don-t-schools-teach-debugging-2014-d9d0234bf773","title":"Why don't schools teach debugging? (2014)","domain":"danluu.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["testing_quality","teaching"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2017-04","inductedMonth":"2020-12","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":12.408,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":276,"evidenceRank":527,"evidenceScore":70.4,"freshAt":"2020-12-07T21:04:00Z","freshnessRank":968,"freshEventScore":64,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 276 pts / 168 comments (2017) + 154 pts / 127 comments (2014), different submitters and 1,168 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":154,"peak_comments":127,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7215870","height":7,"chart_height":95},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10631273","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11561582","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":276,"peak_comments":168,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14190069","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":64,"peak_comments":34,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25337491","height":4,"chart_height":39},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38992358","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48862465","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-don-t-schools-teach-debugging-2014-d9d0234bf773.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-don-t-schools-teach-debugging-2014-d9d0234bf773/"},{"slug":"myths-programmers-believe-about-cpu-caches-2018-d9d0235a3a02","title":"Myths Programmers Believe about CPU Caches (2018)","domain":"software.rajivprab.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["computer_architecture","performance_reliability","distributed_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2023-06","inductedMonth":"2023-06","submissions":9,"submitters":5,"spanYears":7.507,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":366,"evidenceRank":528,"evidenceScore":70.4,"freshAt":"2025-10-31T00:46:56Z","freshnessRank":122,"freshEventScore":156,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 176 pts / 138 comments (2023) + 366 pts / 119 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,301 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":87,"peak_comments":15,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17670095","height":4,"chart_height":40},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":366,"peak_comments":119,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21588893","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29654909","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31031646","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":176,"peak_comments":138,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36333034","height":8,"chart_height":82},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":156,"peak_comments":26,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45767178","height":7,"chart_height":72},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/myths-programmers-believe-about-cpu-caches-2018-d9d0235a3a02.jpg","path":"/hall/link/myths-programmers-believe-about-cpu-caches-2018-d9d0235a3a02/"},{"slug":"the-sound-of-the-dialup-pictured-2012-d9d0234d03eb","title":"The sound of the dialup, pictured (2012)","domain":"www.windytan.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","retrocomputing"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2017-11","inductedMonth":"2020-06","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":10.382,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":675,"evidenceRank":529,"evidenceScore":70.4,"freshAt":"2024-10-16T17:57:43Z","freshnessRank":313,"freshEventScore":25,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 675 pts / 103 comments (2017) + 174 pts / 35 comments (2015), different submitters and 972 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7821095","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":174,"peak_comments":35,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9171514","height":8,"chart_height":44},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":675,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15635144","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23422018","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":169,"peak_comments":44,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26626437","height":8,"chart_height":43},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":99,"peak_comments":21,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34351304","height":5,"chart_height":25},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":25,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41861838","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-sound-of-the-dialup-pictured-2012-d9d0234d03eb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-sound-of-the-dialup-pictured-2012-d9d0234d03eb/"},{"slug":"the-power-of-prolog-d9d02356a472","title":"The Power of Prolog","domain":"www.metalevel.at","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["programming_languages","theory_of_computation","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-04","inductedMonth":"2024-01","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":8.783,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":381,"evidenceRank":530,"evidenceScore":70.4,"freshAt":"2022-06-06T14:34:00Z","freshnessRank":769,"freshEventScore":279,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 348 pts / 161 comments (2017) + 381 pts / 82 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,097 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":348,"peak_comments":161,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14045987","height":17,"chart_height":155},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":36,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17702896","height":4,"chart_height":16},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":381,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22804079","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":279,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31641014","height":13,"chart_height":124},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39205821","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46646633","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-power-of-prolog-d9d02356a472.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-power-of-prolog-d9d02356a472/"},{"slug":"unfit-for-work-d9d02348e1c2","title":"Unfit for work","domain":"apps.npr.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["social_issues","labor_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2025-06","inductedMonth":"2025-06","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":12.211,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":738,"evidenceRank":531,"evidenceScore":70.4,"freshAt":"2025-06-07T14:46:13Z","freshnessRank":202,"freshEventScore":82,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 738 pts / 447 comments (2013) + 82 pts / 131 comments (2025), different submitters and 4,459 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":738,"peak_comments":447,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5424241","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11906506","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":48,"peak_comments":21,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15999322","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21286351","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28534938","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31185666","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":82,"peak_comments":131,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44209986","height":4,"chart_height":19},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/unfit-for-work-d9d02348e1c2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/unfit-for-work-d9d02348e1c2/"},{"slug":"for-40-years-this-russian-family-was-cut-off-from-all-human-cont-d9d0234c1bad","title":"For 40 Years, This Russian Family Was Cut Off from All Human Contact (2013)","domain":"www.smithsonianmag.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["history","religion"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2020-04","inductedMonth":"2020-04","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":9.875,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":226,"evidenceRank":532,"evidenceScore":70.4,"freshAt":"2024-01-11T01:43:47Z","freshnessRank":461,"freshEventScore":25,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 191 pts / 134 comments (2020) + 226 pts / 58 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,687 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":32,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7297722","height":4,"chart_height":24},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":226,"peak_comments":58,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10125523","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21482186","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":191,"peak_comments":134,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22821991","height":9,"chart_height":144},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29527261","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33461594","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":25,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38946330","height":4,"chart_height":19},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/for-40-years-this-russian-family-was-cut-off-from-all-human-cont-d9d0234c1bad.jpg","path":"/hall/link/for-40-years-this-russian-family-was-cut-off-from-all-human-cont-d9d0234c1bad/"},{"slug":"jsfuck-2012-d9d02346f48c","title":"JSFuck (2012)","domain":"www.jsfuck.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2015-05","inductedMonth":"2021-09","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":13.492,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":364,"evidenceRank":533,"evidenceScore":70.4,"freshAt":"2021-09-26T00:21:46Z","freshnessRank":868,"freshEventScore":364,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 364 pts / 156 comments (2021) + 157 pts / 71 comments (2013), different submitters and 2,934 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4421848","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":157,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6379732","height":8,"chart_height":73},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":118,"peak_comments":38,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9479834","height":6,"chart_height":55},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22929979","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":364,"peak_comments":156,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28657292","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38826530","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47076044","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/jsfuck-2012-d9d02346f48c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/jsfuck-2012-d9d02346f48c/"},{"slug":"big-companies-vs-startups-2015-d9d02352308b","title":"Big Companies vs. Startups (2015)","domain":"danluu.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["careers","workplace","startups_entrepreneurship","labor_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2024-05","inductedMonth":"2024-05","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":9.845,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":730,"evidenceRank":534,"evidenceScore":70.3,"freshAt":"2024-05-15T05:01:11Z","freshnessRank":395,"freshEventScore":49,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 730 pts / 402 comments (2015) + 49 pts / 59 comments (2024), different submitters and 3,070 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":730,"peak_comments":402,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10758278","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15710433","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16342776","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20840384","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25053120","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":49,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40363262","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45665702","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/big-companies-vs-startups-2015-d9d02352308b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/big-companies-vs-startups-2015-d9d02352308b/"},{"slug":"why-does-man-print-gimme-gimme-gimme-at-00-30-2017-d9d02358c2a4","title":"Why does man print \"gimme gimme gimme\" at 00:30? (2017)","domain":"unix.stackexchange.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"forum_discussion","typeDisplay":"Forum discussions","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","testing_quality"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-07","inductedMonth":"2021-07","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.872,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1058,"evidenceRank":535,"evidenceScore":70.3,"freshAt":"2024-10-04T01:25:51Z","freshnessRank":322,"freshEventScore":1058,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1058 pts / 409 comments (2024) + 560 pts / 159 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,508 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":560,"peak_comments":159,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15747313","height":24,"chart_height":90},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21916500","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":413,"peak_comments":211,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27994194","height":20,"chart_height":66},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1058,"peak_comments":409,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41736903","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-does-man-print-gimme-gimme-gimme-at-00-30-2017-d9d02358c2a4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-does-man-print-gimme-gimme-gimme-at-00-30-2017-d9d02358c2a4/"},{"slug":"want-to-write-a-compiler-just-read-these-two-papers-d9d0233ead95","title":"Want to Write a Compiler? Just Read These Two Papers.","domain":"prog21.dadgum.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["compilers_runtimes"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2015-12","inductedMonth":"2026-04","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":17.791,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":509,"evidenceRank":536,"evidenceScore":70.3,"freshAt":"2026-04-15T09:41:19Z","freshnessRank":28,"freshEventScore":509,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 509 pts / 159 comments (2026) + 399 pts / 77 comments (2011), different submitters and 5,346 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":51,"peak_comments":39,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=231758","height":4,"chart_height":17},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":399,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2927784","height":19,"chart_height":133},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":237,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10786842","height":11,"chart_height":79},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20076871","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":509,"peak_comments":159,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47776796","height":24,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/want-to-write-a-compiler-just-read-these-two-papers-d9d0233ead95.jpg","path":"/hall/link/want-to-write-a-compiler-just-read-these-two-papers-d9d0233ead95/"},{"slug":"the-c4-model-for-visualising-software-architecture-d9d02357ec4b","title":"The C4 model for visualising software architecture","domain":"c4model.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","visual_design","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2023-10","inductedMonth":"2023-10","submissions":14,"submitters":13,"spanYears":7.576,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":290,"evidenceRank":537,"evidenceScore":70.3,"freshAt":"2023-10-22T09:36:47Z","freshnessRank":508,"freshEventScore":290,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 290 pts / 103 comments (2023) + 187 pts / 59 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,492 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15068532","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17280952","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":187,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21032805","height":9,"chart_height":110},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27065302","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30221923","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":290,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37974021","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43411976","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-c4-model-for-visualising-software-architecture-d9d02357ec4b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-c4-model-for-visualising-software-architecture-d9d02357ec4b/"},{"slug":"database-sharding-came-from-ultima-online-2009-d9d023597b2f","title":"Database “sharding” came from Ultima Online? (2009)","domain":"www.raphkoster.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["databases_storage","distributed_systems","game_history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2023-04","inductedMonth":"2023-04","submissions":8,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.541,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":294,"evidenceRank":538,"evidenceScore":70.2,"freshAt":"2024-08-25T20:42:02Z","freshnessRank":342,"freshEventScore":294,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 168 pts / 172 comments (2020) + 294 pts / 127 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,541 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17926566","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18997385","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":168,"peak_comments":172,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23438399","height":8,"chart_height":97},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30008672","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":209,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35479553","height":10,"chart_height":121},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":294,"peak_comments":127,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41351219","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/database-sharding-came-from-ultima-online-2009-d9d023597b2f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/database-sharding-came-from-ultima-online-2009-d9d023597b2f/"},{"slug":"no-really-pi-is-wrong-the-tau-manifesto-tau-day-2010-d9d02341332d","title":"No, really, pi is wrong: The Tau Manifesto (Tau Day, 2010)","domain":"tauday.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2018-03","inductedMonth":"2020-06","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":14.001,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":367,"evidenceRank":539,"evidenceScore":70.2,"freshAt":"2016-06-28T09:58:40Z","freshnessRank":1148,"freshEventScore":142,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 367 pts / 147 comments (2010) + 142 pts / 120 comments (2016), different submitters and 2,191 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":367,"peak_comments":147,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1468341","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":142,"peak_comments":120,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11992553","height":7,"chart_height":66},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16586453","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20300939","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23667490","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39714896","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/no-really-pi-is-wrong-the-tau-manifesto-tau-day-2010-d9d02341332d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/no-really-pi-is-wrong-the-tau-manifesto-tau-day-2010-d9d02341332d/"},{"slug":"jodd-the-unbearable-lightness-of-java-d9d0233fd531","title":"Jodd – The Unbearable Lightness of Java","domain":"jodd.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2022-01","inductedMonth":"2022-01","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":12.438,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":219,"evidenceRank":540,"evidenceScore":70.2,"freshAt":"2022-01-17T20:11:30Z","freshnessRank":835,"freshEventScore":177,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 177 pts / 232 comments (2022) + 219 pts / 108 comments (2015), different submitters and 2,488 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=753170","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8304779","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":219,"peak_comments":108,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9278704","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16520586","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":24,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20063945","height":4,"chart_height":19},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":177,"peak_comments":232,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29971182","height":8,"chart_height":137},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/jodd-the-unbearable-lightness-of-java-d9d0233fd531.jpg","path":"/hall/link/jodd-the-unbearable-lightness-of-java-d9d0233fd531/"},{"slug":"why-i-quit-google-to-work-for-myself-d9d02359a730","title":"Why I Quit Google to Work for Myself","domain":"mtlynch.io","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["careers","workplace","leadership"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2022-05","inductedMonth":"2024-11","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.694,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1767,"evidenceRank":541,"evidenceScore":70.2,"freshAt":"2024-11-08T20:59:47Z","freshnessRank":300,"freshEventScore":381,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1767 pts / 751 comments (2018) + 381 pts / 231 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,445 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1767,"peak_comments":751,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16483241","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":200,"peak_comments":168,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21882791","height":10,"chart_height":19},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31380508","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":381,"peak_comments":231,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42090430","height":18,"chart_height":37},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-i-quit-google-to-work-for-myself-d9d02359a730.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-i-quit-google-to-work-for-myself-d9d02359a730/"},{"slug":"gpu-js-gpu-accelerated-javascript-d9d02352daac","title":"Gpu.js – GPU Accelerated JavaScript","domain":"gpu.rocks","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","performance_reliability","computer_graphics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-02","inductedMonth":"2021-10","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":5.607,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":321,"evidenceRank":542,"evidenceScore":70.2,"freshAt":"2021-10-08T09:09:57Z","freshnessRank":865,"freshEventScore":290,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 231 pts / 113 comments (2019) + 290 pts / 45 comments (2021), different submitters and 953 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11194687","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":321,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14773964","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":231,"peak_comments":113,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19264154","height":11,"chart_height":122},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24028992","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":290,"peak_comments":45,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28797182","height":14,"chart_height":154},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/gpu-js-gpu-accelerated-javascript-d9d02352daac.jpg","path":"/hall/link/gpu-js-gpu-accelerated-javascript-d9d02352daac/"},{"slug":"mathjax-beautiful-and-accessible-math-in-all-browsers-d9d02340be42","title":"MathJax – Beautiful and accessible math in all browsers","domain":"www.mathjax.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","browsers_web_standards","mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2023-10","inductedMonth":"2023-10","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":13.555,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":318,"evidenceRank":543,"evidenceScore":70.2,"freshAt":"2023-10-13T06:08:50Z","freshnessRank":522,"freshEventScore":228,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 318 pts / 36 comments (2010) + 228 pts / 77 comments (2023), different submitters and 4,693 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":5,"peak_score":318,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1974646","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4888670","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9573799","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11694572","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22319756","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":228,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37867272","height":11,"chart_height":122},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/mathjax-beautiful-and-accessible-math-in-all-browsers-d9d02340be42.jpg","path":"/hall/link/mathjax-beautiful-and-accessible-math-in-all-browsers-d9d02340be42/"},{"slug":"start-all-of-your-commands-with-a-comma-d9d0235f2a89","title":"Start all of your commands with a comma","domain":"rhodesmill.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2024-06","inductedMonth":"2026-02","submissions":6,"submitters":3,"spanYears":6.33,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":655,"evidenceRank":544,"evidenceScore":70.2,"freshAt":"2026-02-04T19:59:12Z","freshnessRank":66,"freshEventScore":655,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 655 pts / 244 comments (2026) + 592 pts / 121 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,322 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21180006","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":253,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22778988","height":12,"chart_height":66},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28954434","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":592,"peak_comments":121,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31846902","height":24,"chart_height":154},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":411,"peak_comments":165,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40769362","height":20,"chart_height":107},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":655,"peak_comments":244,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46890814","height":24,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/start-all-of-your-commands-with-a-comma-d9d0235f2a89.jpg","path":"/hall/link/start-all-of-your-commands-with-a-comma-d9d0235f2a89/"},{"slug":"beginner-s-guide-to-longevity-research-d9d023591c30","title":"Beginner's guide to longevity research","domain":"www.ldeming.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"medicine_health","topicDisplay":"Medicine & health","tags":["biology","medicine","teaching","scientific_method"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2020-08","inductedMonth":"2020-08","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":4.156,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":361,"evidenceRank":545,"evidenceScore":70.2,"freshAt":"2022-02-27T09:20:42Z","freshnessRank":819,"freshEventScore":265,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 261 pts / 142 comments (2020) + 361 pts / 84 comments (2018), different submitters and 964 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":4,"peak_score":361,"peak_comments":84,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16098176","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20986082","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":261,"peak_comments":142,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24320846","height":13,"chart_height":123},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":265,"peak_comments":137,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30486656","height":13,"chart_height":125},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/beginner-s-guide-to-longevity-research-d9d023591c30.jpg","path":"/hall/link/beginner-s-guide-to-longevity-research-d9d023591c30/"},{"slug":"the-talk-d9d02355adfc","title":"The “Talk”","domain":"www.smbc-comics.com","category":"media","categoryDisplay":"Audio, video & images","type":"image_comic","typeDisplay":"Images & comics","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["theory_of_computation","physics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2023-02","inductedMonth":"2023-02","submissions":15,"submitters":9,"spanYears":9.27,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":877,"evidenceRank":546,"evidenceScore":70.2,"freshAt":"2023-02-02T09:30:28Z","freshnessRank":657,"freshEventScore":106,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 877 pts / 112 comments (2019) + 106 pts / 6 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,192 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13283215","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14707361","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17725123","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":877,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21379174","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27212727","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31860198","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":106,"peak_comments":6,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34624224","height":5,"chart_height":21},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47690869","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-talk-d9d02355adfc.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-talk-d9d02355adfc/"},{"slug":"jellyfin-the-free-software-media-system-d9d0236011b5","title":"Jellyfin: The Free Software Media System","domain":"jellyfin.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["open_source","developer_tools","internet_infrastructure"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-01","inductedMonth":"2025-02","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.109,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":492,"evidenceRank":547,"evidenceScore":70.1,"freshAt":"2025-02-15T22:39:19Z","freshnessRank":249,"freshEventScore":492,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 492 pts / 284 comments (2025) + 317 pts / 196 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,238 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":318,"peak_comments":173,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21986282","height":15,"chart_height":110},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":317,"peak_comments":196,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28664802","height":15,"chart_height":110},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37629112","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40331941","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":492,"peak_comments":284,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43063167","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/jellyfin-the-free-software-media-system-d9d0236011b5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/jellyfin-the-free-software-media-system-d9d0236011b5/"},{"slug":"what-every-coder-should-know-about-gamma-d9d02354bf1a","title":"What every coder should know about gamma","domain":"blog.johnnovak.net","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["computer_graphics","visual_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-07","inductedMonth":"2022-11","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":9.725,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":560,"evidenceRank":548,"evidenceScore":70.1,"freshAt":"2026-06-13T22:01:29Z","freshnessRank":5,"freshEventScore":126,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 560 pts / 183 comments (2016) + 154 pts / 50 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,745 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":560,"peak_comments":183,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12552094","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16487345","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21169860","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":154,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27721094","height":7,"chart_height":47},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33808661","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44022753","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":126,"peak_comments":46,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48521925","height":6,"chart_height":38}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-every-coder-should-know-about-gamma-d9d02354bf1a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-every-coder-should-know-about-gamma-d9d02354bf1a/"},{"slug":"in-poor-neighborhoods-mcdonald-s-have-become-de-facto-community-d9d02353d211","title":"In poor neighborhoods, McDonald’s have become de-facto community centers","domain":"www.theguardian.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["social_issues","cities_infrastructure","economics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-12","inductedMonth":"2019-12","submissions":14,"submitters":6,"spanYears":7.233,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":314,"evidenceRank":549,"evidenceScore":70.1,"freshAt":"2019-12-28T11:06:01Z","freshnessRank":1029,"freshEventScore":147,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 314 pts / 428 comments (2016) + 147 pts / 144 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,294 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":4,"peak_score":314,"peak_comments":428,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11886795","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15186272","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16319280","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":147,"peak_comments":144,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21898324","height":7,"chart_height":80},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26991245","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32396666","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37370225","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/in-poor-neighborhoods-mcdonald-s-have-become-de-facto-community-d9d02353d211.jpg","path":"/hall/link/in-poor-neighborhoods-mcdonald-s-have-become-de-facto-community-d9d02353d211/"},{"slug":"caniemail-com-like-caniuse-but-for-email-content-d9d0235ee4ab","title":"Caniemail.com – like caniuse but for email content","domain":"www.caniemail.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","browsers_web_standards","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-04","inductedMonth":"2024-05","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":4.654,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":755,"evidenceRank":550,"evidenceScore":70.1,"freshAt":"2024-05-06T23:03:34Z","freshnessRank":406,"freshEventScore":755,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 682 pts / 273 comments (2021) + 755 pts / 250 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,091 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":666,"peak_comments":196,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20948826","height":24,"chart_height":150},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":682,"peak_comments":273,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27112960","height":24,"chart_height":154},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35697979","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":755,"peak_comments":250,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40280490","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/caniemail-com-like-caniuse-but-for-email-content-d9d0235ee4ab.jpg","path":"/hall/link/caniemail-com-like-caniuse-but-for-email-content-d9d0235ee4ab/"},{"slug":"godot-engine-free-and-open-source-2d-and-3d-game-engine-d9d02354c434","title":"Godot Engine – Free and open-source 2D and 3D game engine","domain":"godotengine.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_development","computer_graphics","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2022-03","inductedMonth":"2022-03","submissions":12,"submitters":11,"spanYears":8.89,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":593,"evidenceRank":551,"evidenceScore":70.1,"freshAt":"2023-09-13T17:27:12Z","freshnessRank":547,"freshEventScore":50,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 593 pts / 131 comments (2017) + 231 pts / 52 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,629 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12566875","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":5,"peak_score":593,"peak_comments":131,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15309989","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18752076","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22419719","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25805409","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":231,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30622830","height":11,"chart_height":66},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":50,"peak_comments":12,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37499210","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44905875","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/godot-engine-free-and-open-source-2d-and-3d-game-engine-d9d02354c434.jpg","path":"/hall/link/godot-engine-free-and-open-source-2d-and-3d-game-engine-d9d02354c434/"},{"slug":"network-protocols-for-anyone-who-knows-a-programming-language-d9d02357317e","title":"Network protocols for anyone who knows a programming language","domain":"www.destroyallsoftware.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","internet_infrastructure","teaching"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2023-08","inductedMonth":"2023-08","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":7.537,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":635,"evidenceRank":552,"evidenceScore":70.1,"freshAt":"2024-12-16T20:01:21Z","freshnessRank":283,"freshEventScore":146,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 635 pts / 71 comments (2019) + 284 pts / 39 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,654 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14474828","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17939110","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":635,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18967387","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29345084","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32830324","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":284,"peak_comments":39,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36984171","height":14,"chart_height":76},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":146,"peak_comments":9,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42434769","height":7,"chart_height":39},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/network-protocols-for-anyone-who-knows-a-programming-language-d9d02357317e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/network-protocols-for-anyone-who-knows-a-programming-language-d9d02357317e/"},{"slug":"the-zig-programming-language-d9d023548544","title":"The Zig Programming Language","domain":"ziglang.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","compilers_runtimes","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-05","inductedMonth":"2019-05","submissions":13,"submitters":12,"spanYears":8.591,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":237,"evidenceRank":553,"evidenceScore":70.1,"freshAt":"2022-05-12T18:02:25Z","freshnessRank":781,"freshEventScore":99,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 237 pts / 218 comments (2016) + 142 pts / 59 comments (2019), different submitters and 976 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":237,"peak_comments":218,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12378922","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15200811","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17220294","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":142,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19811183","height":7,"chart_height":102},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":99,"peak_comments":22,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31357778","height":5,"chart_height":71},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40115888","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43268090","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-zig-programming-language-d9d023548544.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-zig-programming-language-d9d023548544/"},{"slug":"di-taxis-a-systematic-approach-to-technical-documentation-author-d9d02364f194","title":"Diátaxis – A systematic approach to technical documentation authoring","domain":"diataxis.fr","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","writing_craft","teaching"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2024-03","inductedMonth":"2024-12","submissions":14,"submitters":14,"spanYears":5.153,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":514,"evidenceRank":554,"evidenceScore":70.1,"freshAt":"2024-12-05T04:35:36Z","freshnessRank":290,"freshEventScore":514,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 514 pts / 113 comments (2024) + 186 pts / 7 comments (2022), different submitters and 742 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":140,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26824743","height":7,"chart_height":46},{"year":2022,"count":7,"peak_score":186,"peak_comments":7,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33721314","height":9,"chart_height":62},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":514,"peak_comments":113,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42325011","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48250179","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/di-taxis-a-systematic-approach-to-technical-documentation-author-d9d02364f194.jpg","path":"/hall/link/di-taxis-a-systematic-approach-to-technical-documentation-author-d9d02364f194/"},{"slug":"fossil-versus-git-d9d02365c7b6","title":"Fossil versus Git","domain":"www.fossil-scm.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source","software_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2023-09","inductedMonth":"2023-09","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":4.523,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":97,"evidenceRank":555,"evidenceScore":69.9,"freshAt":"2026-01-12T10:10:05Z","freshnessRank":80,"freshEventScore":95,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 97 pts / 187 comments (2023) + 75 pts / 127 comments (2021), different submitters and 809 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":75,"peak_comments":127,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27736980","height":4,"chart_height":131},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":56,"peak_comments":73,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31696940","height":4,"chart_height":98},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":97,"peak_comments":187,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37622064","height":5,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":95,"peak_comments":94,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46586385","height":5,"chart_height":166}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/fossil-versus-git-d9d02365c7b6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/fossil-versus-git-d9d02365c7b6/"},{"slug":"how-to-run-a-small-social-network-site-for-your-friends-d9d0235e45aa","title":"How to run a small social network site for your friends","domain":"runyourown.social","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["online_communities","internet_infrastructure","technology_ethics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2021-12","inductedMonth":"2023-12","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":6.648,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":359,"evidenceRank":556,"evidenceScore":69.9,"freshAt":"2023-12-31T17:08:13Z","freshnessRank":472,"freshEventScore":114,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 359 pts / 209 comments (2021) + 252 pts / 60 comments (2019), different submitters and 882 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":252,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20384970","height":12,"chart_height":119},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":5,"peak_score":359,"peak_comments":209,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29470565","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":114,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38825520","height":5,"chart_height":54},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47208978","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-to-run-a-small-social-network-site-for-your-friends-d9d0235e45aa.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-to-run-a-small-social-network-site-for-your-friends-d9d0235e45aa/"},{"slug":"the-distribution-of-users-computer-skills-worse-than-you-think-d9d023553ee3","title":"The Distribution of Users’ Computer Skills: Worse Than You Think","domain":"www.nngroup.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["user_experience","human_computer_interaction","data_science"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-09","inductedMonth":"2019-09","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":6.639,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":512,"evidenceRank":557,"evidenceScore":69.9,"freshAt":"2023-07-06T18:29:29Z","freshnessRank":596,"freshEventScore":47,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 512 pts / 325 comments (2016) + 275 pts / 271 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,019 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":5,"peak_score":512,"peak_comments":325,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13111768","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17569388","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":275,"peak_comments":271,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21037674","height":13,"chart_height":91},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":47,"peak_comments":58,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36620608","height":4,"chart_height":16},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-distribution-of-users-computer-skills-worse-than-you-think-d9d023553ee3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-distribution-of-users-computer-skills-worse-than-you-think-d9d023553ee3/"},{"slug":"the-biggest-and-weirdest-commits-in-linux-kernel-git-history-d9d023562108","title":"The Biggest and Weirdest Commits in Linux Kernel Git History","domain":"www.destroyallsoftware.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-12","inductedMonth":"2026-05","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":9.41,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":394,"evidenceRank":558,"evidenceScore":69.9,"freshAt":"2020-12-25T12:57:01Z","freshnessRank":961,"freshEventScore":147,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 394 pts / 51 comments (2017) + 147 pts / 19 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,409 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":394,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13647927","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":326,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17265151","height":16,"chart_height":141},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":147,"peak_comments":19,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25536197","height":7,"chart_height":63},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39007631","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48906083","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-biggest-and-weirdest-commits-in-linux-kernel-git-history-d9d023562108.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-biggest-and-weirdest-commits-in-linux-kernel-git-history-d9d023562108/"},{"slug":"laws-of-tech-economics-commoditize-your-complement-d9d02359e479","title":"Laws of Tech Economics: Commoditize Your Complement","domain":"www.gwern.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["economics","management_strategy","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2020-12","inductedMonth":"2020-12","submissions":14,"submitters":12,"spanYears":4.649,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":403,"evidenceRank":559,"evidenceScore":69.8,"freshAt":"2021-01-03T10:56:25Z","freshnessRank":956,"freshEventScore":22,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 403 pts / 148 comments (2018) + 128 pts / 80 comments (2020), different submitters and 952 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":6,"peak_score":403,"peak_comments":148,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17047348","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":156,"peak_comments":35,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18854854","height":7,"chart_height":66},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":128,"peak_comments":80,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25476266","height":6,"chart_height":54},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":22,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25621027","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33646927","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/laws-of-tech-economics-commoditize-your-complement-d9d02359e479.jpg","path":"/hall/link/laws-of-tech-economics-commoditize-your-complement-d9d02359e479/"},{"slug":"mpv-a-free-open-source-and-cross-platform-media-player-d9d0234b2bd6","title":"Mpv – A free, open-source, and cross-platform media player","domain":"mpv.io","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2024-08","inductedMonth":"2024-08","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":10.752,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1113,"evidenceRank":560,"evidenceScore":69.8,"freshAt":"2024-08-17T18:56:36Z","freshnessRank":347,"freshEventScore":1113,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1113 pts / 559 comments (2024) + 474 pts / 176 comments (2022), different submitters and 761 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6744664","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7990761","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9448417","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19738348","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22803860","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":474,"peak_comments":176,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32137275","height":23,"chart_height":72},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1113,"peak_comments":559,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41277014","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/mpv-a-free-open-source-and-cross-platform-media-player-d9d0234b2bd6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/mpv-a-free-open-source-and-cross-platform-media-player-d9d0234b2bd6/"},{"slug":"show-hn-git-bug-distributed-bug-tracker-embedded-in-git-d9d0235b3839","title":"Show HN: git-bug – Distributed bug tracker embedded in git","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source","distributed_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2020-11","inductedMonth":"2022-11","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":5.895,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":447,"evidenceRank":561,"evidenceScore":69.8,"freshAt":"2022-11-24T12:11:48Z","freshnessRank":682,"freshEventScore":366,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 447 pts / 94 comments (2018) + 366 pts / 77 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,560 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":447,"peak_comments":94,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17782121","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":153,"peak_comments":55,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22831604","height":7,"chart_height":58},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29049613","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":366,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33730417","height":18,"chart_height":139},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40912537","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/show-hn-git-bug-distributed-bug-tracker-embedded-in-git-d9d0235b3839.jpg","path":"/hall/link/show-hn-git-bug-distributed-bug-tracker-embedded-in-git-d9d0235b3839/"},{"slug":"functional-programming-jargon-in-plain-english-d9d02354347a","title":"Functional programming jargon in plain English","domain":"github.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","open_source","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-02","inductedMonth":"2022-07","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.938,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":557,"evidenceRank":562,"evidenceScore":69.8,"freshAt":"2022-07-01T10:00:16Z","freshnessRank":757,"freshEventScore":557,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 557 pts / 184 comments (2022) + 359 pts / 99 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,697 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":339,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12153510","height":16,"chart_height":103},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":359,"peak_comments":99,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15641701","height":17,"chart_height":110},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19251107","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":557,"peak_comments":184,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31944352","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/functional-programming-jargon-in-plain-english-d9d02354347a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/functional-programming-jargon-in-plain-english-d9d02354347a/"},{"slug":"collapse-os-d9d0235f2b5e","title":"Collapse OS","domain":"collapseos.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","retrocomputing","embedded_iot","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-05","inductedMonth":"2026-07","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.776,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":753,"evidenceRank":563,"evidenceScore":69.7,"freshAt":"2025-03-26T14:34:32Z","freshnessRank":234,"freshEventScore":226,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 753 pts / 303 comments (2019) + 226 pts / 199 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,996 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":753,"peak_comments":303,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21182628","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":213,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25910108","height":10,"chart_height":48},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":46,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31340518","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":226,"peak_comments":199,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43482705","height":11,"chart_height":51},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48951831","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/collapse-os-d9d0235f2b5e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/collapse-os-d9d0235f2b5e/"},{"slug":"age-a-simple-modern-and-secure-file-encryption-tool-d9d0235f29cc","title":"Age: A simple, modern and secure file encryption tool","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography","developer_tools","open_source","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-09","inductedMonth":"2022-09","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":4.827,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":466,"evidenceRank":564,"evidenceScore":69.7,"freshAt":"2024-08-04T22:42:39Z","freshnessRank":353,"freshEventScore":289,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 466 pts / 197 comments (2019) + 289 pts / 121 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,681 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":466,"peak_comments":197,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21895671","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26760724","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":126,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32980141","height":6,"chart_height":46},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":289,"peak_comments":121,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41156793","height":14,"chart_height":105},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/age-a-simple-modern-and-secure-file-encryption-tool-d9d0235f29cc.jpg","path":"/hall/link/age-a-simple-modern-and-secure-file-encryption-tool-d9d0235f29cc/"},{"slug":"bsd-vs-linux-2005-d9d0234200c1","title":"BSD vs. Linux (2005)","domain":"www.over-yonder.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2016-07","inductedMonth":"2018-08","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":9.878,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":457,"evidenceRank":565,"evidenceScore":69.7,"freshAt":"2018-11-30T21:58:29Z","freshnessRank":1074,"freshEventScore":66,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 457 pts / 356 comments (2016) + 66 pts / 62 comments (2018), different submitters and 878 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":100,"peak_comments":39,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1942778","height":5,"chart_height":37},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":94,"peak_comments":44,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4374865","height":5,"chart_height":35},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":457,"peak_comments":356,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12034277","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":66,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18573083","height":4,"chart_height":25},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23599343","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/bsd-vs-linux-2005-d9d0234200c1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/bsd-vs-linux-2005-d9d0234200c1/"},{"slug":"using-gnu-stow-to-manage-your-dotfiles-2012-d9d0234a76fc","title":"Using GNU Stow to manage your dotfiles (2012)","domain":"brandon.invergo.net","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2020-12","inductedMonth":"2020-12","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":10.363,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":203,"evidenceRank":566,"evidenceScore":69.7,"freshAt":"2022-07-27T16:59:06Z","freshnessRank":743,"freshEventScore":71,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 203 pts / 113 comments (2020) + 149 pts / 69 comments (2013), different submitters and 2,670 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":149,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6331485","height":7,"chart_height":125},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11498098","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":84,"peak_comments":24,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15196141","height":4,"chart_height":70},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":203,"peak_comments":113,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25549462","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":71,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32253018","height":4,"chart_height":59},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39008294","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/using-gnu-stow-to-manage-your-dotfiles-2012-d9d0234a76fc.jpg","path":"/hall/link/using-gnu-stow-to-manage-your-dotfiles-2012-d9d0234a76fc/"},{"slug":"the-fallacy-of-premature-optimization-2009-d9d0234c87c8","title":"The Fallacy of Premature Optimization (2009)","domain":"ubiquity.acm.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2019-12","inductedMonth":"2019-12","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":12.082,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":137,"evidenceRank":567,"evidenceScore":69.7,"freshAt":"2022-10-28T07:19:56Z","freshnessRank":699,"freshEventScore":54,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 93 pts / 103 comments (2019) + 54 pts / 72 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,032 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8394552","height":4,"chart_height":16},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10954554","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":137,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13505721","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":93,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21912667","height":4,"chart_height":115},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":54,"peak_comments":72,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33368570","height":4,"chart_height":67},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48052130","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/the-fallacy-of-premature-optimization-2009-d9d0234c87c8/"},{"slug":"youtube-videos-that-have-almost-zero-previous-views-d9d02355d725","title":"YouTube videos that have almost zero previous views","domain":"astronaut.io","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["internet_culture","film_television"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-05","inductedMonth":"2023-08","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":9.153,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1362,"evidenceRank":568,"evidenceScore":69.7,"freshAt":"2019-07-14T10:48:07Z","freshnessRank":1056,"freshEventScore":1362,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1362 pts / 232 comments (2019) + 429 pts / 136 comments (2017), different submitters and 908 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":429,"peak_comments":136,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13413225","height":21,"chart_height":54},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1362,"peak_comments":232,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20432772","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23232198","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26457410","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37211020","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40624436","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47362553","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/youtube-videos-that-have-almost-zero-previous-views-d9d02355d725.jpg","path":"/hall/link/youtube-videos-that-have-almost-zero-previous-views-d9d02355d725/"},{"slug":"britney-spears-guide-to-semiconductor-physics-2007-d9d0234aaa08","title":"Britney Spears' Guide to Semiconductor Physics (2007)","domain":"britneyspears.ac","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["electronics","physics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2025-11","inductedMonth":"2025-11","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":12.14,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":286,"evidenceRank":569,"evidenceScore":69.6,"freshAt":"2025-11-16T23:15:20Z","freshnessRank":115,"freshEventScore":286,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 168 pts / 112 comments (2021) + 286 pts / 87 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,777 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6448754","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":94,"peak_comments":31,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10872658","height":5,"chart_height":56},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25052040","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":168,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25626532","height":8,"chart_height":100},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33787259","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":37,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35763307","height":4,"chart_height":22},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":286,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45949326","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/britney-spears-guide-to-semiconductor-physics-2007-d9d0234aaa08.jpg","path":"/hall/link/britney-spears-guide-to-semiconductor-physics-2007-d9d0234aaa08/"},{"slug":"java-for-everything-2014-d9d0234ea26f","title":"Java for Everything (2014)","domain":"www.teamten.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","software_architecture","testing_quality"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2019-06","inductedMonth":"2023-07","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":8.802,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":387,"evidenceRank":570,"evidenceScore":69.6,"freshAt":"2021-04-25T17:01:56Z","freshnessRank":920,"freshEventScore":172,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 387 pts / 338 comments (2014) + 172 pts / 246 comments (2021), different submitters and 2,337 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":387,"peak_comments":338,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8677556","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":89,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11386306","height":4,"chart_height":39},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20165081","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":172,"peak_comments":246,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26934297","height":8,"chart_height":76},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37569033","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/java-for-everything-2014-d9d0234ea26f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/java-for-everything-2014-d9d0234ea26f/"},{"slug":"don-t-copy-paste-from-website-to-terminal-d9d02349088d","title":"Don't Copy-Paste from Website to Terminal","domain":"thejh.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2015-11","inductedMonth":"2019-10","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":8.92,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":689,"evidenceRank":571,"evidenceScore":69.6,"freshAt":"2015-11-12T17:43:19Z","freshnessRank":1163,"freshEventScore":665,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 689 pts / 258 comments (2013) + 665 pts / 244 comments (2015), different submitters and 948 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":689,"peak_comments":258,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5508225","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8427858","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":665,"peak_comments":244,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10554679","height":24,"chart_height":164},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18417547","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21204190","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22900793","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30613972","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/don-t-copy-paste-from-website-to-terminal-d9d02349088d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/don-t-copy-paste-from-website-to-terminal-d9d02349088d/"},{"slug":"learn-makefiles-d9d0234ed476","title":"Learn Makefiles","domain":"makefiletutorial.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2023-05","inductedMonth":"2025-06","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":10.494,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":266,"evidenceRank":572,"evidenceScore":69.5,"freshAt":"2025-06-20T08:05:55Z","freshnessRank":196,"freshEventScore":266,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 266 pts / 125 comments (2025) + 170 pts / 95 comments (2023), different submitters and 767 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8783299","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":143,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9979865","height":7,"chart_height":91},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":31,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30413366","height":4,"chart_height":20},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":170,"peak_comments":95,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35936665","height":8,"chart_height":109},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":266,"peak_comments":125,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44325611","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/learn-makefiles-d9d0234ed476.jpg","path":"/hall/link/learn-makefiles-d9d0234ed476/"},{"slug":"the-internals-of-postgresql-d9d0235431cb","title":"The internals of PostgreSQL","domain":"www.interdb.jp","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["databases_storage","performance_reliability","distributed_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-01","inductedMonth":"2019-01","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":8.613,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":477,"evidenceRank":573,"evidenceScore":69.5,"freshAt":"2025-03-03T13:14:22Z","freshnessRank":244,"freshEventScore":194,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 477 pts / 53 comments (2017) + 464 pts / 25 comments (2019), different submitters and 723 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12142364","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":477,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13488315","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17006096","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":464,"peak_comments":25,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18950460","height":22,"chart_height":165},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":194,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43241404","height":9,"chart_height":69},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-internals-of-postgresql-d9d0235431cb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-internals-of-postgresql-d9d0235431cb/"},{"slug":"helix-a-post-modern-modal-text-editor-d9d0236577c1","title":"Helix: a post-modern modal text editor","domain":"helix-editor.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2024-03","inductedMonth":"2026-03","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.761,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":657,"evidenceRank":574,"evidenceScore":69.5,"freshAt":"2026-03-06T23:53:29Z","freshnessRank":50,"freshEventScore":342,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 657 pts / 365 comments (2021) + 342 pts / 187 comments (2026), different submitters and 1,739 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":657,"peak_comments":365,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27358479","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":363,"peak_comments":166,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33494840","height":17,"chart_height":94},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":44,"peak_comments":15,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40487068","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":342,"peak_comments":187,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47282701","height":16,"chart_height":88}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/helix-a-post-modern-modal-text-editor-d9d0236577c1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/helix-a-post-modern-modal-text-editor-d9d0236577c1/"},{"slug":"obs-studio-open-source-software-for-video-recording-and-live-str-d9d02352c032","title":"OBS Studio: Open-source software for video recording and live streaming","domain":"obsproject.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["open_source","developer_tools","film_television"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2022-06","inductedMonth":"2022-06","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":8.832,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1518,"evidenceRank":575,"evidenceScore":69.5,"freshAt":"2022-06-21T22:55:16Z","freshnessRank":763,"freshEventScore":669,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1518 pts / 362 comments (2020) + 669 pts / 238 comments (2022), different submitters and 811 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12288938","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13499540","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19139943","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1518,"peak_comments":362,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22748247","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":669,"peak_comments":238,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31830046","height":24,"chart_height":75},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42449222","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/obs-studio-open-source-software-for-video-recording-and-live-str-d9d02352c032.jpg","path":"/hall/link/obs-studio-open-source-software-for-video-recording-and-live-str-d9d02352c032/"},{"slug":"publish-on-your-own-site-syndicate-elsewhere-d9d02359e1e2","title":"Publish (On Your) Own Site, Syndicate Elsewhere","domain":"indieweb.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["online_communities","web_development","protocols_networking"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2023-04","inductedMonth":"2026-01","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":7.997,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1078,"evidenceRank":576,"evidenceScore":69.5,"freshAt":"2026-03-23T08:29:27Z","freshnessRank":41,"freshEventScore":414,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1078 pts / 248 comments (2026) + 275 pts / 70 comments (2023), different submitters and 988 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":91,"peak_comments":26,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16663850","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":192,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29115696","height":9,"chart_height":30},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":275,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35636052","height":13,"chart_height":43},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42170209","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":1078,"peak_comments":248,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46468600","height":24,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/publish-on-your-own-site-syndicate-elsewhere-d9d02359e1e2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/publish-on-your-own-site-syndicate-elsewhere-d9d02359e1e2/"},{"slug":"treesheets-cross-platform-free-form-data-organizer-app-d9d0234b61e5","title":"Treesheets: cross-platform, free-form data organizer app","domain":"strlen.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["personal_productivity","product_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2021-06","inductedMonth":"2021-06","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":12.556,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":359,"evidenceRank":577,"evidenceScore":69.5,"freshAt":"2021-06-24T07:40:50Z","freshnessRank":897,"freshEventScore":359,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 359 pts / 90 comments (2021) + 188 pts / 58 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,403 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6870813","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":76,"peak_comments":28,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11247372","height":4,"chart_height":36},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":188,"peak_comments":58,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15057392","height":9,"chart_height":89},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23107141","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":359,"peak_comments":90,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27614912","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34184993","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43116757","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47654219","height":4,"chart_height":8}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/treesheets-cross-platform-free-form-data-organizer-app-d9d0234b61e5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/treesheets-cross-platform-free-form-data-organizer-app-d9d0234b61e5/"},{"slug":"hacker-news-s-undocumented-features-and-behaviors-d9d02359986a","title":"Hacker News's Undocumented Features and Behaviors","domain":"github.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["online_communities","internet_culture","digital_archives"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-04","inductedMonth":"2022-10","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.93,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":803,"evidenceRank":578,"evidenceScore":69.4,"freshAt":"2025-01-27T00:15:27Z","freshnessRank":257,"freshEventScore":47,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 803 pts / 391 comments (2018) + 335 pts / 255 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,152 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":803,"peak_comments":391,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16437973","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":55,"peak_comments":25,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20292361","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24548010","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":335,"peak_comments":255,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26866482","height":16,"chart_height":71},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":226,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33076053","height":11,"chart_height":48},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":47,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42835806","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/hacker-news-s-undocumented-features-and-behaviors-d9d02359986a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/hacker-news-s-undocumented-features-and-behaviors-d9d02359986a/"},{"slug":"write-a-shell-in-c-2015-d9d0235574af","title":"Write a Shell in C (2015)","domain":"brennan.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","operating_systems","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-02","inductedMonth":"2022-08","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":8.055,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":379,"evidenceRank":579,"evidenceScore":69.4,"freshAt":"2024-12-26T19:53:39Z","freshnessRank":277,"freshEventScore":205,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 379 pts / 68 comments (2016) + 276 pts / 80 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,530 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":379,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13112589","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16535637","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24501806","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":276,"peak_comments":80,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26126010","height":13,"chart_height":124},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33004362","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38241817","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":205,"peak_comments":16,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42517303","height":10,"chart_height":92},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/write-a-shell-in-c-2015-d9d0235574af.jpg","path":"/hall/link/write-a-shell-in-c-2015-d9d0235574af/"},{"slug":"10-years-since-google-said-to-hang-tight-about-linux-support-for-d9d0234ffe0d","title":"10 years since Google said to “hang tight” about Linux support for Google Drive","domain":"abevoelker.github.io","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2020-08","inductedMonth":"2022-04","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":8.249,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":520,"evidenceRank":580,"evidenceScore":69.3,"freshAt":"2022-04-24T16:40:13Z","freshnessRank":789,"freshEventScore":520,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 520 pts / 215 comments (2022) + 108 pts / 59 comments (2015), different submitters and 2,556 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":108,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9434643","height":5,"chart_height":35},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14160331","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":150,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24183399","height":7,"chart_height":49},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":520,"peak_comments":215,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31145709","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36849773","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/10-years-since-google-said-to-hang-tight-about-linux-support-for-d9d0234ffe0d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/10-years-since-google-said-to-hang-tight-about-linux-support-for-d9d0234ffe0d/"},{"slug":"flix-a-powerful-effect-oriented-programming-language-d9d023637ba6","title":"Flix – A powerful effect-oriented programming language","domain":"flix.dev","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-11","inductedMonth":"2023-11","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.657,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":341,"evidenceRank":581,"evidenceScore":69.3,"freshAt":"2025-07-10T14:02:04Z","freshnessRank":190,"freshEventScore":341,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 341 pts / 190 comments (2025) + 213 pts / 42 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,146 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":122,"peak_comments":84,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25513397","height":6,"chart_height":61},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":213,"peak_comments":42,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31448889","height":10,"chart_height":106},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":222,"peak_comments":121,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38419263","height":11,"chart_height":111},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":341,"peak_comments":190,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44521224","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/flix-a-powerful-effect-oriented-programming-language-d9d023637ba6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/flix-a-powerful-effect-oriented-programming-language-d9d023637ba6/"},{"slug":"the-line-of-death-d9d02355d30a","title":"The Line of Death","domain":"textslashplain.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security","browsers_web_standards","user_experience","abuse_fraud"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2022-03","inductedMonth":"2022-03","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":9.199,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":566,"evidenceRank":582,"evidenceScore":69.3,"freshAt":"2022-03-18T13:10:20Z","freshnessRank":803,"freshEventScore":284,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 566 pts / 105 comments (2017) + 284 pts / 41 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,888 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":566,"peak_comments":105,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13400291","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19773776","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27426820","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":284,"peak_comments":41,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30721728","height":14,"chart_height":85},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36673188","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44281663","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47557866","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-line-of-death-d9d02355d30a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-line-of-death-d9d02355d30a/"},{"slug":"css-zen-garden-d9d0233ff0bb","title":"CSS Zen Garden","domain":"www.csszengarden.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","visual_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2020-03","inductedMonth":"2020-03","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":12.293,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":462,"evidenceRank":583,"evidenceScore":69.3,"freshAt":"2021-12-24T01:28:31Z","freshnessRank":842,"freshEventScore":173,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 462 pts / 217 comments (2020) + 218 pts / 47 comments (2013), different submitters and 2,433 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=811468","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":218,"peak_comments":47,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6076163","height":10,"chart_height":80},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11994723","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21554744","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":462,"peak_comments":217,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22627018","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":173,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29668910","height":8,"chart_height":64},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/css-zen-garden-d9d0233ff0bb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/css-zen-garden-d9d0233ff0bb/"},{"slug":"the-future-of-programming-d9d0234a21b4","title":"The Future of Programming","domain":"worrydream.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["human_computer_interaction","programming_languages","history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2017-10","inductedMonth":"2019-07","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":12.003,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":614,"evidenceRank":584,"evidenceScore":69.3,"freshAt":"2025-07-31T15:43:38Z","freshnessRank":179,"freshEventScore":39,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 614 pts / 341 comments (2013) + 225 pts / 66 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,546 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":614,"peak_comments":341,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6129148","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9808376","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":99,"peak_comments":26,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12051577","height":5,"chart_height":27},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":225,"peak_comments":66,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15539766","height":11,"chart_height":62},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20332795","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28744952","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39747500","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":39,"peak_comments":10,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44746821","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-future-of-programming-d9d0234a21b4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-future-of-programming-d9d0234a21b4/"},{"slug":"dib-guide-detecting-agile-bs-2018-pdf-d9d0235bdc1f","title":"DIB Guide: Detecting Agile BS (2018) [pdf]","domain":"media.defense.gov","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"technical_report","typeDisplay":"Technical reports","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["management_strategy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2022-10","inductedMonth":"2024-07","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":5.744,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":396,"evidenceRank":585,"evidenceScore":69.3,"freshAt":"2024-07-25T21:40:49Z","freshnessRank":357,"freshEventScore":122,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 396 pts / 132 comments (2019) + 122 pts / 40 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,018 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":4,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18314352","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":396,"peak_comments":132,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18910608","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":107,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23962722","height":5,"chart_height":46},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33096879","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":67,"peak_comments":16,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34957523","height":4,"chart_height":29},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":122,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41073688","height":6,"chart_height":52},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/dib-guide-detecting-agile-bs-2018-pdf-d9d0235bdc1f/"},{"slug":"a-course-in-machine-learning-d9d0234a8ef3","title":"A Course in Machine Learning","domain":"ciml.info","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["machine_learning","mathematics","data_science"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-07","inductedMonth":"2016-07","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":10.861,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":402,"evidenceRank":586,"evidenceScore":69.2,"freshAt":"2018-06-02T13:52:01Z","freshnessRank":1094,"freshEventScore":259,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 402 pts / 19 comments (2016) + 229 pts / 39 comments (2013), different submitters and 1,031 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":229,"peak_comments":39,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6389165","height":11,"chart_height":97},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10555653","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":402,"peak_comments":19,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12083124","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":259,"peak_comments":27,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17214588","height":12,"chart_height":110},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35752426","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41082413","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-course-in-machine-learning-d9d0234a8ef3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-course-in-machine-learning-d9d0234a8ef3/"},{"slug":"plain-text-accounting-d9d0236417c8","title":"Plain Text Accounting","domain":"plaintextaccounting.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["finance","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2023-05","inductedMonth":"2024-09","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.975,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":473,"evidenceRank":587,"evidenceScore":69.2,"freshAt":"2024-09-15T21:30:57Z","freshnessRank":331,"freshEventScore":334,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 473 pts / 200 comments (2021) + 334 pts / 120 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,342 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":473,"peak_comments":200,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25745615","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":127,"peak_comments":44,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36022005","height":6,"chart_height":46},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":334,"peak_comments":120,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41550603","height":16,"chart_height":120},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46476300","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/plain-text-accounting-d9d0236417c8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/plain-text-accounting-d9d0236417c8/"},{"slug":"use-youtube-to-improve-your-english-pronunciation-d9d0235e18bf","title":"Use YouTube to improve your English pronunciation","domain":"youglish.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["learning_methods","teaching","language_linguistics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2021-11","inductedMonth":"2025-05","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.93,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":770,"evidenceRank":588,"evidenceScore":69.2,"freshAt":"2023-10-30T19:47:10Z","freshnessRank":503,"freshEventScore":548,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 548 pts / 331 comments (2023) + 770 pts / 236 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,594 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":770,"peak_comments":236,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20225093","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25062113","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":210,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29085092","height":10,"chart_height":46},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":548,"peak_comments":331,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38074701","height":24,"chart_height":121},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44081962","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/use-youtube-to-improve-your-english-pronunciation-d9d0235e18bf.jpg","path":"/hall/link/use-youtube-to-improve-your-english-pronunciation-d9d0235e18bf/"},{"slug":"quick-draw-d9d0235542e1","title":"Quick, Draw","domain":"quickdraw.withgoogle.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"computer_game","typeDisplay":"Computer games","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["machine_learning","human_computer_interaction","data_science"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-03","inductedMonth":"2021-03","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":9.5,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1083,"evidenceRank":589,"evidenceScore":69.2,"freshAt":"2021-03-29T20:12:01Z","freshnessRank":931,"freshEventScore":132,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1083 pts / 328 comments (2016) + 132 pts / 45 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,594 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":1083,"peak_comments":328,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12965311","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18369915","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20649625","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23671864","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":132,"peak_comments":45,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26627556","height":6,"chart_height":21},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32658150","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40365234","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48164897","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/quick-draw-d9d0235542e1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/quick-draw-d9d0235542e1/"},{"slug":"click-d9d0235a649a","title":"Click","domain":"clickclickclick.click","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"computer_game","typeDisplay":"Computer games","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["privacy_surveillance","online_communities"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2023-05","inductedMonth":"2023-05","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":8.003,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1100,"evidenceRank":590,"evidenceScore":69.2,"freshAt":"2026-05-18T23:03:02Z","freshnessRank":15,"freshEventScore":370,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1100 pts / 242 comments (2021) + 370 pts / 99 comments (2026), different submitters and 1,886 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18636038","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24846454","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1100,"peak_comments":242,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26518290","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":129,"peak_comments":35,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35841679","height":6,"chart_height":20},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":370,"peak_comments":99,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48187054","height":18,"chart_height":57}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/click-d9d0235a649a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/click-d9d0235a649a/"},{"slug":"hexing-the-technical-interview-2017-d9d02356a453","title":"Hexing the technical interview (2017)","domain":"aphyr.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["hiring_interviews","workplace","writing_craft"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2019-12","inductedMonth":"2019-12","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":7.165,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":598,"evidenceRank":591,"evidenceScore":69.2,"freshAt":"2021-10-29T19:11:24Z","freshnessRank":859,"freshEventScore":268,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 598 pts / 192 comments (2019) + 111 pts / 6 comments (2017), different submitters and 973 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":111,"peak_comments":6,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14050017","height":5,"chart_height":32},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17724501","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":598,"peak_comments":192,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21717039","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":268,"peak_comments":41,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29042413","height":13,"chart_height":76},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35827856","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40573247","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/hexing-the-technical-interview-2017-d9d02356a453.jpg","path":"/hall/link/hexing-the-technical-interview-2017-d9d02356a453/"},{"slug":"c4-c-in-4-functions-d9d0234e67a7","title":"C4 – C in 4 functions","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["compilers_runtimes","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2020-02","inductedMonth":"2023-08","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":10.905,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":517,"evidenceRank":592,"evidenceScore":69.2,"freshAt":"2023-08-26T14:29:05Z","freshnessRank":561,"freshEventScore":24,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 517 pts / 138 comments (2014) + 436 pts / 131 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,931 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":517,"peak_comments":138,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8558822","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11305635","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":436,"peak_comments":131,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22353532","height":21,"chart_height":143},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":24,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37273245","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41884062","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45427426","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/c4-c-in-4-functions-d9d0234e67a7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/c4-c-in-4-functions-d9d0234e67a7/"},{"slug":"sponsorblock-skip-sponsor-segments-on-youtube-d9d0235e73ec","title":"SponsorBlock – skip sponsor segments on YouTube","domain":"sponsor.ajay.app","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["browsers_web_standards","online_communities","open_source","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2024-08","inductedMonth":"2024-08","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":5.049,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":661,"evidenceRank":593,"evidenceScore":69.2,"freshAt":"2024-08-12T09:10:44Z","freshnessRank":349,"freshEventScore":661,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 661 pts / 400 comments (2024) + 192 pts / 174 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,209 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20535432","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25536515","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":192,"peak_comments":174,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26886275","height":9,"chart_height":49},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33122942","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35733993","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":661,"peak_comments":400,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41222577","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/sponsorblock-skip-sponsor-segments-on-youtube-d9d0235e73ec.jpg","path":"/hall/link/sponsorblock-skip-sponsor-segments-on-youtube-d9d0235e73ec/"},{"slug":"a-mind-is-born-2017-d9d02356cad7","title":"A Mind Is Born (2017)","domain":"linusakesson.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["retrocomputing","computer_architecture","music"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-03","inductedMonth":"2023-04","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":8.222,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":311,"evidenceRank":594,"evidenceScore":69.2,"freshAt":"2021-03-19T08:56:25Z","freshnessRank":934,"freshEventScore":311,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 311 pts / 64 comments (2021) + 306 pts / 53 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,427 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":306,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14164907","height":15,"chart_height":167},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22642527","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":311,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26511266","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34207990","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41488052","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43073504","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-mind-is-born-2017-d9d02356cad7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-mind-is-born-2017-d9d02356cad7/"},{"slug":"a-spectre-is-haunting-unicode-d9d0235b0acd","title":"A Spectre is Haunting Unicode","domain":"www.dampfkraft.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["language_linguistics","history","digital_archives"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2020-10","inductedMonth":"2024-05","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.799,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":353,"evidenceRank":595,"evidenceScore":69.1,"freshAt":"2022-07-14T13:00:12Z","freshnessRank":750,"freshEventScore":268,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 268 pts / 180 comments (2022) + 353 pts / 110 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,446 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":353,"peak_comments":110,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17637375","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21920442","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":323,"peak_comments":130,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24951130","height":16,"chart_height":156},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":268,"peak_comments":180,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32095502","height":13,"chart_height":129},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40377453","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-spectre-is-haunting-unicode-d9d0235b0acd.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-spectre-is-haunting-unicode-d9d0235b0acd/"},{"slug":"firacode-free-monospaced-font-with-programming-ligatures-d9d02350430c","title":"FiraCode: Free monospaced font with programming ligatures","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2023-07","inductedMonth":"2023-07","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":10.475,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":247,"evidenceRank":596,"evidenceScore":69.1,"freshAt":"2023-07-19T02:35:30Z","freshnessRank":589,"freshEventScore":247,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 247 pts / 150 comments (2023) + 97 pts / 81 comments (2015), different submitters and 2,768 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":97,"peak_comments":81,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10764527","height":5,"chart_height":67},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15573407","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17211914","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24204454","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":247,"peak_comments":150,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36781487","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45886703","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/firacode-free-monospaced-font-with-programming-ligatures-d9d02350430c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/firacode-free-monospaced-font-with-programming-ligatures-d9d02350430c/"},{"slug":"osquery-an-sqlite3-virtual-table-exposing-operating-system-data-d9d0235006ae","title":"Osquery: An sqlite3 virtual table exposing operating system data to SQL","domain":"osquery.io","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2024-02","inductedMonth":"2024-02","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":8.83,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":300,"evidenceRank":597,"evidenceScore":69.1,"freshAt":"2024-02-25T14:58:51Z","freshnessRank":441,"freshEventScore":300,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 300 pts / 99 comments (2024) + 224 pts / 26 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,476 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9725512","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":224,"peak_comments":26,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14344644","height":11,"chart_height":127},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20755515","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":62,"peak_comments":13,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24176652","height":4,"chart_height":35},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29230872","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30080942","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":300,"peak_comments":99,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39501281","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/osquery-an-sqlite3-virtual-table-exposing-operating-system-data-d9d0235006ae.jpg","path":"/hall/link/osquery-an-sqlite3-virtual-table-exposing-operating-system-data-d9d0235006ae/"},{"slug":"a-slower-speed-of-light-d9d023478df8","title":"A Slower Speed of Light","domain":"gamelab.mit.edu","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"computer_game","typeDisplay":"Computer games","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["physics","game_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2024-05","inductedMonth":"2024-05","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":11.524,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":284,"evidenceRank":598,"evidenceScore":69.1,"freshAt":"2024-05-12T06:27:34Z","freshnessRank":398,"freshEventScore":223,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 284 pts / 105 comments (2012) + 223 pts / 59 comments (2024), different submitters and 4,208 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":284,"peak_comments":105,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4731749","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9161900","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":89,"peak_comments":15,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17169262","height":4,"chart_height":53},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21539411","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22975109","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26309517","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37203604","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":223,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40332586","height":11,"chart_height":133},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-slower-speed-of-light-d9d023478df8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-slower-speed-of-light-d9d023478df8/"},{"slug":"urbit-d9d02353c9ec","title":"Urbit","domain":"urbit.org","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["internet_infrastructure","distributed_systems","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-11","inductedMonth":"2019-11","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":6.034,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":313,"evidenceRank":599,"evidenceScore":69.1,"freshAt":"2019-11-30T22:23:39Z","freshnessRank":1032,"freshEventScore":313,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 313 pts / 288 comments (2019) + 184 pts / 153 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,271 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":184,"peak_comments":153,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11851849","height":9,"chart_height":100},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15302110","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":313,"peak_comments":288,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21672481","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26665461","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31809595","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/urbit-d9d02353c9ec.jpg","path":"/hall/link/urbit-d9d02353c9ec/"},{"slug":"bad-ssl-d9d02350e3a1","title":"Bad SSL","domain":"badssl.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security","cryptography"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2022-09","inductedMonth":"2022-09","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":8.597,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":404,"evidenceRank":600,"evidenceScore":69.0,"freshAt":"2024-03-02T16:41:46Z","freshnessRank":434,"freshEventScore":40,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 404 pts / 81 comments (2017) + 150 pts / 34 comments (2022), different submitters and 2,020 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10657809","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11864633","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":404,"peak_comments":81,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13900450","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21746101","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24181602","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":150,"peak_comments":34,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33015094","height":7,"chart_height":63},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":40,"peak_comments":11,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39573691","height":4,"chart_height":17},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/bad-ssl-d9d02350e3a1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/bad-ssl-d9d02350e3a1/"},{"slug":"money-creation-in-the-modern-economy-2014-pdf-d9d02359cfb0","title":"Money creation in the modern economy (2014) [pdf]","domain":"www.bankofengland.co.uk","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"technical_report","typeDisplay":"Technical reports","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["economics","finance","markets"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-09","inductedMonth":"2021-09","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":6.089,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":227,"evidenceRank":601,"evidenceScore":69.0,"freshAt":"2021-09-09T19:43:14Z","freshnessRank":876,"freshEventScore":76,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 227 pts / 123 comments (2018) + 76 pts / 114 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,272 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":227,"peak_comments":123,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16604251","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21519022","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23751558","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":76,"peak_comments":114,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28473807","height":4,"chart_height":57},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34220338","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40070404","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/money-creation-in-the-modern-economy-2014-pdf-d9d02359cfb0/"},{"slug":"how-to-turn-an-ikea-coffee-table-into-a-diy-server-rack-d9d0234f2c75","title":"How to Turn an IKEA Coffee Table into a DIY Server Rack","domain":"wiki.eth0.nl","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["computer_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2021-01","inductedMonth":"2021-01","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":7.546,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":414,"evidenceRank":602,"evidenceScore":69.0,"freshAt":"2022-08-19T13:47:09Z","freshnessRank":728,"freshEventScore":347,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 347 pts / 238 comments (2022) + 148 pts / 40 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,977 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8979234","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":148,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13921490","height":7,"chart_height":61},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20864100","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":414,"peak_comments":196,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25978013","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":347,"peak_comments":238,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32520882","height":17,"chart_height":142},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-to-turn-an-ikea-coffee-table-into-a-diy-server-rack-d9d0234f2c75.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-to-turn-an-ikea-coffee-table-into-a-diy-server-rack-d9d0234f2c75/"},{"slug":"new-mersenne-prime-discovered-probably-d9d0234fdc52","title":"New Mersenne Prime discovered (probably)","domain":"www.mersenne.org","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","distributed_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2024-10","inductedMonth":"2024-10","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":9.517,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":368,"evidenceRank":603,"evidenceScore":69.0,"freshAt":"2024-10-16T11:51:33Z","freshnessRank":314,"freshEventScore":368,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 368 pts / 120 comments (2024) + 163 pts / 116 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,102 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":27,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9360994","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10941005","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":163,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28817034","height":8,"chart_height":75},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35177559","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":368,"peak_comments":120,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41858024","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/new-mersenne-prime-discovered-probably-d9d0234fdc52.jpg","path":"/hall/link/new-mersenne-prime-discovered-probably-d9d0234fdc52/"},{"slug":"i-should-have-loved-biology-d9d0236389cb","title":"I should have loved biology","domain":"jsomers.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["biology","teaching","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2024-04","inductedMonth":"2025-07","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.709,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1048,"evidenceRank":604,"evidenceScore":68.9,"freshAt":"2024-04-21T06:28:58Z","freshnessRank":414,"freshEventScore":685,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 800 pts / 298 comments (2020) + 685 pts / 253 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,249 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":800,"peak_comments":298,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25136422","height":24,"chart_height":130},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":1048,"peak_comments":271,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32035054","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":685,"peak_comments":253,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40103590","height":24,"chart_height":111},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44789435","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/i-should-have-loved-biology-d9d0236389cb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/i-should-have-loved-biology-d9d0236389cb/"},{"slug":"paper-airplane-designs-d9d0235bc7d5","title":"Paper Airplane Designs","domain":"www.foldnfly.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"space_transportation","topicDisplay":"Space & transportation","tags":["aviation","teaching","physics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2022-07","inductedMonth":"2022-07","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":7.6,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1753,"evidenceRank":605,"evidenceScore":68.9,"freshAt":"2024-01-23T19:26:31Z","freshnessRank":453,"freshEventScore":38,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1753 pts / 205 comments (2018) + 538 pts / 96 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,368 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":1753,"peak_comments":205,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18249755","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":70,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29466325","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":538,"peak_comments":96,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32134691","height":24,"chart_height":52},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37599117","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":38,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39108360","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48265625","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/paper-airplane-designs-d9d0235bc7d5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/paper-airplane-designs-d9d0235bc7d5/"},{"slug":"l-ve-a-framework-to-make-2d-games-in-lua-d9d023427f60","title":"LÖVE: a framework to make 2D games in Lua","domain":"love2d.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_development","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2023-09","inductedMonth":"2023-09","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":12.589,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":556,"evidenceRank":606,"evidenceScore":68.9,"freshAt":"2023-09-13T09:21:16Z","freshnessRank":548,"freshEventScore":556,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 556 pts / 180 comments (2023) + 101 pts / 18 comments (2012), different submitters and 4,190 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2201158","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":18,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3745631","height":5,"chart_height":31},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6906905","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17845782","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27254628","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33342865","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":556,"peak_comments":180,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37494275","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/l-ve-a-framework-to-make-2d-games-in-lua-d9d023427f60.jpg","path":"/hall/link/l-ve-a-framework-to-make-2d-games-in-lua-d9d023427f60/"},{"slug":"how-recursion-got-into-programming-2014-d9d023512922","title":"How Recursion Got into Programming (2014)","domain":"vanemden.wordpress.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["programming_languages","history","theory_of_computation"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2020-05","inductedMonth":"2020-05","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":10.801,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":127,"evidenceRank":607,"evidenceScore":68.8,"freshAt":"2022-10-07T16:55:12Z","freshnessRank":711,"freshEventScore":32,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 103 pts / 124 comments (2015) + 127 pts / 47 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,711 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":103,"peak_comments":124,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10131664","height":5,"chart_height":138},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15577238","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20303771","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":127,"peak_comments":47,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23061881","height":6,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29389838","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":32,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33123916","height":4,"chart_height":43},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39918620","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48544123","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-recursion-got-into-programming-2014-d9d023512922.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-recursion-got-into-programming-2014-d9d023512922/"},{"slug":"lamest-edit-wars-d9d023416392","title":"Lamest Edit Wars","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["online_communities","internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2023-05","inductedMonth":"2023-05","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":14.76,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":441,"evidenceRank":608,"evidenceScore":68.8,"freshAt":"2023-05-07T16:57:55Z","freshnessRank":633,"freshEventScore":129,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 441 pts / 318 comments (2020) + 129 pts / 88 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,105 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1583578","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6901167","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12795623","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":441,"peak_comments":318,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22992544","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":129,"peak_comments":88,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35853338","height":6,"chart_height":50},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43950258","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/lamest-edit-wars-d9d023416392.jpg","path":"/hall/link/lamest-edit-wars-d9d023416392/"},{"slug":"oberon-2009-d9d0233f7c5b","title":"Oberon (2009)","domain":"ignorethecode.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["user_experience","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2021-01","inductedMonth":"2022-08","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":13.344,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":225,"evidenceRank":609,"evidenceScore":68.8,"freshAt":"2022-08-26T09:55:44Z","freshnessRank":724,"freshEventScore":225,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 225 pts / 143 comments (2022) + 128 pts / 30 comments (2009), different submitters and 4,861 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":2,"peak_score":128,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=593323","height":6,"chart_height":97},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":99,"peak_comments":31,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6498878","height":5,"chart_height":75},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12045480","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":168,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25786470","height":8,"chart_height":127},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":225,"peak_comments":143,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32605287","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/oberon-2009-d9d0233f7c5b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/oberon-2009-d9d0233f7c5b/"},{"slug":"yoda-conditions-d9d0234aaafe","title":"Yoda conditions","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2019-08","inductedMonth":"2019-08","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":9.344,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":133,"evidenceRank":610,"evidenceScore":68.8,"freshAt":"2019-08-15T10:37:37Z","freshnessRank":1050,"freshEventScore":133,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 133 pts / 104 comments (2019) + 76 pts / 79 comments (2017), different submitters and 908 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6450720","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7370759","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8887873","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12312595","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":76,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13668792","height":4,"chart_height":97},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17735332","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":133,"peak_comments":104,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20704028","height":6,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26170107","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34586878","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/yoda-conditions-d9d0234aaafe.jpg","path":"/hall/link/yoda-conditions-d9d0234aaafe/"},{"slug":"mental-models-i-find-repeatedly-useful-d9d023540bee","title":"Mental Models I Find Repeatedly Useful","domain":"medium.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["learning_methods","psychology","personal_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2018-12","inductedMonth":"2018-12","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":5.78,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":929,"evidenceRank":611,"evidenceScore":68.8,"freshAt":"2018-12-25T16:16:10Z","freshnessRank":1072,"freshEventScore":315,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 929 pts / 189 comments (2016) + 315 pts / 34 comments (2018), different submitters and 902 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":4,"peak_score":929,"peak_comments":189,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12040707","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13743344","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":315,"peak_comments":34,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18757895","height":15,"chart_height":58},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31063564","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/mental-models-i-find-repeatedly-useful-d9d023540bee/"},{"slug":"how-to-crawl-a-quarter-billion-webpages-in-40-hours-d9d02346da5e","title":"How to crawl a quarter billion webpages in 40 hours","domain":"www.michaelnielsen.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["internet_infrastructure","distributed_systems","data_engineering"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2018-07","inductedMonth":"2026-04","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":13.678,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":323,"evidenceRank":612,"evidenceScore":68.8,"freshAt":"2023-06-15T07:33:37Z","freshnessRank":612,"freshEventScore":208,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 323 pts / 67 comments (2012) + 296 pts / 61 comments (2018), different submitters and 2,154 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":323,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4367933","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":136,"peak_comments":23,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10865568","height":7,"chart_height":72},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":296,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17460749","height":14,"chart_height":156},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":208,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36337473","height":10,"chart_height":109},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47786459","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-to-crawl-a-quarter-billion-webpages-in-40-hours-d9d02346da5e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-to-crawl-a-quarter-billion-webpages-in-40-hours-d9d02346da5e/"},{"slug":"flipper-zero-portable-multi-tool-device-for-geeks-d9d0235fea4e","title":"Flipper Zero – Portable Multi-Tool Device for Geeks","domain":"flipperzero.one","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["embedded_iot","electronics","application_security"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-07","inductedMonth":"2024-01","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":4.088,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":956,"evidenceRank":613,"evidenceScore":68.7,"freshAt":"2024-01-21T23:27:51Z","freshnessRank":455,"freshEventScore":685,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 685 pts / 320 comments (2024) + 184 pts / 48 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,047 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21842830","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22890613","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":184,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26405919","height":9,"chart_height":33},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":956,"peak_comments":263,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32166058","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38696232","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":685,"peak_comments":320,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39084137","height":24,"chart_height":122},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/flipper-zero-portable-multi-tool-device-for-geeks-d9d0235fea4e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/flipper-zero-portable-multi-tool-device-for-geeks-d9d0235fea4e/"},{"slug":"how-i-went-from-100-an-hour-programming-to-x0-000-a-week-consult-d9d02347b39d","title":"How I went from $100-an-hour programming to $X0,000-a-week consulting","domain":"training.kalzumeus.