HN Hall of Fame Weekly email

John McCarthy: The Robot and the Baby

www-formal.stanford.edu Essays & writing Essays & articles Culture & media Candidate
Screenshot of www-formal.stanford.edu captured 2026-07-20
Page preview · captured 2026-07-20

Resurfaced independently across 5 calendar years, with breakout response in 2 of them.

submissions
5
submitters
5
observed span
2007–2021
peak thread · 28 comments
234 pts
latest 20+ return · 2021-10-27
25 pts

Submission timeline

2007–2026

One slot for every year since HN launched. Height is that year's peak points; orange marks a 100+ point or 50+ comment breakout. Select a bar to open its strongest thread.

First comments on top threads

HN comment order

If you liked this story you may like _The Time of Eve_, which is a short animated Japanese science fiction series. It explores many of the same themes. I hadn't read this story before, but I wouldn't be at all surprised to find out the authors of the series had read it. Viewable on CrunchyRoll, legally, for free: http://www.crunchyroll.com/time-of-eve/episode-1-akiko-45270... There are six episodes of about 15 minutes each.

Interesting short story. The part on robots rings well, but there was one thing about parenting at the end that rang not so well to my ears: "children grew up more attached to their robot nannies than to their actual parents. This was mitigated by making the robot nannies somewhat severe" This reflects a very simplistic view on who kids love. It is in fact wrong even in the first order: kids actually love more severe parents or severe teachers…

gbog·104-point thread·

Interesting that the story assumes a legible AI for the robot. If its behaviour was the result of a deep learning neural net, the story plot would necessarrily be quite different. There would be no talk of understanding the robot's calculations or tweaking the program parameters. From the perspective of today's AI efforts the programming in the story seems antiquated and unrealistic.

dzdt·25-point thread·

What a great piece of techno fiction.

The first top-level comment from each of the four biggest threads, in HN’s own order. Excerpts are shortened; open a comment for full context.

Breakout years
2

100+ points or 50+ comments

Total points
370

reference only — not used in Hall rules or ranking

Total comments
43

reference only — not used in Hall rules or ranking

Every submission

DateTitle as submittedByPointsComments
2007-04-29A bit of future Lisp [fiction]mojuba61
2009-11-09The Robot and the Babywooby10
2011-10-24John McCarthy: The Robot and the BabyFirst breakout · Best threadbootload2349
2014-01-01“The Robot and the Baby” by John McCarthyColinWright10428
2021-10-27The Robot and the Baby (2004)Latest 20+ point returnbigdict255