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["management_strategy","startups_entrepreneurship","careers"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2017-12","inductedMonth":"2025-05","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":13.153,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1034,"evidenceRank":614,"evidenceScore":68.7,"freshAt":"2017-12-23T15:12:52Z","freshnessRank":1114,"freshEventScore":780,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 780 pts / 472 comments (2017) + 1034 pts / 261 comments (2012), different submitters and 1,859 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":1034,"peak_comments":261,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4805091","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12434290","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":780,"peak_comments":472,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15994410","height":24,"chart_height":128},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34492031","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43905236","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46619257","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-i-went-from-100-an-hour-programming-to-x0-000-a-week-consult-d9d02347b39d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-i-went-from-100-an-hour-programming-to-x0-000-a-week-consult-d9d02347b39d/"},{"slug":"croc-easily-and-securely-send-things-from-one-computer-to-anothe-d9d023587ec5","title":"Croc: Easily and securely send things from one computer to another","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","application_security","cryptography","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2023-09","inductedMonth":"2023-09","submissions":11,"submitters":10,"spanYears":8.72,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":300,"evidenceRank":615,"evidenceScore":68.6,"freshAt":"2023-09-22T23:35:01Z","freshnessRank":540,"freshEventScore":300,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 300 pts / 141 comments (2023) + 150 pts / 68 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,100 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15528766","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16919847","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20434909","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":150,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24503077","height":7,"chart_height":85},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31251614","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":300,"peak_comments":141,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37619151","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48882034","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/croc-easily-and-securely-send-things-from-one-computer-to-anothe-d9d023587ec5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/croc-easily-and-securely-send-things-from-one-computer-to-anothe-d9d023587ec5/"},{"slug":"standard-notes-a-notes-app-with-a-focus-on-longevity-portability-d9d02355ae5c","title":"Standard Notes – A notes app with a focus on longevity, portability, and privacy","domain":"standardnotes.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-04","inductedMonth":"2021-04","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":4.293,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":673,"evidenceRank":616,"evidenceScore":68.6,"freshAt":"2021-04-16T20:56:49Z","freshnessRank":923,"freshEventScore":286,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 673 pts / 282 comments (2017) + 286 pts / 248 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,549 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13284186","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":673,"peak_comments":282,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13421927","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17751882","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20692231","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23771061","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":286,"peak_comments":248,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26838992","height":14,"chart_height":72},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/standard-notes-a-notes-app-with-a-focus-on-longevity-portability-d9d02355ae5c/"},{"slug":"regexper-regular-expressions-visualizer-d9d0234813a6","title":"Regexper – Regular expressions visualizer","domain":"regexper.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2018-01","inductedMonth":"2018-01","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":11.403,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":510,"evidenceRank":617,"evidenceScore":68.6,"freshAt":"2018-01-30T15:13:00Z","freshnessRank":1111,"freshEventScore":510,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 510 pts / 102 comments (2018) + 466 pts / 127 comments (2013), different submitters and 1,854 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":466,"peak_comments":127,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4996927","height":22,"chart_height":155},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8148804","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":510,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16265872","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25260607","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40516606","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/regexper-regular-expressions-visualizer-d9d0234813a6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/regexper-regular-expressions-visualizer-d9d0234813a6/"},{"slug":"remarkable-2-0-a-digital-notebook-that-feels-like-paper-d9d02360cf7b","title":"ReMarkable 2.0 – A digital notebook that feels like paper","domain":"remarkable.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["product_design","personal_productivity","electronics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2022-10","inductedMonth":"2024-05","submissions":8,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.468,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1410,"evidenceRank":618,"evidenceScore":68.6,"freshAt":"2024-09-04T12:07:27Z","freshnessRank":337,"freshEventScore":664,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1410 pts / 685 comments (2020) + 664 pts / 546 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,468 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":1410,"peak_comments":685,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24295443","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":299,"peak_comments":424,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33352967","height":14,"chart_height":36},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":664,"peak_comments":546,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41444700","height":24,"chart_height":80},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/remarkable-2-0-a-digital-notebook-that-feels-like-paper-d9d02360cf7b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/remarkable-2-0-a-digital-notebook-that-feels-like-paper-d9d02360cf7b/"},{"slug":"whatsapp-web-d9d0234f127e","title":"Whatsapp Web","domain":"web.whatsapp.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2023-06","inductedMonth":"2023-06","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":11.047,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":131,"evidenceRank":619,"evidenceScore":68.6,"freshAt":"2023-06-05T18:05:20Z","freshnessRank":617,"freshEventScore":105,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 131 pts / 108 comments (2015) + 105 pts / 67 comments (2023), different submitters and 3,056 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":7,"peak_score":131,"peak_comments":108,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8924600","height":6,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20153485","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26516133","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":105,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36200389","height":5,"chart_height":136},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46926433","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/whatsapp-web-d9d0234f127e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/whatsapp-web-d9d0234f127e/"},{"slug":"learning-advanced-javascript-d9d0233ee376","title":"Learning Advanced JavaScript","domain":"ejohn.org","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2016-12","inductedMonth":"2016-12","submissions":9,"submitters":7,"spanYears":8.216,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":302,"evidenceRank":620,"evidenceScore":68.5,"freshAt":"2016-12-11T04:47:14Z","freshnessRank":1143,"freshEventScore":192,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 302 pts / 31 comments (2011) + 192 pts / 55 comments (2016), different submitters and 2,161 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=311956","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":52,"peak_comments":15,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=944211","height":4,"chart_height":29},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":169,"peak_comments":19,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1310022","height":8,"chart_height":95},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":302,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2088314","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5144716","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":192,"peak_comments":55,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13149635","height":9,"chart_height":108},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/learning-advanced-javascript-d9d0233ee376.jpg","path":"/hall/link/learning-advanced-javascript-d9d0233ee376/"},{"slug":"98-css-design-system-for-building-faithful-recreations-of-window-d9d023613e48","title":"98.css – design system for building faithful recreations of Windows 98 UIs","domain":"jdan.github.io","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design","web_development","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2022-10","inductedMonth":"2026-07","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.253,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":838,"evidenceRank":621,"evidenceScore":68.5,"freshAt":"2024-11-06T02:46:58Z","freshnessRank":301,"freshEventScore":471,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 838 pts / 207 comments (2020) + 606 pts / 179 comments (2022), different submitters and 914 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":838,"peak_comments":207,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22940564","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":606,"peak_comments":179,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33310554","height":24,"chart_height":123},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":471,"peak_comments":92,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42056918","height":23,"chart_height":96},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49028927","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/98-css-design-system-for-building-faithful-recreations-of-window-d9d023613e48.jpg","path":"/hall/link/98-css-design-system-for-building-faithful-recreations-of-window-d9d023613e48/"},{"slug":"mosh-the-mobile-shell-d9d023549618","title":"Mosh: The Mobile Shell","domain":"mosh.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-08","inductedMonth":"2021-08","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":8.977,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":449,"evidenceRank":622,"evidenceScore":68.5,"freshAt":"2025-08-28T14:59:14Z","freshnessRank":158,"freshEventScore":155,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 449 pts / 153 comments (2021) + 155 pts / 78 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,477 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":145,"peak_comments":49,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12429203","height":7,"chart_height":55},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":23,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18692618","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":449,"peak_comments":153,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28150287","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38518869","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41247446","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":155,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45053040","height":7,"chart_height":59},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/mosh-the-mobile-shell-d9d023549618.jpg","path":"/hall/link/mosh-the-mobile-shell-d9d023549618/"},{"slug":"tmsu-a-tool-born-out-of-frustration-with-the-hierarchical-nature-d9d0234ebf96","title":"TMSU: a tool born out of frustration with the hierarchical nature of filesystems","domain":"tmsu.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","operating_systems","databases_storage"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2021-02","inductedMonth":"2025-01","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":10.116,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":237,"evidenceRank":623,"evidenceScore":68.5,"freshAt":"2025-01-23T16:29:18Z","freshnessRank":259,"freshEventScore":108,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 237 pts / 128 comments (2016) + 108 pts / 47 comments (2025), different submitters and 3,181 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":209,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8738869","height":10,"chart_height":150},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":237,"peak_comments":128,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11660492","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26072326","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30684985","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37508575","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":108,"peak_comments":47,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42805431","height":5,"chart_height":77},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/tmsu-a-tool-born-out-of-frustration-with-the-hierarchical-nature-d9d0234ebf96.jpg","path":"/hall/link/tmsu-a-tool-born-out-of-frustration-with-the-hierarchical-nature-d9d0234ebf96/"},{"slug":"developers-who-use-spaces-make-more-money-than-those-who-use-tab-d9d023574dd8","title":"Developers who use spaces make more money than those who use tabs","domain":"stackoverflow.blog","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["careers","data_science","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2019-08","inductedMonth":"2023-08","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.204,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":881,"evidenceRank":624,"evidenceScore":68.5,"freshAt":"2021-05-17T07:55:10Z","freshnessRank":911,"freshEventScore":118,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 881 pts / 663 comments (2017) + 118 pts / 259 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,431 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":881,"peak_comments":663,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14560042","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":92,"peak_comments":148,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20718031","height":4,"chart_height":18},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":118,"peak_comments":259,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27181006","height":6,"chart_height":23},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37312006","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/developers-who-use-spaces-make-more-money-than-those-who-use-tab-d9d023574dd8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/developers-who-use-spaces-make-more-money-than-those-who-use-tab-d9d023574dd8/"},{"slug":"thought-terminating-clich-d9d02360f6c0","title":"Thought-Terminating Cliché","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["psychology","language_linguistics","politics_government"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2026-02","inductedMonth":"2026-02","submissions":10,"submitters":9,"spanYears":5.854,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":138,"evidenceRank":625,"evidenceScore":68.4,"freshAt":"2026-02-04T22:54:55Z","freshnessRank":65,"freshEventScore":122,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 138 pts / 138 comments (2021) + 122 pts / 123 comments (2026), different submitters and 1,629 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":10,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23521426","height":4,"chart_height":22},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":138,"peak_comments":138,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28246850","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":40,"peak_comments":25,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36648119","height":4,"chart_height":49},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43828695","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":122,"peak_comments":123,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46893069","height":6,"chart_height":150}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/thought-terminating-clich-d9d02360f6c0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/thought-terminating-clich-d9d02360f6c0/"},{"slug":"the-pitchforks-are-coming-for-us-plutocrats-2014-d9d02352cae1","title":"The Pitchforks Are Coming For Us Plutocrats (2014)","domain":"www.politico.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["economics","social_issues","politics_government"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2024-12","inductedMonth":"2024-12","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":8.786,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":108,"evidenceRank":626,"evidenceScore":68.4,"freshAt":"2024-12-06T02:57:41Z","freshnessRank":289,"freshEventScore":108,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 108 pts / 109 comments (2020) + 108 pts / 72 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,645 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":4,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11156126","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13323649","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20421982","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":108,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23414012","height":5,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38455826","height":4,"chart_height":19},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":108,"peak_comments":72,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42335797","height":5,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/the-pitchforks-are-coming-for-us-plutocrats-2014-d9d02352cae1/"},{"slug":"running-lisp-in-production-2020-d9d0236183d5","title":"Running Lisp in Production (2020)","domain":"www.grammarly.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","performance_reliability","software_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2019-08","inductedMonth":"2022-02","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.259,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":268,"evidenceRank":627,"evidenceScore":68.4,"freshAt":"2023-08-12T22:10:04Z","freshnessRank":569,"freshEventScore":22,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 268 pts / 239 comments (2022) + 167 pts / 60 comments (2019), different submitters and 889 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14298618","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":138,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16860646","height":7,"chart_height":88},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":167,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20814511","height":8,"chart_height":106},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":139,"peak_comments":96,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23292805","height":7,"chart_height":88},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":268,"peak_comments":239,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30172641","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":22,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37104674","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/running-lisp-in-production-2020-d9d0236183d5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/running-lisp-in-production-2020-d9d0236183d5/"},{"slug":"matrix-multiplication-d9d02355595d","title":"Matrix Multiplication","domain":"matrixmultiplication.xyz","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2022-01","inductedMonth":"2022-01","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":8.271,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":873,"evidenceRank":628,"evidenceScore":68.4,"freshAt":"2022-01-17T20:40:13Z","freshnessRank":834,"freshEventScore":438,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 873 pts / 131 comments (2016) + 438 pts / 97 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,879 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":873,"peak_comments":131,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13036386","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24141472","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":438,"peak_comments":97,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29971470","height":21,"chart_height":85},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40875499","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43237696","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/matrix-multiplication-d9d02355595d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/matrix-multiplication-d9d02355595d/"},{"slug":"guerrilla-guide-to-cnc-machining-mold-making-and-resin-casting-2-d9d023477374","title":"Guerrilla guide to CNC machining, mold making, and resin casting (2015)","domain":"lcamtuf.coredump.cx","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["manufacturing","product_design","computer_graphics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2021-06","inductedMonth":"2026-04","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":13.451,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":433,"evidenceRank":629,"evidenceScore":68.4,"freshAt":"2026-04-04T21:00:56Z","freshnessRank":34,"freshEventScore":44,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 383 pts / 157 comments (2023) + 433 pts / 37 comments (2012), different submitters and 3,733 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":433,"peak_comments":37,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4679939","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16325284","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":251,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27645605","height":12,"chart_height":99},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":383,"peak_comments":157,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34339459","height":18,"chart_height":150},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":44,"peak_comments":11,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47643326","height":4,"chart_height":17}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/guerrilla-guide-to-cnc-machining-mold-making-and-resin-casting-2-d9d023477374.jpg","path":"/hall/link/guerrilla-guide-to-cnc-machining-mold-making-and-resin-casting-2-d9d023477374/"},{"slug":"transfer-sh-file-sharing-from-the-command-line-d9d0234e12f2","title":"Transfer.sh – File sharing from the command line","domain":"transfer.sh","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","internet_infrastructure"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2020-03","inductedMonth":"2021-07","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":9.859,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":260,"evidenceRank":630,"evidenceScore":68.4,"freshAt":"2021-07-05T17:22:16Z","freshnessRank":893,"freshEventScore":240,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 260 pts / 113 comments (2018) + 240 pts / 84 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,111 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":226,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8387312","height":11,"chart_height":148},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":260,"peak_comments":113,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17352839","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24510223","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":240,"peak_comments":84,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27739991","height":12,"chart_height":157},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37024352","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41204910","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/transfer-sh-file-sharing-from-the-command-line-d9d0234e12f2/"},{"slug":"technical-writing-courses-d9d023609c9f","title":"Technical Writing Courses","domain":"developers.google.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"course_lecture","typeDisplay":"Courses & lectures","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["writing_craft","developer_tools","teaching"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2022-08","inductedMonth":"2022-08","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":5.922,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":571,"evidenceRank":631,"evidenceScore":68.3,"freshAt":"2026-01-29T09:38:24Z","freshnessRank":70,"freshEventScore":23,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 571 pts / 73 comments (2020) + 165 pts / 36 comments (2022), different submitters and 869 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":8,"peak_score":571,"peak_comments":73,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22652241","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27557393","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":165,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32389588","height":8,"chart_height":49},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39313092","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43380101","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":23,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46807840","height":4,"chart_height":7}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/technical-writing-courses-d9d023609c9f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/technical-writing-courses-d9d023609c9f/"},{"slug":"probabilistic-programming-and-bayesian-methods-for-hackers-2013-d9d0234a1662","title":"Probabilistic Programming and Bayesian Methods for Hackers (2013)","domain":"camdavidsonpilon.github.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["data_science","mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-08","inductedMonth":"2018-02","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":4.597,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":302,"evidenceRank":632,"evidenceScore":68.3,"freshAt":"2018-02-28T12:10:12Z","freshnessRank":1107,"freshEventScore":302,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 302 pts / 36 comments (2018) + 281 pts / 27 comments (2013), different submitters and 1,678 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":281,"peak_comments":27,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6102782","height":13,"chart_height":158},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":192,"peak_comments":10,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9182332","height":9,"chart_height":108},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":172,"peak_comments":10,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12330462","height":8,"chart_height":97},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":302,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16482421","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/probabilistic-programming-and-bayesian-methods-for-hackers-2013-d9d0234a1662/"},{"slug":"turbotax-s-20-year-fight-to-stop-americans-from-filing-taxes-for-d9d0235f4613","title":"TurboTax’s 20-Year Fight to Stop Americans from Filing Taxes for Free","domain":"www.propublica.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["law_regulation","finance","abuse_fraud"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-01","inductedMonth":"2025-10","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.999,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1519,"evidenceRank":633,"evidenceScore":68.3,"freshAt":"2025-10-16T05:31:31Z","freshnessRank":128,"freshEventScore":913,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1519 pts / 447 comments (2019) + 913 pts / 470 comments (2025), different submitters and 2,190 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":1519,"peak_comments":447,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21281411","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":807,"peak_comments":199,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26060414","height":24,"chart_height":90},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":33,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34594832","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":913,"peak_comments":470,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45601750","height":24,"chart_height":102},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/turbotax-s-20-year-fight-to-stop-americans-from-filing-taxes-for-d9d0235f4613.jpg","path":"/hall/link/turbotax-s-20-year-fight-to-stop-americans-from-filing-taxes-for-d9d0235f4613/"},{"slug":"the-worst-volume-control-ui-in-the-world-2017-d9d02357523d","title":"The worst volume control UI in the world (2017)","domain":"uxdesign.cc","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["user_experience","product_design","writing_craft"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2026-03","inductedMonth":"2026-03","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":8.753,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":763,"evidenceRank":634,"evidenceScore":68.3,"freshAt":"2026-03-18T10:22:38Z","freshnessRank":42,"freshEventScore":234,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 763 pts / 477 comments (2021) + 234 pts / 117 comments (2026), different submitters and 1,708 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15263226","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":22,"peak_comments":19,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19407334","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":763,"peak_comments":477,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27819384","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":47,"peak_comments":12,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35624392","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43839030","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":234,"peak_comments":117,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47423762","height":11,"chart_height":52}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-worst-volume-control-ui-in-the-world-2017-d9d02357523d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-worst-volume-control-ui-in-the-world-2017-d9d02357523d/"},{"slug":"should-i-buy-ecc-memory-2015-d9d02356d7c1","title":"Should I buy ECC memory? (2015)","domain":"danluu.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["computer_architecture","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-11","inductedMonth":"2020-11","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":7.034,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":300,"evidenceRank":635,"evidenceScore":68.3,"freshAt":"2024-05-08T03:02:22Z","freshnessRank":405,"freshEventScore":159,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 300 pts / 224 comments (2017) + 159 pts / 137 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,568 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":300,"peak_comments":224,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14206635","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18421709","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":79,"peak_comments":98,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25167288","height":4,"chart_height":45},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":159,"peak_comments":137,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40293943","height":8,"chart_height":90},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/should-i-buy-ecc-memory-2015-d9d02356d7c1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/should-i-buy-ecc-memory-2015-d9d02356d7c1/"},{"slug":"deep-c-d9d023443fdd","title":"Deep C","domain":"www.slideshare.net","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"course_lecture","typeDisplay":"Courses & lectures","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2015-07","inductedMonth":"2022-04","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":11.713,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":375,"evidenceRank":636,"evidenceScore":68.2,"freshAt":"2013-10-23T04:23:07Z","freshnessRank":1172,"freshEventScore":278,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 278 pts / 237 comments (2013) + 375 pts / 141 comments (2011), different submitters and 743 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":375,"peak_comments":141,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3093323","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":278,"peak_comments":237,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6596855","height":13,"chart_height":126},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9882030","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12921332","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31079653","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36495308","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/deep-c-d9d023443fdd.jpg","path":"/hall/link/deep-c-d9d023443fdd/"},{"slug":"localstack-local-aws-emulator-d9d023580774","title":"Localstack – Local AWS Emulator","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","testing_quality","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2026-03","inductedMonth":"2026-03","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":8.553,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":389,"evidenceRank":637,"evidenceScore":68.2,"freshAt":"2026-03-23T18:57:08Z","freshnessRank":40,"freshEventScore":216,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 389 pts / 126 comments (2021) + 216 pts / 126 comments (2026), different submitters and 1,625 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":30,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15154163","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":86,"peak_comments":17,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21538274","height":4,"chart_height":38},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":389,"peak_comments":126,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28820012","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38065938","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39941998","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":216,"peak_comments":126,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47493657","height":10,"chart_height":94}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/localstack-local-aws-emulator-d9d023580774.jpg","path":"/hall/link/localstack-local-aws-emulator-d9d023580774/"},{"slug":"files-are-fraught-with-peril-d9d0235e51f7","title":"Files Are Fraught with Peril","domain":"danluu.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","databases_storage","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-10","inductedMonth":"2025-01","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":5.536,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":240,"evidenceRank":638,"evidenceScore":68.2,"freshAt":"2025-01-23T16:28:34Z","freshnessRank":260,"freshEventScore":203,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 203 pts / 119 comments (2025) + 240 pts / 78 comments (2019), different submitters and 2,011 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":8,"peak_score":240,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20504734","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":103,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25090760","height":5,"chart_height":73},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33344000","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":203,"peak_comments":119,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42805425","height":10,"chart_height":144},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/files-are-fraught-with-peril-d9d0235e51f7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/files-are-fraught-with-peril-d9d0235e51f7/"},{"slug":"ishkur-s-guide-to-electronic-music-d9d0235eb059","title":"Ishkur's Guide to Electronic Music","domain":"music.ishkur.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["music"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-10","inductedMonth":"2025-07","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.105,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":495,"evidenceRank":639,"evidenceScore":68.1,"freshAt":"2025-09-27T10:38:42Z","freshnessRank":140,"freshEventScore":359,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 495 pts / 150 comments (2023) + 286 pts / 71 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,519 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":286,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20744571","height":14,"chart_height":98},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25083516","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":30,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26212706","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":495,"peak_comments":150,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37919241","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":359,"peak_comments":97,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45394642","height":17,"chart_height":123},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/ishkur-s-guide-to-electronic-music-d9d0235eb059.jpg","path":"/hall/link/ishkur-s-guide-to-electronic-music-d9d0235eb059/"},{"slug":"queues-don-t-fix-overload-2014-d9d0234e8ca4","title":"Queues don't fix overload (2014)","domain":"ferd.ca","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2024-01","inductedMonth":"2024-01","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":11.554,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":205,"evidenceRank":640,"evidenceScore":68.1,"freshAt":"2026-06-09T04:10:19Z","freshnessRank":9,"freshEventScore":67,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 193 pts / 153 comments (2024) + 205 pts / 59 comments (2014), different submitters and 3,346 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":205,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8632043","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12198027","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13909243","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23163350","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30606685","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35059554","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":193,"peak_comments":153,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39041477","height":9,"chart_height":160},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":67,"peak_comments":32,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48456279","height":4,"chart_height":56}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/queues-don-t-fix-overload-2014-d9d0234e8ca4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/queues-don-t-fix-overload-2014-d9d0234e8ca4/"},{"slug":"json-with-sqlite-d9d02351a05d","title":"JSON with Sqlite","domain":"www.sqlite.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["databases_storage","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-03","inductedMonth":"2024-07","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":8.731,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":473,"evidenceRank":641,"evidenceScore":68.1,"freshAt":"2023-08-10T23:14:08Z","freshnessRank":572,"freshEventScore":193,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 473 pts / 68 comments (2019) + 311 pts / 70 comments (2017), different submitters and 756 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10412744","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":311,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13556517","height":15,"chart_height":112},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":473,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19277809","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":193,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37082941","height":9,"chart_height":69},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40944752","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/json-with-sqlite-d9d02351a05d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/json-with-sqlite-d9d02351a05d/"},{"slug":"write-code-that-is-easy-to-delete-not-easy-to-extend-2016-d9d0235c6246","title":"Write code that is easy to delete, not easy to extend (2016)","domain":"programmingisterrible.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","performance_reliability","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2024-10","inductedMonth":"2024-10","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":7.474,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":365,"evidenceRank":642,"evidenceScore":68.0,"freshAt":"2024-10-28T07:04:20Z","freshnessRank":305,"freshEventScore":269,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 365 pts / 109 comments (2020) + 269 pts / 100 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,559 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":4,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18756605","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":365,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23914486","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":269,"peak_comments":100,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41968409","height":13,"chart_height":125},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48561153","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/write-code-that-is-easy-to-delete-not-easy-to-extend-2016-d9d0235c6246.jpg","path":"/hall/link/write-code-that-is-easy-to-delete-not-easy-to-extend-2016-d9d0235c6246/"},{"slug":"do-nothing-scripting-the-key-to-gradual-automation-2019-d9d0235e6713","title":"Do-nothing scripting: the key to gradual automation (2019)","domain":"blog.danslimmon.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","performance_reliability","personal_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-08","inductedMonth":"2025-02","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.55,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":804,"evidenceRank":643,"evidenceScore":68.0,"freshAt":"2025-02-07T19:48:16Z","freshnessRank":251,"freshEventScore":582,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 804 pts / 230 comments (2021) + 645 pts / 124 comments (2019), different submitters and 834 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":645,"peak_comments":124,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20495739","height":24,"chart_height":136},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":804,"peak_comments":230,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29083367","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37227810","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":582,"peak_comments":157,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42976698","height":24,"chart_height":123},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/do-nothing-scripting-the-key-to-gradual-automation-2019-d9d0235e6713.jpg","path":"/hall/link/do-nothing-scripting-the-key-to-gradual-automation-2019-d9d0235e6713/"},{"slug":"announcing-your-plans-makes-you-less-motivated-to-accomplish-the-d9d0233fa54c","title":"Announcing your plans makes you less motivated to accomplish them (2009)","domain":"sivers.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["psychology","personal_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2019-09","inductedMonth":"2019-09","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":10.278,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":507,"evidenceRank":644,"evidenceScore":68.0,"freshAt":"2019-09-26T12:03:19Z","freshnessRank":1044,"freshEventScore":507,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 507 pts / 173 comments (2019) + 151 pts / 58 comments (2009), different submitters and 3,753 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":151,"peak_comments":58,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=660720","height":7,"chart_height":51},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6902002","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":74,"peak_comments":21,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7496923","height":4,"chart_height":25},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10530940","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12051699","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14864268","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":507,"peak_comments":173,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21080132","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/announcing-your-plans-makes-you-less-motivated-to-accomplish-the-d9d0233fa54c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/announcing-your-plans-makes-you-less-motivated-to-accomplish-the-d9d0233fa54c/"},{"slug":"restic-backups-done-right-d9d0235ef39b","title":"Restic – Backups Done Right","domain":"restic.net","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","databases_storage","open_source","cryptography"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2021-11","inductedMonth":"2024-10","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.076,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":593,"evidenceRank":645,"evidenceScore":68.0,"freshAt":"2024-10-13T17:42:03Z","freshnessRank":317,"freshEventScore":231,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 573 pts / 286 comments (2021) + 593 pts / 177 comments (2019), different submitters and 743 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":593,"peak_comments":177,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21410833","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":573,"peak_comments":286,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29209455","height":24,"chart_height":164},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":231,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41829913","height":11,"chart_height":66},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/restic-backups-done-right-d9d0235ef39b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/restic-backups-done-right-d9d0235ef39b/"},{"slug":"programming-cheat-sheets-d9d02346663b","title":"Programming cheat sheets","domain":"overapi.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2016-05","inductedMonth":"2016-05","submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":5.405,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":324,"evidenceRank":646,"evidenceScore":68.0,"freshAt":"2017-11-14T13:49:27Z","freshnessRank":1116,"freshEventScore":52,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 324 pts / 46 comments (2016) + 235 pts / 57 comments (2013), different submitters and 1,144 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4846657","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2013,"count":4,"peak_score":235,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5381817","height":11,"chart_height":123},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8388438","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9684409","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":324,"peak_comments":46,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11617259","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":52,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15694899","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/programming-cheat-sheets-d9d02346663b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/programming-cheat-sheets-d9d02346663b/"},{"slug":"jeff-varasano-s-famous-new-york-pizza-recipe-2008-d9d0234131cf","title":"Jeff Varasano's Famous New York Pizza Recipe (2008)","domain":"www.varasanos.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["food_travel"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2017-05","inductedMonth":"2021-12","submissions":9,"submitters":7,"spanYears":13.648,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":350,"evidenceRank":647,"evidenceScore":68.0,"freshAt":"2017-05-08T04:40:46Z","freshnessRank":1127,"freshEventScore":350,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 350 pts / 145 comments (2017) + 201 pts / 88 comments (2010), different submitters and 2,331 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":201,"peak_comments":88,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2023280","height":10,"chart_height":98},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8026634","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":350,"peak_comments":145,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14289307","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29441630","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34081909","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37452609","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39427048","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/jeff-varasano-s-famous-new-york-pizza-recipe-2008-d9d0234131cf.jpg","path":"/hall/link/jeff-varasano-s-famous-new-york-pizza-recipe-2008-d9d0234131cf/"},{"slug":"super-simple-storage-service-d9d0233f73a7","title":"Super Simple Storage Service","domain":"www.supersimplestorageservice.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2022-04","inductedMonth":"2022-04","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":12.991,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":466,"evidenceRank":648,"evidenceScore":68.0,"freshAt":"2022-04-09T22:21:16Z","freshnessRank":794,"freshEventScore":466,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 466 pts / 155 comments (2022) + 154 pts / 67 comments (2010), different submitters and 4,343 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=558295","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":154,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1360436","height":7,"chart_height":56},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2303920","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5863568","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19871681","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25673972","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":466,"peak_comments":155,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30972694","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/super-simple-storage-service-d9d0233f73a7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/super-simple-storage-service-d9d0233f73a7/"},{"slug":"files-are-hard-d9d023522385","title":"Files Are Hard","domain":"danluu.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["databases_storage","performance_reliability","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-03","inductedMonth":"2021-03","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":6.697,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":451,"evidenceRank":649,"evidenceScore":67.9,"freshAt":"2019-12-01T08:55:49Z","freshnessRank":1031,"freshEventScore":170,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 451 pts / 151 comments (2015) + 170 pts / 50 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,448 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":451,"peak_comments":151,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10725859","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15761575","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":127,"peak_comments":26,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16713012","height":6,"chart_height":48},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":170,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21674610","height":8,"chart_height":64},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28207910","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32449578","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/files-are-hard-d9d023522385.jpg","path":"/hall/link/files-are-hard-d9d023522385/"},{"slug":"xz-format-considered-inadequate-for-long-term-archiving-2016-d9d0235a247a","title":"Xz format considered inadequate for long-term archiving (2016)","domain":"www.nongnu.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["performance_reliability","security_incidents","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2024-03","inductedMonth":"2024-11","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":7.351,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":248,"evidenceRank":650,"evidenceScore":67.9,"freshAt":"2025-08-26T04:09:09Z","freshnessRank":161,"freshEventScore":22,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 248 pts / 157 comments (2022) + 235 pts / 135 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,555 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":235,"peak_comments":135,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16884832","height":11,"chart_height":161},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":248,"peak_comments":157,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32210438","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":25,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39871914","height":5,"chart_height":69},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":22,"peak_comments":12,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45022172","height":4,"chart_height":15},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/xz-format-considered-inadequate-for-long-term-archiving-2016-d9d0235a247a/"},{"slug":"how-to-study-mathematics-2017-d9d023598b0a","title":"How to Study Mathematics (2017)","domain":"www.math.uh.edu","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["learning_methods","teaching","mathematics","academic_life"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2022-09","inductedMonth":"2026-07","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":8.37,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":661,"evidenceRank":651,"evidenceScore":67.9,"freshAt":"2024-12-01T21:50:51Z","freshnessRank":292,"freshEventScore":264,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 661 pts / 148 comments (2018) + 264 pts / 103 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,480 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":661,"peak_comments":148,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16392698","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":248,"peak_comments":73,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26524876","height":12,"chart_height":64},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":48,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32973243","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":264,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42290996","height":13,"chart_height":68},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48745363","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-to-study-mathematics-2017-d9d023598b0a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-to-study-mathematics-2017-d9d023598b0a/"},{"slug":"reactos-d9d023490546","title":"ReactOS","domain":"reactos.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","open_source","testing_quality"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2023-01","inductedMonth":"2023-01","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":13.103,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":265,"evidenceRank":652,"evidenceScore":67.9,"freshAt":"2026-05-13T18:20:22Z","freshnessRank":17,"freshEventScore":79,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 265 pts / 133 comments (2020) + 204 pts / 128 comments (2023), different submitters and 825 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6254543","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8152021","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":265,"peak_comments":133,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24787318","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":204,"peak_comments":128,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34426198","height":10,"chart_height":131},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":79,"peak_comments":30,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48125494","height":4,"chart_height":51}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/reactos-d9d023490546.jpg","path":"/hall/link/reactos-d9d023490546/"},{"slug":"ocaml-for-the-masses-2011-d9d023442f1d","title":"OCaml for the Masses (2011)","domain":"queue.acm.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2018-11","inductedMonth":"2018-11","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":8.534,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":304,"evidenceRank":653,"evidenceScore":67.9,"freshAt":"2018-11-26T10:29:35Z","freshnessRank":1075,"freshEventScore":304,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 304 pts / 223 comments (2018) + 100 pts / 88 comments (2014), different submitters and 1,602 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3061573","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":55,"peak_comments":28,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3481700","height":4,"chart_height":31},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5812854","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":100,"peak_comments":88,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8002188","height":5,"chart_height":56},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8886908","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14476236","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":304,"peak_comments":223,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18532352","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22861694","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/ocaml-for-the-masses-2011-d9d023442f1d/"},{"slug":"exa-a-modern-replacement-for-ls-d9d02357c459","title":"Exa, a modern replacement for ls","domain":"the.exa.website","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-12","inductedMonth":"2021-12","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":4.375,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":740,"evidenceRank":654,"evidenceScore":67.9,"freshAt":"2021-12-18T22:48:56Z","freshnessRank":846,"freshEventScore":355,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 740 pts / 403 comments (2017) + 355 pts / 149 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,598 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":740,"peak_comments":403,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14923362","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18658211","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":36,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20564000","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25286923","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":355,"peak_comments":149,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29609388","height":17,"chart_height":82},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/exa-a-modern-replacement-for-ls-d9d02357c459/"},{"slug":"how-i-m-able-to-take-notes-in-mathematics-lectures-using-latex-a-d9d0235d30f7","title":"How I'm able to take notes in mathematics lectures using LaTeX and Vim","domain":"castel.dev","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["learning_methods","mathematics","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2021-11","inductedMonth":"2024-02","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.882,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":703,"evidenceRank":655,"evidenceScore":67.8,"freshAt":"2024-02-05T10:00:19Z","freshnessRank":447,"freshEventScore":248,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 703 pts / 221 comments (2019) + 248 pts / 133 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,782 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":703,"peak_comments":221,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19448678","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":233,"peak_comments":106,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29143707","height":11,"chart_height":56},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":248,"peak_comments":133,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39259316","height":12,"chart_height":60},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-i-m-able-to-take-notes-in-mathematics-lectures-using-latex-a-d9d0235d30f7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-i-m-able-to-take-notes-in-mathematics-lectures-using-latex-a-d9d0235d30f7/"},{"slug":"the-descent-to-c-2013-d9d0234bd24b","title":"The Descent to C (2013)","domain":"www.chiark.greenend.org.uk","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","computer_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2021-09","inductedMonth":"2021-09","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":12.446,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":377,"evidenceRank":656,"evidenceScore":67.8,"freshAt":"2021-09-01T11:51:04Z","freshnessRank":878,"freshEventScore":156,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 377 pts / 230 comments (2014) + 156 pts / 91 comments (2021), different submitters and 2,773 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":377,"peak_comments":230,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7134798","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11525054","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15445059","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17749895","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":156,"peak_comments":91,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28378627","height":7,"chart_height":70},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39551540","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48865571","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-descent-to-c-2013-d9d0234bd24b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-descent-to-c-2013-d9d0234bd24b/"},{"slug":"rsa-is-a-fragile-cryptosystem-d9d0235e447c","title":"RSA is a fragile cryptosystem","domain":"blog.trailofbits.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography","application_security"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-04","inductedMonth":"2024-09","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.216,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":708,"evidenceRank":657,"evidenceScore":67.8,"freshAt":"2022-04-01T15:47:46Z","freshnessRank":797,"freshEventScore":163,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 708 pts / 341 comments (2019) + 163 pts / 101 comments (2022), different submitters and 998 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":708,"peak_comments":341,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20381779","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":165,"peak_comments":113,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25022845","height":8,"chart_height":40},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":163,"peak_comments":101,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30879442","height":8,"chart_height":39},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41632917","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/rsa-is-a-fragile-cryptosystem-d9d0235e447c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/rsa-is-a-fragile-cryptosystem-d9d0235e447c/"},{"slug":"a-computer-science-study-plan-to-become-a-software-engineer-d9d023565af0","title":"A computer science study plan to become a software engineer","domain":"github.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["learning_methods","careers","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-12","inductedMonth":"2022-04","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":9.147,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":374,"evidenceRank":658,"evidenceScore":67.8,"freshAt":"2020-12-16T17:35:14Z","freshnessRank":965,"freshEventScore":374,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 374 pts / 217 comments (2020) + 270 pts / 53 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,101 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":270,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15898263","height":13,"chart_height":123},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":374,"peak_comments":217,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25445493","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33802135","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40055848","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47975764","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-computer-science-study-plan-to-become-a-software-engineer-d9d023565af0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-computer-science-study-plan-to-become-a-software-engineer-d9d023565af0/"},{"slug":"beautiful-racket-2016-d9d02353a615","title":"Beautiful Racket (2016)","domain":"beautifulracket.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","compilers_runtimes","teaching"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2022-05","inductedMonth":"2022-05","submissions":11,"submitters":9,"spanYears":9.569,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":537,"evidenceRank":659,"evidenceScore":67.8,"freshAt":"2022-05-12T16:41:32Z","freshnessRank":782,"freshEventScore":158,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 537 pts / 58 comments (2017) + 158 pts / 11 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,883 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12886530","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":537,"peak_comments":58,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13881535","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19125073","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":158,"peak_comments":11,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31356537","height":8,"chart_height":50},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41801004","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46288431","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/beautiful-racket-2016-d9d02353a615.jpg","path":"/hall/link/beautiful-racket-2016-d9d02353a615/"},{"slug":"email-and-git-3-d9d0235d580a","title":"Email and Git = <3","domain":"git-send-email.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source","online_communities"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-10","inductedMonth":"2023-10","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":6.152,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":289,"evidenceRank":660,"evidenceScore":67.8,"freshAt":"2023-10-12T09:16:14Z","freshnessRank":525,"freshEventScore":289,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 289 pts / 255 comments (2023) + 170 pts / 71 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,651 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":170,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19574257","height":8,"chart_height":100},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24938130","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26274804","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33412331","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":289,"peak_comments":255,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37854995","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44119887","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/email-and-git-3-d9d0235d580a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/email-and-git-3-d9d0235d580a/"},{"slug":"sqlite-as-an-application-file-format-2014-d9d023517620","title":"SQLite as an Application File Format (2014)","domain":"sqlite.org","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"technical_report","typeDisplay":"Technical reports","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["databases_storage","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2020-06","inductedMonth":"2025-11","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":10.16,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":567,"evidenceRank":661,"evidenceScore":67.7,"freshAt":"2025-11-28T08:15:50Z","freshnessRank":112,"freshEventScore":178,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 567 pts / 301 comments (2020) + 178 pts / 99 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,993 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10308691","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":211,"peak_comments":161,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18754634","height":10,"chart_height":63},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":567,"peak_comments":301,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23508923","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":178,"peak_comments":99,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46076642","height":9,"chart_height":53},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/sqlite-as-an-application-file-format-2014-d9d023517620.jpg","path":"/hall/link/sqlite-as-an-application-file-format-2014-d9d023517620/"},{"slug":"adnauseam-fight-back-against-advertising-networks-and-privacy-ab-d9d0235599d7","title":"AdNauseam: Fight Back Against Advertising Networks and Privacy Abuse","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["privacy_surveillance","browsers_web_standards","application_security"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-09","inductedMonth":"2024-12","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":8.025,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":281,"evidenceRank":662,"evidenceScore":67.7,"freshAt":"2023-08-23T01:44:26Z","freshnessRank":564,"freshEventScore":196,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 281 pts / 276 comments (2016) + 196 pts / 152 comments (2023), different submitters and 2,436 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":281,"peak_comments":276,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13222733","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":207,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20048216","height":10,"chart_height":125},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28441930","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":196,"peak_comments":152,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37230898","height":9,"chart_height":119},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42543179","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/adnauseam-fight-back-against-advertising-networks-and-privacy-ab-d9d0235599d7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/adnauseam-fight-back-against-advertising-networks-and-privacy-ab-d9d0235599d7/"},{"slug":"simple-dynamic-strings-library-for-c-d9d0234bec6f","title":"Simple Dynamic Strings library for C","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2019-12","inductedMonth":"2021-06","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":11.548,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":214,"evidenceRank":663,"evidenceScore":67.7,"freshAt":"2025-08-25T15:27:59Z","freshnessRank":162,"freshEventScore":111,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 214 pts / 127 comments (2014) + 107 pts / 83 comments (2019), different submitters and 2,125 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":214,"peak_comments":127,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7190664","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13312548","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18135432","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":107,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21692400","height":5,"chart_height":85},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27595645","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":111,"peak_comments":47,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45014911","height":5,"chart_height":88},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/simple-dynamic-strings-library-for-c-d9d0234bec6f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/simple-dynamic-strings-library-for-c-d9d0234bec6f/"},{"slug":"to-remember-everything-you-learn-surrender-to-this-algorithm-200-d9d023596a81","title":"To Remember Everything You Learn, Surrender to This Algorithm (2008)","domain":"www.wired.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"interview_profile","typeDisplay":"Interviews & profiles","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["learning_methods","personal_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-08","inductedMonth":"2021-08","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":6.899,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":740,"evidenceRank":664,"evidenceScore":67.7,"freshAt":"2024-12-27T09:23:19Z","freshnessRank":276,"freshEventScore":30,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 740 pts / 208 comments (2018) + 215 pts / 110 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,105 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":740,"peak_comments":208,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17706776","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24737918","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":215,"peak_comments":110,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28200913","height":10,"chart_height":49},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":30,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42520942","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/to-remember-everything-you-learn-surrender-to-this-algorithm-200-d9d023596a81.jpg","path":"/hall/link/to-remember-everything-you-learn-surrender-to-this-algorithm-200-d9d023596a81/"},{"slug":"free-python-ebook-bayesian-methods-for-hackers-d9d0234871fc","title":"Free Python ebook: Bayesian Methods for Hackers","domain":"github.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["machine_learning","data_science","mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2020-01","inductedMonth":"2020-01","submissions":9,"submitters":8,"spanYears":11.003,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":395,"evidenceRank":665,"evidenceScore":67.7,"freshAt":"2020-01-12T22:00:06Z","freshnessRank":1027,"freshEventScore":188,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 395 pts / 50 comments (2013) + 188 pts / 17 comments (2020), different submitters and 2,413 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":395,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5817713","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10838059","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17842940","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18958810","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":188,"peak_comments":17,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22029823","height":9,"chart_height":81},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32373136","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39325626","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/free-python-ebook-bayesian-methods-for-hackers-d9d0234871fc.jpg","path":"/hall/link/free-python-ebook-bayesian-methods-for-hackers-d9d0234871fc/"},{"slug":"that-s-a-lot-of-yaml-d9d0235f4aee","title":"That's a Lot of YAML","domain":"noyaml.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["data_engineering","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-09","inductedMonth":"2025-04","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.478,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":429,"evidenceRank":666,"evidenceScore":67.7,"freshAt":"2025-04-10T21:38:15Z","freshnessRank":225,"freshEventScore":82,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 152 pts / 147 comments (2021) + 82 pts / 55 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,261 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21295851","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24638883","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":152,"peak_comments":147,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29019361","height":7,"chart_height":60},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":429,"peak_comments":478,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37687060","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":82,"peak_comments":55,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43648263","height":4,"chart_height":32},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/that-s-a-lot-of-yaml-d9d0235f4aee.jpg","path":"/hall/link/that-s-a-lot-of-yaml-d9d0235f4aee/"},{"slug":"is-it-pokemon-or-big-data-2016-d9d02351f97f","title":"Is it Pokemon or Big Data? (2016)","domain":"pixelastic.github.io","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"computer_game","typeDisplay":"Computer games","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_design","indie_games"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2021-04","inductedMonth":"2021-04","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":8.912,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":387,"evidenceRank":667,"evidenceScore":67.6,"freshAt":"2021-04-11T06:05:08Z","freshnessRank":926,"freshEventScore":387,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 387 pts / 67 comments (2021) + 168 pts / 23 comments (2018), different submitters and 983 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":57,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10622752","height":4,"chart_height":25},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14711466","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":168,"peak_comments":23,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17660883","height":8,"chart_height":74},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25037755","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":387,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26767835","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41913023","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/is-it-pokemon-or-big-data-2016-d9d02351f97f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/is-it-pokemon-or-big-data-2016-d9d02351f97f/"},{"slug":"storing-utc-is-not-a-silver-bullet-d9d0235d4241","title":"Storing UTC is not a silver bullet","domain":"codeblog.jonskeet.uk","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","performance_reliability","databases_storage"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-03","inductedMonth":"2022-03","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.325,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":304,"evidenceRank":668,"evidenceScore":67.6,"freshAt":"2024-07-23T07:24:22Z","freshnessRank":358,"freshEventScore":46,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 243 pts / 184 comments (2022) + 304 pts / 162 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,081 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":304,"peak_comments":162,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19500640","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24685984","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26681275","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":243,"peak_comments":184,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30659164","height":12,"chart_height":136},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":46,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41043499","height":4,"chart_height":26},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/storing-utc-is-not-a-silver-bullet-d9d0235d4241.jpg","path":"/hall/link/storing-utc-is-not-a-silver-bullet-d9d0235d4241/"},{"slug":"learn-rust-by-writing-a-small-os-d9d02357c243","title":"Learn Rust by writing a small OS","domain":"os.phil-opp.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["operating_systems","programming_languages","computer_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2025-07","inductedMonth":"2025-07","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":7.989,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":534,"evidenceRank":669,"evidenceScore":67.6,"freshAt":"2025-07-30T12:01:10Z","freshnessRank":181,"freshEventScore":135,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 534 pts / 80 comments (2022) + 135 pts / 10 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,250 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":86,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14916749","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18388683","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":40,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19955109","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26102947","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":534,"peak_comments":80,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30467572","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37270344","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40017116","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":135,"peak_comments":10,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44733094","height":6,"chart_height":43},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/learn-rust-by-writing-a-small-os-d9d02357c243.jpg","path":"/hall/link/learn-rust-by-writing-a-small-os-d9d02357c243/"},{"slug":"visual-information-theory-2015-d9d0235196c2","title":"Visual Information Theory (2015)","domain":"colah.github.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["theory_of_computation","mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-07","inductedMonth":"2022-07","submissions":9,"submitters":8,"spanYears":10.653,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":543,"evidenceRank":670,"evidenceScore":67.6,"freshAt":"2019-07-24T12:59:51Z","freshnessRank":1054,"freshEventScore":543,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 543 pts / 45 comments (2019) + 151 pts / 21 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,378 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":151,"peak_comments":21,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10388799","height":7,"chart_height":47},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13918282","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":543,"peak_comments":45,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20514755","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32251490","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36066003","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45867840","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46810867","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/visual-information-theory-2015-d9d0235196c2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/visual-information-theory-2015-d9d0235196c2/"},{"slug":"cunningham-s-law-d9d0234c3906","title":"Cunningham's Law","domain":"meta.wikimedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["internet_culture","online_communities"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2022-03","inductedMonth":"2022-03","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":11.88,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":285,"evidenceRank":671,"evidenceScore":67.6,"freshAt":"2022-03-02T00:53:08Z","freshnessRank":818,"freshEventScore":159,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 285 pts / 107 comments (2014) + 159 pts / 74 comments (2022), different submitters and 2,915 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":285,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7364997","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11666344","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18654216","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28220347","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":159,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30522205","height":8,"chart_height":95},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42458020","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45128126","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46736260","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/cunningham-s-law-d9d0234c3906.jpg","path":"/hall/link/cunningham-s-law-d9d0234c3906/"},{"slug":"up-a-tool-for-writing-linux-pipes-with-instant-live-preview-d9d0235bd50e","title":"UP: A tool for writing Linux pipes with instant live preview","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-03","inductedMonth":"2023-07","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":5.99,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":485,"evidenceRank":672,"evidenceScore":67.6,"freshAt":"2021-03-31T06:28:36Z","freshnessRank":930,"freshEventScore":485,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 484 pts / 217 comments (2018) + 485 pts / 83 comments (2021), different submitters and 888 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":484,"peak_comments":217,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18291302","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":485,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26644110","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33317944","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36707204","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41898045","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/up-a-tool-for-writing-linux-pipes-with-instant-live-preview-d9d0235bd50e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/up-a-tool-for-writing-linux-pipes-with-instant-live-preview-d9d0235bd50e/"},{"slug":"your-lifestyle-has-already-been-designed-2010-d9d02342668b","title":"Your Lifestyle Has Already Been Designed (2010)","domain":"www.raptitude.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["social_issues","economics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2021-07","inductedMonth":"2021-07","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":10.508,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":350,"evidenceRank":673,"evidenceScore":67.5,"freshAt":"2021-07-31T03:47:39Z","freshnessRank":888,"freshEventScore":350,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 350 pts / 247 comments (2021) + 227 pts / 121 comments (2013), different submitters and 3,085 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2149377","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":227,"peak_comments":121,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5235214","height":11,"chart_height":110},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7015225","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17384938","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":350,"peak_comments":247,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28015101","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/your-lifestyle-has-already-been-designed-2010-d9d02342668b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/your-lifestyle-has-already-been-designed-2010-d9d02342668b/"},{"slug":"openwrt-a-linux-os-targeting-embedded-devices-d9d0234e1e79","title":"OpenWrt: A Linux OS targeting embedded devices","domain":"openwrt.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","embedded_iot","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2024-12","inductedMonth":"2025-09","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":10.93,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":271,"evidenceRank":674,"evidenceScore":67.5,"freshAt":"2025-09-08T16:13:10Z","freshnessRank":148,"freshEventScore":271,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 271 pts / 185 comments (2025) + 143 pts / 63 comments (2023), different submitters and 811 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8410143","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10203544","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25586089","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":143,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36398418","height":7,"chart_height":90},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":127,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42345500","height":6,"chart_height":80},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":271,"peak_comments":185,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45170087","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/openwrt-a-linux-os-targeting-embedded-devices-d9d0234e1e79.jpg","path":"/hall/link/openwrt-a-linux-os-targeting-embedded-devices-d9d0234e1e79/"},{"slug":"wealth-shown-to-a-pixel-scale-d9d023614f3d","title":"Wealth Shown to a Pixel Scale","domain":"mkorostoff.github.io","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["economics","social_issues"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-02","inductedMonth":"2023-10","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":4.739,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":158,"evidenceRank":675,"evidenceScore":67.5,"freshAt":"2023-10-20T13:09:16Z","freshnessRank":511,"freshEventScore":158,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 158 pts / 215 comments (2023) + 107 pts / 138 comments (2021), different submitters and 802 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22998347","height":5,"chart_height":109},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":107,"peak_comments":138,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28112698","height":5,"chart_height":115},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":158,"peak_comments":215,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37955501","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42796091","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/wealth-shown-to-a-pixel-scale-d9d023614f3d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/wealth-shown-to-a-pixel-scale-d9d023614f3d/"},{"slug":"dead-man-s-switch-d9d0233ee039","title":"Dead Man's Switch","domain":"www.deadmansswitch.net","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["privacy_surveillance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2024-03","inductedMonth":"2024-03","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":15.515,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":149,"evidenceRank":676,"evidenceScore":67.5,"freshAt":"2024-03-24T08:33:23Z","freshnessRank":427,"freshEventScore":38,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 149 pts / 127 comments (2016) + 38 pts / 50 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,728 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":42,"peak_comments":31,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=307584","height":4,"chart_height":48},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2897132","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3833509","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":149,"peak_comments":127,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12628069","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18328229","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33866678","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":38,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39805834","height":4,"chart_height":43},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/dead-man-s-switch-d9d0233ee039.jpg","path":"/hall/link/dead-man-s-switch-d9d0233ee039/"},{"slug":"the-history-of-utf-8-as-told-by-rob-pike-2003-d9d0233f7daa","title":"The history of UTF-8 as told by Rob Pike (2003)","domain":"doc.cat-v.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2025-09","inductedMonth":"2025-09","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":16.389,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":244,"evidenceRank":677,"evidenceScore":67.5,"freshAt":"2025-09-13T08:56:00Z","freshnessRank":146,"freshEventScore":101,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 244 pts / 116 comments (2021) + 101 pts / 36 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,619 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":48,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=577116","height":4,"chart_height":33},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":47,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2410462","height":4,"chart_height":33},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6502389","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22628932","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":244,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26735958","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36832199","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45230515","height":5,"chart_height":70},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-history-of-utf-8-as-told-by-rob-pike-2003-d9d0233f7daa.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-history-of-utf-8-as-told-by-rob-pike-2003-d9d0233f7daa/"},{"slug":"automerge-json-like-data-structure-for-building-collaborative-ap-d9d023596f48","title":"Automerge: JSON-like data structure for building collaborative apps","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["distributed_systems","databases_storage","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2022-02","inductedMonth":"2022-02","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":6.85,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":409,"evidenceRank":678,"evidenceScore":67.4,"freshAt":"2022-02-21T06:35:17Z","freshnessRank":821,"freshEventScore":274,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 409 pts / 98 comments (2018) + 274 pts / 69 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,476 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":409,"peak_comments":98,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16309533","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20009533","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22529211","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29507610","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":274,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30412550","height":13,"chart_height":114},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39425958","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/automerge-json-like-data-structure-for-building-collaborative-ap-d9d023596f48.jpg","path":"/hall/link/automerge-json-like-data-structure-for-building-collaborative-ap-d9d023596f48/"},{"slug":"amit-s-game-programming-information-d9d023407455","title":"Amit's Game Programming Information","domain":"www-cs-students.stanford.edu","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_development","game_design","algorithms_data_structures"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2017-02","inductedMonth":"2017-02","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":11.211,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":317,"evidenceRank":679,"evidenceScore":67.4,"freshAt":"2017-02-19T19:52:53Z","freshnessRank":1135,"freshEventScore":213,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 317 pts / 29 comments (2014) + 213 pts / 13 comments (2017), different submitters and 914 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1074331","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3410894","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6260608","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":317,"peak_comments":29,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8200160","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10306087","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":213,"peak_comments":13,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13681605","height":10,"chart_height":114},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26780575","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/amit-s-game-programming-information-d9d023407455.jpg","path":"/hall/link/amit-s-game-programming-information-d9d023407455/"},{"slug":"lit-simple-fast-web-components-d9d02365144b","title":"Lit: Simple. Fast. Web Components","domain":"lit.dev","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","browsers_web_standards","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2025-09","inductedMonth":"2025-09","submissions":10,"submitters":9,"spanYears":4.37,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":280,"evidenceRank":680,"evidenceScore":67.3,"freshAt":"2025-09-03T06:14:22Z","freshnessRank":155,"freshEventScore":280,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 280 pts / 177 comments (2025) + 211 pts / 141 comments (2023), different submitters and 775 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26891866","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29813416","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":211,"peak_comments":141,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36806747","height":10,"chart_height":128},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41879981","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":280,"peak_comments":177,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45112720","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/lit-simple-fast-web-components-d9d02365144b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/lit-simple-fast-web-components-d9d02365144b/"},{"slug":"algorithms-and-data-structures-explained-and-implemented-in-java-d9d0235a6c5f","title":"Algorithms and Data Structures Explained and Implemented in JavaScript","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["algorithms_data_structures","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-10","inductedMonth":"2021-10","submissions":10,"submitters":9,"spanYears":4.879,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":483,"evidenceRank":681,"evidenceScore":67.3,"freshAt":"2023-04-07T08:09:33Z","freshnessRank":640,"freshEventScore":183,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 483 pts / 43 comments (2018) + 183 pts / 76 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,779 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":5,"peak_score":483,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17134831","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21778356","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25134424","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":115,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28933618","height":6,"chart_height":40},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":183,"peak_comments":76,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35479378","height":9,"chart_height":64},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/algorithms-and-data-structures-explained-and-implemented-in-java-d9d0235a6c5f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/algorithms-and-data-structures-explained-and-implemented-in-java-d9d0235a6c5f/"},{"slug":"gokrazy-a-pure-go-userland-for-raspberry-pi-3-appliances-d9d02358ab02","title":"Gokrazy: A pure-Go userland for Raspberry Pi 3 appliances","domain":"gokrazy.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","embedded_iot","programming_languages","application_security"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2022-01","inductedMonth":"2023-10","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.108,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":366,"evidenceRank":682,"evidenceScore":67.3,"freshAt":"2023-12-19T05:23:20Z","freshnessRank":479,"freshEventScore":262,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 366 pts / 87 comments (2018) + 262 pts / 101 comments (2023), different submitters and 2,094 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15666140","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":366,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16672866","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26768748","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":160,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29959193","height":8,"chart_height":74},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":262,"peak_comments":101,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38692167","height":13,"chart_height":122},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/gokrazy-a-pure-go-userland-for-raspberry-pi-3-appliances-d9d02358ab02.jpg","path":"/hall/link/gokrazy-a-pure-go-userland-for-raspberry-pi-3-appliances-d9d02358ab02/"},{"slug":"what-s-functional-programming-all-about-d9d02355ed7d","title":"What's Functional Programming All About?","domain":"www.lihaoyi.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["programming_languages","software_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2024-09","inductedMonth":"2024-09","submissions":10,"submitters":7,"spanYears":7.608,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":341,"evidenceRank":683,"evidenceScore":67.3,"freshAt":"2024-09-04T18:04:51Z","freshnessRank":335,"freshEventScore":161,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 161 pts / 153 comments (2024) + 341 pts / 139 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,561 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":7,"peak_score":341,"peak_comments":139,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15138429","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20759260","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25753449","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":161,"peak_comments":153,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41448664","height":8,"chart_height":80},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-s-functional-programming-all-about-d9d02355ed7d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-s-functional-programming-all-about-d9d02355ed7d/"},{"slug":"nncp-lossless-data-compression-with-neural-networks-2019-d9d0235d5c41","title":"NNCP: Lossless Data Compression with Neural Networks (2019)","domain":"bellard.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["machine_learning","data_engineering","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2021-05","inductedMonth":"2022-09","submissions":14,"submitters":12,"spanYears":5.736,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":397,"evidenceRank":684,"evidenceScore":67.3,"freshAt":"2021-05-22T06:15:01Z","freshnessRank":907,"freshEventScore":397,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 397 pts / 160 comments (2021) + 214 pts / 33 comments (2019), different submitters and 776 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":214,"peak_comments":33,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19589848","height":10,"chart_height":92},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":397,"peak_comments":160,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27244004","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":4,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33419142","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38413288","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42553977","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/nncp-lossless-data-compression-with-neural-networks-2019-d9d0235d5c41.jpg","path":"/hall/link/nncp-lossless-data-compression-with-neural-networks-2019-d9d0235d5c41/"},{"slug":"typing-the-technical-interview-d9d02356aeab","title":"Typing the technical interview","domain":"aphyr.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["hiring_interviews","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2022-11","inductedMonth":"2022-11","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":8.06,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":413,"evidenceRank":685,"evidenceScore":67.2,"freshAt":"2022-11-02T16:41:13Z","freshnessRank":695,"freshEventScore":123,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 413 pts / 80 comments (2017) + 123 pts / 32 comments (2022), different submitters and 2,032 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":413,"peak_comments":80,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14078852","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":26,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21799125","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28607799","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":123,"peak_comments":32,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33438726","height":6,"chart_height":51},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40351345","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43870470","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/typing-the-technical-interview-d9d02356aeab.jpg","path":"/hall/link/typing-the-technical-interview-d9d02356aeab/"},{"slug":"great-vowel-shift-d9d0234e35a1","title":"Great Vowel Shift","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["language_linguistics","history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2021-04","inductedMonth":"2021-04","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":9.068,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":259,"evidenceRank":686,"evidenceScore":67.2,"freshAt":"2021-04-14T15:11:08Z","freshnessRank":924,"freshEventScore":259,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 259 pts / 268 comments (2021) + 129 pts / 117 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,103 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8454895","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14181822","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":129,"peak_comments":117,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16774428","height":6,"chart_height":85},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21801582","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":259,"peak_comments":268,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26808203","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38196694","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/great-vowel-shift-d9d0234e35a1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/great-vowel-shift-d9d0234e35a1/"},{"slug":"dsxyliea-d9d02352e49c","title":"Dsxyliea","domain":"geon.github.io","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"medicine_health","topicDisplay":"Medicine & health","tags":["neuroscience","learning_methods","human_computer_interaction"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-11","inductedMonth":"2020-07","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.361,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1356,"evidenceRank":687,"evidenceScore":67.1,"freshAt":"2020-07-13T02:40:58Z","freshnessRank":999,"freshEventScore":428,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1356 pts / 200 comments (2016) + 428 pts / 181 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,592 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1356,"peak_comments":200,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11218677","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":465,"peak_comments":176,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15226676","height":22,"chart_height":58},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21833817","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":428,"peak_comments":181,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23816678","height":21,"chart_height":54},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/dsxyliea-d9d02352e49c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/dsxyliea-d9d02352e49c/"},{"slug":"ulid-universally-unique-lexicographically-sortable-identifier-d9d0235b5a8f","title":"ULID: Universally Unique Lexicographically Sortable Identifier","domain":"github.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"standard_specification","typeDisplay":"Standards & specifications","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["databases_storage","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2024-07","inductedMonth":"2024-07","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":7.806,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":238,"evidenceRank":688,"evidenceScore":67.1,"freshAt":"2024-07-14T05:06:28Z","freshnessRank":363,"freshEventScore":107,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 238 pts / 129 comments (2018) + 107 pts / 57 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,025 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":238,"peak_comments":129,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18768909","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27101512","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34053882","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36478967","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":107,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40958959","height":5,"chart_height":76},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48635207","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/ulid-universally-unique-lexicographically-sortable-identifier-d9d0235b5a8f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/ulid-universally-unique-lexicographically-sortable-identifier-d9d0235b5a8f/"},{"slug":"how-the-blog-broke-the-web-d9d0235acbb1","title":"How the Blog Broke the Web","domain":"stackingthebricks.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["internet_culture","web_development","online_communities"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2023-01","inductedMonth":"2023-01","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":4.545,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":230,"evidenceRank":689,"evidenceScore":67.1,"freshAt":"2023-01-15T08:19:45Z","freshnessRank":669,"freshEventScore":191,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 230 pts / 128 comments (2018) + 191 pts / 116 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,653 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":230,"peak_comments":128,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17470426","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23710890","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26741967","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30644130","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":191,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34387754","height":9,"chart_height":141},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-the-blog-broke-the-web-d9d0235acbb1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-the-blog-broke-the-web-d9d0235acbb1/"},{"slug":"it-turns-out-d9d02340a456","title":"“It turns out”","domain":"jsomers.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["writing_craft"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2020-12","inductedMonth":"2026-03","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":16.003,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":328,"evidenceRank":690,"evidenceScore":67.1,"freshAt":"2026-03-04T14:52:46Z","freshnessRank":51,"freshEventScore":328,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 328 pts / 91 comments (2026) + 257 pts / 63 comments (2010), different submitters and 5,845 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":257,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1162965","height":12,"chart_height":133},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":122,"peak_comments":29,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25556578","height":6,"chart_height":63},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43445810","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":328,"peak_comments":91,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47248319","height":16,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/it-turns-out-d9d02340a456.jpg","path":"/hall/link/it-turns-out-d9d02340a456/"},{"slug":"c-compiler-from-scratch-d9d0235fefae","title":"C Compiler from Scratch","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["compilers_runtimes","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2026-03","inductedMonth":"2026-03","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":6.251,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":484,"evidenceRank":691,"evidenceScore":67.1,"freshAt":"2026-03-24T23:44:47Z","freshnessRank":38,"freshEventScore":134,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 484 pts / 66 comments (2020) + 134 pts / 19 comments (2026), different submitters and 2,269 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21861401","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":484,"peak_comments":66,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21968420","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32280387","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42467860","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45708346","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":134,"peak_comments":19,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47511208","height":6,"chart_height":47}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/c-compiler-from-scratch-d9d0235fefae.jpg","path":"/hall/link/c-compiler-from-scratch-d9d0235fefae/"},{"slug":"don-t-end-the-week-with-nothing-2014-d9d0234be651","title":"Don't End the Week with Nothing (2014)","domain":"training.kalzumeus.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["careers","personal_productivity","startups_entrepreneurship"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2021-03","inductedMonth":"2021-03","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":8.821,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":824,"evidenceRank":692,"evidenceScore":67.1,"freshAt":"2021-03-21T15:50:57Z","freshnessRank":933,"freshEventScore":824,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 824 pts / 269 comments (2021) + 456 pts / 101 comments (2014), different submitters and 2,601 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":456,"peak_comments":101,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7179098","height":22,"chart_height":94},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10578506","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13191410","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15897745","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":824,"peak_comments":269,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26531297","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33811033","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/don-t-end-the-week-with-nothing-2014-d9d0234be651.jpg","path":"/hall/link/don-t-end-the-week-with-nothing-2014-d9d0234be651/"},{"slug":"technical-papers-every-programmer-should-read-at-least-twice-d9d023440421","title":"Technical Papers Every Programmer Should Read (At Least Twice)","domain":"blog.fogus.me","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2016-08","inductedMonth":"2016-10","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":9.867,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":467,"evidenceRank":693,"evidenceScore":67.0,"freshAt":"2016-12-01T21:36:59Z","freshnessRank":1144,"freshEventScore":66,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 467 pts / 57 comments (2011) + 366 pts / 66 comments (2014), different submitters and 1,197 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":467,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2979458","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":366,"peak_comments":66,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8775375","height":18,"chart_height":133},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":4,"peak_score":66,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13083766","height":4,"chart_height":24},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27921834","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/technical-papers-every-programmer-should-read-at-least-twice-d9d023440421.jpg","path":"/hall/link/technical-papers-every-programmer-should-read-at-least-twice-d9d023440421/"},{"slug":"why-kakoune-the-quest-for-a-better-code-editor-d9d02355865d","title":"Why Kakoune – The quest for a better code editor","domain":"kakoune.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","human_computer_interaction"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-11","inductedMonth":"2023-06","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":6.519,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":631,"evidenceRank":694,"evidenceScore":67.0,"freshAt":"2023-06-21T20:50:48Z","freshnessRank":606,"freshEventScore":179,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 631 pts / 327 comments (2016) + 179 pts / 89 comments (2023), different submitters and 2,381 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":631,"peak_comments":327,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13165919","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":145,"peak_comments":45,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17781780","height":7,"chart_height":39},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25450025","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28167236","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":179,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36424256","height":9,"chart_height":48},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-kakoune-the-quest-for-a-better-code-editor-d9d02355865d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-kakoune-the-quest-for-a-better-code-editor-d9d02355865d/"},{"slug":"why-software-projects-take-longer-than-you-think-a-statistical-m-d9d0235d73d7","title":"Why software projects take longer than you think – a statistical model","domain":"erikbern.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["management_strategy","mathematics","labor_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-07","inductedMonth":"2023-07","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.244,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":700,"evidenceRank":695,"evidenceScore":67.0,"freshAt":"2023-07-14T07:30:51Z","freshnessRank":592,"freshEventScore":185,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 700 pts / 317 comments (2019) + 185 pts / 173 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,550 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":700,"peak_comments":317,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19671673","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25316479","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":277,"peak_comments":131,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26366112","height":13,"chart_height":67},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":185,"peak_comments":173,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36720573","height":9,"chart_height":45},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-software-projects-take-longer-than-you-think-a-statistical-m-d9d0235d73d7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-software-projects-take-longer-than-you-think-a-statistical-m-d9d0235d73d7/"},{"slug":"elastic-tab-stops-2017-d9d02356fe53","title":"Elastic Tab Stops (2017)","domain":"nickgravgaard.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","user_experience","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2023-10","inductedMonth":"2023-10","submissions":13,"submitters":11,"spanYears":6.434,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":210,"evidenceRank":696,"evidenceScore":67.0,"freshAt":"2023-10-18T19:11:51Z","freshnessRank":513,"freshEventScore":49,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 210 pts / 113 comments (2018) + 49 pts / 60 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,906 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15277395","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":210,"peak_comments":113,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17643629","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27986386","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":27,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31477853","height":4,"chart_height":22},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":49,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37933316","height":4,"chart_height":40},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/elastic-tab-stops-2017-d9d02356fe53.jpg","path":"/hall/link/elastic-tab-stops-2017-d9d02356fe53/"},{"slug":"animated-knots-d9d0235df457","title":"Animated Knots","domain":"www.animatedknots.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-09","inductedMonth":"2026-02","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.664,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":702,"evidenceRank":697,"evidenceScore":67.0,"freshAt":"2026-02-02T13:18:05Z","freshnessRank":68,"freshEventScore":345,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 702 pts / 104 comments (2023) + 345 pts / 49 comments (2026), different submitters and 885 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20106470","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23987755","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":237,"peak_comments":94,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26466443","height":11,"chart_height":57},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":702,"peak_comments":104,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37346115","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":345,"peak_comments":49,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46855697","height":17,"chart_height":84}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/animated-knots-d9d0235df457.jpg","path":"/hall/link/animated-knots-d9d0235df457/"},{"slug":"guidelines-for-brutalist-web-design-d9d0235ad99f","title":"Guidelines for Brutalist Web Design","domain":"brutalist-web.design","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"policy_guidelines","typeDisplay":"Policies & guidelines","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design","user_experience","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2023-05","inductedMonth":"2023-05","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":7.54,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":730,"evidenceRank":698,"evidenceScore":67.0,"freshAt":"2023-05-02T03:54:30Z","freshnessRank":637,"freshEventScore":224,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 730 pts / 312 comments (2018) + 224 pts / 116 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,759 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":730,"peak_comments":312,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17478133","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26762874","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32797493","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":224,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35783189","height":11,"chart_height":52},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41118090","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46696750","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/guidelines-for-brutalist-web-design-d9d0235ad99f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/guidelines-for-brutalist-web-design-d9d0235ad99f/"},{"slug":"graphics-programming-black-book-by-michael-abrash-2001-d9d0234bd90a","title":"Graphics Programming Black Book by Michael Abrash (2001)","domain":"github.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["computer_graphics","computer_architecture","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2019-09","inductedMonth":"2022-11","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":8.805,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":307,"evidenceRank":699,"evidenceScore":66.9,"freshAt":"2021-01-15T10:27:33Z","freshnessRank":953,"freshEventScore":157,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 307 pts / 82 comments (2019) + 229 pts / 25 comments (2017), different submitters and 765 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":112,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7149973","height":5,"chart_height":62},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":229,"peak_comments":25,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14897512","height":11,"chart_height":127},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":307,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20883860","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":157,"peak_comments":42,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25789151","height":8,"chart_height":87},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33682491","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/graphics-programming-black-book-by-michael-abrash-2001-d9d0234bd90a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/graphics-programming-black-book-by-michael-abrash-2001-d9d0234bd90a/"},{"slug":"javascript-isn-t-scheme-d9d0234a0784","title":"JavaScript Isn't Scheme","domain":"journal.stuffwithstuff.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2018-04","inductedMonth":"2018-04","submissions":9,"submitters":6,"spanYears":12.63,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":197,"evidenceRank":700,"evidenceScore":66.9,"freshAt":"2018-04-25T19:05:26Z","freshnessRank":1099,"freshEventScore":84,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 197 pts / 108 comments (2013) + 84 pts / 51 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,741 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":197,"peak_comments":108,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6068360","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12944039","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14469383","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":84,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16924933","height":4,"chart_height":72},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21305731","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22026227","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47272615","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/javascript-isn-t-scheme-d9d0234a0784.jpg","path":"/hall/link/javascript-isn-t-scheme-d9d0234a0784/"},{"slug":"wikipedia-has-cancer-2017-d9d023585de6","title":"Wikipedia Has Cancer (2017)","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["management_strategy","economics","online_communities"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-03","inductedMonth":"2024-04","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.533,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":528,"evidenceRank":701,"evidenceScore":66.9,"freshAt":"2024-04-20T01:33:14Z","freshnessRank":417,"freshEventScore":110,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 528 pts / 310 comments (2019) + 150 pts / 121 comments (2017), different submitters and 786 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":150,"peak_comments":121,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15429067","height":7,"chart_height":48},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":528,"peak_comments":310,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21699011","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":41,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26498031","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":42,"peak_comments":15,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33405257","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":110,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40093801","height":5,"chart_height":35},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/wikipedia-has-cancer-2017-d9d023585de6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/wikipedia-has-cancer-2017-d9d023585de6/"},{"slug":"anki-memorization-with-spaced-learning-d9d023590f0f","title":"Anki: Memorization with Spaced Learning","domain":"apps.ankiweb.net","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["learning_methods","open_source","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2024-01","inductedMonth":"2024-01","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":8.496,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":636,"evidenceRank":702,"evidenceScore":66.9,"freshAt":"2024-01-28T06:35:03Z","freshnessRank":451,"freshEventScore":540,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 540 pts / 429 comments (2024) + 636 pts / 172 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,980 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16000639","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":636,"peak_comments":172,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17846356","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27448414","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31547324","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":540,"peak_comments":429,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39163094","height":24,"chart_height":144},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48643000","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/anki-memorization-with-spaced-learning-d9d023590f0f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/anki-memorization-with-spaced-learning-d9d023590f0f/"},{"slug":"the-tyranny-of-the-rocket-equation-2012-d9d02348ec0d","title":"The tyranny of the rocket equation (2012)","domain":"www.nasa.gov","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"space_transportation","topicDisplay":"Space & transportation","tags":["transportation"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2018-06","inductedMonth":"2022-09","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":9.44,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":214,"evidenceRank":703,"evidenceScore":66.9,"freshAt":"2022-09-04T13:37:49Z","freshnessRank":721,"freshEventScore":111,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 214 pts / 157 comments (2014) + 111 pts / 122 comments (2022), different submitters and 2,865 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5447746","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":214,"peak_comments":157,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8537390","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":91,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17425156","height":4,"chart_height":72},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":83,"peak_comments":45,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21391238","height":4,"chart_height":66},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":111,"peak_comments":122,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32712913","height":5,"chart_height":88},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/the-tyranny-of-the-rocket-equation-2012-d9d02348ec0d/"},{"slug":"how-i-reverse-engineered-google-docs-to-play-back-any-document-s-d9d0234e698f","title":"How I reverse-engineered Google Docs to play back any document's keystrokes","domain":"features.jsomers.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","human_computer_interaction"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2020-12","inductedMonth":"2020-12","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.141,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":501,"evidenceRank":704,"evidenceScore":66.9,"freshAt":"2020-12-26T18:35:54Z","freshnessRank":960,"freshEventScore":413,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 501 pts / 115 comments (2014) + 413 pts / 140 comments (2020), different submitters and 2,243 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":501,"peak_comments":115,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8562483","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":77,"peak_comments":17,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9686135","height":4,"chart_height":26},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15037177","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16112406","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20624921","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":413,"peak_comments":140,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25545361","height":20,"chart_height":140},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-i-reverse-engineered-google-docs-to-play-back-any-document-s-d9d0234e698f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-i-reverse-engineered-google-docs-to-play-back-any-document-s-d9d0234e698f/"},{"slug":"fibonacci-hashing-the-optimization-that-the-world-forgot-d9d0235aaaa8","title":"Fibonacci Hashing: The Optimization That the World Forgot","domain":"probablydance.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["algorithms_data_structures","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2023-04","inductedMonth":"2023-04","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.828,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":405,"evidenceRank":705,"evidenceScore":66.9,"freshAt":"2025-04-14T01:02:41Z","freshnessRank":222,"freshEventScore":143,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 405 pts / 75 comments (2018) + 204 pts / 63 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,776 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":405,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17328756","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22442891","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29218958","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":204,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35739629","height":10,"chart_height":86},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42044719","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":143,"peak_comments":29,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43677122","height":7,"chart_height":60},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/fibonacci-hashing-the-optimization-that-the-world-forgot-d9d0235aaaa8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/fibonacci-hashing-the-optimization-that-the-world-forgot-d9d0235aaaa8/"},{"slug":"the-state-of-building-user-interfaces-in-rust-d9d023618f3c","title":"The state of building user interfaces in Rust","domain":"areweguiyet.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2026-06","inductedMonth":"2026-06","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.064,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":205,"evidenceRank":706,"evidenceScore":66.8,"freshAt":"2026-06-10T16:44:23Z","freshnessRank":8,"freshEventScore":200,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 205 pts / 189 comments (2021) + 200 pts / 150 comments (2026), different submitters and 1,797 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":20,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23216683","height":4,"chart_height":17},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":205,"peak_comments":189,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27782337","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32329863","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39038579","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46006529","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":200,"peak_comments":150,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48479008","height":10,"chart_height":166}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-state-of-building-user-interfaces-in-rust-d9d023618f3c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-state-of-building-user-interfaces-in-rust-d9d023618f3c/"},{"slug":"jmap-a-much-needed-modern-email-open-standard-d9d0234bd54e","title":"JMAP – a much needed modern email open standard","domain":"jmap.io","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"standard_specification","typeDisplay":"Standards & specifications","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2019-08","inductedMonth":"2023-05","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":11.285,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1030,"evidenceRank":707,"evidenceScore":66.8,"freshAt":"2023-05-30T17:26:46Z","freshnessRank":621,"freshEventScore":1030,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1030 pts / 361 comments (2023) + 98 pts / 61 comments (2014), different submitters and 3,408 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":98,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7141152","height":5,"chart_height":16},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":116,"peak_comments":20,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14734091","height":6,"chart_height":19},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20830738","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":1030,"peak_comments":361,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36127703","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43971569","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/jmap-a-much-needed-modern-email-open-standard-d9d0234bd54e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/jmap-a-much-needed-modern-email-open-standard-d9d0234bd54e/"},{"slug":"semantic-ui-d9d0234a8bdf","title":"Semantic UI","domain":"semantic-ui.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","visual_design","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2017-04","inductedMonth":"2017-04","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":9.12,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":768,"evidenceRank":708,"evidenceScore":66.8,"freshAt":"2017-04-10T03:11:35Z","freshnessRank":1131,"freshEventScore":768,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 768 pts / 250 comments (2017) + 230 pts / 81 comments (2013), different submitters and 1,304 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":230,"peak_comments":81,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6381220","height":11,"chart_height":51},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8656947","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10159207","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":768,"peak_comments":250,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14075720","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24322961","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33364299","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/semantic-ui-d9d0234a8bdf.jpg","path":"/hall/link/semantic-ui-d9d0234a8bdf/"},{"slug":"purelymail-cheap-no-nonsense-email-d9d0235cd2a7","title":"Purelymail: Cheap, no-nonsense email","domain":"purelymail.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","privacy_surveillance","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2025-01","inductedMonth":"2025-01","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":5.96,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":606,"evidenceRank":709,"evidenceScore":66.8,"freshAt":"2025-01-27T02:38:25Z","freshnessRank":256,"freshEventScore":310,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 606 pts / 307 comments (2021) + 310 pts / 211 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,304 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19134881","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23567456","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":606,"peak_comments":307,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27707857","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33058691","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35318910","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":310,"peak_comments":211,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42836818","height":15,"chart_height":87},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/purelymail-cheap-no-nonsense-email-d9d0235cd2a7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/purelymail-cheap-no-nonsense-email-d9d0235cd2a7/"},{"slug":"why-van-halen-s-contract-calls-for-the-removal-of-all-brown-m-ms-d9d0233fd0b7","title":"Why Van Halen's contract calls for the removal of all brown M&Ms","domain":"www.snopes.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["music"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2014-05","inductedMonth":"2017-07","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":7.918,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":364,"evidenceRank":710,"evidenceScore":66.7,"freshAt":"2014-05-16T08:08:09Z","freshnessRank":1171,"freshEventScore":246,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 246 pts / 158 comments (2014) + 364 pts / 79 comments (2009), different submitters and 1,744 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":364,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=743860","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":184,"peak_comments":55,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2839581","height":9,"chart_height":86},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":246,"peak_comments":158,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7754334","height":12,"chart_height":115},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14709327","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-van-halen-s-contract-calls-for-the-removal-of-all-brown-m-ms-d9d0233fd0b7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-van-halen-s-contract-calls-for-the-removal-of-all-brown-m-ms-d9d0233fd0b7/"},{"slug":"beej-s-guide-to-c-programming-2007-d9d0234de40d","title":"Beej's Guide to C Programming (2007)","domain":"beej.us","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2023-03","inductedMonth":"2023-03","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":11.228,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":427,"evidenceRank":711,"evidenceScore":66.7,"freshAt":"2023-03-28T09:46:25Z","freshnessRank":641,"freshEventScore":115,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 427 pts / 79 comments (2017) + 115 pts / 36 comments (2023), different submitters and 2,027 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8295024","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10214087","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":427,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15198093","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26100391","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34074633","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":115,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35338074","height":6,"chart_height":46},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46118195","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/beej-s-guide-to-c-programming-2007-d9d0234de40d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/beej-s-guide-to-c-programming-2007-d9d0234de40d/"},{"slug":"get-your-work-recognized-write-a-brag-document-d9d0235e35bb","title":"Get your work recognized: write a brag document","domain":"jvns.ca","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["careers","workplace","personal_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-12","inductedMonth":"2023-12","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":7.028,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":347,"evidenceRank":712,"evidenceScore":66.7,"freshAt":"2023-12-31T17:58:48Z","freshnessRank":471,"freshEventScore":81,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 347 pts / 78 comments (2019) + 81 pts / 69 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,603 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":5,"peak_score":347,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20665225","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":20,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28612015","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":22,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32236407","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":81,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38826014","height":4,"chart_height":40},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48874198","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/get-your-work-recognized-write-a-brag-document-d9d0235e35bb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/get-your-work-recognized-write-a-brag-document-d9d0235e35bb/"},{"slug":"kakoune-code-editor-d9d02351c062","title":"Kakoune Code Editor","domain":"kakoune.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2022-01","inductedMonth":"2022-01","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":8.241,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":304,"evidenceRank":713,"evidenceScore":66.7,"freshAt":"2022-01-18T04:19:07Z","freshnessRank":833,"freshEventScore":304,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 304 pts / 170 comments (2022) + 143 pts / 34 comments (2015), different submitters and 2,270 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":143,"peak_comments":34,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10484653","height":7,"chart_height":80},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13923869","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18448795","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23127974","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27382122","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":304,"peak_comments":170,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29975052","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38131445","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39159848","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/kakoune-code-editor-d9d02351c062.jpg","path":"/hall/link/kakoune-code-editor-d9d02351c062/"},{"slug":"imhex-a-hex-editor-for-reverse-engineers-d9d02363b5fe","title":"Imhex: A hex editor for reverse engineers","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","application_security","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2024-06","inductedMonth":"2024-06","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":3.567,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":634,"evidenceRank":714,"evidenceScore":66.7,"freshAt":"2024-06-29T07:25:49Z","freshnessRank":369,"freshEventScore":634,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 634 pts / 133 comments (2024) + 314 pts / 78 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,298 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":314,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25353965","height":15,"chart_height":84},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":467,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32287902","height":22,"chart_height":125},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":634,"peak_comments":133,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40828493","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/imhex-a-hex-editor-for-reverse-engineers-d9d02363b5fe.jpg","path":"/hall/link/imhex-a-hex-editor-for-reverse-engineers-d9d02363b5fe/"},{"slug":"two-envelopes-problem-d9d0234162fd","title":"Two envelopes problem","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2022-05","inductedMonth":"2022-05","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":14.905,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":249,"evidenceRank":715,"evidenceScore":66.7,"freshAt":"2022-05-30T13:09:18Z","freshnessRank":775,"freshEventScore":249,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 249 pts / 300 comments (2022) + 112 pts / 88 comments (2010), different submitters and 4,314 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":112,"peak_comments":88,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1582219","height":5,"chart_height":76},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5325131","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8393151","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22125494","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":249,"peak_comments":300,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31558583","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39936091","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44445279","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/two-envelopes-problem-d9d0234162fd.jpg","path":"/hall/link/two-envelopes-problem-d9d0234162fd/"},{"slug":"dissolving-the-fermi-paradox-d9d0235aa2c0","title":"Dissolving the Fermi Paradox","domain":"arxiv.org","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"research_paper","typeDisplay":"Research papers","topic":"space_transportation","topicDisplay":"Space & transportation","tags":["space_astronomy","biology","scientific_method"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-05","inductedMonth":"2021-05","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":6.968,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":113,"evidenceRank":716,"evidenceScore":66.7,"freshAt":"2021-05-19T07:47:31Z","freshnessRank":910,"freshEventScore":50,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 113 pts / 126 comments (2018) + 50 pts / 71 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,070 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":113,"peak_comments":126,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17302924","height":5,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":6,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24786499","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":50,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27205742","height":4,"chart_height":75},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38568033","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44153633","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/dissolving-the-fermi-paradox-d9d0235aa2c0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/dissolving-the-fermi-paradox-d9d0235aa2c0/"},{"slug":"magic-the-gathering-is-turing-complete-d9d0235d84c2","title":"Magic: The Gathering is Turing Complete","domain":"arxiv.org","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"research_paper","typeDisplay":"Research papers","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["theory_of_computation","algorithms_data_structures"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-12","inductedMonth":"2023-12","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":6.946,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":192,"evidenceRank":717,"evidenceScore":66.7,"freshAt":"2023-12-14T20:35:54Z","freshnessRank":483,"freshEventScore":135,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 192 pts / 192 comments (2019) + 135 pts / 70 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,682 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":5,"peak_score":192,"peak_comments":192,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19847939","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29105081","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30502908","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":135,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38646892","height":6,"chart_height":120},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47626300","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/magic-the-gathering-is-turing-complete-d9d0235d84c2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/magic-the-gathering-is-turing-complete-d9d0235d84c2/"},{"slug":"the-dhall-configuration-language-d9d0235ccc7c","title":"The Dhall Configuration Language","domain":"dhall-lang.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools","software_architecture","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-07","inductedMonth":"2022-07","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.251,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":232,"evidenceRank":718,"evidenceScore":66.6,"freshAt":"2022-07-14T22:33:18Z","freshnessRank":749,"freshEventScore":232,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 232 pts / 188 comments (2022) + 193 pts / 177 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,106 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":193,"peak_comments":177,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20355405","height":9,"chart_height":141},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27032505","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":232,"peak_comments":188,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32102203","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41458638","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43947738","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-dhall-configuration-language-d9d0235ccc7c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-dhall-configuration-language-d9d0235ccc7c/"},{"slug":"the-z3-theorem-prover-released-under-mit-license-d9d0234fb3d7","title":"The Z3 Theorem Prover released under MIT license","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["theory_of_computation","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-06","inductedMonth":"2019-06","submissions":10,"submitters":6,"spanYears":10.71,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":304,"evidenceRank":719,"evidenceScore":66.6,"freshAt":"2025-12-10T10:00:41Z","freshnessRank":100,"freshEventScore":35,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 304 pts / 66 comments (2015) + 137 pts / 29 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,527 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":304,"peak_comments":66,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9272275","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14365975","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17782167","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":137,"peak_comments":29,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20067413","height":7,"chart_height":77},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26123086","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41880379","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":35,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46215982","height":4,"chart_height":20},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-z3-theorem-prover-released-under-mit-license-d9d0234fb3d7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-z3-theorem-prover-released-under-mit-license-d9d0234fb3d7/"},{"slug":"norvig-s-python-programs-to-practice-or-demonstrate-skills-d9d0235850c4","title":"Norvig's Python programs to practice or demonstrate skills","domain":"github.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["learning_methods","programming_languages","algorithms_data_structures"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-12","inductedMonth":"2021-12","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":5.886,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":937,"evidenceRank":720,"evidenceScore":66.6,"freshAt":"2023-08-23T20:41:01Z","freshnessRank":562,"freshEventScore":270,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 937 pts / 84 comments (2017) + 270 pts / 39 comments (2023), different submitters and 2,095 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":937,"peak_comments":84,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15787023","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16499487","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19329072","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":198,"peak_comments":13,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29699403","height":10,"chart_height":36},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":270,"peak_comments":39,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37241625","height":13,"chart_height":49},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/norvig-s-python-programs-to-practice-or-demonstrate-skills-d9d0235850c4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/norvig-s-python-programs-to-practice-or-demonstrate-skills-d9d0235850c4/"},{"slug":"a-first-person-shooter-in-571-lines-of-gnu-awk-2017-d9d023526417","title":"A first person shooter in 571 lines of GNU Awk (2017)","domain":"github.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"computer_game","typeDisplay":"Computer games","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2023-01","inductedMonth":"2023-01","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":7.017,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":514,"evidenceRank":721,"evidenceScore":66.6,"freshAt":"2023-01-19T16:55:10Z","freshnessRank":665,"freshEventScore":514,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 514 pts / 106 comments (2023) + 350 pts / 55 comments (2016), different submitters and 2,562 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":350,"peak_comments":55,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10896901","height":17,"chart_height":116},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14654226","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20851665","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25144644","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":514,"peak_comments":106,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34442528","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-first-person-shooter-in-571-lines-of-gnu-awk-2017-d9d023526417.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-first-person-shooter-in-571-lines-of-gnu-awk-2017-d9d023526417/"},{"slug":"the-control-group-is-out-of-control-2014-d9d0234cbc0b","title":"The control group is out of control (2014)","domain":"slatestarcodex.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["scientific_method","psychology"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2022-01","inductedMonth":"2023-09","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":12.222,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":184,"evidenceRank":722,"evidenceScore":66.6,"freshAt":"2022-01-22T17:28:41Z","freshnessRank":831,"freshEventScore":184,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 184 pts / 174 comments (2022) + 179 pts / 74 comments (2014), different submitters and 2,825 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":179,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7666575","height":9,"chart_height":165},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9050715","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11537095","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":184,"peak_comments":174,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30038749","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37573512","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44609404","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48972054","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-control-group-is-out-of-control-2014-d9d0234cbc0b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-control-group-is-out-of-control-2014-d9d0234cbc0b/"},{"slug":"a-closure-is-a-poor-man-s-object-an-object-is-a-poor-man-s-closu-d9d0233e345f","title":"“A closure is a poor man’s object; an object is a poor man’s closure” (2003)","domain":"people.csail.mit.edu","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"forum_discussion","typeDisplay":"Forum discussions","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2007,"candidateMonth":"2017-05","inductedMonth":"2017-05","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":14.393,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":289,"evidenceRank":723,"evidenceScore":66.6,"freshAt":"2017-05-01T01:55:04Z","freshnessRank":1128,"freshEventScore":289,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 289 pts / 227 comments (2017) + 132 pts / 38 comments (2010), different submitters and 2,582 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=67719","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":132,"peak_comments":38,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1241717","height":6,"chart_height":78},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2481285","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":86,"peak_comments":27,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9994145","height":4,"chart_height":51},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":289,"peak_comments":227,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14235020","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30576519","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-closure-is-a-poor-man-s-object-an-object-is-a-poor-man-s-closu-d9d0233e345f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-closure-is-a-poor-man-s-object-an-object-is-a-poor-man-s-closu-d9d0233e345f/"},{"slug":"entitlement-issues-2009-d9d0234d96a5","title":"Entitlement issues (2009)","domain":"journal.neilgaiman.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["books_literature","internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2022-03","inductedMonth":"2022-03","submissions":8,"submitters":4,"spanYears":9.07,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":121,"evidenceRank":724,"evidenceScore":66.6,"freshAt":"2022-03-17T10:44:37Z","freshnessRank":804,"freshEventScore":85,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 85 pts / 184 comments (2022) + 121 pts / 151 comments (2014), different submitters and 2,780 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":121,"peak_comments":151,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8136670","height":6,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18782864","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21705403","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23455004","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27904551","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":85,"peak_comments":184,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30709624","height":4,"chart_height":119},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37336783","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/entitlement-issues-2009-d9d0234d96a5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/entitlement-issues-2009-d9d0234d96a5/"},{"slug":"my-husband-works-for-electronic-arts-i-m-a-disgruntled-spouse-20-d9d0233f3303","title":"My [husband] works for Electronic Arts, I'm ... a disgruntled spouse. (2004)","domain":"ea-spouse.livejournal.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"social_post_thread","typeDisplay":"Social posts & threads","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["workplace"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2022-07","inductedMonth":"2022-07","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":13.481,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":206,"evidenceRank":725,"evidenceScore":66.5,"freshAt":"2022-07-15T14:59:04Z","freshnessRank":748,"freshEventScore":206,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 206 pts / 132 comments (2022) + 139 pts / 105 comments (2010), different submitters and 4,405 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=441180","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":139,"peak_comments":105,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1454102","height":7,"chart_height":115},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6751271","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19621717","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":206,"peak_comments":132,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32108852","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/my-husband-works-for-electronic-arts-i-m-a-disgruntled-spouse-20-d9d0233f3303.jpg","path":"/hall/link/my-husband-works-for-electronic-arts-i-m-a-disgruntled-spouse-20-d9d0233f3303/"},{"slug":"facebook-php-source-code-from-august-2007-d9d023474fde","title":"Facebook PHP Source Code from August 2007","domain":"gist.github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"source_code","typeDisplay":"Source code","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["web_development","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2020-01","inductedMonth":"2020-01","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":10.762,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":319,"evidenceRank":726,"evidenceScore":66.5,"freshAt":"2020-01-30T14:09:37Z","freshnessRank":1022,"freshEventScore":229,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 319 pts / 141 comments (2013) + 229 pts / 96 comments (2020), different submitters and 2,301 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4612389","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":319,"peak_comments":141,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6538270","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9252180","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13195134","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":229,"peak_comments":96,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22191355","height":11,"chart_height":122},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36662142","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/facebook-php-source-code-from-august-2007-d9d023474fde.jpg","path":"/hall/link/facebook-php-source-code-from-august-2007-d9d023474fde/"},{"slug":"nnn-a-terminal-file-manager-for-programmers-d9d02356b77c","title":"Nnn – a terminal file manager for programmers","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-11","inductedMonth":"2020-11","submissions":11,"submitters":7,"spanYears":5.64,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":298,"evidenceRank":727,"evidenceScore":66.5,"freshAt":"2020-11-17T15:51:05Z","freshnessRank":972,"freshEventScore":123,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 298 pts / 193 comments (2018) + 123 pts / 103 comments (2020), different submitters and 724 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14109822","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":4,"peak_score":298,"peak_comments":193,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18520898","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":123,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25125137","height":6,"chart_height":70},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33525849","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/nnn-a-terminal-file-manager-for-programmers-d9d02356b77c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/nnn-a-terminal-file-manager-for-programmers-d9d02356b77c/"},{"slug":"wireless-is-a-trap-d9d02361d501","title":"Wireless Is a Trap","domain":"www.benkuhn.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-10","inductedMonth":"2023-10","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.068,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":592,"evidenceRank":728,"evidenceScore":66.5,"freshAt":"2023-10-19T15:11:14Z","freshnessRank":512,"freshEventScore":29,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 592 pts / 419 comments (2020) + 29 pts / 67 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,215 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":592,"peak_comments":419,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23589798","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":474,"peak_comments":409,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31358855","height":23,"chart_height":136},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":29,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37943963","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44463047","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/wireless-is-a-trap-d9d02361d501.jpg","path":"/hall/link/wireless-is-a-trap-d9d02361d501/"},{"slug":"scientists-rename-human-genes-to-stop-ms-excel-from-misreading-t-d9d023627b8e","title":"Scientists rename human genes to stop MS Excel from misreading them as dates","domain":"www.theverge.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["biology","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-11","inductedMonth":"2024-03","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.636,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":621,"evidenceRank":729,"evidenceScore":66.5,"freshAt":"2024-03-26T03:47:53Z","freshnessRank":426,"freshEventScore":191,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 621 pts / 506 comments (2020) + 191 pts / 163 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,327 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":621,"peak_comments":506,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24070385","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":191,"peak_comments":138,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30986329","height":9,"chart_height":52},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38405678","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":191,"peak_comments":163,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39824100","height":9,"chart_height":52},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/scientists-rename-human-genes-to-stop-ms-excel-from-misreading-t-d9d023627b8e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/scientists-rename-human-genes-to-stop-ms-excel-from-misreading-t-d9d023627b8e/"},{"slug":"elementary-os-fast-open-privacy-respecting-replacement-for-windo-d9d0234f4e90","title":"Elementary OS – Fast, open, privacy-respecting replacement for Windows and macOS","domain":"elementary.io","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2025-10","inductedMonth":"2025-10","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":10.656,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":561,"evidenceRank":730,"evidenceScore":66.5,"freshAt":"2025-10-11T21:14:40Z","freshnessRank":132,"freshEventScore":104,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 561 pts / 421 comments (2018) + 104 pts / 87 comments (2025), different submitters and 2,521 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9051144","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12464064","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13427189","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":561,"peak_comments":421,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18472018","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28142801","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":104,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45552768","height":5,"chart_height":32},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/elementary-os-fast-open-privacy-respecting-replacement-for-windo-d9d0234f4e90.jpg","path":"/hall/link/elementary-os-fast-open-privacy-respecting-replacement-for-windo-d9d0234f4e90/"},{"slug":"pyo3-rust-bindings-for-the-python-interpreter-d9d02357ac56","title":"PyO3: Rust Bindings for the Python Interpreter","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools","open_source","compilers_runtimes"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-01","inductedMonth":"2023-03","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":8.282,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":305,"evidenceRank":731,"evidenceScore":66.4,"freshAt":"2021-01-29T12:17:11Z","freshnessRank":950,"freshEventScore":305,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 305 pts / 77 comments (2021) + 138 pts / 15 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,282 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":138,"peak_comments":15,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14859844","height":7,"chart_height":77},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":305,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25956502","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32247452","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35040509","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41047800","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45822702","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/pyo3-rust-bindings-for-the-python-interpreter-d9d02357ac56.jpg","path":"/hall/link/pyo3-rust-bindings-for-the-python-interpreter-d9d02357ac56/"},{"slug":"dumb-ideas-in-computer-security-2005-d9d0233f61f2","title":"Dumb Ideas in Computer Security (2005)","domain":"www.ranum.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2023-01","inductedMonth":"2023-01","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":13.854,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":265,"evidenceRank":732,"evidenceScore":66.4,"freshAt":"2023-01-25T02:55:18Z","freshnessRank":661,"freshEventScore":265,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 265 pts / 198 comments (2023) + 114 pts / 56 comments (2015), different submitters and 2,944 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":44,"peak_comments":20,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=522900","height":4,"chart_height":28},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":114,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8827985","height":5,"chart_height":73},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13213694","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13375816","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20928920","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":265,"peak_comments":198,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34513806","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/dumb-ideas-in-computer-security-2005-d9d0233f61f2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/dumb-ideas-in-computer-security-2005-d9d0233f61f2/"},{"slug":"how-real-are-real-numbers-2004-d9d02356af22","title":"How real are real numbers? (2004)","domain":"arxiv.org","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"research_paper","typeDisplay":"Research papers","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","physics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-08","inductedMonth":"2024-09","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":9.185,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":218,"evidenceRank":733,"evidenceScore":66.4,"freshAt":"2020-08-02T16:53:23Z","freshnessRank":996,"freshEventScore":81,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 218 pts / 265 comments (2017) + 81 pts / 112 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,210 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":218,"peak_comments":265,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14080024","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19126347","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":81,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24029791","height":4,"chart_height":63},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41670324","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48571096","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-real-are-real-numbers-2004-d9d02356af22.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-real-are-real-numbers-2004-d9d02356af22/"},{"slug":"distributed-systems-reading-list-d9d0234c84cc","title":"Distributed Systems Reading List","domain":"dancres.github.io","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["distributed_systems","databases_storage","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2024-10","inductedMonth":"2024-10","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":10.538,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":554,"evidenceRank":734,"evidenceScore":66.4,"freshAt":"2024-10-19T17:17:19Z","freshnessRank":312,"freshEventScore":193,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 554 pts / 76 comments (2020) + 193 pts / 9 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,412 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7539616","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11164670","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14555087","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17505673","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":554,"peak_comments":76,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25327077","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":193,"peak_comments":9,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41889076","height":9,"chart_height":59},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/distributed-systems-reading-list-d9d0234c84cc.jpg","path":"/hall/link/distributed-systems-reading-list-d9d0234c84cc/"},{"slug":"comprehensive-python-cheatsheet-2018-d9d0235c64e7","title":"Comprehensive Python Cheatsheet (2018)","domain":"gto76.github.io","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-12","inductedMonth":"2021-12","submissions":11,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.81,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":335,"evidenceRank":735,"evidenceScore":66.4,"freshAt":"2023-07-20T21:06:12Z","freshnessRank":585,"freshEventScore":295,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 335 pts / 81 comments (2019) + 295 pts / 40 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,627 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18767453","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":335,"peak_comments":81,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19075325","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23674693","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":243,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29679788","height":12,"chart_height":123},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":295,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36806753","height":14,"chart_height":150},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41879941","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/comprehensive-python-cheatsheet-2018-d9d0235c64e7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/comprehensive-python-cheatsheet-2018-d9d0235c64e7/"},{"slug":"reasons-not-to-use-apple-2018-d9d023522ef0","title":"Reasons Not to Use Apple (2018)","domain":"stallman.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["technology_ethics","privacy_surveillance","labor_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-03","inductedMonth":"2021-08","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.637,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":338,"evidenceRank":736,"evidenceScore":66.4,"freshAt":"2021-08-06T23:42:45Z","freshnessRank":885,"freshEventScore":106,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 338 pts / 223 comments (2019) + 56 pts / 106 comments (2016), different submitters and 950 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10753440","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":56,"peak_comments":106,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12244442","height":4,"chart_height":28},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":338,"peak_comments":223,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19407217","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23591821","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":106,"peak_comments":21,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28094108","height":5,"chart_height":53},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/reasons-not-to-use-apple-2018-d9d023522ef0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/reasons-not-to-use-apple-2018-d9d023522ef0/"},{"slug":"european-alternatives-d9d023674808","title":"European Alternatives","domain":"european-alternatives.eu","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["digital_archives","privacy_surveillance","law_regulation"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2024-06","inductedMonth":"2026-01","submissions":9,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.093,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":810,"evidenceRank":737,"evidenceScore":66.3,"freshAt":"2026-01-23T13:01:51Z","freshnessRank":74,"freshEventScore":810,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 357 pts / 235 comments (2021) + 196 pts / 95 comments (2024), different submitters and 908 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":357,"peak_comments":235,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29627097","height":17,"chart_height":75},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35466273","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":196,"peak_comments":95,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40695754","height":9,"chart_height":41},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":4,"peak_score":810,"peak_comments":512,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46731976","height":24,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/european-alternatives-d9d023674808.jpg","path":"/hall/link/european-alternatives-d9d023674808/"},{"slug":"banana-equivalent-dose-d9d023411b08","title":"Banana equivalent dose","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["physics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2023-05","inductedMonth":"2023-05","submissions":9,"submitters":6,"spanYears":12.901,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":470,"evidenceRank":738,"evidenceScore":66.3,"freshAt":"2023-05-02T06:18:08Z","freshnessRank":636,"freshEventScore":84,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 470 pts / 84 comments (2010) + 84 pts / 62 comments (2023), different submitters and 4,704 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":470,"peak_comments":84,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1429524","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2267816","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12225454","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20793054","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34054050","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":84,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35784001","height":4,"chart_height":30},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/banana-equivalent-dose-d9d023411b08.jpg","path":"/hall/link/banana-equivalent-dose-d9d023411b08/"},{"slug":"stellarium-a-free-open-source-planetarium-for-your-computer-d9d0233ed582","title":"Stellarium: A free open-source planetarium for your computer","domain":"stellarium.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"space_transportation","topicDisplay":"Space & transportation","tags":["space_astronomy","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2022-03","inductedMonth":"2022-03","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":13.514,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":445,"evidenceRank":739,"evidenceScore":66.3,"freshAt":"2022-03-06T03:36:22Z","freshnessRank":813,"freshEventScore":258,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 445 pts / 56 comments (2019) + 258 pts / 31 comments (2022), different submitters and 911 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=291078","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4067138","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7146138","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11754973","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":445,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20901358","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":258,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30574809","height":12,"chart_height":99},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/stellarium-a-free-open-source-planetarium-for-your-computer-d9d0233ed582.jpg","path":"/hall/link/stellarium-a-free-open-source-planetarium-for-your-computer-d9d0233ed582/"},{"slug":"when-the-u-s-air-force-discovered-the-flaw-of-averages-d9d023527b28","title":"When the U.S. air force discovered the flaw of averages","domain":"www.thestar.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["history","product_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-04","inductedMonth":"2020-04","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.461,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":471,"evidenceRank":740,"evidenceScore":66.3,"freshAt":"2022-07-09T08:44:00Z","freshnessRank":752,"freshEventScore":43,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 471 pts / 103 comments (2016) + 273 pts / 112 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,509 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":471,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11230287","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16220499","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":273,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22956832","height":13,"chart_height":99},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29712668","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":43,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32033157","height":4,"chart_height":16},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/when-the-u-s-air-force-discovered-the-flaw-of-averages-d9d023527b28/"},{"slug":"hacker-news-parody-thread-2013-d9d02348b3e9","title":"Hacker News Parody Thread (2013)","domain":"bradconte.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2022-11","inductedMonth":"2025-11","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":12.715,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1046,"evidenceRank":741,"evidenceScore":66.3,"freshAt":"2022-11-20T13:14:22Z","freshnessRank":685,"freshEventScore":1046,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1046 pts / 329 comments (2022) + 589 pts / 187 comments (2013), different submitters and 3,546 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":589,"peak_comments":187,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5326511","height":24,"chart_height":96},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10295652","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1046,"peak_comments":329,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33680661","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39850078","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46007444","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/hacker-news-parody-thread-2013-d9d02348b3e9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/hacker-news-parody-thread-2013-d9d02348b3e9/"},{"slug":"composing-programs-python-3-in-the-tradition-of-sicp-d9d02350232a","title":"Composing Programs – Python 3 in the tradition of SICP","domain":"composingprograms.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","teaching"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-07","inductedMonth":"2018-07","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":7.006,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":300,"evidenceRank":742,"evidenceScore":66.3,"freshAt":"2020-11-08T13:14:44Z","freshnessRank":975,"freshEventScore":104,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 300 pts / 94 comments (2016) + 155 pts / 53 comments (2018), different submitters and 842 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10180749","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":300,"peak_comments":94,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11465234","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13924651","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":155,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17651797","height":7,"chart_height":88},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":104,"peak_comments":2,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25025589","height":5,"chart_height":59},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31336420","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/composing-programs-python-3-in-the-tradition-of-sicp-d9d02350232a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/composing-programs-python-3-in-the-tradition-of-sicp-d9d02350232a/"},{"slug":"f-a-proof-oriented-programming-language-d9d023544892","title":"F* – A Proof-Oriented Programming Language","domain":"www.fstar-lang.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["programming_languages","theory_of_computation","application_security","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2024-05","inductedMonth":"2024-05","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":8.397,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":264,"evidenceRank":743,"evidenceScore":66.3,"freshAt":"2024-12-25T13:16:40Z","freshnessRank":279,"freshEventScore":254,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 236 pts / 102 comments (2024) + 264 pts / 95 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,390 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12207928","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":264,"peak_comments":95,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15582969","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20819104","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25728830","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":254,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42508642","height":12,"chart_height":164},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/f-a-proof-oriented-programming-language-d9d023544892.jpg","path":"/hall/link/f-a-proof-oriented-programming-language-d9d023544892/"},{"slug":"what-did-ada-lovelace-s-program-actually-do-d9d0235b3c6e","title":"What Did Ada Lovelace’s Program Actually Do?","domain":"twobithistory.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["history","programming_languages","mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2024-12","inductedMonth":"2024-12","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.324,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":410,"evidenceRank":744,"evidenceScore":66.2,"freshAt":"2024-12-16T16:58:57Z","freshnessRank":284,"freshEventScore":355,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 410 pts / 52 comments (2018) + 355 pts / 129 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,310 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":410,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17797003","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21965308","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26105312","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36487176","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":355,"peak_comments":129,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42432867","height":17,"chart_height":147},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-did-ada-lovelace-s-program-actually-do-d9d0235b3c6e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-did-ada-lovelace-s-program-actually-do-d9d0235b3c6e/"},{"slug":"paged-out-d9d0235e9b36","title":"Paged Out","domain":"pagedout.institute","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","application_security","electronics","retrocomputing"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2025-12","inductedMonth":"2025-12","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.311,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":599,"evidenceRank":745,"evidenceScore":66.2,"freshAt":"2025-12-02T20:14:20Z","freshnessRank":108,"freshEventScore":599,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 599 pts / 64 comments (2025) + 583 pts / 82 comments (2019), different submitters and 2,304 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":583,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20670432","height":24,"chart_height":165},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25176869","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30568755","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":82,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38830777","height":4,"chart_height":23},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":599,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46126217","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/paged-out-d9d0235e9b36.jpg","path":"/hall/link/paged-out-d9d0235e9b36/"},{"slug":"algorithms-for-modern-hardware-d9d02367cb96","title":"Algorithms for Modern Hardware","domain":"en.algorithmica.org","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["algorithms_data_structures","performance_reliability","computer_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2022,"candidateMonth":"2024-03","inductedMonth":"2025-06","submissions":10,"submitters":9,"spanYears":4.151,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":344,"evidenceRank":746,"evidenceScore":66.2,"freshAt":"2024-03-14T05:17:01Z","freshnessRank":428,"freshEventScore":308,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 344 pts / 62 comments (2022) + 308 pts / 76 comments (2024), different submitters and 738 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":344,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30583808","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":308,"peak_comments":76,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39700809","height":15,"chart_height":152},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45065353","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47700337","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/algorithms-for-modern-hardware-d9d02367cb96.jpg","path":"/hall/link/algorithms-for-modern-hardware-d9d02367cb96/"},{"slug":"tarrare-d9d02357d627","title":"Tarrare","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["history","medicine","psychology"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2022-01","inductedMonth":"2022-01","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":7.069,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":388,"evidenceRank":747,"evidenceScore":66.2,"freshAt":"2022-01-16T16:45:42Z","freshnessRank":836,"freshEventScore":388,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 388 pts / 169 comments (2022) + 311 pts / 72 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,076 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14988502","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":311,"peak_comments":72,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19084880","height":15,"chart_height":136},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24165350","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28195861","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":388,"peak_comments":169,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29957475","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41457192","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/tarrare-d9d02357d627.jpg","path":"/hall/link/tarrare-d9d02357d627/"},{"slug":"git-from-the-inside-out-d9d0234fb3d3","title":"Git from the inside out","domain":"codewords.recurse.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","software_architecture","algorithms_data_structures"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-12","inductedMonth":"2022-07","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":7.272,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":722,"evidenceRank":748,"evidenceScore":66.2,"freshAt":"2022-07-03T03:34:11Z","freshnessRank":755,"freshEventScore":178,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 722 pts / 119 comments (2016) + 195 pts / 34 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,139 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":284,"peak_comments":96,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9272249","height":14,"chart_height":67},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":722,"peak_comments":119,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12802949","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":195,"peak_comments":34,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21755090","height":9,"chart_height":46},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26868398","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":178,"peak_comments":10,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31964814","height":9,"chart_height":42},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/git-from-the-inside-out-d9d0234fb3d3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/git-from-the-inside-out-d9d0234fb3d3/"},{"slug":"no-more-secrets-recreate-the-decryption-effect-seen-in-the-1992-d9d023537043","title":"No-more-secrets: recreate the decryption effect seen in the 1992 movie Sneakers","domain":"github.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["film_television","internet_culture","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2023-07","inductedMonth":"2023-07","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":9.881,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1002,"evidenceRank":749,"evidenceScore":66.1,"freshAt":"2023-07-20T12:57:03Z","freshnessRank":586,"freshEventScore":1002,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1002 pts / 257 comments (2023) + 216 pts / 54 comments (2016), different submitters and 2,631 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":216,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11643270","height":10,"chart_height":37},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15172758","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20822160","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1002,"peak_comments":257,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36799776","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46038298","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47413594","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/no-more-secrets-recreate-the-decryption-effect-seen-in-the-1992-d9d023537043.jpg","path":"/hall/link/no-more-secrets-recreate-the-decryption-effect-seen-in-the-1992-d9d023537043/"},{"slug":"changing-san-francisco-is-foreseen-as-a-haven-for-wealthy-and-ch-d9d023510d20","title":"Changing San Francisco Is Foreseen as a Haven for Wealthy and Childless (1981)","domain":"www.nytimes.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["cities_infrastructure","social_issues"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-04","inductedMonth":"2023-07","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":8.578,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":212,"evidenceRank":750,"evidenceScore":66.1,"freshAt":"2019-04-22T20:55:12Z","freshnessRank":1062,"freshEventScore":106,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 212 pts / 178 comments (2017) + 106 pts / 109 comments (2019), different submitters and 819 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10066717","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":212,"peak_comments":178,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13464747","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":106,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19722891","height":5,"chart_height":85},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36885431","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39694288","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/changing-san-francisco-is-foreseen-as-a-haven-for-wealthy-and-ch-d9d023510d20/"},{"slug":"frinkiac-3m-the-simpsons-screencaps-d9d0235299e0","title":"Frinkiac – 3M \"The Simpsons\" Screencaps","domain":"frinkiac.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["film_television","information_retrieval"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2025-12","inductedMonth":"2025-12","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":9.829,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":340,"evidenceRank":751,"evidenceScore":66.1,"freshAt":"2025-12-02T20:28:18Z","freshnessRank":107,"freshEventScore":175,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 340 pts / 84 comments (2016) + 175 pts / 65 comments (2025), different submitters and 3,588 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":340,"peak_comments":84,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11038725","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14662391","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23951518","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26128537","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34589808","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":175,"peak_comments":65,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46126380","height":8,"chart_height":88},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/frinkiac-3m-the-simpsons-screencaps-d9d0235299e0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/frinkiac-3m-the-simpsons-screencaps-d9d0235299e0/"},{"slug":"wayland-is-not-ready-as-a-1-1-compatible-xorg-replacement-just-y-d9d023644f4c","title":"Wayland is not ready as a 1:1 compatible Xorg replacement just yet","domain":"gist.github.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","browsers_web_standards","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2023-10","inductedMonth":"2025-06","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.608,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":195,"evidenceRank":752,"evidenceScore":66.1,"freshAt":"2025-09-12T14:00:24Z","freshnessRank":147,"freshEventScore":36,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 195 pts / 411 comments (2021) + 49 pts / 63 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,010 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":195,"peak_comments":411,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25999071","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":117,"peak_comments":344,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31940765","height":6,"chart_height":102},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":49,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38210694","height":4,"chart_height":43},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":36,"peak_comments":36,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45222251","height":4,"chart_height":31},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/wayland-is-not-ready-as-a-1-1-compatible-xorg-replacement-just-y-d9d023644f4c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/wayland-is-not-ready-as-a-1-1-compatible-xorg-replacement-just-y-d9d023644f4c/"},{"slug":"energy-efficiency-across-programming-languages-pdf-d9d0235f651b","title":"Energy Efficiency across Programming Languages [pdf]","domain":"greenlab.di.uminho.pt","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"research_paper","typeDisplay":"Research papers","topic":"environment_energy","topicDisplay":"Environment & energy","tags":["climate_environment"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-09","inductedMonth":"2022-09","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":5.892,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":192,"evidenceRank":753,"evidenceScore":66.0,"freshAt":"2022-09-21T05:03:39Z","freshnessRank":716,"freshEventScore":79,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 192 pts / 158 comments (2020) + 79 pts / 89 comments (2022), different submitters and 720 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21387419","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":192,"peak_comments":158,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24642134","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":6,"peak_score":79,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32920990","height":4,"chart_height":70},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40061468","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45304658","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/energy-efficiency-across-programming-languages-pdf-d9d0235f651b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/energy-efficiency-across-programming-languages-pdf-d9d0235f651b/"},{"slug":"repalm-d9d0235d9054","title":"RePalm","domain":"dmitry.gr","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","retrocomputing","compilers_runtimes"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-04","inductedMonth":"2023-09","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.615,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":503,"evidenceRank":754,"evidenceScore":66.0,"freshAt":"2025-12-06T03:17:44Z","freshnessRank":104,"freshEventScore":195,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 503 pts / 145 comments (2023) + 195 pts / 29 comments (2025), different submitters and 970 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":175,"peak_comments":37,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19761952","height":8,"chart_height":59},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24993826","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":47,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29197125","height":4,"chart_height":16},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":503,"peak_comments":145,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35511106","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":81,"peak_comments":30,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41194806","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":195,"peak_comments":29,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46170309","height":9,"chart_height":66},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/repalm-d9d0235d9054.jpg","path":"/hall/link/repalm-d9d0235d9054/"},{"slug":"python-data-science-handbook-d9d02357e984","title":"Python Data Science Handbook","domain":"jakevdp.github.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["data_science","machine_learning","data_engineering"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2025-12","inductedMonth":"2025-12","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":8.285,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":455,"evidenceRank":755,"evidenceScore":66.0,"freshAt":"2025-12-02T12:38:28Z","freshnessRank":109,"freshEventScore":312,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 455 pts / 27 comments (2017) + 312 pts / 61 comments (2025), different submitters and 3,016 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":455,"peak_comments":27,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15127672","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24959985","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31303076","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40408337","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":312,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46120611","height":15,"chart_height":117},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/python-data-science-handbook-d9d02357e984.jpg","path":"/hall/link/python-data-science-handbook-d9d02357e984/"},{"slug":"nim-programming-language-d9d0234ef723","title":"Nim programming language","domain":"nim-lang.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","compilers_runtimes","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2020-08","inductedMonth":"2020-08","submissions":9,"submitters":8,"spanYears":8.559,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":195,"evidenceRank":756,"evidenceScore":66.0,"freshAt":"2020-08-16T15:12:02Z","freshnessRank":995,"freshEventScore":155,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 155 pts / 190 comments (2020) + 195 pts / 89 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,215 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8866405","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12883615","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":195,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14143521","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18283151","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":155,"peak_comments":190,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24178438","height":7,"chart_height":135},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36967237","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/nim-programming-language-d9d0234ef723.jpg","path":"/hall/link/nim-programming-language-d9d0234ef723/"},{"slug":"screenshots-from-developers-and-unix-people-taken-in-2002-d9d02351b951","title":"Screenshots from developers and Unix people taken in 2002","domain":"anders.unix.se","category":"media","categoryDisplay":"Audio, video & images","type":"image_comic","typeDisplay":"Images & comics","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["history","operating_systems","digital_archives"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-06","inductedMonth":"2026-02","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":10.448,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":638,"evidenceRank":757,"evidenceScore":66.0,"freshAt":"2019-06-10T09:04:39Z","freshnessRank":1061,"freshEventScore":324,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 638 pts / 232 comments (2015) + 324 pts / 189 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,320 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":638,"peak_comments":232,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10469824","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":324,"peak_comments":189,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20145035","height":16,"chart_height":86},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27955449","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47708195","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/screenshots-from-developers-and-unix-people-taken-in-2002-d9d02351b951.jpg","path":"/hall/link/screenshots-from-developers-and-unix-people-taken-in-2002-d9d02351b951/"},{"slug":"delta-a-syntax-highlighting-pager-for-git-diff-grep-and-blame-ou-d9d0235efe54","title":"Delta: A syntax-highlighting pager for Git, diff, grep, and blame output","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2024-11","inductedMonth":"2024-11","submissions":13,"submitters":9,"spanYears":5.139,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":642,"evidenceRank":758,"evidenceScore":66.0,"freshAt":"2024-11-08T23:46:46Z","freshnessRank":299,"freshEventScore":642,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 642 pts / 92 comments (2024) + 261 pts / 40 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,656 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21016938","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":261,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22996374","height":13,"chart_height":69},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29429707","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31633475","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37949280","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":642,"peak_comments":92,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42091365","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/delta-a-syntax-highlighting-pager-for-git-diff-grep-and-blame-ou-d9d0235efe54.jpg","path":"/hall/link/delta-a-syntax-highlighting-pager-for-git-diff-grep-and-blame-ou-d9d0235efe54/"},{"slug":"c-core-guidelines-d9d0235159b6","title":"C++ Core Guidelines","domain":"github.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-03","inductedMonth":"2018-03","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":10.357,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":268,"evidenceRank":759,"evidenceScore":66.0,"freshAt":"2018-03-09T00:17:22Z","freshnessRank":1105,"freshEventScore":179,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 268 pts / 126 comments (2015) + 179 pts / 110 comments (2018), different submitters and 902 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":268,"peak_comments":126,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10239962","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12482205","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":179,"peak_comments":110,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16548866","height":9,"chart_height":114},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46767147","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/c-core-guidelines-d9d0235159b6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/c-core-guidelines-d9d0235159b6/"},{"slug":"replit-used-legal-threats-to-kill-my-open-source-project-d9d0236585cb","title":"Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project","domain":"intuitiveexplanations.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["law_regulation","open_source","startups_entrepreneurship"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2024-06","inductedMonth":"2024-06","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.003,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":4022,"evidenceRank":760,"evidenceScore":65.9,"freshAt":"2024-06-08T05:43:48Z","freshnessRank":382,"freshEventScore":192,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 4022 pts / 1274 comments (2021) + 192 pts / 114 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,096 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":4022,"peak_comments":1274,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27424195","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33518214","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":112,"peak_comments":8,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34509709","height":5,"chart_height":5},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":192,"peak_comments":114,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40615537","height":9,"chart_height":8},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/replit-used-legal-threats-to-kill-my-open-source-project-d9d0236585cb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/replit-used-legal-threats-to-kill-my-open-source-project-d9d0236585cb/"},{"slug":"includeos-a-minimal-unikernel-operating-system-for-c-services-d9d023519f0d","title":"IncludeOS: a minimal unikernel operating system for C++ services","domain":"www.includeos.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","performance_reliability","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-12","inductedMonth":"2024-12","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":9.166,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":380,"evidenceRank":761,"evidenceScore":65.9,"freshAt":"2024-12-17T21:29:52Z","freshnessRank":282,"freshEventScore":183,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 380 pts / 181 comments (2019) + 183 pts / 46 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,815 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":97,"peak_comments":38,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10409292","height":5,"chart_height":43},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15453092","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":231,"peak_comments":84,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17848324","height":11,"chart_height":103},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":380,"peak_comments":181,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21905856","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":96,"peak_comments":10,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27250596","height":5,"chart_height":43},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":183,"peak_comments":46,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42445508","height":9,"chart_height":82},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/includeos-a-minimal-unikernel-operating-system-for-c-services-d9d023519f0d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/includeos-a-minimal-unikernel-operating-system-for-c-services-d9d023519f0d/"},{"slug":"old-css-new-css-d9d0236056c5","title":"Old CSS, New CSS","domain":"eev.ee","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","browsers_web_standards","internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2024-01","inductedMonth":"2026-07","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.453,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1018,"evidenceRank":762,"evidenceScore":65.9,"freshAt":"2024-04-13T15:48:06Z","freshnessRank":419,"freshEventScore":201,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1018 pts / 244 comments (2020) + 201 pts / 111 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,532 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1018,"peak_comments":244,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22215931","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":284,"peak_comments":97,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29531941","height":14,"chart_height":47},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":201,"peak_comments":111,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40023892","height":10,"chart_height":34},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48943780","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/old-css-new-css-d9d0236056c5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/old-css-new-css-d9d0236056c5/"},{"slug":"sheldon-brown-s-bicycle-technical-info-d9d0235b5615","title":"Sheldon Brown's Bicycle Technical Info","domain":"www.sheldonbrown.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"space_transportation","topicDisplay":"Space & transportation","tags":["transportation"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2026-02","inductedMonth":"2026-02","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":7.439,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":465,"evidenceRank":763,"evidenceScore":65.9,"freshAt":"2026-02-06T15:40:42Z","freshnessRank":63,"freshEventScore":465,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 465 pts / 115 comments (2026) + 323 pts / 134 comments (2023), different submitters and 915 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17875888","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31506229","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":323,"peak_comments":134,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37019396","height":16,"chart_height":118},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":465,"peak_comments":115,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46914159","height":22,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/sheldon-brown-s-bicycle-technical-info-d9d0235b5615.jpg","path":"/hall/link/sheldon-brown-s-bicycle-technical-info-d9d0235b5615/"},{"slug":"the-simpsons-in-css-d9d0234b1b96","title":"The Simpsons in CSS","domain":"pattle.github.io","category":"media","categoryDisplay":"Audio, video & images","type":"image_comic","typeDisplay":"Images & comics","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design","art","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2020-02","inductedMonth":"2020-02","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":10.973,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":554,"evidenceRank":764,"evidenceScore":65.9,"freshAt":"2020-02-27T02:54:11Z","freshnessRank":1019,"freshEventScore":554,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 554 pts / 101 comments (2020) + 238 pts / 78 comments (2013), different submitters and 2,298 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":238,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6710863","height":11,"chart_height":73},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":151,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7937070","height":7,"chart_height":46},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10554012","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":554,"peak_comments":101,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22429958","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42017065","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-simpsons-in-css-d9d0234b1b96.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-simpsons-in-css-d9d0234b1b96/"},{"slug":"the-web-sucks-if-you-have-a-slow-connection-d9d023561028","title":"The web sucks if you have a slow connection","domain":"danluu.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","performance_reliability","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-06","inductedMonth":"2021-06","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":5.799,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1269,"evidenceRank":765,"evidenceScore":65.9,"freshAt":"2021-06-05T16:01:44Z","freshnessRank":904,"freshEventScore":222,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1269 pts / 598 comments (2017) + 222 pts / 173 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,577 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":1269,"peak_comments":598,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13601451","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20979317","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23093047","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":222,"peak_comments":173,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27406132","height":11,"chart_height":30},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33766878","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-web-sucks-if-you-have-a-slow-connection-d9d023561028.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-web-sucks-if-you-have-a-slow-connection-d9d023561028/"},{"slug":"smart-guy-productivity-pitfalls-2013-d9d02348cfc6","title":"Smart Guy Productivity Pitfalls (2013)","domain":"bookofhook.blogspot.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["personal_productivity","workplace"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2018-03","inductedMonth":"2018-03","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":10.248,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":319,"evidenceRank":766,"evidenceScore":65.9,"freshAt":"2018-03-06T15:43:55Z","freshnessRank":1106,"freshEventScore":319,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 319 pts / 84 comments (2018) + 288 pts / 59 comments (2013), different submitters and 1,816 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":288,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5383650","height":14,"chart_height":153},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7569378","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12031405","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15394924","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":319,"peak_comments":84,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16529481","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32591901","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36321852","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/smart-guy-productivity-pitfalls-2013-d9d02348cfc6/"},{"slug":"what-killed-the-linux-desktop-d9d023470294","title":"What killed the Linux desktop","domain":"tirania.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2017-02","inductedMonth":"2024-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":11.42,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":344,"evidenceRank":767,"evidenceScore":65.8,"freshAt":"2017-02-05T16:04:40Z","freshnessRank":1136,"freshEventScore":146,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 344 pts / 378 comments (2012) + 146 pts / 293 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,620 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":344,"peak_comments":378,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4450244","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9324067","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":146,"peak_comments":293,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13572928","height":7,"chart_height":72},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":19,"peak_comments":40,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26668789","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39195691","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-killed-the-linux-desktop-d9d023470294.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-killed-the-linux-desktop-d9d023470294/"},{"slug":"what-can-a-technologist-do-about-climate-change-d9d02351f970","title":"What can a technologist do about climate change?","domain":"worrydream.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"environment_energy","topicDisplay":"Environment & energy","tags":["climate_environment","energy","technology_ethics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2021-06","inductedMonth":"2021-06","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":5.552,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":402,"evidenceRank":768,"evidenceScore":65.8,"freshAt":"2021-06-13T20:44:33Z","freshnessRank":898,"freshEventScore":42,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 402 pts / 289 comments (2015) + 42 pts / 56 comments (2021), different submitters and 2,028 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":402,"peak_comments":289,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10622615","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":6,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15879078","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":36,"peak_comments":10,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16505675","height":4,"chart_height":15},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":49,"peak_comments":12,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20520183","height":4,"chart_height":21},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":42,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27496266","height":4,"chart_height":18},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-can-a-technologist-do-about-climate-change-d9d02351f970.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-can-a-technologist-do-about-climate-change-d9d02351f970/"},{"slug":"carp-a-statically-typed-lisp-without-a-gc-for-real-time-applicat-d9d023556c88","title":"Carp – A statically typed Lisp, without a GC, for real-time applications","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["programming_languages","compilers_runtimes","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-10","inductedMonth":"2021-10","submissions":10,"submitters":7,"spanYears":7.272,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":259,"evidenceRank":769,"evidenceScore":65.8,"freshAt":"2023-01-27T21:51:18Z","freshnessRank":659,"freshEventScore":20,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 259 pts / 134 comments (2021) + 202 pts / 39 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,280 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13087780","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15540614","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":202,"peak_comments":39,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16829278","height":10,"chart_height":133},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22211480","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":259,"peak_comments":134,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28875051","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":20,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34552382","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39670663","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/carp-a-statically-typed-lisp-without-a-gc-for-real-time-applicat-d9d023556c88.jpg","path":"/hall/link/carp-a-statically-typed-lisp-without-a-gc-for-real-time-applicat-d9d023556c88/"},{"slug":"how-opengl-works-software-renderer-in-500-lines-of-code-d9d02352f42e","title":"How OpenGL works: software renderer in 500 lines of code","domain":"github.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["computer_graphics","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2022-03","inductedMonth":"2025-03","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":9.008,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":363,"evidenceRank":770,"evidenceScore":65.8,"freshAt":"2022-03-15T14:59:56Z","freshnessRank":806,"freshEventScore":328,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 363 pts / 36 comments (2016) + 328 pts / 38 comments (2022), different submitters and 2,195 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":4,"peak_score":363,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11264469","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":328,"peak_comments":38,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30686163","height":16,"chart_height":154},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43356556","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-opengl-works-software-renderer-in-500-lines-of-code-d9d02352f42e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-opengl-works-software-renderer-in-500-lines-of-code-d9d02352f42e/"},{"slug":"netscape-and-sun-announce-javascript-1995-d9d0234b612a","title":"Netscape and Sun Announce JavaScript (1995)","domain":"web.archive.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"announcement_post","typeDisplay":"Announcements","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2025-12","inductedMonth":"2025-12","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":11.989,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":755,"evidenceRank":771,"evidenceScore":65.8,"freshAt":"2025-12-04T11:32:00Z","freshnessRank":106,"freshEventScore":211,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 755 pts / 455 comments (2020) + 211 pts / 99 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,825 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6868856","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10645036","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14655207","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":755,"peak_comments":455,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25301437","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36621504","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42323206","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":211,"peak_comments":99,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46146406","height":10,"chart_height":48},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/netscape-and-sun-announce-javascript-1995-d9d0234b612a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/netscape-and-sun-announce-javascript-1995-d9d0234b612a/"},{"slug":"the-fastest-math-typesetting-library-for-the-web-d9d0235d3a68","title":"The fastest math typesetting library for the web","domain":"katex.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","performance_reliability","mathematics","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-06","inductedMonth":"2025-10","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.601,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":237,"evidenceRank":772,"evidenceScore":65.8,"freshAt":"2025-10-29T12:40:16Z","freshnessRank":123,"freshEventScore":181,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 237 pts / 123 comments (2023) + 217 pts / 40 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,484 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":217,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19475273","height":10,"chart_height":156},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":203,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24742518","height":10,"chart_height":146},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31899054","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":237,"peak_comments":123,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35588985","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":181,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45746063","height":9,"chart_height":130},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-fastest-math-typesetting-library-for-the-web-d9d0235d3a68.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-fastest-math-typesetting-library-for-the-web-d9d0235d3a68/"},{"slug":"systemd-ten-years-later-a-historical-and-technical-retrospective-d9d023616260","title":"Systemd, ten years later: a historical and technical retrospective","domain":"blog.darknedgy.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","software_architecture","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2024-06","inductedMonth":"2026-07","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.209,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":381,"evidenceRank":773,"evidenceScore":65.8,"freshAt":"2024-08-06T20:42:03Z","freshnessRank":352,"freshEventScore":72,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 381 pts / 432 comments (2020) + 72 pts / 90 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,555 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":381,"peak_comments":432,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23062072","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":253,"peak_comments":317,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29855045","height":12,"chart_height":113},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":72,"peak_comments":90,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41175105","height":4,"chart_height":32},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48966413","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/systemd-ten-years-later-a-historical-and-technical-retrospective-d9d023616260.jpg","path":"/hall/link/systemd-ten-years-later-a-historical-and-technical-retrospective-d9d023616260/"},{"slug":"stabilizing-the-obra-dinn-1-bit-dithering-process-2017-d9d02358c9c2","title":"Stabilizing the Obra Dinn 1-bit dithering process (2017)","domain":"forums.tigsource.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"forum_discussion","typeDisplay":"Forum discussions","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2024-11","inductedMonth":"2026-03","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":8.309,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":527,"evidenceRank":774,"evidenceScore":65.8,"freshAt":"2026-03-16T22:56:13Z","freshnessRank":45,"freshEventScore":472,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 527 pts / 114 comments (2024) + 291 pts / 20 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,541 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":291,"peak_comments":20,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15766249","height":14,"chart_height":94},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":527,"peak_comments":114,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42084080","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":472,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47406160","height":23,"chart_height":152}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/stabilizing-the-obra-dinn-1-bit-dithering-process-2017-d9d02358c9c2/"},{"slug":"there-s-no-such-thing-as-a-tree-phylogenetically-d9d023652fe5","title":"There’s no such thing as a tree (phylogenetically)","domain":"eukaryotewritesblog.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["biology","scientific_method"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2024-07","inductedMonth":"2025-06","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.159,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":304,"evidenceRank":775,"evidenceScore":65.7,"freshAt":"2025-06-30T15:52:22Z","freshnessRank":193,"freshEventScore":47,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 264 pts / 207 comments (2021) + 47 pts / 58 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,513 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":264,"peak_comments":207,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27094382","height":13,"chart_height":148},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":304,"peak_comments":194,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35081277","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41079289","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":47,"peak_comments":58,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44424747","height":4,"chart_height":26},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/there-s-no-such-thing-as-a-tree-phylogenetically-d9d023652fe5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/there-s-no-such-thing-as-a-tree-phylogenetically-d9d023652fe5/"},{"slug":"craft-a-simple-minecraft-clone-written-in-c-using-opengl-shaders-d9d0234b6568","title":"Craft: A simple Minecraft clone written in C using OpenGL shaders","domain":"github.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"computer_game","typeDisplay":"Computer games","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["indie_games","game_development","computer_graphics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2020-05","inductedMonth":"2025-02","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":11.157,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":578,"evidenceRank":776,"evidenceScore":65.7,"freshAt":"2023-05-26T23:50:22Z","freshnessRank":622,"freshEventScore":47,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 578 pts / 154 comments (2018) + 287 pts / 149 comments (2013), different submitters and 1,717 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":287,"peak_comments":149,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6878565","height":14,"chart_height":84},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":578,"peak_comments":154,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17828187","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23253221","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":47,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36090772","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42946898","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/craft-a-simple-minecraft-clone-written-in-c-using-opengl-shaders-d9d0234b6568.jpg","path":"/hall/link/craft-a-simple-minecraft-clone-written-in-c-using-opengl-shaders-d9d0234b6568/"},{"slug":"trolls-2008-d9d0233e5dad","title":"Trolls (2008)","domain":"www.paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["online_communities","psychology"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2011-12","inductedMonth":"2022-02","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":13.982,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":360,"evidenceRank":777,"evidenceScore":65.7,"freshAt":"2011-12-14T21:09:02Z","freshnessRank":1176,"freshEventScore":360,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 360 pts / 303 comments (2011) + 137 pts / 183 comments (2008), different submitters and 1,397 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":137,"peak_comments":183,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117118","height":7,"chart_height":65},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":360,"peak_comments":303,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3353593","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8803603","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30275339","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/trolls-2008-d9d0233e5dad.jpg","path":"/hall/link/trolls-2008-d9d0233e5dad/"},{"slug":"btop-is-a-power-resource-monitor-for-linux-d9d023667e82","title":"Btop++ is a power resource monitor for Linux","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2024-11","inductedMonth":"2025-11","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.126,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":316,"evidenceRank":778,"evidenceScore":65.7,"freshAt":"2025-11-08T14:50:51Z","freshnessRank":120,"freshEventScore":190,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 190 pts / 118 comments (2025) + 316 pts / 65 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,506 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":316,"peak_comments":65,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28634898","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":111,"peak_comments":12,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36467236","height":5,"chart_height":60},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42509471","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":190,"peak_comments":118,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45856987","height":9,"chart_height":102},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/btop-is-a-power-resource-monitor-for-linux-d9d023667e82.jpg","path":"/hall/link/btop-is-a-power-resource-monitor-for-linux-d9d023667e82/"},{"slug":"ubershaders-a-ridiculous-solution-to-an-impossible-problem-d9d02357b871","title":"Ubershaders: A Ridiculous Solution to an Impossible Problem","domain":"dolphin-emu.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2024-05","inductedMonth":"2024-05","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":6.795,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":772,"evidenceRank":779,"evidenceScore":65.6,"freshAt":"2024-05-16T15:52:53Z","freshnessRank":394,"freshEventScore":222,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 772 pts / 88 comments (2017) + 222 pts / 69 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,482 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":772,"peak_comments":88,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14884992","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20764110","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22320484","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33290457","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34309717","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":222,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40379833","height":11,"chart_height":49},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/ubershaders-a-ridiculous-solution-to-an-impossible-problem-d9d02357b871/"},{"slug":"resolutions-for-programmers-d9d02344e747","title":"Resolutions for programmers","domain":"matt.might.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2015-12","inductedMonth":"2018-06","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":7.581,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":521,"evidenceRank":780,"evidenceScore":65.6,"freshAt":"2015-12-30T13:30:31Z","freshnessRank":1161,"freshEventScore":369,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 369 pts / 221 comments (2015) + 521 pts / 152 comments (2012), different submitters and 1,456 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":521,"peak_comments":152,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3419925","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8206112","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":369,"peak_comments":221,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10811958","height":18,"chart_height":120},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17325843","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20599284","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/resolutions-for-programmers-d9d02344e747.jpg","path":"/hall/link/resolutions-for-programmers-d9d02344e747/"},{"slug":"the-browser-brave-loads-major-news-sites-2x-8x-faster-d9d023527426","title":"The browser “Brave” loads major news sites 2x – 8x faster","domain":"brave.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["browsers_web_standards","privacy_surveillance","internet_infrastructure"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-07","inductedMonth":"2019-07","submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":4.312,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":667,"evidenceRank":781,"evidenceScore":65.6,"freshAt":"2018-01-12T00:05:59Z","freshnessRank":1113,"freshEventScore":105,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 667 pts / 549 comments (2016) + 105 pts / 57 comments (2018), different submitters and 722 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":6,"peak_score":667,"peak_comments":549,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10938593","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15051791","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":105,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16129276","height":5,"chart_height":27},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20529943","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23165087","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-browser-brave-loads-major-news-sites-2x-8x-faster-d9d023527426.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-browser-brave-loads-major-news-sites-2x-8x-faster-d9d023527426/"},{"slug":"pico-css-minimal-css-framework-for-semantic-html-d9d023644b46","title":"Pico CSS – Minimal CSS Framework for Semantic HTML","domain":"picocss.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["web_development","visual_design","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2025-09","inductedMonth":"2025-09","submissions":9,"submitters":8,"spanYears":4.6,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":413,"evidenceRank":782,"evidenceScore":65.6,"freshAt":"2025-09-07T20:31:38Z","freshnessRank":151,"freshEventScore":376,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 413 pts / 100 comments (2021) + 376 pts / 108 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,362 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":413,"peak_comments":100,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29559961","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37574070","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41424591","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":376,"peak_comments":108,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45161855","height":18,"chart_height":155},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/pico-css-minimal-css-framework-for-semantic-html-d9d023644b46.jpg","path":"/hall/link/pico-css-minimal-css-framework-for-semantic-html-d9d023644b46/"},{"slug":"world-airports-voronoi-2014-d9d0234c8c2a","title":"World Airports Voronoi (2014)","domain":"www.jasondavies.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"space_transportation","topicDisplay":"Space & transportation","tags":["aviation","mathematics","computer_graphics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2018-06","inductedMonth":"2025-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":10.771,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":424,"evidenceRank":783,"evidenceScore":65.6,"freshAt":"2018-06-18T12:11:41Z","freshnessRank":1091,"freshEventScore":424,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 424 pts / 107 comments (2018) + 338 pts / 82 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,019 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7557438","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":338,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10161326","height":16,"chart_height":136},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":424,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17337600","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22498585","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42707297","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/world-airports-voronoi-2014-d9d0234c8c2a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/world-airports-voronoi-2014-d9d0234c8c2a/"},{"slug":"hn-the-good-parts-2017-d9d0235509cb","title":"HN: The Good Parts (2017)","domain":"danluu.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["online_communities","internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-10","inductedMonth":"2021-05","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.01,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":733,"evidenceRank":784,"evidenceScore":65.6,"freshAt":"2022-10-27T22:30:24Z","freshnessRank":700,"freshEventScore":37,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 733 pts / 359 comments (2016) + 105 pts / 82 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,655 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":733,"peak_comments":359,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12772925","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":144,"peak_comments":35,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20092118","height":7,"chart_height":33},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24664558","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":105,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27049601","height":5,"chart_height":24},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":37,"peak_comments":48,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33364865","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/hn-the-good-parts-2017-d9d0235509cb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/hn-the-good-parts-2017-d9d0235509cb/"},{"slug":"a-hands-on-introduction-to-video-technology-image-video-codec-an-d9d023567fc2","title":"A hands-on introduction to video technology: image, video, codec and more","domain":"github.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["computer_graphics","performance_reliability","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2019-11","inductedMonth":"2019-11","submissions":9,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.33,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":694,"evidenceRank":785,"evidenceScore":65.6,"freshAt":"2019-11-21T11:37:59Z","freshnessRank":1034,"freshEventScore":561,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 694 pts / 74 comments (2017) + 561 pts / 48 comments (2019), different submitters and 901 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":694,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14475884","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18777142","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":561,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21593158","height":24,"chart_height":137},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23676457","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36812037","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-hands-on-introduction-to-video-technology-image-video-codec-an-d9d023567fc2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-hands-on-introduction-to-video-technology-image-video-codec-an-d9d023567fc2/"},{"slug":"ligatures-in-programming-fonts-hell-no-d9d0235d9d1e","title":"Ligatures in programming fonts: hell no","domain":"practicaltypography.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design","programming_languages","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2021-12","inductedMonth":"2026-02","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":6.776,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":251,"evidenceRank":786,"evidenceScore":65.6,"freshAt":"2023-05-13T05:19:00Z","freshnessRank":630,"freshEventScore":251,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 157 pts / 195 comments (2021) + 124 pts / 86 comments (2019), different submitters and 964 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":124,"peak_comments":86,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19805053","height":6,"chart_height":84},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25161498","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":157,"peak_comments":195,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29637876","height":8,"chart_height":106},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":251,"peak_comments":191,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35925821","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46951883","height":4,"chart_height":9}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/ligatures-in-programming-fonts-hell-no-d9d0235d9d1e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/ligatures-in-programming-fonts-hell-no-d9d0235d9d1e/"},{"slug":"end-of-life-of-technologies-and-devices-d9d0235ddf81","title":"End of Life of Technologies and Devices","domain":"endoflife.date","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-02","inductedMonth":"2023-12","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":5.996,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":315,"evidenceRank":787,"evidenceScore":65.6,"freshAt":"2023-12-10T07:10:12Z","freshnessRank":485,"freshEventScore":315,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 315 pts / 77 comments (2023) + 248 pts / 80 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,656 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":248,"peak_comments":80,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20033728","height":12,"chart_height":134},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28011326","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":219,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30499023","height":11,"chart_height":118},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":315,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38589742","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44094693","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/end-of-life-of-technologies-and-devices-d9d0235ddf81.jpg","path":"/hall/link/end-of-life-of-technologies-and-devices-d9d0235ddf81/"},{"slug":"goodbye-clean-code-d9d023601c34","title":"Goodbye, Clean Code","domain":"overreacted.io","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-06","inductedMonth":"2023-12","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.907,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1678,"evidenceRank":788,"evidenceScore":65.6,"freshAt":"2023-12-08T07:12:15Z","freshnessRank":487,"freshEventScore":386,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1678 pts / 575 comments (2020) + 386 pts / 330 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,426 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1678,"peak_comments":575,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22022466","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":266,"peak_comments":212,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29239861","height":13,"chart_height":27},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":386,"peak_comments":330,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38566235","height":19,"chart_height":39},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/goodbye-clean-code-d9d023601c34.jpg","path":"/hall/link/goodbye-clean-code-d9d023601c34/"},{"slug":"notes-on-programming-in-c-rob-pike-1989-d9d02341e60d","title":"Notes on Programming in C – Rob Pike (1989)","domain":"www.lysator.liu.se","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2017-01","inductedMonth":"2025-08","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":14.804,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":134,"evidenceRank":789,"evidenceScore":65.5,"freshAt":"2025-08-29T01:18:26Z","freshnessRank":157,"freshEventScore":30,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 122 pts / 111 comments (2010) + 134 pts / 39 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,315 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":122,"peak_comments":111,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1887442","height":6,"chart_height":155},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":54,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7728084","height":4,"chart_height":69},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":134,"peak_comments":39,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13852734","height":6,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":30,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45058925","height":4,"chart_height":38},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/notes-on-programming-in-c-rob-pike-1989-d9d02341e60d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/notes-on-programming-in-c-rob-pike-1989-d9d02341e60d/"},{"slug":"ulisp-d9d02353b062","title":"uLisp","domain":"www.ulisp.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","embedded_iot","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-05","inductedMonth":"2021-05","submissions":8,"submitters":6,"spanYears":10.018,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":377,"evidenceRank":790,"evidenceScore":65.5,"freshAt":"2021-05-04T11:17:24Z","freshnessRank":916,"freshEventScore":377,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 377 pts / 87 comments (2021) + 104 pts / 33 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,803 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":104,"peak_comments":33,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11777662","height":5,"chart_height":47},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16980856","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22647402","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":377,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27036317","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36815100","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41681705","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48367880","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/ulisp-d9d02353b062.jpg","path":"/hall/link/ulisp-d9d02353b062/"},{"slug":"cameras-and-lenses-d9d02363bd29","title":"Cameras and Lenses","domain":"ciechanow.ski","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["physics","photography","computer_graphics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2026-01","inductedMonth":"2026-01","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":5.068,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":2132,"evidenceRank":791,"evidenceScore":65.5,"freshAt":"2026-01-01T17:18:01Z","freshnessRank":91,"freshEventScore":549,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 2132 pts / 212 comments (2020) + 549 pts / 57 comments (2026), different submitters and 1,849 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":2132,"peak_comments":212,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25357315","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33008943","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40095523","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":549,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46455872","height":24,"chart_height":44}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/cameras-and-lenses-d9d02363bd29.jpg","path":"/hall/link/cameras-and-lenses-d9d02363bd29/"},{"slug":"netsurf-a-multi-platform-web-browser-d9d02351a29a","title":"NetSurf, a multi-platform web browser","domain":"www.netsurf-browser.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["browsers_web_standards","open_source","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2020-08","inductedMonth":"2024-01","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":8.211,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":202,"evidenceRank":792,"evidenceScore":65.5,"freshAt":"2024-01-04T06:52:31Z","freshnessRank":468,"freshEventScore":133,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 202 pts / 100 comments (2020) + 156 pts / 70 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,757 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":156,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10417807","height":7,"chart_height":131},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15574598","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":202,"peak_comments":100,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24123726","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38804205","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":133,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38863933","height":6,"chart_height":112},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/netsurf-a-multi-platform-web-browser-d9d02351a29a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/netsurf-a-multi-platform-web-browser-d9d02351a29a/"},{"slug":"moreutils-a-collection-of-unix-tools-that-nobody-thought-to-writ-d9d02353fa32","title":"Moreutils: A collection of Unix tools that nobody thought to write long ago","domain":"joeyh.name","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-08","inductedMonth":"2022-04","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.799,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":612,"evidenceRank":793,"evidenceScore":65.5,"freshAt":"2022-04-15T18:16:08Z","freshnessRank":792,"freshEventScore":612,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 612 pts / 258 comments (2022) + 154 pts / 56 comments (2016), different submitters and 2,113 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":154,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12023277","height":7,"chart_height":43},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18772237","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":266,"peak_comments":220,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24241986","height":13,"chart_height":74},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":612,"peak_comments":258,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31043655","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/moreutils-a-collection-of-unix-tools-that-nobody-thought-to-writ-d9d02353fa32.jpg","path":"/hall/link/moreutils-a-collection-of-unix-tools-that-nobody-thought-to-writ-d9d02353fa32/"},{"slug":"monica-open-source-personal-crm-d9d0235bef73","title":"Monica: Open-source personal CRM","domain":"www.monicahq.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["personal_productivity","open_source","privacy_surveillance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2022-11","inductedMonth":"2022-11","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":7.329,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":372,"evidenceRank":794,"evidenceScore":65.5,"freshAt":"2022-11-14T09:56:30Z","freshnessRank":688,"freshEventScore":286,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 286 pts / 137 comments (2022) + 372 pts / 129 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,059 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18381913","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":372,"peak_comments":129,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21850155","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26852183","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":286,"peak_comments":137,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33591970","height":14,"chart_height":131},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47257941","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/monica-open-source-personal-crm-d9d0235bef73.jpg","path":"/hall/link/monica-open-source-personal-crm-d9d0235bef73/"},{"slug":"screenshots-from-developers-2002-vs-2015-2015-d9d023521d6a","title":"Screenshots from developers: 2002 vs. 2015 (2015)","domain":"anders.unix.se","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","developer_tools","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2025-12","inductedMonth":"2025-12","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":9.99,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":462,"evidenceRank":795,"evidenceScore":65.4,"freshAt":"2025-12-06T21:55:09Z","freshnessRank":103,"freshEventScore":462,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 462 pts / 243 comments (2025) + 198 pts / 82 comments (2015), different submitters and 3,647 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":5,"peak_score":198,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10722536","height":10,"chart_height":73},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":57,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26119769","height":4,"chart_height":21},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34886807","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":462,"peak_comments":243,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46176905","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/screenshots-from-developers-2002-vs-2015-2015-d9d023521d6a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/screenshots-from-developers-2002-vs-2015-2015-d9d023521d6a/"},{"slug":"low-level-is-easy-2008-d9d0233e836c","title":"Low level is easy (2008)","domain":"yosefk.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","computer_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2021-07","inductedMonth":"2021-07","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":14.768,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":166,"evidenceRank":796,"evidenceScore":65.4,"freshAt":"2023-01-29T10:50:15Z","freshnessRank":658,"freshEventScore":93,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 153 pts / 101 comments (2021) + 166 pts / 56 comments (2014), different submitters and 2,671 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=171460","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":166,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7538150","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9405266","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":72,"peak_comments":26,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20568736","height":4,"chart_height":74},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":153,"peak_comments":101,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27995788","height":7,"chart_height":157},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":93,"peak_comments":24,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34566918","height":4,"chart_height":95},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/low-level-is-easy-2008-d9d0233e836c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/low-level-is-easy-2008-d9d0233e836c/"},{"slug":"gogs-go-git-service-d9d0234dcd87","title":"Gogs – Go Git Service","domain":"gogs.io","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2018-11","inductedMonth":"2018-11","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":6.39,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":341,"evidenceRank":797,"evidenceScore":65.4,"freshAt":"2018-11-10T19:10:50Z","freshnessRank":1077,"freshEventScore":101,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 341 pts / 183 comments (2016) + 101 pts / 49 comments (2018), different submitters and 957 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8246168","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9146292","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":341,"peak_comments":183,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11374003","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15988008","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":4,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":49,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18422931","height":5,"chart_height":50},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25831384","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/gogs-go-git-service-d9d0234dcd87.jpg","path":"/hall/link/gogs-go-git-service-d9d0234dcd87/"},{"slug":"tox-a-new-kind-of-instant-messaging-d9d023511fd3","title":"TOX – A New Kind of Instant Messaging","domain":"tox.chat","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography","privacy_surveillance","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-01","inductedMonth":"2021-10","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":7.918,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":138,"evidenceRank":798,"evidenceScore":65.4,"freshAt":"2021-10-05T12:38:44Z","freshnessRank":866,"freshEventScore":133,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 138 pts / 107 comments (2016) + 133 pts / 81 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,824 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10110346","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":138,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12657891","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":108,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18839939","height":5,"chart_height":133},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":133,"peak_comments":81,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28758545","height":6,"chart_height":164},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36861739","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/tox-a-new-kind-of-instant-messaging-d9d023511fd3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/tox-a-new-kind-of-instant-messaging-d9d023511fd3/"},{"slug":"algebraic-effects-for-the-rest-of-us-d9d0235e65e3","title":"Algebraic Effects for the Rest of Us","domain":"overreacted.io","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","software_architecture","theory_of_computation"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2026-05","inductedMonth":"2026-05","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":6.847,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":239,"evidenceRank":799,"evidenceScore":65.4,"freshAt":"2026-05-26T17:38:51Z","freshnessRank":13,"freshEventScore":107,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 239 pts / 103 comments (2019) + 107 pts / 89 comments (2026), different submitters and 2,500 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":239,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20496043","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28835723","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32723406","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38669520","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40826052","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45656433","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":107,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48283009","height":5,"chart_height":76}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/algebraic-effects-for-the-rest-of-us-d9d0235e65e3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/algebraic-effects-for-the-rest-of-us-d9d0235e65e3/"},{"slug":"modifications-to-google-chromium-for-removing-google-integration-d9d02354c767","title":"Modifications to Google Chromium for removing Google integration","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["browsers_web_standards","privacy_surveillance","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-06","inductedMonth":"2020-06","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.699,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1105,"evidenceRank":800,"evidenceScore":65.4,"freshAt":"2020-06-07T04:55:24Z","freshnessRank":1002,"freshEventScore":325,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 688 pts / 423 comments (2016) + 1105 pts / 306 comments (2018), different submitters and 727 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":688,"peak_comments":423,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12577787","height":24,"chart_height":106},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":1105,"peak_comments":306,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18053337","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":325,"peak_comments":266,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23444864","height":16,"chart_height":50},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/modifications-to-google-chromium-for-removing-google-integration-d9d02354c767.jpg","path":"/hall/link/modifications-to-google-chromium-for-removing-google-integration-d9d02354c767/"},{"slug":"linux-containers-in-500-lines-of-code-d9d02354fa57","title":"Linux containers in 500 lines of code","domain":"blog.lizzie.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","application_security","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-02","inductedMonth":"2020-02","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.804,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":440,"evidenceRank":801,"evidenceScore":65.3,"freshAt":"2022-03-10T04:56:46Z","freshnessRank":807,"freshEventScore":250,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 440 pts / 49 comments (2017) + 267 pts / 28 comments (2020), different submitters and 823 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12724423","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":440,"peak_comments":49,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15608435","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":267,"peak_comments":28,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22232705","height":13,"chart_height":103},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":250,"peak_comments":27,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30623372","height":12,"chart_height":97},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37029406","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/linux-containers-in-500-lines-of-code-d9d02354fa57.jpg","path":"/hall/link/linux-containers-in-500-lines-of-code-d9d02354fa57/"},{"slug":"filecoin-data-storage-network-and-crypto-currency-based-on-bitco-d9d0234d6db5","title":"Filecoin – Data storage network and crypto-currency based on Bitcoin","domain":"filecoin.io","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["distributed_systems","databases_storage","cryptography"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2017-02","inductedMonth":"2017-02","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":7.693,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":281,"evidenceRank":802,"evidenceScore":65.3,"freshAt":"2017-02-24T14:07:31Z","freshnessRank":1134,"freshEventScore":145,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 281 pts / 137 comments (2014) + 145 pts / 62 comments (2017), different submitters and 951 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":281,"peak_comments":137,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8054571","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10484707","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":145,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13723722","height":7,"chart_height":88},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17799661","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30816699","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/filecoin-data-storage-network-and-crypto-currency-based-on-bitco-d9d0234d6db5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/filecoin-data-storage-network-and-crypto-currency-based-on-bitco-d9d0234d6db5/"},{"slug":"google-humans-txt-d9d023431f3f","title":"Google humans.txt","domain":"www.google.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"source_code","typeDisplay":"Source code","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2016-04","inductedMonth":"2024-07","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":14.39,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":358,"evidenceRank":803,"evidenceScore":65.3,"freshAt":"2016-04-14T17:25:02Z","freshnessRank":1153,"freshEventScore":205,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 358 pts / 57 comments (2011) + 205 pts / 87 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,804 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":358,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2522220","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7285016","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":205,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11498672","height":10,"chart_height":97},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33745879","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41040678","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45378508","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/google-humans-txt-d9d023431f3f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/google-humans-txt-d9d023431f3f/"},{"slug":"osx-kvm-run-macos-on-qemu-kvm-d9d02354c0a0","title":"Osx-kvm: Run macOS on QEMU/KVM","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","computer_architecture","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-12","inductedMonth":"2021-12","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":7.693,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":299,"evidenceRank":804,"evidenceScore":65.3,"freshAt":"2021-12-03T05:18:17Z","freshnessRank":852,"freshEventScore":166,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 299 pts / 106 comments (2018) + 166 pts / 70 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,206 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":185,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12556609","height":9,"chart_height":105},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":299,"peak_comments":106,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17763855","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25591415","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":166,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29426862","height":8,"chart_height":94},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40556418","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/osx-kvm-run-macos-on-qemu-kvm-d9d02354c0a0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/osx-kvm-run-macos-on-qemu-kvm-d9d02354c0a0/"},{"slug":"bruno-simon-3d-portfolio-d9d0235f596f","title":"Bruno Simon – 3D Portfolio","domain":"bruno-simon.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["user_experience","web_development","computer_graphics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2025-12","inductedMonth":"2025-12","submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":6.127,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":777,"evidenceRank":805,"evidenceScore":65.2,"freshAt":"2025-12-09T16:06:58Z","freshnessRank":101,"freshEventScore":777,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 777 pts / 188 comments (2025) + 251 pts / 42 comments (2019), different submitters and 2,236 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":251,"peak_comments":42,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21362200","height":12,"chart_height":55},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":5,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29261594","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32970011","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":777,"peak_comments":188,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46206531","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/bruno-simon-3d-portfolio-d9d0235f596f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/bruno-simon-3d-portfolio-d9d0235f596f/"},{"slug":"pyxel-a-retro-game-development-environment-in-python-d9d0235b0acf","title":"Pyxel: A retro game development environment in Python","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_development","programming_languages","retrocomputing"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2024-07","inductedMonth":"2024-07","submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":5.941,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":549,"evidenceRank":806,"evidenceScore":65.2,"freshAt":"2024-07-07T18:38:06Z","freshnessRank":366,"freshEventScore":276,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 549 pts / 63 comments (2018) + 276 pts / 39 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,166 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":5,"peak_score":549,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17669377","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28737116","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32479008","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38414347","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":276,"peak_comments":39,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40899520","height":13,"chart_height":85},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/pyxel-a-retro-game-development-environment-in-python-d9d0235b0acf.jpg","path":"/hall/link/pyxel-a-retro-game-development-environment-in-python-d9d0235b0acf/"},{"slug":"ryujinx-nintendo-switch-emulator-has-been-removed-from-github-d9d02364b473","title":"Ryujinx (Nintendo Switch emulator) has been removed from GitHub","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["emulation","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2023-05","inductedMonth":"2024-10","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.554,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":473,"evidenceRank":807,"evidenceScore":65.2,"freshAt":"2024-10-01T17:46:16Z","freshnessRank":323,"freshEventScore":473,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 473 pts / 419 comments (2024) + 333 pts / 167 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,297 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":333,"peak_comments":167,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26450096","height":16,"chart_height":120},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":252,"peak_comments":194,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35810977","height":12,"chart_height":91},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":473,"peak_comments":419,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41711709","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/ryujinx-nintendo-switch-emulator-has-been-removed-from-github-d9d02364b473/"},{"slug":"britain-today-generating-90-of-electricity-from-renewables-d9d023600486","title":"Britain today generating 90%+ of electricity from renewables","domain":"grid.iamkate.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"live_data_dashboard","typeDisplay":"Live-data dashboards","topic":"environment_energy","topicDisplay":"Environment & energy","tags":["energy","climate_environment","data_science"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2026-03","inductedMonth":"2026-03","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.234,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":415,"evidenceRank":808,"evidenceScore":65.2,"freshAt":"2026-03-28T11:06:44Z","freshnessRank":37,"freshEventScore":415,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 415 pts / 299 comments (2026) + 140 pts / 166 comments (2023), different submitters and 828 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21939073","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32223611","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":140,"peak_comments":166,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38718702","height":7,"chart_height":57},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":3,"peak_score":415,"peak_comments":299,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47553484","height":20,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/britain-today-generating-90-of-electricity-from-renewables-d9d023600486.jpg","path":"/hall/link/britain-today-generating-90-of-electricity-from-renewables-d9d023600486/"},{"slug":"the-average-font-d9d0234469c3","title":"The Average Font","domain":"iotic.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2025-11","inductedMonth":"2025-11","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":14.026,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":481,"evidenceRank":809,"evidenceScore":65.2,"freshAt":"2025-11-08T19:29:44Z","freshnessRank":119,"freshEventScore":233,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 481 pts / 63 comments (2012) + 233 pts / 50 comments (2025), different submitters and 4,947 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":34,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3174040","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":481,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3877025","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20861027","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26495027","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39520331","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":233,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45859243","height":11,"chart_height":82},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-average-font-d9d0234469c3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-average-font-d9d0234469c3/"},{"slug":"how-to-criticize-computer-scientists-2001-d9d0233f3073","title":"How to Criticize Computer Scientists (2001)","domain":"www.cs.purdue.edu","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":[],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2021-03","inductedMonth":"2021-03","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":13.791,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":264,"evidenceRank":810,"evidenceScore":65.1,"freshAt":"2021-03-28T11:39:41Z","freshnessRank":932,"freshEventScore":232,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 232 pts / 101 comments (2021) + 264 pts / 93 comments (2011), different submitters and 3,652 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":81,"peak_comments":18,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=436058","height":4,"chart_height":52},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":264,"peak_comments":93,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2379758","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8637850","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11091229","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":232,"peak_comments":101,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26609492","height":11,"chart_height":149},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33416600","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-to-criticize-computer-scientists-2001-d9d0233f3073.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-to-criticize-computer-scientists-2001-d9d0233f3073/"},{"slug":"rooms-and-mazes-a-procedural-dungeon-generator-2014-d9d0234ed3e1","title":"Rooms and mazes: A procedural dungeon generator (2014)","domain":"journal.stuffwithstuff.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_development","algorithms_data_structures","computer_graphics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2019-07","inductedMonth":"2022-04","submissions":6,"submitters":4,"spanYears":10.809,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":332,"evidenceRank":811,"evidenceScore":65.1,"freshAt":"2022-04-20T13:48:46Z","freshnessRank":790,"freshEventScore":163,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 332 pts / 48 comments (2014) + 163 pts / 30 comments (2022), different submitters and 2,676 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":332,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8782295","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12945161","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16953781","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":107,"peak_comments":15,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20533546","height":5,"chart_height":55},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":163,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31096914","height":8,"chart_height":83},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45574436","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/rooms-and-mazes-a-procedural-dungeon-generator-2014-d9d0234ed3e1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/rooms-and-mazes-a-procedural-dungeon-generator-2014-d9d0234ed3e1/"},{"slug":"google-s-director-of-engineering-hiring-test-d9d02354f2d8","title":"Google's “Director of Engineering” Hiring Test","domain":"www.gwan.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["hiring_interviews","leadership","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-12","inductedMonth":"2022-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.218,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1764,"evidenceRank":812,"evidenceScore":65.1,"freshAt":"2022-01-01T16:54:04Z","freshnessRank":840,"freshEventScore":144,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1764 pts / 923 comments (2016) + 144 pts / 68 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,906 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":1764,"peak_comments":923,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12701272","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":569,"peak_comments":333,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16932006","height":24,"chart_height":55},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25518207","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":144,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29760190","height":7,"chart_height":14},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/google-s-director-of-engineering-hiring-test-d9d02354f2d8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/google-s-director-of-engineering-hiring-test-d9d02354f2d8/"},{"slug":"galactic-algorithm-d9d0235e2a00","title":"Galactic Algorithm","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["algorithms_data_structures","theory_of_computation"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-12","inductedMonth":"2023-12","submissions":9,"submitters":8,"spanYears":6.798,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":382,"evidenceRank":813,"evidenceScore":65.1,"freshAt":"2026-04-13T11:27:12Z","freshnessRank":29,"freshEventScore":29,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 382 pts / 71 comments (2019) + 123 pts / 25 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,519 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":382,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21163620","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26956109","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":25,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32126107","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":123,"peak_comments":25,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38500782","height":6,"chart_height":55},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45130802","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":29,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47750519","height":4,"chart_height":13}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/galactic-algorithm-d9d0235e2a00.jpg","path":"/hall/link/galactic-algorithm-d9d0235e2a00/"},{"slug":"show-hn-learn-how-webrtc-actually-works-a-book-on-the-protocols-d9d02362b161","title":"Show HN: Learn how WebRTC actually works. A book on the protocols, not just APIs","domain":"webrtcforthecurious.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","web_development","internet_infrastructure"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2024-01","inductedMonth":"2024-01","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":4.624,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":667,"evidenceRank":814,"evidenceScore":65.1,"freshAt":"2025-04-11T15:18:21Z","freshnessRank":224,"freshEventScore":223,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 667 pts / 72 comments (2020) + 223 pts / 48 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,684 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":667,"peak_comments":72,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24323589","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30396776","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37186789","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":205,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38875542","height":10,"chart_height":52},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":223,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43654813","height":11,"chart_height":57},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/show-hn-learn-how-webrtc-actually-works-a-book-on-the-protocols-d9d02362b161.jpg","path":"/hall/link/show-hn-learn-how-webrtc-actually-works-a-book-on-the-protocols-d9d02362b161/"},{"slug":"1-rule-d9d023423fe0","title":"1% rule","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["internet_culture","online_communities"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2020-03","inductedMonth":"2020-03","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":9.216,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":465,"evidenceRank":815,"evidenceScore":65.1,"freshAt":"2020-03-18T23:27:06Z","freshnessRank":1017,"freshEventScore":465,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 465 pts / 151 comments (2020) + 105 pts / 61 comments (2014), different submitters and 2,256 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2074829","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":105,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7051355","height":5,"chart_height":38},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12978033","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19675002","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":465,"peak_comments":151,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22622574","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/1-rule-d9d023423fe0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/1-rule-d9d023423fe0/"},{"slug":"you-shouldn-t-parse-the-output-of-ls-1-d9d0234d54ab","title":"You shouldn't parse the output of ls(1)","domain":"mywiki.wooledge.org","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2024-06","inductedMonth":"2024-06","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":9.944,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":149,"evidenceRank":816,"evidenceScore":65.0,"freshAt":"2024-06-15T21:06:07Z","freshnessRank":377,"freshEventScore":96,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 149 pts / 148 comments (2021) + 96 pts / 83 comments (2024), different submitters and 897 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":31,"peak_comments":18,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7994720","height":4,"chart_height":35},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8914841","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11007601","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18753980","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":149,"peak_comments":148,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29747034","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":96,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40692698","height":5,"chart_height":110},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/you-shouldn-t-parse-the-output-of-ls-1-d9d0234d54ab.jpg","path":"/hall/link/you-shouldn-t-parse-the-output-of-ls-1-d9d0234d54ab/"},{"slug":"the-python-paradox-d9d0234244b8","title":"The Python Paradox","domain":"www.paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","hiring_interviews"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2023-01","inductedMonth":"2023-01","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":12.049,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":161,"evidenceRank":817,"evidenceScore":65.0,"freshAt":"2023-01-27T02:57:48Z","freshnessRank":660,"freshEventScore":148,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 148 pts / 269 comments (2023) + 161 pts / 78 comments (2011), different submitters and 4,400 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":161,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2084732","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5571840","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18711364","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30472551","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":148,"peak_comments":269,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34541933","height":7,"chart_height":156},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-python-paradox-d9d0234244b8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-python-paradox-d9d0234244b8/"},{"slug":"all-software-sucks-d9d0234a7d56","title":"All software sucks","domain":"harmful.cat-v.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2018-08","inductedMonth":"2018-08","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":8.329,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":98,"evidenceRank":818,"evidenceScore":65.0,"freshAt":"2018-08-30T12:45:03Z","freshnessRank":1086,"freshEventScore":42,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 98 pts / 138 comments (2014) + 42 pts / 50 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,594 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6346082","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":98,"peak_comments":138,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7613239","height":5,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11278554","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14059673","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":42,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17876207","height":4,"chart_height":73},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21824415","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29803196","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/all-software-sucks-d9d0234a7d56.jpg","path":"/hall/link/all-software-sucks-d9d0234a7d56/"},{"slug":"floating-point-visually-explained-2017-d9d02357ff5b","title":"Floating point visually explained (2017)","domain":"fabiensanglard.net","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","computer_architecture","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-11","inductedMonth":"2021-11","submissions":9,"submitters":8,"spanYears":8.192,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":451,"evidenceRank":819,"evidenceScore":65.0,"freshAt":"2021-11-28T12:49:44Z","freshnessRank":853,"freshEventScore":288,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 451 pts / 106 comments (2017) + 288 pts / 57 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,521 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":451,"peak_comments":106,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15359574","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22380838","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":288,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29368529","height":14,"chart_height":109},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40130934","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45854288","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/floating-point-visually-explained-2017-d9d02357ff5b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/floating-point-visually-explained-2017-d9d02357ff5b/"},{"slug":"qwant-the-search-engine-that-respects-your-privacy-d9d02350e1a0","title":"Qwant: The Search Engine That Respects Your Privacy","domain":"www.qwant.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["information_retrieval","privacy_surveillance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2020-11","inductedMonth":"2020-11","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":9.013,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":133,"evidenceRank":820,"evidenceScore":65.0,"freshAt":"2020-11-12T19:49:33Z","freshnessRank":973,"freshEventScore":133,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 133 pts / 104 comments (2020) + 72 pts / 71 comments (2018), different submitters and 790 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9960286","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12006445","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":72,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17987220","height":4,"chart_height":92},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":133,"peak_comments":104,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25074053","height":6,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41130007","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/qwant-the-search-engine-that-respects-your-privacy-d9d02350e1a0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/qwant-the-search-engine-that-respects-your-privacy-d9d02350e1a0/"},{"slug":"common-calendrical-fallacies-d9d023567ca9","title":"Common Calendrical Fallacies","domain":"yourcalendricalfallacyis.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","performance_reliability","mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2022-02","inductedMonth":"2022-02","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":7.376,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":256,"evidenceRank":821,"evidenceScore":65.0,"freshAt":"2022-02-08T11:49:53Z","freshnessRank":828,"freshEventScore":72,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 256 pts / 140 comments (2018) + 72 pts / 52 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,237 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13924947","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":256,"peak_comments":140,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18031214","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24703678","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":72,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30257363","height":4,"chart_height":48},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35976992","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41164797","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/common-calendrical-fallacies-d9d023567ca9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/common-calendrical-fallacies-d9d023567ca9/"},{"slug":"daisyui-tailwind-css-components-d9d02365fff4","title":"DaisyUI – Tailwind CSS Components","domain":"daisyui.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["web_development","developer_tools","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2025-07","inductedMonth":"2025-07","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":3.978,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":474,"evidenceRank":822,"evidenceScore":65.0,"freshAt":"2025-07-22T13:48:55Z","freshnessRank":187,"freshEventScore":227,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 227 pts / 176 comments (2025) + 474 pts / 166 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,453 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":474,"peak_comments":166,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28004515","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33953250","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37665127","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41651613","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":227,"peak_comments":176,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44646869","height":11,"chart_height":81},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/daisyui-tailwind-css-components-d9d02365fff4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/daisyui-tailwind-css-components-d9d02365fff4/"},{"slug":"scala-school-d9d023492725","title":"Scala School","domain":"twitter.github.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"course_lecture","typeDisplay":"Courses & lectures","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","testing_quality","distributed_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-03","inductedMonth":"2016-03","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":9.64,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":224,"evidenceRank":823,"evidenceScore":64.9,"freshAt":"2016-03-11T03:21:28Z","freshnessRank":1155,"freshEventScore":224,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 224 pts / 173 comments (2016) + 164 pts / 73 comments (2013), different submitters and 934 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":164,"peak_comments":73,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6236967","height":8,"chart_height":124},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8518863","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9720209","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":224,"peak_comments":173,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11264454","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16749663","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33916679","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/scala-school-d9d023492725.jpg","path":"/hall/link/scala-school-d9d023492725/"},{"slug":"city-roads-draw-all-roads-in-a-city-at-once-d9d0236034e8","title":"City Roads – Draw all roads in a city at once","domain":"anvaka.github.io","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["cities_infrastructure","transportation"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-05","inductedMonth":"2024-12","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.917,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":668,"evidenceRank":824,"evidenceScore":64.9,"freshAt":"2024-12-21T18:16:01Z","freshnessRank":280,"freshEventScore":471,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 668 pts / 143 comments (2020) + 471 pts / 59 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,794 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":668,"peak_comments":143,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22120449","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":173,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27410317","height":8,"chart_height":44},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35943032","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":471,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42481206","height":23,"chart_height":120},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/city-roads-draw-all-roads-in-a-city-at-once-d9d0236034e8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/city-roads-draw-all-roads-in-a-city-at-once-d9d0236034e8/"},{"slug":"don-norman-on-how-design-fails-older-consumers-d9d0235dae25","title":"Don Norman on how design fails older consumers","domain":"www.fastcompany.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-10","inductedMonth":"2023-10","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":4.441,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":234,"evidenceRank":825,"evidenceScore":64.9,"freshAt":"2023-10-16T16:37:00Z","freshnessRank":515,"freshEventScore":202,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 234 pts / 148 comments (2019) + 202 pts / 129 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,621 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":234,"peak_comments":148,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19862536","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":27,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27049977","height":4,"chart_height":20},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":202,"peak_comments":129,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37902412","height":10,"chart_height":147},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/don-norman-on-how-design-fails-older-consumers-d9d0235dae25/"},{"slug":"single-file-c-c-public-domain-open-source-libraries-with-minimal-d9d02355936d","title":"Single-file C/C++ public-domain/open source libraries with minimal dependencies","domain":"github.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","open_source","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-10","inductedMonth":"2020-10","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":7.91,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":303,"evidenceRank":826,"evidenceScore":64.9,"freshAt":"2020-10-26T02:45:43Z","freshnessRank":979,"freshEventScore":115,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 115 pts / 109 comments (2020) + 303 pts / 64 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,408 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":303,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13202114","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20056268","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":115,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24892400","height":6,"chart_height":65},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42139059","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/single-file-c-c-public-domain-open-source-libraries-with-minimal-d9d02355936d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/single-file-c-c-public-domain-open-source-libraries-with-minimal-d9d02355936d/"},{"slug":"amazon-web-services-in-plain-english-d9d0235147b2","title":"Amazon Web Services in Plain English","domain":"www.expeditedssl.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["internet_infrastructure","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-06","inductedMonth":"2018-11","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.187,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1479,"evidenceRank":827,"evidenceScore":64.8,"freshAt":"2018-11-17T13:53:35Z","freshnessRank":1076,"freshEventScore":483,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1479 pts / 223 comments (2015) + 483 pts / 105 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,163 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":1479,"peak_comments":223,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10202286","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":655,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13442022","height":24,"chart_height":75},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":483,"peak_comments":105,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18475518","height":23,"chart_height":56},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/amazon-web-services-in-plain-english-d9d0235147b2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/amazon-web-services-in-plain-english-d9d0235147b2/"},{"slug":"there-s-no-fire-alarm-for-artificial-general-intelligence-d9d023586ca4","title":"There's No Fire Alarm for Artificial General Intelligence","domain":"intelligence.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["artificial_intelligence","technology_ethics","psychology"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-06","inductedMonth":"2022-08","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.1,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":219,"evidenceRank":828,"evidenceScore":64.8,"freshAt":"2020-06-03T08:40:11Z","freshnessRank":1003,"freshEventScore":111,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 219 pts / 206 comments (2017) + 111 pts / 123 comments (2020), different submitters and 963 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":219,"peak_comments":206,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15470920","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19077685","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":111,"peak_comments":123,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23401328","height":5,"chart_height":86},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32557963","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38348897","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/there-s-no-fire-alarm-for-artificial-general-intelligence-d9d023586ca4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/there-s-no-fire-alarm-for-artificial-general-intelligence-d9d023586ca4/"},{"slug":"headscale-open-source-implementation-of-the-tailscale-control-se-d9d023659f3b","title":"Headscale: Open-source implementation of the Tailscale control server","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["protocols_networking","open_source","internet_infrastructure"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2025-04","inductedMonth":"2025-04","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":3.795,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":363,"evidenceRank":829,"evidenceScore":64.8,"freshAt":"2025-04-03T00:23:29Z","freshnessRank":229,"freshEventScore":345,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 363 pts / 66 comments (2021) + 345 pts / 83 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,293 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":363,"peak_comments":66,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28572013","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33999398","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35910837","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41731636","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":345,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43563396","height":17,"chart_height":162},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/headscale-open-source-implementation-of-the-tailscale-control-se-d9d023659f3b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/headscale-open-source-implementation-of-the-tailscale-control-se-d9d023659f3b/"},{"slug":"speed-test-d9d02361abae","title":"Speed Test","domain":"speed.cloudflare.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["internet_infrastructure","protocols_networking","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-08","inductedMonth":"2025-09","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.01,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":664,"evidenceRank":830,"evidenceScore":64.7,"freshAt":"2023-08-10T09:30:44Z","freshnessRank":573,"freshEventScore":664,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 664 pts / 207 comments (2023) + 498 pts / 151 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,170 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":498,"peak_comments":151,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23313657","height":24,"chart_height":128},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":36,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28591474","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":664,"peak_comments":207,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37073885","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45376611","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48339268","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/speed-test-d9d02361abae/"},{"slug":"structure-and-interpretation-of-computer-programs-interactive-ve-d9d0234a6fb8","title":"Structure and Interpretation of Computer Programs: Interactive Version","domain":"xuanji.appspot.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2019-01","inductedMonth":"2021-05","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":9.172,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":458,"evidenceRank":831,"evidenceScore":64.7,"freshAt":"2019-01-31T22:53:10Z","freshnessRank":1068,"freshEventScore":458,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 458 pts / 16 comments (2019) + 213 pts / 14 comments (2014), different submitters and 1,550 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":29,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6314778","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":213,"peak_comments":14,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8550274","height":10,"chart_height":79},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9277275","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":458,"peak_comments":16,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19049834","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27289588","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32056799","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/structure-and-interpretation-of-computer-programs-interactive-ve-d9d0234a6fb8/"},{"slug":"stoicism-s-appeal-to-the-rich-and-powerful-2019-d9d0235d44dc","title":"Stoicism's appeal to the rich and powerful (2019)","domain":"www.exurbe.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["philosophy","history","politics_government"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2025-03","inductedMonth":"2025-03","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.963,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":201,"evidenceRank":832,"evidenceScore":64.7,"freshAt":"2025-03-14T14:35:00Z","freshnessRank":239,"freshEventScore":201,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 201 pts / 320 comments (2025) + 102 pts / 118 comments (2019), different submitters and 2,178 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":102,"peak_comments":118,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19510637","height":5,"chart_height":86},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23658573","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26111825","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38197338","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":201,"peak_comments":320,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43363014","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/stoicism-s-appeal-to-the-rich-and-powerful-2019-d9d0235d44dc.jpg","path":"/hall/link/stoicism-s-appeal-to-the-rich-and-powerful-2019-d9d0235d44dc/"},{"slug":"apache-guacamole-d9d02358cd52","title":"Apache Guacamole","domain":"guacamole.apache.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","web_development","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2019-11","inductedMonth":"2024-03","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.338,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":503,"evidenceRank":833,"evidenceScore":64.7,"freshAt":"2024-03-29T18:59:50Z","freshnessRank":425,"freshEventScore":215,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 503 pts / 116 comments (2021) + 215 pts / 50 comments (2024), different submitters and 846 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":193,"peak_comments":41,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15778902","height":9,"chart_height":65},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":129,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21660925","height":6,"chart_height":44},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":503,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29442643","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":215,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39867702","height":10,"chart_height":73},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/apache-guacamole-d9d02358cd52.jpg","path":"/hall/link/apache-guacamole-d9d02358cd52/"},{"slug":"suckless-org-software-that-sucks-less-d9d023542465","title":"Suckless.org: software that sucks less","domain":"suckless.org","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["open_source","operating_systems","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2025-02","inductedMonth":"2025-02","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":8.602,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":360,"evidenceRank":834,"evidenceScore":64.7,"freshAt":"2025-02-21T18:27:00Z","freshnessRank":245,"freshEventScore":360,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 360 pts / 235 comments (2025) + 138 pts / 112 comments (2022), different submitters and 923 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12104671","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13875109","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23655859","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":138,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32445185","height":7,"chart_height":65},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":360,"peak_comments":235,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43131059","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/suckless-org-software-that-sucks-less-d9d023542465.jpg","path":"/hall/link/suckless-org-software-that-sucks-less-d9d023542465/"},{"slug":"how-nat-traversal-works-2020-d9d02362a4e4","title":"How NAT traversal works (2020)","domain":"tailscale.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","internet_infrastructure","application_security"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-06","inductedMonth":"2023-08","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":2.946,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":351,"evidenceRank":835,"evidenceScore":64.6,"freshAt":"2023-08-02T10:22:46Z","freshnessRank":582,"freshEventScore":305,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 305 pts / 106 comments (2023) + 162 pts / 28 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,075 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":162,"peak_comments":28,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24241105","height":8,"chart_height":78},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":351,"peak_comments":37,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30707711","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":305,"peak_comments":106,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36969018","height":15,"chart_height":148},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-nat-traversal-works-2020-d9d02362a4e4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-nat-traversal-works-2020-d9d02362a4e4/"},{"slug":"org-mode-is-one-of-the-most-reasonable-markup-languages-to-use-f-d9d0235d655f","title":"Org-Mode Is One of the Most Reasonable Markup Languages to Use for Text (2018)","domain":"karl-voit.at","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","writing_craft","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2021-11","inductedMonth":"2026-01","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":6.754,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":518,"evidenceRank":836,"evidenceScore":64.6,"freshAt":"2026-01-10T09:15:30Z","freshnessRank":82,"freshEventScore":287,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 518 pts / 245 comments (2019) + 287 pts / 218 comments (2026), different submitters and 2,467 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":518,"peak_comments":245,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19622019","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25433296","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":113,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29263439","height":5,"chart_height":37},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":287,"peak_comments":218,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46564116","height":14,"chart_height":94}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/org-mode-is-one-of-the-most-reasonable-markup-languages-to-use-f-d9d0235d655f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/org-mode-is-one-of-the-most-reasonable-markup-languages-to-use-f-d9d0235d655f/"},{"slug":"signs-that-you-are-a-bad-programmer-d9d0234454c4","title":"Signs that you are a bad programmer","domain":"www.yacoset.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["testing_quality","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2016-11","inductedMonth":"2022-06","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":10.648,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":450,"evidenceRank":837,"evidenceScore":64.6,"freshAt":"2015-03-08T20:08:02Z","freshnessRank":1165,"freshEventScore":289,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 289 pts / 170 comments (2015) + 450 pts / 168 comments (2011), different submitters and 1,236 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":450,"peak_comments":168,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3131439","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":289,"peak_comments":170,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9167008","height":14,"chart_height":109},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12965998","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30613517","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/signs-that-you-are-a-bad-programmer-d9d0234454c4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/signs-that-you-are-a-bad-programmer-d9d0234454c4/"},{"slug":"using-attrs-for-everything-in-python-d9d023546112","title":"Using attrs for everything in Python","domain":"glyph.twistedmatrix.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","software_architecture","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-12","inductedMonth":"2021-12","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":5.366,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":246,"evidenceRank":838,"evidenceScore":64.6,"freshAt":"2021-12-24T20:07:55Z","freshnessRank":841,"freshEventScore":151,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 151 pts / 111 comments (2021) + 246 pts / 101 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,947 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":6,"peak_score":246,"peak_comments":101,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12359522","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17160262","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":151,"peak_comments":111,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29677238","height":7,"chart_height":104},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/using-attrs-for-everything-in-python-d9d023546112.jpg","path":"/hall/link/using-attrs-for-everything-in-python-d9d023546112/"},{"slug":"waydroid-run-android-containers-on-ubuntu-d9d023667ac0","title":"Waydroid – Run Android containers on Ubuntu","domain":"waydro.id","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","open_source","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2025-02","inductedMonth":"2025-02","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.619,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":684,"evidenceRank":839,"evidenceScore":64.5,"freshAt":"2025-02-02T19:29:45Z","freshnessRank":253,"freshEventScore":520,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 684 pts / 206 comments (2021) + 520 pts / 150 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,229 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":684,"peak_comments":206,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28616985","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":19,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34061214","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34807815","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41757264","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":520,"peak_comments":150,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42911042","height":24,"chart_height":129},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48036516","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/waydroid-run-android-containers-on-ubuntu-d9d023667ac0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/waydroid-run-android-containers-on-ubuntu-d9d023667ac0/"},{"slug":"toml-tom-s-obvious-minimal-language-d9d02362d9b8","title":"TOML: Tom's Obvious Minimal Language","domain":"toml.io","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"standard_specification","typeDisplay":"Standards & specifications","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2024-08","inductedMonth":"2025-02","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.654,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":165,"evidenceRank":840,"evidenceScore":64.5,"freshAt":"2023-05-21T07:56:22Z","freshnessRank":626,"freshEventScore":165,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 165 pts / 221 comments (2023) + 146 pts / 160 comments (2020), different submitters and 982 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":146,"peak_comments":160,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24436550","height":7,"chart_height":150},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":165,"peak_comments":221,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36018817","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41411717","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":12,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43095939","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48048511","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/toml-tom-s-obvious-minimal-language-d9d02362d9b8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/toml-tom-s-obvious-minimal-language-d9d02362d9b8/"},{"slug":"grapheneos-a-privacy-and-security-focused-mobile-os-with-android-d9d0235e0098","title":"GrapheneOS – A privacy and security-focused mobile OS with Android compatibility","domain":"grapheneos.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["privacy_surveillance","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-07","inductedMonth":"2022-07","submissions":10,"submitters":9,"spanYears":5.607,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":366,"evidenceRank":841,"evidenceScore":64.5,"freshAt":"2025-01-17T18:39:04Z","freshnessRank":265,"freshEventScore":27,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 366 pts / 179 comments (2019) + 52 pts / 55 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,131 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":366,"peak_comments":179,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20148771","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22514770","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28824220","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":52,"peak_comments":55,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32118569","height":4,"chart_height":24},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":27,"peak_comments":15,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42741766","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/grapheneos-a-privacy-and-security-focused-mobile-os-with-android-d9d0235e0098.jpg","path":"/hall/link/grapheneos-a-privacy-and-security-focused-mobile-os-with-android-d9d0235e0098/"},{"slug":"doomsday-prep-for-the-super-rich-2017-d9d02355e79a","title":"Doomsday Prep for the Super-Rich (2017)","domain":"www.newyorker.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["social_issues","technology_ethics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-09","inductedMonth":"2021-10","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.913,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":154,"evidenceRank":842,"evidenceScore":64.5,"freshAt":"2021-10-16T13:11:52Z","freshnessRank":863,"freshEventScore":50,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 154 pts / 173 comments (2017) + 50 pts / 66 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,726 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":154,"peak_comments":173,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13462865","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":61,"peak_comments":80,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18793028","height":4,"chart_height":67},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":50,"peak_comments":66,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28887627","height":4,"chart_height":55},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36361834","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/doomsday-prep-for-the-super-rich-2017-d9d02355e79a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/doomsday-prep-for-the-super-rich-2017-d9d02355e79a/"},{"slug":"run-unix-processes-inside-your-browser-d9d02355630e","title":"Run Unix processes inside your browser","domain":"browsix.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","web_development","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2022-01","inductedMonth":"2022-01","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":5.103,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":484,"evidenceRank":843,"evidenceScore":64.4,"freshAt":"2022-01-06T13:03:18Z","freshnessRank":838,"freshEventScore":314,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 484 pts / 124 comments (2016) + 314 pts / 77 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,851 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":484,"peak_comments":124,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13151566","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18272943","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19033997","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":314,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29823022","height":15,"chart_height":110},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/run-unix-processes-inside-your-browser-d9d02355630e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/run-unix-processes-inside-your-browser-d9d02355630e/"},{"slug":"when-free-software-isn-t-practically-superior-d9d02350ed5e","title":"When Free Software Isn't (Practically) Superior","domain":"www.gnu.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["open_source","technology_ethics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2020-12","inductedMonth":"2023-08","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":8.066,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":114,"evidenceRank":844,"evidenceScore":64.4,"freshAt":"2020-12-17T19:24:56Z","freshnessRank":963,"freshEventScore":83,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 114 pts / 117 comments (2016) + 83 pts / 107 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,480 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9987704","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":114,"peak_comments":117,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13054275","height":5,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21222593","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":83,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25459278","height":4,"chart_height":124},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37257323","height":4,"chart_height":25},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/when-free-software-isn-t-practically-superior-d9d02350ed5e/"},{"slug":"frege-a-jvm-pure-functional-programming-language-in-the-spirit-o-d9d0234b12ab","title":"Frege: A JVM pure functional programming language in the spirit of Haskell","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"source_code","typeDisplay":"Source code","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","compilers_runtimes","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-03","inductedMonth":"2022-09","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":11.554,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":185,"evidenceRank":845,"evidenceScore":64.4,"freshAt":"2016-03-06T12:47:07Z","freshnessRank":1157,"freshEventScore":177,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 185 pts / 107 comments (2013) + 177 pts / 48 comments (2016), different submitters and 850 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":185,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6688842","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9954986","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":177,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11233576","height":8,"chart_height":163},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18130007","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33034694","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44112115","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/frege-a-jvm-pure-functional-programming-language-in-the-spirit-o-d9d0234b12ab.jpg","path":"/hall/link/frege-a-jvm-pure-functional-programming-language-in-the-spirit-o-d9d0234b12ab/"},{"slug":"ghidra-by-nsa-d9d0235d0caa","title":"Ghidra by NSA","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2026-02","inductedMonth":"2026-02","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.946,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":433,"evidenceRank":846,"evidenceScore":64.3,"freshAt":"2026-02-14T04:24:18Z","freshnessRank":58,"freshEventScore":433,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 433 pts / 220 comments (2026) + 214 pts / 103 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,054 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":67,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19572994","height":4,"chart_height":26},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25653147","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":214,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35324380","height":10,"chart_height":84},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":433,"peak_comments":220,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47011548","height":21,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/ghidra-by-nsa-d9d0235d0caa.jpg","path":"/hall/link/ghidra-by-nsa-d9d0235d0caa/"},{"slug":"pandoc-d9d023504617","title":"Pandoc","domain":"pandoc.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2020-10","inductedMonth":"2020-10","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.424,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1016,"evidenceRank":847,"evidenceScore":64.3,"freshAt":"2020-10-24T22:41:57Z","freshnessRank":981,"freshEventScore":756,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1016 pts / 204 comments (2018) + 756 pts / 168 comments (2020), different submitters and 789 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10207724","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12880594","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14833728","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1016,"peak_comments":204,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17855104","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":756,"peak_comments":168,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24882480","height":24,"chart_height":126},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/pandoc-d9d023504617.jpg","path":"/hall/link/pandoc-d9d023504617/"},{"slug":"orthodox-c-d9d023526c5f","title":"Orthodox C++","domain":"gist.github.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2024-05","inductedMonth":"2024-05","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":8.345,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":70,"evidenceRank":848,"evidenceScore":64.3,"freshAt":"2024-05-22T19:52:09Z","freshnessRank":391,"freshEventScore":63,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 70 pts / 102 comments (2020) + 63 pts / 66 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,241 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10919370","height":4,"chart_height":22},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":29,"peak_comments":14,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13751244","height":4,"chart_height":70},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19798964","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":70,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25554018","height":4,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35688013","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":63,"peak_comments":66,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40445536","height":4,"chart_height":153},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/orthodox-c-d9d023526c5f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/orthodox-c-d9d023526c5f/"},{"slug":"from-novice-to-master-and-back-again-2013-d9d0234e2fa6","title":"From novice to master, and back again (2013)","domain":"blog.djmnet.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","open_source","retrocomputing"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2022-08","inductedMonth":"2022-08","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":7.825,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":406,"evidenceRank":849,"evidenceScore":64.3,"freshAt":"2022-08-09T14:22:41Z","freshnessRank":734,"freshEventScore":406,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 406 pts / 143 comments (2022) + 351 pts / 27 comments (2014), different submitters and 2,858 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":351,"peak_comments":27,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8443981","height":17,"chart_height":147},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9098635","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11193025","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26746889","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":406,"peak_comments":143,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32398391","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/from-novice-to-master-and-back-again-2013-d9d0234e2fa6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/from-novice-to-master-and-back-again-2013-d9d0234e2fa6/"},{"slug":"building-your-color-palette-d9d0235bf8f9","title":"Building Your Color Palette","domain":"refactoringui.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design","user_experience","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2020-11","inductedMonth":"2022-12","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.361,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1019,"evidenceRank":850,"evidenceScore":64.3,"freshAt":"2020-11-22T19:19:51Z","freshnessRank":971,"freshEventScore":1019,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1019 pts / 189 comments (2020) + 705 pts / 115 comments (2018), different submitters and 743 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":705,"peak_comments":115,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18421755","height":24,"chart_height":118},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1019,"peak_comments":189,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25180180","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27473832","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34084998","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39761141","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/building-your-color-palette-d9d0235bf8f9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/building-your-color-palette-d9d0235bf8f9/"},{"slug":"shipmap-org-d9d0235870bd","title":"Shipmap.org","domain":"www.shipmap.org","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"space_transportation","topicDisplay":"Space & transportation","tags":["maritime","transportation","data_science"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2026-01","inductedMonth":"2026-01","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":8.227,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":803,"evidenceRank":851,"evidenceScore":64.3,"freshAt":"2026-01-07T15:03:41Z","freshnessRank":84,"freshEventScore":803,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 803 pts / 119 comments (2026) + 298 pts / 73 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,740 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15484707","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22537297","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":298,"peak_comments":73,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26679067","height":14,"chart_height":63},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33456084","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41474621","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":803,"peak_comments":119,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46527161","height":24,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/shipmap-org-d9d0235870bd.jpg","path":"/hall/link/shipmap-org-d9d0235870bd/"},{"slug":"aaron-swartz-s-thoughts-on-djb-2009-d9d02340182e","title":"Aaron Swartz's Thoughts on djb (2009)","domain":"www.aaronsw.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["performance_reliability","open_source","internet_infrastructure"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2015-03","inductedMonth":"2019-07","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":9.728,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":271,"evidenceRank":852,"evidenceScore":64.2,"freshAt":"2015-03-06T05:24:19Z","freshnessRank":1166,"freshEventScore":271,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 271 pts / 137 comments (2015) + 107 pts / 116 comments (2009), different submitters and 1,963 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":107,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=890034","height":5,"chart_height":67},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5130133","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":271,"peak_comments":137,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9155741","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20422983","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/aaron-swartz-s-thoughts-on-djb-2009-d9d02340182e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/aaron-swartz-s-thoughts-on-djb-2009-d9d02340182e/"},{"slug":"chernobyl-s-hot-mess-the-elephant-s-foot-is-still-lethal-2013-d9d0234b6692","title":"Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot,” Is Still Lethal (2013)","domain":"nautil.us","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["physics","earth_science","history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-12","inductedMonth":"2016-12","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":5.744,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":149,"evidenceRank":853,"evidenceScore":64.2,"freshAt":"2019-09-08T21:47:06Z","freshnessRank":1048,"freshEventScore":80,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 149 pts / 123 comments (2014) + 66 pts / 96 comments (2016), different submitters and 738 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6881166","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":3,"peak_score":149,"peak_comments":123,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8669044","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8837465","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":66,"peak_comments":96,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13103754","height":4,"chart_height":75},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":80,"peak_comments":41,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20913647","height":4,"chart_height":91},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/chernobyl-s-hot-mess-the-elephant-s-foot-is-still-lethal-2013-d9d0234b6692.jpg","path":"/hall/link/chernobyl-s-hot-mess-the-elephant-s-foot-is-still-lethal-2013-d9d0234b6692/"},{"slug":"unix-as-ide-d9d02354e237","title":"Unix as IDE","domain":"sanctum.geek.nz","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","operating_systems","personal_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-03","inductedMonth":"2020-02","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.392,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":237,"evidenceRank":854,"evidenceScore":64.2,"freshAt":"2020-02-27T22:37:59Z","freshnessRank":1018,"freshEventScore":142,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 237 pts / 209 comments (2016) + 142 pts / 103 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,239 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":237,"peak_comments":209,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12653028","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":162,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17359533","height":8,"chart_height":116},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19416127","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":142,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22438730","height":7,"chart_height":102},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/unix-as-ide-d9d02354e237.jpg","path":"/hall/link/unix-as-ide-d9d02354e237/"},{"slug":"windows-10-wallpaper-was-physically-built-and-photographed-2015-d9d0235fb7da","title":"Windows 10 wallpaper was physically built and photographed (2015)","domain":"gmunk.com","category":"media","categoryDisplay":"Audio, video & images","type":"image_comic","typeDisplay":"Images & comics","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design","photography","product_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2024-05","inductedMonth":"2024-05","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.474,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":773,"evidenceRank":855,"evidenceScore":64.2,"freshAt":"2024-05-22T10:59:46Z","freshnessRank":392,"freshEventScore":773,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 773 pts / 268 comments (2024) + 198 pts / 105 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,613 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":198,"peak_comments":105,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21854161","height":10,"chart_height":44},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27353563","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30497553","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36193774","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":773,"peak_comments":268,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40439515","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/windows-10-wallpaper-was-physically-built-and-photographed-2015-d9d0235fb7da.jpg","path":"/hall/link/windows-10-wallpaper-was-physically-built-and-photographed-2015-d9d0235fb7da/"},{"slug":"htop-explained-d9d023556ca1","title":"Htop Explained","domain":"peteris.rocks","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2024-01","inductedMonth":"2026-07","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":9.585,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":818,"evidenceRank":856,"evidenceScore":64.2,"freshAt":"2024-06-28T02:48:59Z","freshnessRank":370,"freshEventScore":24,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 818 pts / 98 comments (2019) + 716 pts / 101 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,063 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":716,"peak_comments":101,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13087904","height":24,"chart_height":149},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":818,"peak_comments":98,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21414882","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":24,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40817274","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48784777","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/htop-explained-d9d023556ca1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/htop-explained-d9d023556ca1/"},{"slug":"potato-paradox-d9d02350c5b9","title":"Potato paradox","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2020-01","inductedMonth":"2020-08","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":7.373,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":559,"evidenceRank":857,"evidenceScore":64.2,"freshAt":"2018-08-12T12:15:32Z","freshnessRank":1089,"freshEventScore":232,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 559 pts / 132 comments (2015) + 232 pts / 77 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,123 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":559,"peak_comments":132,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9894237","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":232,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17744020","height":11,"chart_height":71},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24199592","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29211859","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33768543","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/potato-paradox-d9d02350c5b9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/potato-paradox-d9d02350c5b9/"},{"slug":"termux-terminal-emulator-and-debian-style-userland-as-an-android-d9d02352b893","title":"Termux: terminal emulator and Debian-style userland as an Android app","domain":"termux.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-11","inductedMonth":"2020-11","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":4.715,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":338,"evidenceRank":858,"evidenceScore":64.1,"freshAt":"2020-11-03T13:08:26Z","freshnessRank":977,"freshEventScore":278,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 278 pts / 208 comments (2020) + 338 pts / 139 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,107 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11570596","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":338,"peak_comments":139,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15529426","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20886471","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":278,"peak_comments":208,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24979258","height":13,"chart_height":140},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/termux-terminal-emulator-and-debian-style-userland-as-an-android-d9d02352b893.jpg","path":"/hall/link/termux-terminal-emulator-and-debian-style-userland-as-an-android-d9d02352b893/"},{"slug":"scim-ncurses-based-vim-like-spreadsheet-d9d02355385b","title":"SCIM: Ncurses based, Vim-like spreadsheet","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["personal_productivity","operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2024-07","inductedMonth":"2024-07","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":9.399,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":420,"evidenceRank":859,"evidenceScore":64.1,"freshAt":"2026-04-06T16:00:29Z","freshnessRank":31,"freshEventScore":98,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 420 pts / 122 comments (2024) + 130 pts / 39 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,404 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12926223","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":61,"peak_comments":10,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17758713","height":4,"chart_height":25},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":130,"peak_comments":39,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24318367","height":6,"chart_height":53},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36163027","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":420,"peak_comments":122,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40876848","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":98,"peak_comments":29,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47662658","height":5,"chart_height":40}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/scim-ncurses-based-vim-like-spreadsheet-d9d02355385b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/scim-ncurses-based-vim-like-spreadsheet-d9d02355385b/"},{"slug":"beets-the-music-geek-s-media-organizer-d9d0235353d9","title":"Beets: The music geek’s media organizer","domain":"beets.io","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["music","personal_productivity","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2025-11","inductedMonth":"2025-11","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":9.563,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":267,"evidenceRank":860,"evidenceScore":64.1,"freshAt":"2025-11-10T06:29:54Z","freshnessRank":118,"freshEventScore":267,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 267 pts / 121 comments (2025) + 179 pts / 58 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,595 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11521949","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16791543","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19367763","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":179,"peak_comments":58,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27672508","height":9,"chart_height":114},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":267,"peak_comments":121,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45873037","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/beets-the-music-geek-s-media-organizer-d9d0235353d9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/beets-the-music-geek-s-media-organizer-d9d0235353d9/"},{"slug":"java-is-pass-by-value-dammit-d9d0234206be","title":"Java is Pass-by-Value, Dammit","domain":"javadude.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2018-04","inductedMonth":"2018-04","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":7.389,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":218,"evidenceRank":861,"evidenceScore":64.1,"freshAt":"2018-04-22T13:48:24Z","freshnessRank":1101,"freshEventScore":164,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 218 pts / 243 comments (2015) + 164 pts / 187 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,127 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":12,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1956497","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5914853","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8449871","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":218,"peak_comments":243,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9245043","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":164,"peak_comments":187,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16896150","height":8,"chart_height":128},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/java-is-pass-by-value-dammit-d9d0234206be.jpg","path":"/hall/link/java-is-pass-by-value-dammit-d9d0234206be/"},{"slug":"brow-sh-a-modern-text-based-browser-d9d0235adcb6","title":"Brow.sh: a modern text-based browser","domain":"www.brow.sh","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["browsers_web_standards","internet_infrastructure","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2024-01","inductedMonth":"2024-01","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":5.525,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":684,"evidenceRank":862,"evidenceScore":64.0,"freshAt":"2024-01-17T02:38:51Z","freshnessRank":458,"freshEventScore":202,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 684 pts / 103 comments (2020) + 202 pts / 34 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,155 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":45,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17490348","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":13,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21630423","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":5,"peak_score":684,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25129747","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":86,"peak_comments":20,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31983769","height":4,"chart_height":21},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":202,"peak_comments":34,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39022535","height":10,"chart_height":50},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/brow-sh-a-modern-text-based-browser-d9d0235adcb6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/brow-sh-a-modern-text-based-browser-d9d0235adcb6/"},{"slug":"valetudo-cloud-replacement-for-vacuum-robots-enabling-local-only-d9d0236714c7","title":"Valetudo – Cloud replacement for vacuum robots enabling local-only operation","domain":"valetudo.cloud","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["privacy_surveillance","embedded_iot","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2023-12","inductedMonth":"2025-10","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.893,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":470,"evidenceRank":863,"evidenceScore":64.0,"freshAt":"2025-10-20T11:08:44Z","freshnessRank":126,"freshEventScore":391,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 391 pts / 213 comments (2025) + 251 pts / 89 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,229 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29373056","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":251,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31665872","height":12,"chart_height":91},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":470,"peak_comments":154,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38788326","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":391,"peak_comments":213,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45642571","height":19,"chart_height":141},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/valetudo-cloud-replacement-for-vacuum-robots-enabling-local-only-d9d0236714c7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/valetudo-cloud-replacement-for-vacuum-robots-enabling-local-only-d9d0236714c7/"},{"slug":"the-coming-civil-war-over-general-purpose-computing-2012-d9d02346fb26","title":"The Coming Civil War over General Purpose Computing (2012)","domain":"boingboing.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["technology_ethics","law_regulation"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2020-10","inductedMonth":"2020-10","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":10.593,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":405,"evidenceRank":864,"evidenceScore":64.0,"freshAt":"2020-10-23T05:29:37Z","freshnessRank":982,"freshEventScore":405,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 405 pts / 210 comments (2020) + 279 pts / 98 comments (2012), different submitters and 2,979 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":279,"peak_comments":98,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4436139","height":13,"chart_height":117},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9595789","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12020913","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19876724","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":405,"peak_comments":210,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24866279","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35382551","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-coming-civil-war-over-general-purpose-computing-2012-d9d02346fb26.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-coming-civil-war-over-general-purpose-computing-2012-d9d02346fb26/"},{"slug":"doing-business-in-japan-d9d0234e6fe1","title":"Doing Business in Japan","domain":"www.kalzumeus.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["startups_entrepreneurship","management_strategy","workplace"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2020-05","inductedMonth":"2020-06","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":8.914,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":818,"evidenceRank":865,"evidenceScore":64.0,"freshAt":"2016-11-06T15:21:55Z","freshnessRank":1146,"freshEventScore":185,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 818 pts / 305 comments (2014) + 185 pts / 51 comments (2016), different submitters and 729 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":818,"peak_comments":305,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8573992","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":185,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12885435","height":9,"chart_height":38},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23559683","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37662219","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/doing-business-in-japan-d9d0234e6fe1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/doing-business-in-japan-d9d0234e6fe1/"},{"slug":"masscan-tcp-port-scanner-scanning-entire-internet-in-under-5-min-d9d0234a8fc8","title":"Masscan: TCP port scanner, scanning entire Internet in under 5 minutes","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"source_code","typeDisplay":"Source code","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security","protocols_networking","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-08","inductedMonth":"2021-09","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":8.033,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":468,"evidenceRank":866,"evidenceScore":64.0,"freshAt":"2021-09-28T14:11:17Z","freshnessRank":867,"freshEventScore":468,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 468 pts / 130 comments (2021) + 147 pts / 29 comments (2014), different submitters and 2,466 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":138,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6391266","height":7,"chart_height":50},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":147,"peak_comments":29,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8803498","height":7,"chart_height":53},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":61,"peak_comments":33,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12260809","height":4,"chart_height":22},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18074125","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":468,"peak_comments":130,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28682986","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/masscan-tcp-port-scanner-scanning-entire-internet-in-under-5-min-d9d0234a8fc8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/masscan-tcp-port-scanner-scanning-entire-internet-in-under-5-min-d9d0234a8fc8/"},{"slug":"life-is-a-game-this-is-your-strategy-guide-2014-d9d0234be838","title":"Life is a game, this is your strategy guide (2014)","domain":"oliveremberton.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["personal_productivity","careers"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2023-03","inductedMonth":"2023-03","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":9.076,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":359,"evidenceRank":867,"evidenceScore":63.9,"freshAt":"2023-03-05T12:12:18Z","freshnessRank":648,"freshEventScore":143,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 359 pts / 172 comments (2014) + 143 pts / 112 comments (2023), different submitters and 3,315 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":359,"peak_comments":172,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7182636","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8832678","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28696534","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":143,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35028913","height":7,"chart_height":68},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/life-is-a-game-this-is-your-strategy-guide-2014-d9d0234be838.jpg","path":"/hall/link/life-is-a-game-this-is-your-strategy-guide-2014-d9d0234be838/"},{"slug":"white-coke-d9d0234a0206","title":"White Coke","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["markets","history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2015-11","inductedMonth":"2023-09","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":10.987,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":478,"evidenceRank":868,"evidenceScore":63.9,"freshAt":"2015-11-26T17:29:27Z","freshnessRank":1162,"freshEventScore":103,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 478 pts / 236 comments (2013) + 103 pts / 24 comments (2015), different submitters and 862 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":478,"peak_comments":236,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6056451","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":103,"peak_comments":24,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10633875","height":5,"chart_height":37},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19870386","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37556551","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40942795","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/white-coke-d9d0234a0206.jpg","path":"/hall/link/white-coke-d9d0234a0206/"},{"slug":"how-i-experience-web-today-d9d02366341f","title":"How I Experience Web Today","domain":"how-i-experience-web-today.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["user_experience","web_development","internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2024-10","inductedMonth":"2024-10","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":4.452,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":985,"evidenceRank":869,"evidenceScore":63.9,"freshAt":"2024-10-14T19:22:53Z","freshnessRank":316,"freshEventScore":454,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 985 pts / 314 comments (2021) + 454 pts / 128 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,148 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":985,"peak_comments":314,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28280051","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":50,"peak_comments":17,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36115671","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":454,"peak_comments":128,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41840931","height":22,"chart_height":78},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46874365","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-i-experience-web-today-d9d02366341f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-i-experience-web-today-d9d02366341f/"},{"slug":"japan-s-rail-workers-pointing-at-things-2017-d9d0235af075","title":"Japan's Rail Workers Pointing at Things (2017)","domain":"www.atlasobscura.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"space_transportation","topicDisplay":"Space & transportation","tags":["transportation","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2022-05","inductedMonth":"2026-06","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":7.91,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":272,"evidenceRank":870,"evidenceScore":63.9,"freshAt":"2022-05-05T17:11:07Z","freshnessRank":785,"freshEventScore":111,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 272 pts / 107 comments (2019) + 111 pts / 50 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,201 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17552388","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":272,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18952193","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":271,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22922277","height":13,"chart_height":169},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":111,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31275988","height":5,"chart_height":69},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48528886","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/japan-s-rail-workers-pointing-at-things-2017-d9d0235af075/"},{"slug":"a-self-learning-modern-computer-science-curriculum-d9d023568e35","title":"A Self-Learning, Modern Computer Science Curriculum","domain":"functionalcs.github.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"course_lecture","typeDisplay":"Courses & lectures","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["learning_methods","teaching","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2023-06","inductedMonth":"2023-06","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.209,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":394,"evidenceRank":871,"evidenceScore":63.9,"freshAt":"2023-06-13T16:25:16Z","freshnessRank":614,"freshEventScore":315,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 394 pts / 30 comments (2019) + 315 pts / 99 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,595 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13977587","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":394,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19028855","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32044662","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":315,"peak_comments":99,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36312603","height":15,"chart_height":136},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-self-learning-modern-computer-science-curriculum-d9d023568e35.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-self-learning-modern-computer-science-curriculum-d9d023568e35/"},{"slug":"spot-the-drowning-child-2015-d9d0235a3561","title":"Spot the Drowning Child (2015)","domain":"spotthedrowningchild.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"medicine_health","topicDisplay":"Medicine & health","tags":["public_health"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2024-07","inductedMonth":"2024-07","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.198,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":697,"evidenceRank":872,"evidenceScore":63.9,"freshAt":"2024-07-08T15:21:01Z","freshnessRank":365,"freshEventScore":189,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 697 pts / 405 comments (2020) + 189 pts / 176 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,587 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16939063","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":697,"peak_comments":405,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22482731","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26122952","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":189,"peak_comments":176,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40906210","height":9,"chart_height":46},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/spot-the-drowning-child-2015-d9d0235a3561.jpg","path":"/hall/link/spot-the-drowning-child-2015-d9d0235a3561/"},{"slug":"rough-js-create-graphics-with-a-hand-drawn-sketchy-appearance-d9d02356268c","title":"Rough.js: Create graphics with a hand-drawn, sketchy, appearance","domain":"roughjs.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","web_development","computer_graphics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-12","inductedMonth":"2023-12","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.845,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":372,"evidenceRank":873,"evidenceScore":63.9,"freshAt":"2023-12-22T08:06:23Z","freshnessRank":477,"freshEventScore":372,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 372 pts / 39 comments (2023) + 236 pts / 23 comments (2021), different submitters and 737 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13662347","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":13,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22787187","height":5,"chart_height":46},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":236,"peak_comments":23,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29555853","height":11,"chart_height":108},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":372,"peak_comments":39,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38732049","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/rough-js-create-graphics-with-a-hand-drawn-sketchy-appearance-d9d02356268c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/rough-js-create-graphics-with-a-hand-drawn-sketchy-appearance-d9d02356268c/"},{"slug":"libui-gui-library-in-c-d9d02353a151","title":"Libui: GUI library in C","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools","human_computer_interaction"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-09","inductedMonth":"2020-09","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.764,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":373,"evidenceRank":874,"evidenceScore":63.8,"freshAt":"2018-05-19T23:38:34Z","freshnessRank":1097,"freshEventScore":356,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 373 pts / 182 comments (2016) + 356 pts / 162 comments (2018), different submitters and 729 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":373,"peak_comments":182,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11735393","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15618551","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":356,"peak_comments":162,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17110342","height":17,"chart_height":162},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24414771","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26235620","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/libui-gui-library-in-c-d9d02353a151.jpg","path":"/hall/link/libui-gui-library-in-c-d9d02353a151/"},{"slug":"serenityos-is-a-love-letter-to-90s-user-interfaces-d9d023624f62","title":"SerenityOS is a love letter to '90s user interfaces","domain":"serenityos.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","open_source","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2025-04","inductedMonth":"2025-04","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.753,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":296,"evidenceRank":875,"evidenceScore":63.8,"freshAt":"2025-04-22T10:24:43Z","freshnessRank":218,"freshEventScore":184,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 184 pts / 194 comments (2025) + 296 pts / 129 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,344 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23911180","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":296,"peak_comments":129,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28206840","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38473043","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39919744","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":184,"peak_comments":194,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43760626","height":9,"chart_height":106},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/serenityos-is-a-love-letter-to-90s-user-interfaces-d9d023624f62.jpg","path":"/hall/link/serenityos-is-a-love-letter-to-90s-user-interfaces-d9d023624f62/"},{"slug":"show-hn-sublime-merge-a-git-client-from-the-makers-of-sublime-te-d9d0235b84ad","title":"Show HN: Sublime Merge – A Git client from the makers of Sublime Text","domain":"www.sublimemerge.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","performance_reliability","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2024-07","inductedMonth":"2024-07","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":7.376,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":935,"evidenceRank":876,"evidenceScore":63.8,"freshAt":"2024-07-03T01:57:10Z","freshnessRank":368,"freshEventScore":88,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 935 pts / 351 comments (2018) + 88 pts / 93 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,112 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":935,"peak_comments":351,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18030446","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25240413","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26712927","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37297337","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":88,"peak_comments":93,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40862144","height":4,"chart_height":16},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46890167","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/show-hn-sublime-merge-a-git-client-from-the-makers-of-sublime-te-d9d0235b84ad.jpg","path":"/hall/link/show-hn-sublime-merge-a-git-client-from-the-makers-of-sublime-te-d9d0235b84ad/"},{"slug":"startups-in-13-sentences-d9d0233f4e5c","title":"Startups in 13 Sentences","domain":"www.paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["startups_entrepreneurship"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2016-08","inductedMonth":"2017-12","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":8.843,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":322,"evidenceRank":877,"evidenceScore":63.8,"freshAt":"2016-08-15T06:49:41Z","freshnessRank":1147,"freshEventScore":306,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 322 pts / 101 comments (2009) + 306 pts / 78 comments (2016), different submitters and 2,730 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":322,"peak_comments":101,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=491196","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6588521","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":306,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12289071","height":15,"chart_height":162},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16020636","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/startups-in-13-sentences-d9d0233f4e5c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/startups-in-13-sentences-d9d0233f4e5c/"},{"slug":"dec64-decimal-floating-point-d9d0234c3959","title":"DEC64: Decimal Floating Point","domain":"dec64.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"standard_specification","typeDisplay":"Standards & specifications","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["computer_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2017-06","inductedMonth":"2018-03","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.29,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":218,"evidenceRank":878,"evidenceScore":63.8,"freshAt":"2019-06-22T21:14:00Z","freshnessRank":1058,"freshEventScore":64,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 218 pts / 187 comments (2014) + 125 pts / 78 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,456 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":218,"peak_comments":187,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7365812","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":45,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10243011","height":4,"chart_height":35},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14877292","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":125,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16513717","height":6,"chart_height":97},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":64,"peak_comments":37,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20251750","height":4,"chart_height":50},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/dec64-decimal-floating-point-d9d0234c3959.jpg","path":"/hall/link/dec64-decimal-floating-point-d9d0234c3959/"},{"slug":"bussed-out-how-america-moves-thousands-of-homeless-people-around-d9d02359099e","title":"Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless people around the country","domain":"www.theguardian.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["social_issues","cities_infrastructure","journalism_media"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2023-11","inductedMonth":"2023-11","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":5.862,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":239,"evidenceRank":879,"evidenceScore":63.8,"freshAt":"2023-11-01T14:09:18Z","freshnessRank":501,"freshEventScore":58,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 239 pts / 119 comments (2018) + 58 pts / 107 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,823 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15980701","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":239,"peak_comments":119,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18375280","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":58,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38098391","height":4,"chart_height":41},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/bussed-out-how-america-moves-thousands-of-homeless-people-around-d9d02359099e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/bussed-out-how-america-moves-thousands-of-homeless-people-around-d9d02359099e/"},{"slug":"why-the-name-d9d0234fc9f4","title":"Why the name?","domain":"wiki.debian.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2020-04","inductedMonth":"2022-02","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.888,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":352,"evidenceRank":880,"evidenceScore":63.8,"freshAt":"2020-04-06T03:05:30Z","freshnessRank":1015,"freshEventScore":317,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 352 pts / 93 comments (2015) + 317 pts / 70 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,828 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":352,"peak_comments":93,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9322904","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12439901","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15214315","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":317,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22790623","height":15,"chart_height":153},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30441757","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-the-name-d9d0234fc9f4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-the-name-d9d0234fc9f4/"},{"slug":"fred-s-imagemagick-scripts-d9d0234b5d05","title":"Fred's ImageMagick Scripts","domain":"www.fmwconcepts.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","computer_graphics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2022-02","inductedMonth":"2022-02","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":12.038,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1149,"evidenceRank":881,"evidenceScore":63.8,"freshAt":"2022-02-18T00:41:27Z","freshnessRank":823,"freshEventScore":284,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1149 pts / 100 comments (2018) + 284 pts / 44 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,426 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6859267","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1149,"peak_comments":100,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16668254","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24409848","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":284,"peak_comments":44,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30380861","height":14,"chart_height":42},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46338134","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/fred-s-imagemagick-scripts-d9d0234b5d05.jpg","path":"/hall/link/fred-s-imagemagick-scripts-d9d0234b5d05/"},{"slug":"plasma-bigscreen-d9d02360f049","title":"Plasma Bigscreen","domain":"plasma-bigscreen.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","open_source","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2026-03","inductedMonth":"2026-03","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.941,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":673,"evidenceRank":882,"evidenceScore":63.7,"freshAt":"2026-03-06T23:59:16Z","freshnessRank":49,"freshEventScore":673,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 640 pts / 269 comments (2022) + 673 pts / 230 comments (2026), different submitters and 1,268 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22702199","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":640,"peak_comments":269,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32859256","height":24,"chart_height":162},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44578308","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":3,"peak_score":673,"peak_comments":230,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47282736","height":24,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/plasma-bigscreen-d9d02360f049.jpg","path":"/hall/link/plasma-bigscreen-d9d02360f049/"},{"slug":"to-build-truly-intelligent-machines-teach-them-cause-and-effect-d9d0235a5f32","title":"To Build Truly Intelligent Machines, Teach Them Cause and Effect (2018)","domain":"www.quantamagazine.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"interview_profile","typeDisplay":"Interviews & profiles","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["artificial_intelligence","machine_learning","scientific_method"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2023-01","inductedMonth":"2023-01","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":6.568,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":146,"evidenceRank":883,"evidenceScore":63.7,"freshAt":"2023-01-03T20:34:37Z","freshnessRank":677,"freshEventScore":50,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 146 pts / 104 comments (2020) + 50 pts / 50 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,072 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":33,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17074189","height":4,"chart_height":38},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21029385","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":146,"peak_comments":104,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22161830","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":50,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34237609","height":4,"chart_height":58},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42354491","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/to-build-truly-intelligent-machines-teach-them-cause-and-effect-d9d0235a5f32.jpg","path":"/hall/link/to-build-truly-intelligent-machines-teach-them-cause-and-effect-d9d0235a5f32/"},{"slug":"crown-shyness-d9d02354bb0a","title":"Crown shyness","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["biology"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2023-12","inductedMonth":"2023-12","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":7.255,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":332,"evidenceRank":884,"evidenceScore":63.7,"freshAt":"2023-12-23T23:00:57Z","freshnessRank":475,"freshEventScore":332,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 332 pts / 48 comments (2023) + 307 pts / 36 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,324 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12540531","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":307,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14998591","height":15,"chart_height":157},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33217484","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":332,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38749170","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/crown-shyness-d9d02354bb0a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/crown-shyness-d9d02354bb0a/"},{"slug":"checked-c-d9d02353e3f0","title":"Checked C","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","application_security","testing_quality"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-02","inductedMonth":"2021-02","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":6.511,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":175,"evidenceRank":885,"evidenceScore":63.7,"freshAt":"2022-12-21T18:29:49Z","freshnessRank":681,"freshEventScore":28,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 175 pts / 133 comments (2021) + 129 pts / 92 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,072 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11927207","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":129,"peak_comments":92,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16588483","height":6,"chart_height":125},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20630517","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":175,"peak_comments":133,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26190403","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":28,"peak_comments":12,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34084455","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/checked-c-d9d02353e3f0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/checked-c-d9d02353e3f0/"},{"slug":"security-txt-d9d023585a13","title":"Security.txt","domain":"securitytxt.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"standard_specification","typeDisplay":"Standards & specifications","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security","web_development","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-03","inductedMonth":"2024-06","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.669,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":746,"evidenceRank":886,"evidenceScore":63.7,"freshAt":"2021-03-14T14:00:59Z","freshnessRank":935,"freshEventScore":746,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 746 pts / 165 comments (2021) + 705 pts / 141 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,255 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":705,"peak_comments":141,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15416198","height":24,"chart_height":161},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25566767","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":746,"peak_comments":165,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26455493","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33344443","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40605928","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/security-txt-d9d023585a13.jpg","path":"/hall/link/security-txt-d9d023585a13/"},{"slug":"how-fighter-jets-lock-on-and-how-the-targets-know-2014-d9d0234e2dde","title":"How fighter jets lock on, and how the targets know (2014)","domain":"gizmodo.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"space_transportation","topicDisplay":"Space & transportation","tags":["aviation","electronics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2021-06","inductedMonth":"2023-09","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":11.729,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":532,"evidenceRank":887,"evidenceScore":63.6,"freshAt":"2021-06-12T10:34:27Z","freshnessRank":900,"freshEventScore":532,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 532 pts / 238 comments (2021) + 251 pts / 85 comments (2014), different submitters and 2,436 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":251,"peak_comments":85,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8439560","height":12,"chart_height":80},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11509226","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":532,"peak_comments":238,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27483412","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37446351","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48775765","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-fighter-jets-lock-on-and-how-the-targets-know-2014-d9d0234e2dde.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-fighter-jets-lock-on-and-how-the-targets-know-2014-d9d0234e2dde/"},{"slug":"xip-io-a-magic-domain-name-that-provides-wildcard-dns-for-any-ip-d9d023464f0f","title":"Xip.io - a magic domain name that provides wildcard DNS for any IP address","domain":"xip.io","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","internet_infrastructure"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2015-12","inductedMonth":"2019-09","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":7.258,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":312,"evidenceRank":888,"evidenceScore":63.6,"freshAt":"2019-09-10T14:25:05Z","freshnessRank":1047,"freshEventScore":174,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 312 pts / 121 comments (2012) + 174 pts / 49 comments (2019), different submitters and 2,650 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":312,"peak_comments":121,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4081591","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":206,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7732457","height":10,"chart_height":112},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10812245","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14357574","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":174,"peak_comments":49,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20928536","height":8,"chart_height":95},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/xip-io-a-magic-domain-name-that-provides-wildcard-dns-for-any-ip-d9d023464f0f/"},{"slug":"elvish-expressive-programming-language-and-a-versatile-interacti-d9d0235b7842","title":"Elvish, expressive programming language and a versatile interactive shell","domain":"elv.sh","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools","operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2024-05","inductedMonth":"2024-05","submissions":9,"submitters":8,"spanYears":5.654,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":177,"evidenceRank":889,"evidenceScore":63.6,"freshAt":"2024-05-10T06:38:44Z","freshnessRank":401,"freshEventScore":177,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 177 pts / 114 comments (2024) + 149 pts / 49 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,338 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":4,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18380976","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":149,"peak_comments":49,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24422491","height":7,"chart_height":143},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29472023","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34723662","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":177,"peak_comments":114,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40316010","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/elvish-expressive-programming-language-and-a-versatile-interacti-d9d0235b7842.jpg","path":"/hall/link/elvish-expressive-programming-language-and-a-versatile-interacti-d9d0235b7842/"},{"slug":"the-guy-i-almost-was-1998-d9d0233fcf22","title":"The Guy I Almost Was (1998)","domain":"www.electricsheepcomix.com","category":"media","categoryDisplay":"Audio, video & images","type":"image_comic","typeDisplay":"Images & comics","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["books_literature"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2020-12","inductedMonth":"2020-12","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":11.398,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":305,"evidenceRank":890,"evidenceScore":63.5,"freshAt":"2020-12-27T05:14:29Z","freshnessRank":959,"freshEventScore":305,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 305 pts / 203 comments (2020) + 105 pts / 25 comments (2009), different submitters and 4,162 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":105,"peak_comments":25,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=740760","height":5,"chart_height":59},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7496117","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10475249","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14799910","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":305,"peak_comments":203,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25549042","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-guy-i-almost-was-1998-d9d0233fcf22.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-guy-i-almost-was-1998-d9d0233fcf22/"},{"slug":"github-classroom-d9d023516174","title":"GitHub Classroom","domain":"classroom.github.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["teaching","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2020-06","inductedMonth":"2022-06","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":8.271,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":559,"evidenceRank":891,"evidenceScore":63.5,"freshAt":"2020-06-03T04:37:01Z","freshnessRank":1004,"freshEventScore":559,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 559 pts / 166 comments (2020) + 205 pts / 60 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,715 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":205,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10258822","height":10,"chart_height":62},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15093414","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":559,"peak_comments":166,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23399742","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31608109","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38820337","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/github-classroom-d9d023516174.jpg","path":"/hall/link/github-classroom-d9d023516174/"},{"slug":"winbtrfs-an-open-source-btrfs-driver-for-windows-d9d02352c95a","title":"WinBtrfs – an open-source btrfs driver for Windows","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","databases_storage","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2024-04","inductedMonth":"2024-04","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":8.12,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":311,"evidenceRank":892,"evidenceScore":63.5,"freshAt":"2024-04-06T21:59:31Z","freshnessRank":422,"freshEventScore":311,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 311 pts / 113 comments (2024) + 158 pts / 100 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,405 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11159378","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":158,"peak_comments":100,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15177002","height":8,"chart_height":86},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33862511","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":311,"peak_comments":113,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39956008","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/winbtrfs-an-open-source-btrfs-driver-for-windows-d9d02352c95a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/winbtrfs-an-open-source-btrfs-driver-for-windows-d9d02352c95a/"},{"slug":"why-do-so-few-people-major-in-computer-science-2017-d9d023597d69","title":"Why do so few people major in computer science? (2017)","domain":"danwang.co","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["academic_life","data_science","careers","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2023-07","inductedMonth":"2023-07","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.421,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":130,"evidenceRank":893,"evidenceScore":63.5,"freshAt":"2023-07-15T01:58:31Z","freshnessRank":591,"freshEventScore":109,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 130 pts / 423 comments (2020) + 109 pts / 291 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,110 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16351231","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":130,"peak_comments":423,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23676331","height":6,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31546298","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":109,"peak_comments":291,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36732424","height":5,"chart_height":143},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-do-so-few-people-major-in-computer-science-2017-d9d023597d69.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-do-so-few-people-major-in-computer-science-2017-d9d023597d69/"},{"slug":"sortition-d9d02351db4b","title":"Sortition","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["politics_government","history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2020-06","inductedMonth":"2022-07","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":9.815,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":189,"evidenceRank":894,"evidenceScore":63.5,"freshAt":"2020-06-01T14:57:26Z","freshnessRank":1005,"freshEventScore":189,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 189 pts / 116 comments (2020) + 108 pts / 62 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,663 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":108,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10548480","height":5,"chart_height":97},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13990293","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":189,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23379148","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33203863","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45132249","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/sortition-d9d02351db4b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/sortition-d9d02351db4b/"},{"slug":"kallithea-self-hosted-alternative-to-github-d9d0234fdc06","title":"Kallithea – Self-hosted alternative to GitHub","domain":"kallithea-scm.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source","software_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-06","inductedMonth":"2021-04","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.988,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":198,"evidenceRank":895,"evidenceScore":63.5,"freshAt":"2021-04-06T08:13:21Z","freshnessRank":928,"freshEventScore":198,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 198 pts / 125 comments (2021) + 119 pts / 59 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,034 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":102,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9360098","height":5,"chart_height":88},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14062972","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":119,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17246386","height":6,"chart_height":102},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21697273","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":198,"peak_comments":125,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26709357","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/kallithea-self-hosted-alternative-to-github-d9d0234fdc06.jpg","path":"/hall/link/kallithea-self-hosted-alternative-to-github-d9d0234fdc06/"},{"slug":"no-hello-please-don-t-just-say-hello-in-chat-d9d02367f29f","title":"No hello – please don't just say hello in chat","domain":"nohello.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["workplace","labor_productivity","personal_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2022,"candidateMonth":"2024-11","inductedMonth":"2025-06","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.296,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":249,"evidenceRank":896,"evidenceScore":63.4,"freshAt":"2025-06-17T10:09:22Z","freshnessRank":198,"freshEventScore":227,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 227 pts / 250 comments (2025) + 249 pts / 77 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,193 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":249,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30642052","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":120,"peak_comments":126,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36623348","height":6,"chart_height":82},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42041597","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":227,"peak_comments":250,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44297431","height":11,"chart_height":155},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/no-hello-please-don-t-just-say-hello-in-chat-d9d02367f29f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/no-hello-please-don-t-just-say-hello-in-chat-d9d02367f29f/"},{"slug":"free-online-courses-from-top-universities-d9d023421539","title":"Free Online Courses from Top Universities","domain":"www.openculture.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["academic_life","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2017-11","inductedMonth":"2019-11","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":8.909,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":392,"evidenceRank":897,"evidenceScore":63.4,"freshAt":"2019-11-05T06:17:18Z","freshnessRank":1039,"freshEventScore":392,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 392 pts / 46 comments (2019) + 112 pts / 12 comments (2011), different submitters and 2,906 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":95,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1985023","height":5,"chart_height":41},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":112,"peak_comments":12,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3259773","height":5,"chart_height":49},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":257,"peak_comments":34,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15771785","height":12,"chart_height":111},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":392,"peak_comments":46,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21450126","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/free-online-courses-from-top-universities-d9d023421539.jpg","path":"/hall/link/free-online-courses-from-top-universities-d9d023421539/"},{"slug":"debugging-an-evil-go-runtime-bug-d9d02358e097","title":"Debugging an evil Go runtime bug","domain":"marcan.st","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","performance_reliability","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2024-07","inductedMonth":"2024-07","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.623,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":498,"evidenceRank":898,"evidenceScore":63.4,"freshAt":"2024-07-19T13:24:40Z","freshnessRank":362,"freshEventScore":206,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 498 pts / 48 comments (2017) + 206 pts / 46 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,418 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":498,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15845118","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17851977","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":46,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21450094","height":4,"chart_height":16},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30284407","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37593337","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":206,"peak_comments":46,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41006308","height":10,"chart_height":70},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/debugging-an-evil-go-runtime-bug-d9d02358e097.jpg","path":"/hall/link/debugging-an-evil-go-runtime-bug-d9d02358e097/"},{"slug":"make-linux-fast-again-2019-d9d0235c13df","title":"Make Linux Fast Again (2019)","domain":"make-linux-fast-again.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2022-06","inductedMonth":"2022-06","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":7.173,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":368,"evidenceRank":899,"evidenceScore":63.4,"freshAt":"2022-06-14T20:31:19Z","freshnessRank":766,"freshEventScore":105,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 368 pts / 314 comments (2020) + 105 pts / 56 comments (2022), different submitters and 795 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18497751","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":11,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19951651","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":368,"peak_comments":314,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22830330","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":105,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31745636","height":5,"chart_height":49},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46718489","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/make-linux-fast-again-2019-d9d0235c13df/"},{"slug":"artificial-intelligence-the-revolution-hasn-t-happened-yet-2018-d9d0235a20d8","title":"Artificial Intelligence – The Revolution Hasn’t Happened Yet (2018)","domain":"medium.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["artificial_intelligence","machine_learning","data_science","technology_ethics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2020-12","inductedMonth":"2022-10","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.52,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":278,"evidenceRank":900,"evidenceScore":63.4,"freshAt":"2022-10-26T16:19:47Z","freshnessRank":701,"freshEventScore":74,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 270 pts / 161 comments (2018) + 278 pts / 120 comments (2020), different submitters and 980 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":270,"peak_comments":161,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16873778","height":13,"chart_height":165},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":278,"peak_comments":120,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25530178","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":74,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33345940","height":4,"chart_height":45},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/artificial-intelligence-the-revolution-hasn-t-happened-yet-2018-d9d0235a20d8/"},{"slug":"if-you-re-so-successful-why-are-you-still-working-70-hours-a-wee-d9d023596c0d","title":"If You’re So Successful, Why Are You Still Working 70 Hours a Week?","domain":"hbr.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["workplace","leadership","personal_productivity","mental_health"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-09","inductedMonth":"2021-09","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.073,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":252,"evidenceRank":901,"evidenceScore":63.4,"freshAt":"2024-03-01T07:37:30Z","freshnessRank":435,"freshEventScore":93,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 252 pts / 267 comments (2021) + 93 pts / 97 comments (2024), different submitters and 904 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":97,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16301849","height":5,"chart_height":65},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23497644","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":252,"peak_comments":267,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28459361","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":93,"peak_comments":97,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39559517","height":4,"chart_height":63},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/if-you-re-so-successful-why-are-you-still-working-70-hours-a-wee-d9d023596c0d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/if-you-re-so-successful-why-are-you-still-working-70-hours-a-wee-d9d023596c0d/"},{"slug":"htmx-high-power-tools-for-html-d9d02361b07f","title":"Htmx – high power tools for HTML","domain":"htmx.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["web_development","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-05","inductedMonth":"2023-05","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.385,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":728,"evidenceRank":902,"evidenceScore":63.4,"freshAt":"2025-10-15T19:49:28Z","freshnessRank":129,"freshEventScore":23,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 435 pts / 287 comments (2023) + 728 pts / 166 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,093 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":728,"peak_comments":166,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23330881","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32268256","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":435,"peak_comments":287,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36078709","height":21,"chart_height":102},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":23,"peak_comments":11,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45597523","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/htmx-high-power-tools-for-html-d9d02361b07f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/htmx-high-power-tools-for-html-d9d02361b07f/"},{"slug":"mystery-signal-from-a-helicopter-d9d0234bde38","title":"Mystery signal from a helicopter","domain":"www.windytan.com","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"technical_report","typeDisplay":"Technical reports","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["protocols_networking","embedded_iot","computer_graphics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2023-01","inductedMonth":"2023-01","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":8.977,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1101,"evidenceRank":903,"evidenceScore":63.4,"freshAt":"2023-01-24T22:43:45Z","freshnessRank":662,"freshEventScore":177,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1101 pts / 78 comments (2014) + 177 pts / 27 comments (2023), different submitters and 3,279 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1101,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7160242","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9175040","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14023983","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25162395","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27068153","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":177,"peak_comments":27,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34511666","height":8,"chart_height":27},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/mystery-signal-from-a-helicopter-d9d0234bde38.jpg","path":"/hall/link/mystery-signal-from-a-helicopter-d9d0234bde38/"},{"slug":"the-open-office-trap-2014-d9d0234eab3a","title":"The Open-Office Trap (2014)","domain":"www.newyorker.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["workplace","management_strategy","psychology"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2025-08","inductedMonth":"2025-08","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":10.716,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":153,"evidenceRank":904,"evidenceScore":63.3,"freshAt":"2025-08-21T10:16:39Z","freshnessRank":167,"freshEventScore":79,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 153 pts / 183 comments (2014) + 79 pts / 56 comments (2025), different submitters and 3,913 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":153,"peak_comments":183,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8696391","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13409350","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16520960","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24254607","height":4,"chart_height":20},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":79,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44970998","height":4,"chart_height":88},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-open-office-trap-2014-d9d0234eab3a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-open-office-trap-2014-d9d0234eab3a/"},{"slug":"forget-privacy-you-re-terrible-at-targeting-anyway-d9d0235cbaab","title":"Forget privacy: you're terrible at targeting anyway","domain":"apenwarr.ca","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["privacy_surveillance","data_science","internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2021-08","inductedMonth":"2023-10","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":4.704,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":312,"evidenceRank":905,"evidenceScore":63.2,"freshAt":"2023-10-16T10:48:01Z","freshnessRank":516,"freshEventScore":75,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 136 pts / 114 comments (2021) + 312 pts / 109 comments (2019), different submitters and 938 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":312,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19055119","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25457168","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":136,"peak_comments":114,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28336850","height":7,"chart_height":74},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":75,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37897958","height":4,"chart_height":41},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/forget-privacy-you-re-terrible-at-targeting-anyway-d9d0235cbaab.jpg","path":"/hall/link/forget-privacy-you-re-terrible-at-targeting-anyway-d9d0235cbaab/"},{"slug":"bottles-gui-front-end-to-run-windows-software-on-linux-d9d023651d3b","title":"Bottles: GUI front end to run Windows software on Linux","domain":"usebottles.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2023-07","inductedMonth":"2025-08","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.285,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":604,"evidenceRank":906,"evidenceScore":63.2,"freshAt":"2025-08-07T13:39:25Z","freshnessRank":174,"freshEventScore":98,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 604 pts / 237 comments (2021) + 98 pts / 65 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,327 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":604,"peak_comments":237,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29612976","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":307,"peak_comments":188,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36592930","height":15,"chart_height":86},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":98,"peak_comments":65,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44824321","height":5,"chart_height":28},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/bottles-gui-front-end-to-run-windows-software-on-linux-d9d023651d3b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/bottles-gui-front-end-to-run-windows-software-on-linux-d9d023651d3b/"},{"slug":"foundations-of-computer-science-d9d0233ef5ac","title":"Foundations of Computer Science","domain":"infolab.stanford.edu","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["algorithms_data_structures","theory_of_computation"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2022-01","inductedMonth":"2025-02","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":16.342,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":325,"evidenceRank":907,"evidenceScore":63.2,"freshAt":"2022-01-27T12:19:48Z","freshnessRank":830,"freshEventScore":325,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 325 pts / 50 comments (2022) + 100 pts / 13 comments (2010), different submitters and 4,237 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=337342","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":100,"peak_comments":13,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1450633","height":5,"chart_height":52},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7071640","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":325,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30099634","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43125834","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/foundations-of-computer-science-d9d0233ef5ac.jpg","path":"/hall/link/foundations-of-computer-science-d9d0233ef5ac/"},{"slug":"show-hn-bear-minimal-blogging-platform-d9d02361ab29","title":"Show HN: Bear – Minimal blogging platform","domain":"bearblog.dev","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","privacy_surveillance","internet_infrastructure"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2022-07","inductedMonth":"2024-06","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.142,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":685,"evidenceRank":908,"evidenceScore":63.2,"freshAt":"2022-07-17T14:57:32Z","freshnessRank":747,"freshEventScore":296,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 685 pts / 349 comments (2020) + 296 pts / 119 comments (2022), different submitters and 781 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":685,"peak_comments":349,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23312339","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":296,"peak_comments":119,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32127363","height":14,"chart_height":73},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40628612","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44592983","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/show-hn-bear-minimal-blogging-platform-d9d02361ab29/"},{"slug":"show-hn-windows-95-in-an-electron-app-d9d0235b4691","title":"Show HN: Windows 95 in an Electron App","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","retrocomputing","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2022-06","inductedMonth":"2022-06","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":7.644,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":213,"evidenceRank":909,"evidenceScore":63.2,"freshAt":"2022-06-27T12:43:26Z","freshnessRank":760,"freshEventScore":137,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 213 pts / 110 comments (2018) + 137 pts / 80 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,403 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":213,"peak_comments":110,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17827797","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22347939","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":137,"peak_comments":80,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31893771","height":7,"chart_height":109},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":19,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45952153","height":4,"chart_height":15},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47785834","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/show-hn-windows-95-in-an-electron-app-d9d0235b4691.jpg","path":"/hall/link/show-hn-windows-95-in-an-electron-app-d9d0235b4691/"},{"slug":"codingfont-a-game-to-help-you-pick-a-coding-font-d9d02366cc47","title":"CodingFont: A game to help you pick a coding font","domain":"www.codingfont.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2026-03","inductedMonth":"2026-03","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.422,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":499,"evidenceRank":910,"evidenceScore":63.2,"freshAt":"2026-03-30T15:16:35Z","freshnessRank":36,"freshEventScore":499,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 499 pts / 239 comments (2026) + 443 pts / 218 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,615 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":443,"peak_comments":218,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29010443","height":21,"chart_height":151},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35926201","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":56,"peak_comments":39,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41604781","height":4,"chart_height":19},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":499,"peak_comments":239,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47575403","height":24,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/codingfont-a-game-to-help-you-pick-a-coding-font-d9d02366cc47.jpg","path":"/hall/link/codingfont-a-game-to-help-you-pick-a-coding-font-d9d02366cc47/"},{"slug":"playdate-a-new-handheld-gaming-system-d9d0235dd1a5","title":"Playdate – A New Handheld Gaming System","domain":"play.date","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["indie_games","game_development","electronics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-09","inductedMonth":"2025-03","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.818,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1370,"evidenceRank":911,"evidenceScore":63.1,"freshAt":"2021-06-08T16:47:41Z","freshnessRank":901,"freshEventScore":353,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1370 pts / 402 comments (2019) + 353 pts / 209 comments (2021), different submitters and 747 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1370,"peak_comments":402,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19986106","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":353,"peak_comments":209,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27437600","height":17,"chart_height":44},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37650850","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41666836","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43379751","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/playdate-a-new-handheld-gaming-system-d9d0235dd1a5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/playdate-a-new-handheld-gaming-system-d9d0235dd1a5/"},{"slug":"gron-make-json-greppable-d9d02359f58a","title":"Gron – Make JSON Greppable","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"source_code","typeDisplay":"Source code","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","data_engineering","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2022-05","inductedMonth":"2023-05","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.673,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":366,"evidenceRank":912,"evidenceScore":63.1,"freshAt":"2023-12-03T21:45:02Z","freshnessRank":488,"freshEventScore":249,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 366 pts / 91 comments (2020) + 249 pts / 73 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,122 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":247,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16727665","height":12,"chart_height":115},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":366,"peak_comments":91,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25006277","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33250055","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":249,"peak_comments":73,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38511077","height":12,"chart_height":116},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/gron-make-json-greppable-d9d02359f58a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/gron-make-json-greppable-d9d02359f58a/"},{"slug":"the-linux-backdoor-attempt-of-2003-2013-d9d0235a3d2b","title":"The Linux Backdoor Attempt of 2003 (2013)","domain":"freedom-to-tinker.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security","security_incidents","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2020-08","inductedMonth":"2023-12","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.662,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":298,"evidenceRank":913,"evidenceScore":63.1,"freshAt":"2023-12-29T14:42:36Z","freshnessRank":473,"freshEventScore":223,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 298 pts / 141 comments (2020) + 223 pts / 98 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,236 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":141,"peak_comments":28,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18173173","height":7,"chart_height":80},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":298,"peak_comments":141,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24106213","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31394610","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":223,"peak_comments":98,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38805439","height":11,"chart_height":127},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-linux-backdoor-attempt-of-2003-2013-d9d0235a3d2b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-linux-backdoor-attempt-of-2003-2013-d9d0235a3d2b/"},{"slug":"the-gentleperson-s-guide-to-forum-spies-2012-d9d02346ae94","title":"The Gentleperson's Guide To Forum Spies (2012)","domain":"cryptome.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["abuse_fraud","privacy_surveillance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2022-10","inductedMonth":"2022-10","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":10.248,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":225,"evidenceRank":914,"evidenceScore":63.1,"freshAt":"2022-10-21T22:53:38Z","freshnessRank":705,"freshEventScore":225,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 225 pts / 187 comments (2022) + 147 pts / 57 comments (2012), different submitters and 3,743 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":147,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4277278","height":7,"chart_height":111},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":89,"peak_comments":33,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7329162","height":4,"chart_height":67},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":49,"peak_comments":10,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21165313","height":4,"chart_height":37},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26653970","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":225,"peak_comments":187,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33293837","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-gentleperson-s-guide-to-forum-spies-2012-d9d02346ae94.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-gentleperson-s-guide-to-forum-spies-2012-d9d02346ae94/"},{"slug":"chimera-linux-d9d02365c4b4","title":"Chimera Linux","domain":"chimera-linux.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","open_source","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2023-12","inductedMonth":"2025-12","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.953,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":267,"evidenceRank":915,"evidenceScore":63.0,"freshAt":"2023-12-16T20:45:35Z","freshnessRank":481,"freshEventScore":267,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 267 pts / 207 comments (2023) + 111 pts / 110 comments (2021), different submitters and 896 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":111,"peak_comments":110,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27721283","height":5,"chart_height":71},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":267,"peak_comments":207,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38667503","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46185962","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48563230","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/chimera-linux-d9d02365c4b4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/chimera-linux-d9d02365c4b4/"},{"slug":"i-draw-figures-for-my-mathematical-lecture-notes-using-inkscape-d9d0235d9168","title":"I draw figures for my mathematical lecture notes using Inkscape","domain":"castel.dev","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["teaching","mathematics","visual_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-05","inductedMonth":"2023-09","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.945,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":542,"evidenceRank":916,"evidenceScore":63.0,"freshAt":"2022-05-01T19:32:28Z","freshnessRank":786,"freshEventScore":312,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 542 pts / 97 comments (2019) + 312 pts / 77 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,099 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":542,"peak_comments":97,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19768012","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":312,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31227940","height":15,"chart_height":98},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37572651","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39950521","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/i-draw-figures-for-my-mathematical-lecture-notes-using-inkscape-d9d0235d9168.jpg","path":"/hall/link/i-draw-figures-for-my-mathematical-lecture-notes-using-inkscape-d9d0235d9168/"},{"slug":"on-generative-algorithms-d9d023511f53","title":"On Generative Algorithms","domain":"inconvergent.net","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["art","computer_graphics","algorithms_data_structures"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-09","inductedMonth":"2018-09","submissions":9,"submitters":8,"spanYears":6.305,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":479,"evidenceRank":917,"evidenceScore":63.0,"freshAt":"2021-12-13T05:34:01Z","freshnessRank":848,"freshEventScore":37,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 479 pts / 41 comments (2018) + 259 pts / 19 comments (2016), different submitters and 738 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10199893","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":4,"peak_score":259,"peak_comments":19,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12476125","height":12,"chart_height":92},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":479,"peak_comments":41,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18032976","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":37,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29536960","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/on-generative-algorithms-d9d023511f53.jpg","path":"/hall/link/on-generative-algorithms-d9d023511f53/"},{"slug":"a-friendly-web-development-tutorial-for-complete-beginners-d9d023561bc4","title":"A friendly web development tutorial for complete beginners","domain":"internetingishard.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","browsers_web_standards","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2019-07","inductedMonth":"2019-11","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":5.467,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":412,"evidenceRank":918,"evidenceScore":63.0,"freshAt":"2019-07-26T09:16:22Z","freshnessRank":1053,"freshEventScore":288,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 412 pts / 54 comments (2017) + 288 pts / 54 comments (2019), different submitters and 892 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":412,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13634363","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":88,"peak_comments":19,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17415270","height":4,"chart_height":36},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":288,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20533446","height":14,"chart_height":119},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22980128","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32332064","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/a-friendly-web-development-tutorial-for-complete-beginners-d9d023561bc4/"},{"slug":"pencil-open-source-gui-prototyping-tool-d9d02348a8fe","title":"Pencil: open-source GUI prototyping tool","domain":"pencil.evolus.vn","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["product_design","user_experience","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2021-05","inductedMonth":"2021-05","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":9.999,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":320,"evidenceRank":919,"evidenceScore":63.0,"freshAt":"2023-03-01T20:43:11Z","freshnessRank":650,"freshEventScore":72,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 320 pts / 79 comments (2016) + 180 pts / 34 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,640 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5302619","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7604085","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":320,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12889053","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":180,"peak_comments":34,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27048163","height":9,"chart_height":96},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":72,"peak_comments":16,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34988045","height":4,"chart_height":38},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/pencil-open-source-gui-prototyping-tool-d9d02348a8fe.jpg","path":"/hall/link/pencil-open-source-gui-prototyping-tool-d9d02348a8fe/"},{"slug":"st-a-simple-terminal-implementation-for-x-d9d023480e6f","title":"St – A simple terminal implementation for X","domain":"st.suckless.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2017-02","inductedMonth":"2022-03","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":9.908,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":274,"evidenceRank":920,"evidenceScore":62.9,"freshAt":"2017-02-02T03:14:40Z","freshnessRank":1138,"freshEventScore":274,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 274 pts / 217 comments (2017) + 92 pts / 83 comments (2014), different submitters and 798 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":91,"peak_comments":39,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4985533","height":4,"chart_height":56},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":92,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8661282","height":4,"chart_height":57},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":274,"peak_comments":217,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13547797","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28551699","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30564279","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/st-a-simple-terminal-implementation-for-x-d9d023480e6f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/st-a-simple-terminal-implementation-for-x-d9d023480e6f/"},{"slug":"magicavoxel-a-free-voxel-art-editor-and-interactive-path-tracing-d9d023527a4c","title":"MagicaVoxel – A free voxel art editor and interactive path tracing renderer","domain":"ephtracy.github.io","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["computer_graphics","visual_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2018-12","inductedMonth":"2023-10","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":7.765,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":334,"evidenceRank":921,"evidenceScore":62.9,"freshAt":"2023-10-28T14:32:59Z","freshnessRank":505,"freshEventScore":334,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 334 pts / 48 comments (2023) + 293 pts / 64 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,773 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":141,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10953918","height":7,"chart_height":72},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":25,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14932554","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":293,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18721555","height":14,"chart_height":149},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":334,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38050106","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/magicavoxel-a-free-voxel-art-editor-and-interactive-path-tracing-d9d023527a4c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/magicavoxel-a-free-voxel-art-editor-and-interactive-path-tracing-d9d023527a4c/"},{"slug":"normalization-of-deviance-2015-d9d02358ddea","title":"Normalization of Deviance (2015)","domain":"danluu.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["workplace","leadership","management_strategy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2023-02","inductedMonth":"2025-09","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":7.759,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":447,"evidenceRank":922,"evidenceScore":62.9,"freshAt":"2025-09-06T18:25:23Z","freshnessRank":153,"freshEventScore":58,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 447 pts / 219 comments (2023) + 180 pts / 43 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,116 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":125,"peak_comments":27,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15835870","height":6,"chart_height":48},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":180,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22144330","height":9,"chart_height":68},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":447,"peak_comments":219,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34791106","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":58,"peak_comments":15,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45151661","height":4,"chart_height":22},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/normalization-of-deviance-2015-d9d02358ddea.jpg","path":"/hall/link/normalization-of-deviance-2015-d9d02358ddea/"},{"slug":"music-theory-for-nerds-d9d02354b675","title":"Music theory for nerds","domain":"eev.ee","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["music","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2022-02","inductedMonth":"2023-09","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.962,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":766,"evidenceRank":923,"evidenceScore":62.9,"freshAt":"2022-02-16T11:58:55Z","freshnessRank":824,"freshEventScore":367,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 766 pts / 378 comments (2016) + 367 pts / 301 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,976 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":766,"peak_comments":378,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12528144","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18768636","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":367,"peak_comments":301,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30358903","height":18,"chart_height":81},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37403141","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/music-theory-for-nerds-d9d02354b675.jpg","path":"/hall/link/music-theory-for-nerds-d9d02354b675/"},{"slug":"every-model-learned-by-gradient-descent-is-approximately-a-kerne-d9d02363b191","title":"Every Model Learned by Gradient Descent Is Approximately a Kernel Machine","domain":"arxiv.org","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"research_paper","typeDisplay":"Research papers","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["machine_learning","artificial_intelligence"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2024-02","inductedMonth":"2024-02","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.646,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":406,"evidenceRank":924,"evidenceScore":62.8,"freshAt":"2024-02-25T01:25:02Z","freshnessRank":442,"freshEventScore":176,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 176 pts / 136 comments (2024) + 406 pts / 107 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,176 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":406,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25314830","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34323369","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":176,"peak_comments":136,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39496747","height":8,"chart_height":74},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44703689","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/every-model-learned-by-gradient-descent-is-approximately-a-kerne-d9d02363b191.jpg","path":"/hall/link/every-model-learned-by-gradient-descent-is-approximately-a-kerne-d9d02363b191/"},{"slug":"android-vendors-don-t-kill-my-app-d9d0235c72ff","title":"Android vendors, don’t kill my app","domain":"dontkillmyapp.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","performance_reliability","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-11","inductedMonth":"2023-11","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.957,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":515,"evidenceRank":925,"evidenceScore":62.8,"freshAt":"2023-11-23T05:20:15Z","freshnessRank":495,"freshEventScore":59,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 515 pts / 402 comments (2019) + 59 pts / 77 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,773 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":515,"peak_comments":402,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18901006","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23633906","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30113716","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":59,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38389618","height":4,"chart_height":19},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46312397","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/android-vendors-don-t-kill-my-app-d9d0235c72ff.jpg","path":"/hall/link/android-vendors-don-t-kill-my-app-d9d0235c72ff/"},{"slug":"linus-torvalds-won-t-do-github-pull-requests-d9d0234611a3","title":"Linus Torvalds won't do github pull requests","domain":"github.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"social_post_thread","typeDisplay":"Social posts & threads","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2021-03","inductedMonth":"2025-12","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":13.629,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":535,"evidenceRank":926,"evidenceScore":62.8,"freshAt":"2023-03-08T19:59:38Z","freshnessRank":646,"freshEventScore":22,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 535 pts / 267 comments (2012) + 43 pts / 70 comments (2021), different submitters and 3,220 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":535,"peak_comments":267,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3960876","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6145991","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":43,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26364697","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":22,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35073974","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46400304","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/linus-torvalds-won-t-do-github-pull-requests-d9d0234611a3/"},{"slug":"why-i-strive-to-be-a-0-1x-engineer-d9d023528125","title":"Why I Strive to be a 0.1x Engineer","domain":"benjiweber.co.uk","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["workplace","labor_productivity","leadership"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2022-11","inductedMonth":"2022-11","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.793,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":445,"evidenceRank":927,"evidenceScore":62.8,"freshAt":"2022-11-10T00:08:08Z","freshnessRank":691,"freshEventScore":126,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 445 pts / 272 comments (2016) + 126 pts / 139 comments (2022), different submitters and 2,478 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":445,"peak_comments":272,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10978841","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14625087","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19318511","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":126,"peak_comments":139,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33540164","height":6,"chart_height":48},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-i-strive-to-be-a-0-1x-engineer-d9d023528125.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-i-strive-to-be-a-0-1x-engineer-d9d023528125/"},{"slug":"applying-to-phd-programs-in-computer-science-2014-pdf-d9d023421b0c","title":"Applying to PhD Programs in Computer Science (2014) [pdf]","domain":"www.cs.cmu.edu","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"course_lecture","typeDisplay":"Courses & lectures","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["academic_life"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2020-05","inductedMonth":"2020-05","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":9.415,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":179,"evidenceRank":928,"evidenceScore":62.7,"freshAt":"2020-05-13T08:02:34Z","freshnessRank":1009,"freshEventScore":179,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 179 pts / 101 comments (2020) + 77 pts / 52 comments (2013), different submitters and 2,389 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":40,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1998666","height":4,"chart_height":38},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3173358","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":77,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6624394","height":4,"chart_height":73},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13800160","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":179,"peak_comments":101,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23164618","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/applying-to-phd-programs-in-computer-science-2014-pdf-d9d023421b0c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/applying-to-phd-programs-in-computer-science-2014-pdf-d9d023421b0c/"},{"slug":"isambard-kingdom-brunel-d9d0234cdc35","title":"Isambard Kingdom Brunel","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["history","cities_infrastructure","manufacturing"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2023-10","inductedMonth":"2023-10","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":9.41,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":165,"evidenceRank":929,"evidenceScore":62.7,"freshAt":"2023-10-10T21:15:40Z","freshnessRank":527,"freshEventScore":165,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 165 pts / 120 comments (2023) + 103 pts / 25 comments (2014), different submitters and 3,437 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":103,"peak_comments":25,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7736288","height":5,"chart_height":106},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":52,"peak_comments":17,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10577096","height":4,"chart_height":54},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13847185","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20360833","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":165,"peak_comments":120,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37837620","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/isambard-kingdom-brunel-d9d0234cdc35.jpg","path":"/hall/link/isambard-kingdom-brunel-d9d0234cdc35/"},{"slug":"takeover-sh-wipe-and-reinstall-a-running-linux-system-via-ssh-wi-d9d0235617ac","title":"Takeover.sh – Wipe and reinstall a running Linux system via SSH without reboot","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2019-03","inductedMonth":"2021-03","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.526,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":515,"evidenceRank":930,"evidenceScore":62.7,"freshAt":"2019-03-11T06:50:04Z","freshnessRank":1064,"freshEventScore":399,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 515 pts / 75 comments (2017) + 399 pts / 79 comments (2019), different submitters and 757 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":515,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13622301","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18741529","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":399,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19357153","height":19,"chart_height":132},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26416464","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/takeover-sh-wipe-and-reinstall-a-running-linux-system-via-ssh-wi-d9d0235617ac.jpg","path":"/hall/link/takeover-sh-wipe-and-reinstall-a-running-linux-system-via-ssh-wi-d9d0235617ac/"},{"slug":"pysimplegui-d9d023601c23","title":"PysimpleGUI","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","programming_languages","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-12","inductedMonth":"2026-01","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.313,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":277,"evidenceRank":931,"evidenceScore":62.7,"freshAt":"2026-05-05T18:18:42Z","freshnessRank":20,"freshEventScore":107,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 277 pts / 153 comments (2023) + 275 pts / 43 comments (2021), different submitters and 809 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22022257","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":275,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28600922","height":13,"chart_height":169},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":277,"peak_comments":153,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38579161","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":107,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48026412","height":5,"chart_height":66}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/pysimplegui-d9d023601c23.jpg","path":"/hall/link/pysimplegui-d9d023601c23/"},{"slug":"decentralized-naming-and-certificate-authority-d9d023604ab5","title":"Decentralized Naming and Certificate Authority","domain":"handshake.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","internet_infrastructure","cryptography"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2022-07","inductedMonth":"2022-07","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":5.054,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":254,"evidenceRank":932,"evidenceScore":62.7,"freshAt":"2022-07-25T08:11:47Z","freshnessRank":744,"freshEventScore":155,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 254 pts / 120 comments (2020) + 155 pts / 95 comments (2022), different submitters and 893 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":254,"peak_comments":120,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22310604","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29221961","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":155,"peak_comments":95,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32221740","height":7,"chart_height":104},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39824514","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43079937","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/decentralized-naming-and-certificate-authority-d9d023604ab5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/decentralized-naming-and-certificate-authority-d9d023604ab5/"},{"slug":"irc-v3-d9d023508c3e","title":"IRC v3","domain":"ircv3.net","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"standard_specification","typeDisplay":"Standards & specifications","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","online_communities"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2021-05","inductedMonth":"2021-05","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":5.908,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":595,"evidenceRank":933,"evidenceScore":62.7,"freshAt":"2021-05-19T17:36:31Z","freshnessRank":908,"freshEventScore":130,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 595 pts / 217 comments (2016) + 130 pts / 94 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,683 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10498554","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":595,"peak_comments":217,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12671063","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20949860","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24922658","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":130,"peak_comments":94,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27211798","height":6,"chart_height":37},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/irc-v3-d9d023508c3e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/irc-v3-d9d023508c3e/"},{"slug":"invisible-electrostatic-wall-at-3m-plant-1996-d9d023449bd0","title":"Invisible Electrostatic Wall at 3M plant (1996)","domain":"amasci.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["physics","electronics","manufacturing"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2025-01","inductedMonth":"2025-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":13.161,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":403,"evidenceRank":934,"evidenceScore":62.7,"freshAt":"2025-01-21T17:37:01Z","freshnessRank":262,"freshEventScore":403,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 403 pts / 221 comments (2025) + 271 pts / 46 comments (2011), different submitters and 4,807 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":271,"peak_comments":46,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3274335","height":13,"chart_height":114},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":96,"peak_comments":23,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5387052","height":5,"chart_height":40},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10164007","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15966172","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":403,"peak_comments":221,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42782914","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/invisible-electrostatic-wall-at-3m-plant-1996-d9d023449bd0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/invisible-electrostatic-wall-at-3m-plant-1996-d9d023449bd0/"},{"slug":"sublime-text-3-marked-as-recommended-build-d9d0233ff9b2","title":"Sublime Text 3 marked as recommended build","domain":"www.sublimetext.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2016-05","inductedMonth":"2022-11","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":13.147,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":233,"evidenceRank":935,"evidenceScore":62.6,"freshAt":"2016-05-31T05:18:45Z","freshnessRank":1150,"freshEventScore":233,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 233 pts / 129 comments (2016) + 91 pts / 72 comments (2009), different submitters and 2,447 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":91,"peak_comments":72,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=828234","height":4,"chart_height":66},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1833945","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6727317","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":233,"peak_comments":129,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11804759","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33543449","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/sublime-text-3-marked-as-recommended-build-d9d0233ff9b2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/sublime-text-3-marked-as-recommended-build-d9d0233ff9b2/"},{"slug":"black-perl-d9d023407c23","title":"Black Perl","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["writing_craft","art","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2019-03","inductedMonth":"2021-07","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":11.57,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":330,"evidenceRank":936,"evidenceScore":62.6,"freshAt":"2013-09-12T00:45:32Z","freshnessRank":1173,"freshEventScore":330,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 330 pts / 67 comments (2013) + 124 pts / 40 comments (2010), different submitters and 1,320 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":124,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1089420","height":6,"chart_height":64},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":330,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6371239","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19372902","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26323991","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/black-perl-d9d023407c23.jpg","path":"/hall/link/black-perl-d9d023407c23/"},{"slug":"why-racket-why-lisp-d9d0235aeaec","title":"Why Racket? Why Lisp?","domain":"beautifulracket.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2022-09","inductedMonth":"2025-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.527,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":327,"evidenceRank":937,"evidenceScore":62.6,"freshAt":"2022-09-14T16:30:03Z","freshnessRank":719,"freshEventScore":202,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 202 pts / 151 comments (2022) + 327 pts / 122 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,214 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17534933","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":327,"peak_comments":122,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19952714","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":202,"peak_comments":151,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32839542","height":10,"chart_height":105},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42806425","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-racket-why-lisp-d9d0235aeaec.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-racket-why-lisp-d9d0235aeaec/"},{"slug":"alan-turing-s-100th-birthday-mathematician-logician-cryptanalyst-d9d02343733f","title":"Alan Turing's 100th Birthday - Mathematician, logician, cryptanalyst, scientist","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["theory_of_computation","cryptography","history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2024-06","inductedMonth":"2024-06","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":12.958,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":146,"evidenceRank":938,"evidenceScore":62.6,"freshAt":"2024-06-07T09:52:54Z","freshnessRank":384,"freshEventScore":103,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 103 pts / 136 comments (2024) + 146 pts / 19 comments (2012), different submitters and 4,367 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":78,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2688079","height":4,"chart_height":91},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":146,"peak_comments":19,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4147637","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5051772","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23616491","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":103,"peak_comments":136,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40607017","height":5,"chart_height":120},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/alan-turing-s-100th-birthday-mathematician-logician-cryptanalyst-d9d02343733f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/alan-turing-s-100th-birthday-mathematician-logician-cryptanalyst-d9d02343733f/"},{"slug":"tinywm-a-tiny-window-manager-in-around-50-lines-of-c-d9d023404da4","title":"TinyWM – A tiny window manager in around 50 lines of C","domain":"incise.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2022-10","inductedMonth":"2022-10","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":12.862,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":335,"evidenceRank":939,"evidenceScore":62.6,"freshAt":"2022-10-25T14:20:46Z","freshnessRank":702,"freshEventScore":211,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 335 pts / 104 comments (2018) + 211 pts / 59 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,532 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":62,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=994794","height":4,"chart_height":31},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4119881","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":335,"peak_comments":104,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17765446","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22368305","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":211,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33330804","height":10,"chart_height":107},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/tinywm-a-tiny-window-manager-in-around-50-lines-of-c-d9d023404da4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/tinywm-a-tiny-window-manager-in-around-50-lines-of-c-d9d023404da4/"},{"slug":"how-crash-bandicoot-hacked-the-original-playstation-2020-video-d9d023609d1f","title":"How Crash Bandicoot hacked the original Playstation (2020) [video]","domain":"www.youtube.com","category":"media","categoryDisplay":"Audio, video & images","type":"video","typeDisplay":"Video","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_development","game_history","retrocomputing"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2022-08","inductedMonth":"2022-08","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":4.758,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":325,"evidenceRank":940,"evidenceScore":62.5,"freshAt":"2022-08-31T15:28:24Z","freshnessRank":723,"freshEventScore":325,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 325 pts / 71 comments (2022) + 265 pts / 77 comments (2020), different submitters and 915 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":265,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22439752","height":13,"chart_height":139},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29541833","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":325,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32663433","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42290106","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-crash-bandicoot-hacked-the-original-playstation-2020-video-d9d023609d1f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-crash-bandicoot-hacked-the-original-playstation-2020-video-d9d023609d1f/"},{"slug":"ideas-for-computing-d9d0234a0b78","title":"Ideas for Computing","domain":"github.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["human_computer_interaction"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2021-05","inductedMonth":"2021-05","submissions":9,"submitters":6,"spanYears":7.828,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":328,"evidenceRank":941,"evidenceScore":62.5,"freshAt":"2021-05-19T09:11:15Z","freshnessRank":909,"freshEventScore":114,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 328 pts / 97 comments (2013) + 114 pts / 16 comments (2021), different submitters and 2,858 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":328,"peak_comments":97,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6078335","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20014629","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":5,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25560540","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":114,"peak_comments":16,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27206198","height":5,"chart_height":59},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/ideas-for-computing-d9d0234a0b78/"},{"slug":"so-you-want-to-write-your-own-language-d9d0234bc300","title":"So you want to write your own language?","domain":"www.drdobbs.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","compilers_runtimes"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2017-03","inductedMonth":"2017-05","submissions":8,"submitters":4,"spanYears":3.324,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":199,"evidenceRank":942,"evidenceScore":62.5,"freshAt":"2017-05-19T11:51:13Z","freshnessRank":1126,"freshEventScore":183,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 199 pts / 203 comments (2014) + 183 pts / 143 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,200 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":3,"peak_score":199,"peak_comments":203,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7172971","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":173,"peak_comments":99,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10782855","height":8,"chart_height":148},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":183,"peak_comments":143,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14374695","height":9,"chart_height":156},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/so-you-want-to-write-your-own-language-d9d0234bc300/"},{"slug":"are-you-an-anarchist-the-answer-may-surprise-you-2000-d9d02356654b","title":"Are you an anarchist? The answer may surprise you (2000)","domain":"theanarchistlibrary.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["politics_government","social_issues","philosophy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2024-05","inductedMonth":"2024-05","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":7.154,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":286,"evidenceRank":943,"evidenceScore":62.4,"freshAt":"2024-05-08T10:54:37Z","freshnessRank":404,"freshEventScore":47,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 286 pts / 812 comments (2020) + 47 pts / 100 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,340 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13855531","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":286,"peak_comments":812,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24383092","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33938748","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36601196","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":47,"peak_comments":100,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40296518","height":4,"chart_height":28},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/are-you-an-anarchist-the-answer-may-surprise-you-2000-d9d02356654b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/are-you-an-anarchist-the-answer-may-surprise-you-2000-d9d02356654b/"},{"slug":"things-to-know-about-gnu-readline-d9d0235eb88a","title":"Things to Know About GNU Readline","domain":"twobithistory.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2024-06","inductedMonth":"2024-06","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.846,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":204,"evidenceRank":944,"evidenceScore":62.4,"freshAt":"2024-06-26T16:00:15Z","freshnessRank":373,"freshEventScore":168,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 204 pts / 113 comments (2019) + 168 pts / 112 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,769 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":204,"peak_comments":113,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20772053","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25594741","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33699287","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36492973","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":168,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40801475","height":8,"chart_height":140},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/things-to-know-about-gnu-readline-d9d0235eb88a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/things-to-know-about-gnu-readline-d9d0235eb88a/"},{"slug":"gnu-librejs-d9d0234908af","title":"GNU LibreJS","domain":"www.gnu.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["open_source","browsers_web_standards","application_security"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2024-05","inductedMonth":"2025-09","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":12.457,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":213,"evidenceRank":945,"evidenceScore":62.4,"freshAt":"2024-05-13T05:12:54Z","freshnessRank":397,"freshEventScore":88,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 213 pts / 159 comments (2016) + 88 pts / 56 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,935 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5508614","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":213,"peak_comments":159,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11598033","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19480874","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":88,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40339998","height":4,"chart_height":70},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45321005","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/gnu-librejs-d9d0234908af/"},{"slug":"six-principles-for-making-new-things-2008-d9d0233e5d69","title":"Six Principles for Making New Things (2008)","domain":"paulgraham.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["product_design","startups_entrepreneurship"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2018-10","inductedMonth":"2019-01","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":10.979,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":173,"evidenceRank":946,"evidenceScore":62.4,"freshAt":"2018-10-12T01:00:46Z","freshnessRank":1080,"freshEventScore":111,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 173 pts / 118 comments (2008) + 111 pts / 15 comments (2018), different submitters and 3,891 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":2,"peak_score":173,"peak_comments":118,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=116768","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":46,"peak_comments":31,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1525068","height":4,"chart_height":45},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":111,"peak_comments":15,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18198313","height":5,"chart_height":109},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19118164","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/six-principles-for-making-new-things-2008-d9d0233e5d69.jpg","path":"/hall/link/six-principles-for-making-new-things-2008-d9d0233e5d69/"},{"slug":"c-isn-t-a-programming-language-anymore-d9d02369a56e","title":"C isn't a programming language anymore","domain":"faultlore.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","compilers_runtimes","software_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2022,"candidateMonth":"2026-02","inductedMonth":"2026-02","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.42,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":238,"evidenceRank":947,"evidenceScore":62.4,"freshAt":"2026-02-06T00:15:55Z","freshnessRank":64,"freshEventScore":114,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 114 pts / 211 comments (2026) + 238 pts / 191 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,186 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":238,"peak_comments":191,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33509223","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":71,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41137063","height":4,"chart_height":51},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":114,"peak_comments":211,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46907350","height":5,"chart_height":81}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/c-isn-t-a-programming-language-anymore-d9d02369a56e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/c-isn-t-a-programming-language-anymore-d9d02369a56e/"},{"slug":"the-church-of-interruption-d9d0235e5bc4","title":"The Church of Interruption","domain":"sambleckley.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["psychology","social_issues"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-08","inductedMonth":"2022-08","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.261,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":399,"evidenceRank":948,"evidenceScore":62.4,"freshAt":"2022-08-21T22:15:47Z","freshnessRank":726,"freshEventScore":250,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 399 pts / 141 comments (2019) + 250 pts / 95 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,064 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":399,"peak_comments":141,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21044009","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26935481","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":250,"peak_comments":95,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32545023","height":12,"chart_height":107},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40811027","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45639378","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-church-of-interruption-d9d0235e5bc4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-church-of-interruption-d9d0235e5bc4/"},{"slug":"safe-deposit-boxes-aren-t-safe-d9d0235e61c3","title":"Safe Deposit Boxes Aren't Safe","domain":"www.nytimes.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["finance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-01","inductedMonth":"2023-01","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":3.466,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":234,"evidenceRank":949,"evidenceScore":62.3,"freshAt":"2023-01-05T20:30:30Z","freshnessRank":675,"freshEventScore":138,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 138 pts / 148 comments (2023) + 234 pts / 143 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,257 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":234,"peak_comments":143,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20545276","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":24,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27109002","height":4,"chart_height":17},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":138,"peak_comments":148,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34266095","height":7,"chart_height":100},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/safe-deposit-boxes-aren-t-safe-d9d0235e61c3/"},{"slug":"json-web-tokens-d9d0234c9ba2","title":"JSON Web Tokens","domain":"jwt.io","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography","application_security","protocols_networking"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2020-05","inductedMonth":"2020-05","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.114,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":467,"evidenceRank":950,"evidenceScore":62.3,"freshAt":"2020-05-26T17:21:17Z","freshnessRank":1006,"freshEventScore":128,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 467 pts / 74 comments (2014) + 128 pts / 42 comments (2020), different submitters and 2,087 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":3,"peak_score":467,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8283006","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9390233","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11387084","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19613447","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":128,"peak_comments":42,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23313844","height":6,"chart_height":47},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/json-web-tokens-d9d0234c9ba2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/json-web-tokens-d9d0234c9ba2/"},{"slug":"bitwarden-compatible-server-written-in-rust-d9d023674f05","title":"Bitwarden compatible server written in Rust","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["privacy_surveillance","open_source","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2024-08","inductedMonth":"2024-08","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.044,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":193,"evidenceRank":951,"evidenceScore":62.3,"freshAt":"2024-08-14T06:21:26Z","freshnessRank":348,"freshEventScore":153,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 153 pts / 116 comments (2024) + 193 pts / 114 comments (2021), different submitters and 964 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":193,"peak_comments":114,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29662418","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":19,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36922433","height":4,"chart_height":17},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":153,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41243147","height":7,"chart_height":135},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46536783","height":4,"chart_height":7}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/bitwarden-compatible-server-written-in-rust-d9d023674f05.jpg","path":"/hall/link/bitwarden-compatible-server-written-in-rust-d9d023674f05/"},{"slug":"why-i-m-putting-all-my-savings-into-bitcoin-2011-d9d0234345be","title":"Why I'm Putting All My Savings into Bitcoin (2011)","domain":"falkvinge.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["finance","markets"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2020-08","inductedMonth":"2020-08","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":9.24,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":116,"evidenceRank":952,"evidenceScore":62.3,"freshAt":"2020-08-24T11:45:39Z","freshnessRank":993,"freshEventScore":37,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 116 pts / 190 comments (2011) + 37 pts / 84 comments (2020), different submitters and 3,374 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":116,"peak_comments":190,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2596475","height":6,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5398850","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":41,"peak_comments":33,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15976946","height":4,"chart_height":60},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":37,"peak_comments":84,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24259700","height":4,"chart_height":54},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-i-m-putting-all-my-savings-into-bitcoin-2011-d9d0234345be.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-i-m-putting-all-my-savings-into-bitcoin-2011-d9d0234345be/"},{"slug":"everyone-has-javascript-right-d9d0235f5e1e","title":"Everyone Has JavaScript, Right?","domain":"kryogenix.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","browsers_web_standards","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2024-04","inductedMonth":"2024-04","submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":4.487,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":87,"evidenceRank":953,"evidenceScore":62.3,"freshAt":"2024-04-21T07:59:16Z","freshnessRank":413,"freshEventScore":87,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 87 pts / 113 comments (2024) + 68 pts / 88 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,043 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21363001","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22009993","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":68,"peak_comments":88,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27484050","height":4,"chart_height":133},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37562084","height":4,"chart_height":18},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":87,"peak_comments":113,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40103948","height":4,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/everyone-has-javascript-right-d9d0235f5e1e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/everyone-has-javascript-right-d9d0235f5e1e/"},{"slug":"google-dataset-search-d9d023603cdb","title":"Google Dataset Search","domain":"datasetsearch.research.google.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["information_retrieval","data_science"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2024-06","inductedMonth":"2024-06","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":4.386,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":388,"evidenceRank":954,"evidenceScore":62.2,"freshAt":"2024-06-12T13:28:42Z","freshnessRank":380,"freshEventScore":107,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 388 pts / 42 comments (2021) + 107 pts / 31 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,132 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":38,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22187127","height":4,"chart_height":17},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":388,"peak_comments":42,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27068551","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35263319","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":107,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40657937","height":5,"chart_height":47},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/google-dataset-search-d9d023603cdb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/google-dataset-search-d9d023603cdb/"},{"slug":"paperback-how-to-store-data-on-a-single-a4-letter-sheet-d9d02346ddcb","title":"PaperBack – How to store data on a single A4/Letter sheet","domain":"ollydbg.de","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["databases_storage","application_security"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2016-04","inductedMonth":"2024-05","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":11.797,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":255,"evidenceRank":955,"evidenceScore":62.2,"freshAt":"2020-04-02T10:37:03Z","freshnessRank":1016,"freshEventScore":23,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 255 pts / 114 comments (2015) + 193 pts / 91 comments (2012), different submitters and 1,132 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":193,"peak_comments":91,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4375797","height":9,"chart_height":129},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":255,"peak_comments":114,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10245836","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11497445","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":23,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22757664","height":4,"chart_height":15},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40538120","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/paperback-how-to-store-data-on-a-single-a4-letter-sheet-d9d02346ddcb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/paperback-how-to-store-data-on-a-single-a4-letter-sheet-d9d02346ddcb/"},{"slug":"ms-paint-ide-d9d0235b6f40","title":"MS Paint IDE","domain":"ms-paint-i.de","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2023-04","inductedMonth":"2025-03","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.48,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":241,"evidenceRank":956,"evidenceScore":62.2,"freshAt":"2025-03-05T11:52:28Z","freshnessRank":242,"freshEventScore":220,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 241 pts / 103 comments (2021) + 220 pts / 75 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,362 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":146,"peak_comments":34,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17958021","height":7,"chart_height":103},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":241,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27481736","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35638632","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":220,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43265431","height":11,"chart_height":155},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/ms-paint-ide-d9d0235b6f40.jpg","path":"/hall/link/ms-paint-ide-d9d0235b6f40/"},{"slug":"the-programmer-s-price-want-to-hire-a-coding-superstar-call-the-d9d0234e846d","title":"The Programmer's Price: Want to hire a coding superstar? Call the agent","domain":"www.newyorker.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["careers","hiring_interviews","startups_entrepreneurship"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2020-10","inductedMonth":"2020-10","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":5.9,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":374,"evidenceRank":957,"evidenceScore":62.2,"freshAt":"2020-10-11T10:36:13Z","freshnessRank":985,"freshEventScore":50,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 374 pts / 216 comments (2014) + 50 pts / 71 comments (2020), different submitters and 2,155 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":374,"peak_comments":216,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8616952","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9810952","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11439483","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":19,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16006157","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":50,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24744867","height":4,"chart_height":23},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-programmer-s-price-want-to-hire-a-coding-superstar-call-the-d9d0234e846d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-programmer-s-price-want-to-hire-a-coding-superstar-call-the-d9d0234e846d/"},{"slug":"this-page-is-designed-to-last-d9d0235fe777","title":"This Page is Designed to Last","domain":"jeffhuang.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["digital_archives","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2021-12","inductedMonth":"2024-01","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.574,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1321,"evidenceRank":958,"evidenceScore":62.1,"freshAt":"2021-12-23T14:11:23Z","freshnessRank":843,"freshEventScore":132,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1321 pts / 446 comments (2019) + 132 pts / 43 comments (2021), different submitters and 734 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":1321,"peak_comments":446,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21840140","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":132,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29661935","height":6,"chart_height":17},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39171617","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48929954","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/this-page-is-designed-to-last-d9d0235fe777.jpg","path":"/hall/link/this-page-is-designed-to-last-d9d0235fe777/"},{"slug":"how-we-built-uber-s-highest-query-per-second-service-using-go-d9d02352d04c","title":"How We Built Uber’s Highest Query per Second Service Using Go","domain":"eng.uber.com","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"technical_report","typeDisplay":"Technical reports","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["performance_reliability","distributed_systems","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-11","inductedMonth":"2019-11","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":3.721,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":187,"evidenceRank":959,"evidenceScore":62.1,"freshAt":"2019-11-14T08:34:51Z","freshnessRank":1035,"freshEventScore":185,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 187 pts / 129 comments (2016) + 185 pts / 117 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,352 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":5,"peak_score":187,"peak_comments":129,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11205776","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":23,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16084090","height":4,"chart_height":21},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":185,"peak_comments":117,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21533799","height":9,"chart_height":168},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/how-we-built-uber-s-highest-query-per-second-service-using-go-d9d02352d04c/"},{"slug":"why-i-program-in-erlang-2012-d9d023478612","title":"Why I program in Erlang (2012)","domain":"www.evanmiller.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2022-11","inductedMonth":"2022-11","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":10.004,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":325,"evidenceRank":960,"evidenceScore":62.0,"freshAt":"2022-11-01T19:17:37Z","freshnessRank":696,"freshEventScore":325,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 325 pts / 136 comments (2022) + 215 pts / 93 comments (2012), different submitters and 3,654 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":215,"peak_comments":93,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4715823","height":10,"chart_height":112},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14857222","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20191793","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":325,"peak_comments":136,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33426041","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-i-program-in-erlang-2012-d9d023478612.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-i-program-in-erlang-2012-d9d023478612/"},{"slug":"open-source-farming-robot-d9d0235ca9b7","title":"Open Source Farming Robot","domain":"farm.bot","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"environment_energy","topicDisplay":"Environment & energy","tags":["agriculture_food_systems","embedded_iot","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2024-08","inductedMonth":"2024-08","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.522,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":714,"evidenceRank":961,"evidenceScore":62.0,"freshAt":"2024-08-03T23:37:52Z","freshnessRank":354,"freshEventScore":714,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 714 pts / 356 comments (2024) + 409 pts / 227 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,135 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19002022","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22623786","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":409,"peak_comments":227,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27628101","height":20,"chart_height":97},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":714,"peak_comments":356,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41150095","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/open-source-farming-robot-d9d0235ca9b7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/open-source-farming-robot-d9d0235ca9b7/"},{"slug":"when-george-soros-broke-the-british-pound-2014-d9d0234ce425","title":"When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014)","domain":"priceonomics.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["economics","markets","history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2019-11","inductedMonth":"2019-11","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.476,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":325,"evidenceRank":962,"evidenceScore":61.9,"freshAt":"2019-11-05T17:18:17Z","freshnessRank":1038,"freshEventScore":325,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 325 pts / 259 comments (2019) + 238 pts / 182 comments (2014), different submitters and 1,999 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":238,"peak_comments":182,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7752291","height":11,"chart_height":124},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11923484","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13544351","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":325,"peak_comments":259,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21454383","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/when-george-soros-broke-the-british-pound-2014-d9d0234ce425.jpg","path":"/hall/link/when-george-soros-broke-the-british-pound-2014-d9d0234ce425/"},{"slug":"a-distributed-posix-file-system-built-on-top-of-redis-and-s3-d9d0236413ea","title":"A distributed Posix file system built on top of Redis and S3","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["databases_storage","distributed_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2026-01","inductedMonth":"2026-01","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.01,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":219,"evidenceRank":963,"evidenceScore":61.9,"freshAt":"2026-01-15T18:45:18Z","freshnessRank":77,"freshEventScore":186,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 219 pts / 116 comments (2021) + 186 pts / 112 comments (2026), different submitters and 1,829 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":219,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25747215","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34417663","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":186,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46637165","height":9,"chart_height":144}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-distributed-posix-file-system-built-on-top-of-redis-and-s3-d9d0236413ea.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-distributed-posix-file-system-built-on-top-of-redis-and-s3-d9d0236413ea/"},{"slug":"paper-models-of-vintage-computers-d9d0235e5960","title":"Paper Models of Vintage Computers","domain":"rockybergen.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["art","retrocomputing"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-02","inductedMonth":"2023-02","submissions":9,"submitters":8,"spanYears":3.611,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":391,"evidenceRank":964,"evidenceScore":61.9,"freshAt":"2023-02-24T20:27:13Z","freshnessRank":653,"freshEventScore":391,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 391 pts / 74 comments (2023) + 240 pts / 36 comments (2021), different submitters and 760 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20449719","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":5,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23458344","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":240,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25898063","height":12,"chart_height":104},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34075379","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":391,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34929638","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/paper-models-of-vintage-computers-d9d0235e5960.jpg","path":"/hall/link/paper-models-of-vintage-computers-d9d0235e5960/"},{"slug":"jetbrains-mono-a-free-and-open-source-typeface-for-developers-d9d02360259e","title":"JetBrains Mono: A free and open-source typeface for developers","domain":"www.jetbrains.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-07","inductedMonth":"2023-07","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":3.507,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":506,"evidenceRank":965,"evidenceScore":61.9,"freshAt":"2023-07-19T16:12:14Z","freshnessRank":587,"freshEventScore":138,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 506 pts / 201 comments (2020) + 138 pts / 111 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,281 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":506,"peak_comments":201,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22053998","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32803484","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":138,"peak_comments":111,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36788767","height":7,"chart_height":46},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/jetbrains-mono-a-free-and-open-source-typeface-for-developers-d9d02360259e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/jetbrains-mono-a-free-and-open-source-typeface-for-developers-d9d02360259e/"},{"slug":"what-i-would-do-if-i-ran-tarsnap-d9d0234c7efc","title":"What I Would Do If I Ran Tarsnap","domain":"www.kalzumeus.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["startups_entrepreneurship","management_strategy","product_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2023-07","inductedMonth":"2023-07","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":9.322,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":801,"evidenceRank":966,"evidenceScore":61.9,"freshAt":"2023-07-30T05:13:56Z","freshnessRank":583,"freshEventScore":101,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 801 pts / 311 comments (2014) + 101 pts / 84 comments (2023), different submitters and 3,404 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":801,"peak_comments":311,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7523953","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14057625","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19541385","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33607240","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":84,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36928043","height":5,"chart_height":21},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-i-would-do-if-i-ran-tarsnap-d9d0234c7efc.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-i-would-do-if-i-ran-tarsnap-d9d0234c7efc/"},{"slug":"beware-of-fast-math-d9d02366f22e","title":"Beware of Fast-Math","domain":"simonbyrne.github.io","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","performance_reliability","compilers_runtimes"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2025-05","inductedMonth":"2025-05","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":3.548,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":319,"evidenceRank":967,"evidenceScore":61.8,"freshAt":"2025-05-31T07:05:57Z","freshnessRank":205,"freshEventScore":319,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 319 pts / 224 comments (2025) + 189 pts / 107 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,295 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":189,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29201473","height":9,"chart_height":101},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34772924","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40285344","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":319,"peak_comments":224,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44142472","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/beware-of-fast-math-d9d02366f22e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/beware-of-fast-math-d9d02366f22e/"},{"slug":"stack-on-a-budget-a-collection-of-services-with-free-tiers-d9d023559455","title":"Stack on a Budget – A collection of services with free tiers","domain":"github.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","startups_entrepreneurship","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-05","inductedMonth":"2024-04","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":9.487,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":353,"evidenceRank":968,"evidenceScore":61.8,"freshAt":"2021-05-03T06:01:26Z","freshnessRank":917,"freshEventScore":353,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 353 pts / 78 comments (2021) + 156 pts / 26 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,593 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":156,"peak_comments":26,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13231951","height":7,"chart_height":75},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":353,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27022075","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40107357","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48526044","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/stack-on-a-budget-a-collection-of-services-with-free-tiers-d9d023559455.jpg","path":"/hall/link/stack-on-a-budget-a-collection-of-services-with-free-tiers-d9d023559455/"},{"slug":"with-proton-and-steam-play-many-windows-games-now-work-on-linux-d9d0235bdfc4","title":"With Proton and Steam Play, many Windows games now work on Linux","domain":"www.protondb.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["emulation"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2020-12","inductedMonth":"2025-12","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":7.091,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":938,"evidenceRank":969,"evidenceScore":61.8,"freshAt":"2025-12-01T07:36:20Z","freshnessRank":111,"freshEventScore":22,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 938 pts / 544 comments (2020) + 932 pts / 311 comments (2018), different submitters and 770 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":932,"peak_comments":311,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18327342","height":24,"chart_height":169},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":938,"peak_comments":544,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25333219","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":22,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46104580","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/with-proton-and-steam-play-many-windows-games-now-work-on-linux-d9d0235bdfc4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/with-proton-and-steam-play-many-windows-games-now-work-on-linux-d9d0235bdfc4/"},{"slug":"an-opinionated-approach-to-gnu-make-d9d0235fe158","title":"An opinionated approach to GNU Make","domain":"tech.davis-hansson.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-08","inductedMonth":"2025-03","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.248,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":414,"evidenceRank":970,"evidenceScore":61.8,"freshAt":"2022-08-21T15:18:49Z","freshnessRank":727,"freshEventScore":185,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 414 pts / 194 comments (2019) + 185 pts / 185 comments (2022), different submitters and 978 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":414,"peak_comments":194,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21812656","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":185,"peak_comments":185,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32541016","height":9,"chart_height":76},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40319742","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43387683","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/an-opinionated-approach-to-gnu-make-d9d0235fe158.jpg","path":"/hall/link/an-opinionated-approach-to-gnu-make-d9d0235fe158/"},{"slug":"google-common-lisp-style-guide-d9d023545ca1","title":"Google Common Lisp style guide","domain":"google.github.io","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"policy_guidelines","typeDisplay":"Policies & guidelines","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","writing_craft"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2024-04","inductedMonth":"2024-04","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":9.139,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":196,"evidenceRank":971,"evidenceScore":61.8,"freshAt":"2024-04-15T23:08:10Z","freshnessRank":418,"freshEventScore":148,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 196 pts / 120 comments (2020) + 148 pts / 55 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,378 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12263802","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":196,"peak_comments":120,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23761346","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37283568","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":148,"peak_comments":55,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40046692","height":7,"chart_height":128},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45422866","height":4,"chart_height":16},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/google-common-lisp-style-guide-d9d023545ca1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/google-common-lisp-style-guide-d9d023545ca1/"},{"slug":"unraveling-the-jpeg-d9d0235d9bbf","title":"Unraveling the JPEG","domain":"parametric.press","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["computer_graphics","algorithms_data_structures"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-03","inductedMonth":"2024-01","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.037,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":399,"evidenceRank":972,"evidenceScore":61.8,"freshAt":"2022-03-08T07:25:32Z","freshnessRank":810,"freshEventScore":109,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 399 pts / 41 comments (2019) + 109 pts / 4 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,041 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":399,"peak_comments":41,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19799650","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26903988","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":109,"peak_comments":4,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30597322","height":5,"chart_height":46},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36429516","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39138069","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43984834","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/unraveling-the-jpeg-d9d0235d9bbf.jpg","path":"/hall/link/unraveling-the-jpeg-d9d0235d9bbf/"},{"slug":"building-the-most-inaccessible-site-with-a-perfect-lighthouse-sc-d9d0235de94f","title":"Building the most inaccessible site with a perfect Lighthouse score (2019)","domain":"www.matuzo.at","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","testing_quality","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-05","inductedMonth":"2022-05","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":6.82,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":331,"evidenceRank":973,"evidenceScore":61.8,"freshAt":"2022-05-28T07:58:59Z","freshnessRank":777,"freshEventScore":145,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 331 pts / 78 comments (2020) + 145 pts / 40 comments (2022), different submitters and 720 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20106766","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":331,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23440752","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":145,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31538475","height":7,"chart_height":74},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47540132","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/building-the-most-inaccessible-site-with-a-perfect-lighthouse-sc-d9d0235de94f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/building-the-most-inaccessible-site-with-a-perfect-lighthouse-sc-d9d0235de94f/"},{"slug":"where-tcl-and-tk-went-wrong-2010-d9d0234541ae","title":"Where Tcl and Tk Went Wrong (2010)","domain":"journal.dedasys.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2017-08","inductedMonth":"2022-09","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":10.631,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":131,"evidenceRank":974,"evidenceScore":61.8,"freshAt":"2017-08-06T14:52:23Z","freshnessRank":1121,"freshEventScore":131,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 131 pts / 109 comments (2017) + 120 pts / 77 comments (2012), different submitters and 2,003 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":120,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3579088","height":6,"chart_height":156},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8072743","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12561268","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":131,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14941525","height":6,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33023609","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/where-tcl-and-tk-went-wrong-2010-d9d0234541ae.jpg","path":"/hall/link/where-tcl-and-tk-went-wrong-2010-d9d0234541ae/"},{"slug":"rfc-1178-choosing-a-name-for-your-computer-1990-d9d02351fb63","title":"RFC 1178: Choosing a name for your computer (1990)","domain":"tools.ietf.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2021-02","inductedMonth":"2021-02","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.205,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":220,"evidenceRank":975,"evidenceScore":61.8,"freshAt":"2021-02-07T10:25:43Z","freshnessRank":944,"freshEventScore":220,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 205 pts / 173 comments (2018) + 220 pts / 121 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,041 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10627352","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":205,"peak_comments":173,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16741009","height":10,"chart_height":158},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25222337","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":220,"peak_comments":121,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26054014","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/rfc-1178-choosing-a-name-for-your-computer-1990-d9d02351fb63.jpg","path":"/hall/link/rfc-1178-choosing-a-name-for-your-computer-1990-d9d02351fb63/"},{"slug":"the-man-in-seat-61-d9d0235c8916","title":"The Man in Seat 61","domain":"www.seat61.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"space_transportation","topicDisplay":"Space & transportation","tags":["transportation","food_travel"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2024-03","inductedMonth":"2024-03","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.15,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":738,"evidenceRank":976,"evidenceScore":61.7,"freshAt":"2024-03-08T08:39:16Z","freshnessRank":431,"freshEventScore":351,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 738 pts / 117 comments (2019) + 351 pts / 101 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,880 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":738,"peak_comments":117,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18895833","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33120493","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37640066","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":351,"peak_comments":101,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39639125","height":17,"chart_height":81},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-man-in-seat-61-d9d0235c8916.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-man-in-seat-61-d9d0235c8916/"},{"slug":"qanat-water-tunnels-in-iran-d9d0234de139","title":"Qanat – Water Tunnels in Iran","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["cities_infrastructure","history","earth_science"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2023-11","inductedMonth":"2023-11","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":9.172,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":423,"evidenceRank":977,"evidenceScore":61.7,"freshAt":"2023-11-11T17:18:16Z","freshnessRank":499,"freshEventScore":423,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 423 pts / 100 comments (2023) + 186 pts / 69 comments (2016), different submitters and 2,733 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8288407","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":186,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11719441","height":9,"chart_height":75},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24580624","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":423,"peak_comments":100,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38232243","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/qanat-water-tunnels-in-iran-d9d0234de139.jpg","path":"/hall/link/qanat-water-tunnels-in-iran-d9d0234de139/"},{"slug":"why-it-s-ok-to-block-ads-2015-d9d023519bec","title":"Why It’s OK to Block Ads (2015)","domain":"blog.practicalethics.ox.ac.uk","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["technology_ethics","privacy_surveillance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2022-09","inductedMonth":"2022-09","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.897,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":91,"evidenceRank":978,"evidenceScore":61.7,"freshAt":"2022-09-08T08:33:08Z","freshnessRank":720,"freshEventScore":91,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 91 pts / 146 comments (2022) + 62 pts / 105 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,722 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":36,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10407810","height":4,"chart_height":67},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":62,"peak_comments":105,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15971443","height":4,"chart_height":116},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":91,"peak_comments":146,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32762895","height":4,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-it-s-ok-to-block-ads-2015-d9d023519bec.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-it-s-ok-to-block-ads-2015-d9d023519bec/"},{"slug":"compressing-and-enhancing-hand-written-notes-2016-d9d02354bd10","title":"Compressing and enhancing hand-written notes (2016)","domain":"mzucker.github.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["computer_graphics","data_engineering"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-04","inductedMonth":"2021-04","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.261,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":639,"evidenceRank":979,"evidenceScore":61.7,"freshAt":"2021-04-10T16:55:08Z","freshnessRank":927,"freshEventScore":204,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 639 pts / 70 comments (2018) + 204 pts / 13 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,125 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":80,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12551207","height":4,"chart_height":21},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":639,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16567275","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23092183","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":204,"peak_comments":13,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26762909","height":10,"chart_height":54},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34139953","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/compressing-and-enhancing-hand-written-notes-2016-d9d02354bd10.jpg","path":"/hall/link/compressing-and-enhancing-hand-written-notes-2016-d9d02354bd10/"},{"slug":"questions-to-ask-at-the-end-of-a-technical-interview-2017-d9d023568d03","title":"Questions to ask at the end of a technical interview (2017)","domain":"smalldata.tech","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["hiring_interviews","careers","workplace"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-04","inductedMonth":"2026-06","submissions":14,"submitters":3,"spanYears":9.213,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":211,"evidenceRank":980,"evidenceScore":61.6,"freshAt":"2020-04-11T11:49:26Z","freshnessRank":1013,"freshEventScore":211,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 211 pts / 108 comments (2020) + 57 pts / 53 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,102 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":5,"peak_score":57,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14037313","height":4,"chart_height":46},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17723235","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19108835","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":211,"peak_comments":108,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22841164","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48525545","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/questions-to-ask-at-the-end-of-a-technical-interview-2017-d9d023568d03.jpg","path":"/hall/link/questions-to-ask-at-the-end-of-a-technical-interview-2017-d9d023568d03/"},{"slug":"a-neural-network-in-11-lines-of-python-d9d02350c150","title":"A Neural Network in 11 Lines of Python","domain":"iamtrask.github.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["machine_learning","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2017-10","inductedMonth":"2017-10","submissions":7,"submitters":5,"spanYears":9.725,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":341,"evidenceRank":981,"evidenceScore":61.6,"freshAt":"2017-10-18T11:59:25Z","freshnessRank":1118,"freshEventScore":234,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 341 pts / 41 comments (2015) + 234 pts / 26 comments (2017), different submitters and 826 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":341,"peak_comments":41,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9886555","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":82,"peak_comments":16,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11378022","height":4,"chart_height":41},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":234,"peak_comments":26,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15498341","height":11,"chart_height":117},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43577960","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-neural-network-in-11-lines-of-python-d9d02350c150.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-neural-network-in-11-lines-of-python-d9d02350c150/"},{"slug":"organic-maps-d9d02365a2ac","title":"Organic Maps","domain":"organicmaps.app","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"space_transportation","topicDisplay":"Space & transportation","tags":["transportation","open_source","privacy_surveillance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2023-09","inductedMonth":"2026-07","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.046,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1401,"evidenceRank":982,"evidenceScore":61.6,"freshAt":"2026-07-05T14:14:30Z","freshnessRank":1,"freshEventScore":66,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1401 pts / 485 comments (2023) + 336 pts / 116 comments (2021), different submitters and 801 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":336,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27576882","height":16,"chart_height":41},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1401,"peak_comments":485,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37347447","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42343654","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":66,"peak_comments":12,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48794446","height":4,"chart_height":8}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/organic-maps-d9d02365a2ac.jpg","path":"/hall/link/organic-maps-d9d02365a2ac/"},{"slug":"show-hn-search-code-in-github-repos-using-regular-expressions-d9d023608f8d","title":"Show HN: Search code in GitHub repos using regular expressions","domain":"grep.app","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","information_retrieval"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-02","inductedMonth":"2024-11","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":5.144,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":614,"evidenceRank":983,"evidenceScore":61.6,"freshAt":"2023-02-07T12:24:29Z","freshnessRank":656,"freshEventScore":189,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 614 pts / 155 comments (2020) + 189 pts / 30 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,079 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":614,"peak_comments":155,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22396824","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":54,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28424845","height":4,"chart_height":15},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":189,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34691804","height":9,"chart_height":52},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42203290","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42747640","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/show-hn-search-code-in-github-repos-using-regular-expressions-d9d023608f8d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/show-hn-search-code-in-github-repos-using-regular-expressions-d9d023608f8d/"},{"slug":"chrysalisp-a-64-bit-lisp-os-with-gui-d9d023586b22","title":"ChrysaLisp – A 64-bit Lisp OS with GUI","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"source_code","typeDisplay":"Source code","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-01","inductedMonth":"2024-04","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":6.497,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":306,"evidenceRank":984,"evidenceScore":61.6,"freshAt":"2023-01-17T17:56:48Z","freshnessRank":667,"freshEventScore":153,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 306 pts / 121 comments (2017) + 153 pts / 16 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,922 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":306,"peak_comments":121,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15466124","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":121,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22019594","height":6,"chart_height":67},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":99,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25779930","height":5,"chart_height":55},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":153,"peak_comments":16,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34415936","height":7,"chart_height":85},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40011738","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/chrysalisp-a-64-bit-lisp-os-with-gui-d9d023586b22.jpg","path":"/hall/link/chrysalisp-a-64-bit-lisp-os-with-gui-d9d023586b22/"},{"slug":"parsing-protobuf-at-2-gb-s-how-i-learned-to-love-tail-calls-in-c-d9d023651469","title":"Parsing Protobuf at 2+GB/S: How I Learned to Love Tail Calls in C","domain":"blog.reverberate.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["performance_reliability","programming_languages","compilers_runtimes","data_engineering"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2024-08","inductedMonth":"2024-08","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":3.329,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":586,"evidenceRank":985,"evidenceScore":61.6,"freshAt":"2024-08-19T08:42:03Z","freshnessRank":345,"freshEventScore":366,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 586 pts / 190 comments (2021) + 366 pts / 160 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,211 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":586,"peak_comments":190,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26931581","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33885541","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37185026","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":366,"peak_comments":160,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41289114","height":18,"chart_height":106},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/parsing-protobuf-at-2-gb-s-how-i-learned-to-love-tail-calls-in-c-d9d023651469.jpg","path":"/hall/link/parsing-protobuf-at-2-gb-s-how-i-learned-to-love-tail-calls-in-c-d9d023651469/"},{"slug":"thirty-three-miniatures-applications-of-linear-algebra-2012-pdf-d9d0234b8b9e","title":"Thirty-three Miniatures: Applications of Linear Algebra (2012) [pdf]","domain":"kam.mff.cuni.cz","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"technical_report","typeDisplay":"Technical reports","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","algorithms_data_structures"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2019-06","inductedMonth":"2024-02","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":10.155,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":346,"evidenceRank":986,"evidenceScore":61.6,"freshAt":"2019-06-21T09:49:03Z","freshnessRank":1059,"freshEventScore":346,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 346 pts / 13 comments (2019) + 247 pts / 11 comments (2017), different submitters and 795 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6969838","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":247,"peak_comments":11,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14129306","height":12,"chart_height":121},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":346,"peak_comments":13,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20241148","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38037686","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39465653","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/thirty-three-miniatures-applications-of-linear-algebra-2012-pdf-d9d0234b8b9e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/thirty-three-miniatures-applications-of-linear-algebra-2012-pdf-d9d0234b8b9e/"},{"slug":"how-to-center-in-css-d9d0234fdf17","title":"How to Center in CSS","domain":"howtocenterincss.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2020-05","inductedMonth":"2020-05","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.101,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1036,"evidenceRank":987,"evidenceScore":61.6,"freshAt":"2020-05-19T14:32:28Z","freshnessRank":1007,"freshEventScore":161,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1036 pts / 289 comments (2015) + 161 pts / 69 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,856 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":1036,"peak_comments":289,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9405284","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":135,"peak_comments":39,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11697621","height":6,"chart_height":22},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":161,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23235278","height":8,"chart_height":26},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-to-center-in-css-d9d0234fdf17.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-to-center-in-css-d9d0234fdf17/"},{"slug":"consciousness-as-a-state-of-matter-d9d0234ba256","title":"Consciousness as a State of Matter","domain":"arxiv.org","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"research_paper","typeDisplay":"Research papers","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["physics","neuroscience","artificial_intelligence"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2017-04","inductedMonth":"2019-01","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.06,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":94,"evidenceRank":988,"evidenceScore":61.5,"freshAt":"2019-01-30T20:20:26Z","freshnessRank":1069,"freshEventScore":49,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 94 pts / 134 comments (2014) + 49 pts / 73 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,848 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":4,"peak_score":94,"peak_comments":134,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7024651","height":5,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":76,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14192946","height":4,"chart_height":137},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":49,"peak_comments":73,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19039012","height":4,"chart_height":89},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/consciousness-as-a-state-of-matter-d9d0234ba256.jpg","path":"/hall/link/consciousness-as-a-state-of-matter-d9d0234ba256/"},{"slug":"lessons-from-outsourcing-to-india-china-and-the-philippines-d9d023553627","title":"Lessons from Outsourcing to India, China and the Philippines","domain":"www.troyhunt.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["management_strategy","labor_productivity","workplace","geopolitics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-02","inductedMonth":"2023-06","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.628,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":265,"evidenceRank":989,"evidenceScore":61.5,"freshAt":"2020-02-24T17:49:32Z","freshnessRank":1020,"freshEventScore":207,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 265 pts / 113 comments (2016) + 207 pts / 105 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,200 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":265,"peak_comments":113,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12923925","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":207,"peak_comments":105,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22406359","height":10,"chart_height":133},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36503301","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/lessons-from-outsourcing-to-india-china-and-the-philippines-d9d023553627.jpg","path":"/hall/link/lessons-from-outsourcing-to-india-china-and-the-philippines-d9d023553627/"},{"slug":"draw-an-iceberg-and-see-how-it-would-float-in-water-d9d023647ed6","title":"Draw an iceberg and see how it would float in water","domain":"joshdata.me","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["physics","scientific_method","computer_graphics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2024-06","inductedMonth":"2026-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.882,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1669,"evidenceRank":990,"evidenceScore":61.5,"freshAt":"2024-06-08T22:04:24Z","freshnessRank":381,"freshEventScore":388,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1669 pts / 171 comments (2021) + 388 pts / 61 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,204 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1669,"peak_comments":171,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26201160","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35443883","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":388,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40620472","height":19,"chart_height":40},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46541829","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/draw-an-iceberg-and-see-how-it-would-float-in-water-d9d023647ed6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/draw-an-iceberg-and-see-how-it-would-float-in-water-d9d023647ed6/"},{"slug":"tarsnap-online-backups-for-the-truly-paranoid-d9d02349806b","title":"Tarsnap – Online backups for the truly paranoid","domain":"www.tarsnap.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["databases_storage","application_security","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2017-01","inductedMonth":"2017-01","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":4.977,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":147,"evidenceRank":991,"evidenceScore":61.5,"freshAt":"2017-01-28T00:35:52Z","freshnessRank":1139,"freshEventScore":139,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 147 pts / 132 comments (2013) + 139 pts / 74 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,343 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":147,"peak_comments":132,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5767116","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7447814","height":4,"chart_height":15},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11128150","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":139,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13504046","height":7,"chart_height":161},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17090689","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/tarsnap-online-backups-for-the-truly-paranoid-d9d02349806b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/tarsnap-online-backups-for-the-truly-paranoid-d9d02349806b/"},{"slug":"how-to-read-mathematics-d9d0233f8136","title":"How to Read Mathematics","domain":"web.stonehill.edu","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["scientific_method"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2017-04","inductedMonth":"2017-04","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":8.005,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":393,"evidenceRank":992,"evidenceScore":61.5,"freshAt":"2017-04-30T18:12:36Z","freshnessRank":1129,"freshEventScore":393,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 393 pts / 31 comments (2017) + 169 pts / 24 comments (2010), different submitters and 2,460 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=583977","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":169,"peak_comments":24,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1576969","height":8,"chart_height":73},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":115,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2704979","height":6,"chart_height":50},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":393,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14232977","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/how-to-read-mathematics-d9d0233f8136/"},{"slug":"animated-factorisation-diagrams-d9d02347849e","title":"Animated Factorisation Diagrams","domain":"www.datapointed.net","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2025-05","inductedMonth":"2025-05","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":12.559,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":325,"evidenceRank":993,"evidenceScore":61.5,"freshAt":"2025-05-21T14:39:37Z","freshnessRank":209,"freshEventScore":284,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 325 pts / 72 comments (2012) + 284 pts / 63 comments (2025), different submitters and 4,570 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":325,"peak_comments":72,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4788224","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":97,"peak_comments":30,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10776019","height":5,"chart_height":51},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21512894","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":284,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44051958","height":14,"chart_height":149},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/animated-factorisation-diagrams-d9d02347849e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/animated-factorisation-diagrams-d9d02347849e/"},{"slug":"secretive-macos-native-app-to-store-ssh-keys-in-the-secure-encla-d9d023620ca1","title":"Secretive – macOS native app to store SSH keys in the Secure Enclave","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography","developer_tools","operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-03","inductedMonth":"2025-05","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.857,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":417,"evidenceRank":994,"evidenceScore":61.5,"freshAt":"2023-03-10T04:06:29Z","freshnessRank":644,"freshEventScore":292,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 417 pts / 106 comments (2020) + 292 pts / 125 comments (2023), different submitters and 985 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":417,"peak_comments":106,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23664129","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":48,"peak_comments":11,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28853329","height":4,"chart_height":20},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":292,"peak_comments":125,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35090238","height":14,"chart_height":119},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42821484","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/secretive-macos-native-app-to-store-ssh-keys-in-the-secure-encla-d9d023620ca1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/secretive-macos-native-app-to-store-ssh-keys-in-the-secure-encla-d9d023620ca1/"},{"slug":"which-word-begins-with-y-and-looks-like-an-axe-in-this-picture-2-d9d0235767ef","title":"Which word begins with \"y\" and looks like an axe in this picture? (2017)","domain":"english.stackexchange.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"forum_discussion","typeDisplay":"Forum discussions","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["language_linguistics","children_parenting"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2024-01","inductedMonth":"2024-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.56,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1220,"evidenceRank":995,"evidenceScore":61.5,"freshAt":"2024-01-17T22:03:15Z","freshnessRank":457,"freshEventScore":1220,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1220 pts / 289 comments (2024) + 615 pts / 158 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,392 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":615,"peak_comments":158,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14670306","height":24,"chart_height":86},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":56,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22685058","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1220,"peak_comments":289,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39034160","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/which-word-begins-with-y-and-looks-like-an-axe-in-this-picture-2-d9d0235767ef.jpg","path":"/hall/link/which-word-begins-with-y-and-looks-like-an-axe-in-this-picture-2-d9d0235767ef/"},{"slug":"google-web-designer-d9d0234ab3d4","title":"Google Web Designer","domain":"www.google.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design","web_development","computer_graphics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-12","inductedMonth":"2016-12","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":3.211,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1126,"evidenceRank":996,"evidenceScore":61.5,"freshAt":"2016-12-16T03:26:27Z","freshnessRank":1142,"freshEventScore":437,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1126 pts / 442 comments (2013) + 437 pts / 149 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,172 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":1126,"peak_comments":442,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6470426","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":79,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7939668","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10215060","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":437,"peak_comments":149,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13190824","height":21,"chart_height":66},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/google-web-designer-d9d0234ab3d4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/google-web-designer-d9d0234ab3d4/"},{"slug":"iknowwhatyoudownload-com-torrent-activity-checker-d9d02355a324","title":"Iknowwhatyoudownload.com – Torrent Activity Checker","domain":"iknowwhatyoudownload.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["privacy_surveillance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2023-11","inductedMonth":"2023-11","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.869,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":148,"evidenceRank":997,"evidenceScore":61.5,"freshAt":"2023-11-07T10:39:35Z","freshnessRank":500,"freshEventScore":148,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 148 pts / 136 comments (2023) + 125 pts / 83 comments (2016), different submitters and 2,508 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":125,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13249578","height":6,"chart_height":144},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":53,"peak_comments":38,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22102806","height":4,"chart_height":61},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29174058","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":47,"peak_comments":27,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32404358","height":4,"chart_height":54},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":148,"peak_comments":136,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38175311","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/iknowwhatyoudownload-com-torrent-activity-checker-d9d02355a324/"},{"slug":"free-and-open-source-alternative-to-airdrop-d9d0234c654d","title":"Free and Open Source Alternative to Airdrop","domain":"www.sharedrop.io","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","protocols_networking","privacy_surveillance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2024-01","inductedMonth":"2024-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":9.826,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":228,"evidenceRank":998,"evidenceScore":61.4,"freshAt":"2024-01-21T15:26:11Z","freshnessRank":456,"freshEventScore":228,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 228 pts / 154 comments (2024) + 165 pts / 68 comments (2014), different submitters and 3,588 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":165,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7468328","height":8,"chart_height":123},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22762969","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25869441","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35778525","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":228,"peak_comments":154,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39079256","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/free-and-open-source-alternative-to-airdrop-d9d0234c654d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/free-and-open-source-alternative-to-airdrop-d9d0234c654d/"},{"slug":"byte-magazine-special-issue-smalltalk-1984-d9d0234badc3","title":"Byte Magazine Special Issue: Smalltalk (1984)","domain":"archive.org","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["history","retrocomputing","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2022-08","inductedMonth":"2022-08","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":8.575,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":136,"evidenceRank":999,"evidenceScore":61.4,"freshAt":"2022-08-11T15:15:29Z","freshnessRank":733,"freshEventScore":136,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 136 pts / 116 comments (2022) + 123 pts / 42 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,173 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":79,"peak_comments":32,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7052479","height":4,"chart_height":99},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":22,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15021759","height":4,"chart_height":28},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":123,"peak_comments":42,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20014281","height":6,"chart_height":154},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":136,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32427002","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/byte-magazine-special-issue-smalltalk-1984-d9d0234badc3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/byte-magazine-special-issue-smalltalk-1984-d9d0234badc3/"},{"slug":"why-zig-when-there-is-already-c-d-and-rust-d9d023642320","title":"Why Zig when there is already C++, D, and Rust?","domain":"ziglang.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools","compilers_runtimes"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2024-01","inductedMonth":"2026-06","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":5.407,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":276,"evidenceRank":1000,"evidenceScore":61.4,"freshAt":"2024-01-22T02:07:51Z","freshnessRank":454,"freshEventScore":155,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 276 pts / 259 comments (2021) + 155 pts / 204 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,101 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":276,"peak_comments":259,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25797025","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32799618","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":155,"peak_comments":204,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39085238","height":7,"chart_height":95},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46159301","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48515318","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-zig-when-there-is-already-c-d-and-rust-d9d023642320.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-zig-when-there-is-already-c-d-and-rust-d9d023642320/"},{"slug":"bearssl-smaller-ssl-tls-d9d023552666","title":"BearSSL – Smaller SSL/TLS","domain":"bearssl.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography","application_security","embedded_iot"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2022-10","inductedMonth":"2022-10","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":8.449,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":338,"evidenceRank":1001,"evidenceScore":61.4,"freshAt":"2022-10-29T07:44:28Z","freshnessRank":698,"freshEventScore":143,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 338 pts / 195 comments (2016) + 143 pts / 63 comments (2022), different submitters and 2,185 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":338,"peak_comments":195,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12863699","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13350289","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":143,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33381920","height":7,"chart_height":72},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43707513","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/bearssl-smaller-ssl-tls-d9d023552666.jpg","path":"/hall/link/bearssl-smaller-ssl-tls-d9d023552666/"},{"slug":"neural-networks-zero-to-hero-d9d0236ade49","title":"Neural Networks: Zero to Hero","domain":"karpathy.ai","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"course_lecture","typeDisplay":"Courses & lectures","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["machine_learning","artificial_intelligence","teaching"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2023,"candidateMonth":"2026-01","inductedMonth":"2026-01","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":2.982,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":791,"evidenceRank":1002,"evidenceScore":61.3,"freshAt":"2026-01-04T05:02:16Z","freshnessRank":86,"freshEventScore":791,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 791 pts / 77 comments (2026) + 642 pts / 68 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,004 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":5,"peak_score":642,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35459031","height":24,"chart_height":138},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41358459","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":791,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46485090","height":24,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/neural-networks-zero-to-hero-d9d0236ade49.jpg","path":"/hall/link/neural-networks-zero-to-hero-d9d0236ade49/"},{"slug":"atkinson-hyperlegible-font-d9d023660163","title":"Atkinson Hyperlegible Font","domain":"brailleinstitute.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"source_code","typeDisplay":"Source code","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design","user_experience","product_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2024-09","inductedMonth":"2026-03","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.66,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":799,"evidenceRank":1003,"evidenceScore":61.3,"freshAt":"2024-09-15T20:42:03Z","freshnessRank":332,"freshEventScore":786,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 799 pts / 235 comments (2022) + 786 pts / 214 comments (2024), different submitters and 735 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28010540","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":799,"peak_comments":235,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32799872","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":786,"peak_comments":214,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41550211","height":24,"chart_height":167},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47558460","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/atkinson-hyperlegible-font-d9d023660163.jpg","path":"/hall/link/atkinson-hyperlegible-font-d9d023660163/"},{"slug":"thoughts-on-public-speaking-2014-d9d0234bb118","title":"Thoughts on Public Speaking (2014)","domain":"speaking.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["teaching","careers"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2017-06","inductedMonth":"2017-06","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":3.395,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":371,"evidenceRank":1004,"evidenceScore":61.3,"freshAt":"2017-06-07T19:19:16Z","freshnessRank":1122,"freshEventScore":125,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 371 pts / 106 comments (2014) + 125 pts / 69 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,239 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":4,"peak_score":371,"peak_comments":106,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7059303","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10088033","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11277575","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":125,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14509110","height":6,"chart_height":57},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/thoughts-on-public-speaking-2014-d9d0234bb118.jpg","path":"/hall/link/thoughts-on-public-speaking-2014-d9d0234bb118/"},{"slug":"teenager-finds-classical-alternative-to-quantum-recommendation-a-d9d0235b101c","title":"Teenager Finds Classical Alternative to Quantum Recommendation Algorithm","domain":"www.quantamagazine.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["theory_of_computation","algorithms_data_structures","mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-09","inductedMonth":"2025-07","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.982,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":824,"evidenceRank":1005,"evidenceScore":61.3,"freshAt":"2025-07-24T16:42:25Z","freshnessRank":186,"freshEventScore":121,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 824 pts / 216 comments (2018) + 121 pts / 49 comments (2025), different submitters and 2,550 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":824,"peak_comments":216,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17654220","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":113,"peak_comments":44,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28413023","height":5,"chart_height":23},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":121,"peak_comments":49,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44672859","height":6,"chart_height":25},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/teenager-finds-classical-alternative-to-quantum-recommendation-a-d9d0235b101c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/teenager-finds-classical-alternative-to-quantum-recommendation-a-d9d0235b101c/"},{"slug":"c-implementation-of-tic-tac-toe-in-a-single-call-to-printf-d9d02361ca6e","title":"C implementation of Tic-Tac-Toe in a single call to printf","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"source_code","typeDisplay":"Source code","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2022-06","inductedMonth":"2024-04","submissions":10,"submitters":9,"spanYears":4.167,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":377,"evidenceRank":1006,"evidenceScore":61.3,"freshAt":"2022-06-08T01:40:08Z","freshnessRank":768,"freshEventScore":202,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 377 pts / 82 comments (2020) + 202 pts / 21 comments (2022), different submitters and 730 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":377,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23445546","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":202,"peak_comments":21,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31662275","height":10,"chart_height":91},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":7,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41157511","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/c-implementation-of-tic-tac-toe-in-a-single-call-to-printf-d9d02361ca6e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/c-implementation-of-tic-tac-toe-in-a-single-call-to-printf-d9d02361ca6e/"},{"slug":"stop-reading-news-2013-d9d0235b7d50","title":"Stop Reading News (2013)","domain":"fs.blog","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["journalism_media","personal_productivity","psychology"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-09","inductedMonth":"2021-09","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":3.014,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":211,"evidenceRank":1007,"evidenceScore":61.3,"freshAt":"2021-09-22T13:35:03Z","freshnessRank":869,"freshEventScore":171,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 211 pts / 202 comments (2019) + 171 pts / 108 comments (2021), different submitters and 960 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18256691","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":211,"peak_comments":202,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19084099","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23238645","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":171,"peak_comments":108,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28616134","height":8,"chart_height":138},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/stop-reading-news-2013-d9d0235b7d50.jpg","path":"/hall/link/stop-reading-news-2013-d9d0235b7d50/"},{"slug":"statistical-formulas-for-programmers-d9d023497175","title":"Statistical Formulas For Programmers","domain":"www.evanmiller.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["data_science","mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2025-03","inductedMonth":"2025-03","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":11.814,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":395,"evidenceRank":1008,"evidenceScore":61.3,"freshAt":"2025-03-13T14:09:21Z","freshnessRank":240,"freshEventScore":240,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 395 pts / 64 comments (2013) + 240 pts / 39 comments (2025), different submitters and 4,315 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":395,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5735730","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11578513","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39172931","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":240,"peak_comments":39,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43353551","height":12,"chart_height":103},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/statistical-formulas-for-programmers-d9d023497175.jpg","path":"/hall/link/statistical-formulas-for-programmers-d9d023497175/"},{"slug":"halt-and-catch-fire-syllabus-d9d023643400","title":"Halt and Catch Fire Syllabus","domain":"bits.ashleyblewer.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"course_lecture","typeDisplay":"Courses & lectures","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["teaching","history","film_television"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2025-08","inductedMonth":"2025-08","submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":4.586,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":480,"evidenceRank":1009,"evidenceScore":61.2,"freshAt":"2025-08-24T20:19:55Z","freshnessRank":164,"freshEventScore":182,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 480 pts / 171 comments (2021) + 182 pts / 77 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,671 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":480,"peak_comments":171,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25912241","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39007198","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":182,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45007414","height":9,"chart_height":64},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/halt-and-catch-fire-syllabus-d9d023643400.jpg","path":"/hall/link/halt-and-catch-fire-syllabus-d9d023643400/"},{"slug":"please-enough-with-the-dead-butterflies-2017-d9d02365f440","title":"Please, enough with the dead butterflies (2017)","domain":"www.emilydamstra.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["art","biology","visual_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2024-03","inductedMonth":"2026-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.52,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":614,"evidenceRank":1010,"evidenceScore":61.2,"freshAt":"2024-03-03T22:40:13Z","freshnessRank":433,"freshEventScore":324,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 614 pts / 210 comments (2021) + 324 pts / 94 comments (2024), different submitters and 952 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":614,"peak_comments":210,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27948008","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37341159","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":324,"peak_comments":94,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39585207","height":16,"chart_height":90},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46842087","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/please-enough-with-the-dead-butterflies-2017-d9d02365f440.jpg","path":"/hall/link/please-enough-with-the-dead-butterflies-2017-d9d02365f440/"},{"slug":"solidjs-javascript-ui-library-d9d02365c708","title":"Solidjs – JavaScript UI Library","domain":"www.solidjs.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","programming_languages","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2025-04","inductedMonth":"2025-04","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.789,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":349,"evidenceRank":1011,"evidenceScore":61.2,"freshAt":"2025-04-19T07:50:38Z","freshnessRank":219,"freshEventScore":316,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 316 pts / 173 comments (2025) + 349 pts / 88 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,236 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":349,"peak_comments":88,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29388296","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38093159","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40496395","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":316,"peak_comments":173,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43734911","height":15,"chart_height":154},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/solidjs-javascript-ui-library-d9d02365c708.jpg","path":"/hall/link/solidjs-javascript-ui-library-d9d02365c708/"},{"slug":"sql-style-guide-d9d02350d9ec","title":"SQL Style Guide","domain":"www.sqlstyle.guide","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"policy_guidelines","typeDisplay":"Policies & guidelines","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["databases_storage"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2024-11","inductedMonth":"2024-11","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":9.314,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":257,"evidenceRank":1012,"evidenceScore":61.2,"freshAt":"2024-11-15T02:45:29Z","freshnessRank":297,"freshEventScore":56,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 257 pts / 146 comments (2016) + 56 pts / 68 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,958 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":10,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9941150","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":257,"peak_comments":146,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12671667","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":59,"peak_comments":16,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17924917","height":4,"chart_height":39},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23990001","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":56,"peak_comments":68,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42143528","height":4,"chart_height":37},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/sql-style-guide-d9d02350d9ec.jpg","path":"/hall/link/sql-style-guide-d9d02350d9ec/"},{"slug":"e-ink-writing-pad-noteslate-d9d02342604f","title":"E-ink writing pad, Noteslate.","domain":"www.noteslate.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["electronics","product_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2015-10","inductedMonth":"2015-10","submissions":8,"submitters":7,"spanYears":5.166,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":296,"evidenceRank":1013,"evidenceScore":61.2,"freshAt":"2015-10-02T00:25:35Z","freshnessRank":1164,"freshEventScore":92,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 296 pts / 116 comments (2011) + 92 pts / 70 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,700 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":3,"peak_score":296,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2180623","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7507340","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":92,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10315807","height":4,"chart_height":53},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11360506","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/e-ink-writing-pad-noteslate-d9d02342604f/"},{"slug":"the-myopia-boom-2015-d9d0234f9efe","title":"The myopia boom (2015)","domain":"www.nature.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"medicine_health","topicDisplay":"Medicine & health","tags":["public_health"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-04","inductedMonth":"2019-09","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.537,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":311,"evidenceRank":1014,"evidenceScore":61.1,"freshAt":"2019-09-30T05:55:19Z","freshnessRank":1043,"freshEventScore":172,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 311 pts / 100 comments (2015) + 199 pts / 67 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,136 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":4,"peak_score":311,"peak_comments":100,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9227541","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":199,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16948264","height":10,"chart_height":109},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":172,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21112121","height":8,"chart_height":94},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-myopia-boom-2015-d9d0234f9efe.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-myopia-boom-2015-d9d0234f9efe/"},{"slug":"how-https-works-d9d0235a2ed8","title":"How HTTPS Works","domain":"howhttps.works","category":"media","categoryDisplay":"Audio, video & images","type":"image_comic","typeDisplay":"Images & comics","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography","protocols_networking","browsers_web_standards"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2020-09","inductedMonth":"2021-12","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":7.956,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":466,"evidenceRank":1015,"evidenceScore":61.1,"freshAt":"2020-09-14T23:53:43Z","freshnessRank":991,"freshEventScore":466,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 466 pts / 64 comments (2020) + 163 pts / 72 comments (2018), different submitters and 738 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":163,"peak_comments":72,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17932728","height":8,"chart_height":59},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":466,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24476469","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29520873","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47704817","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-https-works-d9d0235a2ed8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-https-works-d9d0235a2ed8/"},{"slug":"why-developers-never-use-state-machines-2011-d9d02343f46d","title":"Why Developers Never Use State Machines (2011)","domain":"skorks.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2023-01","inductedMonth":"2023-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":11.395,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":237,"evidenceRank":1016,"evidenceScore":61.1,"freshAt":"2023-01-23T00:03:48Z","freshnessRank":663,"freshEventScore":93,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 93 pts / 117 comments (2023) + 237 pts / 92 comments (2011), different submitters and 4,161 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":237,"peak_comments":92,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2949543","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12204038","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20875583","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":93,"peak_comments":117,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34483779","height":4,"chart_height":67},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-developers-never-use-state-machines-2011-d9d02343f46d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-developers-never-use-state-machines-2011-d9d02343f46d/"},{"slug":"benjamin-button-reviews-the-new-macbook-pro-d9d023551cb0","title":"Benjamin Button Reviews the New MacBook Pro","domain":"blog.pinboard.in","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["computer_architecture","product_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-10","inductedMonth":"2021-10","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.966,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":253,"evidenceRank":1017,"evidenceScore":61.1,"freshAt":"2021-10-19T18:36:46Z","freshnessRank":861,"freshEventScore":157,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 157 pts / 117 comments (2021) + 253 pts / 110 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,814 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":253,"peak_comments":110,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12834902","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":89,"peak_comments":10,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18337493","height":4,"chart_height":60},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":157,"peak_comments":117,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28921700","height":8,"chart_height":105},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/benjamin-button-reviews-the-new-macbook-pro-d9d023551cb0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/benjamin-button-reviews-the-new-macbook-pro-d9d023551cb0/"},{"slug":"textql-execute-sql-against-csv-or-tsv-d9d0234be4b1","title":"TextQL: Execute SQL Against CSV or TSV","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","databases_storage","data_engineering"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2018-04","inductedMonth":"2023-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":8.923,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":658,"evidenceRank":1018,"evidenceScore":61.0,"freshAt":"2018-04-07T15:59:14Z","freshnessRank":1102,"freshEventScore":658,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 658 pts / 91 comments (2018) + 130 pts / 91 comments (2014), different submitters and 1,523 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":130,"peak_comments":91,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7175830","height":6,"chart_height":34},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13177250","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13418481","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":658,"peak_comments":91,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16781294","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34288777","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/textql-execute-sql-against-csv-or-tsv-d9d0234be4b1.jpg","path":"/hall/link/textql-execute-sql-against-csv-or-tsv-d9d0234be4b1/"},{"slug":"is-parallel-programming-hard-and-if-so-what-can-you-do-about-it-d9d0235b585e","title":"“Is Parallel Programming Hard, and, If So, What Can You Do About It?” v2 Is Out","domain":"mirrors.edge.kernel.org","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["distributed_systems","operating_systems","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2023-06","inductedMonth":"2023-06","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.114,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":197,"evidenceRank":1019,"evidenceScore":61.0,"freshAt":"2023-06-13T22:09:59Z","freshnessRank":613,"freshEventScore":184,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 184 pts / 191 comments (2023) + 197 pts / 75 comments (2021), different submitters and 813 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17883783","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22048811","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":197,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26537298","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":184,"peak_comments":191,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36318280","height":9,"chart_height":159},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41809267","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/is-parallel-programming-hard-and-if-so-what-can-you-do-about-it-d9d0235b585e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/is-parallel-programming-hard-and-if-so-what-can-you-do-about-it-d9d0235b585e/"},{"slug":"the-jank-programming-language-d9d023697505","title":"The jank programming language","domain":"jank-lang.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"standard_specification","typeDisplay":"Standards & specifications","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","compilers_runtimes","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2022,"candidateMonth":"2025-07","inductedMonth":"2025-07","submissions":8,"submitters":6,"spanYears":2.891,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":423,"evidenceRank":1020,"evidenceScore":61.0,"freshAt":"2025-07-06T16:56:42Z","freshnessRank":192,"freshEventScore":423,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 423 pts / 137 comments (2025) + 320 pts / 79 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,054 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":320,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32493217","height":15,"chart_height":129},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42315631","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":423,"peak_comments":137,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44482273","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-jank-programming-language-d9d023697505.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-jank-programming-language-d9d023697505/"},{"slug":"please-don-t-theme-our-apps-d9d0235dd82e","title":"Please don’t theme our apps","domain":"stopthemingmy.app","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["user_experience","visual_design","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2021-09","inductedMonth":"2023-09","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.364,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":169,"evidenceRank":1021,"evidenceScore":61.0,"freshAt":"2023-10-05T14:58:09Z","freshnessRank":530,"freshEventScore":43,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 169 pts / 194 comments (2019) + 43 pts / 87 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,594 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":169,"peak_comments":194,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20008396","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":73,"peak_comments":80,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28400337","height":4,"chart_height":73},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":43,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37779435","height":4,"chart_height":43},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/please-don-t-theme-our-apps-d9d0235dd82e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/please-don-t-theme-our-apps-d9d0235dd82e/"},{"slug":"the-man-with-1-000-klein-bottles-under-his-house-video-d9d023508ee3","title":"The man with 1,000 klein bottles under his house [video]","domain":"www.youtube.com","category":"media","categoryDisplay":"Audio, video & images","type":"video","typeDisplay":"Video","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2021-06","inductedMonth":"2024-02","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":8.619,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":386,"evidenceRank":1022,"evidenceScore":60.9,"freshAt":"2021-06-30T11:08:57Z","freshnessRank":895,"freshEventScore":141,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 386 pts / 122 comments (2015) + 141 pts / 17 comments (2021), different submitters and 2,199 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":386,"peak_comments":122,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9762331","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21832137","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23547389","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":141,"peak_comments":17,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27687148","height":7,"chart_height":62},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39247710","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-man-with-1-000-klein-bottles-under-his-house-video-d9d023508ee3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-man-with-1-000-klein-bottles-under-his-house-video-d9d023508ee3/"},{"slug":"ditherpunk-the-article-i-wish-i-had-about-monochrome-image-dithe-d9d0236403ea","title":"Ditherpunk: The article I wish I had about monochrome image dithering","domain":"surma.dev","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["computer_graphics","visual_design","game_development","art"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2023-05","inductedMonth":"2024-09","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":4.197,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1290,"evidenceRank":1023,"evidenceScore":60.9,"freshAt":"2023-05-21T18:50:21Z","freshnessRank":625,"freshEventScore":255,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1290 pts / 200 comments (2021) + 255 pts / 37 comments (2023), different submitters and 867 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1290,"peak_comments":200,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25633483","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31420405","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":255,"peak_comments":37,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36023706","height":12,"chart_height":34},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41626755","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43391209","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/ditherpunk-the-article-i-wish-i-had-about-monochrome-image-dithe-d9d0236403ea.jpg","path":"/hall/link/ditherpunk-the-article-i-wish-i-had-about-monochrome-image-dithe-d9d0236403ea/"},{"slug":"show-hn-onedev-a-lightweight-gitlab-alternative-d9d02360291c","title":"Show HN: OneDev – A Lightweight GitLab Alternative","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2022-08","inductedMonth":"2022-08","submissions":8,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.739,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":459,"evidenceRank":1024,"evidenceScore":60.9,"freshAt":"2022-08-02T08:12:56Z","freshnessRank":739,"freshEventScore":200,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 459 pts / 94 comments (2020) + 200 pts / 69 comments (2022), different submitters and 927 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":459,"peak_comments":94,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22081419","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28687551","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":200,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32316251","height":10,"chart_height":74},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45556924","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/show-hn-onedev-a-lightweight-gitlab-alternative-d9d02360291c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/show-hn-onedev-a-lightweight-gitlab-alternative-d9d02360291c/"},{"slug":"how-to-create-an-os-from-scratch-tutorial-d9d02356ed94","title":"How to create an OS from scratch – tutorial","domain":"github.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","computer_architecture","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2025-09","inductedMonth":"2025-09","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":8.402,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":377,"evidenceRank":1025,"evidenceScore":60.8,"freshAt":"2025-09-29T23:32:10Z","freshnessRank":139,"freshEventScore":227,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 377 pts / 58 comments (2018) + 227 pts / 79 comments (2025), different submitters and 2,567 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14273375","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":377,"peak_comments":58,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18023062","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19181907","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24047897","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":227,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45420173","height":11,"chart_height":102},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-to-create-an-os-from-scratch-tutorial-d9d02356ed94.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-to-create-an-os-from-scratch-tutorial-d9d02356ed94/"},{"slug":"cpu-utilization-is-wrong-d9d02356f60f","title":"CPU Utilization is Wrong","domain":"www.brendangregg.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["performance_reliability","computer_architecture","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2023-07","inductedMonth":"2025-09","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":8.334,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":624,"evidenceRank":1026,"evidenceScore":60.8,"freshAt":"2025-09-08T08:06:39Z","freshnessRank":149,"freshEventScore":40,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 624 pts / 91 comments (2017) + 94 pts / 57 comments (2023), different submitters and 2,246 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":624,"peak_comments":91,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14301739","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17869066","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23827032","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":94,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36580006","height":5,"chart_height":26},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":40,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45165749","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/cpu-utilization-is-wrong-d9d02356f60f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/cpu-utilization-is-wrong-d9d02356f60f/"},{"slug":"ftp-must-die-d9d02343715a","title":"FTP Must Die","domain":"mywiki.wooledge.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","application_security"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2016-03","inductedMonth":"2019-10","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":8.282,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":174,"evidenceRank":1027,"evidenceScore":60.7,"freshAt":"2016-03-09T09:36:11Z","freshnessRank":1156,"freshEventScore":46,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 174 pts / 116 comments (2012) + 46 pts / 84 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,500 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2684121","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":174,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3526277","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5364856","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":46,"peak_comments":84,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11251907","height":4,"chart_height":45},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21145916","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/ftp-must-die-d9d02343715a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/ftp-must-die-d9d02343715a/"},{"slug":"the-paranoid-style-in-american-politics-1964-d9d0236194fa","title":"The Paranoid Style in American Politics (1964)","domain":"harpers.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["politics_government","history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2025-08","inductedMonth":"2025-08","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":5.221,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":120,"evidenceRank":1028,"evidenceScore":60.7,"freshAt":"2025-08-08T02:55:28Z","freshnessRank":173,"freshEventScore":100,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 120 pts / 101 comments (2020) + 100 pts / 21 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,739 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":120,"peak_comments":101,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24964931","height":6,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38300002","height":4,"chart_height":17},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41256980","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":100,"peak_comments":21,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44832927","height":5,"chart_height":142},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-paranoid-style-in-american-politics-1964-d9d0236194fa.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-paranoid-style-in-american-politics-1964-d9d0236194fa/"},{"slug":"reversing-sinclair-s-amazing-1974-calculator-hack-half-the-rom-o-d9d0234a6bbb","title":"Reversing Sinclair's amazing 1974 calculator hack - half the ROM of the HP-35","domain":"files.righto.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["computer_architecture","retrocomputing","mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2021-09","inductedMonth":"2021-09","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":8.049,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":303,"evidenceRank":1029,"evidenceScore":60.6,"freshAt":"2021-09-17T00:01:51Z","freshnessRank":872,"freshEventScore":207,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 303 pts / 96 comments (2013) + 207 pts / 54 comments (2021), different submitters and 2,939 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":303,"peak_comments":96,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6302364","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10240263","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15839892","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23291883","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":207,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28559442","height":10,"chart_height":116},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/reversing-sinclair-s-amazing-1974-calculator-hack-half-the-rom-o-d9d0234a6bbb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/reversing-sinclair-s-amazing-1974-calculator-hack-half-the-rom-o-d9d0234a6bbb/"},{"slug":"systems-built-on-trust-norms-and-institutions-function-better-th-d9d0235a01db","title":"Systems built on trust, norms, and institutions function better than blockchain","domain":"medium.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["technology_ethics","economics","philosophy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2022-01","inductedMonth":"2022-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.786,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":303,"evidenceRank":1030,"evidenceScore":60.6,"freshAt":"2022-01-18T11:37:13Z","freshnessRank":832,"freshEventScore":92,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 303 pts / 220 comments (2018) + 92 pts / 194 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,382 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":303,"peak_comments":220,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16774293","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21071369","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22526278","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":92,"peak_comments":194,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29977716","height":4,"chart_height":52},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/systems-built-on-trust-norms-and-institutions-function-better-th-d9d0235a01db/"},{"slug":"a-practical-guide-to-securing-macos-d9d0235534cc","title":"A practical guide to securing macOS","domain":"github.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security","privacy_surveillance","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-08","inductedMonth":"2020-08","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.784,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":633,"evidenceRank":1031,"evidenceScore":60.6,"freshAt":"2020-08-22T09:23:07Z","freshnessRank":994,"freshEventScore":323,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 633 pts / 84 comments (2016) + 323 pts / 89 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,367 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":633,"peak_comments":84,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13023823","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":25,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13857893","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":62,"peak_comments":32,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17903149","height":4,"chart_height":17},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":323,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24242890","height":16,"chart_height":87},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-practical-guide-to-securing-macos-d9d0235534cc.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-practical-guide-to-securing-macos-d9d0235534cc/"},{"slug":"the-architecture-behind-a-one-person-tech-startup-d9d02364f426","title":"The architecture behind a one-person tech startup","domain":"anthonynsimon.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","startups_entrepreneurship","internet_infrastructure"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2024-06","inductedMonth":"2024-06","submissions":9,"submitters":8,"spanYears":3.19,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1330,"evidenceRank":1032,"evidenceScore":60.5,"freshAt":"2024-06-16T01:51:54Z","freshnessRank":376,"freshEventScore":234,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1330 pts / 320 comments (2021) + 234 pts / 78 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,164 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1330,"peak_comments":320,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26737771","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33213199","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":5,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38263606","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":234,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40694103","height":11,"chart_height":30},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-architecture-behind-a-one-person-tech-startup-d9d02364f426.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-architecture-behind-a-one-person-tech-startup-d9d02364f426/"},{"slug":"webamp-winamp-2-in-the-browser-d9d0235ae500","title":"Webamp: Winamp 2 in the browser","domain":"webamp.org","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["music","web_development","internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-04","inductedMonth":"2022-09","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.181,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":281,"evidenceRank":1033,"evidenceScore":60.5,"freshAt":"2022-09-16T12:38:41Z","freshnessRank":718,"freshEventScore":135,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 281 pts / 104 comments (2021) + 139 pts / 41 comments (2018), different submitters and 997 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":139,"peak_comments":41,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17583997","height":7,"chart_height":84},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22670625","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":281,"peak_comments":104,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26811696","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":135,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32865304","height":6,"chart_height":82},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/webamp-winamp-2-in-the-browser-d9d0235ae500.jpg","path":"/hall/link/webamp-winamp-2-in-the-browser-d9d0235ae500/"},{"slug":"tips-for-mathematical-handwriting-2007-d9d0235dadd6","title":"Tips for mathematical handwriting (2007)","domain":"johnkerl.org","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","teaching","writing_craft"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2025-02","inductedMonth":"2025-02","submissions":7,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.758,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":283,"evidenceRank":1034,"evidenceScore":60.5,"freshAt":"2025-02-08T19:20:10Z","freshnessRank":250,"freshEventScore":283,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 283 pts / 158 comments (2025) + 150 pts / 76 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,749 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19861653","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":150,"peak_comments":76,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22983274","height":7,"chart_height":90},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":25,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32665846","height":4,"chart_height":15},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41964686","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":283,"peak_comments":158,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42985427","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/tips-for-mathematical-handwriting-2007-d9d0235dadd6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/tips-for-mathematical-handwriting-2007-d9d0235dadd6/"},{"slug":"how-did-europe-become-the-richest-part-of-the-world-d9d023562241","title":"How did Europe become the richest part of the world?","domain":"aeon.co","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["economics","history","geopolitics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2022-03","inductedMonth":"2022-03","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.09,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":87,"evidenceRank":1035,"evidenceScore":60.5,"freshAt":"2022-03-20T12:19:54Z","freshnessRank":801,"freshEventScore":87,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 87 pts / 271 comments (2022) + 75 pts / 110 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,857 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":75,"peak_comments":110,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13665837","height":4,"chart_height":147},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22455802","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":87,"peak_comments":271,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30742048","height":4,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-did-europe-become-the-richest-part-of-the-world-d9d023562241.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-did-europe-become-the-richest-part-of-the-world-d9d023562241/"},{"slug":"gnu-units-d9d023640915","title":"GNU Units","domain":"www.gnu.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","mathematics","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2023-08","inductedMonth":"2026-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.068,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":421,"evidenceRank":1036,"evidenceScore":60.5,"freshAt":"2023-08-03T15:39:37Z","freshnessRank":580,"freshEventScore":216,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 421 pts / 203 comments (2021) + 216 pts / 114 comments (2023), different submitters and 939 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":421,"peak_comments":203,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25657311","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":216,"peak_comments":114,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36987372","height":10,"chart_height":87},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46838433","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/gnu-units-d9d023640915/"},{"slug":"the-radix-2-51-trick-2017-d9d02361b665","title":"The radix 2^51 trick (2017)","domain":"www.chosenplaintext.ca","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["algorithms_data_structures","cryptography","performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2025-05","inductedMonth":"2025-05","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.002,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":518,"evidenceRank":1037,"evidenceScore":60.4,"freshAt":"2025-05-30T03:55:37Z","freshnessRank":206,"freshEventScore":431,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 518 pts / 83 comments (2020) + 431 pts / 82 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,826 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":518,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23351007","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":51,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33706153","height":4,"chart_height":17},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":431,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44132673","height":21,"chart_height":141},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-radix-2-51-trick-2017-d9d02361b665.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-radix-2-51-trick-2017-d9d02361b665/"},{"slug":"sioyek-is-a-pdf-viewer-with-a-focus-on-textbooks-and-research-pa-d9d02366775e","title":"Sioyek is a PDF viewer with a focus on textbooks and research papers","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source","academic_life"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2024-05","inductedMonth":"2024-05","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.463,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":336,"evidenceRank":1038,"evidenceScore":60.4,"freshAt":"2024-05-09T21:28:43Z","freshnessRank":402,"freshEventScore":336,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 336 pts / 111 comments (2024) + 238 pts / 81 comments (2022), different submitters and 810 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29117769","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":238,"peak_comments":81,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30395649","height":11,"chart_height":120},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37997821","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":336,"peak_comments":111,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40313143","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47308346","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/sioyek-is-a-pdf-viewer-with-a-focus-on-textbooks-and-research-pa-d9d02366775e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/sioyek-is-a-pdf-viewer-with-a-focus-on-textbooks-and-research-pa-d9d02366775e/"},{"slug":"localsend-an-open-source-cross-platform-alternative-to-airdrop-d9d0236b10eb","title":"Localsend: An open-source cross-platform alternative to AirDrop","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["open_source","protocols_networking","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2023,"candidateMonth":"2026-04","inductedMonth":"2026-04","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":3.239,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":923,"evidenceRank":1039,"evidenceScore":60.3,"freshAt":"2026-04-28T11:54:20Z","freshnessRank":24,"freshEventScore":923,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 923 pts / 275 comments (2026) + 563 pts / 229 comments (2023), different submitters and 922 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":563,"peak_comments":229,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37938183","height":24,"chart_height":104},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43343574","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":923,"peak_comments":275,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47933208","height":24,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/localsend-an-open-source-cross-platform-alternative-to-airdrop-d9d0236b10eb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/localsend-an-open-source-cross-platform-alternative-to-airdrop-d9d0236b10eb/"},{"slug":"utm-virtual-machines-for-ios-and-macos-d9d023608c46","title":"UTM – Virtual Machines for iOS and macOS","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-08","inductedMonth":"2023-08","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.524,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":342,"evidenceRank":1040,"evidenceScore":60.3,"freshAt":"2023-08-31T06:53:43Z","freshnessRank":557,"freshEventScore":342,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 342 pts / 169 comments (2023) + 335 pts / 145 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,286 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":335,"peak_comments":145,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22385370","height":16,"chart_height":167},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28140970","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29955148","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":342,"peak_comments":169,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37333404","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/utm-virtual-machines-for-ios-and-macos-d9d023608c46.jpg","path":"/hall/link/utm-virtual-machines-for-ios-and-macos-d9d023608c46/"},{"slug":"so-you-want-to-build-an-embedded-linux-system-d9d0236333e8","title":"So you want to build an embedded Linux system?","domain":"jaycarlson.net","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["embedded_iot","operating_systems","electronics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-11","inductedMonth":"2024-08","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.844,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":535,"evidenceRank":1041,"evidenceScore":60.2,"freshAt":"2024-08-20T00:29:40Z","freshnessRank":344,"freshEventScore":127,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 535 pts / 111 comments (2020) + 127 pts / 40 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,403 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":535,"peak_comments":111,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24800037","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":233,"peak_comments":76,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30273301","height":11,"chart_height":74},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38100509","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":127,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41295692","height":6,"chart_height":40},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/so-you-want-to-build-an-embedded-linux-system-d9d0236333e8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/so-you-want-to-build-an-embedded-linux-system-d9d0236333e8/"},{"slug":"lulu-an-open-source-macos-firewall-that-blocks-unknown-outgoing-d9d023581dac","title":"LuLu: An open-source macOS firewall that blocks unknown outgoing connections","domain":"objective-see.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security","privacy_surveillance","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-01","inductedMonth":"2021-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.335,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":804,"evidenceRank":1042,"evidenceScore":60.1,"freshAt":"2021-01-12T07:34:46Z","freshnessRank":954,"freshEventScore":364,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 804 pts / 238 comments (2018) + 364 pts / 150 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,088 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15226560","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":804,"peak_comments":238,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16188502","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20660687","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":364,"peak_comments":150,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25743546","height":17,"chart_height":77},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/lulu-an-open-source-macos-firewall-that-blocks-unknown-outgoing-d9d023581dac.jpg","path":"/hall/link/lulu-an-open-source-macos-firewall-that-blocks-unknown-outgoing-d9d023581dac/"},{"slug":"design-docs-at-google-d9d0236224c2","title":"Design Docs at Google","domain":"www.industrialempathy.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","management_strategy","writing_craft"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2024-05","inductedMonth":"2024-05","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.833,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":459,"evidenceRank":1043,"evidenceScore":60.1,"freshAt":"2024-05-06T11:54:25Z","freshnessRank":407,"freshEventScore":345,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 459 pts / 187 comments (2020) + 345 pts / 185 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,384 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":459,"peak_comments":187,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23915521","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37534558","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":345,"peak_comments":185,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40273534","height":17,"chart_height":128},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/design-docs-at-google-d9d0236224c2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/design-docs-at-google-d9d0236224c2/"},{"slug":"is-it-really-complex-or-did-we-just-make-it-complicated-video-d9d0234ef161","title":"Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicated'? [video]","domain":"www.youtube.com","category":"media","categoryDisplay":"Audio, video & images","type":"video","typeDisplay":"Video","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["software_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2017-04","inductedMonth":"2017-04","submissions":6,"submitters":4,"spanYears":10.979,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":229,"evidenceRank":1044,"evidenceScore":60.1,"freshAt":"2017-04-24T21:58:26Z","freshnessRank":1130,"freshEventScore":185,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 229 pts / 158 comments (2015) + 185 pts / 79 comments (2017), different submitters and 837 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":229,"peak_comments":158,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8857113","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13129594","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":185,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14188759","height":9,"chart_height":137},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46436382","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/is-it-really-complex-or-did-we-just-make-it-complicated-video-d9d0234ef161.jpg","path":"/hall/link/is-it-really-complex-or-did-we-just-make-it-complicated-video-d9d0234ef161/"},{"slug":"low-level-bit-hacks-you-absolutely-must-know-d9d0233fb008","title":"Low Level Bit Hacks You Absolutely Must Know","domain":"www.catonmat.net","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["algorithms_data_structures"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2018-05","inductedMonth":"2018-05","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":8.86,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":342,"evidenceRank":1045,"evidenceScore":60.1,"freshAt":"2018-05-10T21:23:02Z","freshnessRank":1098,"freshEventScore":342,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 342 pts / 171 comments (2018) + 139 pts / 76 comments (2009), different submitters and 3,236 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":139,"peak_comments":76,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=681282","height":7,"chart_height":69},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3599961","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7133643","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":342,"peak_comments":171,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17043082","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/low-level-bit-hacks-you-absolutely-must-know-d9d0233fb008.jpg","path":"/hall/link/low-level-bit-hacks-you-absolutely-must-know-d9d0233fb008/"},{"slug":"startup-playbook-2015-d9d0235c6414","title":"Startup Playbook (2015)","domain":"playbook.samaltman.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["startups_entrepreneurship","management_strategy","leadership"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2023-04","inductedMonth":"2025-12","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.968,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":640,"evidenceRank":1046,"evidenceScore":60.1,"freshAt":"2024-08-11T08:57:22Z","freshnessRank":350,"freshEventScore":25,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 640 pts / 55 comments (2019) + 237 pts / 65 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,563 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18763540","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":640,"peak_comments":55,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18917362","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":237,"peak_comments":65,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35745293","height":11,"chart_height":63},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":25,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41214900","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46261844","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/startup-playbook-2015-d9d0235c6414.jpg","path":"/hall/link/startup-playbook-2015-d9d0235c6414/"},{"slug":"what-s-wrong-with-git-a-conceptual-design-analysis-2016-d9d023550b00","title":"What’s wrong with Git? A conceptual design analysis (2016)","domain":"blog.acolyer.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","software_architecture","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-04","inductedMonth":"2021-04","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.507,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":142,"evidenceRank":1047,"evidenceScore":60.1,"freshAt":"2021-04-27T20:24:45Z","freshnessRank":919,"freshEventScore":142,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 142 pts / 212 comments (2021) + 92 pts / 109 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,645 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":92,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12785200","height":4,"chart_height":110},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20043468","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":142,"peak_comments":212,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26961044","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-s-wrong-with-git-a-conceptual-design-analysis-2016-d9d023550b00.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-s-wrong-with-git-a-conceptual-design-analysis-2016-d9d023550b00/"},{"slug":"goatcounter-simple-web-statistics-with-no-tracking-of-personal-d-d9d023602274","title":"GoatCounter – Simple web statistics, with no tracking of personal data","domain":"www.goatcounter.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","privacy_surveillance","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-01","inductedMonth":"2023-01","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.726,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":475,"evidenceRank":1048,"evidenceScore":60.0,"freshAt":"2023-01-05T19:25:34Z","freshnessRank":676,"freshEventScore":249,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 475 pts / 136 comments (2020) + 249 pts / 47 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,087 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":475,"peak_comments":136,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22044854","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27945094","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31460535","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":249,"peak_comments":47,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34265127","height":12,"chart_height":89},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41748812","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/goatcounter-simple-web-statistics-with-no-tracking-of-personal-d-d9d023602274.jpg","path":"/hall/link/goatcounter-simple-web-statistics-with-no-tracking-of-personal-d-d9d023602274/"},{"slug":"falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-phone-numbers-2016-d9d023530376","title":"Falsehoods Programmers Believe About Phone Numbers (2016)","domain":"github.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-02","inductedMonth":"2019-02","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":2.935,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":451,"evidenceRank":1049,"evidenceScore":60.0,"freshAt":"2019-02-21T02:31:10Z","freshnessRank":1066,"freshEventScore":451,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 451 pts / 198 comments (2019) + 236 pts / 121 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,068 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":236,"peak_comments":121,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11321236","height":11,"chart_height":89},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18024850","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":451,"peak_comments":198,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19214035","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-phone-numbers-2016-d9d023530376.jpg","path":"/hall/link/falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-phone-numbers-2016-d9d023530376/"},{"slug":"how-some-good-corporate-engineering-blogs-are-written-d9d02360bd76","title":"How some good corporate engineering blogs are written","domain":"danluu.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["hiring_interviews","writing_craft","management_strategy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2024-05","inductedMonth":"2024-05","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":6.015,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":617,"evidenceRank":1050,"evidenceScore":60.0,"freshAt":"2024-05-30T14:56:40Z","freshnessRank":388,"freshEventScore":215,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 617 pts / 94 comments (2020) + 215 pts / 60 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,541 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":617,"peak_comments":94,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22544688","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30210047","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":215,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40524531","height":10,"chart_height":59},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47419192","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-some-good-corporate-engineering-blogs-are-written-d9d02360bd76.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-some-good-corporate-engineering-blogs-are-written-d9d02360bd76/"},{"slug":"a-free-as-in-freedom-re-implementation-of-google-s-android-user-d9d023531dff","title":"A free-as-in-freedom re-implementation of Google’s Android user space","domain":"microg.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","open_source","privacy_surveillance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2020-11","inductedMonth":"2020-11","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.676,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":790,"evidenceRank":1051,"evidenceScore":60.0,"freshAt":"2020-11-30T11:05:26Z","freshnessRank":970,"freshEventScore":790,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 790 pts / 187 comments (2020) + 123 pts / 16 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,708 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":123,"peak_comments":16,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11373435","height":6,"chart_height":26},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14658162","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18344966","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19899327","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":790,"peak_comments":187,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25252598","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-free-as-in-freedom-re-implementation-of-google-s-android-user-d9d023531dff.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-free-as-in-freedom-re-implementation-of-google-s-android-user-d9d023531dff/"},{"slug":"a-home-made-lithographically-fabricated-integrated-circuit-d9d0235a3a12","title":"A home-made lithographically-fabricated integrated circuit","domain":"sam.zeloof.xyz","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["electronics","manufacturing","computer_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-08","inductedMonth":"2021-08","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":3.316,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":712,"evidenceRank":1052,"evidenceScore":60.0,"freshAt":"2021-08-22T08:02:44Z","freshnessRank":880,"freshEventScore":114,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 712 pts / 116 comments (2018) + 114 pts / 13 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,210 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":4,"peak_score":712,"peak_comments":116,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16955549","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":247,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21239145","height":12,"chart_height":59},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":114,"peak_comments":13,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28263714","height":5,"chart_height":27},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-home-made-lithographically-fabricated-integrated-circuit-d9d0235a3a12.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-home-made-lithographically-fabricated-integrated-circuit-d9d0235a3a12/"},{"slug":"aerc-an-email-client-that-runs-in-the-terminal-d9d0235def65","title":"Aerc – An email client that runs in the terminal","domain":"aerc-mail.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","protocols_networking","open_source","cryptography"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-10","inductedMonth":"2024-08","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.982,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":722,"evidenceRank":1053,"evidenceScore":60.0,"freshAt":"2022-10-11T17:22:03Z","freshnessRank":710,"freshEventScore":205,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 722 pts / 264 comments (2019) + 205 pts / 50 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,225 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":722,"peak_comments":264,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20090950","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":205,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33166054","height":10,"chart_height":48},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41271160","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44119635","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/aerc-an-email-client-that-runs-in-the-terminal-d9d0235def65.jpg","path":"/hall/link/aerc-an-email-client-that-runs-in-the-terminal-d9d0235def65/"},{"slug":"star-citizen-crowdfunding-passes-750m-d9d0235fb947","title":"Star Citizen crowdfunding passes $750M","domain":"robertsspaceindustries.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"live_data_dashboard","typeDisplay":"Live-data dashboards","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_development","finance","startups_entrepreneurship"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2024-12","inductedMonth":"2024-12","submissions":7,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.999,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":125,"evidenceRank":1054,"evidenceScore":60.0,"freshAt":"2024-12-01T22:12:24Z","freshnessRank":291,"freshEventScore":125,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 125 pts / 167 comments (2024) + 57 pts / 71 comments (2022), different submitters and 803 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21680999","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23512946","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29289859","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":57,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32916496","height":4,"chart_height":78},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":125,"peak_comments":167,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42291101","height":6,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/star-citizen-crowdfunding-passes-750m-d9d0235fb947.jpg","path":"/hall/link/star-citizen-crowdfunding-passes-750m-d9d0235fb947/"},{"slug":"libreboot-open-letter-to-the-free-software-community-d9d02354e77e","title":"Libreboot: Open Letter to the Free Software Community","domain":"libreboot.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["operating_systems","open_source","computer_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-09","inductedMonth":"2021-09","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.923,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":272,"evidenceRank":1055,"evidenceScore":60.0,"freshAt":"2021-09-10T08:35:48Z","freshnessRank":875,"freshEventScore":209,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 272 pts / 207 comments (2017) + 209 pts / 67 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,617 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":167,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12669086","height":8,"chart_height":104},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":272,"peak_comments":207,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14052927","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":209,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28479084","height":10,"chart_height":131},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/libreboot-open-letter-to-the-free-software-community-d9d02354e77e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/libreboot-open-letter-to-the-free-software-community-d9d02354e77e/"},{"slug":"modern-ci-is-too-complex-and-misdirected-2021-d9d02364f22a","title":"Modern CI is too complex and misdirected (2021)","domain":"gregoryszorc.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","testing_quality","software_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2025-08","inductedMonth":"2025-08","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.37,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":212,"evidenceRank":1056,"evidenceScore":59.9,"freshAt":"2025-08-20T03:30:06Z","freshnessRank":168,"freshEventScore":212,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 212 pts / 201 comments (2025) + 208 pts / 178 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,595 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":208,"peak_comments":178,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26727790","height":10,"chart_height":167},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34517898","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":212,"peak_comments":201,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44958400","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/modern-ci-is-too-complex-and-misdirected-2021-d9d02364f22a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/modern-ci-is-too-complex-and-misdirected-2021-d9d02364f22a/"},{"slug":"what-americans-die-from-vs-what-the-news-reports-on-d9d0235de167","title":"What Americans die from vs. what the news reports on","domain":"ourworldindata.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"medicine_health","topicDisplay":"Medicine & health","tags":["public_health","journalism_media","data_science"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2025-10","inductedMonth":"2025-10","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":6.379,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":710,"evidenceRank":1057,"evidenceScore":59.9,"freshAt":"2025-10-14T18:40:23Z","freshnessRank":131,"freshEventScore":710,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 710 pts / 474 comments (2025) + 168 pts / 112 comments (2019), different submitters and 2,329 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":168,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20049364","height":8,"chart_height":40},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25495805","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":710,"peak_comments":474,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45583336","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-americans-die-from-vs-what-the-news-reports-on-d9d0235de167.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-americans-die-from-vs-what-the-news-reports-on-d9d0235de167/"},{"slug":"hiring-is-broken-my-interview-experience-in-the-tech-industry-d9d023536949","title":"Hiring Is Broken – My interview experience in the tech industry","domain":"medium.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["hiring_interviews","workplace","careers"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-01","inductedMonth":"2019-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":2.724,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":376,"evidenceRank":1058,"evidenceScore":59.9,"freshAt":"2019-01-17T14:52:04Z","freshnessRank":1070,"freshEventScore":163,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 376 pts / 671 comments (2016) + 163 pts / 307 comments (2019), different submitters and 995 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":376,"peak_comments":671,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11579757","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16100240","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":163,"peak_comments":307,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18931129","height":8,"chart_height":74},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/hiring-is-broken-my-interview-experience-in-the-tech-industry-d9d023536949/"},{"slug":"why-is-it-hard-to-buy-things-that-work-well-d9d023681455","title":"Why is it hard to buy things that work well?","domain":"danluu.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["markets","management_strategy","product_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2022,"candidateMonth":"2024-12","inductedMonth":"2024-12","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":2.76,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":848,"evidenceRank":1059,"evidenceScore":59.8,"freshAt":"2024-12-16T12:38:11Z","freshnessRank":285,"freshEventScore":693,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 693 pts / 577 comments (2024) + 848 pts / 521 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,007 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":848,"peak_comments":521,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30679935","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36892720","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":693,"peak_comments":577,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42430450","height":24,"chart_height":139},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-is-it-hard-to-buy-things-that-work-well-d9d023681455.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-is-it-hard-to-buy-things-that-work-well-d9d023681455/"},{"slug":"adsl-works-over-wet-string-2017-d9d023672341","title":"ADSL works over wet string (2017)","domain":"www.revk.uk","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","electronics","internet_infrastructure"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2024-05","inductedMonth":"2026-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.142,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":418,"evidenceRank":1060,"evidenceScore":59.7,"freshAt":"2024-05-17T07:24:02Z","freshnessRank":393,"freshEventScore":273,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 418 pts / 153 comments (2021) + 273 pts / 109 comments (2024), different submitters and 894 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":418,"peak_comments":153,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29440681","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":273,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40387318","height":13,"chart_height":111},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46750417","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/adsl-works-over-wet-string-2017-d9d023672341.jpg","path":"/hall/link/adsl-works-over-wet-string-2017-d9d023672341/"},{"slug":"yt-dlp-a-youtube-dl-fork-with-additional-features-and-fixes-d9d023649b2d","title":"Yt-dlp – A YouTube-dl fork with additional features and fixes","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source","internet_infrastructure"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2023-09","inductedMonth":"2025-04","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.137,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":822,"evidenceRank":1061,"evidenceScore":59.7,"freshAt":"2023-09-11T21:37:28Z","freshnessRank":549,"freshEventScore":187,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 822 pts / 332 comments (2021) + 187 pts / 113 comments (2023), different submitters and 746 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":822,"peak_comments":332,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28319624","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":187,"peak_comments":113,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37474066","height":9,"chart_height":39},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43763774","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/yt-dlp-a-youtube-dl-fork-with-additional-features-and-fixes-d9d023649b2d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/yt-dlp-a-youtube-dl-fork-with-additional-features-and-fixes-d9d023649b2d/"},{"slug":"below-the-surface-finds-from-an-archaeological-project-in-the-ri-d9d0235ac961","title":"Below the Surface – Finds from an archaeological project in the River Amstel","domain":"belowthesurface.amsterdam","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["archaeology","digital_archives"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2026-01","inductedMonth":"2026-01","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":7.537,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":522,"evidenceRank":1062,"evidenceScore":59.7,"freshAt":"2026-01-11T14:36:13Z","freshnessRank":81,"freshEventScore":100,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 522 pts / 104 comments (2018) + 100 pts / 17 comments (2026), different submitters and 2,750 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":4,"peak_score":522,"peak_comments":104,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17439832","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34941977","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":100,"peak_comments":17,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46576091","height":5,"chart_height":33}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/below-the-surface-finds-from-an-archaeological-project-in-the-ri-d9d0235ac961.jpg","path":"/hall/link/below-the-surface-finds-from-an-archaeological-project-in-the-ri-d9d0235ac961/"},{"slug":"self-hosted-photo-and-video-backup-solution-directly-from-your-m-d9d02369f7ff","title":"Self-hosted photo and video backup solution directly from your mobile phone","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["digital_archives","privacy_surveillance","open_source","photography"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2022,"candidateMonth":"2025-09","inductedMonth":"2025-09","submissions":7,"submitters":5,"spanYears":2.91,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":757,"evidenceRank":1063,"evidenceScore":59.7,"freshAt":"2025-09-08T07:58:38Z","freshnessRank":150,"freshEventScore":565,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 757 pts / 344 comments (2023) + 565 pts / 205 comments (2025), different submitters and 790 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33159796","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":4,"peak_score":757,"peak_comments":344,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36673224","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":565,"peak_comments":205,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45165684","height":24,"chart_height":127},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/self-hosted-photo-and-video-backup-solution-directly-from-your-m-d9d02369f7ff.jpg","path":"/hall/link/self-hosted-photo-and-video-backup-solution-directly-from-your-m-d9d02369f7ff/"},{"slug":"newlisp-d9d0233f28e3","title":"NewLisp","domain":"www.newlisp.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2020-08","inductedMonth":"2020-08","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":11.65,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":120,"evidenceRank":1064,"evidenceScore":59.7,"freshAt":"2020-08-31T10:55:08Z","freshnessRank":992,"freshEventScore":100,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 120 pts / 142 comments (2016) + 100 pts / 30 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,424 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=421936","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":74,"peak_comments":17,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2909490","height":4,"chart_height":105},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":120,"peak_comments":142,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12651889","height":6,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":100,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24330126","height":5,"chart_height":142},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/newlisp-d9d0233f28e3/"},{"slug":"this-page-is-anonymous-d9d02349459d","title":"This page is anonymous","domain":"voidnull.sdf.org","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["privacy_surveillance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2019-06","inductedMonth":"2022-07","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":9.229,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":450,"evidenceRank":1065,"evidenceScore":59.7,"freshAt":"2019-06-19T01:11:28Z","freshnessRank":1060,"freshEventScore":149,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 450 pts / 243 comments (2013) + 149 pts / 51 comments (2019), different submitters and 2,239 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":450,"peak_comments":243,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5638988","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9989166","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":149,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20220048","height":7,"chart_height":56},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29715701","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32215681","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/this-page-is-anonymous-d9d02349459d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/this-page-is-anonymous-d9d02349459d/"},{"slug":"how-a-small-group-of-activists-got-gas-powered-leaf-blowers-bann-d9d0235d1602","title":"How a small group of activists got gas-powered leaf blowers banned in D.C.","domain":"www.theatlantic.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["cities_infrastructure","climate_environment","politics_government"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-08","inductedMonth":"2022-08","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.406,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":197,"evidenceRank":1066,"evidenceScore":59.7,"freshAt":"2022-08-04T12:00:37Z","freshnessRank":738,"freshEventScore":88,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 197 pts / 229 comments (2019) + 88 pts / 164 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,242 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":197,"peak_comments":229,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19351934","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26030655","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":88,"peak_comments":164,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32341745","height":4,"chart_height":76},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-a-small-group-of-activists-got-gas-powered-leaf-blowers-bann-d9d0235d1602.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-a-small-group-of-activists-got-gas-powered-leaf-blowers-bann-d9d0235d1602/"},{"slug":"the-awful-german-language-1880-d9d0236529eb","title":"The Awful German Language (1880)","domain":"faculty.georgetown.edu","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["language_linguistics","books_literature"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2025-05","inductedMonth":"2025-05","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.044,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":198,"evidenceRank":1067,"evidenceScore":59.7,"freshAt":"2025-05-16T04:09:48Z","freshnessRank":212,"freshEventScore":198,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 198 pts / 473 comments (2025) + 136 pts / 253 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,460 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":136,"peak_comments":253,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27173967","height":7,"chart_height":117},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38054398","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":198,"peak_comments":473,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44001765","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-awful-german-language-1880-d9d0236529eb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-awful-german-language-1880-d9d0236529eb/"},{"slug":"friendica-a-decentralized-social-network-d9d02359ff76","title":"Friendica – A Decentralized Social Network","domain":"friendi.ca","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["online_communities","protocols_networking","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2026-04","inductedMonth":"2026-04","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":8.0,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":166,"evidenceRank":1068,"evidenceScore":59.7,"freshAt":"2026-04-05T10:41:06Z","freshnessRank":33,"freshEventScore":166,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 134 pts / 137 comments (2018) + 166 pts / 58 comments (2026), different submitters and 2,921 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":134,"peak_comments":137,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16763779","height":6,"chart_height":137},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26118241","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32365636","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":166,"peak_comments":58,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47648048","height":8,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/friendica-a-decentralized-social-network-d9d02359ff76.jpg","path":"/hall/link/friendica-a-decentralized-social-network-d9d02359ff76/"},{"slug":"tools-for-better-thinking-d9d02361b34c","title":"Tools for Better Thinking","domain":"untools.co","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["personal_productivity","management_strategy","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2022-06","inductedMonth":"2024-06","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.03,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1092,"evidenceRank":1069,"evidenceScore":59.6,"freshAt":"2024-06-08T04:33:09Z","freshnessRank":383,"freshEventScore":60,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1092 pts / 135 comments (2020) + 855 pts / 72 comments (2022), different submitters and 739 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1092,"peak_comments":135,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23339830","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":855,"peak_comments":72,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31647181","height":24,"chart_height":133},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":60,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40615299","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/tools-for-better-thinking-d9d02361b34c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/tools-for-better-thinking-d9d02361b34c/"},{"slug":"nova-by-panic-d9d02362e8fc","title":"Nova by Panic","domain":"nova.app","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","programming_languages","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2024-09","inductedMonth":"2024-09","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.019,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1051,"evidenceRank":1070,"evidenceScore":59.6,"freshAt":"2024-09-23T20:34:44Z","freshnessRank":328,"freshEventScore":121,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1051 pts / 542 comments (2020) + 121 pts / 105 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,468 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1051,"peak_comments":542,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24495330","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37902938","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":121,"peak_comments":105,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41630223","height":6,"chart_height":20},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/nova-by-panic-d9d02362e8fc.jpg","path":"/hall/link/nova-by-panic-d9d02362e8fc/"},{"slug":"git-appraise-distributed-code-review-for-git-d9d023513bdb","title":"git-appraise – Distributed Code Review for Git","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source","testing_quality"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2023-08","inductedMonth":"2023-08","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":7.934,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":253,"evidenceRank":1071,"evidenceScore":59.6,"freshAt":"2023-08-11T02:52:46Z","freshnessRank":571,"freshEventScore":253,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 253 pts / 162 comments (2023) + 189 pts / 26 comments (2015), different submitters and 2,797 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":189,"peak_comments":26,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10726113","height":9,"chart_height":127},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17245599","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24231939","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":253,"peak_comments":162,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37084575","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/git-appraise-distributed-code-review-for-git-d9d023513bdb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/git-appraise-distributed-code-review-for-git-d9d023513bdb/"},{"slug":"net-orleans-d9d023500cd3","title":".NET Orleans","domain":"dotnet.github.io","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["distributed_systems","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2020-10","inductedMonth":"2020-10","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.435,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":278,"evidenceRank":1072,"evidenceScore":59.6,"freshAt":"2020-10-05T20:12:26Z","freshnessRank":988,"freshEventScore":278,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 278 pts / 280 comments (2020) + 175 pts / 65 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,541 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9465819","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":175,"peak_comments":65,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12108336","height":8,"chart_height":107},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15899075","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":278,"peak_comments":280,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24691500","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/net-orleans-d9d023500cd3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/net-orleans-d9d023500cd3/"},{"slug":"google-and-http-d9d023599f15","title":"Google and HTTP","domain":"this.how","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","browsers_web_standards","technology_ethics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2023-07","inductedMonth":"2023-07","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.352,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":80,"evidenceRank":1073,"evidenceScore":59.6,"freshAt":"2023-07-04T15:16:11Z","freshnessRank":599,"freshEventScore":80,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 80 pts / 172 comments (2023) + 43 pts / 58 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,954 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":43,"peak_comments":58,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16461923","height":4,"chart_height":91},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22521898","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34168148","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":80,"peak_comments":172,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36587788","height":4,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/google-and-http-d9d023599f15.jpg","path":"/hall/link/google-and-http-d9d023599f15/"},{"slug":"show-hn-bookstack-an-open-source-wiki-platform-and-alternative-t-d9d02352915d","title":"Show HN: BookStack – An open source wiki platform and alternative to Confluence","domain":"www.bookstackapp.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["open_source","developer_tools","databases_storage"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2024-09","inductedMonth":"2024-09","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":8.654,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":562,"evidenceRank":1074,"evidenceScore":59.4,"freshAt":"2024-09-27T00:25:15Z","freshnessRank":326,"freshEventScore":127,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 562 pts / 198 comments (2022) + 127 pts / 27 comments (2024), different submitters and 992 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11009098","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24493691","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26760995","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":562,"peak_comments":198,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29851834","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":127,"peak_comments":27,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41665029","height":6,"chart_height":38},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/show-hn-bookstack-an-open-source-wiki-platform-and-alternative-t-d9d02352915d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/show-hn-bookstack-an-open-source-wiki-platform-and-alternative-t-d9d02352915d/"},{"slug":"grain-a-strongly-typed-functional-programming-language-for-the-m-d9d0235b0d54","title":"Grain: A strongly-typed functional programming language for the modern web","domain":"grain-lang.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","compilers_runtimes","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-04","inductedMonth":"2021-04","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.144,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":259,"evidenceRank":1075,"evidenceScore":59.4,"freshAt":"2021-04-24T06:59:10Z","freshnessRank":922,"freshEventScore":60,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 259 pts / 153 comments (2018) + 60 pts / 80 comments (2021), different submitters and 998 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":259,"peak_comments":153,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17645004","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23789383","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":60,"peak_comments":80,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26922857","height":4,"chart_height":39},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37596602","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/grain-a-strongly-typed-functional-programming-language-for-the-m-d9d0235b0d54.jpg","path":"/hall/link/grain-a-strongly-typed-functional-programming-language-for-the-m-d9d0235b0d54/"},{"slug":"uxn-d9d0236553b0","title":"Uxn","domain":"100r.co","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","operating_systems","retrocomputing"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2023-07","inductedMonth":"2026-01","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":4.632,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":450,"evidenceRank":1076,"evidenceScore":59.4,"freshAt":"2024-10-08T14:52:33Z","freshnessRank":319,"freshEventScore":450,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 450 pts / 98 comments (2024) + 230 pts / 47 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,239 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":230,"peak_comments":47,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27185950","height":11,"chart_height":87},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":257,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36734445","height":12,"chart_height":97},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":450,"peak_comments":98,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41777995","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46471618","height":4,"chart_height":7}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/uxn-d9d0236553b0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/uxn-d9d0236553b0/"},{"slug":"evolution-of-a-python-programmer-d9d023407afc","title":"Evolution of a Python programmer","domain":"gist.github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"source_code","typeDisplay":"Source code","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2016-11","inductedMonth":"2017-07","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":7.469,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":366,"evidenceRank":1077,"evidenceScore":59.4,"freshAt":"2012-03-08T16:43:03Z","freshnessRank":1175,"freshEventScore":255,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 366 pts / 90 comments (2010) + 255 pts / 40 comments (2012), different submitters and 768 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":366,"peak_comments":90,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1087068","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":255,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3680398","height":12,"chart_height":118},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12961777","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14807392","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/evolution-of-a-python-programmer-d9d023407afc.jpg","path":"/hall/link/evolution-of-a-python-programmer-d9d023407afc/"},{"slug":"show-hn-video-game-in-a-font-d9d02364bf3c","title":"Show HN: Video Game in a Font","domain":"www.coderelay.io","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"computer_game","typeDisplay":"Computer games","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["indie_games","game_development","interactive_fiction"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2023-05","inductedMonth":"2026-02","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":4.906,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":605,"evidenceRank":1078,"evidenceScore":59.3,"freshAt":"2023-05-26T20:48:45Z","freshnessRank":623,"freshEventScore":128,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 605 pts / 76 comments (2021) + 128 pts / 8 comments (2023), different submitters and 800 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":5,"peak_score":605,"peak_comments":76,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26495059","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":128,"peak_comments":8,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36089333","height":6,"chart_height":36},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46979823","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/show-hn-video-game-in-a-font-d9d02364bf3c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/show-hn-video-game-in-a-font-d9d02364bf3c/"},{"slug":"gb-studio-drag-and-drop-retro-game-creator-for-gameboy-d9d0235d77a5","title":"GB Studio: Drag and drop retro game creator for GameBoy","domain":"www.gbstudio.dev","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_development","retrocomputing","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2021-04","inductedMonth":"2023-06","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.167,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":376,"evidenceRank":1079,"evidenceScore":59.3,"freshAt":"2023-06-17T17:26:37Z","freshnessRank":609,"freshEventScore":376,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 376 pts / 48 comments (2023) + 295 pts / 29 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,517 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":295,"peak_comments":29,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19717558","height":14,"chart_height":133},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":250,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26979879","height":12,"chart_height":113},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":376,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36372284","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/gb-studio-drag-and-drop-retro-game-creator-for-gameboy-d9d0235d77a5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/gb-studio-drag-and-drop-retro-game-creator-for-gameboy-d9d0235d77a5/"},{"slug":"mail-in-a-box-a-mail-server-in-a-box-d9d02354142e","title":"Mail-in-a-Box: a mail server in a box","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["internet_infrastructure","application_security","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2023-11","inductedMonth":"2023-11","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":7.376,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":227,"evidenceRank":1080,"evidenceScore":59.3,"freshAt":"2023-11-24T17:58:35Z","freshnessRank":492,"freshEventScore":227,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 227 pts / 128 comments (2023) + 188 pts / 90 comments (2016), different submitters and 2,552 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":188,"peak_comments":90,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13050500","height":9,"chart_height":141},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17636636","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23895852","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":227,"peak_comments":128,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38406478","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/mail-in-a-box-a-mail-server-in-a-box-d9d02354142e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/mail-in-a-box-a-mail-server-in-a-box-d9d02354142e/"},{"slug":"fork-fast-and-friendly-git-client-for-mac-d9d023548688","title":"Fork: Fast and Friendly Git Client for Mac","domain":"git-fork.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2022-05","inductedMonth":"2022-05","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.752,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":142,"evidenceRank":1081,"evidenceScore":59.3,"freshAt":"2022-05-31T09:56:39Z","freshnessRank":773,"freshEventScore":74,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 142 pts / 103 comments (2016) + 74 pts / 65 comments (2022), different submitters and 2,100 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":142,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12382493","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":49,"peak_comments":34,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17448551","height":4,"chart_height":59},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22462492","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28539667","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":74,"peak_comments":65,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31567702","height":4,"chart_height":89},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/fork-fast-and-friendly-git-client-for-mac-d9d023548688.jpg","path":"/hall/link/fork-fast-and-friendly-git-client-for-mac-d9d023548688/"},{"slug":"what-every-programmer-should-know-about-solid-state-drives-d9d0234f4de6","title":"What every programmer should know about solid-state drives","domain":"codecapsule.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["computer_architecture","performance_reliability","databases_storage"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2022-05","inductedMonth":"2022-05","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":7.269,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":170,"evidenceRank":1082,"evidenceScore":59.3,"freshAt":"2022-05-23T07:21:06Z","freshnessRank":780,"freshEventScore":170,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 170 pts / 110 comments (2022) + 135 pts / 31 comments (2015), different submitters and 2,654 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":135,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9049630","height":6,"chart_height":135},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13911186","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28613921","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":170,"peak_comments":110,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31476172","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-every-programmer-should-know-about-solid-state-drives-d9d0234f4de6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-every-programmer-should-know-about-solid-state-drives-d9d0234f4de6/"},{"slug":"learn-tla-2018-d9d0235b28c5","title":"Learn TLA+ (2018)","domain":"learntla.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["theory_of_computation","distributed_systems","software_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2022-09","inductedMonth":"2025-10","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":7.201,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":387,"evidenceRank":1083,"evidenceScore":59.2,"freshAt":"2022-09-28T17:28:08Z","freshnessRank":713,"freshEventScore":254,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 387 pts / 92 comments (2019) + 254 pts / 64 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,262 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17737019","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":387,"peak_comments":92,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19661329","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":254,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33010645","height":12,"chart_height":112},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45672122","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/learn-tla-2018-d9d0235b28c5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/learn-tla-2018-d9d0235b28c5/"},{"slug":"how-shazam-works-d9d02350bbb0","title":"How Shazam works","domain":"coding-geek.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["algorithms_data_structures"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2020-07","inductedMonth":"2022-08","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":7.107,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":446,"evidenceRank":1084,"evidenceScore":59.2,"freshAt":"2020-07-11T21:23:43Z","freshnessRank":1000,"freshEventScore":47,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 446 pts / 47 comments (2015) + 236 pts / 12 comments (2017), different submitters and 809 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":446,"peak_comments":47,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9870408","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":236,"peak_comments":12,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15350729","height":11,"chart_height":90},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":47,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23806142","height":4,"chart_height":18},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32524520","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-shazam-works-d9d02350bbb0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-shazam-works-d9d02350bbb0/"},{"slug":"azgaar-s-fantasy-map-generator-2018-d9d0235a85a2","title":"Azgaar’s Fantasy Map Generator (2018)","domain":"azgaar.github.io","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design","game_development","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-11","inductedMonth":"2021-11","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.81,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":470,"evidenceRank":1085,"evidenceScore":59.2,"freshAt":"2021-11-12T21:56:20Z","freshnessRank":856,"freshEventScore":214,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 470 pts / 36 comments (2019) + 214 pts / 24 comments (2021), different submitters and 776 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17933765","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":470,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21099344","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":214,"peak_comments":24,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29205001","height":10,"chart_height":77},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35269517","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/azgaar-s-fantasy-map-generator-2018-d9d0235a85a2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/azgaar-s-fantasy-map-generator-2018-d9d0235a85a2/"},{"slug":"learning-synths-d9d0235e25f0","title":"Learning Synths","domain":"learningsynths.ableton.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["music","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-05","inductedMonth":"2024-01","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.794,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":969,"evidenceRank":1086,"evidenceScore":59.1,"freshAt":"2022-05-05T23:40:31Z","freshnessRank":784,"freshEventScore":241,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 969 pts / 172 comments (2019) + 241 pts / 63 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,045 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":969,"peak_comments":172,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20272346","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29055775","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":241,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31279526","height":12,"chart_height":42},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39990284","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/learning-synths-d9d0235e25f0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/learning-synths-d9d0235e25f0/"},{"slug":"write-you-a-haskell-building-a-modern-functional-compiler-from-f-d9d0234eea41","title":"Write You a Haskell: Building a modern functional compiler from first principles","domain":"dev.stephendiehl.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["compilers_runtimes","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2017-03","inductedMonth":"2017-03","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.772,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":472,"evidenceRank":1087,"evidenceScore":59.1,"freshAt":"2017-03-03T18:50:57Z","freshnessRank":1133,"freshEventScore":151,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 472 pts / 47 comments (2015) + 151 pts / 17 comments (2017), different submitters and 788 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":472,"peak_comments":47,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8838712","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11362617","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":151,"peak_comments":17,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13785132","height":7,"chart_height":54},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21252946","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/write-you-a-haskell-building-a-modern-functional-compiler-from-f-d9d0234eea41.jpg","path":"/hall/link/write-you-a-haskell-building-a-modern-functional-compiler-from-f-d9d0234eea41/"},{"slug":"why-i-two-space-d9d023476102","title":"Why I Two-Space","domain":"stevelosh.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["writing_craft","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2022-10","inductedMonth":"2022-10","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":10.029,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":77,"evidenceRank":1088,"evidenceScore":59.1,"freshAt":"2022-10-23T00:01:39Z","freshnessRank":704,"freshEventScore":35,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 77 pts / 102 comments (2012) + 35 pts / 70 comments (2022), different submitters and 3,662 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":77,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4645121","height":4,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19415001","height":4,"chart_height":29},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29086740","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":35,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33303313","height":4,"chart_height":77},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-i-two-space-d9d023476102.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-i-two-space-d9d023476102/"},{"slug":"why-isn-t-the-internet-more-fun-and-weird-d9d0235cb547","title":"Why isn't the internet more fun and weird?","domain":"jarredsumner.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-07","inductedMonth":"2022-07","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.431,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1516,"evidenceRank":1089,"evidenceScore":59.1,"freshAt":"2022-07-06T11:07:13Z","freshnessRank":754,"freshEventScore":313,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1516 pts / 588 comments (2019) + 313 pts / 270 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,252 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1516,"peak_comments":588,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19038327","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26337793","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":313,"peak_comments":270,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31999259","height":15,"chart_height":35},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/why-isn-t-the-internet-more-fun-and-weird-d9d0235cb547/"},{"slug":"the-stem-crisis-is-a-myth-d9d0234a6ce4","title":"The STEM Crisis is a Myth","domain":"spectrum.ieee.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["careers","labor_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2017-02","inductedMonth":"2017-02","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.428,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":139,"evidenceRank":1090,"evidenceScore":59.1,"freshAt":"2017-02-03T19:04:07Z","freshnessRank":1137,"freshEventScore":112,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 112 pts / 177 comments (2017) + 139 pts / 145 comments (2013), different submitters and 1,252 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":139,"peak_comments":145,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6305671","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10433168","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":112,"peak_comments":177,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13562277","height":5,"chart_height":137},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-stem-crisis-is-a-myth-d9d0234a6ce4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-stem-crisis-is-a-myth-d9d0234a6ce4/"},{"slug":"atlas-of-surveillance-d9d023623827","title":"Atlas of Surveillance","domain":"atlasofsurveillance.org","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["privacy_surveillance","law_regulation","cities_infrastructure"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-10","inductedMonth":"2025-02","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.649,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":386,"evidenceRank":1091,"evidenceScore":59.0,"freshAt":"2023-10-13T17:35:38Z","freshnessRank":521,"freshEventScore":183,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 386 pts / 134 comments (2020) + 183 pts / 76 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,186 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":386,"peak_comments":134,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23824845","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":24,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29559218","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":183,"peak_comments":76,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37873237","height":9,"chart_height":81},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43080764","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/atlas-of-surveillance-d9d023623827.jpg","path":"/hall/link/atlas-of-surveillance-d9d023623827/"},{"slug":"briar-peer-to-peer-encrypted-messaging-d9d02360e270","title":"Briar: Peer to Peer Encrypted Messaging","domain":"briarproject.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["privacy_surveillance","cryptography","protocols_networking"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2025-03","inductedMonth":"2025-03","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":4.975,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":450,"evidenceRank":1092,"evidenceScore":58.9,"freshAt":"2025-03-14T14:36:23Z","freshnessRank":238,"freshEventScore":450,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 450 pts / 211 comments (2025) + 422 pts / 141 comments (2022), different submitters and 844 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24037625","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":422,"peak_comments":141,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33686094","height":20,"chart_height":159},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":450,"peak_comments":211,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43363031","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/briar-peer-to-peer-encrypted-messaging-d9d02360e270.jpg","path":"/hall/link/briar-peer-to-peer-encrypted-messaging-d9d02360e270/"},{"slug":"easyos-an-experimental-linux-distribution-d9d0235cf3a9","title":"EasyOS: An experimental Linux distribution","domain":"easyos.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2024-06","inductedMonth":"2025-10","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.615,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":281,"evidenceRank":1093,"evidenceScore":58.9,"freshAt":"2024-06-19T18:59:40Z","freshnessRank":374,"freshEventScore":281,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 281 pts / 143 comments (2024) + 136 pts / 86 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,734 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":136,"peak_comments":86,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21023989","height":7,"chart_height":82},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25993149","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":281,"peak_comments":143,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40731360","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45489440","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/easyos-an-experimental-linux-distribution-d9d0235cf3a9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/easyos-an-experimental-linux-distribution-d9d0235cf3a9/"},{"slug":"wails-electron-alternative-powered-by-go-d9d0235d998b","title":"Wails – Electron Alternative Powered by Go","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","web_development","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2025-11","inductedMonth":"2025-11","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.571,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":394,"evidenceRank":1094,"evidenceScore":58.9,"freshAt":"2025-11-24T04:33:57Z","freshnessRank":114,"freshEventScore":98,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 394 pts / 93 comments (2022) + 98 pts / 77 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,256 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19792767","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22940362","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":394,"peak_comments":93,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31764773","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":98,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46030414","height":5,"chart_height":42},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/wails-electron-alternative-powered-by-go-d9d0235d998b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/wails-electron-alternative-powered-by-go-d9d0235d998b/"},{"slug":"open-source-mission-control-software-from-nasa-d9d023547786","title":"Open Source Mission Control Software from NASA","domain":"nasa.github.io","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["web_development","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-01","inductedMonth":"2021-01","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.435,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":307,"evidenceRank":1095,"evidenceScore":58.9,"freshAt":"2021-01-28T22:37:37Z","freshnessRank":951,"freshEventScore":307,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 307 pts / 48 comments (2021) + 170 pts / 14 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,619 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":170,"peak_comments":14,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12339966","height":8,"chart_height":94},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18438707","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20845395","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":307,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25950487","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/open-source-mission-control-software-from-nasa-d9d023547786.jpg","path":"/hall/link/open-source-mission-control-software-from-nasa-d9d023547786/"},{"slug":"a-half-hour-to-learn-rust-d9d02362cbc9","title":"A half-hour to learn Rust","domain":"fasterthanli.me","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","learning_methods"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-08","inductedMonth":"2023-08","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":2.962,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1444,"evidenceRank":1096,"evidenceScore":58.7,"freshAt":"2023-08-23T14:49:31Z","freshnessRank":563,"freshEventScore":219,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1444 pts / 330 comments (2021) + 219 pts / 79 comments (2023), different submitters and 963 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24383655","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1444,"peak_comments":330,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25610741","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30870288","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":219,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37236916","height":11,"chart_height":26},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-half-hour-to-learn-rust-d9d02362cbc9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-half-hour-to-learn-rust-d9d02362cbc9/"},{"slug":"list-of-printers-which-do-or-do-not-display-tracking-dots-d9d0234fc890","title":"List of Printers Which Do or Do Not Display Tracking Dots","domain":"www.eff.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["privacy_surveillance","electronics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2017-06","inductedMonth":"2021-06","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.223,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":586,"evidenceRank":1097,"evidenceScore":58.7,"freshAt":"2021-06-24T20:33:03Z","freshnessRank":896,"freshEventScore":94,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 586 pts / 210 comments (2017) + 142 pts / 42 comments (2015), different submitters and 794 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":142,"peak_comments":42,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9319344","height":7,"chart_height":41},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13114806","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":586,"peak_comments":210,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14501894","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":94,"peak_comments":28,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27623393","height":5,"chart_height":27},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/list-of-printers-which-do-or-do-not-display-tracking-dots-d9d0234fc890.jpg","path":"/hall/link/list-of-printers-which-do-or-do-not-display-tracking-dots-d9d0234fc890/"},{"slug":"software-architecture-is-overrated-clear-and-simple-design-is-un-d9d0235ef80e","title":"Software Architecture Is Overrated, Clear and Simple Design Is Underrated","domain":"blog.pragmaticengineer.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","management_strategy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-08","inductedMonth":"2025-11","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.166,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":608,"evidenceRank":1098,"evidenceScore":58.6,"freshAt":"2022-08-09T00:30:50Z","freshnessRank":735,"freshEventScore":136,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 608 pts / 211 comments (2019) + 136 pts / 31 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,055 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":608,"peak_comments":211,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21001676","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29567824","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":136,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32392793","height":7,"chart_height":38},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45947324","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/software-architecture-is-overrated-clear-and-simple-design-is-un-d9d0235ef80e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/software-architecture-is-overrated-clear-and-simple-design-is-un-d9d0235ef80e/"},{"slug":"build-your-own-react-d9d0235f8f9d","title":"Build Your Own React","domain":"pomb.us","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["web_development","programming_languages","software_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2025-12","inductedMonth":"2025-12","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.1,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1478,"evidenceRank":1099,"evidenceScore":58.6,"freshAt":"2025-12-20T00:16:13Z","freshnessRank":93,"freshEventScore":181,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1478 pts / 108 comments (2019) + 181 pts / 21 comments (2025), different submitters and 2,227 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1478,"peak_comments":108,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21536789","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":32,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28839948","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":46,"peak_comments":18,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40905899","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":181,"peak_comments":21,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46332526","height":9,"chart_height":21},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/build-your-own-react-d9d0235f8f9d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/build-your-own-react-d9d0235f8f9d/"},{"slug":"mrustc-a-rust-compiler-written-in-c-d9d023546a8f","title":"Mrustc: a Rust compiler written in C++","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["compilers_runtimes","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-02","inductedMonth":"2022-09","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.073,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":182,"evidenceRank":1100,"evidenceScore":58.6,"freshAt":"2021-02-28T19:35:25Z","freshnessRank":938,"freshEventScore":80,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 182 pts / 121 comments (2017) + 80 pts / 62 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,255 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12301474","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":182,"peak_comments":121,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15307205","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":80,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26296318","height":4,"chart_height":75},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32806450","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/mrustc-a-rust-compiler-written-in-c-d9d023546a8f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/mrustc-a-rust-compiler-written-in-c-d9d023546a8f/"},{"slug":"how-to-get-your-first-ten-customers-2013-d9d0234a03e8","title":"How to get your first ten customers (2013)","domain":"danshipper.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["startups_entrepreneurship","management_strategy","markets"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2019-08","inductedMonth":"2019-08","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.053,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":314,"evidenceRank":1101,"evidenceScore":58.6,"freshAt":"2019-08-06T03:12:00Z","freshnessRank":1051,"freshEventScore":314,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 314 pts / 26 comments (2019) + 257 pts / 44 comments (2013), different submitters and 2,129 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":257,"peak_comments":44,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6504451","height":12,"chart_height":139},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9587892","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16723954","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":314,"peak_comments":26,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20621769","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-to-get-your-first-ten-customers-2013-d9d0234a03e8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-to-get-your-first-ten-customers-2013-d9d0234a03e8/"},{"slug":"ruffle-a-flash-player-emulator-written-in-rust-d9d023639192","title":"Ruffle – A Flash Player emulator written in Rust","domain":"ruffle.rs","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["open_source","emulation","programming_languages","browsers_web_standards"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-10","inductedMonth":"2023-10","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":2.916,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":381,"evidenceRank":1102,"evidenceScore":58.5,"freshAt":"2023-10-21T11:33:28Z","freshnessRank":509,"freshEventScore":351,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 351 pts / 173 comments (2023) + 381 pts / 89 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,056 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":381,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25242115","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26527411","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":351,"peak_comments":173,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37965947","height":17,"chart_height":157},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/ruffle-a-flash-player-emulator-written-in-rust-d9d023639192.jpg","path":"/hall/link/ruffle-a-flash-player-emulator-written-in-rust-d9d023639192/"},{"slug":"kopia-open-source-fast-and-secure-open-source-backup-software-d9d02360b6a0","title":"Kopia: Open-Source, Fast and Secure Open-Source Backup Software","domain":"kopia.io","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["open_source","databases_storage","security_incidents"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-09","inductedMonth":"2026-03","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.988,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":326,"evidenceRank":1103,"evidenceScore":58.5,"freshAt":"2023-09-15T17:32:25Z","freshnessRank":546,"freshEventScore":326,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 326 pts / 132 comments (2023) + 176 pts / 76 comments (2021), different submitters and 826 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22521949","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":176,"peak_comments":76,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27471945","height":8,"chart_height":92},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":326,"peak_comments":132,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37526477","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47265159","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/kopia-open-source-fast-and-secure-open-source-backup-software-d9d02360b6a0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/kopia-open-source-fast-and-secure-open-source-backup-software-d9d02360b6a0/"},{"slug":"a-14kb-page-can-load-much-faster-than-a-15kb-page-d9d023698aa5","title":"A 14kb page can load much faster than a 15kb page","domain":"endtimes.dev","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","performance_reliability","protocols_networking"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2022,"candidateMonth":"2025-07","inductedMonth":"2025-07","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":2.899,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":933,"evidenceRank":1104,"evidenceScore":58.5,"freshAt":"2025-07-19T08:26:45Z","freshnessRank":188,"freshEventScore":504,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 933 pts / 343 comments (2022) + 504 pts / 311 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,059 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":933,"peak_comments":343,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32587740","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":19,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41270245","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":504,"peak_comments":311,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44613625","height":24,"chart_height":92},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-14kb-page-can-load-much-faster-than-a-15kb-page-d9d023698aa5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-14kb-page-can-load-much-faster-than-a-15kb-page-d9d023698aa5/"},{"slug":"text-rendering-hates-you-d9d0235f16a7","title":"Text Rendering Hates You","domain":"gankra.github.io","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["computer_graphics","human_computer_interaction"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-02","inductedMonth":"2022-02","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":2.379,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":542,"evidenceRank":1105,"evidenceScore":58.5,"freshAt":"2022-02-14T09:47:45Z","freshnessRank":826,"freshEventScore":399,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 542 pts / 169 comments (2019) + 399 pts / 153 comments (2022), different submitters and 869 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":542,"peak_comments":169,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21105625","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27305533","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":399,"peak_comments":153,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30330144","height":19,"chart_height":125},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/text-rendering-hates-you-d9d0235f16a7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/text-rendering-hates-you-d9d0235f16a7/"},{"slug":"when-you-browse-instagram-and-find-tony-abbott-s-passport-number-d9d02362e6b0","title":"When you browse Instagram and find Tony Abbott's passport number","domain":"mango.pdf.zone","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["privacy_surveillance","application_security","politics_government"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-02","inductedMonth":"2024-08","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.0,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":2326,"evidenceRank":1106,"evidenceScore":58.5,"freshAt":"2023-02-28T08:13:40Z","freshnessRank":652,"freshEventScore":132,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 2326 pts / 340 comments (2020) + 132 pts / 41 comments (2023), different submitters and 895 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2326,"peak_comments":340,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24488224","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30324035","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":132,"peak_comments":41,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34966909","height":6,"chart_height":10},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41559502","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/when-you-browse-instagram-and-find-tony-abbott-s-passport-number-d9d02362e6b0.jpg","path":"/hall/link/when-you-browse-instagram-and-find-tony-abbott-s-passport-number-d9d02362e6b0/"},{"slug":"many-temptations-of-an-open-source-chrome-extension-developer-d9d023643aaf","title":"Many temptations of an open-source Chrome extension developer","domain":"github.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"forum_discussion","typeDisplay":"Forum discussions","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["open_source","browsers_web_standards","technology_ethics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2023-08","inductedMonth":"2025-10","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.98,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":1123,"evidenceRank":1107,"evidenceScore":58.5,"freshAt":"2023-08-09T18:28:30Z","freshnessRank":574,"freshEventScore":1123,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 1123 pts / 360 comments (2023) + 214 pts / 61 comments (2021), different submitters and 801 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":214,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27327892","height":10,"chart_height":32},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1123,"peak_comments":360,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37066680","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45770744","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46671695","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/many-temptations-of-an-open-source-chrome-extension-developer-d9d023643aaf.jpg","path":"/hall/link/many-temptations-of-an-open-source-chrome-extension-developer-d9d023643aaf/"},{"slug":"how-to-parent-more-predictably-2018-d9d0235b5a12","title":"How to parent more predictably (2018)","domain":"www.jefftk.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["children_parenting","teaching"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2023-08","inductedMonth":"2023-08","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.95,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":555,"evidenceRank":1108,"evidenceScore":58.4,"freshAt":"2023-08-13T07:37:17Z","freshnessRank":568,"freshEventScore":102,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 555 pts / 248 comments (2019) + 102 pts / 77 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,521 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18563527","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":555,"peak_comments":248,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20173675","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25553036","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":102,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37107563","height":5,"chart_height":31},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-to-parent-more-predictably-2018-d9d0235b5a12.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-to-parent-more-predictably-2018-d9d0235b5a12/"},{"slug":"ocaml-programming-correct-and-efficient-and-beautiful-d9d023663a0d","title":"OCaml Programming: Correct and Efficient and Beautiful","domain":"cs3110.github.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","learning_methods","testing_quality"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2025-07","inductedMonth":"2025-07","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":3.918,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":347,"evidenceRank":1109,"evidenceScore":58.4,"freshAt":"2025-07-26T21:18:38Z","freshnessRank":184,"freshEventScore":138,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 347 pts / 239 comments (2022) + 138 pts / 54 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,129 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28298861","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":347,"peak_comments":239,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31848178","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39145030","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":138,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44696979","height":7,"chart_height":68},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/ocaml-programming-correct-and-efficient-and-beautiful-d9d023663a0d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/ocaml-programming-correct-and-efficient-and-beautiful-d9d023663a0d/"},{"slug":"javascript-for-shell-scripting-d9d023653a63","title":"JavaScript for Shell Scripting","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2024-02","inductedMonth":"2024-02","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":2.765,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":385,"evidenceRank":1110,"evidenceScore":58.3,"freshAt":"2024-02-10T06:01:20Z","freshnessRank":444,"freshEventScore":162,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 385 pts / 181 comments (2021) + 162 pts / 137 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,009 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":385,"peak_comments":181,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27072515","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34389109","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":162,"peak_comments":137,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39323986","height":8,"chart_height":72},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/javascript-for-shell-scripting-d9d023653a63.jpg","path":"/hall/link/javascript-for-shell-scripting-d9d023653a63/"},{"slug":"jpl-open-source-rover-project-based-on-the-rovers-on-mars-d9d0235b1298","title":"JPL Open-Source Rover Project Based on the Rovers on Mars","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["embedded_iot","electronics","space_astronomy","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2023-09","inductedMonth":"2023-09","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.142,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":324,"evidenceRank":1111,"evidenceScore":58.2,"freshAt":"2023-09-22T19:23:59Z","freshnessRank":541,"freshEventScore":211,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 324 pts / 67 comments (2018) + 211 pts / 32 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,876 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":324,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17676730","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26216513","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":211,"peak_comments":32,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37616513","height":10,"chart_height":111},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/jpl-open-source-rover-project-based-on-the-rovers-on-mars-d9d0235b1298.jpg","path":"/hall/link/jpl-open-source-rover-project-based-on-the-rovers-on-mars-d9d0235b1298/"},{"slug":"c-s-biggest-mistake-2009-d9d02362de1f","title":"C’s Biggest Mistake (2009)","domain":"digitalmars.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","software_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-07","inductedMonth":"2026-04","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.569,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":232,"evidenceRank":1112,"evidenceScore":58.2,"freshAt":"2023-07-02T19:00:22Z","freshnessRank":600,"freshEventScore":103,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 232 pts / 374 comments (2020) + 103 pts / 96 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,023 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":232,"peak_comments":374,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24454369","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":46,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27567311","height":4,"chart_height":34},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":103,"peak_comments":96,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36564535","height":5,"chart_height":75},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47687642","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/c-s-biggest-mistake-2009-d9d02362de1f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/c-s-biggest-mistake-2009-d9d02362de1f/"},{"slug":"how-devops-is-killing-the-developer-2014-d9d02350e1e5","title":"How 'DevOps' Is Killing the Developer (2014)","domain":"jeffknupp.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["workplace"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-06","inductedMonth":"2021-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.487,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":121,"evidenceRank":1113,"evidenceScore":58.2,"freshAt":"2018-06-28T13:34:47Z","freshnessRank":1090,"freshEventScore":121,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 121 pts / 140 comments (2018) + 52 pts / 66 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,032 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":52,"peak_comments":66,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10145196","height":4,"chart_height":73},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13500147","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":121,"peak_comments":140,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17416694","height":6,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25856244","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/how-devops-is-killing-the-developer-2014-d9d02350e1e5/"},{"slug":"sketch-systems-d9d0235a8619","title":"Sketch.systems","domain":"sketch.systems","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["product_design","user_experience","software_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2023-06","inductedMonth":"2023-06","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":5.049,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":333,"evidenceRank":1114,"evidenceScore":58.2,"freshAt":"2023-06-18T09:51:59Z","freshnessRank":608,"freshEventScore":333,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 333 pts / 53 comments (2023) + 147 pts / 27 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,835 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":4,"peak_score":147,"peak_comments":27,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17270625","height":7,"chart_height":75},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21797649","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":333,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36378731","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/sketch-systems-d9d0235a8619.jpg","path":"/hall/link/sketch-systems-d9d0235a8619/"},{"slug":"my-business-card-runs-linux-d9d0235ff250","title":"My Business Card Runs Linux","domain":"www.thirtythreeforty.net","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["embedded_iot","electronics","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-06","inductedMonth":"2025-06","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.454,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":2595,"evidenceRank":1115,"evidenceScore":58.2,"freshAt":"2023-06-03T12:41:53Z","freshnessRank":619,"freshEventScore":220,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 2595 pts / 397 comments (2019) + 220 pts / 58 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,257 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2595,"peak_comments":397,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21871026","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28152900","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":220,"peak_comments":58,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36176198","height":11,"chart_height":14},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44210315","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/my-business-card-runs-linux-d9d0235ff250.jpg","path":"/hall/link/my-business-card-runs-linux-d9d0235ff250/"},{"slug":"using-ld-preload-to-cheat-inject-features-and-investigate-progra-d9d0235383b4","title":"Using LD_PRELOAD to cheat, inject features and investigate programs","domain":"rafalcieslak.wordpress.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","developer_tools","application_security"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2023-09","inductedMonth":"2023-09","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":7.335,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":202,"evidenceRank":1116,"evidenceScore":58.1,"freshAt":"2023-09-08T20:41:20Z","freshnessRank":552,"freshEventScore":202,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 202 pts / 108 comments (2023) + 142 pts / 86 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,104 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11655489","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":142,"peak_comments":86,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15841312","height":7,"chart_height":120},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":202,"peak_comments":108,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37439125","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/using-ld-preload-to-cheat-inject-features-and-investigate-progra-d9d0235383b4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/using-ld-preload-to-cheat-inject-features-and-investigate-progra-d9d0235383b4/"},{"slug":"women-s-pockets-are-inferior-d9d0235b33fd","title":"Women's Pockets are Inferior","domain":"pudding.cool","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["social_issues","visual_design","data_science"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2023-10","inductedMonth":"2023-10","submissions":6,"submitters":4,"spanYears":6.754,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":68,"evidenceRank":1117,"evidenceScore":58.1,"freshAt":"2023-10-24T09:33:21Z","freshnessRank":506,"freshEventScore":39,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 39 pts / 151 comments (2023) + 68 pts / 52 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,895 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":68,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17769517","height":4,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":42,"peak_comments":35,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27031513","height":4,"chart_height":105},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":39,"peak_comments":151,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37996702","height":4,"chart_height":98},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44012705","height":4,"chart_height":25},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/women-s-pockets-are-inferior-d9d0235b33fd.jpg","path":"/hall/link/women-s-pockets-are-inferior-d9d0235b33fd/"},{"slug":"how-is-gnu-yes-so-fast-d9d02357475c","title":"How is GNU `yes` so fast?","domain":"www.reddit.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"forum_discussion","typeDisplay":"Forum discussions","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["performance_reliability"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2022-06","inductedMonth":"2022-06","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.975,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":872,"evidenceRank":1118,"evidenceScore":58.1,"freshAt":"2022-06-04T11:20:03Z","freshnessRank":771,"freshEventScore":142,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 872 pts / 334 comments (2017) + 142 pts / 63 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,817 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":872,"peak_comments":334,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14542938","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20502232","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":142,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31619076","height":7,"chart_height":28},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/how-is-gnu-yes-so-fast-d9d02357475c/"},{"slug":"burned-house-horizon-d9d0235577a9","title":"Burned House Horizon","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["archaeology","history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2021-03","inductedMonth":"2021-03","submissions":7,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.244,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":331,"evidenceRank":1119,"evidenceScore":58.1,"freshAt":"2021-03-06T01:06:26Z","freshnessRank":937,"freshEventScore":331,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 331 pts / 146 comments (2021) + 180 pts / 62 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,549 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":180,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13120301","height":9,"chart_height":92},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":5,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24493088","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":331,"peak_comments":146,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26364285","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/burned-house-horizon-d9d0235577a9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/burned-house-horizon-d9d0235577a9/"},{"slug":"meilisearch-zero-config-alternative-to-elasticsearch-made-in-rus-d9d0235fca7d","title":"MeiliSearch: Zero-config alternative to Elasticsearch, made in Rust","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["information_retrieval","data_engineering","developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2025-04","inductedMonth":"2025-04","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.35,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":437,"evidenceRank":1120,"evidenceScore":58.1,"freshAt":"2025-04-14T12:46:45Z","freshnessRank":220,"freshEventScore":151,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 437 pts / 113 comments (2020) + 151 pts / 73 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,845 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21736410","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":437,"peak_comments":113,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22685831","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30791082","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":151,"peak_comments":73,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43680699","height":7,"chart_height":59},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/meilisearch-zero-config-alternative-to-elasticsearch-made-in-rus-d9d0235fca7d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/meilisearch-zero-config-alternative-to-elasticsearch-made-in-rus-d9d0235fca7d/"},{"slug":"your-real-biological-clock-is-you-re-going-to-die-2018-d9d0235bca49","title":"Your real biological clock is you’re going to die (2018)","domain":"hmmdaily.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["psychology","philosophy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2026-01","inductedMonth":"2026-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":7.206,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":103,"evidenceRank":1121,"evidenceScore":58.1,"freshAt":"2026-01-02T05:39:13Z","freshnessRank":89,"freshEventScore":88,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 103 pts / 133 comments (2022) + 88 pts / 75 comments (2026), different submitters and 1,350 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18257049","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":103,"peak_comments":133,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31121453","height":5,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":88,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46461778","height":4,"chart_height":145}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/your-real-biological-clock-is-you-re-going-to-die-2018-d9d0235bca49.jpg","path":"/hall/link/your-real-biological-clock-is-you-re-going-to-die-2018-d9d0235bca49/"},{"slug":"raytracing-in-one-weekend-2016-d9d0235f138e","title":"Raytracing in One Weekend (2016)","domain":"raytracing.github.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["computer_graphics","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2025-01","inductedMonth":"2025-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.268,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":316,"evidenceRank":1122,"evidenceScore":58.0,"freshAt":"2025-01-02T07:54:28Z","freshnessRank":273,"freshEventScore":110,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 316 pts / 80 comments (2020) + 110 pts / 14 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,494 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21092805","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":316,"peak_comments":80,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25244301","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40678855","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":110,"peak_comments":14,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42572602","height":5,"chart_height":59},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/raytracing-in-one-weekend-2016-d9d0235f138e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/raytracing-in-one-weekend-2016-d9d0235f138e/"},{"slug":"a-wall-of-lava-lamps-helps-encrypt-the-internet-d9d023591a6c","title":"A wall of lava lamps helps encrypt the internet","domain":"www.atlasobscura.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography","internet_infrastructure","journalism_media"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2022-07","inductedMonth":"2023-02","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.15,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":356,"evidenceRank":1123,"evidenceScore":57.9,"freshAt":"2023-02-24T15:20:35Z","freshnessRank":654,"freshEventScore":50,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 356 pts / 151 comments (2017) + 107 pts / 92 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,075 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":356,"peak_comments":151,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16041295","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":107,"peak_comments":92,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25385038","height":5,"chart_height":51},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31993109","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":50,"peak_comments":38,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34925320","height":4,"chart_height":24},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/a-wall-of-lava-lamps-helps-encrypt-the-internet-d9d023591a6c/"},{"slug":"jvm-internals-2013-d9d023494915","title":"JVM Internals (2013)","domain":"blog.jamesdbloom.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["compilers_runtimes","operating_systems"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2018-06","inductedMonth":"2018-06","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.103,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":520,"evidenceRank":1124,"evidenceScore":57.9,"freshAt":"2018-06-09T07:03:55Z","freshnessRank":1092,"freshEventScore":520,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 520 pts / 126 comments (2018) + 144 pts / 24 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,147 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5646597","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7087182","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":144,"peak_comments":24,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9401860","height":7,"chart_height":47},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":520,"peak_comments":126,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17271913","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/jvm-internals-2013-d9d023494915.jpg","path":"/hall/link/jvm-internals-2013-d9d023494915/"},{"slug":"pinball-map-crowd-sourced-worldwide-map-of-public-pinball-machin-d9d0235ea0b4","title":"Pinball Map: Crowd-sourced worldwide map of public pinball machines","domain":"pinballmap.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":[],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2024-02","inductedMonth":"2025-06","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":5.878,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":290,"evidenceRank":1125,"evidenceScore":57.9,"freshAt":"2024-02-02T16:08:51Z","freshnessRank":448,"freshEventScore":290,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 290 pts / 130 comments (2024) + 203 pts / 85 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,476 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20689781","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":203,"peak_comments":85,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22079160","height":10,"chart_height":119},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30892564","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":290,"peak_comments":130,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39230244","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44412180","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/pinball-map-crowd-sourced-worldwide-map-of-public-pinball-machin-d9d0235ea0b4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/pinball-map-crowd-sourced-worldwide-map-of-public-pinball-machin-d9d0235ea0b4/"},{"slug":"rediscovering-the-small-web-d9d02361a78b","title":"Rediscovering the Small Web","domain":"neustadt.fr","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","internet_culture","digital_archives"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2024-08","inductedMonth":"2024-08","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.268,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":472,"evidenceRank":1126,"evidenceScore":57.9,"freshAt":"2024-08-31T03:56:38Z","freshnessRank":340,"freshEventScore":256,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 472 pts / 120 comments (2020) + 256 pts / 64 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,556 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":472,"peak_comments":120,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23326329","height":23,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28554416","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":34,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33388354","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":256,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41406453","height":12,"chart_height":92},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/rediscovering-the-small-web-d9d02361a78b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/rediscovering-the-small-web-d9d02361a78b/"},{"slug":"apache-superset-d9d023643a8b","title":"Apache Superset","domain":"superset.apache.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["data_science","data_engineering","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2024-02","inductedMonth":"2025-07","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.613,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":696,"evidenceRank":1127,"evidenceScore":57.8,"freshAt":"2024-02-26T14:36:35Z","freshnessRank":438,"freshEventScore":696,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 696 pts / 189 comments (2024) + 212 pts / 49 comments (2021), different submitters and 820 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":212,"peak_comments":49,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29368664","height":10,"chart_height":52},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":696,"peak_comments":189,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39511676","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45152778","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/apache-superset-d9d023643a8b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/apache-superset-d9d023643a8b/"},{"slug":"gow-the-lightweight-alternative-to-cygwin-d9d0234499e7","title":"Gow – The lightweight alternative to Cygwin","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","operating_systems","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2014-11","inductedMonth":"2014-11","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":2.96,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":181,"evidenceRank":1128,"evidenceScore":57.8,"freshAt":"2014-11-08T16:40:43Z","freshnessRank":1170,"freshEventScore":175,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 175 pts / 113 comments (2014) + 181 pts / 93 comments (2011), different submitters and 1,069 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":181,"peak_comments":93,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3312009","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":161,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4085022","height":8,"chart_height":151},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5758158","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":175,"peak_comments":113,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8577359","height":8,"chart_height":164},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/gow-the-lightweight-alternative-to-cygwin-d9d0234499e7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/gow-the-lightweight-alternative-to-cygwin-d9d0234499e7/"},{"slug":"tv-detector-van-d9d0235c6ccb","title":"TV detector van","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["history","law_regulation","privacy_surveillance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2023-12","inductedMonth":"2023-12","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.953,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":151,"evidenceRank":1129,"evidenceScore":57.8,"freshAt":"2023-12-14T03:05:54Z","freshnessRank":484,"freshEventScore":71,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 151 pts / 327 comments (2019) + 71 pts / 81 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,588 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18795797","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":151,"peak_comments":327,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20646743","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34022302","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":71,"peak_comments":81,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38637310","height":4,"chart_height":80},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/tv-detector-van-d9d0235c6ccb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/tv-detector-van-d9d0235c6ccb/"},{"slug":"lotus-1-2-3-arbitrary-resolution-d9d0236495b5","title":"Lotus 1-2-3 arbitrary resolution","domain":"lock.cmpxchg8b.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["retrocomputing","developer_tools","computer_graphics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2023-05","inductedMonth":"2024-10","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":3.639,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":520,"evidenceRank":1130,"evidenceScore":57.8,"freshAt":"2023-05-09T11:35:44Z","freshnessRank":632,"freshEventScore":197,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 520 pts / 123 comments (2021) + 197 pts / 117 comments (2023), different submitters and 797 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":520,"peak_comments":123,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26316637","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":197,"peak_comments":117,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35872758","height":9,"chart_height":64},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41898618","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/lotus-1-2-3-arbitrary-resolution-d9d0236495b5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/lotus-1-2-3-arbitrary-resolution-d9d0236495b5/"},{"slug":"feynman-on-fermat-s-last-theorem-d9d0235404a4","title":"Feynman on Fermat's Last Theorem","domain":"www.lbatalha.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-02","inductedMonth":"2019-02","submissions":6,"submitters":4,"spanYears":6.171,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":220,"evidenceRank":1131,"evidenceScore":57.8,"freshAt":"2019-02-11T11:23:43Z","freshnessRank":1067,"freshEventScore":101,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 220 pts / 109 comments (2016) + 101 pts / 54 comments (2019), different submitters and 954 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":220,"peak_comments":109,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12018221","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":97,"peak_comments":28,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14940636","height":5,"chart_height":75},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19133642","height":5,"chart_height":78},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32692067","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/feynman-on-fermat-s-last-theorem-d9d0235404a4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/feynman-on-fermat-s-last-theorem-d9d0235404a4/"},{"slug":"goodbyedpi-deep-packet-inspection-circumvention-utility-d9d0235ed7c7","title":"GoodbyeDPI: Deep Packet Inspection circumvention utility","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["privacy_surveillance","protocols_networking","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-07","inductedMonth":"2024-08","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.923,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":297,"evidenceRank":1132,"evidenceScore":57.8,"freshAt":"2022-07-23T02:00:10Z","freshnessRank":746,"freshEventScore":297,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 297 pts / 118 comments (2022) + 112 pts / 43 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,024 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":112,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21137436","height":5,"chart_height":64},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29034927","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":297,"peak_comments":118,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32199468","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41167154","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/goodbyedpi-deep-packet-inspection-circumvention-utility-d9d0235ed7c7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/goodbyedpi-deep-packet-inspection-circumvention-utility-d9d0235ed7c7/"},{"slug":"the-shortest-papers-ever-published-2016-d9d023564fac","title":"The Shortest Papers Ever Published (2016)","domain":"paperpile.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","academic_life","writing_craft"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2023-10","inductedMonth":"2023-10","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.628,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":382,"evidenceRank":1133,"evidenceScore":57.7,"freshAt":"2023-10-20T23:35:32Z","freshnessRank":510,"freshEventScore":257,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 382 pts / 93 comments (2017) + 257 pts / 75 comments (2023), different submitters and 2,160 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":382,"peak_comments":93,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15737611","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20390165","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":257,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37962682","height":12,"chart_height":114},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-shortest-papers-ever-published-2016-d9d023564fac.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-shortest-papers-ever-published-2016-d9d023564fac/"},{"slug":"regex-crossword-d9d023556f59","title":"RegEx Crossword","domain":"jimbly.github.io","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"computer_game","typeDisplay":"Computer games","topic":"computer_games","topicDisplay":"Computer games","tags":["game_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2023-11","inductedMonth":"2025-10","submissions":5,"submitters":3,"spanYears":8.901,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":390,"evidenceRank":1134,"evidenceScore":57.7,"freshAt":"2025-10-28T14:37:55Z","freshnessRank":125,"freshEventScore":60,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 390 pts / 151 comments (2021) + 155 pts / 31 comments (2023), different submitters and 964 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13095987","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13598475","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":390,"peak_comments":151,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26439208","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":155,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38111449","height":7,"chart_height":68},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":60,"peak_comments":22,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45733453","height":4,"chart_height":26},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/regex-crossword-d9d023556f59.jpg","path":"/hall/link/regex-crossword-d9d023556f59/"},{"slug":"helenos-portable-microkernel-based-multiserver-operating-system-d9d023495cb6","title":"HelenOS: portable microkernel-based multiserver operating system","domain":"www.helenos.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","open_source","embedded_iot"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2022-11","inductedMonth":"2022-11","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":9.528,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":201,"evidenceRank":1135,"evidenceScore":57.7,"freshAt":"2022-11-19T14:10:18Z","freshnessRank":686,"freshEventScore":198,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 198 pts / 112 comments (2022) + 201 pts / 67 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,919 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5687891","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":201,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15046249","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":198,"peak_comments":112,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33670177","height":10,"chart_height":167},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/helenos-portable-microkernel-based-multiserver-operating-system-d9d023495cb6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/helenos-portable-microkernel-based-multiserver-operating-system-d9d023495cb6/"},{"slug":"the-decline-of-stack-overflow-2015-d9d02354c6f5","title":"The decline of Stack Overflow (2015)","domain":"hackernoon.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["online_communities","developer_tools","social_issues"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-10","inductedMonth":"2019-10","submissions":7,"submitters":7,"spanYears":3.069,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":322,"evidenceRank":1136,"evidenceScore":57.7,"freshAt":"2019-10-21T17:56:35Z","freshnessRank":1042,"freshEventScore":94,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 322 pts / 293 comments (2016) + 94 pts / 78 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,121 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":322,"peak_comments":293,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12576124","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":48,"peak_comments":22,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15817105","height":4,"chart_height":25},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":94,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21315213","height":5,"chart_height":50},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-decline-of-stack-overflow-2015-d9d02354c6f5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-decline-of-stack-overflow-2015-d9d02354c6f5/"},{"slug":"nestflix-d9d023661c00","title":"Nestflix","domain":"nestflix.fun","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["film_television","internet_culture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2021,"candidateMonth":"2024-01","inductedMonth":"2025-05","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":4.318,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":428,"evidenceRank":1137,"evidenceScore":57.6,"freshAt":"2024-01-04T19:41:51Z","freshnessRank":467,"freshEventScore":428,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 428 pts / 127 comments (2024) + 237 pts / 51 comments (2021), different submitters and 872 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":237,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28189435","height":11,"chart_height":94},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":428,"peak_comments":127,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38871295","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46159452","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/nestflix-d9d023661c00.jpg","path":"/hall/link/nestflix-d9d023661c00/"},{"slug":"what-mongodb-got-right-d9d02351d7f7","title":"What MongoDB got right","domain":"blog.nelhage.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["databases_storage","software_architecture"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2017-11","inductedMonth":"2022-03","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":6.319,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":144,"evidenceRank":1138,"evidenceScore":57.6,"freshAt":"2017-11-28T08:27:36Z","freshnessRank":1115,"freshEventScore":89,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 144 pts / 110 comments (2015) + 89 pts / 93 comments (2017), different submitters and 746 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":144,"peak_comments":110,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10554391","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":89,"peak_comments":93,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15795377","height":4,"chart_height":105},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30577824","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-mongodb-got-right-d9d02351d7f7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-mongodb-got-right-d9d02351d7f7/"},{"slug":"set-up-an-email-server-in-two-hours-d9d02349fcfe","title":"Set up an email server in two hours","domain":"sealedabstract.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security","privacy_surveillance","protocols_networking"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-03","inductedMonth":"2018-02","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.561,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":220,"evidenceRank":1139,"evidenceScore":57.5,"freshAt":"2016-03-14T06:35:32Z","freshnessRank":1154,"freshEventScore":69,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 220 pts / 127 comments (2013) + 69 pts / 50 comments (2016), different submitters and 972 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":220,"peak_comments":127,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6045194","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9630711","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":69,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11281383","height":4,"chart_height":53},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16308657","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/set-up-an-email-server-in-two-hours-d9d02349fcfe.jpg","path":"/hall/link/set-up-an-email-server-in-two-hours-d9d02349fcfe/"},{"slug":"to-be-great-be-good-repeatably-d9d0235e06ff","title":"To be great, be good repeatably","domain":"blog.stephsmith.io","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["personal_productivity"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-12","inductedMonth":"2023-12","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.517,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":435,"evidenceRank":1140,"evidenceScore":57.5,"freshAt":"2023-12-18T19:26:30Z","freshnessRank":480,"freshEventScore":157,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 435 pts / 46 comments (2019) + 157 pts / 56 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,650 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":435,"peak_comments":46,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20167310","height":21,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25169061","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29652029","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":157,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38686997","height":8,"chart_height":61},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/to-be-great-be-good-repeatably-d9d0235e06ff.jpg","path":"/hall/link/to-be-great-be-good-repeatably-d9d0235e06ff/"},{"slug":"what-is-minikanren-d9d0234e16e3","title":"What Is miniKanren?","domain":"minikanren.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["programming_languages","theory_of_computation","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2025-01","inductedMonth":"2025-01","submissions":5,"submitters":3,"spanYears":10.256,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":235,"evidenceRank":1141,"evidenceScore":57.3,"freshAt":"2025-01-02T13:15:23Z","freshnessRank":272,"freshEventScore":235,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 235 pts / 135 comments (2025) + 224 pts / 44 comments (2018), different submitters and 2,208 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":85,"peak_comments":22,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8395079","height":4,"chart_height":61},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13301033","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":224,"peak_comments":44,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18698718","height":11,"chart_height":162},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":235,"peak_comments":135,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42574125","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-is-minikanren-d9d0234e16e3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-is-minikanren-d9d0234e16e3/"},{"slug":"cells-are-fast-and-crowded-places-2011-d9d02358a0dd","title":"Cells are fast and crowded places (2011)","domain":"www.righto.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["biology","neuroscience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-10","inductedMonth":"2022-06","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.038,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":294,"evidenceRank":1142,"evidenceScore":57.3,"freshAt":"2020-10-05T12:30:30Z","freshnessRank":989,"freshEventScore":294,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 294 pts / 117 comments (2020) + 205 pts / 79 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,063 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":205,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15635000","height":10,"chart_height":119},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":294,"peak_comments":117,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24687100","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31600424","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/cells-are-fast-and-crowded-places-2011-d9d02358a0dd.jpg","path":"/hall/link/cells-are-fast-and-crowded-places-2011-d9d02358a0dd/"},{"slug":"systems-design-explains-the-world-volume-1-d9d02363f324","title":"Systems design explains the world: volume 1","domain":"apenwarr.ca","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","management_strategy","leadership"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-03","inductedMonth":"2024-08","submissions":6,"submitters":4,"spanYears":4.216,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":337,"evidenceRank":1143,"evidenceScore":57.3,"freshAt":"2023-03-09T05:37:36Z","freshnessRank":645,"freshEventScore":193,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 337 pts / 152 comments (2020) + 193 pts / 43 comments (2023), different submitters and 801 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":337,"peak_comments":152,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25552267","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33584999","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":193,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35078590","height":9,"chart_height":97},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41211190","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43379104","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/systems-design-explains-the-world-volume-1-d9d02363f324.jpg","path":"/hall/link/systems-design-explains-the-world-volume-1-d9d02363f324/"},{"slug":"xsv-a-fast-csv-command-line-toolkit-written-in-rust-d9d0234f5f8d","title":"XSV: A fast CSV command-line toolkit written in Rust","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","databases_storage","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2018-09","inductedMonth":"2021-06","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":6.311,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":609,"evidenceRank":1144,"evidenceScore":57.2,"freshAt":"2018-09-08T22:13:04Z","freshnessRank":1084,"freshEventScore":609,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 609 pts / 188 comments (2018) + 101 pts / 47 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,294 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":47,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9088805","height":5,"chart_height":28},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":37,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12559515","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":609,"peak_comments":188,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17943076","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27512179","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/xsv-a-fast-csv-command-line-toolkit-written-in-rust-d9d0234f5f8d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/xsv-a-fast-csv-command-line-toolkit-written-in-rust-d9d0234f5f8d/"},{"slug":"national-park-typeface-d9d0235cc3c6","title":"National Park Typeface","domain":"nationalparktypeface.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"design_creativity","topicDisplay":"Design & creativity","tags":["visual_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2021-12","inductedMonth":"2024-09","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.58,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":623,"evidenceRank":1145,"evidenceScore":57.1,"freshAt":"2021-12-16T02:00:01Z","freshnessRank":847,"freshEventScore":203,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 623 pts / 84 comments (2019) + 203 pts / 31 comments (2021), different submitters and 925 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":623,"peak_comments":84,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20096120","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":203,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29573976","height":10,"chart_height":55},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41448722","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/national-park-typeface-d9d0235cc3c6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/national-park-typeface-d9d0235cc3c6/"},{"slug":"liberapay-d9d023566b02","title":"Liberapay","domain":"en.liberapay.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["finance","open_source","startups_entrepreneurship"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2025-03","inductedMonth":"2025-03","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":8.011,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":352,"evidenceRank":1146,"evidenceScore":57.0,"freshAt":"2025-03-18T12:21:12Z","freshnessRank":237,"freshEventScore":352,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 352 pts / 89 comments (2025) + 160 pts / 24 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,656 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":160,"peak_comments":24,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15882912","height":8,"chart_height":77},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19616191","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":352,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43398539","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/liberapay-d9d023566b02.jpg","path":"/hall/link/liberapay-d9d023566b02/"},{"slug":"algorithm-no-one-knows-about-2016-d9d023532f0b","title":"Algorithm No One Knows About (2016)","domain":"getkerf.wordpress.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["algorithms_data_structures","mathematics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-09","inductedMonth":"2022-03","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":5.944,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":286,"evidenceRank":1147,"evidenceScore":57.0,"freshAt":"2019-09-13T10:38:59Z","freshnessRank":1046,"freshEventScore":286,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 286 pts / 190 comments (2019) + 117 pts / 74 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,257 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":117,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11419529","height":6,"chart_height":70},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17059603","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":286,"peak_comments":190,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20960832","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30686142","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/algorithm-no-one-knows-about-2016-d9d023532f0b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/algorithm-no-one-knows-about-2016-d9d023532f0b/"},{"slug":"show-hn-listmonk-fast-self-hosted-newsletter-and-mailing-list-ma-d9d0235e511b","title":"Show HN: Listmonk – Fast self-hosted newsletter and mailing list manager","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["open_source","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2024-02","inductedMonth":"2024-11","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":5.38,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":343,"evidenceRank":1148,"evidenceScore":56.9,"freshAt":"2021-09-02T06:51:48Z","freshnessRank":877,"freshEventScore":145,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 343 pts / 50 comments (2019) + 145 pts / 48 comments (2021), different submitters and 782 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":343,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20421243","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":145,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28389346","height":7,"chart_height":72},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40013786","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/show-hn-listmonk-fast-self-hosted-newsletter-and-mailing-list-ma-d9d0235e511b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/show-hn-listmonk-fast-self-hosted-newsletter-and-mailing-list-ma-d9d0235e511b/"},{"slug":"save-your-eyes-start-using-f-lux-d9d0233f4c96","title":"Save your eyes, start using f.lux","domain":"stereopsis.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2013-01","inductedMonth":"2013-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.888,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":423,"evidenceRank":1149,"evidenceScore":56.9,"freshAt":"2013-01-10T12:43:19Z","freshnessRank":1174,"freshEventScore":423,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 423 pts / 255 comments (2013) + 107 pts / 42 comments (2009), different submitters and 1,420 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":2,"peak_score":107,"peak_comments":42,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=488211","height":5,"chart_height":43},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":56,"peak_comments":22,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1832097","height":4,"chart_height":23},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3167600","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":423,"peak_comments":255,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5036590","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/save-your-eyes-start-using-f-lux-d9d0233f4c96.jpg","path":"/hall/link/save-your-eyes-start-using-f-lux-d9d0233f4c96/"},{"slug":"apple-s-great-gpl-purge-d9d023453654","title":"Apple’s great GPL purge","domain":"meta.ath0.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["law_regulation"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2019-11","inductedMonth":"2019-11","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":7.803,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":241,"evidenceRank":1150,"evidenceScore":56.9,"freshAt":"2019-11-27T05:56:38Z","freshnessRank":1033,"freshEventScore":67,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 241 pts / 205 comments (2012) + 67 pts / 69 comments (2019), different submitters and 2,850 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":241,"peak_comments":205,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3559990","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17401653","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":67,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21645618","height":4,"chart_height":47},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/apple-s-great-gpl-purge-d9d023453654/"},{"slug":"the-rise-and-fall-of-getting-things-done-d9d02363869a","title":"The Rise and Fall of Getting Things Done","domain":"www.newyorker.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["personal_productivity","workplace","management_strategy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-05","inductedMonth":"2024-09","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.808,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":293,"evidenceRank":1151,"evidenceScore":56.8,"freshAt":"2023-05-31T15:25:36Z","freshnessRank":620,"freshEventScore":62,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 293 pts / 160 comments (2020) + 62 pts / 67 comments (2023), different submitters and 924 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":293,"peak_comments":160,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25131848","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33232073","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":62,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36139432","height":4,"chart_height":36},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41479998","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-rise-and-fall-of-getting-things-done-d9d02363869a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-rise-and-fall-of-getting-things-done-d9d02363869a/"},{"slug":"it-s-easier-to-manage-four-people-than-one-person-d9d023625c01","title":"It’s easier to manage four people than one person","domain":"staysaasy.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["management_strategy","leadership","workplace"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2022-08","inductedMonth":"2022-08","submissions":6,"submitters":4,"spanYears":4.734,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":267,"evidenceRank":1152,"evidenceScore":56.8,"freshAt":"2022-08-18T10:32:03Z","freshnessRank":730,"freshEventScore":210,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 210 pts / 102 comments (2022) + 267 pts / 90 comments (2020), different submitters and 751 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":267,"peak_comments":90,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23964905","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29349161","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":210,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32507596","height":10,"chart_height":134},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43742735","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/it-s-easier-to-manage-four-people-than-one-person-d9d023625c01.jpg","path":"/hall/link/it-s-easier-to-manage-four-people-than-one-person-d9d023625c01/"},{"slug":"guide-to-web-authentication-d9d0235ca649","title":"Guide to Web Authentication","domain":"webauthn.guide","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["application_security","cryptography","browsers_web_standards"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-06","inductedMonth":"2022-06","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":3.409,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":240,"evidenceRank":1153,"evidenceScore":56.8,"freshAt":"2022-06-22T15:02:08Z","freshnessRank":762,"freshEventScore":240,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 205 pts / 119 comments (2020) + 240 pts / 80 comments (2022), different submitters and 898 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18990519","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":205,"peak_comments":119,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21962424","height":10,"chart_height":145},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":240,"peak_comments":80,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31836922","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/guide-to-web-authentication-d9d0235ca649.jpg","path":"/hall/link/guide-to-web-authentication-d9d0235ca649/"},{"slug":"nuclear-war-survival-skills-1987-pdf-d9d02358363a","title":"Nuclear War Survival Skills (1987) [pdf]","domain":"oism.org","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["geopolitics","public_health"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2022-03","inductedMonth":"2022-03","submissions":5,"submitters":3,"spanYears":4.444,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":334,"evidenceRank":1154,"evidenceScore":56.7,"freshAt":"2022-03-02T21:28:24Z","freshnessRank":816,"freshEventScore":134,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 334 pts / 213 comments (2017) + 134 pts / 102 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,623 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":334,"peak_comments":213,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15305892","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28349482","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":134,"peak_comments":102,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30533432","height":6,"chart_height":68},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/nuclear-war-survival-skills-1987-pdf-d9d02358363a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/nuclear-war-survival-skills-1987-pdf-d9d02358363a/"},{"slug":"openbsd-why-and-how-2016-d9d023548e52","title":"OpenBSD: Why and How (2016)","domain":"sivers.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","application_security"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-11","inductedMonth":"2019-11","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":3.198,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":218,"evidenceRank":1155,"evidenceScore":56.5,"freshAt":"2019-11-13T07:17:26Z","freshnessRank":1036,"freshEventScore":218,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 218 pts / 114 comments (2019) + 102 pts / 48 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,167 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":102,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12403655","height":5,"chart_height":80},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17089200","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":218,"peak_comments":114,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21521774","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/openbsd-why-and-how-2016-d9d023548e52.jpg","path":"/hall/link/openbsd-why-and-how-2016-d9d023548e52/"},{"slug":"history-and-effective-use-of-vim-d9d0235e6171","title":"History and Effective Use of Vim","domain":"begriffs.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-07","inductedMonth":"2022-07","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":3.025,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":593,"evidenceRank":1156,"evidenceScore":56.3,"freshAt":"2022-07-28T09:43:14Z","freshnessRank":742,"freshEventScore":170,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 593 pts / 218 comments (2019) + 170 pts / 95 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,104 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":593,"peak_comments":218,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20481512","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27069198","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":170,"peak_comments":95,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32262285","height":8,"chart_height":49},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/history-and-effective-use-of-vim-d9d0235e6171.jpg","path":"/hall/link/history-and-effective-use-of-vim-d9d0235e6171/"},{"slug":"the-sound-so-loud-that-it-circled-the-earth-four-times-d9d0234e10b6","title":"The Sound So Loud That It Circled the Earth Four Times","domain":"nautil.us","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["earth_science","physics","history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2018-12","inductedMonth":"2020-11","submissions":5,"submitters":3,"spanYears":6.171,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":639,"evidenceRank":1157,"evidenceScore":56.3,"freshAt":"2020-11-30T18:31:40Z","freshnessRank":969,"freshEventScore":94,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 639 pts / 107 comments (2014) + 184 pts / 38 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,545 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":639,"peak_comments":107,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8383158","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10327293","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10976301","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":184,"peak_comments":38,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18746225","height":9,"chart_height":49},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":94,"peak_comments":36,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25257162","height":5,"chart_height":25},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-sound-so-loud-that-it-circled-the-earth-four-times-d9d0234e10b6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-sound-so-loud-that-it-circled-the-earth-four-times-d9d0234e10b6/"},{"slug":"the-medieval-habit-of-two-sleeps-d9d02367738b","title":"The medieval habit of ‘two sleeps’","domain":"www.bbc.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["history","medicine"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2022,"candidateMonth":"2024-02","inductedMonth":"2026-04","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.296,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":348,"evidenceRank":1158,"evidenceScore":56.1,"freshAt":"2024-02-02T04:02:27Z","freshnessRank":449,"freshEventScore":106,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 348 pts / 245 comments (2022) + 106 pts / 78 comments (2024), different submitters and 752 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":348,"peak_comments":245,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29886907","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":106,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39224865","height":5,"chart_height":52},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46912468","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-medieval-habit-of-two-sleeps-d9d02367738b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-medieval-habit-of-two-sleeps-d9d02367738b/"},{"slug":"why-general-artificial-intelligence-will-not-be-realized-d9d023620e83","title":"Why general artificial intelligence will not be realized","domain":"www.nature.com","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"research_paper","typeDisplay":"Research papers","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["artificial_intelligence","philosophy","technology_ethics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2022-08","inductedMonth":"2024-08","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":4.131,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":181,"evidenceRank":1159,"evidenceScore":56.0,"freshAt":"2022-08-06T18:58:32Z","freshnessRank":737,"freshEventScore":25,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 181 pts / 386 comments (2020) + 25 pts / 76 comments (2022), different submitters and 757 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":181,"peak_comments":386,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23793108","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":25,"peak_comments":76,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32370635","height":4,"chart_height":23},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41259987","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-general-artificial-intelligence-will-not-be-realized-d9d023620e83.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-general-artificial-intelligence-will-not-be-realized-d9d023620e83/"},{"slug":"huginn-an-open-source-ifttt-yahoo-pipes-d9d02348cc9d","title":"Huginn, an Open Source IFTTT / Yahoo Pipes","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source","web_development"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-02","inductedMonth":"2016-02","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":2.886,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":374,"evidenceRank":1160,"evidenceScore":55.9,"freshAt":"2016-02-01T20:30:59Z","freshnessRank":1160,"freshEventScore":264,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 374 pts / 70 comments (2013) + 264 pts / 44 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,053 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":374,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5377651","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8815482","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9362788","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":264,"peak_comments":44,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11015147","height":13,"chart_height":120},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/huginn-an-open-source-ifttt-yahoo-pipes-d9d02348cc9d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/huginn-an-open-source-ifttt-yahoo-pipes-d9d02348cc9d/"},{"slug":"cue-a-new-language-for-data-validation-d9d0235ecddc","title":"Cue: A new language for data validation","domain":"cuelang.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","data_engineering","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2021-10","inductedMonth":"2023-08","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.945,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":354,"evidenceRank":1161,"evidenceScore":55.8,"freshAt":"2023-08-11T16:52:08Z","freshnessRank":570,"freshEventScore":23,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 354 pts / 152 comments (2019) + 203 pts / 89 comments (2021), different submitters and 779 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":354,"peak_comments":152,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20847943","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":203,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28915655","height":10,"chart_height":97},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":23,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37090857","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/cue-a-new-language-for-data-validation-d9d0235ecddc.jpg","path":"/hall/link/cue-a-new-language-for-data-validation-d9d0235ecddc/"},{"slug":"why-don-t-we-use-chemical-weapons-anymore-d9d02360da58","title":"Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore?","domain":"acoup.blog","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["history","geopolitics","law_regulation"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2022-10","inductedMonth":"2022-10","submissions":6,"submitters":6,"spanYears":2.546,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":203,"evidenceRank":1162,"evidenceScore":55.8,"freshAt":"2022-10-06T23:53:34Z","freshnessRank":712,"freshEventScore":52,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 203 pts / 157 comments (2020) + 52 pts / 80 comments (2022), different submitters and 927 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":203,"peak_comments":157,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22661465","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28167872","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":52,"peak_comments":80,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33115725","height":4,"chart_height":44},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-don-t-we-use-chemical-weapons-anymore-d9d02360da58.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-don-t-we-use-chemical-weapons-anymore-d9d02360da58/"},{"slug":"show-hn-open-source-javascript-library-to-record-and-replay-the-d9d0235c6750","title":"Show HN: Open source JavaScript library to record and replay the web","domain":"www.rrweb.io","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["web_development","developer_tools","open_source","privacy_surveillance"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2024-07","inductedMonth":"2024-07","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":5.566,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":353,"evidenceRank":1163,"evidenceScore":55.6,"freshAt":"2024-07-22T04:10:23Z","freshnessRank":360,"freshEventScore":177,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 353 pts / 51 comments (2018) + 177 pts / 33 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,032 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":353,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18776496","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27745083","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":177,"peak_comments":33,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41030862","height":8,"chart_height":85},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/show-hn-open-source-javascript-library-to-record-and-replay-the-d9d0235c6750.jpg","path":"/hall/link/show-hn-open-source-javascript-library-to-record-and-replay-the-d9d0235c6750/"},{"slug":"claude-shannon-how-a-genius-thinks-works-and-lives-d9d02357a3b5","title":"Claude Shannon: How a Genius Thinks, Works, and Lives","domain":"medium.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["personal_productivity","learning_methods","history"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-01","inductedMonth":"2021-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.504,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":362,"evidenceRank":1164,"evidenceScore":55.4,"freshAt":"2021-01-20T12:34:42Z","freshnessRank":952,"freshEventScore":157,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 362 pts / 100 comments (2017) + 157 pts / 82 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,279 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":362,"peak_comments":100,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14819377","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19299860","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":157,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25845683","height":8,"chart_height":74},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/claude-shannon-how-a-genius-thinks-works-and-lives-d9d02357a3b5/"},{"slug":"patterns-of-distributed-systems-2020-d9d0236279e9","title":"Patterns of Distributed Systems (2020)","domain":"martinfowler.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["distributed_systems","software_architecture","databases_storage"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-06","inductedMonth":"2023-06","submissions":6,"submitters":5,"spanYears":2.891,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":313,"evidenceRank":1165,"evidenceScore":55.4,"freshAt":"2023-06-27T16:43:12Z","freshnessRank":602,"freshEventScore":235,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 313 pts / 58 comments (2021) + 235 pts / 71 comments (2023), different submitters and 867 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24065086","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":313,"peak_comments":58,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26089683","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":235,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36495335","height":11,"chart_height":128},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/patterns-of-distributed-systems-2020-d9d0236279e9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/patterns-of-distributed-systems-2020-d9d0236279e9/"},{"slug":"harvard-cracks-dna-storage-crams-700-terabytes-of-data-into-a-si-d9d02346e86a","title":"Harvard cracks DNA storage, crams 700 terabytes of data into a single gram","domain":"www.extremetech.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"news_report","typeDisplay":"News reports","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["biology","databases_storage"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2015-02","inductedMonth":"2015-10","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":3.192,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":346,"evidenceRank":1166,"evidenceScore":55.1,"freshAt":"2015-02-04T18:25:39Z","freshnessRank":1168,"freshEventScore":72,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 346 pts / 129 comments (2012) + 72 pts / 73 comments (2015), different submitters and 901 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":346,"peak_comments":129,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4396931","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7015863","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":72,"peak_comments":73,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8998584","height":4,"chart_height":35},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/harvard-cracks-dna-storage-crams-700-terabytes-of-data-into-a-si-d9d02346e86a/"},{"slug":"janet-a-lisp-like-functional-imperative-programming-language-d9d0235cdf33","title":"Janet – a Lisp-like functional, imperative programming language","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","compilers_runtimes","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2021-10","inductedMonth":"2023-11","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":4.747,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":224,"evidenceRank":1167,"evidenceScore":55.0,"freshAt":"2021-10-13T11:26:12Z","freshnessRank":864,"freshEventScore":224,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 224 pts / 135 comments (2021) + 152 pts / 50 comments (2019), different submitters and 969 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":152,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19179963","height":7,"chart_height":115},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":224,"peak_comments":135,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28850861","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38281100","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/janet-a-lisp-like-functional-imperative-programming-language-d9d0235cdf33.jpg","path":"/hall/link/janet-a-lisp-like-functional-imperative-programming-language-d9d0235cdf33/"},{"slug":"what-silicon-valley-gets-about-engineers-that-traditional-compan-d9d023633eac","title":"What Silicon Valley gets about engineers that traditional companies do not","domain":"blog.pragmaticengineer.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"work_careers","topicDisplay":"Work & careers","tags":["workplace","management_strategy","careers"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2020,"candidateMonth":"2023-09","inductedMonth":"2023-09","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":2.908,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":805,"evidenceRank":1168,"evidenceScore":54.7,"freshAt":"2023-09-17T06:56:08Z","freshnessRank":544,"freshEventScore":71,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 805 pts / 324 comments (2021) + 71 pts / 66 comments (2023), different submitters and 979 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24837980","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":805,"peak_comments":324,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25717390","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":71,"peak_comments":66,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37542236","height":4,"chart_height":15},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-silicon-valley-gets-about-engineers-that-traditional-compan-d9d023633eac.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-silicon-valley-gets-about-engineers-that-traditional-compan-d9d023633eac/"},{"slug":"drop-a-raindrop-anywhere-in-the-world-and-watch-where-it-ends-up-d9d02367672b","title":"Drop a raindrop anywhere in the world and watch where it ends up","domain":"river-runner-global.samlearner.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["earth_science","climate_environment","interactive_fiction"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2022,"candidateMonth":"2025-01","inductedMonth":"2025-01","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":3.058,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":790,"evidenceRank":1169,"evidenceScore":54.6,"freshAt":"2025-01-26T11:09:17Z","freshnessRank":258,"freshEventScore":172,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 790 pts / 115 comments (2022) + 172 pts / 42 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,114 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":790,"peak_comments":115,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29841737","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38208890","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41752052","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":172,"peak_comments":42,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42829346","height":8,"chart_height":37},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/drop-a-raindrop-anywhere-in-the-world-and-watch-where-it-ends-up-d9d02367672b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/drop-a-raindrop-anywhere-in-the-world-and-watch-where-it-ends-up-d9d02367672b/"},{"slug":"kill-google-amp-before-it-kills-the-web-d9d02357114e","title":"Kill Google AMP before it kills the web","domain":"www.theregister.co.uk","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","browsers_web_standards","technology_ethics"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2020-01","inductedMonth":"2020-01","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":2.672,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":969,"evidenceRank":1170,"evidenceScore":54.5,"freshAt":"2020-01-21T19:44:33Z","freshnessRank":1025,"freshEventScore":148,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 969 pts / 462 comments (2017) + 148 pts / 20 comments (2020), different submitters and 975 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":969,"peak_comments":462,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14384187","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19974765","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":148,"peak_comments":20,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22110726","height":7,"chart_height":26},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/kill-google-amp-before-it-kills-the-web-d9d02357114e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/kill-google-amp-before-it-kills-the-web-d9d02357114e/"},{"slug":"web-fundamentals-a-handbook-for-best-practices-d9d0234cc026","title":"Web Fundamentals: A handbook for best practices","domain":"developers.google.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","browsers_web_standards","user_experience"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2016-12","inductedMonth":"2016-12","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":2.631,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":379,"evidenceRank":1171,"evidenceScore":54.4,"freshAt":"2016-12-16T20:43:29Z","freshnessRank":1141,"freshEventScore":204,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 379 pts / 64 comments (2014) + 204 pts / 36 comments (2016), different submitters and 961 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":379,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7675865","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9287865","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":204,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13196605","height":10,"chart_height":92},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/web-fundamentals-a-handbook-for-best-practices-d9d0234cc026.jpg","path":"/hall/link/web-fundamentals-a-handbook-for-best-practices-d9d0234cc026/"},{"slug":"bootos-monolithic-operating-system-in-512-bytes-of-x86-machine-c-d9d0235e79fc","title":"BootOS: Monolithic operating system in 512 bytes of x86 machine code","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","retrocomputing","programming_languages"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2023-06","inductedMonth":"2023-06","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":3.858,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":588,"evidenceRank":1172,"evidenceScore":54.2,"freshAt":"2023-06-07T20:16:19Z","freshnessRank":616,"freshEventScore":246,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 588 pts / 121 comments (2019) + 246 pts / 30 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,407 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":588,"peak_comments":121,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20569438","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":87,"peak_comments":14,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28326311","height":4,"chart_height":25},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":246,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36232900","height":12,"chart_height":71},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/bootos-monolithic-operating-system-in-512-bytes-of-x86-machine-c-d9d0235e79fc.jpg","path":"/hall/link/bootos-monolithic-operating-system-in-512-bytes-of-x86-machine-c-d9d0235e79fc/"},{"slug":"my-approach-to-building-large-technical-projects-2023-d9d0236c4f8e","title":"My approach to building large technical projects (2023)","domain":"mitchellh.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["software_architecture","personal_productivity","management_strategy"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2023,"candidateMonth":"2025-10","inductedMonth":"2025-10","submissions":5,"submitters":5,"spanYears":2.36,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":384,"evidenceRank":1173,"evidenceScore":54.1,"freshAt":"2025-10-10T03:45:29Z","freshnessRank":133,"freshEventScore":384,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 384 pts / 52 comments (2025) + 233 pts / 27 comments (2023), different submitters and 860 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":233,"peak_comments":27,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36161397","height":11,"chart_height":103},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42531590","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":384,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45535202","height":18,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/my-approach-to-building-large-technical-projects-2023-d9d0236c4f8e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/my-approach-to-building-large-technical-projects-2023-d9d0236c4f8e/"},{"slug":"you-don-t-need-moment-js-d9d0235b71a8","title":"You Don't Need Moment.js","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","web_development","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2021-09","inductedMonth":"2021-09","submissions":6,"submitters":4,"spanYears":3.017,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":241,"evidenceRank":1174,"evidenceScore":54.0,"freshAt":"2021-09-18T18:57:02Z","freshnessRank":870,"freshEventScore":149,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 149 pts / 128 comments (2021) + 241 pts / 85 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,099 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":241,"peak_comments":85,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17990859","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22247683","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":149,"peak_comments":128,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28578395","height":7,"chart_height":105},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/you-don-t-need-moment-js-d9d0235b71a8.jpg","path":"/hall/link/you-don-t-need-moment-js-d9d0235b71a8/"},{"slug":"show-hn-open-source-alternative-to-intercom-drift-zendesk-freshc-d9d0235f9664","title":"Show HN: Open-Source Alternative to Intercom, Drift, Zendesk, FreshChat","domain":"github.com","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["open_source","web_development","developer_tools"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2022-09","inductedMonth":"2022-09","submissions":5,"submitters":4,"spanYears":2.858,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":417,"evidenceRank":1175,"evidenceScore":53.2,"freshAt":"2022-09-26T07:09:48Z","freshnessRank":714,"freshEventScore":101,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 417 pts / 79 comments (2019) + 101 pts / 26 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,043 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":417,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21559139","height":20,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29500167","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":26,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32980309","height":5,"chart_height":41},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/show-hn-open-source-alternative-to-intercom-drift-zendesk-freshc-d9d0235f9664.jpg","path":"/hall/link/show-hn-open-source-alternative-to-intercom-drift-zendesk-freshc-d9d0235f9664/"},{"slug":"the-fall-of-roam-2022-d9d02367c933","title":"The Fall of Roam (2022)","domain":"every.to","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["personal_productivity","developer_tools","product_design"],"collection":"hall","firstSeenYear":2022,"candidateMonth":"2025-05","inductedMonth":"2025-05","submissions":5,"submitters":3,"spanYears":3.261,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":136,"evidenceRank":1176,"evidenceScore":51.8,"freshAt":"2025-05-18T18:36:54Z","freshnessRank":211,"freshEventScore":136,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 109 pts / 103 comments (2022) + 136 pts / 98 comments (2025), different submitters and 1,190 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 3 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":109,"peak_comments":103,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30320977","height":5,"chart_height":136},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36148651","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":136,"peak_comments":98,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44023423","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-fall-of-roam-2022-d9d02367c933.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-fall-of-roam-2022-d9d02367c933/"},{"slug":"the-tty-demystified-2008-d9d0234264f5","title":"The TTY demystified (2008)","domain":"www.linusakesson.net","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2014-07","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":32,"submitters":32,"spanYears":16.197,"breakoutYears":6,"maxScore":243,"evidenceRank":1,"evidenceScore":84.0,"freshAt":"2025-08-26T10:56:23Z","freshnessRank":176,"freshEventScore":96,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 243 pts / 43 comments (2017) + 218 pts / 21 comments (2014), different submitters and 923 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 32 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 32 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":93,"peak_comments":13,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=658155","height":4,"chart_height":65},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1513058","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2145991","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":4,"peak_score":161,"peak_comments":46,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4062981","height":8,"chart_height":113},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6157178","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":218,"peak_comments":21,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8094186","height":10,"chart_height":153},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":168,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10631513","height":8,"chart_height":118},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13187062","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":243,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13571055","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":4,"peak_score":98,"peak_comments":12,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17765683","height":5,"chart_height":69},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19986213","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22059823","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":187,"peak_comments":35,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26803109","height":9,"chart_height":131},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":146,"peak_comments":22,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31146862","height":7,"chart_height":102},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37088796","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":40,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38987804","height":4,"chart_height":28},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":96,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45024847","height":5,"chart_height":67},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-tty-demystified-2008-d9d0234264f5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-tty-demystified-2008-d9d0234264f5/"},{"slug":"richard-feynman-and-the-connection-machine-d9d02340b97c","title":"Richard Feynman and the Connection Machine","domain":"longnow.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["computer_architecture","history"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2013-05","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":29,"submitters":28,"spanYears":15.31,"breakoutYears":7,"maxScore":225,"evidenceRank":2,"evidenceScore":83.4,"freshAt":"2024-09-07T07:20:34Z","freshnessRank":398,"freshEventScore":177,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 225 pts / 32 comments (2016) + 177 pts / 49 comments (2024), different submitters and 2,946 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 29 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 28 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":81,"peak_comments":23,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1205500","height":4,"chart_height":61},{"year":2011,"count":4,"peak_score":161,"peak_comments":46,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2079473","height":8,"chart_height":122},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":127,"peak_comments":11,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5660763","height":6,"chart_height":96},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":119,"peak_comments":23,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8681061","height":6,"chart_height":90},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9568164","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":225,"peak_comments":32,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12283614","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18005085","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":152,"peak_comments":33,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18987188","height":7,"chart_height":115},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24047161","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":161,"peak_comments":49,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28981275","height":8,"chart_height":122},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33501365","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36644772","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":177,"peak_comments":49,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41472135","height":8,"chart_height":134},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44520162","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/richard-feynman-and-the-connection-machine-d9d02340b97c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/richard-feynman-and-the-connection-machine-d9d02340b97c/"},{"slug":"seeing-theory-2017-d9d0235c66d9","title":"Seeing Theory (2017)","domain":"seeing-theory.brown.edu","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","data_science","learning_methods"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2022-01","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":15,"submitters":15,"spanYears":7.138,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":526,"evidenceRank":3,"evidenceScore":79.4,"freshAt":"2026-02-15T08:40:12Z","freshnessRank":48,"freshEventScore":62,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 526 pts / 18 comments (2018) + 62 pts / 2 comments (2026), different submitters and 2,606 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":526,"peak_comments":18,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18769099","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":113,"peak_comments":4,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18988023","height":5,"chart_height":37},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":519,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24633484","height":24,"chart_height":168},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":35,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32097167","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40559574","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46103270","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":62,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47022067","height":4,"chart_height":20}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/seeing-theory-2017-d9d0235c66d9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/seeing-theory-2017-d9d0235c66d9/"},{"slug":"best-paper-awards-in-computer-science-over-the-past-25-years-d9d02363fedf","title":"Best Paper Awards in Computer Science over the past 25 years","domain":"jeffhuang.com","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"dataset","typeDisplay":"Datasets","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["academic_life","data_science","digital_archives"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2013-12","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":19,"submitters":15,"spanYears":15.63,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":192,"evidenceRank":4,"evidenceScore":79.1,"freshAt":"2022-01-03T09:03:49Z","freshnessRank":1167,"freshEventScore":159,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 192 pts / 57 comments (2012) + 159 pts / 24 comments (2022), different submitters and 3,455 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 19 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":3,"peak_score":129,"peak_comments":38,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2051437","height":6,"chart_height":114},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":33,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2293535","height":4,"chart_height":29},{"year":2012,"count":3,"peak_score":192,"peak_comments":57,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4261954","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":129,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6992010","height":6,"chart_height":114},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8788886","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":72,"peak_comments":11,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11005334","height":4,"chart_height":64},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":142,"peak_comments":11,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25610531","height":7,"chart_height":126},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":159,"peak_comments":24,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29778762","height":8,"chart_height":141},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38795439","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38842669","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47656326","height":4,"chart_height":5}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/best-paper-awards-in-computer-science-over-the-past-25-years-d9d02363fedf.jpg","path":"/hall/link/best-paper-awards-in-computer-science-over-the-past-25-years-d9d02363fedf/"},{"slug":"goi-nia-accident-d9d0234e8dfb","title":"Goiânia Accident","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["physics","public_health"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2023-02","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":11.655,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":298,"evidenceRank":5,"evidenceScore":79.0,"freshAt":"2023-02-01T12:50:12Z","freshnessRank":886,"freshEventScore":298,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 298 pts / 185 comments (2023) + 21 pts / 2 comments (2020), different submitters and 948 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8635015","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10263608","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13400899","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20249182","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":21,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23664402","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":205,"peak_comments":121,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29127586","height":10,"chart_height":117},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":298,"peak_comments":185,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34609730","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40689761","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45046458","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48953560","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/goi-nia-accident-d9d0234e8dfb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/goi-nia-accident-d9d0234e8dfb/"},{"slug":"wat-video-2012-d9d02345098a","title":"Wat [video] (2012)","domain":"www.destroyallsoftware.com","category":"media","categoryDisplay":"Audio, video & images","type":"video","typeDisplay":"Video","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2023-03","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":36,"submitters":36,"spanYears":14.264,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":394,"evidenceRank":6,"evidenceScore":79.0,"freshAt":"2023-03-29T20:29:53Z","freshnessRank":848,"freshEventScore":394,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 394 pts / 144 comments (2023) + 38 pts / 0 comments (2012), different submitters and 4,088 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 36 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 36 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":4,"peak_score":38,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3479019","height":4,"chart_height":16},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6307393","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2014,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8225418","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10610280","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":5,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12604104","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15512025","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17802674","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19147259","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22456576","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":147,"peak_comments":28,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26850630","height":7,"chart_height":63},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32484336","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":394,"peak_comments":144,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35363044","height":19,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":4,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45088487","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47886945","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/wat-video-2012-d9d02345098a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/wat-video-2012-d9d02345098a/"},{"slug":"reverse-engineering-for-beginners-d9d0234da264","title":"Reverse Engineering for Beginners","domain":"beginners.re","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["computer_architecture","programming_languages","retrocomputing"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2015-12","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":13,"submitters":12,"spanYears":11.362,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":340,"evidenceRank":7,"evidenceScore":78.5,"freshAt":"2016-07-29T08:25:13Z","freshnessRank":1840,"freshEventScore":235,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 235 pts / 23 comments (2016) + 229 pts / 26 comments (2014), different submitters and 810 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5399596","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":276,"peak_comments":28,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8161316","height":13,"chart_height":138},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":340,"peak_comments":34,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10812055","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":235,"peak_comments":23,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12185586","height":11,"chart_height":118},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15008552","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21580581","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24339917","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28566121","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30929102","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41100866","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/reverse-engineering-for-beginners-d9d0234da264.jpg","path":"/hall/link/reverse-engineering-for-beginners-d9d0234da264/"},{"slug":"cdecl-turns-english-phrases-into-c-declarations-d9d02340303f","title":"Cdecl – Turns English phrases into C declarations","domain":"cdecl.org","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2019-01","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":21,"submitters":21,"spanYears":14.998,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":163,"evidenceRank":8,"evidenceScore":78.0,"freshAt":"2024-11-11T20:22:15Z","freshnessRank":355,"freshEventScore":66,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 95 pts / 62 comments (2022) + 163 pts / 36 comments (2013), different submitters and 3,155 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 21 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 21 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=938371","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1857521","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2073080","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4885436","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":163,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6311235","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13231953","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13385049","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":5,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17203884","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":150,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18842939","height":7,"chart_height":156},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":69,"peak_comments":26,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25021605","height":4,"chart_height":72},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":95,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31132715","height":5,"chart_height":99},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":66,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42110159","height":4,"chart_height":69},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/cdecl-turns-english-phrases-into-c-declarations-d9d02340303f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/cdecl-turns-english-phrases-into-c-declarations-d9d02340303f/"},{"slug":"a-modern-javascript-tutorial-d9d0234357cd","title":"A Modern JavaScript Tutorial","domain":"javascript.info","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["web_development","programming_languages"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2022-05","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":14,"submitters":13,"spanYears":13.952,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":893,"evidenceRank":9,"evidenceScore":77.7,"freshAt":"2022-05-15T20:24:31Z","freshnessRank":1075,"freshEventScore":538,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 538 pts / 101 comments (2022) + 5 pts / 2 comments (2019), different submitters and 914 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2633154","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14485384","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18553256","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21520760","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":893,"peak_comments":292,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25333350","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":538,"peak_comments":101,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31390742","height":24,"chart_height":102},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37912497","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39573048","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44054756","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-modern-javascript-tutorial-d9d0234357cd.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-modern-javascript-tutorial-d9d0234357cd/"},{"slug":"phoebus-cartel-d9d0234d80d2","title":"Phoebus Cartel","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"economics_business","topicDisplay":"Economics & business","tags":["markets","manufacturing","history"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2019-11","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":16,"submitters":15,"spanYears":11.901,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":195,"evidenceRank":10,"evidenceScore":77.3,"freshAt":"2021-04-26T13:07:27Z","freshnessRank":1322,"freshEventScore":126,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 126 pts / 82 comments (2021) + 131 pts / 48 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,006 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8087582","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":131,"peak_comments":48,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17606748","height":6,"chart_height":114},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":195,"peak_comments":120,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21596792","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":7,"peak_score":126,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26942110","height":6,"chart_height":110},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36086996","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41189497","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45381847","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48596367","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/phoebus-cartel-d9d0234d80d2.jpg","path":"/hall/link/phoebus-cartel-d9d0234d80d2/"},{"slug":"what-happens-when-you-type-google-com-into-your-browser-and-pres-d9d0234b151e","title":"“What happens when you type Google.com into your browser and press enter?”","domain":"github.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["browsers_web_standards","protocols_networking","internet_infrastructure"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-05","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":20,"submitters":19,"spanYears":12.279,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":491,"evidenceRank":11,"evidenceScore":77.2,"freshAt":"2022-02-16T08:42:48Z","freshnessRank":1140,"freshEventScore":20,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 491 pts / 129 comments (2015) + 20 pts / 1 comments (2022), different submitters and 2,587 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 19 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6693621","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":491,"peak_comments":129,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8902105","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":132,"peak_comments":38,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11737233","height":6,"chart_height":46},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18923788","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":5,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24509381","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":20,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30357656","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34662022","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39325316","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42576950","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47057446","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-happens-when-you-type-google-com-into-your-browser-and-pres-d9d0234b151e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-happens-when-you-type-google-com-into-your-browser-and-pres-d9d0234b151e/"},{"slug":"2011-startup-school-d9d0233dfedb","title":"2011 Startup School","domain":"startupschool.org","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"course_lecture","typeDisplay":"Courses & lectures","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["teaching","startups_entrepreneurship"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2007,"candidateMonth":"2013-09","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":19,"submitters":17,"spanYears":15.51,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":282,"evidenceRank":12,"evidenceScore":76.8,"freshAt":"2019-12-10T17:05:36Z","freshnessRank":1543,"freshEventScore":108,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 282 pts / 82 comments (2011) + 191 pts / 60 comments (2017), different submitters and 2,064 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 19 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":1,"peak_score":37,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=74","height":4,"chart_height":22},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":3,"peak_score":73,"peak_comments":31,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=764433","height":4,"chart_height":44},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":33,"peak_comments":13,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1726607","height":4,"chart_height":20},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":282,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2873865","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4484610","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":136,"peak_comments":65,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6323603","height":7,"chart_height":82},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8193937","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":191,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14045607","height":9,"chart_height":115},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":10,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17754868","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":108,"peak_comments":35,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21754306","height":5,"chart_height":65},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32582723","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/2011-startup-school-d9d0233dfedb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/2011-startup-school-d9d0233dfedb/"},{"slug":"why-the-web-won-t-be-nirvana-1995-d9d0234b522a","title":"Why the Web Won't Be Nirvana (1995)","domain":"www.newsweek.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["internet_culture","journalism_media"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2017-04","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":20,"submitters":20,"spanYears":12.539,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":130,"evidenceRank":13,"evidenceScore":76.6,"freshAt":"2024-02-18T11:07:12Z","freshnessRank":559,"freshEventScore":97,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 94 pts / 67 comments (2013) + 130 pts / 54 comments (2020), different submitters and 2,432 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":94,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6835403","height":5,"chart_height":123},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":4,"peak_score":35,"peak_comments":55,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10542682","height":4,"chart_height":46},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":7,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15272888","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":94,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17585520","height":5,"chart_height":123},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":130,"peak_comments":54,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24011058","height":6,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":21,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31718420","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":97,"peak_comments":45,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39418102","height":5,"chart_height":127},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44662235","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48574183","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/why-the-web-won-t-be-nirvana-1995-d9d0234b522a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/why-the-web-won-t-be-nirvana-1995-d9d0234b522a/"},{"slug":"the-night-watch-2013-pdf-d9d02351f856","title":"The Night Watch (2013) [pdf]","domain":"www.usenix.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","careers"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2019-03","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":18,"submitters":16,"spanYears":9.298,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":244,"evidenceRank":14,"evidenceScore":76.4,"freshAt":"2025-03-12T21:12:05Z","freshnessRank":277,"freshEventScore":205,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 244 pts / 33 comments (2017) + 205 pts / 33 comments (2025), different submitters and 2,909 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 18 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10620346","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12490689","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":244,"peak_comments":33,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13954077","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":111,"peak_comments":10,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19289353","height":5,"chart_height":77},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23898541","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27505138","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33719507","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":138,"peak_comments":35,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34522845","height":7,"chart_height":96},{"year":2024,"count":4,"peak_score":173,"peak_comments":28,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42440496","height":8,"chart_height":121},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":205,"peak_comments":33,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43347724","height":10,"chart_height":143},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-night-watch-2013-pdf-d9d02351f856.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-night-watch-2013-pdf-d9d02351f856/"},{"slug":"jq-a-command-line-json-processor-d9d023497111","title":"Jq – A Command-line JSON processor","domain":"stedolan.github.io","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","data_engineering"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2015-09","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":18,"submitters":16,"spanYears":7.775,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":451,"evidenceRank":15,"evidenceScore":76.4,"freshAt":"2015-04-27T15:41:10Z","freshnessRank":1910,"freshEventScore":451,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 451 pts / 91 comments (2015) + 4 pts / 0 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,153 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 18 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":132,"peak_comments":29,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5734683","height":6,"chart_height":50},{"year":2014,"count":4,"peak_score":229,"peak_comments":55,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7895076","height":11,"chart_height":86},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":451,"peak_comments":91,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9446980","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13097728","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17385953","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20619692","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22720888","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26273534","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/jq-a-command-line-json-processor-d9d023497111.jpg","path":"/hall/link/jq-a-command-line-json-processor-d9d023497111/"},{"slug":"bit-twiddling-hacks-d9d0233e4395","title":"Bit Twiddling Hacks","domain":"graphics.stanford.edu","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"documentation_reference","typeDisplay":"Documentation & references","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["algorithms_data_structures","computer_architecture"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2007,"candidateMonth":"2020-12","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":46,"submitters":45,"spanYears":18.472,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":143,"evidenceRank":16,"evidenceScore":76.1,"freshAt":"2024-08-23T00:09:32Z","freshnessRank":409,"freshEventScore":92,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 143 pts / 33 comments (2020) + 127 pts / 24 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,614 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 46 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 45 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":1,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=86419","height":4,"chart_height":21},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":49,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=513935","height":4,"chart_height":58},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1519869","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":3,"peak_score":60,"peak_comments":14,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2570269","height":4,"chart_height":71},{"year":2012,"count":5,"peak_score":50,"peak_comments":17,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3452408","height":4,"chart_height":59},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6932565","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":50,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8754904","height":4,"chart_height":59},{"year":2015,"count":6,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9536189","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":127,"peak_comments":24,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12026879","height":6,"chart_height":151},{"year":2017,"count":5,"peak_score":66,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15734119","height":4,"chart_height":78},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17629156","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19800813","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":143,"peak_comments":33,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25300310","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":5,"peak_score":136,"peak_comments":25,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33326360","height":7,"chart_height":162},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":5,"peak_score":92,"peak_comments":25,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41325284","height":4,"chart_height":109},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46238395","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48283240","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/bit-twiddling-hacks-d9d0233e4395.jpg","path":"/hall/link/bit-twiddling-hacks-d9d0233e4395/"},{"slug":"list-of-cognitive-biases-d9d0233fca7f","title":"List of Cognitive Biases","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["psychology"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2013-12","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":36,"submitters":35,"spanYears":15.176,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":214,"evidenceRank":17,"evidenceScore":76.1,"freshAt":"2019-07-02T05:25:23Z","freshnessRank":1595,"freshEventScore":214,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 214 pts / 64 comments (2019) + 168 pts / 62 comments (2013), different submitters and 2,035 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 36 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 35 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=731544","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2010,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1106502","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3121508","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":17,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3754697","height":5,"chart_height":80},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":168,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6851475","height":8,"chart_height":133},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8131082","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":5,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8944514","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":4,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12964917","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2017,"count":5,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15435561","height":4,"chart_height":14},{"year":2018,"count":4,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18536036","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":214,"peak_comments":64,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20332375","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27486746","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31831880","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41724733","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/list-of-cognitive-biases-d9d0233fca7f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/list-of-cognitive-biases-d9d0233fca7f/"},{"slug":"ecosia-a-search-engine-that-plants-trees-d9d023430867","title":"Ecosia – A search engine that plants trees","domain":"www.ecosia.org","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["information_retrieval","climate_environment","conservation"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2021-01","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":17,"submitters":16,"spanYears":13.092,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":297,"evidenceRank":18,"evidenceScore":76.0,"freshAt":"2021-01-10T10:09:36Z","freshnessRank":1386,"freshEventScore":297,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 297 pts / 144 comments (2021) + 2 pts / 1 comments (2013), different submitters and 2,665 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2476928","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6434509","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12306783","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15776372","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18219983","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":235,"peak_comments":86,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19324766","height":11,"chart_height":135},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25001214","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":297,"peak_comments":144,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25713050","height":14,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33468361","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40479593","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/ecosia-a-search-engine-that-plants-trees-d9d023430867/"},{"slug":"the-light-phone-d9d023504809","title":"The Light Phone","domain":"www.thelightphone.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["electronics"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2015,"candidateMonth":"2021-08","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":9.613,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":240,"evidenceRank":19,"evidenceScore":75.9,"freshAt":"2021-08-14T21:15:33Z","freshnessRank":1262,"freshEventScore":119,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 240 pts / 277 comments (2020) + 13 pts / 8 comments (2015), different submitters and 1,683 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9599142","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10972904","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16356013","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20951777","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":240,"peak_comments":277,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21943649","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":119,"peak_comments":157,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28184006","height":6,"chart_height":84},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37969119","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39135293","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42585204","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":null,"path":"/hall/link/the-light-phone-d9d023504809/"},{"slug":"radicle-is-an-open-source-peer-to-peer-code-collaboration-stack-d9d0235b6916","title":"Radicle is an open source, peer-to-peer code collaboration stack built on Git","domain":"radicle.xyz","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source","distributed_systems","cryptography"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2026-01","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":26,"submitters":24,"spanYears":7.379,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":286,"evidenceRank":20,"evidenceScore":75.3,"freshAt":"2026-01-23T13:25:42Z","freshnessRank":66,"freshEventScore":286,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 286 pts / 144 comments (2026) + 39 pts / 4 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,880 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 26 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 24 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17937376","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":7,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19888140","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":39,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25253407","height":4,"chart_height":23},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32558266","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":4,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38673264","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":7,"peak_score":155,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40166736","height":7,"chart_height":92},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46101277","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":286,"peak_comments":144,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46732213","height":14,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/radicle-is-an-open-source-peer-to-peer-code-collaboration-stack-d9d0235b6916.jpg","path":"/hall/link/radicle-is-an-open-source-peer-to-peer-code-collaboration-stack-d9d0235b6916/"},{"slug":"how-to-write-a-lisp-interpreter-in-python-d9d02341ab95","title":"(How to Write a (Lisp) Interpreter (in Python))","domain":"norvig.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["compilers_runtimes","programming_languages"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2014-05","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":16,"submitters":14,"spanYears":15.723,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":222,"evidenceRank":21,"evidenceScore":75.1,"freshAt":"2022-02-23T17:48:17Z","freshnessRank":1137,"freshEventScore":66,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 222 pts / 39 comments (2010) + 144 pts / 41 comments (2014), different submitters and 1,338 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":222,"peak_comments":39,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1745322","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2275085","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":144,"peak_comments":41,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7825054","height":7,"chart_height":110},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":4,"peak_score":130,"peak_comments":28,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12777852","height":6,"chart_height":100},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14397620","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17787469","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":132,"peak_comments":29,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20590439","height":6,"chart_height":101},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27064669","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":66,"peak_comments":9,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30443949","height":4,"chart_height":51},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48619831","height":4,"chart_height":11}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/how-to-write-a-lisp-interpreter-in-python-d9d02341ab95.jpg","path":"/hall/link/how-to-write-a-lisp-interpreter-in-python-d9d02341ab95/"},{"slug":"harry-potter-and-the-methods-of-rationality-just-got-several-fas-d9d02344ebae","title":"Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality just got several fascinating updates","domain":"hpmor.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"book_longform","typeDisplay":"Books & long-form works","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["books_literature"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2014-07","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":17,"submitters":16,"spanYears":10.56,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":163,"evidenceRank":22,"evidenceScore":75.1,"freshAt":"2021-03-07T14:23:42Z","freshnessRank":1354,"freshEventScore":26,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 163 pts / 127 comments (2014) + 26 pts / 3 comments (2021), different submitters and 2,423 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3697672","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":125,"peak_comments":99,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5976609","height":6,"chart_height":130},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":163,"peak_comments":127,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8053606","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9002960","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11720347","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":24,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17754285","height":4,"chart_height":25},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21617527","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22466862","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":26,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26376034","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32267983","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/harry-potter-and-the-methods-of-rationality-just-got-several-fas-d9d02344ebae.jpg","path":"/hall/link/harry-potter-and-the-methods-of-rationality-just-got-several-fas-d9d02344ebae/"},{"slug":"learn-x-in-y-minutes-d9d02349d44e","title":"Learn X in Y Minutes","domain":"learnxinyminutes.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","developer_tools"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2016-11","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":26,"submitters":26,"spanYears":13.005,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":241,"evidenceRank":23,"evidenceScore":75.0,"freshAt":"2023-08-19T00:30:23Z","freshnessRank":726,"freshEventScore":60,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 241 pts / 50 comments (2021) + 161 pts / 22 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,846 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 26 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 26 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5952101","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7687719","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":126,"peak_comments":18,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9440679","height":6,"chart_height":89},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":161,"peak_comments":22,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12999284","height":8,"chart_height":114},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16861273","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20169364","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":8,"peak_score":241,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29518955","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":60,"peak_comments":15,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37184077","height":4,"chart_height":42},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":4,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48449065","height":4,"chart_height":5}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/learn-x-in-y-minutes-d9d02349d44e.jpg","path":"/hall/link/learn-x-in-y-minutes-d9d02349d44e/"},{"slug":"a-stick-figure-guide-to-the-advanced-encryption-standard-aes-d9d0233ffddb","title":"A Stick Figure Guide to the Advanced Encryption Standard (AES)","domain":"www.moserware.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2011-11","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":24,"submitters":16,"spanYears":14.437,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":267,"evidenceRank":24,"evidenceScore":74.7,"freshAt":"2022-02-03T02:21:04Z","freshnessRank":1152,"freshEventScore":70,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 267 pts / 24 comments (2011) + 137 pts / 8 comments (2013), different submitters and 744 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 24 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":178,"peak_comments":8,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=836761","height":9,"chart_height":113},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":267,"peak_comments":24,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2898718","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3547105","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":137,"peak_comments":8,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6307517","height":7,"chart_height":87},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10706623","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12579111","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":5,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13903584","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":83,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16722368","height":4,"chart_height":53},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22854597","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27849426","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":70,"peak_comments":14,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30187633","height":4,"chart_height":45},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39548388","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-stick-figure-guide-to-the-advanced-encryption-standard-aes-d9d0233ffddb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-stick-figure-guide-to-the-advanced-encryption-standard-aes-d9d0233ffddb/"},{"slug":"draw-a-math-symbol-and-get-the-corresponding-latex-code-d9d0233fb959","title":"Draw a math symbol and get the corresponding LaTeX code","domain":"detexify.kirelabs.org","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","information_retrieval"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2020-02","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":19,"submitters":18,"spanYears":16.671,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":193,"evidenceRank":25,"evidenceScore":74.5,"freshAt":"2023-11-14T23:56:20Z","freshnessRank":647,"freshEventScore":173,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 193 pts / 38 comments (2009) + 173 pts / 38 comments (2023), different submitters and 5,238 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 19 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 18 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":193,"peak_comments":38,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=700043","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":22,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1607964","height":4,"chart_height":19},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":46,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3251762","height":4,"chart_height":41},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4200849","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6903179","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8761278","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9928539","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":91,"peak_comments":15,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11155978","height":4,"chart_height":80},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17245138","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":144,"peak_comments":28,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22356361","height":7,"chart_height":127},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32835520","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":173,"peak_comments":38,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38271534","height":8,"chart_height":152},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47382002","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/draw-a-math-symbol-and-get-the-corresponding-latex-code-d9d0233fb959.jpg","path":"/hall/link/draw-a-math-symbol-and-get-the-corresponding-latex-code-d9d0233fb959/"},{"slug":"kivy-develop-multi-touch-enabled-python-apps-d9d02342df9f","title":"Kivy: Develop multi-touch enabled Python apps","domain":"kivy.org","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source","user_experience"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2014-08","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":16,"submitters":15,"spanYears":11.784,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":185,"evidenceRank":26,"evidenceScore":74.5,"freshAt":"2020-12-20T06:48:58Z","freshnessRank":1402,"freshEventScore":177,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 185 pts / 45 comments (2016) + 177 pts / 55 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,614 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2743730","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":3,"peak_score":107,"peak_comments":23,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4601016","height":5,"chart_height":98},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5984567","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":154,"peak_comments":47,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8181306","height":7,"chart_height":142},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9025744","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":185,"peak_comments":45,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12127158","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14288156","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17496023","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":177,"peak_comments":55,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25484451","height":8,"chart_height":163},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33668761","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34333922","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/kivy-develop-multi-touch-enabled-python-apps-d9d02342df9f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/kivy-develop-multi-touch-enabled-python-apps-d9d02342df9f/"},{"slug":"a-mathematician-s-lament-2002-pdf-d9d0234cd33d","title":"A Mathematician’s Lament (2002) [pdf] ","domain":"www.maa.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["teaching","mathematics","children_parenting"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2014,"candidateMonth":"2017-05","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":27,"submitters":22,"spanYears":9.013,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":170,"evidenceRank":27,"evidenceScore":74.0,"freshAt":"2023-05-13T15:31:42Z","freshnessRank":819,"freshEventScore":132,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 170 pts / 89 comments (2015) + 159 pts / 27 comments (2017), different submitters and 857 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 27 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 22 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8711638","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":170,"peak_comments":89,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8845507","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11925532","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":5,"peak_score":159,"peak_comments":27,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14331752","height":8,"chart_height":159},{"year":2018,"count":3,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18472970","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21847333","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22807023","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":5,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28896695","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":4,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33104251","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":132,"peak_comments":47,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35929333","height":6,"chart_height":132},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/a-mathematician-s-lament-2002-pdf-d9d0234cd33d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/a-mathematician-s-lament-2002-pdf-d9d0234cd33d/"},{"slug":"the-fable-of-the-dragon-tyrant-2005-d9d0233f1e85","title":"The Fable of the Dragon-Tyrant (2005)","domain":"www.nickbostrom.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"medicine_health","topicDisplay":"Medicine & health","tags":["medicine","technology_ethics"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2020-10","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":19,"submitters":18,"spanYears":12.964,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":81,"evidenceRank":28,"evidenceScore":73.9,"freshAt":"2021-12-05T00:22:30Z","freshnessRank":1189,"freshEventScore":61,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 61 pts / 91 comments (2020) + 81 pts / 71 comments (2018), different submitters and 899 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 19 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 18 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=402205","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":72,"peak_comments":25,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=656713","height":4,"chart_height":151},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2184054","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":19,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5694725","height":4,"chart_height":40},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8426908","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":57,"peak_comments":38,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9559360","height":4,"chart_height":120},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15518781","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":4,"peak_score":81,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16945915","height":4,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":61,"peak_comments":91,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24770566","height":4,"chart_height":128},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":61,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29445605","height":4,"chart_height":128},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-fable-of-the-dragon-tyrant-2005-d9d0233f1e85.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-fable-of-the-dragon-tyrant-2005-d9d0233f1e85/"},{"slug":"design-principles-behind-smalltalk-1981-d9d0233fb4c6","title":"Design Principles Behind Smalltalk (1981)","domain":"www.cs.virginia.edu","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","software_architecture","human_computer_interaction"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2020-06","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":17,"submitters":17,"spanYears":14.804,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":194,"evidenceRank":29,"evidenceScore":73.7,"freshAt":"2023-12-31T03:36:01Z","freshnessRank":611,"freshEventScore":74,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 194 pts / 87 comments (2020) + 114 pts / 53 comments (2017), different submitters and 1,218 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=690742","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":27,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1643098","height":4,"chart_height":24},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3476051","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":61,"peak_comments":38,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9689800","height":4,"chart_height":53},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12628807","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":114,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13611222","height":5,"chart_height":100},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":81,"peak_comments":30,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17825747","height":4,"chart_height":71},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":194,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23496800","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28446296","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":101,"peak_comments":82,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31448395","height":5,"chart_height":89},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":74,"peak_comments":11,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38821506","height":4,"chart_height":65},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40173986","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/design-principles-behind-smalltalk-1981-d9d0233fb4c6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/design-principles-behind-smalltalk-1981-d9d0233fb4c6/"},{"slug":"pipe-operator-for-javascript-d9d02357c545","title":"Pipe Operator (|>) For JavaScript","domain":"github.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"standard_specification","typeDisplay":"Standards & specifications","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","web_development","open_source"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2023-01","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":8.654,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":309,"evidenceRank":30,"evidenceScore":73.6,"freshAt":"2023-01-20T15:15:31Z","freshnessRank":891,"freshEventScore":309,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 309 pts / 426 comments (2023) + 5 pts / 0 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,516 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14926995","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18532485","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20583280","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":155,"peak_comments":180,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28916775","height":7,"chart_height":85},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":309,"peak_comments":426,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34454184","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47581458","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/pipe-operator-for-javascript-d9d02357c545.jpg","path":"/hall/link/pipe-operator-for-javascript-d9d02357c545/"},{"slug":"god-s-number-is-20-2010-d9d0234164df","title":"God's Number is 20 (2010)","domain":"cube20.org","category":"research","categoryDisplay":"Research & data","type":"technical_report","typeDisplay":"Technical reports","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","algorithms_data_structures"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2013-10","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":15.74,"breakoutYears":5,"maxScore":276,"evidenceRank":31,"evidenceScore":73.3,"freshAt":"2023-03-16T13:30:32Z","freshnessRank":858,"freshEventScore":34,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 276 pts / 61 comments (2010) + 259 pts / 56 comments (2016), different submitters and 2,322 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":276,"peak_comments":61,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1587340","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3921215","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":177,"peak_comments":35,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6574178","height":8,"chart_height":109},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":131,"peak_comments":47,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7374994","height":6,"chart_height":81},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":259,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13201910","height":12,"chart_height":160},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":152,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19680372","height":7,"chart_height":94},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":34,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35181695","height":4,"chart_height":21},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43886910","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48039363","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/god-s-number-is-20-2010-d9d0234164df.jpg","path":"/hall/link/god-s-number-is-20-2010-d9d0234164df/"},{"slug":"let-s-build-a-compiler-1995-d9d0233e3176","title":"Let’s Build a Compiler (1995)","domain":"compilers.iecc.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["compilers_runtimes"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2007,"candidateMonth":"2013-10","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":18.598,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":247,"evidenceRank":32,"evidenceScore":73.2,"freshAt":"2023-12-26T16:18:33Z","freshnessRank":618,"freshEventScore":124,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 247 pts / 56 comments (2013) + 240 pts / 41 comments (2020), different submitters and 2,300 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":1,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=63004","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":196,"peak_comments":17,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1727004","height":9,"chart_height":135},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2368594","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":247,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6641117","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9496335","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11673032","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19324588","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":240,"peak_comments":41,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22346532","height":12,"chart_height":165},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31340479","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":124,"peak_comments":15,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38773049","height":6,"chart_height":85},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48083509","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/let-s-build-a-compiler-1995-d9d0233e3176.jpg","path":"/hall/link/let-s-build-a-compiler-1995-d9d0233e3176/"},{"slug":"five-hundred-and-seven-mechanical-movements-1908-d9d023498fcb","title":"Five Hundred and Seven Mechanical Movements (1908)","domain":"507movements.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["manufacturing","product_design","history"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2021-03","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":13.12,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":798,"evidenceRank":33,"evidenceScore":72.9,"freshAt":"2024-09-18T13:17:28Z","freshnessRank":388,"freshEventScore":41,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 798 pts / 147 comments (2019) + 41 pts / 5 comments (2024), different submitters and 1,947 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5800217","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8019787","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15158711","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":798,"peak_comments":147,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19968114","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":159,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26373539","height":8,"chart_height":34},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32345799","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":41,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41579354","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47294270","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/five-hundred-and-seven-mechanical-movements-1908-d9d023498fcb.jpg","path":"/hall/link/five-hundred-and-seven-mechanical-movements-1908-d9d023498fcb/"},{"slug":"benford-s-law-d9d0233e5058","title":"Benford's Law","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics","data_science"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2020-02","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":35,"submitters":33,"spanYears":18.357,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":145,"evidenceRank":34,"evidenceScore":72.8,"freshAt":"2020-02-15T23:24:28Z","freshnessRank":1522,"freshEventScore":145,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 145 pts / 93 comments (2020) + 107 pts / 44 comments (2017), different submitters and 818 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 35 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 33 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=100540","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=662386","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":25,"peak_comments":32,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1429336","height":4,"chart_height":29},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6326583","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":5,"peak_score":56,"peak_comments":19,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7794190","height":4,"chart_height":66},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10152441","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11998119","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":107,"peak_comments":44,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15732971","height":5,"chart_height":125},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21008892","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":145,"peak_comments":93,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22338755","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27827858","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33514400","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37864013","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2024,"count":4,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40880189","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48297653","height":4,"chart_height":5}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/benford-s-law-d9d0233e5058.jpg","path":"/hall/link/benford-s-law-d9d0233e5058/"},{"slug":"online-encyclopedia-of-integer-sequences-d9d0234237bc","title":"Online Encyclopedia of Integer Sequences","domain":"oeis.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2024-04","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":35,"submitters":33,"spanYears":15.493,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":232,"evidenceRank":35,"evidenceScore":72.8,"freshAt":"2024-04-04T02:09:01Z","freshnessRank":524,"freshEventScore":232,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 232 pts / 50 comments (2024) + 160 pts / 31 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,082 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 35 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 33 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2057842","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3668115","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":72,"peak_comments":20,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6650490","height":4,"chart_height":53},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6999681","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":63,"peak_comments":19,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9919535","height":4,"chart_height":46},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":5,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15900294","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18524115","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":80,"peak_comments":28,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21366618","height":4,"chart_height":59},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":160,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26848517","height":8,"chart_height":117},{"year":2022,"count":5,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33873137","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":4,"peak_score":16,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37041585","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":232,"peak_comments":50,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39925787","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45086274","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46919940","height":4,"chart_height":5}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/online-encyclopedia-of-integer-sequences-d9d0234237bc.jpg","path":"/hall/link/online-encyclopedia-of-integer-sequences-d9d0234237bc/"},{"slug":"german-tank-problem-d9d0233faa15","title":"German tank problem","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["mathematics"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2014-02","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":27,"submitters":27,"spanYears":16.961,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":231,"evidenceRank":36,"evidenceScore":72.8,"freshAt":"2023-11-26T00:10:19Z","freshnessRank":640,"freshEventScore":39,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 231 pts / 83 comments (2014) + 103 pts / 18 comments (2009), different submitters and 1,704 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 27 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 27 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":103,"peak_comments":18,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=670218","height":5,"chart_height":76},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":28,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2280807","height":4,"chart_height":21},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6861870","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":231,"peak_comments":83,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7278198","height":11,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9533499","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":4,"peak_score":64,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13095178","height":4,"chart_height":47},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17378337","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21533153","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23590459","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":4,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33771909","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":5,"peak_score":39,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38418034","height":4,"chart_height":29},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":3,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47189922","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/german-tank-problem-d9d0233faa15.jpg","path":"/hall/link/german-tank-problem-d9d0233faa15/"},{"slug":"list-of-emerging-technologies-d9d0233eed9d","title":"List of Emerging Technologies","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["technology_ethics"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2021-04","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":25,"submitters":24,"spanYears":17.435,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":162,"evidenceRank":37,"evidenceScore":72.8,"freshAt":"2021-04-16T18:00:58Z","freshnessRank":1328,"freshEventScore":162,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 162 pts / 44 comments (2021) + 160 pts / 15 comments (2019), different submitters and 768 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 25 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 24 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=325993","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1700473","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3147262","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":78,"peak_comments":41,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3987566","height":4,"chart_height":82},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6337800","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7367258","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9733938","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12932625","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15183067","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16367734","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":160,"peak_comments":15,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19349518","height":8,"chart_height":168},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25402400","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":162,"peak_comments":44,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26837152","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38198850","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47390202","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/list-of-emerging-technologies-d9d0233eed9d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/list-of-emerging-technologies-d9d0233eed9d/"},{"slug":"free-for-developers-d9d0235d0184","title":"Free for Developers","domain":"free-for.dev","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","open_source"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2021-04","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":14,"submitters":13,"spanYears":6.543,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":967,"evidenceRank":38,"evidenceScore":72.8,"freshAt":"2022-07-19T13:37:31Z","freshnessRank":1020,"freshEventScore":137,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 235 pts / 24 comments (2019) + 137 pts / 34 comments (2022), different submitters and 1,004 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":235,"peak_comments":24,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21293397","height":11,"chart_height":41},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":967,"peak_comments":197,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26239711","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":5,"peak_score":137,"peak_comments":34,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32151216","height":7,"chart_height":24},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40028051","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45247017","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/free-for-developers-d9d0235d0184.jpg","path":"/hall/link/free-for-developers-d9d0235d0184/"},{"slug":"does-visual-studio-rot-the-mind-2005-d9d0233f164c","title":"Does Visual Studio Rot the Mind? (2005)","domain":"charlespetzold.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2008,"candidateMonth":"2022-01","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":8,"submitters":8,"spanYears":14.182,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":108,"evidenceRank":39,"evidenceScore":72.7,"freshAt":"2022-01-01T16:52:26Z","freshnessRank":1170,"freshEventScore":98,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 98 pts / 143 comments (2022) + 30 pts / 37 comments (2008), different submitters and 4,774 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":1,"peak_score":30,"peak_comments":37,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=387495","height":4,"chart_height":47},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3386102","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4214236","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8115319","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":108,"peak_comments":118,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22258198","height":5,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28833552","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":98,"peak_comments":143,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29760171","height":5,"chart_height":154},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34742334","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/does-visual-studio-rot-the-mind-2005-d9d0233f164c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/does-visual-studio-rot-the-mind-2005-d9d0233f164c/"},{"slug":"buffalo-buffalo-buffalo-buffalo-buffalo-buffalo-buffalo-buffalo-d9d023408033","title":"Buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["language_linguistics"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2023-09","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":24,"submitters":24,"spanYears":16.112,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":178,"evidenceRank":40,"evidenceScore":72.6,"freshAt":"2023-09-07T21:26:33Z","freshnessRank":706,"freshEventScore":178,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 178 pts / 96 comments (2023) + 174 pts / 69 comments (2010), different submitters and 4,964 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 24 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 24 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":174,"peak_comments":69,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1097258","height":8,"chart_height":166},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3340300","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4773341","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6785788","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":52,"peak_comments":17,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11654975","height":4,"chart_height":50},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15477788","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18391960","height":4,"chart_height":17},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19025117","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":29,"peak_comments":19,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22288372","height":4,"chart_height":28},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28144370","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29950479","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":4,"peak_score":178,"peak_comments":96,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37425842","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":19,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43213767","height":4,"chart_height":18},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":14,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47394684","height":4,"chart_height":13}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/buffalo-buffalo-buffalo-buffalo-buffalo-buffalo-buffalo-buffalo-d9d023408033.jpg","path":"/hall/link/buffalo-buffalo-buffalo-buffalo-buffalo-buffalo-buffalo-buffalo-d9d023408033/"},{"slug":"scunthorpe-problem-d9d02341e920","title":"Scunthorpe Problem","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["online_communities"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2023-04","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":25,"submitters":24,"spanYears":14.322,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":71,"evidenceRank":41,"evidenceScore":72.6,"freshAt":"2023-04-13T10:47:21Z","freshnessRank":840,"freshEventScore":51,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 71 pts / 59 comments (2017) + 51 pts / 55 comments (2023), different submitters and 2,198 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 25 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 24 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1893733","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4907311","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5569383","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7098362","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":71,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14041207","height":4,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":51,"peak_comments":48,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18467719","height":4,"chart_height":122},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":6,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24988006","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2021,"count":6,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29331820","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33014433","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":51,"peak_comments":55,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35553514","height":4,"chart_height":122},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43300344","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/scunthorpe-problem-d9d02341e920.jpg","path":"/hall/link/scunthorpe-problem-d9d02341e920/"},{"slug":"ever-expanding-animation-of-the-life-of-the-796th-floor-of-a-spa-d9d0236a4475","title":"Ever-expanding animation of the life of the 796th floor of a space station","domain":"floor796.com","category":"media","categoryDisplay":"Audio, video & images","type":"image_comic","typeDisplay":"Images & comics","topic":"culture_media","topicDisplay":"Culture & media","tags":["internet_culture","film_television"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2022,"candidateMonth":"2025-07","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":11,"submitters":11,"spanYears":3.129,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":1066,"evidenceRank":42,"evidenceScore":72.6,"freshAt":"2024-05-18T17:50:10Z","freshnessRank":477,"freshEventScore":533,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 1066 pts / 118 comments (2023) + 7 pts / 3 comments (2025), different submitters and 876 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":4,"peak_score":771,"peak_comments":88,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33612401","height":24,"chart_height":123},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":1066,"peak_comments":118,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35510067","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":533,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40400648","height":24,"chart_height":85},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45104402","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/ever-expanding-animation-of-the-life-of-the-796th-floor-of-a-spa-d9d0236a4475.jpg","path":"/hall/link/ever-expanding-animation-of-the-life-of-the-796th-floor-of-a-spa-d9d0236a4475/"},{"slug":"gallery-of-processor-cache-effects-d9d023407ec6","title":"Gallery of Processor Cache Effects","domain":"igoro.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["computer_architecture","performance_reliability"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2014-12","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":13,"submitters":12,"spanYears":16.101,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":153,"evidenceRank":43,"evidenceScore":72.5,"freshAt":"2023-07-14T11:58:44Z","freshnessRank":761,"freshEventScore":153,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 153 pts / 37 comments (2023) + 150 pts / 36 comments (2019), different submitters and 1,570 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":128,"peak_comments":23,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1094797","height":6,"chart_height":142},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2209979","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4382148","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":119,"peak_comments":15,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8778990","height":6,"chart_height":132},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":4,"peak_score":150,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19492424","height":7,"chart_height":167},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":153,"peak_comments":37,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36722587","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42578665","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47333026","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/gallery-of-processor-cache-effects-d9d023407ec6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/gallery-of-processor-cache-effects-d9d023407ec6/"},{"slug":"nuke-map-interactive-nuclear-bomb-map-d9d023455786","title":"Nuke Map: Interactive Nuclear Bomb Map","domain":"nuclearsecrecy.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["physics","geopolitics"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2020-05","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":28,"submitters":27,"spanYears":14.031,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":160,"evidenceRank":44,"evidenceScore":72.5,"freshAt":"2022-03-01T17:14:14Z","freshnessRank":1128,"freshEventScore":24,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 160 pts / 87 comments (2017) + 156 pts / 74 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,024 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 28 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 27 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3618590","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6667422","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7890015","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10103165","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13197899","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":160,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14975863","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":156,"peak_comments":74,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23365823","height":7,"chart_height":166},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29503006","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":24,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30516807","height":4,"chart_height":26},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39510024","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2025,"count":3,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44327047","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46891865","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/nuke-map-interactive-nuclear-bomb-map-d9d023455786.jpg","path":"/hall/link/nuke-map-interactive-nuclear-bomb-map-d9d023455786/"},{"slug":"at-t-archives-the-unix-operating-system-video-1982-d9d023459f7f","title":"AT&T Archives: The Unix Operating System [video] (1982)","domain":"www.youtube.com","category":"media","categoryDisplay":"Audio, video & images","type":"video","typeDisplay":"Video","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["operating_systems","history"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2021-08","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":52,"submitters":51,"spanYears":13.969,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":143,"evidenceRank":45,"evidenceScore":72.5,"freshAt":"2021-08-28T07:06:25Z","freshnessRank":1255,"freshEventScore":143,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 63 pts / 21 comments (2014) + 143 pts / 28 comments (2021), different submitters and 2,644 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 52 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 51 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":5,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4483029","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2013,"count":5,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5196196","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2014,"count":7,"peak_score":63,"peak_comments":21,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7830478","height":4,"chart_height":75},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9281449","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12625837","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13945354","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":5,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16810226","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19550551","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2020,"count":11,"peak_score":105,"peak_comments":29,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23343753","height":5,"chart_height":125},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":143,"peak_comments":28,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28336192","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34167279","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":4,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37841620","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39893396","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45954133","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47361680","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/at-t-archives-the-unix-operating-system-video-1982-d9d023459f7f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/at-t-archives-the-unix-operating-system-video-1982-d9d023459f7f/"},{"slug":"m-nchhausen-trilemma-d9d0234a5a2f","title":"Münchhausen trilemma","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"history_humanities","topicDisplay":"History & humanities","tags":["philosophy"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2020-03","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":12.285,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":156,"evidenceRank":46,"evidenceScore":72.4,"freshAt":"2020-03-19T03:02:24Z","freshnessRank":1513,"freshEventScore":138,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 138 pts / 128 comments (2020) + 8 pts / 0 comments (2023), different submitters and 1,184 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6260369","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9343839","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":156,"peak_comments":77,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17043954","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21103852","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":138,"peak_comments":128,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22623980","height":7,"chart_height":150},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32703769","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36358646","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40149335","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46154852","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/m-nchhausen-trilemma-d9d0234a5a2f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/m-nchhausen-trilemma-d9d0234a5a2f/"},{"slug":"moravec-s-paradox-d9d02347f1f4","title":"Moravec's paradox","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"ai_data","topicDisplay":"AI & data","tags":["artificial_intelligence"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2019-08","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":33,"submitters":32,"spanYears":13.602,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":188,"evidenceRank":47,"evidenceScore":72.4,"freshAt":"2019-08-15T00:36:19Z","freshnessRank":1585,"freshEventScore":155,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 155 pts / 87 comments (2019) + 188 pts / 43 comments (2012), different submitters and 2,434 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 33 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 32 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":188,"peak_comments":43,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4923299","height":9,"chart_height":170},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":17,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8006105","height":4,"chart_height":15},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10111549","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":30,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11048941","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15668932","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":30,"peak_comments":6,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16891191","height":4,"chart_height":27},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":155,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20701480","height":7,"chart_height":140},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27042393","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32087053","height":4,"chart_height":16},{"year":2023,"count":4,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36270601","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2024,"count":6,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40199147","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":5,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45141920","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2026,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48390591","height":4,"chart_height":5}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/moravec-s-paradox-d9d02347f1f4.jpg","path":"/hall/link/moravec-s-paradox-d9d02347f1f4/"},{"slug":"starship-a-minimal-fast-and-customizable-prompt-for-any-shell-d9d0235ef658","title":"Starship: A minimal, fast, and customizable prompt for any shell","domain":"starship.rs","category":"software","categoryDisplay":"Software & code","type":"software_project","typeDisplay":"Software projects","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools","programming_languages","open_source"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2019,"candidateMonth":"2025-06","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":14,"submitters":13,"spanYears":5.769,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":465,"evidenceRank":48,"evidenceScore":72.3,"freshAt":"2025-06-24T11:11:52Z","freshnessRank":221,"freshEventScore":465,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 465 pts / 211 comments (2025) + 69 pts / 14 comments (2019), different submitters and 2,107 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 6 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":69,"peak_comments":14,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20990076","height":4,"chart_height":25},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25563486","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":7,"peak_score":48,"peak_comments":7,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29463507","height":4,"chart_height":18},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36633102","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":174,"peak_comments":155,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39133612","height":8,"chart_height":64},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":465,"peak_comments":211,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44364874","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/starship-a-minimal-fast-and-customizable-prompt-for-any-shell-d9d0235ef658.jpg","path":"/hall/link/starship-a-minimal-fast-and-customizable-prompt-for-any-shell-d9d0235ef658/"},{"slug":"what-is-the-best-comment-in-source-code-you-have-ever-encountere-d9d0233f7261","title":"What is the best comment in source code you have ever encountered? (2011)","domain":"stackoverflow.com","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"forum_discussion","typeDisplay":"Forum discussions","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2013-09","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":22,"submitters":22,"spanYears":16.728,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":157,"evidenceRank":49,"evidenceScore":72.3,"freshAt":"2013-09-19T09:35:45Z","freshnessRank":1957,"freshEventScore":157,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 157 pts / 95 comments (2013) + 127 pts / 46 comments (2010), different submitters and 1,098 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 22 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 22 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=555201","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":127,"peak_comments":46,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1699760","height":6,"chart_height":138},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2566782","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4838161","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":4,"peak_score":157,"peak_comments":95,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6410682","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9242078","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12680071","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16141811","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19714407","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21934637","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":19,"peak_comments":10,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28796887","height":4,"chart_height":21},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38682208","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46442687","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/what-is-the-best-comment-in-source-code-you-have-ever-encountere-d9d0233f7261.jpg","path":"/hall/link/what-is-the-best-comment-in-source-code-you-have-ever-encountere-d9d0233f7261/"},{"slug":"swatch-internet-time-d9d0233f606d","title":"Swatch Internet Time","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["internet_infrastructure"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2018-02","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":22,"submitters":21,"spanYears":17.153,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":103,"evidenceRank":50,"evidenceScore":72.3,"freshAt":"2024-04-14T22:33:03Z","freshnessRank":511,"freshEventScore":61,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 103 pts / 96 comments (2014) + 86 pts / 78 comments (2018), different submitters and 1,484 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 22 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 21 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":28,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=520004","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":103,"peak_comments":96,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7046178","height":5,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15583914","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":86,"peak_comments":78,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16307725","height":4,"chart_height":142},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21561156","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":6,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22528768","height":4,"chart_height":7},{"year":2021,"count":4,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29564119","height":4,"chart_height":13},{"year":2022,"count":3,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31642887","height":4,"chart_height":12},{"year":2023,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34523860","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":61,"peak_comments":39,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40035084","height":4,"chart_height":101},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48114397","height":4,"chart_height":12}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/swatch-internet-time-d9d0233f606d.jpg","path":"/hall/link/swatch-internet-time-d9d0233f606d/"},{"slug":"microjs-d9d023431971","title":"Microjs","domain":"microjs.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["web_development","developer_tools"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2011,"candidateMonth":"2014-07","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":13.243,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":274,"evidenceRank":51,"evidenceScore":72.2,"freshAt":"2024-07-30T01:16:23Z","freshnessRank":427,"freshEventScore":274,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 274 pts / 60 comments (2024) + 139 pts / 23 comments (2014), different submitters and 3,665 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":45,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2729322","height":4,"chart_height":28},{"year":2012,"count":4,"peak_score":104,"peak_comments":26,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3717231","height":5,"chart_height":65},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5407303","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":139,"peak_comments":23,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8046505","height":7,"chart_height":86},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11071273","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18387004","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19421046","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":73,"peak_comments":22,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33144206","height":4,"chart_height":45},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":274,"peak_comments":60,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41105261","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/microjs-d9d023431971.jpg","path":"/hall/link/microjs-d9d023431971/"},{"slug":"the-raft-consensus-algorithm-2015-d9d02353a374","title":"The Raft Consensus Algorithm (2015)","domain":"raft.github.io","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["distributed_systems","algorithms_data_structures"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2025-08","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":15,"submitters":13,"spanYears":9.232,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":343,"evidenceRank":52,"evidenceScore":72.0,"freshAt":"2025-08-13T09:09:34Z","freshnessRank":186,"freshEventScore":171,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 343 pts / 76 comments (2023) + 7 pts / 0 comments (2016), different submitters and 2,503 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12789488","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15648266","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16070267","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20625728","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22458172","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25890873","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":343,"peak_comments":76,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37369826","height":16,"chart_height":170},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":171,"peak_comments":45,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44886202","height":8,"chart_height":85},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-raft-consensus-algorithm-2015-d9d02353a374.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-raft-consensus-algorithm-2015-d9d02353a374/"},{"slug":"git-cheatsheet-visualization-d9d02341a601","title":"Git Cheatsheet (Visualization)","domain":"www.ndpsoftware.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["developer_tools"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2013-11","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":12.364,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":255,"evidenceRank":53,"evidenceScore":71.9,"freshAt":"2023-02-07T05:44:52Z","freshnessRank":882,"freshEventScore":26,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 255 pts / 21 comments (2011) + 225 pts / 53 comments (2013), different submitters and 934 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1733955","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":255,"peak_comments":21,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2461700","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2012,"count":3,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3514272","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":225,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6695648","height":11,"chart_height":150},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7267819","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":179,"peak_comments":33,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17987033","height":9,"chart_height":119},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20768405","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":191,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28578896","height":9,"chart_height":127},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":26,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34689188","height":4,"chart_height":17},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/git-cheatsheet-visualization-d9d02341a601.jpg","path":"/hall/link/git-cheatsheet-visualization-d9d02341a601/"},{"slug":"roadmap-to-becoming-a-web-developer-in-2017-d9d023566ca6","title":"Roadmap to becoming a web developer in 2017","domain":"github.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["learning_methods","careers","web_development"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-12","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":13,"submitters":13,"spanYears":8.745,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":261,"evidenceRank":54,"evidenceScore":71.9,"freshAt":"2019-01-10T14:29:14Z","freshnessRank":1645,"freshEventScore":255,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 255 pts / 130 comments (2019) + 2 pts / 0 comments (2021), different submitters and 1,064 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":9,"peak_score":261,"peak_comments":108,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13970781","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":255,"peak_comments":130,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18874028","height":12,"chart_height":166},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29502531","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46242270","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/roadmap-to-becoming-a-web-developer-in-2017-d9d023566ca6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/roadmap-to-becoming-a-web-developer-in-2017-d9d023566ca6/"},{"slug":"micromort-d9d023403eb6","title":"Micromort","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"medicine_health","topicDisplay":"Medicine & health","tags":["public_health"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2020-06","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":20,"submitters":20,"spanYears":15.989,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":173,"evidenceRank":55,"evidenceScore":71.9,"freshAt":"2020-06-19T00:18:25Z","freshnessRank":1479,"freshEventScore":152,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 173 pts / 99 comments (2013) + 152 pts / 72 comments (2020), different submitters and 2,491 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 20 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=965045","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3706043","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":173,"peak_comments":99,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6266462","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10641107","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12223419","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15122733","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19728523","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":152,"peak_comments":72,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23569648","height":7,"chart_height":149},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29220988","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":4,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37269239","height":4,"chart_height":15},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46030044","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/micromort-d9d023403eb6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/micromort-d9d023403eb6/"},{"slug":"need-to-refresh-your-math-skills-from-basic-algebra-to-calculus-d9d0233fcb79","title":"Need to refresh your math skills? From basic algebra to calculus and beyond.","domain":"www.khanacademy.org","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"course_lecture","typeDisplay":"Courses & lectures","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["teaching"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2009,"candidateMonth":"2011-11","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":11.943,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":344,"evidenceRank":56,"evidenceScore":71.8,"freshAt":"2011-11-01T16:41:56Z","freshnessRank":1989,"freshEventScore":307,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 307 pts / 181 comments (2011) + 12 pts / 0 comments (2009), different submitters and 732 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":2,"peak_score":12,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=911882","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2010,"count":4,"peak_score":344,"peak_comments":70,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1058359","height":17,"chart_height":170},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":307,"peak_comments":181,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3182893","height":15,"chart_height":152},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5370136","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27784184","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/need-to-refresh-your-math-skills-from-basic-algebra-to-calculus-d9d0233fcb79.jpg","path":"/hall/link/need-to-refresh-your-math-skills-from-basic-algebra-to-calculus-d9d0233fcb79/"},{"slug":"c-is-best-d9d02359c921","title":"C Is Best","domain":"sqlite.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["programming_languages","performance_reliability","databases_storage"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2018,"candidateMonth":"2025-10","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":4,"submitters":4,"spanYears":7.817,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":408,"evidenceRank":57,"evidenceScore":71.8,"freshAt":"2026-01-06T12:33:54Z","freshnessRank":80,"freshEventScore":408,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 408 pts / 559 comments (2026) + 372 pts / 345 comments (2018), different submitters and 2,854 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":false,"detail":"Current: 4 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":372,"peak_comments":345,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16585120","height":18,"chart_height":155},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":127,"peak_comments":124,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28278859","height":6,"chart_height":53},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":357,"peak_comments":391,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45584464","height":17,"chart_height":149},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":408,"peak_comments":559,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46511470","height":20,"chart_height":170}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/c-is-best-d9d02359c921.jpg","path":"/hall/link/c-is-best-d9d02359c921/"},{"slug":"hckr-news-hacker-news-sorted-by-time-d9d02341a16f","title":"Hckr news – Hacker News sorted by time","domain":"hckrnews.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["online_communities"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2017-08","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":14,"submitters":13,"spanYears":15.614,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":168,"evidenceRank":58,"evidenceScore":71.6,"freshAt":"2022-10-03T21:35:32Z","freshnessRank":955,"freshEventScore":168,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 82 pts / 62 comments (2010) + 168 pts / 56 comments (2022), different submitters and 4,392 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 13 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":1,"peak_score":82,"peak_comments":62,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1722914","height":4,"chart_height":83},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5362223","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11523204","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":75,"peak_comments":53,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14962820","height":4,"chart_height":76},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18416111","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19285560","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":23,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22228071","height":4,"chart_height":23},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":168,"peak_comments":56,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33074025","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40675669","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44493461","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48036196","height":4,"chart_height":5}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/hckr-news-hacker-news-sorted-by-time-d9d02341a16f.jpg","path":"/hall/link/hckr-news-hacker-news-sorted-by-time-d9d02341a16f/"},{"slug":"wide-band-websdr-shortwave-radio-on-the-internet-d9d0234905c9","title":"Wide-Band WebSDR – Shortwave Radio on the Internet","domain":"websdr.ewi.utwente.nl","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"hardware_electronics","topicDisplay":"Hardware & electronics","tags":["electronics","internet_infrastructure","protocols_networking"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2020-03","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":16,"submitters":16,"spanYears":13.158,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":201,"evidenceRank":59,"evidenceScore":71.6,"freshAt":"2022-04-20T10:35:35Z","freshnessRank":1095,"freshEventScore":104,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 201 pts / 59 comments (2020) + 104 pts / 17 comments (2022), different submitters and 766 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5501103","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7935131","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":54,"peak_comments":17,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9574966","height":4,"chart_height":46},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":2,"peak_score":145,"peak_comments":36,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18566905","height":7,"chart_height":123},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":201,"peak_comments":59,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22579719","height":10,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":6,"peak_score":104,"peak_comments":17,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31094927","height":5,"chart_height":88},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45161713","height":4,"chart_height":15},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48376148","height":4,"chart_height":5}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/wide-band-websdr-shortwave-radio-on-the-internet-d9d0234905c9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/wide-band-websdr-shortwave-radio-on-the-internet-d9d0234905c9/"},{"slug":"listen-to-wikipedia-d9d0234a1be3","title":"Listen to Wikipedia","domain":"listen.hatnote.com","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"live_data_dashboard","typeDisplay":"Live-data dashboards","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["online_communities","data_engineering"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2020-12","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":27,"submitters":27,"spanYears":11.105,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":140,"evidenceRank":60,"evidenceScore":71.5,"freshAt":"2020-12-28T17:17:08Z","freshnessRank":1397,"freshEventScore":134,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 140 pts / 63 comments (2015) + 134 pts / 34 comments (2020), different submitters and 1,978 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 27 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 27 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":5,"peak_score":15,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6182576","height":4,"chart_height":18},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":68,"peak_comments":10,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8588576","height":4,"chart_height":83},{"year":2015,"count":4,"peak_score":140,"peak_comments":63,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9972781","height":7,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":5,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12674438","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13558025","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19779773","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":3,"peak_score":134,"peak_comments":34,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25560953","height":6,"chart_height":163},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31199676","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36960823","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41451598","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/listen-to-wikipedia-d9d0234a1be3.jpg","path":"/hall/link/listen-to-wikipedia-d9d0234a1be3/"},{"slug":"the-socratic-method-teaching-by-asking-instead-of-by-telling-d9d0233e2682","title":"The Socratic Method: Teaching by Asking Instead of by Telling","domain":"www.garlikov.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"tutorial_guide","typeDisplay":"Tutorials & guides","topic":"education_learning","topicDisplay":"Education & learning","tags":["teaching"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2007,"candidateMonth":"2015-04","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":11,"submitters":9,"spanYears":18.79,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":253,"evidenceRank":61,"evidenceScore":71.5,"freshAt":"2022-03-06T02:19:28Z","freshnessRank":1125,"freshEventScore":67,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 211 pts / 93 comments (2017) + 253 pts / 67 comments (2015), different submitters and 904 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":1,"peak_score":7,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47432","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":1,"peak_score":195,"peak_comments":31,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2446316","height":9,"chart_height":131},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":115,"peak_comments":24,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3578807","height":6,"chart_height":77},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6737563","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":253,"peak_comments":67,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9362252","height":12,"chart_height":170},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":211,"peak_comments":93,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15387434","height":10,"chart_height":142},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27721593","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":67,"peak_comments":5,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30574388","height":4,"chart_height":45},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43884646","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48507893","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/the-socratic-method-teaching-by-asking-instead-of-by-telling-d9d0233e2682.jpg","path":"/hall/link/the-socratic-method-teaching-by-asking-instead-of-by-telling-d9d0233e2682/"},{"slug":"wikihouse-open-source-modular-wood-based-zero-carbon-housing-d9d023481e7a","title":"WikiHouse – Open source, modular, wood based, zero carbon housing","domain":"www.wikihouse.cc","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"environment_energy","topicDisplay":"Environment & energy","tags":["climate_environment","cities_infrastructure","manufacturing"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2024-01","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":11.003,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":505,"evidenceRank":62,"evidenceScore":71.5,"freshAt":"2024-01-09T21:48:05Z","freshnessRank":601,"freshEventScore":494,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 505 pts / 278 comments (2022) + 4 pts / 0 comments (2013), different submitters and 3,530 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":5,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5019896","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8292645","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10070361","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":505,"peak_comments":278,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32748592","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":494,"peak_comments":209,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38932603","height":24,"chart_height":166},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/wikihouse-open-source-modular-wood-based-zero-carbon-housing-d9d023481e7a.jpg","path":"/hall/link/wikihouse-open-source-modular-wood-based-zero-carbon-housing-d9d023481e7a/"},{"slug":"show-hn-the-deadlock-empire-slay-dragons-master-concurrency-d9d02352910c","title":"Show HN: The Deadlock Empire – Slay dragons, master concurrency","domain":"deadlockempire.github.io","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"computer_game","typeDisplay":"Computer games","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["distributed_systems","programming_languages"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2016,"candidateMonth":"2019-03","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":16,"submitters":15,"spanYears":8.435,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":269,"evidenceRank":63,"evidenceScore":71.4,"freshAt":"2024-07-08T20:29:40Z","freshnessRank":439,"freshEventScore":216,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 269 pts / 30 comments (2016) + 216 pts / 41 comments (2024), different submitters and 3,072 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 16 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 15 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":2,"peak_score":269,"peak_comments":30,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11064507","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17587497","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":2,"peak_score":133,"peak_comments":4,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19411641","height":6,"chart_height":84},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":97,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22040117","height":5,"chart_height":61},{"year":2021,"count":5,"peak_score":150,"peak_comments":20,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29431308","height":7,"chart_height":95},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37665051","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":3,"peak_score":216,"peak_comments":41,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40909334","height":10,"chart_height":137},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/show-hn-the-deadlock-empire-slay-dragons-master-concurrency-d9d02352910c.jpg","path":"/hall/link/show-hn-the-deadlock-empire-slay-dragons-master-concurrency-d9d02352910c/"},{"slug":"ngrok-secure-tunnels-to-localhost-d9d02349d1e9","title":"Ngrok: Secure tunnels to localhost","domain":"ngrok.com","category":"sites","categoryDisplay":"Sites & organizations","type":"organization_product_site","typeDisplay":"Organization & product sites","topic":"web_internet","topicDisplay":"Web & internet","tags":["protocols_networking","internet_infrastructure","application_security"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2017-05","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":17,"submitters":17,"spanYears":8.621,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":468,"evidenceRank":64,"evidenceScore":71.4,"freshAt":"2017-05-06T04:40:38Z","freshnessRank":1780,"freshEventScore":468,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 468 pts / 187 comments (2017) + 66 pts / 35 comments (2013), different submitters and 1,409 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 17 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 5 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":5,"peak_score":66,"peak_comments":35,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5946981","height":4,"chart_height":24},{"year":2014,"count":5,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8179183","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":180,"peak_comments":40,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10077883","height":9,"chart_height":65},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":4,"peak_score":468,"peak_comments":187,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14278703","height":22,"chart_height":170},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30258630","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/ngrok-secure-tunnels-to-localhost-d9d02349d1e9.jpg","path":"/hall/link/ngrok-secure-tunnels-to-localhost-d9d02349d1e9/"},{"slug":"oh-my-god-particle-d9d0234921a7","title":"Oh-My-God particle","domain":"en.wikipedia.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"encyclopedia_entry","typeDisplay":"Encyclopedia entries","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["physics","space_astronomy"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2018-02","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":14,"submitters":14,"spanYears":12.498,"breakoutYears":3,"maxScore":165,"evidenceRank":65,"evidenceScore":71.3,"freshAt":"2023-10-06T14:32:14Z","freshnessRank":681,"freshEventScore":69,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 118 pts / 71 comments (2018) + 165 pts / 41 comments (2014), different submitters and 1,391 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 14 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 11 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":9,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5563907","height":4,"chart_height":9},{"year":2014,"count":1,"peak_score":165,"peak_comments":41,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7713057","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":11,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10717874","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14534174","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":118,"peak_comments":71,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16473966","height":6,"chart_height":122},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21846346","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28398123","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":6,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30325431","height":4,"chart_height":6},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":69,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37791298","height":4,"chart_height":71},{"year":2024,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41887451","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45611494","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/oh-my-god-particle-d9d0234921a7.jpg","path":"/hall/link/oh-my-god-particle-d9d0234921a7/"},{"slug":"scale-of-the-universe-d9d023453f01","title":"Scale of the Universe","domain":"www.htwins.net","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"visualization_map","typeDisplay":"Visualizations & maps","topic":"space_transportation","topicDisplay":"Space & transportation","tags":["space_astronomy"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2021-12","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":24,"submitters":23,"spanYears":12.112,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":276,"evidenceRank":66,"evidenceScore":71.2,"freshAt":"2021-12-08T18:33:52Z","freshnessRank":1185,"freshEventScore":276,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 276 pts / 79 comments (2021) + 194 pts / 80 comments (2014), different submitters and 2,843 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 24 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 23 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":8,"peak_score":13,"peak_comments":2,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3787462","height":4,"chart_height":8},{"year":2013,"count":3,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5482688","height":4,"chart_height":5},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":194,"peak_comments":80,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7298423","height":9,"chart_height":119},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":8,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9629418","height":4,"chart_height":11},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13260200","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16095568","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24810689","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2021,"count":3,"peak_score":276,"peak_comments":79,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29488511","height":13,"chart_height":170},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39792135","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/scale-of-the-universe-d9d023453f01.jpg","path":"/hall/link/scale-of-the-universe-d9d023453f01/"},{"slug":"tldrlegal-software-licenses-explained-in-plain-english-d9d0234684f6","title":"TldrLegal – Software Licenses Explained in Plain English","domain":"tldrlegal.com","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"society_policy","topicDisplay":"Society & policy","tags":["law_regulation","open_source"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2012,"candidateMonth":"2015-02","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":12,"submitters":12,"spanYears":9.958,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":321,"evidenceRank":67,"evidenceScore":71.0,"freshAt":"2014-03-09T00:56:05Z","freshnessRank":1945,"freshEventScore":321,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 321 pts / 95 comments (2014) + 18 pts / 3 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,004 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 12 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 8 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":1,"peak_score":147,"peak_comments":55,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4193152","height":7,"chart_height":78},{"year":2013,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5991757","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2014,"count":2,"peak_score":321,"peak_comments":95,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7367027","height":15,"chart_height":170},{"year":2015,"count":3,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10632549","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2016,"count":1,"peak_score":18,"peak_comments":3,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13123736","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13473000","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28507281","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":8,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31787154","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/tldrlegal-software-licenses-explained-in-plain-english-d9d0234684f6.jpg","path":"/hall/link/tldrlegal-software-licenses-explained-in-plain-english-d9d0234684f6/"},{"slug":"pink-trombone-d9d02356c09b","title":"Pink Trombone","domain":"dood.al","category":"interactive","categoryDisplay":"Tools, games & demos","type":"interactive_tool_demo","typeDisplay":"Interactive tools & demos","topic":"computer_science","topicDisplay":"Computer science","tags":["human_computer_interaction","web_development"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2017,"candidateMonth":"2021-05","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":9,"submitters":9,"spanYears":8.454,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":575,"evidenceRank":68,"evidenceScore":71.0,"freshAt":"2019-01-15T17:01:18Z","freshnessRank":1644,"freshEventScore":575,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 575 pts / 75 comments (2019) + 2 pts / 0 comments (2021), different submitters and 854 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 9 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 7 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":1,"peak_score":325,"peak_comments":52,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14135658","height":16,"chart_height":96},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":575,"peak_comments":75,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18912628","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27211029","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2022,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29865123","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36513750","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2024,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42322196","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2025,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45440001","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/pink-trombone-d9d02356c09b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/pink-trombone-d9d02356c09b/"},{"slug":"software-optimization-resources-d9d02340918b","title":"Software optimization resources","domain":"www.agner.org","category":"reference","categoryDisplay":"Reference","type":"curated_collection_archive","typeDisplay":"Curated collections & archives","topic":"software_engineering","topicDisplay":"Software engineering","tags":["performance_reliability","programming_languages","computer_architecture"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2010,"candidateMonth":"2020-03","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":18,"submitters":18,"spanYears":16.339,"breakoutYears":2,"maxScore":172,"evidenceRank":69,"evidenceScore":70.9,"freshAt":"2022-07-19T03:29:50Z","freshnessRank":1021,"freshEventScore":20,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":false,"detail":"Best current eligible pair: 172 pts / 22 comments (2020) + 115 pts / 3 comments (2016), different submitters and 1,166 days apart. Hall requires one event with 300+ pts or 100+ comments and another with 100+ pts or 50+ comments."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 18 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 18 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 10 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":2,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1129223","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2011,"count":2,"peak_score":3,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2794935","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2012,"count":2,"peak_score":10,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4045165","height":4,"chart_height":10},{"year":2013,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":2,"peak_score":61,"peak_comments":4,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8874206","height":4,"chart_height":60},{"year":2016,"count":3,"peak_score":115,"peak_comments":3,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13258254","height":6,"chart_height":114},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":1,"peak_score":1,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18422310","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2019,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2020,"count":2,"peak_score":172,"peak_comments":22,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22511446","height":8,"chart_height":170},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":1,"peak_score":20,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32147217","height":4,"chart_height":20},{"year":2023,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":2,"peak_score":4,"peak_comments":1,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42585374","height":4,"chart_height":4},{"year":2026,"count":1,"peak_score":2,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48605500","height":4,"chart_height":4}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/software-optimization-resources-d9d02340918b.jpg","path":"/hall/link/software-optimization-resources-d9d02340918b/"},{"slug":"nsa-s-backdoor-key-from-lotus-notes-2002-d9d02349a3d5","title":"NSA's Backdoor Key from Lotus Notes (2002)","domain":"www.cypherspace.org","category":"writing","categoryDisplay":"Essays & writing","type":"essay_article","typeDisplay":"Essays & articles","topic":"security_privacy","topicDisplay":"Security & privacy","tags":["cryptography","privacy_surveillance","history"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2013,"candidateMonth":"2019-12","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":4,"submitters":4,"spanYears":10.278,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":564,"evidenceRank":70,"evidenceScore":70.8,"freshAt":"2023-09-18T10:47:17Z","freshnessRank":693,"freshEventScore":344,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 breakout events 720+ days apart","completion_label":"breakout pair","passed":true,"detail":"Qualifying pair: 564 pts / 87 comments (2019) + 442 pts / 85 comments (2013), different submitters and 2,388 days apart."},{"key":"submissions","label":"5+ submissions","need_label":"5 submissions","completion_label":"5th submission","passed":false,"detail":"Current: 4 submissions. Hall requires 5."},{"key":"submitters","label":"3+ submitters","need_label":"3 submitters","completion_label":"3rd submitter","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 known submitters. Hall requires 3."},{"key":"years","label":"3+ active years","need_label":"3 active years","completion_label":"3rd active year","passed":true,"detail":"Current: 4 active calendar years. Hall requires 3."}],"spark":[{"year":2007,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2008,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2009,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2010,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2011,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2012,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2013,"count":1,"peak_score":442,"peak_comments":85,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5846189","height":21,"chart_height":133},{"year":2014,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2015,"count":1,"peak_score":281,"peak_comments":51,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9291404","height":13,"chart_height":85},{"year":2016,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2017,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2018,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2019,"count":1,"peak_score":564,"peak_comments":87,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21859581","height":24,"chart_height":170},{"year":2020,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2021,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2022,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2023,"count":1,"peak_score":344,"peak_comments":168,"front":true,"hn_url":"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37554504","height":17,"chart_height":104},{"year":2024,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2025,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3},{"year":2026,"count":0,"peak_score":0,"peak_comments":0,"front":false,"hn_url":"","height":3,"chart_height":3}],"thumbnail":"/hall/assets/thumbnails/nsa-s-backdoor-key-from-lotus-notes-2002-d9d02349a3d5.jpg","path":"/hall/link/nsa-s-backdoor-key-from-lotus-notes-2002-d9d02349a3d5/"},{"slug":"quantum-mechanics-as-a-generalization-of-probability-2007-d9d0233e40de","title":"Quantum mechanics as a generalization of probability (2007)","domain":"www.scottaaronson.com","category":"learning","categoryDisplay":"Books & learning","type":"course_lecture","typeDisplay":"Courses & lectures","topic":"mathematics_science","topicDisplay":"Mathematics & science","tags":["physics"],"collection":"candidates","firstSeenYear":2007,"candidateMonth":"2014-09","inductedMonth":null,"submissions":10,"submitters":10,"spanYears":16.392,"breakoutYears":4,"maxScore":209,"evidenceRank":71,"evidenceScore":70.6,"freshAt":"2024-04-17T12:38:40Z","freshnessRank":507,"freshEventScore":101,"hallChecks":[{"key":"traction_pair","label":"Two breakout events","need_label":"2 br